Helloween - A tale that wasn't right (live in Sao Paulo)

[kwagung]

AMAZING voice of ANDI DERIS, rhythmic than kiske...!

[kwagung]

for Matin99SG, youve just 12 years old but i think u have power metal soul, awesome...i agree if rock music like HELLOWEEN and any others will never die till a hundreds years...this is an legend and will be a legendary. viva power metal!

[bigju666]

Best version of this song

[lizrolon17]

I love the song!

[MrHetfield24]

Fucking Amazing :o

[SkuldBR]

13 ppl will sleep alone tonight... so sad....

[alvaro34687]

michael era mt melhor q esse andy

n crt mais hoje em diaaaa

[SkuldBR]

@alvaro34687 Estilos diferentes. Andi é um puta vocalista, um puta frontman pro Helloween, além de ser um dos compositores dos principais sucessos da banda. Sinceramente, Kiske não faz falta nenhuma. Se gosta tanto dele vai ouvir os trabalhos do cara. Ele ainda canta, mas não é mais metal. Últimos trabalhos que vi dele são legais, gravou um album com Amanda Sommerville. Da pra ver que o cara ainda tem uma voz excelente. Mas sinceramente eu gosto muito mais do Helloween com o Deris.

[nyamar]

he sings from the heart

[puckoster]

kiske may be kiske, but deris really puts his soul into this performance, which is epic in my opinion.

[Matin99SG]

This gets less than 200,000 views while Justin Biebs got 580,000,000 in just one song! Wth! His music isn't great at all! What is wrong with the new world and their media! I'm 12 and LOVE rock! Hopefully ROCK DOESN'T DIE!

[woerink]

@Matin99SG I'd die before Rock dies. Life without rock isn't meant to be lived.

[mettall1981]

@Matin99SG Don't worry, Metal Will always live on. JB is just a flash in the pan. 10 years from now JB will be just a faded dream. He is supported by millions of 13 year old girls who will mature and will find something more mature to listen to. So Matin99SG you have nothing to worry about. Metal has been around before JB and wil most definitely be around when he has faded into the wax.

[sidewwinder]

Fuckin great!!!

[serega334]

супер

[fabiokorg]

realmente odio pagar con estas cosas me encanta este tema

[liodhan]

dammn....=)

[parazitofparadise]

BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­

[BirdIsTheWord89]

Who cares about 'who sang it better', this is epic regardless so shut the fuck up and appreciate.

[DestroyeR7904]

Both did it great,really.You can never sing it perfect,everyone sings it from one's own heart,that's why the song changes from one person to another.But I'[m still left speechless by the song.It's just perfect..Maybe it's just because I'm one of those living dead.I'm rather young,"...but the only thing I feel is pain"(c)

[anapofasistos123]

10 people thought the tale WAS right!

[erol12345]

enough of kiske deris shit as enough of metallica megadeth and all other poser shits. just grow the fuck up. kiske was great but he was 80s deris is awesome and he is pretty 902s. I wished that kiske could have done better after he depated from helloween. because I really like his voice. but it didnt happend accept the freaking reality that helooween is way better and way more succesfull with deris guy.

[KRUSHERN]

fucking badass,,UP THE IRONS

[Misteriuna]

This melody is great and the voice is very nice, very very exciting.

[Victorianiusis]

He is very good!!!!!

The voice is exciting.

[PerfectHeroBand]

Deris Truly Delivers on this Live Version:) Thanks for posting...

[TheRockapak1]

@adiwid.Thanks a lot for the info bro.Kiske is still alive after all.I only knew that he's been featured in a lot of other band's works.Well in that case i sincerely hope Kiiske has a succesful new beginning with Unisonic.Hamsen as their new guitarist?Kiske+Hansen=A heavenly combo i guess...;-)

[douninio]

Great performance but this video is from Bulgaria...

[TheRockapak1]

Helloween died in 1993 BUT only to be reborn again to be a much,much better band in all aspect thanks to this Perfect Gentleman by the name of Andi Deris.If u still think that Micheal Kiske is your hero well then what can i say?Keep living in the past people.Anyway where is your so called hero now?Is he gonna come out to answer all your prayers?I dont think so.Hansen is doing great with Gamma Ray but Kiske?What happens to the guy that i used to love and respect?

[adiwild]

@TheRockapak1 You don't follow any metal news? Kai Hansen is the new guitarist in Kiske's band Unisonic and they play heavy metal. The new Unisonic album will be ready by the end of this year. By the way - I love how Andi Deris fits in Helloween, he is awsome.

[miraperlin]

Kiske is better !

[wtglb]

I like Deris a lot better, he has more character to his voice, can sing in different styles and shows more emotion- and he is hands-down a better showman.

I have listened alot to early Helloween and I don't know what all the fuss is about Kiske, and while he's not a bad singer, I just can't listen to too much of that falsetto shouting, to me that's not metal vocals

[METALPENNIS]

#1 ""HELLOWEEN""-A THALE THAT WASN´T RIGHT - Y COMO NO SEÑORES EL NUMERO UNO REY DE REYES ESTE CUENTO QUE NO ESTABA BIEN ES PERFECTO"" TODA LA GAMA DE HELLOWEEN DESDE HANSEN , KISKE , Y AHORA ANDY DERIS ES LA MER BANDA LE PESE A QUEIN LE PESE SU MAJESTAD EN MIS MEMORIAS SIEMPRE ESTARAS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11111111111111­11111111

[StraightEdgeSavi0r66]

Haters gonna Hatin. Hansen, Kiske and Deris, all made or make a good Job. Dont cry, just listen. Deris have an Awesome Voice, Kiske had one too. And Kai have good one too. I like all Helloween Album (Yes, the Unarmed too) and If you say Deris Sucks, you just are Fanboys. What would Helloweeen be with Kiske now? A Country Band. With Deris helloween stepped out of the shadow and blow the speakers down. I dont want to tell you what you have to like, but Deris isnt bad, just give him a chance.

[GiannisKJ19]

andi "crap" deris...helloween without kiske and hansen are nothing..they don't even exist any more as a metal band...deris you are killing that great song...just quit from helloween...

[anapofasistos123]

Don't blame those who disliked the song. They just never ever ever were sad in their lives!

[drakonimetal]

I fell in love with the girl in 2:39.

[paul44miles]

Another Spectacular performance by Helloween.

[DARCHITEK]

Powerful! absolutely incredible! makes me emotional

[tobbol]

Doesn´t like his " sle he he hep tonight.

[Diablita2110]

Andy`s voice is just perfect for helloween...Soon I´ll go to the concert in colombia...Love helloween

[erol12345]

grow a fucking little. and tear down those prejudices in your brains. accept the fact that deris took this song to a higher level. thanks to him and his brillant voice.

[AZMETALERO]

esta la canta bien para kiske le rompe el culo a deris

[elninjacopia99]

@AZMETALERO por dios deris la interpreta muy bien y le suena excelente , siempre con la misma bobada de quien es mejor , ambas eras por asi decirlo o epocas son excelentes y antes debemos agradecer que tenemos helloween , ademas nocaiga en el error de decir que si kiske te gusta mas deris sea malo eso lo haria un niñato sin fender, en cambio ponga a cantar paint a new world, are you metal, etc kiske no lo haria igual, mejor digan helloween es grande y siempre lo sera 7 sinners excelente album

[9ANDRA9]

To jest Niesamowite . ! ! ! ! ! ! < 333

[tickas007]

deris rules<!!

[dethNiCk]

Brazil has the best live concerts!

[yourmegadaddy]

all kiske lovers go listen to Unisonic and stop listening to Helloween!!!

[jepgmetal]

this guy really souldnt try to sing any song that was sung by kiske he just doesnt cut it!!

[Bablumar]

@jepgmetal You kiddin me? He does a great job on this one. And his voice fits this song perfectly. He might not be able to do it in original key, but this sounds awesome. pfft.

[jepgmetal]

@Bablumar i respect your opinion but i think its all about likes and to me singing this song at that note... its just no good but if you like it thumbs up after all its metal for the sake of metal!! xD

[Bablumar]

@jepgmetal True. Deris is metal times 20. hehe ;3

[naaqacr]

de putamare esta baina....

[sonnic1995]

lets make a deal...deris can you just sing this one...and stop singning the other keeper songs

[666Sleepwalker666]

Haters gonna haaate!

[farfallina132]

agree, andreas wins!

[johnmatzakos]

Andi Deris has a great performance in this great song. Also Kiske has great voice one of the best metal voices. But I prefer Hellowwen with Deris. Two words we can say for Helloween: "JUST GREAT".

[ikkaku01]

@johnmatzakos the difference isn't only Kiske, but also the Hansen absence..

I think he is a Power metal genius..i love both version of Helloween, but the first one is my favourite band in all time!

[ikkaku01]

Normally i don't like deris in kiske song, but this one is a great version!!

[farfallina132]

kiske, don't even think about it!

[GuilhermeMilner]

Please, PLEASE Kiske.. Come back!

[Bapfel]

THANK YOU! Finally a good video of this song.

[thoule204]

7 persons have no life.

[Tabessa11]

hey dude great video, just an observation mate, this video is from bulgaria not from brazil, but anyway, great and thanks!

[puckoster]

@Tabessa11: this is actually from São Paulo (you can see the cap in Brasilian colors on the mascott's head at the beginning), only alternate views of this video are from Sofia.

Touching track, awesome atmosphere.

[Edea161090]

brazilian fans look awesome at every rock show..

[MetalWarrior95]

7 Kiske fagboys that hate Deris dislike this :/

ooh c'mon I'm a great fan of Helloween-Kiske ERA!

but Deris is a kickass singer!!!

LONG LIVE TO HELLOWEEN!!

[gabrielcapixaba]

porra essa música é muuuito irada!!!

[navsaja]

7 persons whose dislike must die!!!

[333halfdevil1]

7 dislike?????????

Fuck you all.

[bigju666]

2:40 oh yea!

[tammysyl]

This version is NOT bad!  Andi will never be Michael, conversely, Michael will never be Andi! So the matter`s settled!

[bqpetrucci]

kiske is great but but i like deris version of this song than kiske

[Oliver23142]

DERIS is better than KISKE on this song.

[bqpetrucci]

DERIS IS REALLY GREAT :x:X:X

[ilovethefukingmetal]

final version is even better with Michael Kiske!!

[dkkpa]

One of the best ballads ever.......Respect from Greece!

[MrSam2901]

Pas de vitalité. Une telle magnifique chanson. Pas la pêche. J'en pleure.

[guitarshism]

hmmmm I like deris songs but i dont like it when he does kiske or hansen....It doesn't work for me.

[namdancer]

tuyet voi

[badboi002]

This is bull$hit!!!! one of the best song of all time and there's only 104,164 views....In my heart ,in my soul i really hate to pay this toll....Should be strong young and bold, but the only thing i feel is pain...It's alright well stay friends!!!!!

[Froizon]

@badboi002

This is because the most of the people prefer to listen this song with KISKE on vocals

[stavrospyriflegethon]

AVE DERIS!!!!! 

[Sirius13jhp]

I can not stop listening this song is just great!!! and for some reason with deris is more depressing

[Sirius13jhp]

With Deris is like with more feeling ....I love helloween i do not care about the singer

[3nderoX]

@Sirius13jhp I'm just glad they got a singer that has talent didn't want kai and kiske replaced by someone who sucks...

[tsigkelo]

weikath god

[skatetothedeth]

If theres one Kiske era song that Deris totally ownes, ITS THIS!

[021Sweden]

@skatetothedeth i totally agree, kiske is a god but the way deris preforms this one blows my mind, the chorus is beyond epic, it makes the hair in the back of my neck stand !!

[Redshiftnow]

It's wrong to expect Deris to be Kiske. If Deris had sung the original people would complain about how Kiske sang it.

What's important is that the song is great and both singers do it justice in their own way. As for this particular rendition, I think Andi stamped his personality on it and pulled it off magnificently.

Fittingly, he put his heart and soul into it - and it shows.

There's not a perfect way to sing a song. Halford changes how he sings Beyond the Realms of Death on every tour.

[Sirius13jhp]

@Redshiftnow exactly i am totally agree with you....the way he sing it is great!!!!

[himoJ]

@Redshiftnow thats not true man... Deris sings veeeeeery bad.... and for example... victim of fate.... kiske version is great.... and it isn´t the original....

[myuncle2]

Enrique Iglesias copied "hero" from this song. Pathetic.

[samsulbahrikm]

amazing..a great helloween's song

[MasterChico13]

5 guys must have hit the thumbs down button by mistake. it's wonderfull.

[rifandi01]

The lyrics... The Music... Perfect!!!

[STRATOVODKA]

you rock deris...helloween 4evr

[HeavyMetalista666]

Helloween - A tale that wasn't right -very good son

[xdkonnixd]

it is fuckin amazing

[xdkonnixd]

i cannot describe how I luv it in words

[SirEetsa2nd]

Helloween is coming to Finland in december! finally get to see them and hopefully they play this masterpiece :D Happy happy halloween

[biblio360]

great sound and his voice is just wow, i like it very much, one of my favorite

[semanray]

aí galera vejam meu cover dessa musica no meu canal,prometo q nao eh uma merda!!!!!!!!

hey people check my cover of this song,it´s on my channel!!! I promise it´s not shit!!!!

[SixMrTy]

my emotions sank along with the tune of this song... absolute awesome..

[shovelthumbs78]

The best live voice. My fave live dvd of all time - if you don't have it BUY IT!

[21code]

people always said deris give emotions to songs than kiske...how come you know...Timo Tolkki ever said, he choose Kiske in his projects cause kiske sing with soul....it is difficult to sing in high tones as keeper song era..... if only try deris dare sing keepers songs without change the key lowe as he always did, i bet you, there will be duck voice....

[astarothsv]

@21code Tolkki's brain is cosumed by alcohol.... sides from being a sold dickhead, I hope Tolkki's carrers goes down just like Kiske's carreer did... music is not just about hitting high notes... its about make the crowd feel the song and Andy is a kick ass front man!

[popcorn77881987]

love it

[dethNiCk]

deris unlike kiske, always gives his 100% breath to sing kiske's songs

i think that's because 1)He was a big fan of him, and 2)He knows it's impossible to sing like kiske do, but he tries and do it well, the notes are really damm right!

[mayatmaot]

@dethNiCk I respect your views on deris. he tend to add a little of his 'flavour' to a kiske song. in addition, he sings ballads with full emotions. something kiske doesn't do.

[dethNiCk]

@mayatmaot yeah, that's like i said, he tries and do it well, because the notes are so damm perfect, and also he uses full breath!

but the natural voice of kiske is too loud... i think kiske's lungs are made of steel, no one can compete with that!

in particular, i think deris voice suits more from this age, so helloween can be more agressive, more heavy!

[JMZHIGGINS]

@dethNiCk fucking bullshit....nothing else to say, kiske is the only one alowded to sing this song

[dethNiCk]

@JMZHIGGINS because what?

kiske is awesome, but he preffers god than metal.

i respect him, he has a wonderful voice but he sings about god now, respect him, and respect the ones that made this song!

without helloween kiske would be nothing!

[blackraven6449]

@JMZHIGGINS deris version is much much much better deal with this or u cant stand the true?????? if u like kiske u cant tell that this isnt not good but brilliant....

[287107]

la cancion es hermosa, pero siento mas feeling con Kiske que con Deris

[STRATOVODKA]

@287107 kiske es un puto popero y maricon de mierda deris se la metio doblada en esta rola..

[creiGnn]

Much respect for Deris, and although i know he gives his 100% to this song, there's no way he can sing like Kiske did.

[eddiedark15]

Andy deris se parece un poco a bret the hitman hart fisicamente hablando exelente rola muy buena balada muy llegadora helloween RULES

[shovelthumbs78]

Total respect for Andi. It took me a long time to accept him. The guy gives this song 100%. It must be a very hard for him when people compare him with Kiske. But Andi wouldn't give a shit what anyone thinks- like him or hate him, he puts on a hell of a show.

[shovelthumbs78]

absolutely fantastic

[jampiish]

Muchachos... el mejor vocalista k ya tenido helloween sin duda es andy deris, es el unico k compone fielmente a los temas de la escencia de helloween, michael kiske es solo su registro vocal, pero por favor, kiske es pop, no metal!!!!! deris tiene una voz totalmente de metal, y no es desafinado en vivo, solo canta los temas a su manera...Carlos

[moluskoz]

la voz de helloween es kiske, desde los 7 años hasta los 10 solo escuchaba un casette regrabado de una cinta grabada del keepers todos los dias, durante 3 años y fue por la culpa del dichoso kiske, no me comparen por dios. Puede que ande lleve en helloween mucho mas tiempo pero por dios, helloween son lo que son por el cambio que dio gracias a kiske.

ahh!!! y prefiero a Kai Hansen antes que a Andi Deris

[moluskoz]

only michael kiske sing this song perfect

andi deris is good, michael kiske is god

[ceabrus]

rofl he really makes me feel like shit. when i play the song on the guitar,i can do it, but my fingers get all sloppy and he does it with such ease

[Chachi5Montes]

Claro, Kiske ya fue!... obvio, fue mil veces mejor!...pero ya fue!

[GustavOlea]

me apesta como la gente apesar de tantos años nose da cuenta q Andi Deris es LA VOZ de Helloween ... kiske ya fue...

[cacike29]

Me temo que discrepo contigo en eso compadre , para mi sin duda la verdadera voz de Helloween fue Kiske , aunque al tipo ni le gustara el heavy metal , de hecho , fue la salida de Kiske y la entrada de Deris la que provoco un cambio radical en la banda sumiendose mas en el power metal y escapando al heavy metal . Es cosa de gustos obviamente , algunos fans de Helloween preferimos a Kiske y otros a Deris .

[PonchitoRudito1990]

@cacike29 muy cierto, tienes razón, aunque yo prefiero a Andi Deris.

[TheFJansen]

And they say, play this song again -Weiki-

[kajsa21]

Thanks for uploading this. LOVE IT

[ThePower2MEtal]

this is a great song, and its really awesome hearing Deris sing it, he did a great job

[felipelazari]

@ThePower2MEtal

I guess Kiske sing well, but, you can feel all the soul Andi put on the song, I Like much more Helloween with Deris than Kiske, Long Live Andi

[ThePower2MEtal]

agreed man andi has got more balls when he sings, it sounds a lot more manly, he is a power metal god

[3nderoX]

@ThePower2MEtal Nobody sounds like deris that what makes him so great his vocals are unique which is something i can't say for most power metal bands.

[MarcosKeld]

Deris impressed me in this one. He is a great frontman.

[cacike29]

Claramente no es lo mismo que Kiske , pero de todas formas la version sigue sonando preciosa con Deris en las voces .

[Andiderius]

juro que me emociona!!

[felipelazari]

@Andiderius

a mim tb, música muito linda A Tale that Wasn't Right, principalmente com os vocais de Andi Deris

[slayer00of00dreams1]

es mejor kiske se olle mejor una vox ma limpia

[textera147]

esto esta en vivo igual... pero si... este tipo no canta lo que kiske... ni en 4 o 5 mil años jaja

[vocalista2]

kai hansen creador y primer vocalista de helloween para aquellos ignorantes

[TheBaskerman]

alfredo el primer vocal fue hansen deduzco que no has escuchado los dos primeros discos por cierto autentico speed metal

[TheFJansen]

★★★★★★

[TheFJansen]

★★★★★★

[alfredo4059]

Que pendejos son aquellos que comparana a Andi con Kiske. Ambos son voces diferentes con matices distintas, si bien, Kiske fue el primer vocal, Andi por meritos y por esfuerzos merece ser el icono indiscutible de Helloween Pendejos

[461195]

deris, in this song he sing very good because he´ve got a special performance

[elninjacopia99]

una gran voz con una gran cancion, andi deris desde q lo esuche en vivo en un concierto, es mi cantante o unos de mis cantantes favoritos.

[djusch]

haha this sucks! no one can sing this song like kiske

[romanist458]

No bad, but there's minus one tone of original version :)

[roquerama15]

Wow! Deris kicked ass in this! (^_^) V

[gabrielenxotado20]

huol,vejo sempre

[soundkeeperchannel]

Greatest version of this song :D

[tlintaeum]

lindo!!

[Bodomism]

octaveless

[deris4ever]

Deris always sings with all his heart. He's a great man!

[astarothsv]

@deris4ever Thats why he's better than Kiske!

[Joe22c]

2:40 girl is cute miming the lyrics haha :)

[xelanoise]

Just the fact that she knows the lyrics makes her really hot!!! Brazillian women...mmm mmm! LOL

[mayatmaot]

deris sings ballads with all his heart.... he's even almost pushed to tears at times

[Kha096]

this is a masterpiece