nine inch nails- the line begins to blur- live

[Dj23123]

The best lineup for NIN is from the Fragility tour. Lohner, Finck. Would've been complete with Freese.

[AyaxTelemonio]

cortini is my favorite, i hope he remains forever in nin

[reznorfan15]

@AyaxTelemonio sadly, he left in '08.

[tvraiderz]

Badass.

[FoShizzle713]

The solo at the end is fucking amazing.

[brandondavenport562]

I use to like manson, then I took an arrow to the knee. Now NIN is the shit



[NINgatita9]

@brandondavenport562 ah, you have seen the light!

[hentaisexfreak4life1]

nice tune here wow cool

[tordek3d]

*fap fap fap* :D

[mrkb2k]

Fuck what you think. I was there, ruthless jam. One of my faves. :)

[sesxesex]

wow i love this song and video

[dedecus]

Great Music, Great Performance and a great Visual Setting, what else can you ask for NIN?

[link89]

I love this song but my gosh this line ups back up vocals bastardized it.

[oswalddeath]

@link89 so many of his songs have backing vocals it would sound so dry without them no matter who is in the lineup. :]

[link89]

@oswalddeath Oh yeah I totally dig back up vocals. It's just this particular line up didn't lend itself well to them. Lights in the sky and Fragility were great though.

[meowmuak]

love this song!

[amapolavioleta]

I'ts so good I don't know what to say...

[entropiakalanen]

Not kidding - just had the top 10 shittiest restaurant night and this gem start playing in my head: Isn't anybody serving me? I DON'T KNOW! I DON'T KNOW!

(hehe)

[GWARMIKE]

@entropiakalanen I gotcha dude! This actually made me feel better.

[benfox80]

@entropiakalanen lol!

[milliperezxx1]

this is my favorite song from the live DVD, i fell in love with it as soon as i heard it

[TheChickenmaster77]

i love these guys as much as i love chickens

[TheChickenmaster77]

GREAT FUCKING SONG

[drunkdonutboy]

This music is perfect for those reclusive bouts of just zoning out and doing shit. Reading, writing, art, research, w/e just doing your own thing. It's like the silence of concentration that isn't silent? I don't know how else to put it. Maybe it's just me.

[shoom013]

powerful!



[holocaustocannibal]

Great song

[dominicarjona]

Trent and the rest of the guys KILL this song...totally awesome performance.

[101101101777]

ha, the fans look funny singing along, "i don't know, i don't know", and the singing kinda sux

[windman600]

it's fuckin' epic from 0:06 to 3:52!!!

[mrkb2k]

the line begins to blur...

[NarizSangrante]

I DON'T KNOW! I DON'T KNOW!

[avonladylinda303]

The more I stay in here

The more it's not so clear

The more I stay in here

The more I disappear

[evillordsnotser]

Stoned hangover classic

[fantazmacy]

i could listen to this song for days

[TheAPC91]

7 seconds more, and you could hear ".........You fucking pigs!" :D

[faaip0de0oaid]

this song is epic!

[DeathNebula]

Who is the guitarist?

[Arimanthael]

@DeathNebula  there Is always one Hater

[DeathNebula]

@Arimanthael What are you talking about.....I got nothing but love here...that dude is bad azzz....hence me asking his name....

[Sharpster7]

@DeathNebula aaron north

[stef0619]

one person doesn't know wtf good music is

[Rw7451]

love this shit.

[Rw7451]

3:05 to 3:52 ;)

[greatsarcasma782]

Trent Reznor and NIN are easily one of the best bands of all time. I have been a HUGE fan since the beginning and still am. Hard to believe when you see where he started to where he is now the transformation is amazing, he is a genius and a god.

[drunkdonutboy]

solo is righteous

[mantranova]

Amazing 

[thehornypuppy]

NOrth's playing is so...ugly...

[johnroiberts]

lol rezno was cooler in the nineties

[MissSalmonella82]

Not many artists can make such incredible show. And of course only Trent sings that good live !!! I dream about NIN concert and ME in first line but... God hates me and I live in Poland :| [I love my country, unfortunately for NIN tours it's the end of the world :( ]

[cambruoso]

Dave Grohl played drums on the album version.

[AyaxTelemonio]

@cambruoso josh freese is better than dave grohl

[NoBadBlood]

This song describes exactly how i feel right now.. i find i can always do that with Nine Inch Nails songs.

[Hackmoune]

the dark mood of this song is so unique

[NvikIngsN]

One of my Favorite songs of all time. I'm not into lyrics like some people, but to me it sounds like how War could effect you after multiple deployments.

[Fluxion29]

to counter your point, I love this DVD =p

[33hegemon]

He stamps on a spider at 1:15

[ningirl86]

@33hegemon hahahaaa!!! yes he did a big one

[123AllAboutMeee]

urgh i fucking love this

[MeKeshani]

I dont know how he does it but everytime i see him sweating, singing and performing i want to be near him.... he's actually very sexy and i am attracted to him like hell :-*

[paulmanson]

one of the few last songs of nine inch nails that i liked......

[crimmy0204]

trent never lets the fans down always delivers on an epic level.

[paulmanson]

@crimmy0204 have you heard his new project how to kill angels?what can u say about that?if you will speak positive comment ,,let me guess,,ur just a recent fan,,unless otherwise..

[Darknarf91]

@smartaspresidentbush so true

[oldchilltortoise]

when i saw NIN last summer it was and still is the best show ive ever been to.

[fac3tious]

I want to touch him.

[kshensley11]

FUCK... i love this song..

[brgs27]

OMG 1:00 Yeeheeyeyaaaaaah!!!! FUCKING BAD MOTHER FUCKING ASS!

He is and will always outlast and outlive!!! He is forever and eternal!

I will raise my children to respect his music as my parents raised me to respect Floyd and Zep!

[Resistance61513]

Attended my first NIN concert on Feb 26 2006 at the Toledo Sports Arena. The visuals for this song blew me away, they are easily my favorite from the With_Teeth tour.

[stinkfists462]

i cant believe how much trent needed to force his voice on that one

[cesarkillzone40]

Trent's "hey!" is totally badass.

[ThaTruth223]

aaron north is too awesome

[nin666nin]

thank you very much for posting_

[IronRevolution]

Where is it from??? A DVD??? And this was one of the best NIN lineups ever

[mannycosmo02]

yes the dvd is call beside you in time!!!!!!!

[mistic0Spyral]

From Beside You In Time, the dvd after With Teeth

[wass8462]

@IronRevolution

it frim besides you in time dvd

[xXkiLLeDD0LLx3]

omg allesandros voice at the end sounds amazing!!! it fits perfect

i looove this part so much!!

[moneymylez]

Agreed.

[angie4josh]

Bring back memories of Asheville NC, has nothing to do with Nine Inch Nails but just memories.

[lifedeath08]

it's far beyond repair.. and i don't really care<3

[TheNineinchsnails]

most underated song by nin by far

[DissonanceTheory]

@TheNineinchsnails

this is one of my fav.s no doubt.

I think its underrated commercially(vs hand that feeds/closer etc.) but NIN fans love it.

[diex]

@TheNineinchsnails you mean people in general don't like that song? I don't get "underated"

[TheNineinchsnails]

@diex  its a very unappreciated song... do you want me to elaborate more....

[diex]

@TheNineinchsnails no its okay thanks, in french we wouldn't mind if a song is underated, maybe because people have strange tastes, its good to learn new words!

[cambruoso]

@TheNineinchsnails I think it's one of their best songs.And I think he had a better band line up in the "And All That Could Have Been" tour.But the set list on this DVD is much better.

[Perniciousdeeds]

@TheNineinchsnails Non-Entity

[TheNineinchsnails]

@Perniciousdeeds that is not one of my favorite songs

[mistic0Spyral]

what bass guitar is playing Jeordie ?

[nin666nin]

thank you for posting. NIN ftw

[Oneiroi729]

Damn it there were some things I needed to do while I was younger. Being at his performances should've been one of them. *Sigh. Damn it

[err0r]

lol.... it really wasn't that long ago....

[zejnulla]

Best nine inch nails line-up ever

[bulletproofcupid007]

Best line up ever? No, that would be Charlie Clouser, Robin Finck, Danny Lohner & Chris Vrenna.

[sickboyduke]

right, this was the greatest. especially finck and lohner went along genious with the idea NIN

[zejnulla]

Well, I guess that we think different then. Sure, finck, lohner clouser and Vrenna was a great line up too. But I acctually like Ramirez, North, Cortini and Freese better. (K)

[bullsfan93]

^^Yes^^i agree

[justauselessshandle]

I agree

[bullsfan93]

I dont know imo Aaron North is a better guitarist

[Booh4]

@bulletproofcupid007

I totally agree with you. Self Destruct tour line-up for the fucking win. And I think Aaron North is more like a clown, jumping and doing ridiculous stuff around the stage... man, Robin Finck kicked so much ass back then. And Chris Vrenna is unreplaceable. Just like Lohner and Clouser. I miss them all.

[Pierceher]

yeah, jumpy mc jump just wants to jump and do irrelevant riffs most of the time.

Finck is the man :D

[oswalddeath]

@bulletproofcupid007 Alessandro Cortini, Robin Finck, Jeordie White, Jerome Dillon and Danny Lohner is. Plus special guest David Bowie.

[TheNineinchsnails]

the most underated song by nin ..tho this aint the greatest version..lyrics are great meaning is great and the chorus is great

[empty216]

I don't know why, but I don't quite like this DVD, not as much as And All That Could Have Been.

[reznorfan15]

agreed.

[empty216]

I think it's Aaron North. I just don't like him: he seems to care more about image than performance. Robin however, well, he's just astonishing.

[fireoceanqc]

well its not that bad

i find it pretty good :P

[cambruoso]

@empty216 Because he had a better band.

[abmellah]

@empty216

I think I know why.

Its because AATCHB was more natural&honest.

BYIT is also good, but it's more professional, high definition and stuff. Reznor is like a director, who is looking from a distance to the rock&roll circus. @AATCHB he was inside the r&r circus without the distance.

AATCHB and BYIT shows the difference between the XX and XXI century. Today music is produced, promote and promoted live in a different way.

For some it's better, for other - it;s worse.

[cambruoso]

@abmellah Well i compared the two recently.And i get what your saying.He was about ten years younger when AATCHB was made.The performance was much more intense.He screamed without the worry of straining his vocal cords.Which isn't the case now and for obvious reasons.And the distortion and amps were turned up a little more.With BYIT it's more melodic and polished.But both are great in their own way.With BYIT the bonus live studio performances are fantastic.

[Muskateering]

@abmellah very well said, I agree with all that.

[philsrt6]

maybe you have not grown up with them.

[Muskateering]

@empty216 Yeah I know, it's too polished, too 'arena' like.

[abmellah]

@Muskateering @cambruso

IMO, it's not a defect, that Reznor is going into much more produced music. I love Ghosts, also the Social Network soundtrack with Atticus Ross is great. IMO, its a good direction for over-40 years old guy: to focus on the mysterious, spooky, piano-dark-ambient-delay&fuzz guitar part of NIN and Reznor's creation.

[Deathsex22]

@empty216 agreed

[NonEss3ntial]

@empty216 I agree. I think he is loosing his voice and his energy. He rock out like he used to.

[StickyInADarkBlueCut]

@empty216 because AATCHB was NiN at their finest... Sobriety and age starts to reallyshow on trent this tour

[TheChildre]

@empty216 agree



[TheChildre]

@empty216 

[DOTAMIA]

he's so ht in this video...sugar daddy crush : )

[JulianTrick]

Esta es una de las cansiones mas prendidas y completas que he escuchado!.. Nine Inch Nails siempre se va superando...

[Grollomatikus]

shit... this performance is just awesome... you have to love the backup vocals :D... can't stop watching it

[saaalut]

there are a lot of studio vocal editing ... listen closely to the chorus ...

[anthonyzxD]

One of the greatest live performances i've seen, ever.

[ikharus1]

cant wait TOMORW I SEE them IN ROMANIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAA

[huntor007]

better than the actual song itself, for once the live version of a song is better than the original! :D

[UnknownShadow718]

Dude trust me, this is not the only song that it's live version is better than the studio version.

[cambruoso]

@UnknownShadow718 I have to disagree.Off the top of my head.Head Like A Hole and Wish also definitely sound better live.

[Perniciousdeeds]

@UnknownShadow718 Non Entity

[manulito2]

damn, the backup vocals are just great. the with teeth line up was the best NIN line up ever, imo.

[dcfcassie]

sometimes i forget that he's engaged.

but then it comes back to me & i get a little teary eyed. :(

[LiveFastDieYoung92]

Oh man...

The solo at 3:06 is so amazing

=]

[ny5280]

With Teeth, one of his best,allways will be a fan??????

[juanCarlosvp7]

This song mmm :P...Isn't anybody stopping me?

I don't know, I don't know.

[54spiritedwill54]

Simply Amazing

[NoBadBlood]

The man never disappoints! =D

[abpiv]

FAVORITE SONG!!! he's coming to sweden in a month or something!

[nin4lifefan]

OOH my favorite nin song...out of every song he made this is the best one..in my opinion just love the bass and how it starts off so hard then dies down softly then back to rocking out! love you trent!

[898fr444]

for me the best is the hand that feeds...

[afthefragile]

You've just gotta love the bass in this track!!!

My fav from With Teeth. Or maybe very close behind The Collector.

[DOTAMIA]

so hot (she begins to cheese)

[hahhhaaemmaa]

I LOVE THIS SONG

[vampirorock33]

my favotite song NINE INCH NAILS

[TheGematria]

I love this song to death. A fave from [With_Teeth]!

[polock2112]

its cool that trent kept josh on for more drums...best drummer for nin...so cool to see hes around still

[AustFisch]

He left the band.

[josielefler]

This live version is incredibly sexy. I would so lick the sweat off his face!

[thebrownfury]

that's really weird.

[ladonnaschild]

Not really weird, I would too.

[OrangeColita]

wow, hahah harmonization issues.

[PhrostCope]

what?

[OrangeColita]

0:55

[limpicatto]

Yeah, I get it. Singing back vocals is a difficult thing to do, I can't do it.

I don't even know how to do it lol.

[OrangeColita]

agreed! especially live.

seems like most instruments lose about half their quality live, and vocals are no exception. heck, vocals have it the worst, so much other noise to compete with and the balance of noises are always tricky im sure.

the concert is the one place the bassist really DOESNT take the back seat!

[qba95]

Damn... i'm sad beacouse of that they aren't all together now. Don't get me wrong: JMJ and finck are damn awesome too but much different.

However... Nin kicked asses as hell then and they still kick now!

[imranrehman100]

the best tune in my eyes... ever! Along with AIC - Would... two of the greatest tunes for me...

[hannibalsloat]

Agreed. And all that could have been is a far superior dvd.

[Idkfawin32]

Its good, for a live version

[vampirorock33]

esa es mi cancion favorita yea NIN

[liamuk08]

This song is so great live.

[Crueltool8]

i LOVE this song but "And all that could've been" kicked this DVD's ass

[sgf1989]

my favorite song in this show

[typeonegativefan]

Best.lineup.ever!!!

[AyaxTelemonio]

@typeonegativefan i think the woodstock one is far better, with lohner and vrenna. aaron north ruins the songs

[Idkfawin32]

Trent is such a fuckin best now. He used to be skinny as hell back during pretty hate machine.

[undeadpresident]

Yeah he almost looks like a completely different person.

[Idkfawin32]

Yeah but he still has that wonderful voice.

[beer4me88]

jeordie white is so fuckin cool with his instruments

[Erakyd]

I agree, my favourite cd is And all that could have been. I also saw them live in 2005 and that was really cool.

[waynedrake]

"I DON'T KNOOW, I DON'T KNOOOW!!!"