Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (327)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Merry Mee!! <3

  • <3

  • genial<3

  • OhMyGod. You just won my heart. <3

  • Awesome. <3

  • ur too .... handsome(: great singer -3

  • Ok be my girl : )

  • This is in addition to my previous post. I didn't say anything bad about Katy Perry. She sold ten of millions of records already so she must be doing something right :) no doubt about that.

    It's just a different genre. That is why I made the comment and I still like this version better.

  • I love this and I also agree with BTC0288 after I listened to Ms Perry's performance of this song, I prefer troye's version it's 100x better than Ms Perry's version.

  • I prefer this version over Katy`s

  • 02:24 - 03:03 My favourite part <3

  • Cute, beautiful eyes, and a beautiful voice! How's that possible? :O

  • Go listen to Katy Perry's original and then come back and listen to this. This song has such a heartbreaking lyric, and unfortunately Ms Perry has buried it under an Electro-Pop arrangement. I think Troye's choice of musical arrangement is much more inspired as it allow him to really bring out the heartache. Just listen to how he builds it up and then drives it home on the line "I should have told you what you meant to me...". Just amazing :)

  • I'm really glad you didn't change the lyrics (girl to guy, etc) like most of the other guys that perform this do. I really enjoyed this cover!

  • both you and your voice are extraordinary beautiful. thank you for singing for us.

  • wow!!! im in love with your voice!!!

  • :) ouuhh is soo beautiful :D

  • I like this version better. The tune seems more fitting to the story its telling<3 keep singing.

  • I just found you today and your amazing! I subscribed:)

  • This made me smile :)

  • Kudos for keeping the pronoun as-is. It adds another layer of poignancy.

  • lo ame!

  • i love this version I think that you have much tallent...realy it's mervelous songs and u have beutiful voice....

  • When he said tattoos, I almost melted. <3

  • Cutest smile ever at 0:08/3:50 <33333

  • @TroyeSivan18 You looks adorable here! and your voice is beautiful! You're a real angel! :')

  • you made me cry....

  • I love troyes voice......

  • I'm fortunate to have lived long enough to see this! how simply. miraculously, fortunate indeed.

  • Your beautiful

  • Upload more songs Troye your voice is so clean!!!!!

  • beautiful cover!

  • cool.

  • i love you,troye ♡

  • melodrama song! thumbs up for you troye! =))

  • @63Mastermind I don't know if you joking or trying to be funny but I did. 1 person will. I did.

  • it's cute, he sounds good, but it's reaaaallly slow and makes me tired.

  • Your eyes = Innocence :) <3

  • Got troyesivan-ed. ♥_♥ you got hot voice troye!! :")

  • This is my 8th time watching this video straight through within the last couple of hours. It is absolutely amazing, such a peaceful and unstrained voice. Plus, you are extremely handsome :) Pretty soft eyes and nice white teeth! Not to mention the clearest skin ever! You've got quite the package!

  • i was one of da first viewers to c ur first vid... evn though ive only had this channel for a yr ive been on youte for i dont evn kno how long n just so u know.... im always gunna b ur fan

  • Aneyone Else Notice He Has The Most Amazing Eyes?

    Troye Sivan <3

  • Also could someone please tell me what that microphone is called that he is using. I want to buy one and then start posting my own videos! Thank you in advance!

  • @meghat93 I'm pretty certain that it is a Rode K2 which retails for about 700USD.

  • @BTC0288 U r awesome! Thank you soooo much!

  • I just watched Spud and I was never bored once while watching it. He had such a natural ability to act and he lured me in. I was so into the moving I subconsciously was muttering things outloud lol!When the girl lead him outside after the play to kiss, I was muttering,"Don't do it.The blondie really likes you. Please!I bawled my eyes out whenever he was accepted by his peers because I felt that struggle and then the relief of feeling apart of something more! Amazing Troye, can't wait 4 more!

  • @meghat93  How did you get to see the movie? ive been looking for it everwhere!

  • suuuper :)

  • HOW OLD IS HE NOW? LAST TIME I SEEN HIM HE WAS 14?!?!?!

  • @cunninghamchick He is 16 now

  • he is a good singer but need more expression/feelings....

  • hay it's the wolverine kid ! awesome :D

  • This is really good, you've got an amazing voice, good song it makes me cry :( the official video is so sad :') keep this up man! cause i'll be buying your CD. <3

  • i really like your voice..keep it up!

  • You are so stinkin' cute!:)

  • love your eyes :)

  • I really do love your version Troye and You're soooo talented .... Could I ask to have your tune ?

  • @kiwikrak I'm with @urdevoice - Troye is absolutely amazing. He recorded his own harmonics in the background. Also, if you don't think Justin Bieber is autotuned, you don't know music anyway. He didn't autotune his early videos, but that's not what thousands of fans scream about and beg to be played on the radio.

    Troye, stay real and keep doing what you love.

  • Amaizing video...

  • Wow.....o.o.....where has he been my whole life.....my ears have never heard so much beauty o.o....wow.

  • You look so young!! :) But your voice is mature, and nice to listen to. Btw, nice accent :) Your eyes are amazing. Haha

  • I love that you didn't change the lyrics (:

  • This was very nice to listen to! Your voice is pleasant.

  • We may hate justin beiber, but for him to get famous he never autotuned his videos, this guy here cleary does, noone can hear his true voice therefor hell never make it

  • Autotuned-= sick of this shit,

  • @kiwikrak It's not auto tuned, its just enhanced with harmonics he's recorded.

    I wish i could sing as good as him.

  • You are such a treasure Troye.

  • Troye, another great cover, just off bandcamp and downloaded all you songs. Great videos, thanks

  • amazing

  • Wow his voice has definitely changed since his first vid.

  • @thecontemp613 if he changed girl to boy it wouldn't rhyme with world...

  • @Sinneration girl doesnt even rhyme with world......

  • @DevineTimeToShine its called poetic justice

  • @Sinneration when a guy sings this, it should be "you would be my girl"

  • @Sinneration I don't think it would notice and would be more sincere

  • ur good

  • @thecontemp613 maybe he's gay or he just didn't think about it. Either way it doesn't matter, I just enjoy listening to him sing.

  • i think I love you.

  • Very good sung

    Amazing

  • Comment removed

  • @thecontemp613 does it matter?

    he sounds great plus the song wouldnt make any sense...

  • Genuine talent there, mate!

    I hope everything's going great for you.

  • Beautiful.

  • Beautiful.

  • Beautiful.

  • Beautiful.

  • Wow

  • :)

  • looooove it! :)

  • TROY. MARRY ME

  • Ur a amazing singer :D

  • I've been your fan since years ago when you sang For Them and though your voice has deepened considerably I'm still a huge fan of yours, please keep singing! :) -Singapore

  • Beautifully sung Troy. I have always loved your voice a-cappella or with minimal accompany and this is just right.

  • can i ask you just one question

    WHY YOU ARE NOT FAMOUS YET ? 1

  • wow you have an amazing voice!:) what mic are you using in your video? Great job!!:)

  • didn't expect that to come from you if i'm honest! you're amazing! xx

  • I'm seriously in love with your voice.. It's perfect. -3

  • I loved this! Great job! :-)

  • Tell your dad "Thanks" for taking an interest in his son's talent and encouraging his dreams.

  • This is the first video I've ever watched a video of you....and when it started, I looked at you and thought about what the sound of your voice would be like....I was blown away! I was not expecting what your voice turned out to be! You sound so much older then you look! Your amazing :3 xx

  • @karlzandcass01 he is also a actor. he played young hugh jackman the movie wolverine, and he had played the lead role in the movie called "Spud the movie"

  • the way you sing "in another life.." sounds *amazing*

  • Everyone sent this to Ellen!

  • beautiful!!! the voice is great (im not a fan of the music track though...) but please keep recording music! moreoriginal could be interesting! :)

  • Love your voice! I stumbled across you by accident when I was looking up videos! Now I'm going to go find as many of your songs/coves as I can! Your amazing! Keep it up! -3

  • ~ Such a beautiful boy ~

  • I only knew about you from spud and youre its like woa you are amazing.:D♥

  • Just great, Troye! 

  • Beautiful, Troye. What a shame that HUGE mic protector thingy always hides your face...

  • omg i heard johnny cash! it just made my day! lol

  • Now sing this same song and change the lyrics from "girl" to "boy". I think it will sound much better coming from you. Wait, I might be wrong, because you are saying "in another life, I would be your girl", maybe it is how it should be. I stand corrected.

  • Now sing this same song and change the lyrics from "girl" to "boy". I think it will sound much better coming from you.

  • I'm sold Troye, your voice is beautiful and so are you. Your voice could put me to sleep it is so relaxing and I meant that as a compliment. :-) I want to hear you write some of your own music, you have been through a lot for a young guy like yourself, you should be able to write some pretty good songs about your life and experiences, your wants and needs, feelings and emotions. Go for it my friend. Good luck and great success to you.

  • Beautifully done! You've either been blessed with a great voice as a child and still as an "adult" (almost) or you've worked hard to maintain it. I think it's awesome your dad helps you out on the videos -- so many teens  don't want them anywhere near the camera.

  • I've liked his singing since I first watched the video where he sang Tell me why.

  • @palokowski he's only got worse since :/

  • @2ees4 lol

  • @palokowski Yea me to, I dont understand why he doesnt make very many videos anymore. Such a beautiful voice.

  • Amazing cover! <3

  • Another song and artist that are not high on my list of favorites, but you own this song so well, Troye - beautiful job, man!

  • holy crab ?! o.O First of all I thought OMG what's comming up .. but then you started and .. it's just AWESOME .. Keep your work up dude :)) regards from Austria

  • Your voice doesn't suite your Looks...

  • Most beautiful voice and performance...well done Troye. You are a star..

  • Woow...just wow <3

  • I love it! can i say ive officially fallen in love with u if u sang that to me id faint

  • Finger up from Colombia

  • @RichardoRodriguez

    I hope you mean no other finger but your thumb... ;)

  • beautiful

  • Wow, that was great !!!

  • sweet!

  • Still have a fantasic voice Troye!!!!

  • Great job Troye! 

  • Voice of an Angel :)

  • น่ารักมาก = You're so cute!

  • so cute !!!

  • Amazing! Sounds so good... Congratulations! Keep recording! x from Portugal

  • every frame is a priceless screen cap~~~ <333

  • o_o why didnt he change the words? o_o

  • I would have changed girl to not, but still that was Awesome!

  • Defs gay

  • @willay23

    ...whatever... :)

  • ชอบตา ตาสวยนะ :)

  • I'm wondering why u don't have a girl friend...

  • You'd be my girl? (;

  • You have an awesome voice. :)

  • Troye, you must take the leap to writing your own music. Metaphorically speaking you've a diamond mine in your front yard (that voice/talent) all you need now is to learn to write what you feel, then the whole world will be a jewel in your pocket.

  • Well hey, in another life, who knows? Anyway, I couldnt find my headphones so I just had to blast it on my Altec/Lansing 885 system LOL. Man the speakers jumped to life! :) Your voice is sure sounding great with your new range. Cant wait to get another CD.

  • INCREDIBLE. I love that you kept the lyrics. Brave man. Very very cool.

  • pretty sure i've already commented on this three times.. but imma just go ahead and remind you how AMAZING you are!

  • w0ow simplemente

    beautiful¡¡¡¡¡

  • Amazing cover Troye! :) Added to my favorites:)

  • Dang you got older lmao! Your voice scared me at first! But it's still really good.

  • I don't know what to say that hasn't already been said. Your voice is so perfect. You have an amazing gift. You're such a romantic, too. You choose some really great songs. I think it's awesome that you share your voice with us here. Thanks!

  • 0:07 I love his smile. Cute :)

  • i love this song so muchhhh

  • I love this, but I wish you left the drum track out. ): Otherwise, it sounds lovely!

  • Troye, you really do have an amazing voice! Been listening to your singing for about 2 years and you just get better and better :) Awesome as usual!! :)

  • Amazing(:

  • OMFG, Troyes you're soooo grown up now. It's crazy to see you so much older! This was beautiful, stunning. Amazing job! c:

  • I keep listening with my earphones and tears keep falling. Such a beautiful job Troye!! <3

  • Wow. That was really good Troye. Loved the slight glance at the end too :-)

  • Very nice!

  • i have 7.1 sound i usually play games with that sound hehe my mom is crazy about it but decided to use it with youtube and wow u sounded amazing.

    Keep posting like be4 the xmen thing took u away from youtube.

    Kenny

  • YOU SHOULD CHANGE THE LYRICS... MAKE IT YOUR OWN SONG.