@14Gaia14 WHAT AGE ARE YOU MAN I MEAN PINK FLOYD IS GOD WHAT A LOT OF SHITE I MEAN THEY ARE ONE OF THE GREATEST BANDS OF ALL TIME BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY THEY ARE JUST MEN THAT EAT SHIT AND SLEEP LIKE YOU AND ME
@hxtrjeff your a right fool you and for the record i think more folk would agree that zeppelin are just as good hence the fact like floyd they are loved the world over and they are just men like you and me whats that they dont eat and shit like me and you all about what do they do then you fucking clown
@hxtrjeff your a right fool you and for the record i think more folk would agree that zeppelin are just as good hence the fact like floyd they are loved the world over and they are just men like you and me whats that they dont eat and shit like me and you all about what do they do then you clown
@Corrupt5358 ledzep are inferior shut up look at all the classic songs the recorded going to califonia the rain song tangerine ten years gone over the hills and far away what is and should never be i could go on and on thats why zep are loved the world over floyd and zep are as good as each other and ps communication breakdown is a classic mate those of us who are alive inside like this sort of stuff
@MissCartoonist Sorry, I've had w/ the flu for the past week and have been a little disoriented, didn't even recognize my own reply, my bad, cheers to you!
lets just say, without Syd, Nick and Richard. We would of never heard of Pink Floyd. After all, who came up with name. So quit flapping your shit talking mouth. And just enjoy the fucking music
Can't anyone just watch the video and listen to the music. Isn't that why you come here. Do any of you know the members of Pink Floyd personally? Probably not, so shut the fuck up!
im a pink floyd fan, and this song is 100% weed, where the fuck did they get the lyrics???? after i overdose of weed or lsd, they are ever so high damn
I think David Gilmour did a gr8 job with this. No David Gilmour is not Syd Barrett, he is David Gilmour. Roger Waters was the trouble in the band. At least David Gilmour spent the time with Syd Barrett to produce his albums after he left Pink Floyd, what did Roger Waters do. He was then and is now all about himself, just look at the Syd Barrett story. Yes Syd was a genius, I love his music, I wonder what could of been. RIP Syd may your music live forever.
@filmfanman65 YOU STUPID INBREED BASTARD CUNT. EVERYONE KNOWS SYD STARTED THE BAND, "BUT" WITHOUT GILMOUR AND WATERS FILLING UP THE FUCKING CUP WHICH SYD ONLY SPIT AT, THE BAND WOUDN'T BE KNOWN AND YOU WOUDN'T HAVE HEARD OF THEM. YOU IMBECILIC IDIOT. THE LATER ALBUMS WHICH G AND W CONTRIBUTED WAS THE SHIT AND WAS KNOWN UNIVERSALLY, AND NOT THAT SYD STUFF. YOU WOUDN"T EVEN HAVE HEARD OF SYD WITHOUT HEARING THE GILMOUR OF WATERS SOUND. CUNT.
Gilmour and Waters along with Wright and Mason attribute their success, their sound, and their creative identity as Pink Floyd to Syd Barrett. Their sound obviously veered away from his psychedelic/progressive-rock sound but according to interviews with Waters, Mason and Wright, Syd's tremendous creative influence persisted on very strongly even in "The Wall".
I'd listen to the actual members of Pink Floyd rather than a joke like you.
gilmour is not is not good at this song,well i meen he's not syd barrett,his vocals can't do this song i dont like it when he does it his voice just isnt right for this
In an interview, David mentioned he had known Syd since they were 14 years-old and were at school together. David is probably the best friend Syd could have wished for.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
david, david david....u pathetic usurper is right.......it makes me so angry to watch pseudo-centric, fake copycat having the neck to just go and steal the great work of a genius like syd barrett.
Roger waters and David Gilmore and go fuck eachother....worthless assholes who were both jealous of Syds creative brillance, his good looks, his style, and his immense charisma and musical ability!!!! Gilmores vocals on this version does not do this song any justice and insults Syds memory. RIP SYD
Gilmour was wanted in the band by syd barrett from the beginning and after helped syd produce and record his solo albums after his breakdown. I mean, Gilmour was approached by Floyd, not the other way around
@danceflooroddities Damn u are ignorant! Syd tatooed his brain all the way and they did miss him as a friend. Syd was talented and I love his music, but he fk'd up. He had so much more to give, but couldn't lay off the drugs. Roger and Dave made Floyd as we know them. Their success is like no other band ever
Grandissimo syd Barrett,la versione dove canta gilmour fa cagare,Gilmour sei uno spietato traditore,hai aprofitato dei problemi del tuo migliore amico per rubargli il posto dopo che syd ha dato il nome al gruppo,ha composto tutti i brani(musica e testi) ha disegnato le copertine dei singoli e sempre grazie a lui la Emi ha stipulato il contratto discografico ai Pink,sei un uomo senza scrupoli e dignità.
David e Syd si conoscevano da quando avevano 14 anni e stavano a scuola insieme. Syd e Roger hanno chiesto a David di entrare nel gruppo nel 68 quando Syd gia non stava bene. David ha sempre difeso le interesse di Syd con la prova che Syd non ha mai mancato in vita sua ed ha lasciato $ 2 milioni USA in eredita a sua sorella Rosemary, cosa che non sarebbe mai successo senza l'appoggio di David. Non cerco la polemica - questa e semplicemente la realta.
@scubaduba23 he doesn't suck ass he does a pretty good job. no where near what syd could do though. just imagine the music syd would have made during the 70's (if syd had made music during the 70's!)
@willm1105 he did make music in the seventies. and he is terrible on this one, I never liked gilmour, he's just a pretty boy who plays a boring guitar.
@scubaduba23 Oh god i knew someone was going to comment after looking at allmusic and seeing he had 2 albums that came out in the 70's. He barely shared any of his music related art after 70'. You know what i meant. And i don't like gilmour either. I am just saying that in this one particular performance he does a pretty decent job compared to his other stuff.
@scubaduba23 you have no clue about anything. you are extremely ignorant. Like i said even what he "recorded in the "early" seventies he had already written and been playing years earlier. you dont got shit you dumbass
@willm1105 you're not fucking understanding me. I'am not dumb, I would outsmart you while I beat you the fuck down you gritty house-pet. Your preferred well-being is dressed down, fucked out and you're a regular everyday whore. KILL YOURSELF.
@scubaduba23 thats what you are you loser. I am way more intelligent than you and i will kick your ass any day. you are a mundayne average person. you are a complete poser and you like things to look cool so stfu dumbass. you would never outsmart me in any facet of anything.
@scubaduba23 im 6'3" 255 pounds im far from a little man like you are. you like like you have barely reached puberty. You were the first one to make it personal. I even sent you a message trying to be civil and laugh it off with you get over it. dont talk shit about the beatles being simple if you like the ramones and misfits. Two of the simplest and worst bands i've ever heard.
@willm1105 fuck ramones. and misfits are the shit so suck it, and why are you giving me your measurements, I dont give a fuck and im 6'3 as well and I love how I look young. so, once again, suck it real good for me.
@scubaduba23 you just say things with no substantiation whatsoever. your comments are so bias its ridiculous. you are such a hipocrite. You are the one who called me little man.
@scubaduba23 I have been using words that are relatively common. I am not intentionally attempting to sound sophisticated. I was just using words that best adhered to the point i was trying to make.
@willm1105 alright, man. I'm done being an asshole. Sorry about that, I've just boiled over recently if you can't tell. Sorry, again, have a nice day.
whoa interesting david look like syd from a side profile point of view for a min but it not syd reason syds hair is much shorter it wasnt that length until 1970 barrett , madcap laughs era
when he was done in black (eye liner) and hair teased! well the first gothic look it the day think the movie the crow ! branden lee ohh that reminds me lead singer of the CURE his looks was influenced of Syds MadCap Laughs
I think this is a better version than the album. Mr. Gilmour seems a bit overwhelmed at first, but then the voice comes in...and then the music...and then...Pink Floyd.
I miss Syd in this, but Gilmour did a really really good job of it.
Corrupt5358 2 months ago
rare indeed its hard for me to hear it without syd but still awesome footage!!
ripcurl9799 4 months ago
Wonderful!!!
egdonheath1 6 months ago
fascinating!
matthakeaz 6 months ago
Syd and Glimour was frends, and you criticize them?Pink floyd is God, Glimour, Syd, Rick,Waters and Bob are angels. Fuck off crictize!
14Gaia14 7 months ago
@14Gaia14 WHAT AGE ARE YOU MAN I MEAN PINK FLOYD IS GOD WHAT A LOT OF SHITE I MEAN THEY ARE ONE OF THE GREATEST BANDS OF ALL TIME BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY THEY ARE JUST MEN THAT EAT SHIT AND SLEEP LIKE YOU AND ME
bedsitsongbird33 6 months ago
@bedsitsongbird33 they are music god's and n o one better..... ever!. An no they dont shit, eat, sleep like you and I. Think about that..
hxtrjeff 6 months ago
@hxtrjeff your a right fool you and for the record i think more folk would agree that zeppelin are just as good hence the fact like floyd they are loved the world over and they are just men like you and me whats that they dont eat and shit like me and you all about what do they do then you fucking clown
bedsitsongbird33 6 months ago
@hxtrjeff your a right fool you and for the record i think more folk would agree that zeppelin are just as good hence the fact like floyd they are loved the world over and they are just men like you and me whats that they dont eat and shit like me and you all about what do they do then you clown
bedsitsongbird33 6 months ago
@bedsitsongbird33 Led Zep are so inferior there is no comparison. Communication breakdown? lol
Corrupt5358 2 months ago
@Corrupt5358 ledzep are inferior shut up look at all the classic songs the recorded going to califonia the rain song tangerine ten years gone over the hills and far away what is and should never be i could go on and on thats why zep are loved the world over floyd and zep are as good as each other and ps communication breakdown is a classic mate those of us who are alive inside like this sort of stuff
bedsitsongbird33 2 months ago
hell yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
charadeyouareha 8 months ago
sweet footage.... thanks!
brooksjackson70 8 months ago
wtf is that gilmore
corpralkirsch 9 months ago
wow i've noticed that gilmour does syd pretty awesomly.. not as good as syd.. but still awesome
TilderyKoadil 9 months ago
no david can do syd's song
kucasuncanikola 10 months ago
Whoa, is that really David singing? I thought it was Syd! How weird! Are you guys sure?
MissCartoonist 1 year ago
@MissCartoonist yep
egyptianminor 11 months ago
@egyptianminor Daaang. :O
MissCartoonist 11 months ago
@MissCartoonist Excue me, r u replying to which comment of mine?
egyptianminor 11 months ago
@egyptianminor I was replying to your "yep".
MissCartoonist 11 months ago
@MissCartoonist Sorry, I've had w/ the flu for the past week and have been a little disoriented, didn't even recognize my own reply, my bad, cheers to you!
egyptianminor 11 months ago
@egyptianminor That's okay. :D Feel better.
MissCartoonist 11 months ago
@MissCartoonist I'm OK now, Flu's gone, thanks for the kind words, cheers :)
egyptianminor 11 months ago
Comment removed
gen6k 1 year ago
Hey dumbass, "The Wall" was based on the downfall of Syd. Of course you still see the influence, check the facts.
jarmenta69 1 year ago
lets just say, without Syd, Nick and Richard. We would of never heard of Pink Floyd. After all, who came up with name. So quit flapping your shit talking mouth. And just enjoy the fucking music
jarmenta69 1 year ago
Can't anyone just watch the video and listen to the music. Isn't that why you come here. Do any of you know the members of Pink Floyd personally? Probably not, so shut the fuck up!
dickrobot 1 year ago
im a pink floyd fan, and this song is 100% weed, where the fuck did they get the lyrics???? after i overdose of weed or lsd, they are ever so high damn
macondo1080 1 year ago
Obiously David doesn't feel the song at all on this one... hey!
adamlinks 1 year ago
I love them both. Both on disc and live. But somehow, to me, david gilmour's voice gave the song a higher edge. His voice is strong.
jossy2112 1 year ago
seriously cool, Roger is a little ahead of his time with that disco-sounding bass line @ :36
charadeyouareha 1 year ago
I think David Gilmour did a gr8 job with this. No David Gilmour is not Syd Barrett, he is David Gilmour. Roger Waters was the trouble in the band. At least David Gilmour spent the time with Syd Barrett to produce his albums after he left Pink Floyd, what did Roger Waters do. He was then and is now all about himself, just look at the Syd Barrett story. Yes Syd was a genius, I love his music, I wonder what could of been. RIP Syd may your music live forever.
tuxedogstring 1 year ago 2
@tuxedogstring One of Syd's two albums was in fact co-produced by Gilmour and Waters! The other one was by Gilmour and Wright.
Flowerbranche 10 months ago
David Gilmour saved The Floyd. I think they are all great, especially Syd, Waters and David. My favorite band of all time
bullfury19 1 year ago 5
@bullfury19 such a great statement, couldnt agree more...would like to add Richard Wrights key / synth / organ playing...essential
glueforall 1 year ago
Like the syd version better.
DanCamFXPro 1 year ago 2
I've actually never heard david sing this, pretty awesome. if there was a live recording with both david and syd, oh man...
thanatossassin 1 year ago 2
@thanatossassin i think there is somewhere...but syd is only staring at his mirror top tele
glueforall 1 year ago
I do not care what you all bitch about, if was not for syd there would be no Pink Floyd
jarmenta69 1 year ago 48
@jarmenta69 WRONG. If there was no Gilmour and Waters, there would be no syd.
tramista86 1 year ago
@tramista86 you are fucking retarded, Syd Barrett started the band in 1965, Gilmour came later in 1968. Get your fucking facts straight, dumbshit.
filmfanman65 1 year ago
@filmfanman65 YOU STUPID INBREED BASTARD CUNT. EVERYONE KNOWS SYD STARTED THE BAND, "BUT" WITHOUT GILMOUR AND WATERS FILLING UP THE FUCKING CUP WHICH SYD ONLY SPIT AT, THE BAND WOUDN'T BE KNOWN AND YOU WOUDN'T HAVE HEARD OF THEM. YOU IMBECILIC IDIOT. THE LATER ALBUMS WHICH G AND W CONTRIBUTED WAS THE SHIT AND WAS KNOWN UNIVERSALLY, AND NOT THAT SYD STUFF. YOU WOUDN"T EVEN HAVE HEARD OF SYD WITHOUT HEARING THE GILMOUR OF WATERS SOUND. CUNT.
tramista86 1 year ago
@tramista86
... yeah, because that makes sense /end sarcasm
Gilmour and Waters along with Wright and Mason attribute their success, their sound, and their creative identity as Pink Floyd to Syd Barrett. Their sound obviously veered away from his psychedelic/progressive-rock sound but according to interviews with Waters, Mason and Wright, Syd's tremendous creative influence persisted on very strongly even in "The Wall".
I'd listen to the actual members of Pink Floyd rather than a joke like you.
valaurwen 1 year ago
gilmour is not is not good at this song,well i meen he's not syd barrett,his vocals can't do this song i dont like it when he does it his voice just isnt right for this
ThePsychedelicFlower 1 year ago
@ThePsychedelicFlower its not bad....it isnt Syd, thats for sure..but for a pretty much novice vocalist...good job
glueforall 1 year ago
Boggy dew, indeed!
WizardGlik 1 year ago
In an interview, David mentioned he had known Syd since they were 14 years-old and were at school together. David is probably the best friend Syd could have wished for.
IsisTiamat 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david, david david....u pathetic usurper is right.......it makes me so angry to watch pseudo-centric, fake copycat having the neck to just go and steal the great work of a genius like syd barrett.
Roger waters and David Gilmore and go fuck eachother....worthless assholes who were both jealous of Syds creative brillance, his good looks, his style, and his immense charisma and musical ability!!!! Gilmores vocals on this version does not do this song any justice and insults Syds memory. RIP SYD
danceflooroddities 2 years ago
Gilmour was wanted in the band by syd barrett from the beginning and after helped syd produce and record his solo albums after his breakdown. I mean, Gilmour was approached by Floyd, not the other way around
7663264 2 years ago 29
@danceflooroddities Damn u are ignorant! Syd tatooed his brain all the way and they did miss him as a friend. Syd was talented and I love his music, but he fk'd up. He had so much more to give, but couldn't lay off the drugs. Roger and Dave made Floyd as we know them. Their success is like no other band ever
bullfury19 1 year ago
Gilmour singing, of course
earlejohn3 2 years ago
Yea I realized a bit later. Thanks though.
LEOJATT 2 years ago
Isn't that Syd singing?
LEOJATT 2 years ago
who is singing?
itsnotgoodforme 2 years ago
MISTA GILMOUR but we all no syd does the studio one
andyourbirdcansing64 2 years ago
you must realise that syd has left the band that year ('68). i think David sings this great too very pure
marnixdecroock 2 years ago
Grandissimo syd Barrett,la versione dove canta gilmour fa cagare,Gilmour sei uno spietato traditore,hai aprofitato dei problemi del tuo migliore amico per rubargli il posto dopo che syd ha dato il nome al gruppo,ha composto tutti i brani(musica e testi) ha disegnato le copertine dei singoli e sempre grazie a lui la Emi ha stipulato il contratto discografico ai Pink,sei un uomo senza scrupoli e dignità.
sonosardo76 2 years ago
@sonosardo76
David e Syd si conoscevano da quando avevano 14 anni e stavano a scuola insieme. Syd e Roger hanno chiesto a David di entrare nel gruppo nel 68 quando Syd gia non stava bene. David ha sempre difeso le interesse di Syd con la prova che Syd non ha mai mancato in vita sua ed ha lasciato $ 2 milioni USA in eredita a sua sorella Rosemary, cosa che non sarebbe mai successo senza l'appoggio di David. Non cerco la polemica - questa e semplicemente la realta.
IsisTiamat 2 years ago
This is Syd's music. Gilmour a pathetic usurper!
BlueJoe21 2 years ago
BlueJoe21 you are an idiot.
now you cry for syd but when he was alive you and many hypocrites ignored
marcosliguori 2 years ago
david sucks ass on the vocal.
scubaduba23 2 years ago
@scubaduba23 he doesn't suck ass he does a pretty good job. no where near what syd could do though. just imagine the music syd would have made during the 70's (if syd had made music during the 70's!)
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 he did make music in the seventies. and he is terrible on this one, I never liked gilmour, he's just a pretty boy who plays a boring guitar.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 Oh god i knew someone was going to comment after looking at allmusic and seeing he had 2 albums that came out in the 70's. He barely shared any of his music related art after 70'. You know what i meant. And i don't like gilmour either. I am just saying that in this one particular performance he does a pretty decent job compared to his other stuff.
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 dig deeper, there's so many syd recordings, look further boy. and yeah I got you.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 you have no clue about anything. you are extremely ignorant. Like i said even what he "recorded in the "early" seventies he had already written and been playing years earlier. you dont got shit you dumbass
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 you're not fucking understanding me. I'am not dumb, I would outsmart you while I beat you the fuck down you gritty house-pet. Your preferred well-being is dressed down, fucked out and you're a regular everyday whore. KILL YOURSELF.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 thats what you are you loser. I am way more intelligent than you and i will kick your ass any day. you are a mundayne average person. you are a complete poser and you like things to look cool so stfu dumbass. you would never outsmart me in any facet of anything.
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 hahahaahahahahaha you know nothing about me little man.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 im 6'3" 255 pounds im far from a little man like you are. you like like you have barely reached puberty. You were the first one to make it personal. I even sent you a message trying to be civil and laugh it off with you get over it. dont talk shit about the beatles being simple if you like the ramones and misfits. Two of the simplest and worst bands i've ever heard.
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 fuck ramones. and misfits are the shit so suck it, and why are you giving me your measurements, I dont give a fuck and im 6'3 as well and I love how I look young. so, once again, suck it real good for me.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 you just say things with no substantiation whatsoever. your comments are so bias its ridiculous. you are such a hipocrite. You are the one who called me little man.
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 haha you're trying to seem sophisticated with those words. you're not fooling me, bitch ass neega.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 I have been using words that are relatively common. I am not intentionally attempting to sound sophisticated. I was just using words that best adhered to the point i was trying to make.
willm1105 1 year ago
@willm1105 alright, man. I'm done being an asshole. Sorry about that, I've just boiled over recently if you can't tell. Sorry, again, have a nice day.
scubaduba23 1 year ago
@scubaduba23 Dude what kind of hard cocaine derived drugs were you smoking? David doesn't suck ass at anything.
charadeyouareha 1 year ago
whoa interesting david look like syd from a side profile point of view for a min but it not syd reason syds hair is much shorter it wasnt that length until 1970 barrett , madcap laughs era
when he was done in black (eye liner) and hair teased! well the first gothic look it the day think the movie the crow ! branden lee ohh that reminds me lead singer of the CURE his looks was influenced of Syds MadCap Laughs
wolfenzero70 2 years ago
which year is this?
skinnyskaller 2 years ago
1968
marnixdecroock 2 years ago
I think this is a better version than the album. Mr. Gilmour seems a bit overwhelmed at first, but then the voice comes in...and then the music...and then...Pink Floyd.
toadbeacon 2 years ago
es gilmour syd barrett no toco ahi
LIVE SYD!!!!!
sydbarrett1989 2 years ago
WOW!! very, very, very good video!
Thank you very much!
aetio2 2 years ago
gillmore es una pedazo de mierda
ShortdarkMorrison 2 years ago
the guy before syd barrett what a joke??? check my you tube
echoes707 3 years ago
hey yyyyyyyyyyyy you the best fantastic 5 stars *******
echoes707 3 years ago
I believe that is Syd. Is this true?
hotrodfloyd 3 years ago
no its gilmour
rushfloydzeppelin 3 years ago