This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yeah, those are great songs, from a great album, from a great singer and there are strong vibes coming from both these songs. Emmylou is the female Bruce Springsteen - and I mean that as a criticism as much as a compliment. Sometimes their works take you up, sometimes they sink you down in negativity. On any interpretation, Red Dirt Girl is a song which disrespects red dirt people and red dirt towns. There is nothing wrong about being "only 27 and having 5 kids" - nor Alabama for that matter!
I don't get the disrespect part. "Red Dirt Girl" is a story, and those details are part of the story. It's not saying that anyone from a red dirt town or anyone who has 5 kids by the age of 27 is messed up. It's simply telling a story of a girl who had dreams that were crushed, and this is the story of how it happened.
@mabewa I agree! If this were writing it would be a novel, or a least a short story, not a blog or magazine opinion piece nor a political pamphlet: it is a reportage rather than sociology, a snapshot rather than a documentary.
Whatever, I like this song because it makes me cry, and that takes skill.
What gets me is that the song is obviously written about the American South, but I'm from rural Washington State, and this song reminds me of so many people I grew up with. It's a heartbreaking story that also rings completely true to me.
@mabewa Its obviously SET in the American South, but is not about there. It reminds you of your past, as it does me, who grew up in a suburb, but who in this small country was never that far away from the rural. A story of lost hopes and limited horizons is pretty universal, and that is where her skill lies, in making the particular speak to us all. Are we done agreeing? :-)
I will be seeing Emmylou, Shawn Colvin, Patty Griffin and Buddy Miller at the Birchmere in Alexandria Va next Tuesday, Feb.3, 2009. I've seen Emmylou several times, and I can't wait for the concert next week.
Mary Ann Kennedy and Pam Rose singing and playing also.
I have searched the Web for some video of Kennedy-Rose when they did a PBS show on Austin City Limits to no avail. That is where I first saw and heard them and I was hooked forever. I wish someone could find and post it
Oh ... just your average Emmylou -> meaning: It merely goes from absolutely gorgeous to soooo moving that you're left nearly stunned. Two amazing songs sung by ... well ... Emmylou Harris. Need more be said?
I think that even more so than the beautiful "quality" of her voice is the "soul" that resonates within it. A soul that seems to know intimately pain, wisdom, AND peace.
Thanks for this great vid post! And Thanks to Emmylou!!!
was there with my mum aged 81. she just died and this will play at mum's funeral. Emmylou has the voice of an angel, yes. and i and my beloved mum thank her. is this recording on a cd?
thanks. i am just so glad she was able to see Emmylou live. had to choose a song for the funeral today. didn't have this. mum loved all the songs. any recommendations?
I'm 64 and could live another 64 years and would never hear another artist as beautiful as Emmylou. Been listening to her for 35 years and she only gets better. Truly, she is a gift from God.
bellissima
schiavolini 11 months ago
une très très grande artiste avec une voix qui donne des frissons dans le dos....
1757jojo 1 year ago
Pretty damned good. Beautiful sound, beautiful woman.
jongreek 1 year ago
exquisite! more delicate and elegant than the studio recording, but just as powerful.
i bought the cd when it first came out and listened to it for many months...
i still put it on ten years later...what a great gift she has and how she uses it...
thegoochieguy 1 year ago
Agree, sweet!
windrose777 1 year ago
Absolutely perfect!!!!!
johnlen3 1 year ago
Vocally this is the best version I've heard, but the drums make this song. Just didn't sound right without them.
dwmitch 2 years ago
Can anyone tell me if that is Larry Klein on bass?
danlay 2 years ago
i was thier best ive ever seen emmy she is very special
swampy1952 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, those are great songs, from a great album, from a great singer and there are strong vibes coming from both these songs. Emmylou is the female Bruce Springsteen - and I mean that as a criticism as much as a compliment. Sometimes their works take you up, sometimes they sink you down in negativity. On any interpretation, Red Dirt Girl is a song which disrespects red dirt people and red dirt towns. There is nothing wrong about being "only 27 and having 5 kids" - nor Alabama for that matter!
AlistairMcConnachie 2 years ago
you are right, the problem is being POOR and having 5 kids
rsholter68 2 years ago 3
I don't get the disrespect part. "Red Dirt Girl" is a story, and those details are part of the story. It's not saying that anyone from a red dirt town or anyone who has 5 kids by the age of 27 is messed up. It's simply telling a story of a girl who had dreams that were crushed, and this is the story of how it happened.
mabewa 2 years ago
@mabewa I agree! If this were writing it would be a novel, or a least a short story, not a blog or magazine opinion piece nor a political pamphlet: it is a reportage rather than sociology, a snapshot rather than a documentary.
Whatever, I like this song because it makes me cry, and that takes skill.
flamencoprof 1 year ago
What gets me is that the song is obviously written about the American South, but I'm from rural Washington State, and this song reminds me of so many people I grew up with. It's a heartbreaking story that also rings completely true to me.
mabewa 1 year ago
@mabewa Its obviously SET in the American South, but is not about there. It reminds you of your past, as it does me, who grew up in a suburb, but who in this small country was never that far away from the rural. A story of lost hopes and limited horizons is pretty universal, and that is where her skill lies, in making the particular speak to us all. Are we done agreeing? :-)
flamencoprof 1 year ago
Comment removed
michaelmouse1 2 years ago
Unfortunately you are confirming my point exactly michaelmouse1 - you have now made explicit the subtle prejudices implicit in that song.
AlistairMcConnachie 2 years ago
two of my favorite emmylou songs...thanks.
madeleineinthecity 2 years ago 2
very very beautiful!!!
Her voice is full of emotion and I am very
happy to have found Emmylou on YT.
Thank you for posting this.
nmsan2008 2 years ago 3
...you're tearing my heart out Emmyloo...
rurbert 2 years ago 4
Purest voice in music.
The Emmylous and Dollys of the world are what mainstream Country Music has forgotten. Less LoneStar and Rascal Flats please, more of this.
ZestyItalian2 2 years ago 2
C;est bien!
louiseduvee 2 years ago 2
I will be seeing Emmylou, Shawn Colvin, Patty Griffin and Buddy Miller at the Birchmere in Alexandria Va next Tuesday, Feb.3, 2009. I've seen Emmylou several times, and I can't wait for the concert next week.
Aliciente 3 years ago
Very beautiful.
Mary Ann Kennedy and Pam Rose singing and playing also.
I have searched the Web for some video of Kennedy-Rose when they did a PBS show on Austin City Limits to no avail. That is where I first saw and heard them and I was hooked forever. I wish someone could find and post it
KG5RQ 3 years ago 2
"one thing they don't tell you 'bout the blues when you got 'em, is you keep on fallin' cause there ain't no bottom... there ain't no end"
incredible, wish i had thought of that =D
GovmentTookMaBaby 3 years ago 2
God bless you babe!
mikesakhalin 3 years ago 2
Oh ... just your average Emmylou -> meaning: It merely goes from absolutely gorgeous to soooo moving that you're left nearly stunned. Two amazing songs sung by ... well ... Emmylou Harris. Need more be said?
I think that even more so than the beautiful "quality" of her voice is the "soul" that resonates within it. A soul that seems to know intimately pain, wisdom, AND peace.
Thanks for this great vid post! And Thanks to Emmylou!!!
Cheers!
PforPanchetta 4 years ago 6
fuck yeah!
yeah sorry i'm hammered.
GovmentTookMaBaby 4 years ago
was there with my mum aged 81. she just died and this will play at mum's funeral. Emmylou has the voice of an angel, yes. and i and my beloved mum thank her. is this recording on a cd?
lawhore55 4 years ago 3
There's no official DVD or CD of Emmy @ Cambridge FF 2006.
If it's of special significance, can rip and and email you source quality stereo mp3 audio of the bits broadcast.
Commiserations on the loss of your mother.
mnemonyxx 4 years ago
thanks. i am just so glad she was able to see Emmylou live. had to choose a song for the funeral today. didn't have this. mum loved all the songs. any recommendations?
lawhore55 4 years ago
Ditto .. in 54 years!
jimdahm 4 years ago
Comment removed
rjd53 4 years ago
Emmylou is fabulous to look at and to listen to. I believe she herself wrote Red Dirt Girl.
jnhealy1 4 years ago
I'm 64 and could live another 64 years and would never hear another artist as beautiful as Emmylou. Been listening to her for 35 years and she only gets better. Truly, she is a gift from God.
Sammy2784 4 years ago 2
We SO need an official DVD of this show!
SonofEmmy2 4 years ago
Gorrrrrgeous! :)
Pulsatron1985 4 years ago
No embedding? Thanks for not really sharing.
kliljedahl 4 years ago
Emmylou is, as always AMAZING! Thanks for posting this.
Ilsathedog 5 years ago 2
Stunning. Compelling. Emmylou = peerless. She's my hero. I will see her in concert next month. yay! Awesome live footage here, thanks!
tommiji 5 years ago
Gorgeous. Thanks so much for posting these.
siren9 5 years ago
legendary... thanks.
peace,
russ
russtacean 5 years ago
legendary.
thanks!
peace,
russ
russtacean 5 years ago