I never understood why Charlie (from Season 13) made more appearances compared to Billy (from Season 11) and Norman (so far from Day of the Diesels and the last ep. of Season 15) made a bit more appearances than Dennis (Season 9)....? Merchandising maybe? T_T'
6:09 Rocky what are you doing with that crate, he sounds Italian like Bella out of Fireman sam, I'm glad Stanley spoke again, when I first saw this episode I thought that was Oliver 0:16 puffing past Belle on the bridge.
When I first saw this episode I thought that was Oliver passing Belle at 0:17. Still never mind I liked in this episode how Stanley spoke and 6:11 Victor telling Rocky off he sounds italian a bit like Bella out of Fireman Sam
0:42-2:35 Does anyone notice all 3 of those scenes are exactly the same, with different engines? HiT has got to learn that stuff like that is getting rather repetitive...
I like how when Thomas bumps Charlie, Charlie needs to be repaired. But when James is crushed by Gordon and nearly drowned in a swamp, he still manages to work right afterward. :P
@OptimusPrime289 - actually coupling rods and side rods are interchangeable terms. Not to be confused with "connecting rods". Generally coupling rods/side rods couple together driving wheelsets in some form.
i think i saw Belle rolling on the bridge at 0:22. and i must say, Stanley's voice is not bad, he sounds very well done like Pierce Brosnan does in TGD. but this episode kind of reminds me of 'The Party Surprise' one of the other Thomas stories.
It was quite suprising to see Belle make a Cameo in this episode. It was also good to see stanley have a role in this one. Another role for Charlie, telling jokes and what not. Its average and one piece of music sounded like the one from Pop Goes Thomas.
Whether the episodes are great, average or bad; undoubtedly curiousity wins people over when it comes to watching them. This was a pretty good episode and I must admit they did a good job of not making it too repetetive ;) I'm amazed Belle has appeared already as I thought she was gonna be introduced in DOTD but apparently not as her actual debut will be in the season 15 episode Big Belle.
I really enjoyed this. Yeah, the repetition and rhyming made me gasp and groan :P but it's nice that Thomas knows that he can't take Victor for granted( I mean, Victor's got his own work to get done, he can't exactly drop what he's doing every time an engine's broken down!), and Stanley spoke! Kinda does sound like Brosnan's Stanley voice, doesn't it. Belle's appearance was a little surprising. is this to take place before or after DOTD?
@Lightninging63 I would assume after since Belle is still gonna be introduced in the film despite having a major role in the upcoming season 15 episode Big Belle; seems strange to have an episode air before her actual introduction though. Though we'll just see how it goes :)
8/10. I love that Stanley FINALLY spoke in full CGI, and he sounds fantastic. And the cameo by Belle was nice, though a bit of a shame considering no-one's seen DOTD yet.
The plot's pretty good, and the lights make the Steamworks look even better IMO. The only downside is the CONSTANT Winter Holiday tripe. It's Christmas, end of.
Well, this could be worse... sure we end up having the retarded 3 strikes you're out, retarded rhyming, tiresome repeats and more stupidity, yet again.... BUUUT the only good thing I can think of is Stanley actually speaks for the first time, in Season 15 that is...
@ThompsOnline3 - stumped as to how anyone could think that these eleven episodes that have aired could be anything other than sub standard. When you consider the writing of the first three seasons, and even the first of the CGI specials, in comparison to this season, it shows up the writing as simplistic, morally broken, poorly devised and rehashes of itself and other episodes in triplicate.
I gave this episode 2/10 on the SiF blog. 1000/10 is ludicrous, sorry to say. :(
FINALLY! Stanley speaks! And Belle cameos! This episode was awesome. Good plot, good cast of characters, and all the opening scenes were fantastic. That festive music at the end was actually pretty catchy.
@simierski- How true Simon. Same could be said for 'Henry's Happy Coal'. Yeah it was good, but... just a poorly disguised 'Good to be Gordon rehash' with rhymes.
I liked this episode, but again, does Thomas have to repeat exactly the same things as a rhyme? And come on, "my piston's nearly pooped', "my firebox is faulty". Amazing that all problems engines have are alliterative, eh? :P
@simierski I find it rather hard to choose, because I never was really thrilled with The Party Surprise, as I'd hoped for a better introduction of Colin. They're both rather bland... except for the models and CGI. The visuals are (almost) always great in Thomas.
@TugboatsandThomas - thats the problem. The visual quality does not match the quality of the writing. It's by far the best thing about Thomas. In the older episodes, forgiving the problems associated with the models, the writing was far better.
But then it has to be said, the original stories translated much better to screen than any of these scripts are. Chances are, it's down to two things: understanding of railways, and characterization.
Why the frigging hell did Thomas cause so many accidents. What is Sharon Miller thinking. I am amazed this got made. It isnt the worst ep, maiy because of Stanley appearing with a speaking role, but what is the deal with the freight trains. There are never any brakevans. But i love Greg's shots today. The opening scenes were magnificent. He is a credit to this show.
since the great discovery.
importednascar 1 month ago
i think edward buffers are to big
roloboy97 4 months ago
0:00-0:47 are awesome moving shots!
Ty43219CPV 5 months ago
Party hhmm? cool thats sounds!
roloboy97 5 months ago
new drinking! game every time they rhyme you take a drink
captainofthetitanic 6 months ago
@captainofthetitanic tried it *hiccup* not trying again *hiccup*
TdafanficReal 5 months ago
@TdafanficReal XD
captainofthetitanic 5 months ago
@captainofthetitanic and every time they say an overused catchphrase or method, take several drinks untill you pass out =P
trainboy7 3 months ago
@captainofthetitanic lol ud be pissed outa ur mind
bonnie641 2 months ago
How the fuck can anybody host a party in such a repair facility?
ClearwaterMK2 8 months ago
Bv nnr
pilarp72 9 months ago
Thomas is becoming rather inept isn't he?
bobo577 9 months ago
it would be sooo funny if thomas said to stanley " WELL MAYBE YOU SHULDN'T HAVE TRIED TO REPLACE ME",and then left him there
SuperMarioNJ 11 months ago 2
I love Charlie's jokes they crack me up:)
bigthomasfan624 11 months ago
I never understood why Charlie (from Season 13) made more appearances compared to Billy (from Season 11) and Norman (so far from Day of the Diesels and the last ep. of Season 15) made a bit more appearances than Dennis (Season 9)....? Merchandising maybe? T_T'
Zorran202 11 months ago
6:09 Rocky what are you doing with that crate, he sounds Italian like Bella out of Fireman sam, I'm glad Stanley spoke again, when I first saw this episode I thought that was Oliver 0:16 puffing past Belle on the bridge.
93DOL 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When I first saw this episode I thought that was Oliver passing Belle at 0:17. Still never mind I liked in this episode how Stanley spoke and 6:11 Victor telling Rocky off he sounds italian a bit like Bella out of Fireman Sam
93DOL 11 months ago
Why is it a winter holiday party? Don't people celebrate Christmas anymore?
472Colin 11 months ago
*Kevin Drives Into the Box* Rocky should have said "Slip O' The 'ook
TdafanficReal 11 months ago
Look what i found on the wiki!!!!!
It was recently announced that Apax Partners, HiT's current owner, is prepared to sell it sometime in 2011.
OMG HOPE ITS TRUE
tomytrackfan 11 months ago
@tomytrackfan It wouldn't BE on the Wiki if it was false, now, would it? -_-
SodorProductionsII 10 months ago
@SodorProductionsII On the wiki it said Lady would be in Season 15, and Bill and Ben, and HANK, and nope, we see none of them.
crazyracer12 10 months ago
@crazyracer12 I hope you know that we have the occasional nooby spammers who put that false crap up.
SodorProductionsII 10 months ago
@SodorProductionsII Of course. But this was on SIX wikias. ._.
crazyracer12 10 months ago
Yes but its been a long time
sscthomasfan10 11 months ago
@TMRReturns I know but HIT should know the UK fans would be confused
HOLYCRAPITJACKIECHAN 11 months ago
4:00-4:08 Yet another horrible joke by Charlie...
RandomRobloxian 11 months ago
0:42-2:35 Does anyone notice all 3 of those scenes are exactly the same, with different engines? HiT has got to learn that stuff like that is getting rather repetitive...
RandomRobloxian 11 months ago
Why does HiT keep using "Winter Holiday"? Don't they know it's called Christmas?
RandomRobloxian 11 months ago
I only like this episode because Stanley's in it! Other than that this is a pretty boring story line.
bella4172 11 months ago
I only like this episode because Stanley's in it! Other than that this is a pretty boring story line.
bella4172 11 months ago
I like how when Thomas bumps Charlie, Charlie needs to be repaired. But when James is crushed by Gordon and nearly drowned in a swamp, he still manages to work right afterward. :P
TheUnluckyTug02 11 months ago
that was an alright episode, could have been better
Heekimaster 11 months ago
All we'll have to wait for is Stanley's US voice (by Ben Small) to be heard in the states now.... hope it'll be as epic as the UK voice!
Zorran202 11 months ago
Edward, you look worried? How can Thomas tell if all he can see is Edward's butt? XD
SodorProductions 11 months ago 14
@SodorProductions he can tell by the way of his voice.
nmbnunes1 6 months ago
@OptimusPrime289 - actually coupling rods and side rods are interchangeable terms. Not to be confused with "connecting rods". Generally coupling rods/side rods couple together driving wheelsets in some form.
simierski 11 months ago
I think I like this episode!
For one thing
STANLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He has a CGI speaking role at last!
I noticed Belle made a cameo at the beginning.
Diesel has also made his Season 15 debut, if I'm correct.
BramGroatFilms 11 months ago
at least thomas made his mistake 2 times instead of the usual 3 times.... but more importantly there's no "you have caused confusion and delay"
thomas5070 11 months ago
YAY STANLEYS FIRST SPEAKING ROLE :D
sscthomasfan10 11 months ago 16
@sscthomasfan10 Didn't he speak in TGD and S12?
HOLYCRAPITJACKIECHAN 11 months ago
@sscthomasfan10 for cgi that is.
nmbnunes1 7 months ago
I liked it. And Charlie has his first accident
Mike197mr1 11 months ago
This Is Now My Favourite Episode Of Season 15 Great Range Of Characters, A Cameo From Belle & Of Course Stanley Finally Having His Own Voice 9.5/10
lg77612 11 months ago
i think i saw Belle rolling on the bridge at 0:22. and i must say, Stanley's voice is not bad, he sounds very well done like Pierce Brosnan does in TGD. but this episode kind of reminds me of 'The Party Surprise' one of the other Thomas stories.
LionelThomas200 11 months ago
@LionelThomas200 Yea that is Belle. I don't understand why HIT is showing her so early
HOLYCRAPITJACKIECHAN 11 months ago
Glad to see Stanley finally gets his first speaking role in the CGI series.
disneyrangerblue02 11 months ago
And can I ask what part Bella is in?
penninefilms 11 months ago
@penninefilms when rosie, percy pass near the bridge after a second or 2 u see belle on the left side of sodor
98malimal 11 months ago
@98malimal Are yes thanks for pointing it out to me,
penninefilms 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@penninefilms when rosie, percy pass near the bridge after a second or 2 u see belle on the left side of sodor bridge
98malimal 11 months ago
I would like to see some faces on the truck but other then that it was an OK episode.
penninefilms 11 months ago
It was quite suprising to see Belle make a Cameo in this episode. It was also good to see stanley have a role in this one. Another role for Charlie, telling jokes and what not. Its average and one piece of music sounded like the one from Pop Goes Thomas.
Rating 8.5/10
Next up: Spencer the Grand
lbbrian 11 months ago
It's great that Stanley had a speaking role.
BiggestThomasFan 11 months ago
great to hear Stanley talking again since season 12! also Belles cameo was suprising
class47peter 11 months ago
Stanley's Voice is Great!
thomasfan1993 11 months ago
Whether the episodes are great, average or bad; undoubtedly curiousity wins people over when it comes to watching them. This was a pretty good episode and I must admit they did a good job of not making it too repetetive ;) I'm amazed Belle has appeared already as I thought she was gonna be introduced in DOTD but apparently not as her actual debut will be in the season 15 episode Big Belle.
Damocles178 11 months ago
Wait nevermind apparently she is introduced in DOTD.... quite odd to have an episode about her air before her actual introduction.
Damocles178 11 months ago
if sodor has one more fucking party they r gonna be the jersey shore
SodorMR 11 months ago
@SodorMR i agree with u!
TheRManProds 11 months ago
I really enjoyed this. Yeah, the repetition and rhyming made me gasp and groan :P but it's nice that Thomas knows that he can't take Victor for granted( I mean, Victor's got his own work to get done, he can't exactly drop what he's doing every time an engine's broken down!), and Stanley spoke! Kinda does sound like Brosnan's Stanley voice, doesn't it. Belle's appearance was a little surprising. is this to take place before or after DOTD?
Lol'd at Rocky- "Dropping it... boss." xD
Best Yet :D
Lightninging63 11 months ago
@Lightninging63 I would assume after since Belle is still gonna be introduced in the film despite having a major role in the upcoming season 15 episode Big Belle; seems strange to have an episode air before her actual introduction though. Though we'll just see how it goes :)
Damocles178 11 months ago
BELLE 0:22 !
LOL 6:26
sTANLEY 2:13
TheDirtyTrain1 11 months ago
Thanks for uploading these. It is great to see you're getting so many viewers! :)
TugboatsandThomas 11 months ago
WHY DOESNT HIT USE BRAKEVANS
pokeyjokekid 11 months ago
ENOUGH WITH THE FUCKING RHYMING ALREADY!! ITS ANNOYING!!
Thomasfan89 11 months ago
It's nice to see Stanley getting a proper CGI appearance! With a speaking role as well! I love his voice!
donaldengine9 11 months ago
well there goes eight minutes and forty six seconds of my life i'll never get back.
love how thomas doesn't laugh when charlie told his joke then knocks him off the rails.
LEON13858 11 months ago
'Dropping it....boss' XD This was a brilliant ep.
Kinda weird how they did the 3 strikes thing, twice but Thomas wasnt being an idiot so it wasnt so bad.
And finally, Stanley speaks. I'm glad he sounds a little like Pierce Brosnan :)
TheBlueE2 11 months ago
I cheered when I saw Stanley the first time. I didn't actually think he'd speak but when he did, I was all like "wow".
SamTheThomasFan1 11 months ago
Emily really shoudln't have arrived so soon after Gordon... And Thomas goes backwards as if to push Percy, but we then see him in front of Percy!
This was ok I guess. But the highlight? STANLEY SPEAKS!
therailwayinspector3 11 months ago
Another problem - why would they need Rocky to put Charlie on the tracks, when there's an-in-building crane right above them all?
therailwayinspector3 11 months ago
Piston Rods can crack? I thought they bent. Oh well. XP
crazyracer12 11 months ago
8/10. I love that Stanley FINALLY spoke in full CGI, and he sounds fantastic. And the cameo by Belle was nice, though a bit of a shame considering no-one's seen DOTD yet.
The plot's pretty good, and the lights make the Steamworks look even better IMO. The only downside is the CONSTANT Winter Holiday tripe. It's Christmas, end of.
ThomasPercyandToby2 11 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 belle is gonna be in another episode "Big Belle"
carson08022000 11 months ago
@carson08022000 ...Really? I NEVER knew that(!) (sarcasm)
ThomasPercyandToby2 11 months ago
@ThomasPercyandToby2 lol
carson08022000 11 months ago
finally get to hear Stanley's voice,cameo from Belle and seeing Victor and Charlie that was a good episode
plunderbird 11 months ago
YAY Stanley is back I love his voice ^^
PrettyRosie1995 11 months ago
This is definatly my favourite :)
NemesisHero123 11 months ago
Well, this could be worse... sure we end up having the retarded 3 strikes you're out, retarded rhyming, tiresome repeats and more stupidity, yet again.... BUUUT the only good thing I can think of is Stanley actually speaks for the first time, in Season 15 that is...
Zorran202 11 months ago
Its not god awful, but its not really great. Its basically just The Party Surprise all over again........only stupider.
missoliverandblossom 11 months ago
My god best ep yet!
thomasisbest23 11 months ago
love this episode! 1000/10
ThompsOnline3 11 months ago
@ThompsOnline3 - stumped as to how anyone could think that these eleven episodes that have aired could be anything other than sub standard. When you consider the writing of the first three seasons, and even the first of the CGI specials, in comparison to this season, it shows up the writing as simplistic, morally broken, poorly devised and rehashes of itself and other episodes in triplicate.
I gave this episode 2/10 on the SiF blog. 1000/10 is ludicrous, sorry to say. :(
simierski 11 months ago
suggestion:ask first,have permission
episode rating 8 out of 10
carson08022000 11 months ago
FINALLY! Stanley speaks! And Belle cameos! This episode was awesome. Good plot, good cast of characters, and all the opening scenes were fantastic. That festive music at the end was actually pretty catchy.
TheUnluckyTug02 11 months ago
Not bad, but again not great. Compared to the majority of the season this is a bit better. Sharon really needs to get on the ball.
This is going on my list of episodes to rewrite.
SodorProductions 11 months ago
Belle's On The Bridge in The Beginning!
nintendoalien479 11 months ago
FINALLY! :D a good season 15 episode 7/10
trainboy62 11 months ago
This was actually pretty good!
TheFattHatt1943 11 months ago
Big improvement but would be better without the rhyming 7.5/10
thecoolt 11 months ago
Go and watch the previous episode "The Party Surprise" and come back and tell me that you still think that this was a good episode!
simierski 11 months ago
@simierski- How true Simon. Same could be said for 'Henry's Happy Coal'. Yeah it was good, but... just a poorly disguised 'Good to be Gordon rehash' with rhymes.
I liked this episode, but again, does Thomas have to repeat exactly the same things as a rhyme? And come on, "my piston's nearly pooped', "my firebox is faulty". Amazing that all problems engines have are alliterative, eh? :P
modelsofsodor 11 months ago
@simierski There's always the choice of which one you like better between the two... XD
TugboatsandThomas 11 months ago
@TugboatsandThomas - the former as opposed the latter!
simierski 11 months ago
@simierski I find it rather hard to choose, because I never was really thrilled with The Party Surprise, as I'd hoped for a better introduction of Colin. They're both rather bland... except for the models and CGI. The visuals are (almost) always great in Thomas.
TugboatsandThomas 11 months ago
@TugboatsandThomas - thats the problem. The visual quality does not match the quality of the writing. It's by far the best thing about Thomas. In the older episodes, forgiving the problems associated with the models, the writing was far better.
But then it has to be said, the original stories translated much better to screen than any of these scripts are. Chances are, it's down to two things: understanding of railways, and characterization.
simierski 11 months ago
@simierski I'm glad there are a couple of us left who care about good storytelling. I'm an aspiring author myself.
TugboatsandThomas 11 months ago
Not bad. Way better than the last one. Glad i got to hear Stanley's voice and i did notice the cameo by Belle. 7/10
griffoization 11 months ago
This was great episode. Thanks for uploading. :)
PlutonovLed 11 months ago
@PlutonovLed My pleasure - glad you enjoyed it! :)
TTTEpisodeS15 11 months ago
not a bad episode. Quite enjoyable, but the rhyming is quite annoying.
8/10
TheSI3DRemakist 11 months ago
Why the frigging hell did Thomas cause so many accidents. What is Sharon Miller thinking. I am amazed this got made. It isnt the worst ep, maiy because of Stanley appearing with a speaking role, but what is the deal with the freight trains. There are never any brakevans. But i love Greg's shots today. The opening scenes were magnificent. He is a credit to this show.
etenks1 11 months ago
This was pretty good. Finally we got to hear Stanley! :D
TheSodorSteamworks 11 months ago
cameo by belle at 0.21
etenks1 11 months ago
@etenks1 Yep!
TTTEpisodeS15 11 months ago