At first I was confused because part of the song was missing, but after listening to the whole thing, I absolutely love your arrangement. It's really beautiful. Great job!
It would be more logical if autumn's monologue part came before fiction we live part, because the fiction we live part seems to be like a reaction on the autumn's monologue part. Just saying ;D
its kinda choppy during the chorus and during the last part from The Fiction We Live.... but its better than any other version I've heard of the combined songs :) (may I ask what program you used to combine them?)
realllllly reallly really well done. I heard this track first by legion of doom autumn to ashes. I loved it for well over a year and just discovered this remix. truely brings me to tears. love it. its goin on my ipod. THX
I love this, it's absolutely amazing, but I think it should have ended at 5:42 perhaps dragging out Melanies voice for an extra 5 or so seconds that it does in the original
Mixing two songs (especially of similar or equal tempo) is no excuse for songs to go offbeat. Both original songs seem to be in 4/4 time, and it sounds great at the beginning, but at the end it gets choppy. Just work on smoothly switching between the two songs at the end, and it'll be perfect.
Other than that, great mix! Love both of these songs sooo much!
gotta say this is the best version i have listened to where they were combined perfectly, great job! btw love how you put we only exist in teh END of the songs,
theres mixed reasons, one person just left the band before they were to record. others wanted to pursue other artistic interests. some had nothing left to say in music. wik. it for a better answer, that was very vag
well, live they actually preform these two songs together so this is how it'd more then likely sound live, i think thats what the creator of this was trying to do. its great and i have absolutely no quarrels with this.
there is a program you can download and it allows you to download youtube videos and convert them to wma, i used it for a couple of songs so i could slow them down on windows media player to help me play the guitar lol just google it i cant remember the name of it, and btw its free so if you find one thats not free its probably not that one lol good luck
i only found this band again after 10 years of not hearing them...forgot how truly powerful they were...especially this song..the fast stuff is good but it's good to be able to slow down once in a while
its in the wrong order...the girl is suppose to sing first for it to make sense...
and how come they cut out the part right after "been dreaming of this soo long" its suppose to say "but we only exist in this song" after that...its cut out....
man you can go to bed dead then wake up alive that shit would be redundant .... lol sry its just hilarious i was watching scary movie 4 when i read your comment
I agree with everyone else that this combination is amazing! but I really think you should try to do it so that the girl is first, at lest for a portion and then have him and her talking...his part only makes sense if it comes after hers
I edited that out towards the end on purpose. If you listen to it at the beginning you will hear that it's in there. The reason I did that was just so the song has a variance towards the end.
Gah this sounds exactly like me and a friend of mine. i try to help her out, but she is so broken that its so hard to do it. i wish i could do more, but i cant. :(
ohhhh..... what a sadsong that this band brings... tsk... a very deep meanings of lyrics suits yourself... ouch... but the song was great inspite of its sad lyrics...
very very good m8. both songs are so amazing, but YOU, combined them. making a.... songasm. very good job, i love it when the both sing at the same time, i think that's how it shoulda been in the first place.
I do have the album. That section that your talking about isn't at the beginning of my mix, but if you listen towards the end of the song I left it in. The reason I took it out at the beginning is cause I liked it better at the end, and I wanted a slight difference between the first and last part of the guys version of the song.
haha yeah that's true. They are meant to be together and everyone is interested in hearing them as a mix, so that's why they are so many combinations out there. "The Fiction We Live" is only 1:18 long, so it's a short song. But they are some videos here on Youtube that have them play back to back so really your not missing anything of either song, they are just played one after another if you can find the right video.
Damn! Just when i though couldn't be something better thant that 2 songs... Just Great.
LuigiPhenomenon 1 month ago
This is epic... love it...
xXGAM3OVERXx 1 month ago
damn, i has been trough something that autumns monologue translate very well!!! = , (
Louhcaah 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Love it. Not much can be said other than that.
mregobuster 4 months ago
Thats awesome what you did here.
xpiecemealx 5 months ago
At first I was confused because part of the song was missing, but after listening to the whole thing, I absolutely love your arrangement. It's really beautiful. Great job!
hime0301 6 months ago
It would be more logical if autumn's monologue part came before fiction we live part, because the fiction we live part seems to be like a reaction on the autumn's monologue part. Just saying ;D
LegionoftheSuus 6 months ago
This is fucking great! Awesome job :D
LooWeezy2210 7 months ago
Beautiful. Just fucking beautiful.
eocine 7 months ago
amazing job. thanks
kartheel 7 months ago
its kinda choppy during the chorus and during the last part from The Fiction We Live.... but its better than any other version I've heard of the combined songs :) (may I ask what program you used to combine them?)
Kiitay16 7 months ago
these two songs saved me when i was 16.. so beautiful
m1k3yk 8 months ago
Badass mix for sure
futchofdeth666 8 months ago
Good job : )
CollinSilencer 9 months ago
This is the best mix of these two songs. Thank you for this! I miss FATA greatly. <3
rocksickkle 10 months ago
realllllly reallly really well done. I heard this track first by legion of doom autumn to ashes. I loved it for well over a year and just discovered this remix. truely brings me to tears. love it. its goin on my ipod. THX
crimsonx83 1 year ago
I love this, it's absolutely amazing, but I think it should have ended at 5:42 perhaps dragging out Melanies voice for an extra 5 or so seconds that it does in the original
CarnageMerc 1 year ago
Mixing two songs (especially of similar or equal tempo) is no excuse for songs to go offbeat. Both original songs seem to be in 4/4 time, and it sounds great at the beginning, but at the end it gets choppy. Just work on smoothly switching between the two songs at the end, and it'll be perfect.
Other than that, great mix! Love both of these songs sooo much!
bodom0015 1 year ago
I don't like this... I like the originals so much better...
Falinore 1 year ago
Beautiful.
PixelizedSnowflake 1 year ago
This song is like poison to me! Always makes me depressed xD
iThnake 1 year ago 3
I love it
Jaromiafly 1 year ago
Hard to really groove when the beats are off...clean it up a bit and I think you'll have a FATA masterpiece.
tehmattbookpro 1 year ago
@tehmattbookpro groove, i think the beats are off on purpose you people do realize its two songs
norskwizard 1 year ago 2
the perfect song :')
XxXxAshleeAnnexXxX 1 year ago
how could i come across downloading this song i cant seem to find this exact combo anywhere but youtube..anyone wanna help me out??
TheSkolos 1 year ago
I really actually appreciate the way you mixed this....
buriedindreams 1 year ago
gotta say this is the best version i have listened to where they were combined perfectly, great job! btw love how you put we only exist in teh END of the songs,
dustybizzie 1 year ago 4
This is awsome.. Great job dude!!!
HobbitFateBack 1 year ago
Amazing :D
ParamoreObsessives 1 year ago
this is great
Ardarel 1 year ago
Where can I get this?
Gloveman1 1 year ago
dont u got it backward?.....isn't the guys version a reply to the girls...u should put hers first.
whiteboy311kn 1 year ago
SPEECHLESS
MsYounha 1 year ago
clasic!!!
TheMaurolara 1 year ago
i really loved it!!!
it's so fuckin amazing!!!
Why didn't FATA have this idea of mixing'em??
soerlove 1 year ago
epic! you should post a link for an mp3 download or something love this!
blockislandboy 1 year ago
this is purely amazing..
jordan02civic 1 year ago
Very good. :)
JuleLovesHerBoard 1 year ago
where can i get this mix ??? uploader pleeezzz send me the song...
CradleOfRazors 1 year ago
This should be the song,
there is alot more expression. and it flows good together.
if only this band were still together . RIP FATA
Perfectchew 1 year ago 2
why did they break up?
shecter100 1 year ago
theres mixed reasons, one person just left the band before they were to record. others wanted to pursue other artistic interests. some had nothing left to say in music. wik. it for a better answer, that was very vag
Perfectchew 1 year ago
well, live they actually preform these two songs together so this is how it'd more then likely sound live, i think thats what the creator of this was trying to do. its great and i have absolutely no quarrels with this.
CRTmonitor89 1 year ago 3
It would be amazing if i could get an mp3 of this. Does anyone know where i could get one of the two sons together, or at least make the mp3 myself.
SANDXcalliber 1 year ago
there is a program you can download and it allows you to download youtube videos and convert them to wma, i used it for a couple of songs so i could slow them down on windows media player to help me play the guitar lol just google it i cant remember the name of it, and btw its free so if you find one thats not free its probably not that one lol good luck
clinkyec 1 year ago
dude i just got am idea im rip the song from the video and email it to u :)
CradleOfRazors 1 year ago
Best combination of these two songs, great job! :)
Fornonine 1 year ago
beautifullll<3
MrsDepp66 1 year ago
really really good but The fiction we live is a response to autumns monologue actually
ForrealBeastly 2 years ago
This is Entirly Amazing ;]
How incredible!
Splendid Song x]
ElectricBeatingHeart 2 years ago
hey i really like how you mashed them together. great combo
safedanger90 2 years ago
Nice Job, Best combo of the two songs that i heard!!!
ThanatosL1e 2 years ago 2
this is the BEST combo of these two songs that ive heard.. fantastic job
willtaraluvr90 2 years ago 2
you did a good job man
lucyeXcorpse 2 years ago 2
But we only exist in this song
this is just kinda missing from the song right? or is this a different version?
ericjamesrobb 2 years ago 11
this song is nice
harrybreakell04 2 years ago
i only found this band again after 10 years of not hearing them...forgot how truly powerful they were...especially this song..the fast stuff is good but it's good to be able to slow down once in a while
toddwolf27 2 years ago 2
beautiful <3
ichigoxlovu 2 years ago 2
absolutly amazing song
SerialKilla92 2 years ago 2
cangratulations men !!!
kayklos 2 years ago
Comment removed
cutebaby69xx 2 years ago
Comment removed
cutebaby69xx 2 years ago
beautiful song :)
maratatasaun 2 years ago
the woman singing is autumn. and although the lyrics arent in the right order this is badass! one of my favorite songs of all time!!
brianlovestoskate 2 years ago
who is this woman??
Uhualleskleber 2 years ago 2
the woman singing is autumn
brianlovestoskate 2 years ago
Melanie Wills of the band called One True Thing
deathwish124 2 years ago
Yeah it is in the wrong order, but great effort!
phayzette 2 years ago
Great song, the mix is really good, grats and thanks for this great mix
virusjerry 2 years ago
A great song!!!
99bay 2 years ago
its in the wrong order...the girl is suppose to sing first for it to make sense...
and how come they cut out the part right after "been dreaming of this soo long" its suppose to say "but we only exist in this song" after that...its cut out....
mruwsoccer 2 years ago 3
i totaly agree...
cezarthakyrkos 2 years ago
Indeed.. Like this, it doesn't make any sense..
Too bad.
TheClue1988 2 years ago
I dont believe the female is suppost to ever goes first, takes away the dramatic effect.
norskwizard 2 years ago
im not a huge fan of this genre but hell this is just one of the few times I like it
fcukurlf2009 2 years ago
wads the 2 songs? i love this song!
SingsForHer 2 years ago
always happy
everytime i hear this song :)
no doubt
its beautiful
10/5
pawTDWP 2 years ago 19
this is so great *_* i love both songs
manukilledyou 2 years ago
Perfect song
BellatrixAlicia 2 years ago 2
Their voices compliment eachother soo much its redundantly amazing :-)
Metalcool36 2 years ago
man you can go to bed dead then wake up alive that shit would be redundant .... lol sry its just hilarious i was watching scary movie 4 when i read your comment
SilenceSoSudden 2 years ago
No offense, but why is there a line missing from the song? It's one of my favorite lines and nobody has a video that actually includes it --
"But we only exist in this song."
jensaysxstfu 2 years ago
"But we only exist in this song." is at 6:03
AliceImTruemmerland 2 years ago
that is the best line
SilenceSoSudden 2 years ago
thanks niq for intro me to this song...
love this song so much...
thanks..
love ya...
lovesadgurlfallingin 2 years ago
Schöner song
Tikeeetack 2 years ago
beautiful... felt in love with yu piece of work ^^
heldenfan 2 years ago
i like when emily sings it better
lawenforcer2111 2 years ago
autumns monologue is supposed to come first
xChallisx 2 years ago
did you read the descripition by chance?
Dari2870 2 years ago
That wasn't in the description when i wrote that, considering it was 3 weeks ago.
xChallisx 2 years ago
download..The legion of doom-The fiction we live....its the songs combined
Izaiahsmommy21 2 years ago
I just love the mixing of the two! sooo damn good!
cintypie86 2 years ago
I agree with everyone else that this combination is amazing! but I really think you should try to do it so that the girl is first, at lest for a portion and then have him and her talking...his part only makes sense if it comes after hers
thwarted72 2 years ago
I LOVE how you put these songs together.
GREAT JOB.
zopenyoureyez 2 years ago
incomplete " cause we only exist in this song" passage is missing....
Sharkishungry 2 years ago 10
agreed...
squall513 2 years ago
I edited that out towards the end on purpose. If you listen to it at the beginning you will hear that it's in there. The reason I did that was just so the song has a variance towards the end.
juan2049 2 years ago 4
They split up =(
Malmequer11 2 years ago
this is the best band of all time,they are amazing,and with her voice is fantastic.
good work putting the 2 togetha....but sorri 2 say this but u shud of put her voice 1st as his part is an answer 2 her song...
muhammadoll13 2 years ago
you are a god, please send me the mp3 of this, i would do ANYTHING!!! lol
alexbg93 2 years ago
WHOA! that's so cool how they're combined. Thanks! :)
RainingPianos 2 years ago
after watching 6 or 8 versions of this, this is my definite favorite - way to go!
moaserdggg 2 years ago
Makes me sad ;O;
but.... this song is awesome (:
xRawrlk 2 years ago
Waaa!
B E A U T I F U L S O N G
:D!
xRawrlk 2 years ago
this is amazing!!!
my brother and i were trying to work out a way we could mix the two songs, so I'm gonna show him this!!!
it's so awesome.
xXxneverwalkalonexXx 2 years ago
Awesome you did a great Job. Very Beautiful
5*
AliceImTruemmerland 2 years ago
I love From Autumn to Ashes.
Autumn's Monologue and the fiction we live were great.
Frans and her singing is very wonderful in this.
I love what you did with it. Its good.
zackywackyyo 2 years ago
I will say, though.
Maybe during the chorus, you should have made it say "you don't see me" THEN "Ofcourse I see you" then "You don't" "I DO!"
Maybe, have frans singing like a second delayed.
MAYBE, im saying. this is still fine.
zackywackyyo 2 years ago 4
Where Can I Download This?
queenbeesxoxoxoxoxo 2 years ago
just use the youtube downloader.... you can convert it to mp3 using it aswell
AUSMOPARGUY 2 years ago
Great songs, but the way the voices were overlaid around 2:12 sounds absolutely horrible, kind of killed the songs.
tgs455 2 years ago
i agree and disagree. its ok i guess but it kinda ruined it
CwalkersCantDance 2 years ago
best song ... love it
kichomacedonia 2 years ago
I LOVE IT
hhdd5 2 years ago 2
WOW!
im LOVE THIS SONG! !!!!
cameragirl016 2 years ago 2
when the guy sing in same time as the girl , It's like WOW. this is what i call music
blackxthink 2 years ago 3
really rreally cool
but asnt the girl suppose to sing first
tunayuna10 2 years ago
This is amazing.
sarahFREAKINAWESOME 2 years ago
The visual effects at 1:20 dont fit at all!
koreanstyler 2 years ago
I would have played Autumns monologue part first, and then the Fiction We Live as a response.
LeesiePolice 2 years ago 2
classic...strop strop fort!!!!!!!!!!!!
superstarbeebotch 2 years ago
I love the chorus. It's just amazing. Good job!
PipoGoreQueen 2 years ago 3
i love chorus part it is amazing! i love both the songs and i've always wanted them formed together and you did it!
micaelaluvzp 2 years ago 7
good job, so beautiful.
raiinb0wh 2 years ago 3
Excellent mix
1kkinz 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
1 c0ver y0ur m0uth with y0ur hand
2 make a wish int0 it
3 cl0se y0ur hand {make it int0 a fist}
4 h0ld y0ur fist t0 y0ur heart f0r 5 sec.
5 send dis t0 3 m0re vide0s
6 t0m0rr0w will be y0ur best day ever
ninjadude159 2 years ago
I think..I might be crying a little bit? This is awesome! It's sad too..
TeenAngstKills 2 years ago 2
this is amazing
browneyedbeauty914 2 years ago 3
absoloutely brill.
lyricsandtunes 2 years ago 2
this song is absolutly amazing i have been showing it to all my friends and they love it...and this song relates to me and my ex so much
Dragonkiller179 2 years ago
The Legion of Doom has a really good mix pretty sure its titled "the fiction we live" but i got it on frostwire
mahsentry 2 years ago
Gah this sounds exactly like me and a friend of mine. i try to help her out, but she is so broken that its so hard to do it. i wish i could do more, but i cant. :(
groundnpound07 2 years ago 2
Nice, nice!
MyOwnFuneral 2 years ago
i want i want i want!!!!!
confused542 2 years ago
sweet :)
CrimsonCameron 2 years ago
ive heard them combined better, but its still a good mix.
cawksinmehcar 2 years ago
would you happen to have a link to a better mix?
CrimsonCameron 2 years ago
hey i have a different mix i downloaded its a bit better then this one
iminloveagain07 2 years ago
where from?
CrimsonCameron 2 years ago
i got mine on limewire its hard to get it on limewire though if you want i could send it to you
ninjasword71 2 years ago
can you send me the link too?
music24seven4life 2 years ago
this is my account i accdently used my fathers lol ok i have the song but not link its the remix i got on limewire
iminloveagain07 2 years ago
Can you send me one?
joshj99 2 years ago
this is by far the BEST mix of these two songs. and it is AMAZING
great jobb xD
LAZYKUBANITA 2 years ago
Very well done
Castnine 2 years ago
Just gnarly. I'm listening the song thanx a friend... Great song.
Bru.
brunomltv 3 years ago 2
i just love the chours!
pppunkmoi 3 years ago
awesome mix...but
the chours is not very good :(
but still an awesome mix ♥
KingBrazzer 3 years ago
ohhhh..... what a sadsong that this band brings... tsk... a very deep meanings of lyrics suits yourself... ouch... but the song was great inspite of its sad lyrics...
narrowheads 3 years ago 2
very very good m8. both songs are so amazing, but YOU, combined them. making a.... songasm. very good job, i love it when the both sing at the same time, i think that's how it shoulda been in the first place.
BlottedPsychosis 3 years ago 2
nice job like it a lot
christmyer23 3 years ago 2
i love these two songs!! and when you put them together its sounds great!
gemma1fan 3 years ago 2
i think autumns monologue should go first before the fiction we live...
misstagged 3 years ago 5
yea thats how its supposed to be. cause ficion we live is a response to what she's saying in autumns monologue
PromisedDarkness 3 years ago 2
T^T I love this song
tobzxvampy 3 years ago
i wish i could download:(
Tomthewumpus 3 years ago
the best mix ever
this too songs are alone beautiful but this is much better ♥♥♥
groogysgroogs 3 years ago 2
love it
Spiderschweeein 3 years ago
Well done, but tbh, I think The Fiction We Live should come as a response to Autumn's Monologue, not the other way around.
Stormakov 3 years ago 3
Yeah so many people have said that, I suppose I could of done it that way too
juan2049 3 years ago
Really really well done! Gorgeous.
rosiero87 3 years ago
This is really well done - nice work ♥
Animedemon89 3 years ago
i really love this mix :D
onthaprowl 3 years ago
this is the best mix of this song i've heard.
most people put together the verses and it sounds bad and it sounds mixed... this sounds like it's the actual song.
i love it!!
dancingwithfire 3 years ago
this is a sad song! But i love it!!! : - ) I feel like crying.
dairycloud 3 years ago
The Waves that Rhym are couples entwined
wraitheyes121 3 years ago
this song is missing the part that says,
"but we only exist in this song"
after he says "ive been dreaming this for so long"
EcuaChinc92 3 years ago
i love this song it makes me think!!
christmyer23 3 years ago 2
i think this mix is awesome
JoeCordo 3 years ago 3
this song make's me sad...:(
TheLoveMobile 3 years ago
This is a great version! Combining the two really gives the energy that those songs need! C'est une perle rare!
bananapeanutsandwich 3 years ago 3
The link doesn't work anymore, I'd love to have this for my ipod does anybody got a place where I could get the MP3 of this or a mix like it?
Justin560999 3 years ago
this is not the complete "the fiction we live song".
coz if u buy the album, they have the lyric "but we only exist in this song".
just so you know.
so buy the album...
HermanAtion 3 years ago
I do have the album. That section that your talking about isn't at the beginning of my mix, but if you listen towards the end of the song I left it in. The reason I took it out at the beginning is cause I liked it better at the end, and I wanted a slight difference between the first and last part of the guys version of the song.
juan2049 3 years ago
ohh sheesh.
you took it out and it sounded pretty natural.
you must have done a good job then(:
HermanAtion 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The link doesn't work anymore, I'd love to have this for my ipod does anybody got a place where I could get the MP3 of this or a mix like it?
Justin560999 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't think the artist needed you to edit the song for him.
You should have left it alone, and I disagree, it doesn't sound 'natural'
WhisperMeALoveSong 3 years ago
i cant find "the fiction we live" by itself, its always combined with another song. i want to hear the original
2608giz 3 years ago
haha yeah that's true. They are meant to be together and everyone is interested in hearing them as a mix, so that's why they are so many combinations out there. "The Fiction We Live" is only 1:18 long, so it's a short song. But they are some videos here on Youtube that have them play back to back so really your not missing anything of either song, they are just played one after another if you can find the right video.
juan2049 3 years ago
Awesome job dude, love both theses songs, better as a du