Added: 4 years ago
From: rozzapezza
Views: 157,522
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (253)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • after all they had to leave because it was not their country

  • fuck israel, it will disappear soon

  • I just finished listening to the audiobook, which I thought was excellent! The trailer is pretty intense. ("SHPITZER!!!!!" And i know what that means...)

    But in the book, the guy was called "Erez," dang it, EREZ.

    I know it is difficult for a movie to be the same as the book, even though Casino Royale pretty much nailed that to an extremely high degree.

  • I just borrowed the novel (; going to watch the movie after.

  • I don't like watching movies with a language I don't understand. But I really liked this film! :-)

  • @magr187

    I really, really, really hate a movie that's based in another country(e.g. Germany, russia) and the actors speak with a stupid BRITISH accent. It ruins the whole movie for me..

  • @dynoahmite True, it's a British actor, I don't recall his name. But he try so really much speaking "badass" American, but it's just getting stupid when you clearly hear his british.

  • @dynoahmite

    that is at the Mt Harmon in Israel.

  • I have the chills from this movie! amazing!!! our boys our soldiers!

  • @jacobmillerme12

    it is an anti war film

    anyway, read the book, so much better...

  • i really feel sorry for the israeli soldiers because they do a good deed by fighting for their country and yet their is propagandi that israeli soldiers love and enjoy killing palastinians in cold blood. They should be respected

  • @schippeck

    That is muslim anti-jew propaganda, and the world is taking it in.

  • @schippeck

    And I really feel sorry for those who emit opinions on such grave matters without first deigning to educate themselves. Brush up on your history man or simply open your eyes and learn to think for youself- or zip it

  • @schippeck God yeah we should respect them so much, must be really hard killing innocent civilians. Before you make such a comment do your research, buddy!

  • @bamigogy12345

    as a matter of fact it is!!!

    Make sure you research before u comment MATE !!!

  • @bamigogy12345 Watching youtube videos of Israeli "war crimes" is not what anyone would call research, jackass.

  • @ForeverRepublic I haven't just based my opinion on a film, by the way.

  • @bamigogy12345 i am aware of that.

  • @ForeverRepublic Jolly good, then.

  • @bamigogy12345 Yes :)

  • The book (by Ron Leshem) is far better than the movie.

  • anyone know the song?

  • Just bought this movie from Barnes and Noble and all I have to say is WOW!!!!!!!! It was so amazing, I was crying on some parts. Also, I LOVE Oshri Cohen. He is a fantastic actor!!!!

    Shalom from the US

  • @jacobmillerme12

    It is a pure Israeli movie, so how could it be antri Israeli?

  • @jacobmillerme12 It's not anti-Israel in anyway. If there is any comparable American film it is "Full Metal Jacket" in that it focuses on a platoon of soldiers and shows the emotional roller coaster they go through from war. It shows the stress soldiers go through. The movie doesn't touch the politics of the Arab-Israel conflict. THe only politics mentioned are the internal politics of Israel in terms of the debate going on in 2000 during the withdrawal.

  • @jacobme12gmod Just so you know, I'm a major Zionist, and I love this film. It is not a movie that glorifies war, but it does make you respect the soldiers.

  • @gobears1987 Thx for the info ;D

  • liraz is so hot! everybodie in this film was just HOT!

    amazing movie I realy liked it a lot, so good!!

    so great NO WORDS! but its too hard to get this

    kind of films in mexico! I loved this movie!

  • excelente filme. muuuuuuito bom :o)

    shalom Israel

  • leftitst trash movie

  • Comment removed

  • one of the most powerful, and strong movies i have ever seen.

  • It's such an amazing film.

  • Can someone please tell me where can I get this movie from??? I don't seem to find it!!

  • @rudyeilabouni you can find it on bbc iplayer in the movies category

  • Thanks for the heads up on that - great stuff.

  • it's instant view on netflix

  • Does anyone know what the song playing in the background is?

  • Unbelievably bad translation, doesn't even come close to capture the idea and spirit of what is told.

  • all of them soooooooo hot and handsome

  • @Berrymore84

    True, but what's with the big hats already?

    Flattering they are not and surely they make a bigger target for snipers?

  • @AngloAmalgamated

    yeah i know it's kinda funny.

  • those hats make camouflage...

    and it's just bigger helmet...

  • its actually the opposite, these so called large helmets serve as a larger area for snipers to shoot at which increases the chance that a sniper will miss. Besides that they protect from the sand of the stormy deserts, and from shrapnel.

  • This is movie was really good.

  • Does anyone know the title of the song in the background?

    I know others have asked but it's been a while and no one has answered yet

  • when I can dowload this movie?????!!!!!!!!!

    please help me

  • u can download it anytime u like anywhere u like with a computer n internet access

  • The movie is ok, but seriously, read the book, it's so much better, it goes so much deeper.

  • I totally agree with you, I am int he prograss of finnishing the book after I saw the movie and the book is AMAZING tells much more than the movie..

  • this discussion is absurd.

  • great movie!!!!

  • 9-я рота по израильски!

  • But, i think its a modern problem, and israeli government makes mistakes indeed they make!!

    But when you see people like Hamas..

    Well, thats actually how I know the history, and I think the jewish people have actually a right also to life in Israel.. and the Palestinians.. I think if you give the westbank and Gaza(well you see how it turned out) back, there will be peace, but you cant forget that de arbian country's dont want a jewish land in the middle east.

  • many people run away, and they killed much jewish and muslim people. There only left 1000 jewish families in Israel. Afterwards the Ottomanians took over Middle East, and then much jewish people returned after the Spanish Inquistion. In the year 1500 till 1922 the Ottomanianes ruled over the Middle East, then came the British kolonian. Thats how I Learned the history, there was never something like Palestina, and the Palestinians only came to Israel in the 7th century..

  • and let's not forget all the indigenous Jews from all the middle-east that were expellde by the Arabs within the last century and now make up the Israeli population. More than the population of Arabs that have ever lived in Israel...and now their is no Jewish community left in those places but there is more Arabs than ever in Israel

  • @ Arbih, thats true indeed!

    But, what you said last isn't true, offcourse there are people who really become, but i know people in the army that didnt became. But when you actually kill a person, i think it really awakenss something in you.

    But you know that jewish people lived in the Israel of now, for many years!

    I mean if you look into the history you find King Salumon and Jesus(the year 0), who were jewish people living in Kanaan/Israel. When the christian pelgrimages came to Jeruzalem

  • Oliver Stone Styles Movie ?

  • @no1deebo,

    i wasn't there, but family of mine were in the north and were hitten by rockets..

    Myself I think it was stupid to do, so don't tell me what I think, causee you say you life in the village? right?

    Did I say it was good to do? I Didnt say so.

    I think it was a big mistake to make. And uhmm i don't know what you'r talkin bout, but like i already said, my family were hitten by rockets who were launched from Lebanon into the north of Israel. So please dont talk Sht.

  • @ no1deebo,

    so you claim that the jewish people took over the state in the time of the WW2 when they where 'running away'?

    And another thing, like hamas en hesbollah, you want to tell me that they didnt kill countless and inocent civilians in Israel? And another thing, it was a big mistake putting those soldiers up there!

  • You monkey i said PRIOR TO WW2 for fucks sake..

    and NO they havent killed as many innocent civilians as u have, U TELL ME WHEN HEZBOLLAH OCCUPIED TEL AVIV AND BOMBED IT EVERYDAY ? they havent even set foot in there...

    and are you alll running away from the fact that, your pussies soldiers WERE OCCUPYING MY COUNTRY ? thats in my village, i seen your own soldiers run for their lifes, so please dont talk shit, HAVE U BEEN THERE ? no u havent.

    Unless u want to believe ur gov *cough* winograd lol

  • The jewish people took over Palestine by massive immigration into those lands. That is true you cant deny that. Immigration happend before, during and after ww2 and is still continuing today. Israelis ar luckey that no arab government actualy like the palestinians. If they did they would have helped them long long time ago.

  • they didn't take over anything. they MADE Palestine. Palestine was just a word used to designate a huge chunk of the middle-east from the Medditeranean sea all the way to the end of what TODAY is called the country "Jordan." A small part of the desert there was being populated by Jews while the Ottomans and British colonized the middle-east...no country had existed there for over 1000 years until Zionism started. Meanwhile arabs moved there because Jews gave them jobs...then fighting started

  • The majority of people living in palestine before world War one was Muslims. YOu cant deny that. But i also think it is stupid to go back 1000 years to legitimate a claim on land. 1000 years ago there did not exist a state of Israel in modern terms that is just propaganda, what existed was a kingdom. Thousands of kingdoms has come and gone, there is nothing special with the Old Kingdom of Israel. Sry to say that dont mean to insult, just sayin my opinion.

  • No one is basing the "legitimate claim" on the land. Obviously there were Arabs living there, as well as a minority of Jews (who had a majority in some towns however). Nonetheless, when land was purchased through the JNF etc. given permission from the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire, Jews migrated and created commerce and jobs. Simply more Jews came, the Arabs didn't like it as they were always dhimmi (second class). Could/can't accept the success of second class people, no one 'stole' land.

  • All in all they were a minority. I think the root to the problem started later, afther the second world war. If the Palestininas and the Israelis were left to solve the problem on their own i think that today they would not have the same problems.

    Egypt, Syria, Jordan are the countries to blame here. They said without consulting with the palestinians in 49 that they could not lett a state of israel exist. The point here is that no one asked the people living in Palestine what they wanted.

  • The IDF are not cowards or animals and no im not jewish!

  • all soldiers become animals because som aincent animal instinct is awaken in us. we are all human

  • i understand that but thats not what i ment, i ment israelies are not animals. but in the heat of combat everyone changes.

  • This movie is actually about a mistake that the governement made by putting these soldiers up there.

    Much Israelian civilians were really against the decision of the governement for putting the soldiers with no reason to up there.

    You can talk whatever you want, but you dont know anything about Israel and the civilians. So just stop criticizing everything

  • You people are so hypocritical. Dont even know the israelian army, never been there? So just shut up!

    I know people in the army, they have a hard life, they need to protect the civilians of israel. And ofcourse they are afraid, who wouldn't be?

    If you were fighting as a 22 year old person against Hisbolah, you would have run away.

  • U are such a liar!

  • Lier or not, believe what you want, your soldiers LEFT lebanon for a reason, and they couldnt even hold onto 1 village in lebanon in 2006 with 30 000 troops...

    All ur efforsts failed, u didnt stop the rockets, u didnt destroy hezbollah, and u didnt even get ur 2 soldiers back.... hahah we lost civilians yeah, you are real tough killing civilians, but u lost 2 shits , 100 tanks, 4 helicopters and 250 soldiers...

    Not bad for some country boys high

    high tech my ass, ur biggest weakness is urself

  • So much retardation in one post.

  • Couldn't agree more

  • uh duuude come on man get a grip idf soldiers are the bravest this film is just very anti

  • good movie

  • why don't you say the truth, that Israel fights terror?

    do you have another solution to stop missiles? I guess not..so sit and be quiet.

  • i saw this movie like 5 times.

    great movie, i cried alot hehe.. =\

  • its just a movie take it easy man..

    and no, somebody should stop these TERRORISTS

    that destroying the world

  • what peace in the middle east? the gazan civil war or the lebannese civil war? the syrian massacure of hama or the iraq slaughtering the kuwaity? the slaughter of palestinian in jordan in 71 or the following syrian invasion to jordan? or maybe the yemanise civil war or the iraq iran war?

    that peace? the middle east would have war with or without israel...actually its israel that stopped the arab world from ripping one another throtes from the start.

  • Fuck israel

  • What's the background song called?

  • Does anyone know what the song playing in the background is?

  • Can you tell me the name of the novel this movie based upon?

  • im yesh gan eden (if there is heaven), by ron leshem. i started to read it- very good book

  • Is it available in the U,S?

  • this seriously make want to get the novel!!!!

  • This is my favorite movie so far!! it really sad that the bomb squad guy died.

  • thanks ass

  • lol how am i spose to know you havent saw it

  • dick!

  • dont spoil it for the ones that havent seen it yet

  • lol :P

  • That movie sould have won the oscar

  • What is the song playing in the background?

  • Most of this trailer is not in the real movie...non-sense !

  • That's simply not true. All of it is in the movie.

  • When he tells that army is not the real world, or in the end when he's in a river...that's not in the movie. Or it means that my version is cut or censored. But it still a great movie and with the original language kept, it's beautifuler !

  • Your version is cut...

  • @rozzapezza No, the dialogue on which this trailer is based between Liraz and that other guy does not take place in the film. Maybe there is more than one version. I saw the film two minutes ago and I'm totally sure that dialogue was not in it. very good film though, a must see.

  • The best movie I have ever seen.

  • Beautiful movie and great actors!

  • How come they wear them funny big hats in the israeli army?

  • they use them for camouflage.

    most of the soldiers dont use them.

  • They use these especially in the north.

    The north consists mainly of fields filled with grass and rock.

    At distances, the only way to recognise your ennemy is to look at his human characteristics. One of the main factors is the head. If you see a round head, you recognise a human. However, if your head is disformed, it takes the ennemy much more time to recognise it.

    It's especially useful when lying down, making your head seem like a rock, or next to a bush. Makes you blend with it.

  • Looks silly, but makes sense

  • hey! does anybody know the name of the song which is played in the trailer?

    thank you very much!

  • I wanna know that too !

  • estupenda pelicula!!!!!!!!

    great movie!!!!!!

  • Has anyone seen this in the U.S.? I am dying to see it but all the tapes I am finding on line are region II (Europe only, I think)...I believe I need a region I to be able to view this in the U.S...Please comment if you know. Thanks!

  • U can allways do*nl*ad :)

  • do*nl*ad ??? what does that mean?? LOL!

  • Isnt is just easier to say download then?lol...not like ommiting 2 letters makes it easy or anything..lol

  • He meant DowNLoAd

  • It isn't in any American format yet...It probably will be made in an American format soon but I do not know.

  • Excellent movie.

    Terrible and beautiful and real and touching.

  • this looks really good!! i'd love to see it.

    peace from Leb.

  • Any word on a US DVD release? I really want to see this film!

  • This is the best damn movie I seen for a while.

  • i saw the moovie but this scenes are not on the dvd...when liraz talk to oshri...why???

  • Watched it last night and was pretty impressed. I have very little sympathy for Isreal but regardless of this I was moved and identified with the characters. There is some impressive footage here, one critic said at times it was like a scifi movie for which I agree.

  • amazinng movie I watchet it yesterday

  • I haven't seen the movie yet, but it looks very interesting.

    :) good job, Joseph.

  • Exactly1!!

  • i swear someone always starts a fight in comment blogs..haha thats so funny. tell me thats not true! i swear go on any comment blog and someone will be fighting..that shits hilarious.

  • I think Beaufort and Katyn have the biggest chance to win Oscars.

  • Wining Oscar doesn't mean a shit.

  • Commenting on someone else's comment doesn't mean a shit.

  • To Joseph Cedar

    Good luck at the Oscars, hope you win!

  • i think so too.

  • the movie tries to be very realistic but and i think the director did a good job. but there arent any "war sceens" where soldies fight soldiers. the soldiers dont see the enemy, they are whatching the mountain "so he wont run away"... (a line from the movie) until there is an order to leave it.

  • how can you say that?

    you're just a stupid ass!

    you must be realy stupid to say something like that!

  • Look at his name...

    Look at where that user is from...

    Its obvious "IT" is some little racist...

    This trailer looks great and I will be looking for the film asap :)

  • whaha i agree xD

  • LEave this shit alone, he's pallestinian / arab/ something else...

    I wish him to burn and to die as soon as pissible.

    And the movie is great.

    ISRAEL FOREVER!!! :)

  • Israel is a joke of a country just like all other sky fairy ran countries in the middle east. However I side with the Palestinians on this one because unlike Zionists, Palestinians have occupied that land for hundreds of years. Regardless, any cult that tried to assume power in order to fulfill their sky fairies' scripture should be wiped off the face of the earth.

    However, keep up the good work in Gaza, looks like Zionists learned a few tricks from the Nazis

  • Did you know that there were Jews living in the Middle East since prior to the establishment of Christianity and Islam? In fact, there were Jews that never left.

    There were also Jews that were kicked out of Middle Eastern countries or fled because it was no longer acceptable to be Jewish. Today we're witnessing a similar predicament with Christians fleeing Arab lands.

    Your comment is not only ridiculous but is bigoted. Muslims control countries they believe they have religious ties to.

  • You must think I am taking sides here. I think muslim beliefs are as ridiculous as jewish beliefs. Religion is the cause of all the misery in this world and any country or movement that is founded with the idea of fulfilling scripture is insanity. It is the 21st century and people are still basing their life around a sky fairy instead of dealing with reality.

  • "i side with the palestinians on this one"

    ammm yes i think that is taking sides.

    not that i care...

  • When it comes to beliefs I am not taking sides, Judaism and islam are both ridiculous.

    The motivation behind Zionism & Israel is scripture the motivation of palestinians is displacement.

    I am on the side of what is right.

    Taking something that does not belong to you is wrong, taking something that does not belong to you because of scripture that is not only wrong but insane.

  • Ok people believe in something right? SO why the fuck do you give a damn so much? You're a great example of what being an athesit does to you: you have nothing to believe in. SO you end up going to people and claiming what they believe in is wrong because you don't have anything to belive in. That's just being a dumbass. There's a fine line between expressing your opinion and being a total douche-bag. And you fucking crossed it.

  • Actually you are wrong, religion affects me as much as you!

    When you have countries that r religiously motivated & have with them a nuclear arsenal it DOES effect me.

    When you have crazy religious lunatics hijacking planes and crashing them into buildings, it does effect me.

    When you have Christians condemning the use of condoms in africa, it does effect me.

    I can go on & on...

    More people have died in the name of religion then for any other cause, so excuse me for being a little concerned.

  • It's the PEOPLE not the RELIGON that fuck up everything. It all started out as all peaceful during ancient times, but once people saw that they could easily get power and influence others in their own twisted view, things went corrupt. I'm not saying religion is perfect but it's what gives people hope. When you see terrorists who go and kill people in the name of God, that IS NOT THE FACE OF RELIGION. THAT IS THE FACE OF CORRUPTION. If you can't tell the difference, that's your problem.

  • bla bla bla, whom are you trying to convince that you aren't taking sides here? get real and be honest at least next time when you start lecturing others!

  • Honest about what? I am taking the side of what is right, not based on religious beliefs, that is the difference.

    I think all religions are bull shit.

    But displacement and crimes against humanity are not bull shit they are real.

  • yeah and why are you so sure that you have right to judge in this case? why do you think that you're point of view is the right one??? what crime against humanity has Israel done to anyone???? did Israel start the wars, is Israel supporting terrorists?

  • There is 149 articles of the fourth Geneva convention that deal with human rights. Israel is currently and has for a long time now violated almost all of them. Violations of the 4th Geneva convention are "WAR CRIMES" so you can't blame people for calling Israel a terrorist state. The only reason action is not taken is because of the US power of veto & AIPAC.

    Google "crimes against humanity" Israel is mentioned in every link.

  • way to be a total retard you fucking hypocrite. How about you go to the middle east yourself and see what the truth REALLY is before you start bitching to other people about religon and your retarded assumptions about people.

  • No actually the last place i would ever want to go to is the middle east, it is the insane asylum of the world.

    Fighting over who loves their sky fairy the most is not really my cup of tea.

    The TRUTH about the middle east is that scripture, not common sense, is the law of the land.

    Religion is a cancer

  • it's not your comment that you think religion is bullshit, that's just an opinion. But what really pissed me off was that you insult jews in general and the nation of ISRAEL. You don't acknowledge Isreal as a country? That's just retarded. It's a country like anyother out there you insignifact piece of shit. I dare you to go and say to an israeli, he'd knock the shit out of your iggnorant ass.

  • No, Religion is dangerous and It is not an opinion, look at world history, look at the middle east today.

    I am against any country that holds religion as the law of the land because that leads to misery. The Jewish state should be in germany but because everything is religiously motivated we find Israel in its current location. I have nothing against Jewish people but I do have a problem with zionism which you don't have to be jewish to support, there are allot of christian zionists out there

  • the only joke here is palestine, with no land no currency and no history and no culture of his owen what my vidios of palestine girl in gaza strip you going to like it

  • No i think the real joke here is god.

  • the REAL joke here is that you care so much.

  • Well you are right i do care too much

  • exactly, so shut the fuck up, you prick.

  • First of all, very creative on the name calling, very well done. Also the reason I care is because the people that are in power in the middle east are also religious nut jobs that have the nuclear capability of ending life on earth as we know it. So it affects all of us.

  • once again you've just proved how much of a retard you truely are. Did I say religion didn't affect you? I just said that you didn't have anything to believe in. You also just totally missed my point about the "people who corrupt religon, not the other way around." Ok you know what? Don't even reply to my comments anymore, cuz I'm sick of talking to an immature athesit who THINKS he knows how the world functions. Grow the fuck up. I'm done here.

  • First, I don't need a manual to guide me, I know what is important in life. Also I have not said anything wrong about the Jewish people, I am talking about the Zionist movement which by the way many jews are against. Israel has broken more international laws (4th Geneva convention) then any other country, it is not opinion it is fact, look it up. The US power of veto is what keeps the anyone from taking action against it.

  • Main reason the US backs Israel is cuz the Christian coalition in the US want nothing mor then a Jewish state cuz that will fulfills christian scriptures & will give path to the second coming,Armageddon,bullshit.

    Christianity wants nothing more then for the world to come to an end & so does islam. Judaism even though it is the sanest of all 3 monotheistic religions is being brought down by zionists.

    Jesus said "The Kingdom of god is within you" Luke17:21

    So Religion is bullshit, faith is better.

  • i dont think a lot of jewish people are against the zionist movement.

    you talk a lot but i dont think you know history very well.

    the zionist movement is not bad.

    the situation here in israel is very complicated so i dont like people wo have no say in the matter think they know it all.

    are you jewish? israeli? palestinian?