Added: 4 years ago
From: AdamTomaszewskiPL
Views: 474,722
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (520)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The utter silence from these fans for this song is amazing. It brought the best out of this song. Last thing we need is some douchebag screaming halfway through: YEAHHHHHHHH.

    I'll be like: ok, we get it, we know you're a fan, that's why you paid the goddamn ticket. But this isn't a rock song. So please, shut the fuck up. :)

  • goosebumps

    

  • this is MUSIC

  • I am going to cry. So damn beautiful!

  • The bell gives me chills. What a great performance. I love GOOD live music.

  • uwielbiam to :D

  • the ringings of the division bell have begun..

  • i cried when i saw that concert....i am egyptian and i can tell with no doubt that david gulmor roger walters are one of the best musician performers in the history of music....well pink floyed of my point of view are philosophers who use the music to discuss their visions....any way i respect those men and i am just say hail to their masterpiece high hopes

  • what a perfect example that barney stinson and so many other fools are wrong:

    everybody is dressed and suited up like they go to prom or opernball - David Gilmoure (note: the only two capital letters in my comment) is wearing a pyjama that old - it could be a present from Syd Barrett.. and still.. there is no fucking question about who the king is. even the paying audience is quiet like shit because they don't want to miss a tone.

    that's how you recognize a great man.

  • What amazes me, is the utter silence. Beautiful.

  • ...Groovin' out with Mr Gilmour would be a true pleasure!!...

  • outstandind

    

  • ingenious!

  • we should learn from this song. how one single man with a lap steel guitar and background band can take effect on a bunch of people who do nothing but listening. Next time we use words to talk we should think about what we say as we know now what effect it can have on others... only by listening.

  • AWSOME!! one of the best song!

  • that's not pink floyd.it's gilmour and the others..

  • eating special cookies and watching pink floyd, while listerning to gilmour is even more

  • eating cookies abd watching tv is fun

  • I visit this video everyday....its perfect, so much talent on display in one place.

    Phewwww!!!!!!!......

  • Wish I'd been around 30 years ago to watch this in all its raw fulminance. Still bloody great,but ..

  • @LuikSkywalker This was only three years ago :D

  • it's amazing

  • thumbs up if guys fell `` the secret to gettin high without takin a joint but listening to pink Floyd high hopes ;p the solo in the end reaches the equilibrium of ur soul ;p

  • Perfection.

  • 13 dislikes O.o

  • Kto słucha ESKI ROCK? :) Często leci ten genialny kawałek!

  • @michaelszczerbiec

    Na Esce jednej i drugiej lecą same genialne kawałki i także co do częstotliwości się nie pominałeś z prawdą-wszystko leci często. Buhaha :P.

  • Is that Michael Kamen playing the piano?

  • @Rudykri87 Just wanted to ask the same

  • @Rudykri87 yes, he is. two years before he passed away unfortunately

  • I cry when i listen to this.How come the guys who are actually in it.nobody cries?!

  • that guitar solo at the end.i go back,play that solo like 5 fuckin times everytime i listen to this song.this is the only piece of religion and god that i get everyday

  • que musica do caralho

  • I keep coming back to this video.....it doesn't get any better than this...superb

  • Fuck yeah OBOE

  • WOW.

  • everybody 1 dislike for that guys comment below me plz

  • @Yrroth1 IMO u r a.ha ha i cant even bring myself to say this.ha ha u r not worth explaining this to.u r jus unlucky and god doesnt love u as much as he loves us pink floyd fans.sorry for u

  • I cannot die in peace until I listen to pink Floyd LIVE!

  • Michael Kamen...David Gilmour...wow

  • is for such songs..why I love to play music

  • increibleeee

  • My beloved Father passed away yesterday... This song gives me so much hope and strenght... I hope he's "beyond the horizon of the place he lived when he was young"...

    i hope that "The grass is greener, the light is brighter, the taste is sweeter, the nights are full of wonders... With friends surrounded, the dawn mist glowing, the water flowing, the endless river... Forever and ever

    I will love you forever dad!!

    Markus

  • Why?? WHY?! why has this song to end?? I would love to compromise it, print it out and sleep with it and have it with me all the time. music? nooo! thats so much more. impossible to describe what this is... definitly not just music. words are not huge enough. great - epic - godlike - [...] 100 steps further you find this song!

  • This took my breath away, I`m amazed how he touch man´s souls.... simply... Amazing!!!

  • why is this such an impopular song?

  • Thumbs up for the cap wearing bassist! ;D

  • great band and fabulous music , pink floyd the best

  • One of the best of? This is the best of. Greatest song of all time.

  • @markogear So you are saying other Pink Floyd (Other bands too, ofcourse) songs are not as good?

  • @Amoscus i think this music is unique

  • @Amoscus course not. Thats just my opinion. Greatest for me

  • Never seen a silence like this in any concert... amazing. Pure music here, a true ear-gasm. We miss, really, really miss such bands in our time.

    I begin to believe that we have lost sooo much in music, in creation, during the last 20 years... and im only 23.

  • This song is epic!! Pink Floyd in my opinion were and still are the greatest band of all time. They are so influential and inspiring!!! :) 

  • so sad Rick wasn't there.

  • perfect!!!

    

  • I <3 it.

  • What is the name of this concert? Tnx

  • @AltecGS

    "David Gilmour in Concert" DVD.

    The performance took place at the Royal Festival Hall (London) in June 2001, as part of the Robert Wyatt-curated Meltdown festival.

  • guys i have a big problem: i need to study but i cant turn this tab off, i just CANT !

  • Superb............<3

  • nice song

  • Do i dream?

  • Comment removed

  • Michael Kamen... rest in peace ((

  • 8 dislike? justin biebers funs :| god please help them :)))

  • Comment removed

  • Thank you ..it is just wonderful....<3

  • très belle vidéo! :) une des meilleures chansons de Pink Floyd!

  • genialurii : )

  • Awesome!

    This is the main theme for the brandnew pc-game-thriller "Julia - Innocent Eyes"!

  • top

  • I'm french,no speak english.

    Mon frere est un grand fan de Pink Floyd ! Et maintenant bah je le suis aussi ...

    David Guilmour et un dieux de la musique !

    Cette musique est ma preferer !

    I love Pink Floyd !

  • chucha que esta guaton el david gilmour pero aun asi sigue manteniendo el talento

  • 7 don't like !! Sure they don't like the music ! Excuse me if some mistranslations because i'm frensh but i can only say : PINK FLOYD THE BEST FOREVER ! THEY ARE THE GODS OF THE MUSIC !

    Without hesitation this video in my favorites

    THANK YOU SO MUCH AdamTomaszewskiPL !

  • Comment removed

  • Incredible ........Is the pianist the late M. Kamen?

  • The solo literally makes my nipples hard everytime i hear it

  • @barsn11 same here LOL

  • @barsn11 And you're a reptile. Imagine that!

  • sorry, but PF no Gods - feelin is human & need no a god ...

  • ohh man i have become totally numb after hearing this music

  • @piyushkcnlu why don't you feel COMFOTRABLY numb? ;))))))

  • @rzicha yeh man i would be feeling comfortably numb after i take weed ...:)

  • 6 dislikes? O_O

    Bring these people to justice!!

  • @ratten131

    old mans sing a song - but we need the youth for the world today also - crisis ... HEY Make the world ! ...

  • This is pure perfection !!!

  • wonderfull!!!! 

  • wow! una excelente obra maestra!

  • Is that Michael Kamen?

  • @otpenagos It's David Gilmour... the soul behind Pink Floyd!

  • @smokey590able Yeah i Know, i meant the Piano/Oboe guy

  • se? he just picks it up, and uses the guitar extraordinarily, in what ever way he wants. That was the beauty of pink floyd, they saw music in its every form, from the ringing of the bells, to the way they construct their songs.

  • why am i crying?!

  • Meravigliosa!! Non servono altre parole..

    Wonderful, no additional words.. Incredible and unique Pink Floyd

  • Any idea where I can get the complete album of this performance. It's not available on Amazon.

  • Respect David !

  • wow, love the cellos. they reflect the sadness in this speachless song..

  • If I had to pick just one song, that I could take on a deserted island, and spend the rest of my life with, it would probably be this song.. Perfection

  • Heavenly <3

  • Very goood ! ^^

  • Perfection at its best 

  • Been a 100 times Or Been so many times:)

  • The music and lyrics have touched this world and I am thankful.

  • Perfect david :*

  • Simply a masterpiece.......

  • probably going to get downrated to hell for typing this!

    but i'll type it anyway!

    Nightwish did a brilliant cover of this, they've put a heavier take on it so only check it out if you like heavier stuff,

    obviously no cover could ever rival ole' pink, but still worth checking it out! :)

  • cuanta armonia y creatividad, queee voces, porrrr favorrr ....excelente.

  • Michael Kammen in the piano! he played with metallica in the S&M albm

  • alexveldin who do you perfer ?

  • brilliant voice...

  • as some had said i agree let this be my Funeral / Besna song too.... and its a masterpiece..... a rare feat of the great floyd and nick carmen together..... the obe chelo are awesome to compliment the lead played by HIM....

  • as some had said i agree let this be my Funeral / Besna song too.... and its a masterpiece..... a rare feat of the great floyd and nick carmen together.....

  • Pink Floyd > Bieber + Gaga

  • zajebista piosenka

  • Bitsede Gitsek Amq

  • David's vocal and phrasing is utterly perfect.

  • have you listened to the NIGHTWISH version

  • @MrJakko22

    I came here from the nightwish version.

  • Try pressing CTRL + Thumb up

  • And here I was hpoing that at least on a Pink Floyd video there wouldn't be any mention of third rate "musicians" and I find it to be a top rated comment. That is more than sad...it's tragic. Pink floyd deserves better.

    For once it would be excellent to actually see a contructive comment as a top rated one.

    Pink Floyd are gods, they haven't any need to be compared to mere ants nor can they beused in any comparison for that matter. It just wouldn't be fair to others - being crushed like that :]

  • @Checkp0intcharlie

    nobody is god - a illusion is this. But this song have a great human feelin - this is more as a god in human illusion ... 

  • Entre todas la miles de rolas q he escuchado en mi vida, esta es una q nunka me voy a aburrir de escuchar jamas y cada ves la disfruto mas.....mi favorita!!! PInkFloyd

  • David Gilmour and Thom Yorke are gods!

  • R.I.P. Michael Kamen !

  • i love what he is wearing, a simple jeans and a simple blue t shirt, probably with more than 20 years xD and in the end, that doesnt fucking matter! what matters is the music

  • this is mindblowingly incrdible

  • just fantasticoooooooooooo

    

  • Is that Michael Kamen????

  • @opethician

    yes,it was Michael Kamen as pianist ;)

  • I Love lady gaga and i love pink floyd.

  • What a masterpiece..

    

  • 1:54 amazing 

  • how can anybody dilike that ?

  • Shit works a little too good.

  • i dont give 2 shits about the thumbs up or down, whoever disliked this video is a complete waste of skin go kill yourself u dumb piece of mongoloid shit whoever u are, this is song is perfection creater by an imperfect being

  • You know it's an artist when they sound better live than on recordings. Pink Floyd, thank you for existing...and thank you for making music. I truly feel honored to be able to listen to it.

  • sooo beautiful!!! that song makes me cry!!! :'( i love it so much!!

  • @xxxmafexxxoomph this is the only song that has ever made me cry, gilmour's deep voice and the rythmic piano on the background make my tears flow

  • my girfriend once asked me : what is pink floyd? now, i'm alone..

  • @MrChuckNorrris man, it's great joke  =)

  • @MrChuckNorrris ok,enough with those comments.

  • @MrChuckNorrris LOOOOOOL fooock DUDE YOU ROCKS!

  • Just the bell got the fans goin'. Awesome.

  • he sounds just as good live as on the tracks. That is pretty unique i think.

  • super ***

  • Forever and ever!

  • very nice

  • Just eargasm!!!

  • First time I have heard this version, and I must say, it's damned good! The arrangement lends a chilling element the original did not have. Does anyone know if there is a recording of this to buy anywhere?

  • Dobra robota kolego. Genialna wersja, genialnego kawałka. Pozdro z Wawy :-)

  • fukin awesome!!!!

  • music just doesnt get much better then this, Mr. Gilmure, you Sir are a legend!!

  • Comment removed

  • sounds even better at live. just brilliant.

    Sir David Gilmour you are a genious.

  • They are much better in the studio ... : /

    This song has lost its intensity during this live ...

    But also (and especially) by the number of times I listened! (in studio)

    (not too many spelling mistakes? I am learning English ...)

  • R.I.P Michael Kamen

  • objasnjava!

  • this is absolutely great and unique.pink floyd is wonderful...music,lyrics,show.­..and high hopes gives an exact picture of life,it is the process of life...the truth.

  • As soon as someone invents a time machine - You'll see me sitting in the front row

  • I love this so m,uch this to me is how pink floyd should be remebered. Hint of the pyschedelic of the older years and the musicianship of later years

  • The dont need fucking naked tits and assess . Once more .

    

  • @AdamTomaszewskiPL

    ok, but why you use this words...

  • @bpskiba turn on the MTV and see why he said so...

  • @AdamTomaszewskiPL Guy, you can't compare .. this is a music to sit ad listen, there another musics to dance and party .. it's pretty diferent ..

  • @AdamTomaszewskiPL David will be remembered until the end of our days, because on this track you have to stop and think. This artist needs no ornaments, music can be vindicated.

  • when was this concert? a shame i wasnt there.....

  • I think Marco's version is better

  • Just Beautiful ...

  • What a stunning piece of music. I can think of only another song with that level of power and sophistication, and that's Sunset by Kate Bush...

  • The Division Bell is one of my favorite albums and these song is for me the most beautiful in the worl!! i love it!!

  • this should not be called music...it's so much more than that.. my biggest dream: make my Dad's dream come true and take him to David Gilmour's concert...some day... somehow...

  • pure music, no bullshit

  • GODS!!!!

  • Its a legend

  • 1:42 WTF LOL

  • I would have applause an hour long

  • Nightwish <3