林道遠 天天 vs 林宥嘉 你是我的眼

[tn00777479]

林宥嘉的聲音乍聽之下或許沒有楊宗緯獲蕭敬騰令人驚艷, 但用心去聽他, 林宥嘉完全不輸他們兩個

[jasoninelmstreet]

其实如果是林宥嘉连续pk萧敬腾，我不认为林宥嘉可以有任何胜算­。

[DADA706958]

很享受舞台的小胖子，林宥嘉很有自己的風格



[edisonsun21c]

不知为何，辛晓琪笑的样子让人感觉压力好大

[smo757]

舞台 完全沒氣氛

[xsam510]

歌贏太多

[TCEYDD]

同意之前有人講林宥嘉唱的不錯，但沒有25分的水準，林道遠今天­反而唱的比他好



[lckvfantasticfour]

@TCEYDD 林道遠這次的辨識度不是很高吧...

[myl9797]

唱得很棒，虽然没哭 可是听到后还是觉得心里酸酸的 T.T 我看到后面有一个留言 觉得蛮不爽，想说一些话（绝无批评成分） 有人说这首歌如果让杨宗纬唱一定更好更有感情 杨宗纬唱悲歌是很有感情没错 可是这首歌我觉得林宥嘉诠释得真的很棒 达到满分也是名副其实的 我看那位应该是鸽子吧，因为杨分数没yoga高所以才来贬低Yo­ga 纯属个人意见 见怪请原谅~

[jasonstorr]

he sang it better than david sorry,david fans they both so good!

[jasonstorr]

he sang it better than david sorry,david fans

[xietianhao]

賴虎酷喔！！

[a52917g1]

這集真的精彩前面是楊對蕭對決後面又來一個完美作

[broomhead8]

@10205159 給這位瞧不起台灣的大陸人 沒錯 香港很多紅星 如你所說成龍 劉德華 張國榮 許冠傑 這位紅星個個努力 謙卑 所以即使香港只是小小的地方 他們仍就能穿越國界的讓他們的聲音.他們的表演 傳達到很遠的外地 這就是這些人能夠成為巨星的基本功 同樣的 台灣也有很多巨星的舞台 不僅侷限於台灣本島 他們在香港大陸 甚至其他國家 也有很大的名氣 因為他們也很努力 並且知道什麼叫"目中有人" 大陸有很多演員 我也非常喜歡 因為音樂 藝術 或是其他藝文表演 本來就沒有國界 更無需政治立場 我知道跟你說這些您大概還是不屑看 對你而言 你想要作的 "只不過想要瞧不起別人而已" 也許"井蛙觀天"這句成語 真的就是為您設定的

[jPoPbOl]

damn hate his pattern!!!!!

[yanyanchanful]

yoga棒到没话说

[boy13856]

林道遠唱天天也不錯喔

[MakiNagato]

林道遠也很強拉

[adaluicy]

在這一次pk賽我反而比較喜歡林道遠.

宥嘉感情表達顯得有點吃力... 當然"你是我的眼"是比較難唱的

[goyoling]

宥嘉的共鳴真的很好~~

你是"我"的眼，的"我"很有力!!!!

[tristatong]

yoga!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ispd123]

看到他的嘴巴就好想笑哈哈哈

[fanfanchau]

宥嘉非常強,這個不用說

林道遠也真的唱的非常好!只可惜運氣不夠了.

[KmiowC]

i remember when i first watched this and 林道遠performed first, i was like "Oh no, Yoga's F*****, this guy is gooood!" and then Yoga did so well with 你是我的眼..Yoga's incredible!!

First season was the best!

[Daisyhok]

宥嘉这首唱的太棒了！

完全把感觉唱出来了

更胜于原创

[PoorHarrison]

反而聽聽原創是唱得比較有感情喔

[Daisyhok]

可能每个人不同吧...反正是宥嘉把我唱哭了，原唱倒没有呢

[qszwax92]

@Daisyhok 你這句話會被一堆人鞭死吧 你聽過蕭煌奇唱過!!!??

那個就做感動人 YOGA視唱不出蕭煌奇的意境的

沒身歷其境是挺會不出那種感覺得

[yuga321]

@qszwax92 的确，不是亲身体验的经历唱不出那种感觉。但也不是说不是失明的­人就不能唱出感动。

[vincentnorth]

fantastic song.....i adore your voice

[015135]

我覺得林道遠唱得很棒了，超好聽的可能運氣不好遇到另一個對手也­perfect的吧不過，他唱得真的很好，挺你！

[wbrianmatch]

agree i like lim very much

[nerisio]

THIS VIDEO IS GREAT

v=B0w4gDJpg1

ok okok

[lit6219]

爲什麽以前的參賽者不用set頭髮，不用化妝，不用穿得像棒棒堂­一樣；一件白襯衫，就能唱出這麼感動人心的歌？

[hanabi77]

我觉得林宥佳这个你是我的眼的确是经典 特别是这首歌真的很不好诠释，很有深度的一首歌，一个不留神就会­完全变味，但yoga真的是又唱出自己的味道但又抓住了歌的灵魂­，i just can't get tird listenin to this performance ...so perfect

[tokyojoe1698]

我都是香港人,大部份的香港歌手都沒有練好基本的唱功丶還有現時­大部份的香港曲和詞都很垃圾、很難唱出感情丶所以台灣的確很多好­聽的歌・

[xcheeb]

@tokyojoe1698 This definitely do not include Eason and Wyman.

[happydays1698]

@xcheeb agree.

[tungfat1985]

@tokyojoe1698 香港近年好像有點小陽春,老實說,例如,王苑之,at17,ju­no等的音樂真的很好

編,歌,詞也有一定質素。可是,不紅,LOL

[wongtszlamj]

@tokyojoe1698 你前面所說的和台灣有好聽的歌有關係嗎?

[raymondsze27]

香港也有很多好聲~

like eason , khalil , hin etc...~

however,香港也有賣樣>賣唱的人~

[wct11]

老實說..台灣的確很多好聽的聲音

利益伸報: 我是香港人!

[lovekarakara]

作為香港人

我每天只能到處找各國的音樂去滿足耳朵

想起了本土所謂的『歌手』..真是侮辱了歌手兩字..

[joeykari]

i agree !!! :D

[shakebooty]

You don't have to be that negative about the HK pop culture. There are some up coming singers or singers that have sung in HK for many years some credit. People like Eason, William So, Justin, Hins, Khalil (even though he is ABC) are respectable in their singing abilities. New stars such as GEM deserves much more credit. Even though the proportionality of TW singers selling "looks" more than "voice" is less compared to HK, but they still do it..E.g. F4

[siuming375ml]

2位都唱得超好喔~ 但我較喜歡林道遠

[s866217]

道遠是二班的遺珠之憾 他真的有一副好嗓音 他起碼唱贏4班所有選手 胖胖的好有人緣 敗在跳舞對他很不公平 我可以接受一個歌手唱好歌給我聽 不需要會手舞足蹈

[hua1104]

道遠的歌聲聽起來好舒服

[leoisinlove]

taiwan singers are excellent. really really impressed. hong kong singers are ... sigh... shame for them.

I am hong kongese between.

[alexyeung91]

兩位都好棒-v-"

[hit8881]

講的好直接....但台灣真的要加油要把握這些因為民主思想開放­的優勢 才能真的成為華人的音樂中心阿!

[10205159]

台湾同胞...台湾歌星红的确是有但我觉得红半边天的也许只有几­个而已就象邓丽君...其余的都是来自香港,就象有张学友,哥哥­张国勇,成龙,周捘发,刘德华,许冠杰,他们都是从八十年代成名­到现在,而台湾的也不就是来来去去那几个小猫而已嘛...哈哈哈­....

[paulineqc]

同意。。。。。台湾新人太多了

[bear5482]

@10205159 我不認為在台灣只有鄧麗君紅其餘都是香港人紅，你並不是台灣人對­台灣流行文化一知半解，拜託不要說這種自以為是的話

[climbv67970]

繼續貶低其他的地方人吧

這一代的小孩好像沒被教過禮貌這回事

台灣人是全球最強的,對吧?

[tonyyau1000]

林道遠好樣衰...個咀係到歪...

[myacnt8999]

actually lin dao yuan has very good voice and technique, pretty equal with lin you jia, but he totally lost to lin you jia in terms of emotion, character (style), and stage presence. lin you jia is almost perfect singer.

[EricLauKM]

心理學實驗証明，人在絕大部份其他人都肯定一件荒謬的事的時候，­自己也會因為這種群眾壓力，又或者『絕大多數人不會都錯吧』這心­態，而放棄自己正確的看法，反而會跟隨大隊的去指鹿為馬。當評審­們重複的、一貫的去肯定林宥嘉的唱功時，有著羊群心態的大眾就會­去認同『國皇的新衣』，『認真』的去認為林唱的真的很不錯！這效­應在這次對唱可算是再明顯不過了。

[Jason123171]

有很多人扣我的分可能誤會了我的意思.

[Jason123171]

林道遠唱得很不錯..

可以他的外表不適合唱這樣情歌..

[casperkichi]

林道遠其實也唱得不錯, 但感情好像還是差一點點

這方面yoga比較優勝

[shineluvslambiel]

林道遠其實唱的真的很不錯

[Strangerimissyou]

外表一d都5重要

雖然，林道遠係好肥

但唱歌總好比香港d先

[LujaxChan]

actually lin dao yuan sing quite good ma... dun GIV him bad comment becoz he is FAT N UGLY! Of coz compare both of them Yoga is better...

[Yangace]

林道遠 sang pretty well.. just because his appearance is not as attractive, you all make such negative assumptions.

[myacnt8999]

please show some respect. being fat doesn't mean a bad singer. of course yoga is a better singer, but i bet 林道遠 sings much better than you.

[tvbifreak]

respect? being fat doesnt mean a bad singer, i know that. when did i say being fat means they sing bad? however, which singer do you know that is fat? you cant compare me to him ya know, how old is he?

[myacnt8999]

sorry if i offended you..XD but i just think that lin dao yuan's singing is pretty good, obviously not better than yoga, but it is pretty rude to say that he's fat.

[tvbifreak]

haha its ok, im just saying that to be a celeb, its kinda better to have a fit body.

[irene1128]

就是因為總有你們這種人的想法

所以香港才會有那種只賣樣不賣唱的歌手

[tvbifreak]

aha. you are very funny. even those artists who DONT sell, HAVE A FIT BODY!

[irene1128]

就是因為總有你們這種人的想法

所以香港才會有那種只賣樣不賣唱的歌手

[voiceless2005]

你一步步邁向光明路

我則朝向黑暗爬行!_!

[voiceless2005]

對慢慢就快失去眼前景象的我而言

我對蕭的唱法沒感受,對林的唱法則大感動

蕭的唱歌中只有面對眼盲想迴避

感情只見過度內斂

林則外放(或許是因為要表演)

但至少就是能聽出失去光明的悲哀

[voiceless2005]

To 認為蕭煌奇唱得好的人 他因為yoga錢賺到不行 不過卻因為一堆人說他唱得沒yoga好 所以他一直要和yoga劃界線 演唱會請了蕭敬騰 有別苗頭之意 不過這就當八卦聽 最重要的是 聽說他要去開刀了 眼睛有重見光明的可能 到時大家再去聽,那時的好才是真好吧.

[tvbifreak]

whos that fat guy? how can he and yoga compare? yoga is so much better!

[pohhwa5200]

林道遠 唱歌很可爱 很享受 很好听！！！！！！！！！！！

[x96283ql4]

林宥嘉GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD啦

[hellashehe]

林宥嘉唱你是我的眼都唱得幾好聽, 但我覺得不值25分這個完美分數吧! 如果換給楊宗緯唱一定唱得更好更有感情, 還有賴銘偉也唱得好好, 還好過林宥嘉, 因為賴銘偉不但能唱出感情, 而唱功和運氣也很好, 絶不像林宥嘉唱時出現換氣聲入晒咪, 唔好話呢d叫表達感情而美化呢d缺點呀! 陶醉緊美妙的歌聲時, 中間夾雜呢d聲, 完全是另人突然抽出陶醉的意境, 真是一種破壞的...

[startingsprinter]

yoga doesn't know how to sing. end.

[pitter0929]

林宥嘉唱的真好.

道遠也不錯.

謝謝有"你是我的眼"這首歌的存在.

[MakiYamato]

簡單一句

你是我的眼只有蕭煌奇唱得好..

[voiceless2005]

又是一個以瞎與否來定歌聲者

[tvbifreak]

i think so too

[voiceless2005]

yoga唱天天當然不可能唱成林道遠的樣子

yoga的特色就是多變且還保有自己的色彩

就連選歌也是

而且PK就是各選自己擅長的歌來唱

所以評比的時候說叫A唱對方的歌一定唱不好

這句話是沒有必要的

但如果差個一兩分還可以說是少數人控制分數

現在兩人分數差距這麼大

代表評審多數贊同yoga唱得很好

這是無法否認的

[withrain]

林宥嘉用喉嚨的力量唱歌  換氣聲超大

叫他來唱天天，他唱不出清亮的聲音

雖然他聲音有特色 詮釋得也不錯

[ISISTHEBEST4EVER]

用喉嚨唱歌是一個很大的錯誤，如果林宥嘉真的是那樣，評審一定會­提出來且批評

林宥嘉根本就不是用喉嚨的力量來唱啊、而且有時候換氣聲也是表達­感情的一種方式，如果一首歌完全沒有小小的瑕疵反倒變得不完美吧­。

[withrain]

說真的  很難接受你是我的野這首歌

蕭煌奇唱的那麼好聽 唉

林道遠唱的比較好！雖然我不是林道遠的歌迷

[xboredBITCH]

Both of them sang nicely , but yoga sang better . He has more uhh , so called ''FEEL'' :D

[kelhws]

Win maybe coz tht song popularity ?

[wyq85626]

this song become popular, because he chose it,people know this song from this competition

[ckm1313]

看到3分14秒.小玲老師在一開始已經說了:很好

[sianxian]

actually in terms of preparation i think dao yuan did better. he's got better flow of the whole song, 尾音 etc all very well done.

but lin you jia has more feel...

[StarUchiha0805]

說得也是啊 道遠是唱得不錯啦

不過 他對上的是我在每季超級星光大道中

最欣賞的兩位選手之一 更是獨一無二的林宥嘉

抽到宥嘉算他不幸 宥嘉能給予的震撼力

道遠可是比不過的

[prosaici]

林宥嘉唱這首歌時我怎個就是覺得超讚ㄉ!!太讚了

[babig0910ivy]

林宥嘉唱ㄉ超好聽ㄉ 簡直唱出大家ㄉ心聲  蕭煌奇老師太棒ㄌ 謝謝他把這首歌帶給世界ㄉ每伊ㄍ人 太好聽ㄌ之前我覺ㄉ很不喜歡不過真ㄉ太好聽ㄌ

[leondaz]

good vocal for both of them,but yoga better.

[laviniayi]

这位老兄唱的也很不错，可惜对上林宥嘉真是太不幸了。

就算只听歌声，还是林宥嘉的更有感染力......

[fishzz928]

both also good

[oioiioooo]

宥嘉很棒!!

[venusking222]

touching

yoga is the best

[yogre89]

he so suay kena yoga

[letlet33]

林宥嘉's voice.........very touching~~~

[akurim1234]

Really好聽!

[tayjrong93]

Great..

[jwangphp3]

this was a PK episode? i didn't know 道遠 was here already...i didn't know of him until a contestant on 2nd season

[wwwmnit]

林道遠,, 很厲害哦,,

比起兩個,說實在我喜歡林道遠多點,

唱歌技巧很厲害,而且樣子很口愛,

[KInskinsU]

我也覺得他很可愛...胖胖的body

[blueymiao]

我也是！！ 道远 加油

[174063444]

同意

而且林宥嘉未必唱到林道遠唱的那首歌

題外話..為什麼會負七分

[loveumei]

well done 林宥嘉 jia you^^

[wf2305]

林道遠唱的不比林宥嘉差吧...好好聽

[xiinx]

not bad wor !

[acdegbh]

Yoga sing this song so well .

[hb1226741]

我覺得林宥嘉換氣生真的有點大.....

[obrianbear]

感覺林道遠唱得真棒

每天聽一次心情都很好～

[pinga6302]

能唱出自己的特色,沒有別人的影子又能打動人心,早已超越任何人­,25分是一定要的啦,太棒了~

[AngieJoyce]

I agree with you

[gd3v1l]

but i think 林道遠 jz sing as how tao ze sing i mean he din modify and make it bcome his song. he does not has his own style however, 林宥嘉 definitely has more practice as he alr attend the context for such long

on the other hand, 林宥嘉 has make a little different from the originals and u can definitely noe tat is 林宥嘉 who is singing not others

[JaLysC]

先入為主...林宥嘉讓我認識這首歌"你是我的眼"林宥嘉的演唱­讓我感動。再去尋找原創+原唱蕭煌奇演繹時讓我流淚...感情﹖­兩個都有﹗演繹﹖兩人唱功各有千秋﹗畢竟宥嘉剛出道歷煉不深﹐不­過我們心目中的迷幻王子會暴紅的﹗宥嘉加油﹗﹗至於大夥兒在爭論­誰唱的好唱的有感情...無可否認詞曲創作人+演唱者蕭煌奇唱的­是自己的心聲...我們...又能對一個對音樂那麼有熱誠與天賦­的盲胞爭辯什麼呢?支持他們才是我們該做的..."你是我的眼"­...好歌﹗

[theutman]

"你是我的眼" can be a very good lovers' song~ ;)

[jiyanz615]

i think yoga sang well! He is my favourite contestant..i love when he sings this song =) However, i totally agree that the original singer will sing nicer..so..both are good ^^ I like you jia!!

[bogy7300]

哇

你太誇張了

蕭煌奇的地位豈是你說的狀況

林宥嘉是很好

但是原唱的生命力和靈魂無人可比

[startingsprinter]

yoga is only an okay singer... don't exaggerate him too much, don't compare him with xiao huang qi's version.

你真無知

[moomoocowz]

你不知道蕭煌奇是你無知!!

[szechia]

both have different feels..both have nice voice..

taiwan have many wonderful singers..looking forward to see more new faces

[DeSpErAte2BeYouRs]

both ppl sang soo well!!

[cliveisback]

nt bad...

[andriy5319]

good......~~

[carydef]

林道遠太緊張,很多橋段都很"急"的唱完,(連最後的口白"I Luv U Babe"都很趕,不過歌聲很不錯,事實上林宥嘉的情感很融入,­不過換氣聲應不至滿分,坦白說滿分是有些言過其實,但有20分的­實力了

[is36k]

宥嘉唱你是我的眼...

真的把我帶進了那樣的氛圍

以不花俏卻真摯的方式

把感動傳達出來

[Daphne577]

i love yoga

[lovinghiro]

his mouth yam got wad kaitan wif u arh?dun like to c dun c lo..

[eukia]

actually e guy in black sang quite well BUT still yoga put in much more feeling into his singing =DDD

[nien0310]

damn love his style... <3 yoga~

[x2sweet4ux]

what does ㄍ一ㄥmean?

[14yearsX]

ㄍ一ㄥmeans stiff

[szewei]

of course Yoga is better!! the judges r profesional okay!! he deserved to win!!!

[tiffiiffi]

ahahha i love tao zhi's reaction shes like...i know i know!! i wore my glasses !!

[kvuerroa]

hell no...你是我的眼is sooo much better then that shit. 林宥嘉 you ROCK

[kvuerroa]

no, but even if 林宥嘉 sing the same song as him. 林宥嘉's still going to win. he's like one of the best ppl in the group.

[antimage27]

not neccessarly

.. his voice is not fit for r&b

nevertheless...hes a great singer...im simply saying its hard to judge 2 songs from totally genre

so dont flame me casue im sharing difference of opinion

[skyblueIce]

你是我的眼 林宥嘉唱得真好, his voice is so powerful, which i think made his performance even better.

[josh17767]

I like 林道遠, he sings really well.

I will say that 林宥嘉 has more emoiton in the song.

[antimage27]

ok...first of all u cannot compare people's singing with 2 different songs...its not fair ok..天天 is just hard to sing...david tao is just sick ok anyways 天天 is SOOO! much harder to sing compare 你是我的眼

the judges are too bias....so are the people watchin the show

even IF 林宥嘉 is better...theyre both really good

[kaikai601]

agree, 天天 is a much harder song!

[templardna]

LOL! "天天 is a much harder song"?

please, 你是我的眼 is way harder. It's got really low and high notes, not alot of people can sing this song well. even the original singer said that.

[antimage27]

its lower ..but not higher

dude a song thats versitile doesnt make it more difficult..im not saying 你是我的眼 is easy..im simply saying 天天 is harder.

go ask anyone from a vocal music background

[itmfl2046]

No way, buddy. i have a vocal music background, and there is no way i would consider 天天 to be harder to sing. It is easier to sing than 你是我的眼 for sure. Yoga's singing voice and overall performance was much better than the other guy, as well.

[antimage27]

yes i agree that yoga is a better singer...for sure BUT tian tian is harder..its A LOT more dynamic and hard to perfect...although 你是我的眼 is more versitile

[ilovelespauls27]

im sorry but i have to agree with antimage27.

tian tian has a much higher difficulty level, its higher pitch, more transitions, plus riffing.

Song choice = no contest.

Anyone with a good vocal range with a bit of power can sing you are my eyes.

prove me wrong

[rosemars8]

這是林宥嘉唱得最好的一首歌, 我覺得啦.

[aznmav1]

anyone know where i can dl these songs?

[blessedjiru]

can someone tell me if the extra 5points are something like bonus points? i'm quite confused if the full marks are 20 or 25.