Added: 2 years ago
From: indymogul
Views: 44,851
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (455)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Okay

  • I hated the use of handheld digital camera in this film!!! I could totally tell the whole time, and it took me right out of the movie! I could go into great detail on the subject of why I believe film is much better, but I won't! All I'll say is that I like my movies to look like movies, not like crappy t.v. reality shows or independent documentaries! For me, it kinda ruins most of the action scenes, which I think would've looked phenomenal if they'd been filmed in more traditional ways!

  • Did anyone else find themselves slowly moving away from the screen when she started shouting at us.

  • way to interview the stupidest people

  • well i enjoyed the drama , my fav. ganster Public Enemy No. 1

  • 'Yes'

    'Oh how so?'

    'When um, they was running through the woods'....

    Round of applause for that guy...

  • I fucking loved this film :)

  • I really enjoyed this film. Both Johnny Depp and Christian Bale were great in it. Not only was the story great but I really enjoyed the way they filmed it. I agree that it's pretty long but that doesn't take away from the film. It still feels like a fast-paced movie at times due to the acting and crime scenes. Another movie, Viva Riva, is similar in that nature. I actually really liked Viva Riva, and think you should do a review of it. vivarivamovie. com

  • that THING'S voice irritates me -_-

  • Indy Mogul please can you make a m4 carbine i will aprechiate it if you can

    also please could you make a video on how to make fake bullets and muzzle flashes andsound effects

    Thanks

    bart7478

  • @dopeandkorn so I'm off ten years, nothin happened in a decade, :D

  • I heard a lot of negative shit about this movie then I actually got round to watching it.I thought it was first rate, great performances all round especially from Depp as John Dillinger and Cotilliard as the love interest.Mann got the feel and look of the era just right and delivered a cracking movie.

  • @TheLegoTube1

    michael mann sold out history in order to make an action movie. there story of what actually happened was changed. not to add drama. not to make a the story tie up easier. but to make a movie centered on shootouts.

    that would be understandable if michael bay did it (like he did with pearl harbor) or john woo.

    but this is michael mann.

  • this movie sucks! i rather be kicked in the balls that watching this shit again.

  • @jeermarff that could be arranged.

  • dicaprio was suppose to play dillinger

  • johnny depp was not a good pick

  • shes anoing as shit...

    

  • I hated public enemies to long and no speed in it

  • I destroy my enemies when I make them my friends

  • Your reviews are fucking awsome! Good job :)

  • THIS MOVIE IS ONE OF THE BIGGEST CRAP EVER !!!

  • id have to give it a near 10/10. its pretty amazing and johnny depp did an awesome job :)

  • Yes. Coultilliard was pretty good. She was excellent in La Vie en Rose, won best actress.

  • Ps...This announcer doesn't bother me, at all. I've heard way worse. I think she's just being good natured and trying to stay uninvolved. If you can't do better, then WTF? Ps: "Johnny Depp wears Dillingers ACTUAL pants...and, they fit! If you want more historical accuracy than that, well, then, you're just, too damn picky"...Ha...so, there...

  • Christian Bale and Johnny Depp were both really good in this movie.

  • Jesus... the way this woman talks and her facial expressions are annoying as hell! 

  • I'm gonna get both haters and lovers for stating my oppinion: One thing that could make this better is having Jeremy Davies as Melvin Pervus. Check the pictures of Pervus and Davies and compare. Please comment. I'm interested.

  • @DonnieDaniels Ok...as Christian Bale's possible biggest fan, ever...I still gotta check out your theory, cuz, I adore Jeremy Davies, as well...Wow...ok, you're right...wouldn't want to put Christian out of a job, ever, or, anything...eeh...but, I love everything Jeremy does, and he could have done this part, immaculately, for sure...minus hand gestures, of course....good (casting) call...

  • @moremoxi Thank you. It's what I live for.

  • #CUTE Zero Cost Movies . com #OMG - it's free here

  • Johnny Depp ROCKS!!!!!

  • this movie is badass

  • More like pubic enemies, lol XD

  • Woah .. this blew me away. Btw.. its online at Full Movie World . com

  • omg i hate this bitch hate uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuu i hope u will die tomorow

  • Looked *everywhere* for this but only found one site that had a good version. it's Ace Free Movies . com

  • very good movie.acting was great,

  • god this movie was disappointing

  • damm that girl is enoying with all her ohhhhs and ahhhhs

  • You don't shoot a period piece on digital!

  • one of the best movies ever.

    best quote: "everything. right now."

  • That woman has a goofy voice, lol

  • Great movie,much bette than other summer movies that are childrem movies,like harry potter,fuck harry potter!!!

  • Grace dislike it this movie,she prefers dumb children blockbuster mvoies like harry potter and animated movies,sad but true.........

  • This was a bad ass movie. That girl is kind of weird, but I would bang in the bed room lol.

  • this movie is pretty boring. i didn't like it, i was disappointed by the acting and the editing. just turned out to be lame. i walked out the movies.

  • I'm not big into these type of movies..but wow I actually like this one :) I liked the view from the bad guys point haha.

  • Those people saying it's too long, or something else was not so good, then they should go fuck em selfs. The movie is great, i've watched it over 20 times now, i'm jsut so fuckin obssessed with it. Because it's John Dillingers role. and he was a legend

  • 9.5/10

  • public enimies is a slightly long yet entertaining and over all a great experience to watch.

  • Bets Movie Ever :D 10/10

  • It's only 2 hrs. and 20 minutes-not that long. Be patient people.

  • He even wears his pants????!!!!

  • absolutely awesome movie 10/10

  • Not the first time Leo was down to be in a film Bale was in, only to drop out. Shutter Island looks good and Public Enemies was AMAZING.

  • dvd

  • I loved that movie so much and of course i would give it a ten.

  • i give it a 10

  • Man, I gotta move to NY. Miss Randolph is a fox!

    Mrrraaoow!

  • 'Little bit more real, less gay' lols

  • I like the font and the movie was horrible plus the video camera they used was really different and pretty much that ruined the movie. Also this film was shot kind of where I live.

  • stupid bitch. male driven movie?

    it's about a gang of fucking gangsters in the 1940's!!! what do you expect!?

  • The 1920's to 30's actualy seeing as Dillinger was killed in 1934... still, there "were" some pretty screwed up women back then too...

    Ma Baker (head of a gangster family,) Myra Hindley (Child Killer,) Bonnie Parker (Bank Robber,) Belle Starr (Female outlaw,) Ruth Ellis....

    Plenty more of em probably

  • @Erulin68 didn't know that O_o..

  • @mikepyro713 Male driven..hooray!! ...if the 'males' in question are awesome as Bale and Depp!! In my opinion, however, at times, little known Marion Colliard almost stole this whole damn film...as much as I love you, boys, seriously...think about it...she tore it up, in every scene she was in...

  • @mikepyro713 well Idk what the fuck was wrong with her but I love tis movie I dont think its male driven just fucking badass :)

  • o god i cant hold it in, why is this a must see in theaters movie? why o why i bootlegged it and im glad i did cause it was a waste of time i get more excitement from dc's new movies and im sorry there not just for kids, i bet you would let depp have his way with you manhood if hollywood said so

  • I'll try man but i doubt its still on

  • HOLY SHIT A NEW FONT!!!!

  • I love this movie so far it is on top of my favorites this year

  • i tried gettin in and im 14 but i got caught the movie's a 15 over here in the uk but I'll get the dvd when it comes out!

  • FAVORITE MOVIE!!! :) 10 STARS!

    movie was a new twist on a classic love story, between a poor girl and a ganster.

  • wow your so wrong, yah if this were ment to be a love story i wasnt told i was told this was an action gangster movie and i was on of the first 10k to watch it as i got the screener crap crap craptastic liked titantic better as it didnt lie about being a love story

  • its was good, long, but awsome

  • sad that most people prefer to watch gay movies like harry poter and dislike this movie that is great,fuck children summer movies

  • i dont understand why people r saying this is good movie

    it is just piece of crap of marketing movie

    i was getting a headache while i was watcing it . only great point is it is based on true story.

  • go watch harry poter motherfucker,people who like children movies hates this one,this movie is great

  • no people who like gangster movies hate this because it is crap lies all lies dillenger was a badass american icon nothing depp can protray o and dose anyone who is redueing alice in wonderland?

    i bet you like anything hollywood feeds you save kid movies o and lets compare harry potter about a wizard and child plot wizard grows to be a man,

  • now public enemies depp breaks out of a fictional prison with fictional cronies they commence to rob banks and be one women men yah there isnt much bank robbing as there is way to much love making dillenger was a free man for only 1 year and they expect us to beleve he was a one woman man i can say that with out laughing dilllinger was a public icon this movie dosnt even represent

  • that properily he did so much in his 1 free year this is nothing but a joke compared to the actually life of jhon dillenger if you like this movie you have no sence of true history dillinger was a badass and in no way was that protrayed

  • johnny depp = incredible

  • well... its maybe because u dont like depp.

  • buy yourself a brain

  • Too gory, really violent, while not being appropriate for kids, it's not at all appropriate for adults either. It isn't for many people. Leonardo, Leonardo. what have you done? I bet Sherlock Holmes will be better.

  • lolwtf

    why would you take your kids to a gangster movie?

  • im 13 and i went 2 see it

  • I just don't think people should critique a movie based on it's rating. If it's rated R, don't take your kids. It's that simple.

  • i bet you liked it as hollwood tells you to like it

  • The movie was great 100/10

  • Miss Indyfilm Babe,

    I love you.

  • i loved the movie but Dillinger is too likeable to be an interesting gangster(he's not really menacing) and the movie is too focused on Dillinger.

    Purvis is interesting as "pitbull in a suit" tortured but we didn't see him many times in screen.

    Frechette is charming but Cotillard hasn't many thing to act

    The movie is very stylish and i like that

  • ahhh amazing movie i love it...can watch it over and over i love it just love it

  • I didnt like some of the camera work, more specifically during the fight scene at that hotel/bar thing.

  • I don't get why people are giving this movie bad reviews? I thought it was amazing and Johnny Depp was amazing as usual. Does anyone know why it is getting bad reviews??

  • because it was completely average and the acting cant save a boring film

  • because people are stupid

  • but im pissed John doesnt get back at that fat ass for smackin the fuck outa his girl!

  • i though that it was a gooood movie,i kinda cried at the end! Johnny Depp is sooooooo hot! and there deff.shoulda been a better sex scene

  • i know its good...

  • This movie doesn't hide the fact it uses a HD digital camera to film its scenes. Honestly, at one point of the movie, I thought I was watching a badly calibrated Blu-Ray movie from Best Buy. It was really hurting to the eyes.

    Also, The movie moved ever so slowly. So many scenes were extremely unnecessary, but were just put in to increase run time and fool people into thinking this movie was going to be epic. This film was insanely screaming "Oscar, Oscar" for all the wrong reasons.

  • "It could have been filmed this day. . .", well y'know, other than the thompson submachineguns and old school fords, you really don't see too many of those on the streets, as well as the levels of security in banks. . .

  • The trailer doesn't really fit the movie...

  • Something else i would like to add about the movie, is that in real life, their were several very exciting and cool fight scenes that the director left out in the movie.

    also, several things in the movie were made up, such as when baby face nelsons dies when they are at the motel. in reality, Nelson survived this fight, and lived for a little over a year later. again , sorry for the negativity, 1/5 stars

  • Im sorry but u would not reccomend this movie for several reasons.

    For one, it has a very slow plot, and when you get to the fighting scenes, it is hard to understand what is going on due to the odd filming, and bad lighting.

    Secondly, Their are way too many characters blatantly introduced, and then u are expected to know who they are by name.

    and thirdly, i have read the biography this movie is based off of, and it is disgusting how inaccurate it is. im sorry johnny depp.

    1/5 stars

  • it's historical. you're expected to know basic american history/pop culture.

  • I know! Johnny Depp doesn't even look like Dillinger. He's only in here to make people have a reason to watch the movie otherwise no one would see this awful film.

    The bad lighting was due to the digital video used to film the movie. Bad decision on that.

  • i need to know why its raded R ... my mom wont let me see it if its got a sex seen v.v .... yah

  • their is no sex scene in it, it jsut has some bloody sequences in it.

  • hahaha.

  • hey.. my mom wass the same. but after we saw it she agreed that its not that bad. Theres only one sex scene, but they r clothed. go to imdb and look at the parental advisory,. but over all its mainly just very violent.

  • oh ok :P

  • lol, i like her shirt: public frenemy ^.^

  • 6/10

    This movie's kinda like "Valkyrie", too much talk

  • i loked johnny depp, but the movie was not told to well. i really hated the filming style with the HD instead of film. it really pissed me off at the begining, with the shaky and odd style of filming

  • The style was as similar to a badly calibrated Blu-Ray movie from Best Buy.

  • the movie shooting scenes were to dark, couldnt see

  • what is that song when there gonig into the bank 0:03

  • 9/10

  • 8.5/10 Like everyone says its slow. but I didnt mind. the shooting scenes were really good. Johnny Depp played it well. and The guy who played baby face nelson was good also.

  • 90/10

    Awesome.

    Hot.

    Sexy.

    Oh wait, I was talking about johnny...

    hahahaha :)

  • they made one of public enemies but what about the private enemies?

  • 8.5/10 good but a little too slow.

  • It was like a documentary but at the same time, not as crappy. It seemed very cool, calm, but definitely not Batman good.

  • I have not seen the movie yet, but I know it will be good because it has Johnny 7/10.

  • I give the font 50/10

  • Worth a one time watch at the least. (especially at an AMC theatre!)

  • i very much so enjoyed this film, the actors were fantastic, which didnt suprise me coming from such a great cast. they should have used film, but it was still good

  • wat you could hear wat he said in the movie

  • lol, as a follow up to my previous comment - they just explained why the film looked like that. (I typed my comment before watching all the video). Yes, it is fairly noticeable that they didn't film with film.

  • 7/10 - entertaining, but I wouldn't want to see it again. Also, did anyone else notice the varying framerate? At points it was super smooth like live TV, and at others it was the normal 24fps.

  • Yeah I noticed that aswell.

  • Good movie, i just think it all happened too fast...and i just dont like Mann's way of directing, nice soundtrack, the action was great too..also, where can i get that font?

    7/10

  • the hd video explains the wierd look

  • made it look like a history channel special

  • This is exactly how I explain the look to other people lol

  • one hott gangster bioflick that's definitely got major legs, give it a 9, tho it's gonna take the general public a minute to find out (go figure!)

  • you can tell it is shot on digital through tracking blur and alternating frame rates.

  • Effectively stylized, and shot beautifully shot on digital.

    7/10

  • Hmm, pretty much action and gangster stuff, but really kinda long, but at least soundtrack was good.

    8/10

  • how the hell am i supposed to write a serious one sentence review without that masculine and unmovable text?!?!?

  • hahaha at first I thought that guy was describing--vulgarly--what was wrong with the end. then I realized "oh he was spoiling it" x]

  • was a good movie, like hollywood use to

    make without a lot of the cartoonish

    computer effects like transformers which sucked need to put that to rest adults go see it all the young folks are to busy texting or staring at there cell phone to appreciate or understand a thinking movie

  • eh... didn't live up to my expectations. and the HD looked like late night programing on PBS rather than a hollywood movie. 6/10

  • 1

    somehow a bunch of talented people managed to make john dillinger's life boring with horrible cinematography all in the name of cinema verite.

  • bad movie bad ending

  • that's life

  • This movie was terrible at best.

    "Public Enemies" is yet another uninspired, digital/film romp; led by Michael Mann, a clueless film director lost without a compass.

    The film was all over the place. The score was atrocious. And the writing was incredibly half-assed.

    8 people walked out of the theatre. Who cares if the film is historically accurate, it's still not interesting.

    I enjoyed this movie the first time, when it was called, "Dillinger."

  • The Movie was great. I would give the movie a 8/10.

    Reasoning: The Film depicted about as close to gang life back then, acting good, great gun replicas, and effects, but longer than should be.

  • I lovedddd ittt, i'd give it a 9.5!! And damn johnny depp looked hott as an outlaw haha.!

  • 8.5

    Story was great, the action was great, the acting was awesome,The sound was great for the gun scenes, just dragged a tiny bit,but still was a great movie.

  • johnny depp

    marceloezequiel1

  • Close but no cigar.

  • 10 if not that then an 11, so essentially a 10.5

    I didn't care to see the movie but I'm surprised that I how much I enjoyed a historical film and that's because it has good character development for this American Robin Hood and the filming techniques gave it a sense of old school moving pictures while making it crisper and richer in quality and realism.

  • The filming, editing, set direction, costuming, were excellent. The acting was excellent. The screen play....hmmm. It went too quickly to the chase of Dillinger. There was little if any character development. The viewer could not truly relate, care or sympathize with and about the characters, with exception of Dillinger and Billie, and that was just barely. This film could have been SO much better. But it did move along well, and Johnny was perfection.

  • It was very good

    I'd give it a 9/10

    It was very exciting.

    It dragged a little bit but I didn't mind.

  • hey why can't i post my comment in new deal !?

    I can't wait to see it, next to inglourious bastards (which i saw already) it will be my favorite movie the summer besides al the other cool movies

  • guys,  were is High Definition

  • Nice episode grace, what a find, bumping in to a suporting actor comming out the cinimar, or was it all planned?

  • Totally random! He was there to buy tickets for the evening show to take his mother - very cool to get to talk to him. :)

  • brilliant film to long for you average audients

    comparable with films like

    watch man

    just to long films should only be 2 hr. to explain a signal story line

    Films like lord of the rings are exceptions because the plot lines is easy to understand from the beginning

    For the rest I most say that this Jonny Deep acted amazingly something you can expect from someone like J.D. The scenery was magnificent

  • loved it, but a little shaky at the start

  • The film was exciting, sad, full of twists and simply great.

    9/10

  • worst movie of the summer sucked othing happened johnny depp and christian bale were terrible and it was long and boring i would rather give my grandma a sponge bath then watch ths movie again

  • It was a good movie 8/10

    It wasn't the most solid movie in the world, but I liked it.

  • Is this movie to innapropriate to take an 12 year old to?

  • yes it is

  • How about a Teen? (13)

  • no, unless ur worried about blood. there's also a sex scene, but neither one is naked. nobody says fuck either

  • besides the gangster action(somtimes quite bloody) it doesnt have alot bad language (it say the f-word 1 time but in a way it was needed) but if you can let those 2 slip it was a really good movie

  • I love johnny depp's work  this was not that good 4/10

  • solid 10/10

    Godfather maybe the Kubrick of gangster flicks but Public enemies makes a shocking comeback and shows that the mafia still exists in cinema

  • @Teixeirapictures

    I don't think John Dillinger was part of the Mafia... he just robbed banks.

  • acutualy he is slightly. bank robery is gust a crime to get money. He was in a crime gang with Floyd and Nelson.

    actualy your right. I wrote it wrong. He was a gangster not in the mafia because mafia is a family buisness

  • I'd say this movie is more of a very unsolid, smelly 0/10

    also this had nothing to do with the mafia, and im curious, how is godfather the kubrick of gangsta flicks? kubrick was a recluse...??

  • I said I made a typeo. I didn't mean mafia I meant gangster. I wrote mafia to keep it away from the gangstas today.

    The kubrick thing, its an expresion. Godfather was the king of gangster flicks, no doubt about it.

  • I see ur point, my bad