Considering that this video was filmed almost 2 years ago, I must say that the quality is really good! This video was really helpful! Thank you so much! :)
eek. help me. should i buy snow white because i've been dying to don the red lipstick look atleast once and idk which one. my hair is golden brown..i have almond shaped hazel eyes. and my skin tone is fair with pink tones in them. also...my teeth do look sorta yellowish ..and you said snow white would be good.
I love your videos Gina!!! I found your channel through the "other" Gina. She's cool but I like you sooooooo much better!!! Love your reviews. Thinking of getting some NYX lipsticks. Do you use Benefit silky finish?
yes it is this great creamy color. its got some orange peach shimmer in it but it is just so smooth. its one of those natural fall nude type of colors. soo gorgeous
@HannahBoNanna3 I love it, too! I'm so glad I got it on a whim because I have not seen any recommendations for it whatsoever. It looks great on me. Cherry Culture is actually sold out of it now so maybe people are catching on. :)
This video has been so helpful! I've recently been getting into NYX lip products but there are so many different choices that it can be overwhelming! I have to order online and the fact that the swatches on websites are so off doesn't help any. Now I know which ones I want to put in my next order. :)
I have several stores by me that sell them but I notice that online it's cheaper and they offer deals on shipping and sometimes buy one get one free. Online is really a good way to go. Try cherryculture. com
can you recommend a red lipstick that isn't to bold for someone like me who never wears red lipstick (my darkest lipstick is vivaglam VI) I just think I should have one that is a staple ;)
*lol* yeah I wanna start wearing red or at least have one red lipstick that makes me look and feel classy and sophisticated. I just need something that is not to shocking bold (I wanna break out from my routine of wearing nudes and pinks ;))
I'm not sure with actual stores. It started as a pretty small company and has quickly grown, so I think that's why it's pretty random, yet. Some boutiques carry it, but lots of online stores like cherryculture . com and others carry it.
hey gina, i was wanting to get some nyx products on ebay, do you think it's worth it? and what eyeshadows and eyeshadow jumbo sticks do you recommend getting? i think you get such a better deal on ebay...=)
ok, sorry to keep on asking, but what e/s would you recommend getting to start off? i found this really good ebay seller, but do you have any recommended ebay sellers? thanks xx
as far as e/s goes, I'm not a good person to ask. I only own one NYX blush and one e/s trio that was a gift. I did, however, buy one e/s trio that was adorable for someone and it was called "casablanca" but don't recall the number. I bought from someone called pinkkittyzone. Anyone that has high feedback and good % I'd say go for it.
hey sweetie! I have two nyx swatch videos in my archives for the majority of my lippies. I'll maybe do a lip collection video if you'd like? I own a lot so not sure how long it'd be.. lol!
thanks! I'm wearing pink freeze for my lid by mac, stately black from the hello kitty too dolly palette, gosh darling on my lips to blank them out and YSL rouge volupte sensual silk #2 on top.. xoo!
Nice picks!!! Can u believe I am still waiting on my order from CherryCulture that I made from the NYX anniversary??? I have quite a few of those in my order! Can't wait for it to come!
eeek!! Cherry Culture was way fast for me, but I've only made one order from them ever and not much of my NYX is from them as I got tons on ebay. That sucks to wait! GRR!
I think it depends on your skin tone. If you're a very warm toned person I think you'd look better in an ivory/cream color? Otherwise I just used a wet and wild clear with metallic sheen to pearlize mine out so there's more dimension to it. xoxo!
Have you tried Nyx lipstick in Spoiled (I heart this one) I also like Thalia and Indian Pink. I've got to try Honey b/c I bought a back up of Brave New Bronze. I am so totally obsessed with lipstick lately~It would probably take me 10 yrs to use up all the lipsticks I've collected ;)
I go to Boston regularly to visit relatives because it's only a five hour drive from Montreal. If I'm ever in California i'll certainly come knocking on your door, and hope you do the same if you visit Montreal! ;) xxx
Just got done with my order. Shoot me now! Here's what I got. The one I'm dying to try is Pandora. I've got so dark this summer nothing shows up on me. I have a feeling that one will! 1. LSS550 Indian Pink 2. LSS595 Strawberry Milk 3. LSS592 Baby Pink 4. LSS520 Pandora 5. LSS569 Snow White 6. LSS578 Earth Angel 7. LSS509 Narcissus 8. LSS623 Heather 9. LSS643 Femme 10. LSS634 Louisiana 11. LSS580 Chambord 12. LSS548 Apollo
yes!! I bet it will! try eucalyptus too if you want another more bold one.. it's more of a fuscia. I bet it looks amazing on your dark complexion right now!
I don't have any of that brand lipstick but they look really nice. I am going to check them out. Thanks Gina! BTW I just ordered Saint Germain online. I have never tried it and the Macys Mac did not have it. Hope I like it.
Awesome thank you!!
MissMorganC 3 weeks ago
can you do an updated version of this? thanks
BiNkY2BoNkA3RoX 3 weeks ago
Oh im getting Snow White soon ! Can't wait !!! Oh by the way have you tried YSL lipsticks ? are they nice ? Thanks !
kotonaiishida 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
For more go to skinsamples.blogspot.com ! :)
SkinSamples 5 months ago
You say "umm" quite alot of times xD
ralithelion 8 months ago
szkoda ,że nie pokazujesz na ustach,ponieważ na dłoni jest inny kolor na ustach inny!!!!pozdrawienia z Polski Mira
KubanBMW 8 months ago
Considering that this video was filmed almost 2 years ago, I must say that the quality is really good! This video was really helpful! Thank you so much! :)
RealAsianBeauty 8 months ago
you look like brunette hilary duff in the thumbnail!
athenaloca 9 months ago
is indian pink similar to MACs Ever Hip lipstick?
10glossygirl 10 months ago
perfect lighting! thanks so much!
Rona004 10 months ago
what's the fifth (purple)one?
immg0604 1 year ago
I like how ur videos are straight to the point! (: I hate 10 minute videos with 8 minutes of blah blah blah... LOL
pinkiil0ve 1 year ago
You look so pretty in this video
Coralsilk 1 year ago
eek. help me. should i buy snow white because i've been dying to don the red lipstick look atleast once and idk which one. my hair is golden brown..i have almond shaped hazel eyes. and my skin tone is fair with pink tones in them. also...my teeth do look sorta yellowish ..and you said snow white would be good.
Jesvel18 1 year ago
Isnt strawberry milk hard to wear? It has a weird consistency where its too slippery
Jbsa1998 1 year ago
I sthere a NYX color similar to the color you have on your lips? It is gorgeous!
lulubelle2010 1 year ago
Do you have a hair tutorial for the look in this video!? Your hair looks so beautiful!
tatsudoshi65 1 year ago
I love Harmonica!
tatsudoshi65 1 year ago
U r beautiful :)
hmm1704 1 year ago
which is the best nude from nyx?
thatgirllx0x 1 year ago
you certainly own a lot of make up
ragi099 1 year ago
love your videos!! Keep em coming please!!! This was very helpful!:-)
MsBubblegumGucci 1 year ago
super helpful thank you :)
christiner0se 1 year ago
I love Indian pink!! It is AWESOME!!! :D
suerte1866 1 year ago
your video was so helpful! im deff putting an order in soon!
fogarty1122 1 year ago
@springbride exactly just tried to order another lat week and it took forever for me to find it. all out of stock :) haha
HannahBoNanna3 1 year ago
where u get the nyx round lipstick i love the baby pink=)
jessica902999 1 year ago
you got good lighting. I like this video and it is really helpful =)!
glacieras 1 year ago
OMG this vid is sooo helpfull. and the coloures show off great ion this vid. thanks !
GlitsyMakeUp 2 years ago
my favorite is paris, its such a gorgeous hot pink color!!!!!
PlumDressing17 2 years ago
What is the quality of these lipsticks? I hate drug store ones so, I was afraid to try these. :)
cutevwbug 2 years ago
pleeeease make an eye make up tutorial!! I love this look!!
JulyChuck 2 years ago
thank you for this really helpful video! i just ordered indian pink and lousiana. ;)
vivalasara 2 years ago
is baby pink and/or harmonica decently long lasting? it's like impossible to find a light pink that doesn't rub off at the slightest touch.
mollymariex 2 years ago
I've been resisting Baby Pink, but now I may have to get it when I'm off of my No Buy. :) Snow White is amazing!
kragey 2 years ago
do you have any of the black label lipsticks?
natesmom2244 2 years ago
love that you compaired the two ipsticks to eachother. thank you for that.
sfstarla2416 2 years ago
That was very helpful! What are you wearing on your lips?
ktgrenier 2 years ago
hmm looking at it i would say....gosh darling to blank out her lips..then ysl rouge volupte #2 sensual lipstick on top..would you agree?
dramatification 2 years ago
Thank you you helped me alot gorgeous!
zachansonhasbigballs 2 years ago
I love your videos Gina!!! I found your channel through the "other" Gina. She's cool but I like you sooooooo much better!!! Love your reviews. Thinking of getting some NYX lipsticks. Do you use Benefit silky finish?
JannaKulasa 2 years ago
i adore pumpkin pie. i noticed that it actually isnt that common?!? have you tried it yet?
HannahBoNanna3 2 years ago
i haven't!! i'm guessing it's kind of a peachy orange creamy color?
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
yes it is this great creamy color. its got some orange peach shimmer in it but it is just so smooth. its one of those natural fall nude type of colors. soo gorgeous
HannahBoNanna3 2 years ago
@HannahBoNanna3 I love it, too! I'm so glad I got it on a whim because I have not seen any recommendations for it whatsoever. It looks great on me. Cherry Culture is actually sold out of it now so maybe people are catching on. :)
springbride 1 year ago
@HannahBoNanna3 omg it's amazingg!!!!
makeupnerdful 1 year ago
thank you, it's very helpful for a nyx newbie :)
really love nude colors
kappina88 2 years ago
if you love nudes! I highly recommend circe!! it's a purchase after this vid.. xoox
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
@ginabinawina99 hi there pls give us nudes shades aside from circe we're buying 12's plus hint of orange and pink..give us idea pls
ivygero 1 year ago
very helpful Thx!
honeybumblebee 2 years ago
my pleasure! Thanks for watching!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
This video has been so helpful! I've recently been getting into NYX lip products but there are so many different choices that it can be overwhelming! I have to order online and the fact that the swatches on websites are so off doesn't help any. Now I know which ones I want to put in my next order. :)
You're gorgeous!!
awishedforsong 2 years ago
it's my pleasure!! I have a nude favorite as well if you like nudes Circe is excellent. Seriously dupable to Estee Lauder's Vanilla Truffle
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
celine reminds me of freckletone, i haven't compared the two though, it just looks like that from the video
shimmercoconut 2 years ago
ooh!! you're right! I see a resemblance.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
GREAT VIDEO. GREAT SWATCHES!
cocoalovely 2 years ago
how much are nyx lipsticks usually?
maryandcourtney4ever 2 years ago
around $2 :) depends on the place, but as low as $1 at times.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
we don't have NYX in Greece :(((
TheAlikaki 2 years ago
do u know stores that sell nyx stuff in maryland?? I have looked for it everywhere but i can never find them :(
hollisterlover0522 2 years ago
anywhere that has an Ulta store should have them; otherwise it's very hit and miss. I do order most of mine online, myself. xoxo
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I have several stores by me that sell them but I notice that online it's cheaper and they offer deals on shipping and sometimes buy one get one free. Online is really a good way to go. Try cherryculture. com
honeybumblebee 2 years ago
ive ordered from them as well, but buy most of mine cheaper in bulk off ebay :) hugs!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
This video was SO helpful, thank you!<3
PrettiestPinkGun 2 years ago
my pleasure sweetie! xoxo
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
i love nyx round lipsticks! my fave is strawberry milk. thanks for showing us your faves, i'm definitely gonna get all the ones you recommended!
shesURBAN 2 years ago
yes! strawberry milk is a great one! Hugs!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
So helpful!!!
Going to order some NYX lipsticks now.
Cintaku78 2 years ago
yay!! hope you like them :)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
You have got to be a model! You are stunning!!!
AprilAthena7 2 years ago
aww! you're too kind!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
can you recommend a red lipstick that isn't to bold for someone like me who never wears red lipstick (my darkest lipstick is vivaglam VI) I just think I should have one that is a staple ;)
australialover24 2 years ago
so you want me to recommend a softer red for you or mentioning you would never wear red? xoxo!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
*lol* yeah I wanna start wearing red or at least have one red lipstick that makes me look and feel classy and sophisticated. I just need something that is not to shocking bold (I wanna break out from my routine of wearing nudes and pinks ;))
australialover24 2 years ago
I've looked and looked and I can't find a subtle red that I own, especially nyx.. so sorry
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
for all the Canadians watching you can buy NYX products at Rexall and Pharmaplus drugstores but they do not have the full line of NYX products
CMeilach 2 years ago
thanks for helping the Canadian watchers! hugs
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
no problem!
CMeilach 2 years ago
hi Gina! Are those the black label lipsticks or the regular? Thanks...love your makeup as always!
cassandrasmom 2 years ago
just the regular round ones :) xoxo to you!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
does anyone know if u can get NYX in UK stores anywhere. i dont trust ebay for makeup!!
hellorachael1 2 years ago
NYX is US only, but cherryculture . com i think ships international. a lot of us shop from that site
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Where are the NYX lipsticks made in?
inflamedbullet 2 years ago
I hear they're "made" here in the USA, but can't find information to completely confirm. The company originated in Los Angeles.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
ahah!! let me know what you think! you have great taste!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
hehe you have nars on the mind!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
nyx is soo good, cheap prices but really good quality :) your so pretty!
ThatsBeckie 2 years ago
nyx is verrry good! thanks xoxoxo!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
gosh i cant find indian pink out here :( is it close to margerita? or miracle? i dunno if u have miracle....its gorgeous!
jcanangel 2 years ago
margerita would look lovely on you but I don't have miracle. Margerita is a bit more bold than indian pink xoxox
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
where can you purchase NYX products at??
complicated427 2 years ago
ulta
jinjin501 2 years ago
do you know anywhere else, i don't have a ulta close to me, and they don't sell them online.
complicated427 2 years ago
I'm not sure with actual stores. It started as a pretty small company and has quickly grown, so I think that's why it's pretty random, yet. Some boutiques carry it, but lots of online stores like cherryculture . com and others carry it.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
i love them all, i want them all LOL xx
LucyMarie85 2 years ago
teehehe
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
i reli like that snow white lipstick that looks so nice ! x
faz78626 2 years ago
it is a super nice red and oh so creamy to apply. I find a lot of reds to be drying for some reason.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
hey gina, i was wanting to get some nyx products on ebay, do you think it's worth it? and what eyeshadows and eyeshadow jumbo sticks do you recommend getting? i think you get such a better deal on ebay...=)
dongdongy 2 years ago
I bought most of my lippies off ebay in bulk, actually. Love ebay! I recommend pots and pans and milk for sure for e/s jumbo sticks
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
ok, sorry to keep on asking, but what e/s would you recommend getting to start off? i found this really good ebay seller, but do you have any recommended ebay sellers? thanks xx
dongdongy 2 years ago
as far as e/s goes, I'm not a good person to ask. I only own one NYX blush and one e/s trio that was a gift. I did, however, buy one e/s trio that was adorable for someone and it was called "casablanca" but don't recall the number. I bought from someone called pinkkittyzone. Anyone that has high feedback and good % I'd say go for it.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
can you do the rest of your NYX lippis as well and maybe NYX glosses and YSL rouge volupte? To name the NYX dupes for MAC was so helpful :) thanks
australialover24 2 years ago
hey sweetie! I have two nyx swatch videos in my archives for the majority of my lippies. I'll maybe do a lip collection video if you'd like? I own a lot so not sure how long it'd be.. lol!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Now I want to buy all of them except Honey. Thanks for the video :)
roseidyllic 2 years ago
anytime! xoxoxo!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
what MAC and NYX color is similar to the gosh darling you use to blank out your lips?
australialover24 2 years ago
I'm sure there's a similar color to gosh darling out there, but unfortunately I don't own it. I believe there's over 144 colors in nyx lippies.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Great video girl!!! I need to go try some of these out!!!
michellybelly24 2 years ago
Hi! What make up brands/names are you wearing on this look? I love the lipstick your wearing and the eyeshadow shade!
Please do more make up tutorials! I love your purples and dark colors smoky eyes! You look like barbie!
imaginarydiva 2 years ago
thanks! I'm wearing pink freeze for my lid by mac, stately black from the hello kitty too dolly palette, gosh darling on my lips to blank them out and YSL rouge volupte sensual silk #2 on top.. xoo!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I've been wanting the nyx lipstick forever, but they don't sell them in my country :(
I've been too lazy to order online + postage is always pretty high.
kittynail 2 years ago
yes postage is annoying!! oy :(
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Yeah I really wanna get my hands on those lipsticks. Are the NYX eyeshadows any good?
kittynail 2 years ago
Nice picks!!! Can u believe I am still waiting on my order from CherryCulture that I made from the NYX anniversary??? I have quite a few of those in my order! Can't wait for it to come!
ghett0flower 2 years ago
eeek!! Cherry Culture was way fast for me, but I've only made one order from them ever and not much of my NYX is from them as I got tons on ebay. That sucks to wait! GRR!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Great haul! Love all the colors, will have to go to my Ulta and pick up a few.
wikkirn 2 years ago
hi gina
loved your top 10
i want to try white nailpolish but i don't
know its ugly on me so ther is rules to
wear white nailpolish??
SuGaRyBLoSsOm 2 years ago
I think it depends on your skin tone. If you're a very warm toned person I think you'd look better in an ivory/cream color? Otherwise I just used a wet and wild clear with metallic sheen to pearlize mine out so there's more dimension to it. xoxo!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
hey gina, do you maybe know if i can order nyx from europe? i would really like to try out these lipsticks! thank you :-*
suuuncokreeet 2 years ago
hey sweety! Check cherry culture . com and see if they ship international? Otherwise maybe some ebay sellers offer international shipping?
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
must agree with all of them i love all the ones u showed !
strawberry milk is my fav !
or spoiled is great as well !
xox
xoxoamandakisses 2 years ago
Where do you buy your NYX cosmetic at?
azianricefarts 2 years ago
ive bought a ton off ebay and others from cherryculture . com :)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
oh! and a couple from ulta!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Have you tried Nyx lipstick in Spoiled (I heart this one) I also like Thalia and Indian Pink. I've got to try Honey b/c I bought a back up of Brave New Bronze. I am so totally obsessed with lipstick lately~It would probably take me 10 yrs to use up all the lipsticks I've collected ;)
carrierossman 2 years ago
ooh I dont have spoiled! i'll have to check it out!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I love NYX lippies.....they are so nice for the price, I have a load of them~ :-)
KarlaKayM 2 years ago
aww so pretty. I'm upset now lol. You can't get those here :(
mikiforeverxox 2 years ago
Nice! Can't wait to go to the States to get some of those NYX lipsticks!
blushingbabe1 2 years ago
come here!!!!! where are you going in the states?
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I go to Boston regularly to visit relatives because it's only a five hour drive from Montreal. If I'm ever in California i'll certainly come knocking on your door, and hope you do the same if you visit Montreal! ;) xxx
blushingbabe1 2 years ago
great color choices!!!
oreonshadow 2 years ago
thanks! I do enjoy them!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
hey, i was always wondering...how can u tell what undertones are in the lipstick?
tokiohoteluvour 2 years ago
it's all based on color theory really. Mixing primary colors gets secondary and you can tell which primary color shows through more.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
lovely colours they look nice an creamy to apply , :o)
cardingsan 2 years ago
they are very creamy! love your lil smiley lol aww :o)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Oh ya i love strawberry milk, Narcissus, power, orange soda! They remind me of MAC although there nothing like them in consistency!
pinkdollylips 2 years ago
exactly!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Do you know if NYX has any nice nude lipsticks?(: thankyou!
liesareforfriends 2 years ago
like a nude beige ie: myth?
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
what nail polish are you wearing?
jackooolantern 2 years ago
its MAC festral white nail polish from cco :)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
very pretty, expectially Indian pink!
paraniodmusiclover 2 years ago
it is! I love it! xoxo
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I so love Honey & Indian Pink! Thanks, for the swatches =)
MellissaL01 2 years ago
Hey, some of those lipsticks look mighty familiar. They really are great quality and so pretty!
CurlyNicky 2 years ago
glad you like yours sugar lumps!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I yi YI! Now I have Indian Pink, Strawberry Milk, Baby Pink & Pandora on my list. I'm going to buy another opal too because Bella took mine! LOL
What is it with honey? I keep putting mine on and I swear it's the nicest, creamiest lipstick ever.
julykasa 2 years ago
I know!! I looked at honey initially and was like.. eh it's ok.. but when its on it applies like a dream and looks so nice!!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
julykasa 2 years ago
yes!! I bet it will! try eucalyptus too if you want another more bold one.. it's more of a fuscia. I bet it looks amazing on your dark complexion right now!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I don't have any of these colors:o) Soooo pretty!
Zoeebella 2 years ago
just like you!! loved your lanaindiana contest entry!!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I love these lipsticks!!!!
SillyMando2008 2 years ago
me too!! xoxo
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Harmonica looks like one for me!! I'll check those out!! Thanks, Gina!! Lisa
LisaLisaD1 2 years ago
ooh!! you should own it!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
thanks for posting the names on the side bar...
roannavm 2 years ago
anytime :)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
i love power with mac's little vi lustreglass over it.
kmikeya 2 years ago
ooh!! sounds fab!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I don't have any of that brand lipstick but they look really nice. I am going to check them out. Thanks Gina! BTW I just ordered Saint Germain online. I have never tried it and the Macys Mac did not have it. Hope I like it.
CocoPink44 2 years ago
Saint german is super popular. Hope you enjoy it!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Your skin has been looking so flawless lately. I love Indian Pink its so bright and fresh and summery.
livegorgeouslygreen 2 years ago
Thanks! i'm wearing the chanel foundations a ton lately. you're so right about indian pink!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Those look really creamy and pigmented! I think Power looks awesome, have you ever worn that one in a video? I'd love to see on!
BrandyC83 2 years ago
i'm trying to think if I have worn it in a video.. I'm sure i have! will have to check! xoxo
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
nice nayo.
preferably there's this store that sells these, for $1.99
is this a relevant price for one of these products you have in your existence?
AndrewFuckingRichie 2 years ago
1.99 is definitely doable.. cherry culture used to have them for only .99 but they've not been that cheap for some time
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Fun vid cutie! I love your cheek color!
Gimme!
xxG
LovePeaceandLipGloss 2 years ago
thanks sweetie! it's seriously one of my favorites! smashbox breast cancer LE in "blushing pink" fushion blush
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
"there so pretty" as ms Sophie would say. Love that honey!
MACwishin 2 years ago
yes~! honey is a must! It doesnt look like anything special in the tube, but is so lovely on!
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
I am crazy about all these NYX lipsticks iv'e been buying them up at all the shops! : )
pinkdollylips 2 years ago