Still, 6% of the land was owned by Arabs. Well, no one said they had to leave. That was never Ben-Gurion's plan (as he specifically states in a letter to his son Amos, "We must never expell the Arabs and takek their place," commonly twisted by anti-Israel haters to "we must expell"). Jews even accepted partition plan for 2 states. Arabs didn't. Arabs attacked in 1948. Israel won. Israel was born. And again in '67 and '73.
If you were a Jew who did that, you'd still get in trouble... Jews and non-Jews are guaranteed equal rights under the law (and seriously, why would I let someone take over my backyard, even if they are a Jew?)
Now, attacking with the intent of destroying other countries is not allowed (ex: Arabs to Israel in 1948, 1967, in 1967 Israel won much territory).
Pre-1948 - British Mandate of Palestine - they can give it to whoever they want. Most vacant.
@ExitOnlyEntry You have it backwards. If a Muslim perpetrates diabolical violence and mayhem against civilian (including Muslim) women and children within Israel (or Judea or Samaria)- since they've been brainwashed by Arafat & Co to rejoice in the misery of the mourners, the IDF delivers a deterrent dose of justice to the murderer's edifice. BTW, Syrian and Jordanian Arabs came to squat in Judea AFTER Jews in 19th Cent. Sorry that this contradicts the propaganda you've been brainwashed under.
@democast I don't know if you know but Arafat has been long dead. But maybe he continues to brainwash out of his grave.
So are you saying that if a Palestinian family has their home demolished for a lack of building permit (which Palestinians rarely ever receive) it is absolutely ok to make them homeless? If demolishing homes is "a deterrent dose of justice to the murderer's edifice" did Yigal Amir's home or that of this parent's get demolished? if not WHY NOT?
@democast But of course they have HaHa, just like any random Jew coming from any random country can simply settle in any part of the Holy Land, while Palestinians can't. That is called democracy I guess.....Israeli style. (Oh please do remind me God gave all the land to the Jews)
I don't expect of you to see reality, how can you when individuals like yourself can only feel sympathy for their own kind
@ExitOnlyEntry Your hypocrisy is galling. You should honor, not deride, Israel for respecting not reciprocally expelling Muslims, as Arabs have Jews. Please show us some of YOUR EMPATHETIC Comments in support of Jews & Christians discriminated against by Arab & Muslim countries! Saudi Arabia is hostile in oppressing Christians & Jews. Muslim countries are hostile to Jews & Israelis. Where are all your Comments denouncing Muslim violence against Coptic Christians in Egypt? Or Nigerian Christians?
@democast oh please don't forget to change the topic. attack based on assumptions about me and my thinking is your best defense?
how merciful Israel truly is for not entirely 'cleansing' its own territory, West Bank and Gaza of Muslims. All of those Muslims should fall on their knees and thank their lords, the Israelis, for being sooooo merciful.
Instead of acting like a 5-year old by making assumptions which are based on no actual knowledge of what I think or feel, why don't you ask me?
@democast but to help you gain insight: I condemn any type of discrimination against any people in any country. Seeing that you absurdly believe Muslims should be grateful to Israel for not being expelled, I will not even ask of you to make the same statement as I just did. Simply because it would not be truthful
P.S.
It would rather polite of you to answer the questions I posed in my comment 3 days ago, instead of so lamely trying to evade it
"Saudi Arabia is hostile in oppressing Christians & Jews."
Wrong. I don't think Saudi Arabia has any Jews, and the few Chrisitans they do have are not allowed to show their religion in public.
Yes, there were millions of Jews in the Arab countries before 1948 and the 50's and 60's, and their land was seized, they were attacked, had pogroms, etc, and fled. Apartheid? Ethnic cleansing? I think so!
@ExitOnlyEntry So, most countries have immigration laws that favor individuals with ethnic ties to these countries. Israel was created as a Jewish state, meaning that Jews have easy access to their ancestral homeland and a haven from persecution, and Israel can maintain a Jewish character. I myself will soon be moving to Israel. Palestinian refugees should be resettled in Arab countries and stop living under the delusion that they will return someday.
@warpedcomedy oh yes that rather silly utopia of ethnically homogeneous nation states. most people in the world have moved on (having learned from the Hitler disaster) and yet there are those comical creatures who still hold onto decadent 19th century nationalistic ideas of tribalism. Including the barbaric idea of 'resettling' people, also known as ETHNIC CLEANSING
Good luck to you, try however not to settle on someone's property
@ExitOnlyEntry Don't you know anything? There are no "Palestinians" - The description was conjured up when Israel became a state to act as propaganda to wage continual war against the Jewish people. Funny that you speak of reality when you are so blind to it. You should focus more on the slaughter of Christians all over the middle east by muslims - but you seem to have mis-placed angst at Israel - the most free and peaceful country in the middle east.....people who think like you dumbfound me
@Y2KCIA of course all those non-Jews living in Israel, West Bank and Gaza are fata morganas. how silly of me not to realize that.
yes let us all focus on some injustices so we can all ignore other injustices. GREAT IDEA! Let us be utterly selective in our sympathies and condemnations.
@ExitOnlyEntry Exactly - when Israel let Hamas take over Gaza - all of those "non-Jews" you speak of suffered great human rights abuses and terror in the hands of your make-believe "Palestinians" - I thought you might show a little more concern....but as all Leftists are - you are a hypocrite and a waste of time. Stay out of these forums that you don't understand and haunt a video that you actually know something about. Your sarcasm and ignorance sickens me. You're in way over your head.
@ExitOnlyEntry I wonder if arabs bow their heads in shame when they shoot missiles at schools and blow themselves up in public squares? Or when they preach violence against Jews all over the world in their mosques? This documentary is too sympathetic to these genocidal arabs - it should have demanded they all leave the West Bank, just as the int' community is demanding Jews stop settling and building in their own city. People will see what they want to see, and you're perfect proof of this
Those "genocidial arabs" you are talking about are they ALL arabs or just some arabs. and those arab mosques all over the world that you say preach hatred against Jews: i hope you know that only 15% of the global Muslim population is Muslim (a clear minority). anyway don't want to sound sympathetic to antisemitism that is actually being preached
so you are a supporter of ETHNIC CLEANSING...how nice, Adolf Hitler would give you a warm hug
@Y2KCIA the international community demands the halt to Israel squatting simply because it is against THE LAW! Can I come into your backyard, set up a tent and simply claim 'this is now mine, you can't stop me living where ever I want'? CAN I? Oh please don*'t answer this with the God-gave-it-to-me bullshit
Can I as a non-Jew move to- lets say -Tel Aviv and simply take someone's house over? yes?
@ExitOnlyEntry
A lot else was bought by Jews.
Still, 6% of the land was owned by Arabs. Well, no one said they had to leave. That was never Ben-Gurion's plan (as he specifically states in a letter to his son Amos, "We must never expell the Arabs and takek their place," commonly twisted by anti-Israel haters to "we must expell"). Jews even accepted partition plan for 2 states. Arabs didn't. Arabs attacked in 1948. Israel won. Israel was born. And again in '67 and '73.
israelawareness1 4 months ago
@ExitOnlyEntry
"Can I as a non-Jew"
If you were a Jew who did that, you'd still get in trouble... Jews and non-Jews are guaranteed equal rights under the law (and seriously, why would I let someone take over my backyard, even if they are a Jew?)
Now, attacking with the intent of destroying other countries is not allowed (ex: Arabs to Israel in 1948, 1967, in 1967 Israel won much territory).
Pre-1948 - British Mandate of Palestine - they can give it to whoever they want. Most vacant.
israelawareness1 4 months ago
They should had expelled all the terrorists from gaza, and all the gaza strip should had been given to this beautiful Jewish community.
ronny585 10 months ago
I wonder do IDF soldiers bow their heads in shame when they demolish homes of Palestinians or make entire Palestinian families homeless?
This documentary is an excellent propaganda piece for all squatter (=Jewish settlers) fans
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@ExitOnlyEntry You have it backwards. If a Muslim perpetrates diabolical violence and mayhem against civilian (including Muslim) women and children within Israel (or Judea or Samaria)- since they've been brainwashed by Arafat & Co to rejoice in the misery of the mourners, the IDF delivers a deterrent dose of justice to the murderer's edifice. BTW, Syrian and Jordanian Arabs came to squat in Judea AFTER Jews in 19th Cent. Sorry that this contradicts the propaganda you've been brainwashed under.
democast 1 year ago
@democast I don't know if you know but Arafat has been long dead. But maybe he continues to brainwash out of his grave.
So are you saying that if a Palestinian family has their home demolished for a lack of building permit (which Palestinians rarely ever receive) it is absolutely ok to make them homeless? If demolishing homes is "a deterrent dose of justice to the murderer's edifice" did Yigal Amir's home or that of this parent's get demolished? if not WHY NOT?
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@democast But of course they have HaHa, just like any random Jew coming from any random country can simply settle in any part of the Holy Land, while Palestinians can't. That is called democracy I guess.....Israeli style. (Oh please do remind me God gave all the land to the Jews)
I don't expect of you to see reality, how can you when individuals like yourself can only feel sympathy for their own kind
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@ExitOnlyEntry Your hypocrisy is galling. You should honor, not deride, Israel for respecting not reciprocally expelling Muslims, as Arabs have Jews. Please show us some of YOUR EMPATHETIC Comments in support of Jews & Christians discriminated against by Arab & Muslim countries! Saudi Arabia is hostile in oppressing Christians & Jews. Muslim countries are hostile to Jews & Israelis. Where are all your Comments denouncing Muslim violence against Coptic Christians in Egypt? Or Nigerian Christians?
democast 1 year ago
@democast oh please don't forget to change the topic. attack based on assumptions about me and my thinking is your best defense?
how merciful Israel truly is for not entirely 'cleansing' its own territory, West Bank and Gaza of Muslims. All of those Muslims should fall on their knees and thank their lords, the Israelis, for being sooooo merciful.
Instead of acting like a 5-year old by making assumptions which are based on no actual knowledge of what I think or feel, why don't you ask me?
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@democast but to help you gain insight: I condemn any type of discrimination against any people in any country. Seeing that you absurdly believe Muslims should be grateful to Israel for not being expelled, I will not even ask of you to make the same statement as I just did. Simply because it would not be truthful
P.S.
It would rather polite of you to answer the questions I posed in my comment 3 days ago, instead of so lamely trying to evade it
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@democast
"Saudi Arabia is hostile in oppressing Christians & Jews."
Wrong. I don't think Saudi Arabia has any Jews, and the few Chrisitans they do have are not allowed to show their religion in public.
Yes, there were millions of Jews in the Arab countries before 1948 and the 50's and 60's, and their land was seized, they were attacked, had pogroms, etc, and fled. Apartheid? Ethnic cleansing? I think so!
Also, don't forget about Yamit.
israelawareness1 4 months ago
@ExitOnlyEntry So, most countries have immigration laws that favor individuals with ethnic ties to these countries. Israel was created as a Jewish state, meaning that Jews have easy access to their ancestral homeland and a haven from persecution, and Israel can maintain a Jewish character. I myself will soon be moving to Israel. Palestinian refugees should be resettled in Arab countries and stop living under the delusion that they will return someday.
warpedcomedy 1 year ago
@warpedcomedy oh yes that rather silly utopia of ethnically homogeneous nation states. most people in the world have moved on (having learned from the Hitler disaster) and yet there are those comical creatures who still hold onto decadent 19th century nationalistic ideas of tribalism. Including the barbaric idea of 'resettling' people, also known as ETHNIC CLEANSING
Good luck to you, try however not to settle on someone's property
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@ExitOnlyEntry Don't you know anything? There are no "Palestinians" - The description was conjured up when Israel became a state to act as propaganda to wage continual war against the Jewish people. Funny that you speak of reality when you are so blind to it. You should focus more on the slaughter of Christians all over the middle east by muslims - but you seem to have mis-placed angst at Israel - the most free and peaceful country in the middle east.....people who think like you dumbfound me
Y2KCIA 1 year ago
@Y2KCIA of course all those non-Jews living in Israel, West Bank and Gaza are fata morganas. how silly of me not to realize that.
yes let us all focus on some injustices so we can all ignore other injustices. GREAT IDEA! Let us be utterly selective in our sympathies and condemnations.
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@ExitOnlyEntry Exactly - when Israel let Hamas take over Gaza - all of those "non-Jews" you speak of suffered great human rights abuses and terror in the hands of your make-believe "Palestinians" - I thought you might show a little more concern....but as all Leftists are - you are a hypocrite and a waste of time. Stay out of these forums that you don't understand and haunt a video that you actually know something about. Your sarcasm and ignorance sickens me. You're in way over your head.
Y2KCIA 1 year ago
@ExitOnlyEntry I wonder if arabs bow their heads in shame when they shoot missiles at schools and blow themselves up in public squares? Or when they preach violence against Jews all over the world in their mosques? This documentary is too sympathetic to these genocidal arabs - it should have demanded they all leave the West Bank, just as the int' community is demanding Jews stop settling and building in their own city. People will see what they want to see, and you're perfect proof of this
Y2KCIA 1 year ago
@Y2KCIA why don't you ask them?
Those "genocidial arabs" you are talking about are they ALL arabs or just some arabs. and those arab mosques all over the world that you say preach hatred against Jews: i hope you know that only 15% of the global Muslim population is Muslim (a clear minority). anyway don't want to sound sympathetic to antisemitism that is actually being preached
so you are a supporter of ETHNIC CLEANSING...how nice, Adolf Hitler would give you a warm hug
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago
@Y2KCIA the international community demands the halt to Israel squatting simply because it is against THE LAW! Can I come into your backyard, set up a tent and simply claim 'this is now mine, you can't stop me living where ever I want'? CAN I? Oh please don*'t answer this with the God-gave-it-to-me bullshit
Can I as a non-Jew move to- lets say -Tel Aviv and simply take someone's house over? yes?
ExitOnlyEntry 1 year ago