@NotOrdinaryInGames This was originally done for the Animals album but i think due to running time, it was split into 2 parts, minus the solo. Think, as scrutex says below, this version was put on the 8 track version. Hopefully it will be on the new experience/immersion reissues!
Pink Floyd Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set and Pink Floyd The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site/video and audio clips/more info
The greatest band in history, there will be no band like floyd, and it's sad we won't hear new music from them. Floyd has set the bar high for bands to high for most of them
Just plain good music. Loved Floyd many years ago, and have never given them up, never will. Hope to been sitting in a rocking chair in my older, old age listening to Pigs on the Wing.
The lyrics pretty much define all that is wrong with the world today... "care" is what is wrong, or at least the inverse of care- contempt. All other global issues stem from us having contempt for our fellow humans. The engineering of how to resolve contempt is the beginning of Enlightenment, which is the next phase of human existence. Enlightenment is the activation of the Higher Mind after disassembling all reactive/learned components. The tune is pretty good too.
@pigsontherun Without Richard Wright, it's highly unlikely. If he hadn't passed away, it'd probably have ended up happening. Hell, it almost did, but... I forget if it was Reading or Glastonbury, but the festival had already booked its bands and refused to bump one so that Pink Floyd could headline. Damn shame.
How in the hell is it that I've NEVER heard this in it's complete form....including the guitar thing bridging ........what serve as sort of musical "bookends" to the rest of the album?
@uh0oo DUDE!!! I'm wondering the same thing! I used to have the "Animals" album and this version is not on there? The songs were cut in half and it was all acoustic. Where did this come from? LOL!!! Anyways it's a GREAT version!
@uh0oo As far as I remember, this version was created for the Stereo 8 cartridge version; since in this format the albums loop, a special bridge was created with a solo played by Snowy White, who was hired as second guitar/bass for the tour...
There is always something good in everyone, but its human nature to find the bad. Be different and look for the good and the bad may fade. PINK FLOYD'S music will be popular forever.
ive been a floyd head 20 fukn years and i never knew there was more to this song than what was on the amimals album!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what the fuk!!!!!!!!!!!!??? i fuking breathe pink floyd.. how did i not know that???????????
I had a man ask me once if I were stranded on an island and had only one band to listen to, who would I choose? I love music, plain and simple. Melodies, riffs and lyrics stay in my head. My son played his first air guitar to AC/DC. It was beautiful. The best band ever? The Beatles. No. The Rolling Stones. No. I may have AC/DC in my heart but my mind is right. Stranded on an island and only able to listen to one band? I choose the best band ever. PINK FLOYD!
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video, please see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips, more info
@envade2 thepopsheep is fucking crazy! Waters IS Pink Floyd. "Fuck Waters"? So, why would all those guys attach themselves to the music demos and lyrics Waters brought? Because they NEEDED him! PF's peak was when Waters was in the band-do the math.... They became bloated after Waters left.....
Does anyone know where I can buy the complete version (such as this)? I've listened to this about ten times in a row and can't stop even though I have so much stuff to do today. I would very much like to listen to this on the train.
its from the album animals when they releised it on cd they cut it into 2 parts and took out the geutar solo for the album animal;s im sure u could get the full version off lime wire or something
@1000DonkeyBalls No. This version was only on the 8-track version of the album. The only other place I ever found it (aside filesharing sites) was on a hard-to-find Snowy White compilation - he was the one who played the middle solo.
By the way guys, it's Snowy White on the lead guitar, not David Gilmore...and it is awesome. I've had this version on US 8-track Tape (only place it was ever released) since it came out in '77. Thanks for posting this much-improved sounding version of it!
By the way guys, it's Snowy White on the lead guitar, not David Gilmore...and it is awesome. I've had this version on US 8-track Tape (only place it was ever released) since it came out in '77. Thanks for posting this much-improved sounding version of it!
If David Gilmour (it's not "Gilmore," I am very peevish about this) would have left pink Floyd for any reason, White would have been an ideal substitute. He is an amazing guitarist, who plays his solos with lots (!) of feeling, as much as Gilmour. He "gets" it.
@cypresscoach The opening chords are the same but it's not exactly the same. Both songs begin with a G chord but the rhythm and chord changes are different.
@ziggyonthemoon I am sure someone else has explained herein, but, for the sake of simplicity: due to limitations in the format, the 8-track version of "Animals" had the songs a different order than LP and, later, cd. For 8-Track, the two version of POTW were connected together as one track as heard here. If I recall, the guitar solo is by Snowy White, not Gilmour. Still, very nice.
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc, 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun VIdeo website, link, audio/video clips can be found on our youtube channel
@zsacapala It means that if two people didn't care for each other, they would be miserable. Hoping for some reason that they should be together. A perfect sign would be "when pigs fly." Or "Pigs on the wing"
If anything, pigs on the wing are a good thing in the song, and saying that everyone who disliked a song is a pig on the wing discredits the song as much as it credits them.
Hi folks Snowy was not from Deep purple he was with Thin Lizzy .He has played rhythm guitar with pink Floyd many time live the wall tour and div bell tour he also played on Richard wrights and several of Roger Waters solo albums and played rhythm with roger on his tours.
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video, please see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips, more info
If Syd Barrett were still alive, I'd sit and listen and ponder all his amazing thoughts and philosophies. I don't give a fuck if he was "insane". He will live on forever.
@FatmanCaufield Actually what I said was pretty pathetic I take it back. Syd Barrett's work was amazing, having listened to his solo work I understand what he could've become had he not been a fool. :-)
@agentmouthwash - 8 Track, that explains it..........slightly before my time; but not long enough for me not to know what an 8 track is, unfortunately
americaxskater11- again; Syd Barret was the influence, he led them in that direction, but recording wise he wasn't around when they made LISTENABLE music
The song's title character is a transvestite whose primary pastime is stealing women's clothes and undergarments from washing lines. According to Roger Waters, "Arnold Layne" was actually based on a real person. Waters: "Both my mother and Syd's mother had students as lodgers because there was a girls' college up the road so there were constantly great lines of bras and knickers on our washing lines and 'Arnold' or whoever he was, had bits off our washing lines."
rockwillnerverdie; i don't wanna start comparing any of the beatles to anyone in pink floyd, or vice versa, gilmour is bad ass!! I only made the comparison between waters & lennon because the song that sparked the waters conversation was written & is sung by waters!
Barrett was a huge part, but it was after Barrett was (dropped) gone that they became what they became. I'm not downplaying barrettes leadership at all,
@DoodooRandyBootyclap they couldn´t START without him, but they couldn´t CONTINUE with him, barret was good por the beginning, but waters was better, you only have to listen dark side of the moon, but also Syd helped for the water´s comotitions, he was important but not the most important, thats all I think
@envade2 no no no, you're doing it wrong. You're supposed to say: "The Floyd without Wright is like The Beatles without Lennon." Let's not forget his creative genius .
@ThePopsheep waters is'nt THAT good? he isn't THAT bad either gilmour is a fantastic guitarist but as a songwriter he just can't cut it i'm afraid. i mean he even got his wife to write songs for the division bell
@outfirstball yeah, he is a good songwriter, but i hate that he is SO self-indulgant! he acts as if he's the global center of attention, and i just hate that.
@ThePopsheep i have to agree he is egotistical but that doesn't stop me loving his work a bit like bono really he's very much the same but i still love u2's work. i choose to see through the man and just cherish his genius
Beautiful music, beautiful pics... I've never heard that guitar solo in the middle before, it made me very happy. :)
MissCartoonist 5 months ago
where can i buy the record
PuffSmelly 5 months ago
snowy white...!!!
m1d4s13 5 months ago
i like the solo of who is cuz the origunal dont have it
TheWally1990 5 months ago
ssooooo great! From Lori
ssxrickybobby 5 months ago
WHERE DOES THE COMPLETE VERSION COME FROM?!?
NotOrdinaryInGames 5 months ago
@NotOrdinaryInGames This was originally done for the Animals album but i think due to running time, it was split into 2 parts, minus the solo. Think, as scrutex says below, this version was put on the 8 track version. Hopefully it will be on the new experience/immersion reissues!
bds9999 5 months ago
My dad once said This song is about the dependance of relationships and how nothing can be done with out your lover or friend.
Viewtifulexprience 5 months ago
@Viewtifulexprience I love it. Good Dad. Dependence in the best way possible, I think.
bronxred 5 months ago
The eight track version with Snowy White, been looking for a good sounding copy for a while! Thanks.
scrutex 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pink Floyd Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set and Pink Floyd The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video please see our Youtube channel for link to web site/video and audio clips/more info
ClassicRockDVD 6 months ago 2
The one band who could have a 5-song album and it's still incredible.
SSHGL 6 months ago
absolutly a fantastic sad song
stanjack007 6 months ago
The greatest band in history, there will be no band like floyd, and it's sad we won't hear new music from them. Floyd has set the bar high for bands to high for most of them
1953sls 6 months ago
pink floyd never did a bad song ever
jkozak1963 6 months ago
first time i've listen to this version,to short and mixed no good
TheMartinrt 6 months ago
does anyone know how i might go about getting this on my itunes????
clay2728 7 months ago
@clay2728 A Tube Catcher. c o m
pepejfc 6 months ago
Mocart, Betoven ,Da Vinci , PINK FLOYDI i lik sto je provalio VUTRU su najveci ljudi koji su ikada hodali !
rastabalkanraj 7 months ago
Just plain good music. Loved Floyd many years ago, and have never given them up, never will. Hope to been sitting in a rocking chair in my older, old age listening to Pigs on the Wing.
hicknan219 7 months ago
0:47 = BBF
Image & Lyrics Fit Perfectly
GlaceDuFraise 8 months ago
this song must be included on the album..perfect to close animals
LIBERTINEPARANOIC 8 months ago
Where did you get all those old Sid pictures??
ChimpFromSpace 8 months ago
lo mejor de mis tiempos mozos
SuperMaury70 8 months ago
lo mejor de mis tiempos.......sin duda alguna
SuperMaury70 8 months ago
The lyrics pretty much define all that is wrong with the world today... "care" is what is wrong, or at least the inverse of care- contempt. All other global issues stem from us having contempt for our fellow humans. The engineering of how to resolve contempt is the beginning of Enlightenment, which is the next phase of human existence. Enlightenment is the activation of the Higher Mind after disassembling all reactive/learned components. The tune is pretty good too.
bce257 8 months ago
Best version WITH SOLO!!
joconnor6 8 months ago
Great song that reminds of me of trying to hold on to someone special in your life.
311iker 8 months ago
I knew there was something different about the guitar solo.... It just didn't sound like Gilmour.
byron2521 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please, stop to be stubborn and get together again
pigsontherun 8 months ago
please, stop to be stubborn get together again
pigsontherun 8 months ago
@pigsontherun Without Richard Wright, it's highly unlikely. If he hadn't passed away, it'd probably have ended up happening. Hell, it almost did, but... I forget if it was Reading or Glastonbury, but the festival had already booked its bands and refused to bump one so that Pink Floyd could headline. Damn shame.
TotzthePlaid 8 months ago
i get crazy if i cannot listen this
pigsontherun 8 months ago
How in the hell is it that I've NEVER heard this in it's complete form....including the guitar thing bridging ........what serve as sort of musical "bookends" to the rest of the album?
195511SM 8 months ago
@195511SM This was a special version for the 8-track release of the album.
TotzthePlaid 8 months ago
@195511SM because this was a special edit with Snowy White on guitar and Richard Wright on the Hammond Organ
Papic1 8 months ago
There is a reason they call it a band. It takes more than one.
byron2521 8 months ago
i totally care!!!!
fuzpuppy 8 months ago
love the pics on this vid!!!
fuzpuppy 8 months ago
occasionally glancing up through the rain
tobybirdmann 8 months ago in playlist 420
Why can't more artist write and sing like they did. With intense passion. PINK FLOYD (I'll always love you guys)
ProZack6 8 months ago
THE DESCRIPTION IS RIGHT, THIS IS THE GREATEST BAND EVER!!
AK4TsEv3N 9 months ago
Wait where the hell did the solo come from. Was this released as a single?
uh0oo 9 months ago
@uh0oo DUDE!!! I'm wondering the same thing! I used to have the "Animals" album and this version is not on there? The songs were cut in half and it was all acoustic. Where did this come from? LOL!!! Anyways it's a GREAT version!
mrbeerjones 9 months ago
@mrbeerjones This version is one they recorded with a guy named Snowy White, he's the one doing the solo
AK4TsEv3N 9 months ago
@AK4TsEv3N Thanks man!!!
mrbeerjones 8 months ago
@mrbeerjones Yep, You're welcome =)
AK4TsEv3N 8 months ago
@uh0oo As far as I remember, this version was created for the Stereo 8 cartridge version; since in this format the albums loop, a special bridge was created with a solo played by Snowy White, who was hired as second guitar/bass for the tour...
Herod9 8 months ago
23 people have clearly gone deaf
amy2873 9 months ago
There is always something good in everyone, but its human nature to find the bad. Be different and look for the good and the bad may fade. PINK FLOYD'S music will be popular forever.
turboted777 9 months ago 2
@turboted777
You are absolutely right !!!
This muse is beautiful !
SOMAN1983V 9 months ago 2
There is always something good in everyone, its just human nature to find the bad. Be different look for the good and the bad tends to fade.
turboted777 9 months ago
So is this the version from the Animals 8-track or the one from the Snowy White comp. because I'm told they're slightly different??
skunkape2 9 months ago
Great sound quality.
YoussefFishere 9 months ago
ive been a floyd head 20 fukn years and i never knew there was more to this song than what was on the amimals album!!!!!!!!!!!!!! what the fuk!!!!!!!!!!!!??? i fuking breathe pink floyd.. how did i not know that???????????
michellekfleming 9 months ago
@michellekfleming This is just parts 1 and 2 put together...
DarkSunGod 9 months ago
@DarkSunGod Where did the guitar solo come from?
YoussefFishere 9 months ago
@michellekfleming how about a 30+ year fan who didn't know about this version until today? Those secretave bastards!
whoWouldYaLIKEmeToBe 9 months ago
sounds a bit like "Mother" from the wall.
turbocat64 9 months ago
@turbocat64 Yup, major use of the C and G chords. I get mixed up myself when I play either of the songs.
blazefootball91 9 months ago
I had a man ask me once if I were stranded on an island and had only one band to listen to, who would I choose? I love music, plain and simple. Melodies, riffs and lyrics stay in my head. My son played his first air guitar to AC/DC. It was beautiful. The best band ever? The Beatles. No. The Rolling Stones. No. I may have AC/DC in my heart but my mind is right. Stranded on an island and only able to listen to one band? I choose the best band ever. PINK FLOYD!
biailwy 9 months ago
what an awsome melody, all the musical pieces with Rogers voice just makes this an amazing song words cant discribe.
cloudchaser07 9 months ago
Pink Floyd were 50 years before their time
Most people still don't undertsand what they were singing
DeadJesus100 9 months ago 20
This has been flagged as spam show
@DeadJesus100 and why you think in this way?
SOMAN1983V 8 months ago
this song is the best unheard solo
TheGunTotingAtheist 9 months ago 2
This song is real or what?? I'm on shock!!!
chiefshinobi 9 months ago 2
gilmour is indeed magical...but the solo is stormy white
DBRGroup 10 months ago
@DBRGroup snowy white lol
drums127 10 months ago
@drums127 ya, snowy white did the solo. look it up.
DBRGroup 9 months ago
@DBRGroup I know he did , i never said he didnt lol . I love his solo here
drums127 9 months ago
one of my favorites on this album. Love Floyd.Never tire of it
hicknan219 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video, please see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips, more info
Tommygun1028 10 months ago
ThePopsheep,, you can put all 11 tracks on Division Bell & don't add up to any of the 5 tracks on Animals
envade2 10 months ago
@envade2 We'll have to agree to disagree.
oneofspades 10 months ago
@envade2 thepopsheep is fucking crazy! Waters IS Pink Floyd. "Fuck Waters"? So, why would all those guys attach themselves to the music demos and lyrics Waters brought? Because they NEEDED him! PF's peak was when Waters was in the band-do the math.... They became bloated after Waters left.....
FatmanCaufield 9 months ago
yea blazed out eyeballs, hahahaha,
rondawwg420 10 months ago
Does anyone know where I can buy the complete version (such as this)? I've listened to this about ten times in a row and can't stop even though I have so much stuff to do today. I would very much like to listen to this on the train.
Spaceshiptopluto 10 months ago
I got this song on vinyl...And let me tell u that some gold i got!
123InDaPlaceToBe 10 months ago
Comment removed
123InDaPlaceToBe 10 months ago
Syd Barrett rifaba!! el mejor
makenoises 10 months ago
probably my favorite Pink Floyd song... off a great album
drew040 10 months ago
Thank You
micago62 10 months ago
where did you get this from? Been listening to floyd for 27 years and have never heard this before.
11ellsbells 10 months ago
@11ellsbells lol this is the first and fifth track of their 1977 album 'Animals' put together
baksteen123 10 months ago
@11ellsbells i should have listened first... didnt notice this was a diffrent version nevermind
baksteen123 10 months ago
its from the album animals when they releised it on cd they cut it into 2 parts and took out the geutar solo for the album animal;s im sure u could get the full version off lime wire or something
@11ellsbells
1000DonkeyBalls 10 months ago
@1000DonkeyBalls nah, it was like that on the 12" vinyl record too....
11ellsbells 10 months ago
@1000DonkeyBalls No. This version was only on the 8-track version of the album. The only other place I ever found it (aside filesharing sites) was on a hard-to-find Snowy White compilation - he was the one who played the middle solo.
Billinois78 10 months ago
must we waste time talking about before/after Waters? just enjoy the music.
MrKillerhaven 10 months ago 33
@MrKillerhaven
Amen.Who fucking cares anymore? They made great music together. Let's enjoy.
AngusShanks 9 months ago
In which album can I find this version?
faberkazam 10 months ago
@faberkazam
Besides the original 8-track (which was the ONLY official place this was EVER released), the version here is the best quality I've heard.
agentfiftyseven1 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
By the way guys, it's Snowy White on the lead guitar, not David Gilmore...and it is awesome. I've had this version on US 8-track Tape (only place it was ever released) since it came out in '77. Thanks for posting this much-improved sounding version of it!
agentfiftyseven1 10 months ago
By the way guys, it's Snowy White on the lead guitar, not David Gilmore...and it is awesome. I've had this version on US 8-track Tape (only place it was ever released) since it came out in '77. Thanks for posting this much-improved sounding version of it!
agentfiftyseven1 10 months ago
@agentfiftyseven1
If David Gilmour (it's not "Gilmore," I am very peevish about this) would have left pink Floyd for any reason, White would have been an ideal substitute. He is an amazing guitarist, who plays his solos with lots (!) of feeling, as much as Gilmour. He "gets" it.
5jerry1 10 months ago
I just realized this is note for note, exactly the same as "Mother".
cypresscoach 10 months ago 2
@cypresscoach The opening chords are the same but it's not exactly the same. Both songs begin with a G chord but the rhythm and chord changes are different.
uhoitsjono 10 months ago
I dedicate this listening to Holly...
doctorwintercold 10 months ago
wheres this solo come from? i never new this song had a version with a solo , can some one explain please lol.
ziggyonthemoon 10 months ago
@ziggyonthemoon I am sure someone else has explained herein, but, for the sake of simplicity: due to limitations in the format, the 8-track version of "Animals" had the songs a different order than LP and, later, cd. For 8-Track, the two version of POTW were connected together as one track as heard here. If I recall, the guitar solo is by Snowy White, not Gilmour. Still, very nice.
crusteous 10 months ago
@crusteous ah thanks! its a shame they omitted this from cd.
ziggyonthemoon 10 months ago
best Floyd album easily
Scumbagization 11 months ago
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc, 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun VIdeo website, link, audio/video clips can be found on our youtube channel
ClassicRockDVD 11 months ago
23 People are pigs on the wing
zsacapala 11 months ago
@zsacapala Do you even know what that phrase means?
omega4104 11 months ago
@omega4104 I think so
zsacapala 11 months ago
@zsacapala It means that if two people didn't care for each other, they would be miserable. Hoping for some reason that they should be together. A perfect sign would be "when pigs fly." Or "Pigs on the wing"
If anything, pigs on the wing are a good thing in the song, and saying that everyone who disliked a song is a pig on the wing discredits the song as much as it credits them.
omega4104 11 months ago
@omega4104 Ok thank you for the explanation and i´m sorry ja
zsacapala 11 months ago
Davids tones on this album where outstanding
SpEcIaLoPsM4mAn 11 months ago
WERE CAN I GET THIS ITS NOT ON THE VINYL WOW AMAZING
RockerWatt 11 months ago
Hi folks Snowy was not from Deep purple he was with Thin Lizzy .He has played rhythm guitar with pink Floyd many time live the wall tour and div bell tour he also played on Richard wrights and several of Roger Waters solo albums and played rhythm with roger on his tours.
davesweet63 11 months ago
that solo :)
rastabalkanraj 11 months ago
....Eargasim....
LedHed65 11 months ago
Man,I really like this song.
unclechipper 11 months ago
Pink Floyd, Live in Oakland 1977 3-disc 2CD/DVD set, Pink Floyd, The Wall Live at Earl's Court 1980 DVD available at Tommygun Video, please see youtube channel for link, video/audio clips, more info
ClassicRockDVD 11 months ago
Snowy White played the solo again for a compilation album as he had played a solo for the 8 track cartridge version to bridge the gap
Mateokow 11 months ago
If Syd Barrett were still alive, I'd sit and listen and ponder all his amazing thoughts and philosophies. I don't give a fuck if he was "insane". He will live on forever.
IndieRokker6 11 months ago 2
@IndieRokker6 i hear you man. just picked up his latest biography. i dont think he had much to do aside from influence with this song, tho
rfsh101 11 months ago
I've never heard this version. Thank you!
Driver8852 1 year ago
22 people voted to put pigs like george bush on the wing
nonesta13 1 year ago
@nonesta13 u r dum
spencexxx 11 months ago
@spencexxx you cant even spell..
nonesta13 11 months ago
Comment removed
rastabalkanraj 1 year ago
Yeah... Wow.. Thought I'd heard it all...
69mag 1 year ago
We're not really ... all that different now are we ... ;^)
unclwldo 1 year ago
........mind=blown
Gazonkie 1 year ago
21 PIECE OF SHIT PIGS!
MrDodstink 1 year ago
everyone fights about gilmour/waters...
simple:
waters - brilliant song-writer
gilmour - gave the music a soul, and GREAT singer and guitarist
wright - made things wonderfully coherent and magical
mason - fuck yeah drums
and i miss barrett :(
waterbagel 1 year ago 59
@waterbagel sid was all of that...
Manojlo3 10 months ago
@waterbagel More people fight about Gilmour and Barrett than Gilmour and Waters
fungusuarus 9 months ago
@waterbagel
Snowy White - very great solo.
DarkSideOfPlanetGONG 9 months ago
@waterbagel OMG!!! THAT IS THE MOST COHERENT COMMENT I'VE EVER SEEN
AK4TsEv3N 9 months ago
Pink Floyd without Barrett is more like Beatles without Pete Best.
GenesisKnights 1 year ago
@GenesisKnights Yes, agreed. Totally overrated.
FatmanCaufield 10 months ago
@FatmanCaufield Actually what I said was pretty pathetic I take it back. Syd Barrett's work was amazing, having listened to his solo work I understand what he could've become had he not been a fool. :-)
GenesisKnights 10 months ago
Wow! I'd never heard this version before. Thanks for posting it.
666slink 1 year ago
that solo should have been on the album
Stairmaster9068 1 year ago
this version was released only on a cassete version of animals.
and by the way,the solo is not by the gilmour but by snowy white (a second guitarist for pink floyd shows and nowadays a guitarist for roger waters)
k0stil 1 year ago
@k0stil But who wrote the solo.? Snowy or Dave? Cuz it's the best part of the song. I bet Roger is the one that cut it from the Animals album.
fuzpuppy 1 year ago
@fuzpuppy
i think its snowy who wrote the solo,
otherwise if you write the solo ,why would you want somebody else to play it???
nobody cut it from the album!
i think pink floyd liked both version and they thought that it would be a good idea to release one version on LP and another version on a 8-track.
the full version was also released on snowy white`s "goldtop" compilation album
k0stil 1 year ago
@k0stil thnx for your answer!!
crtzrs 11 months ago
my song better type in (u fucked me hard)
ringofl123 1 year ago
aszxc
ringofl123 1 year ago
Pink Floyd always gives me the goosebumps.
KingMada1 1 year ago
Thumbs up for pink floyd!
sonicsteev 1 year ago
The world is a better place with Pink Floyd in it
toobularbells 1 year ago 2
bernardmmarx- see what I mean, you're having to find one of only a few good songs while with Barrett, but damn!! that is a good song
envade2 1 year ago
were can i find this full version...???
crtzrs 1 year ago
@crtzrs on the album animals
iamthechanceman 1 year ago
@iamthechanceman i have the album but its not with this guitar solo 1:16
tnx!!!!
crtzrs 1 year ago
I love David Gilmour, but Snowy White does this solo. It's from the 8-Track version of Animals
agentmouthwash 1 year ago
@agentmouthwash - 8 Track, that explains it..........slightly before my time; but not long enough for me not to know what an 8 track is, unfortunately
fuzpuppy 1 year ago
oops, meant bigboimlp; no disrespect!!
envade2 1 year ago
nigboimlp - oh hell yeah!!
envade2 1 year ago
americaxskater11- again; Syd Barret was the influence, he led them in that direction, but recording wise he wasn't around when they made LISTENABLE music
envade2 1 year ago
@envade2 Wrong-Arnold Layne!
The song's title character is a transvestite whose primary pastime is stealing women's clothes and undergarments from washing lines. According to Roger Waters, "Arnold Layne" was actually based on a real person. Waters: "Both my mother and Syd's mother had students as lodgers because there was a girls' college up the road so there were constantly great lines of bras and knickers on our washing lines and 'Arnold' or whoever he was, had bits off our washing lines."
toobularbells 1 year ago
@envade2 dude, are you saying that Piper at the gates of dawn isn't listenable?
bernardmmarx 1 year ago
rockwillnerverdie; i don't wanna start comparing any of the beatles to anyone in pink floyd, or vice versa, gilmour is bad ass!! I only made the comparison between waters & lennon because the song that sparked the waters conversation was written & is sung by waters!
envade2 1 year ago
doodoobootycrap
Barrett was a huge part, but it was after Barrett was (dropped) gone that they became what they became. I'm not downplaying barrettes leadership at all,
listen to their music before & after.
FAG!!
envade2 1 year ago
if you dont think that waters is a huge part of pink floyd than you must have never listened to the lyrics of a pink floyd song
f3l18ipsk8erm 1 year ago
Absolutely adore this full version, I'm such a huge floyd fan an was really pleased to hear this existed.
jamieGism 1 year ago
Pink Floyd without Waters is like The Beatles without Lennon!!
envade2 1 year ago 50
@envade2 Pink Floyd without Barret is like The Beatles without balls
Tincho730 1 year ago
@envade2 correction: Pink floyd without BARRETT is like The Beatles without Lennon
DoodooRandyBootyclap 1 year ago
@DoodooRandyBootyclap they couldn´t START without him, but they couldn´t CONTINUE with him, barret was good por the beginning, but waters was better, you only have to listen dark side of the moon, but also Syd helped for the water´s comotitions, he was important but not the most important, thats all I think
zsacapala 1 year ago
@envade2 im gay
DoodooRandyBootyclap 1 year ago
@envade2 correction: Pink Floyd without BARRETT is like The Beatles without Lennon
DoodooRandyBootyclap 1 year ago
@envade2 And I think that if it was without Gilmour, We could compare the Beatles without Paul McCartney!!!!
rockwillnerverdie 1 year ago
@envade2 More like without syd barrett.
emericaxskater11 1 year ago 3
@envade2 Can we please not argue. . .let's just say Pink Floyd without Gilmour is like a man without a penis.
bigboimlp 1 year ago 2
@envade2 Great point!
QueenieMaya 1 year ago
@envade2 Less douchey and self important, but lyrically lost? Agreed
poop2poop2 1 year ago 2
@envade2 no no no, you're doing it wrong. You're supposed to say: "The Floyd without Wright is like The Beatles without Lennon." Let's not forget his creative genius .
CanOChili 1 year ago 3
@envade2 luckily waters hasnt been shot and he isnt some hippy asshole
fungusuarus 11 months ago
@envade2 what about the division bell?
fuck waters.
this is my favorite band, but waters isnt THAT good.
ThePopsheep 10 months ago
@ThePopsheep waters is'nt THAT good? he isn't THAT bad either gilmour is a fantastic guitarist but as a songwriter he just can't cut it i'm afraid. i mean he even got his wife to write songs for the division bell
outfirstball 10 months ago
@outfirstball yeah, he is a good songwriter, but i hate that he is SO self-indulgant! he acts as if he's the global center of attention, and i just hate that.
ThePopsheep 10 months ago
@ThePopsheep i have to agree he is egotistical but that doesn't stop me loving his work a bit like bono really he's very much the same but i still love u2's work. i choose to see through the man and just cherish his genius
outfirstball 10 months ago
Comment removed
ThePopsheep 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@outfirstball when I said waters isnt that good, i meant as a musician, not as a songwriter.
plus, I hate him for trying to dissolve the group by leaving it. he is an ass, but gilmour and wright were able to bring the group back together.
ThePopsheep 9 months ago