Added: 5 years ago
From: stevids
Views: 53,704
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (53)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • Although this is not what Leiber ans Stoller intended it's supposed to be a different, blusey treatment of this song. and it works very well. There are some serious imbeciles on YouTube. Anyone thinking Elkie Brooks is a 'trash vocalist' are clueless beyond words. (Shakes head).

  • @m06een00 This was taken from Elkie's album "Two Days Away" which was produced by Lieber & Stoller. I feel this IS very much what was intended.Elkie vocals are and have always been superb.

  • This is truly terrible; no tune, no rhythm and Brooks getting only half-hearted support from the band and backing singers who, I strongly suspect, know how bad it is. An ill-judged and unpleasant cover of this great song.

  • @ArchieRoylance

    Hmm, I don´t know. I think the band wanted to stay cool and give her the space. On the other hand the song obviously doesnt work.

  • @anonymusum The song does sooooo work. Great version.

  • @ArchieRoylance A great version and judged very well by the producers " Lieber & Stoller" Elkie Brooks has a GREAT voice'

  • This is a GREAT version. As usual there are some stupid people, that think they are music critics beyond approach. So SAD. They need to get a life.

  • What you need is stayin' away from this song. She couldn't even re-write the lyrics (as she's a woman, the word "chicks" had ta be modified) she put an extra (and really poor) line in This song (the original) is one of the rare tunes that mad complete sense & told a funny story in the '60s.Where's the copper from the story y'know the punch-line! And she made those guys singing this fuckin' "gonna give my man some love potion # 9" ... pathetic vocalists and trash cover! POMY COLLINGWOOD

  • @PomyCollingwood You are one deaf person ,Elkie Brooks is a GREAT vocalist.

  • @PomyCollingwood Leiber & Stoller rewrote the lyrics, it was their production. Guess you don't know who they are, as you seem to know little or nothing about music.

  • @Eamonn20a

    No matter who did the "new" lyrics, Stoller & Lieber might be great musicians but they smelled dough so they did this cover. It is really poor, still I say and about your remark: I do know my music and I have a nice deal of information of the inside-of-music-creating-and-s­elling it does not save U or this production! The hell with it and U as well!

    POMY COLLINGWOOD

  • Comment removed

  • i pity the poor drummer looking at that arse all night

  • @45ltr I bet some drummers would like to be in his place.

  • believe it or not I actually remember seeing this Sight & Sound concert on TV at the time (I was 9 in 1977). I remember it being on past my bedtime and sneakily watching it while half hiding behind the living room door. I also remember Elkie making me feel a bit strange ...it must have been that jump suit!!

  • Peerless !

  • saw her a coupla months ago...dress sense is horrendous (miaow) but boy...the voice is still amazing!!! Second spot was quite bluesy...for me..that's the style she does best!!! This lady survives the passage of time...terrific!!!

  • anyboby dont give five stars is a

  • Cool version!:)*****

  • My favorite " Elkie ",

    Thanks Steve,

  • XD XD xD XD

  • she didnt mean it that way .. BUT..

    her opening remark is right on!

  • You agree with who? This sounds Great. Awesome. From the Two Days Away album. Produced by the legendary Lieber and Stoller.

  • Elkie Brooks is the bomb!! I've loved her for years and years.. I saw her in concert in Dublin years ago and when I came to the states I couldn't get any albums of hers no one knew who she was. Thank god for Itunes and Youtube!! Yay Elkie!

  • Going to see ELKIE in Dublin, in May. Should be a good gig....

  • Here's another pale chick doing black music in the blackest way. Etta, calm down. This is fantastic music. ;-)

  • Wow! really cool version!

  • I saw Elkie preform this 2 days ago and met her backstage. She's got a good voice but blues songs arnt really my cup of tea.

  • If you had the great fortune to meet the wonderful Elkie (I wish I had) then you should show a little more respect.  Perhaps you should stick to Britney!

  • elkreborn I agree with you. feel the music sounds a bit sad to me. Going back stage to meet the artist and then to make negative comments SAD..

  • I saw Elkie live with robert palmer in vinegar joe many years ago in sunderland

    ghreat band too

  • great singer.

  • she sounds hot!!!!

  • The production for Elkies version of the song was by the actual writers, the great Lieber and Stoller partnership. So if its OK for them its OK for me.

  • I saw Elkie sing this last week in Leeds.............. She still sings it as good as she did all those years ago. She is still an awesome singer

  • Carma, dont get annoyed, just dont listen. Elkie has a GREAT voice. To appreciate her voice one has to really understand music..

  • I never said her voice was bad. Its the type of music that i don't like. And i do beleive i am aloud to have an opinion, i never said this type was bad and sucked and should be banned from stores, i know people like it. I am merely stating my opinion that i personally don't like it.

  • @carma don't you think this is incredibly sexy? Admittedly she isn't shaking her arse at 100mph shouting 'look at my booty', but this is the song you want to get it on to

  • Elkie Brooks, one of the best rock/blues/jazz singers ever.

  • flusem666.I totally agree Elkie is one of the best singers around. Much loved also by other singers

  • Seen Elkie 4 times live & she's awesome.

  • Not bad...but she sang this with much raspier, gutsier soul on the album Two Days Away. Also nice on that Lp were "Honey, CanI Put On Your Clothes" and "Spiritland."

  • YES, great tracks from Two Days Away, by Elkie.Elkie is still touring and sound better than ever.

  • Shame this one was edited out of the BBC Sight and Sound half hour concert last week. The original 1977 show was an hour long with 14 songs not just the 8 of last week

  • This for me is the best version of this song.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more