techniken sind sind ok aber Leute .... warum zieht ihr euch sone fachingskostüme an und dann auch noch Holzschwerter ?!?! Legt euch bitte mal echte Harnische und Blankwaffen zu das sieht nicht nur tausendmal besser aus sondern macht auch tausendmal mehr Spass. viele Grüße
Now THAT's how it's supposed to look. Swings and slashes were practically useless against heavy armour so they had to come up with a much more sophisticated way of fighting. Who says only the Asians could perform martial arts?
I don't mind the plastic armour much, but the bamboo swords disappoint me. I think with all of the padding steel would've been safe, or at least wood.
if its a staged fight, then there is no need to use real armor, because it only shows how men in armor WOULD fight, their armor really just sets the tone.
Training with the protections helps becouse they can strike fast and hard without having to worry about hurting their training partners. Without the protections, the demostration would have to be done slowly.
Excellent job, well presented and executed. The very practical and realistic abandonment of various weapons after the point is passed is something of a shock, but seems very correct. Ignore the full plate elitists. I've seen plenty of extremely well-equipped fat men who bang weapons together like children while wearing the most exquisite armor. What matters is your scholarship and your intensity in training. Keep up the good work. Good luck.
dissapointed that you don't use the right armour, or even a proper sword. Since it's staged there is absolutely no need to adjust the weapons. I know armour can be expensive, but nothing will replicate it at all. get the real stuff, or don't do it, to be honest, the weight, the flexibility, the vision, it's all different in this kit.
Not so fast! Wearing plastic armour doesn't have to simulate wearing plate armour, it it could be worn for protection. The fighters could to be representing unarmoured warriors. A dagger was sticking out of the chest of one of the fellows, something that wouldn't happen if they were wearing plate. .
and yes, some stuff wouldn't work that way in real armour. armour isn't That expensive, and nothing will tell you how it feels to wear it and fight or ride in it other than the real deal.
Airnt, you are so right! Especially with armoured combat there is absolutly no point in using modern protective wear... Harnischfechten is fighting in harness. You can't train it as an alternative matrial art, because it deals with a situation which is completely historic. You simply won't happen to be sentenced to fight an ordeal in full armour ( as in the video a judical duel is shown ). It is only working under the circumstances of its time, to which belongs historic armour, no plastic shit.
Ansonsten habt ihr ein schönes Video gedreht, aber leider werden eure Mühen durch die (zumindest aus meiner Sicht) mangelhafte rüstung zunichte gemacht. Ich meine, ihr könntet euch für nur ein paar euro mehr als ihr für die plastikpanzerung ausgeben habt Rüstungen zulegen, die für eure Zwecke ausreichen. Wenn ihr euch ernsthaft mit harnischfechten auseinandersetzen wollt, führt da mal echt kein Weg dran vorbei, denn ohne Harnisch macht ihr nunmal kein Harnischfechten. Ansonsten schönes Video...
wirklich sehr schön, möchte nur wissen warum ihr mit dem schwert am schluss kämpft, so wie man in einem engen gang konfrontiert wird ( 2te hand an der klinge), und nicht richtige schläge setzt, ihr habt doch ausreichend platz, aber an sich wirklich seeeeeeehr schön^^
Once the effective range of a spear is closed in upon, it is useless. Same with long sword - If there's no distance to cut or strike, it's more effective to close in grapple and finish him with a dagger.
you see, this is what i mean: in real harness it would have been clear why there is no point in the weapon once the point is passed. pommel strikes, for example, to a helmet, even a sallet do naught! To grapple is the most effective and logical.
the plastic confuses this point.
the techniques are descibed in these ways in many manuscripts, show the youtube community why.
Your attitude seems to suggest that only those who can afford a full harness have any business exploring armored combat techniques. I think the solution these guys have found is 100% better than just studying Harnischfechten from a book... Also, please let me deliver a Mordhau to your expensively helmeted skull and let's see what happens.
no it's just nonsensical to spend money on protective gear from football etc. where you could just as well get actual armour for a compareable sum.
armoured like this or something lighter, you are best equipped for half-contact practice of historic fencing (with a federschwert for even more safety).
armoured fencing goes for thrusts to the unarmoured spots and these are deadly today as they have always been. there is no save method of practice here but only coreographed half-contact drills.
mordhau, i would damage my expensive helmet and be angry. i don't think it would hurt more than a lance to the face, whilst jousting which I've had numerous times.
all stupid stuff aside...
My first armour was 1345 pounds to buy. It was by no means perfect but gave decent ideas about how it works. The $35000 one i have now is much better, but of course not everyone wants to go that far.
I don't think 1345 quid is much to pay, if one is serious about doing this.
Honestly, these guys have put together a far more elegant, not to mention cinematically superior work than MOST of what I've seen on YouTube. If they choose to do it in hockey gear, I couldn't care less.
Very impressive. The only thing that I would like to see would be period steel harness used as this will affect and change how you move as opposed to the modern equipment.
I like how you guys fought holding both spear and bastard sword. Fighting spear in long range and then sword and finaly dagger in close range. I might use that at some future point in SCA melees.
Another very fun video. I like your solution for fighting in harness without having to spend a fortune on a suit of full plate. This looks just like the armored set from one of Talhoffer's books.
5:01 right in the family jewels.
WitheringintheDark 6 months ago
that was badass
scarywitch13 8 months ago
techniken sind sind ok aber Leute .... warum zieht ihr euch sone fachingskostüme an und dann auch noch Holzschwerter ?!?! Legt euch bitte mal echte Harnische und Blankwaffen zu das sieht nicht nur tausendmal besser aus sondern macht auch tausendmal mehr Spass. viele Grüße
Quetzalgoatl 9 months ago
its rare to see that kind of intent of movement in weapons combat.
regardless of whether it was staged or otherwise, both combatants move with
purpose, job well done.
universalJok3r 1 year ago
buen trabajo, ese tipo de armadura esta excelente para praticar este estilo.
folkendraken2 1 year ago
Now THAT's how it's supposed to look. Swings and slashes were practically useless against heavy armour so they had to come up with a much more sophisticated way of fighting. Who says only the Asians could perform martial arts?
Europa for the win! :D
GERdeathstar 1 year ago
wuhoh, 1:14 hes Catholic!
bu1letpr00f 2 years ago
I liked the vid. Interesting use of the weapons too!
GOBRAGH2 2 years ago
Woher habt ihr diese Rüstungen???
programmer456 2 years ago
Suuuuuuuper!
Respekt!
programmer456 2 years ago
Wahnsinn, ist das LAAANGWEILIG!!!
ck586 2 years ago
Cinematically this is amazing. I don't mind the wood weapons and plastic gear.
My only concern is how easily they lost their spears and swords.
Great job anyways.
duran3d 2 years ago
wood!? how cheap!
speeedsk8ter 2 years ago
how much safer!
VikingWannaBe51887 2 years ago
practice equipment, even medieval knights used wood swords for training
artiepoore 2 years ago
I'd like to see this being done everywhere except with real weapons
Deathicorn 2 years ago
"Blossfechter"? das ist doch die Bezeichnung für Kämpfe OHNE Rüstung... xP
moep 2 years ago
Great job guys
Deustchland!!!!
87thebull87 2 years ago
I don't mind the plastic armour much, but the bamboo swords disappoint me. I think with all of the padding steel would've been safe, or at least wood.
Danpaco 3 years ago
if its a staged fight, then there is no need to use real armor, because it only shows how men in armor WOULD fight, their armor really just sets the tone.
anyways, i love it, good work.
memphadon 3 years ago
Training with the protections helps becouse they can strike fast and hard without having to worry about hurting their training partners. Without the protections, the demostration would have to be done slowly.
panstriato2 3 years ago
Excellent job, well presented and executed. The very practical and realistic abandonment of various weapons after the point is passed is something of a shock, but seems very correct. Ignore the full plate elitists. I've seen plenty of extremely well-equipped fat men who bang weapons together like children while wearing the most exquisite armor. What matters is your scholarship and your intensity in training. Keep up the good work. Good luck.
Hugonis 3 years ago 8
dissapointed that you don't use the right armour, or even a proper sword. Since it's staged there is absolutely no need to adjust the weapons. I know armour can be expensive, but nothing will replicate it at all. get the real stuff, or don't do it, to be honest, the weight, the flexibility, the vision, it's all different in this kit.
poor indeed
airnt 3 years ago
Not so fast! Wearing plastic armour doesn't have to simulate wearing plate armour, it it could be worn for protection. The fighters could to be representing unarmoured warriors. A dagger was sticking out of the chest of one of the fellows, something that wouldn't happen if they were wearing plate. .
MrPotatoesLatkie 3 years ago
dude, the clips is called: Harnischfechten!
= german for armoured fighting!
the plastic shit might as well not be there.
and yes, some stuff wouldn't work that way in real armour. armour isn't That expensive, and nothing will tell you how it feels to wear it and fight or ride in it other than the real deal.
airnt 3 years ago
Airnt, you are so right! Especially with armoured combat there is absolutly no point in using modern protective wear... Harnischfechten is fighting in harness. You can't train it as an alternative matrial art, because it deals with a situation which is completely historic. You simply won't happen to be sentenced to fight an ordeal in full armour ( as in the video a judical duel is shown ). It is only working under the circumstances of its time, to which belongs historic armour, no plastic shit.
Harkilas 3 years ago
Ansonsten habt ihr ein schönes Video gedreht, aber leider werden eure Mühen durch die (zumindest aus meiner Sicht) mangelhafte rüstung zunichte gemacht. Ich meine, ihr könntet euch für nur ein paar euro mehr als ihr für die plastikpanzerung ausgeben habt Rüstungen zulegen, die für eure Zwecke ausreichen. Wenn ihr euch ernsthaft mit harnischfechten auseinandersetzen wollt, führt da mal echt kein Weg dran vorbei, denn ohne Harnisch macht ihr nunmal kein Harnischfechten. Ansonsten schönes Video...
Harkilas 3 years ago
was für einen brustpanzer hat thomas da an?
CenrionPrime 3 years ago
Was für Rüstungen am Oberkörper benutzt ihr?
Lahron 3 years ago
Wir kämpfen im Halbschwert, weil das ganze Harnischfechten darstellen soll!
astragand 4 years ago
wirklich sehr schön, möchte nur wissen warum ihr mit dem schwert am schluss kämpft, so wie man in einem engen gang konfrontiert wird ( 2te hand an der klinge), und nicht richtige schläge setzt, ihr habt doch ausreichend platz, aber an sich wirklich seeeeeeehr schön^^
respekt
100Maggots 4 years ago
poor ;/
dorian26uk 4 years ago
Where can you get such body armor? Is it custom made?
Konane12 4 years ago
class lads
buckodcelt 4 years ago
XD awesome!!
nielsdejong 4 years ago
I don't understand why they tossed away their weapons so easily.
sportgrappler 4 years ago
because it's staged
varangianguard01 4 years ago
Once the effective range of a spear is closed in upon, it is useless. Same with long sword - If there's no distance to cut or strike, it's more effective to close in grapple and finish him with a dagger.
Gunyo 4 years ago
However there are some long sword techniques that gets around that.
kingcobra101z 3 years ago 3
Defintely, halfswording reduces the longsword's range to, well half really. Also pommel and cross strike are effective at very close range.
But yes, once grappling commences it is often best to have a rondel (dagger).
Cheers!
GambleD13 3 years ago
you see, this is what i mean: in real harness it would have been clear why there is no point in the weapon once the point is passed. pommel strikes, for example, to a helmet, even a sallet do naught! To grapple is the most effective and logical.
the plastic confuses this point.
the techniques are descibed in these ways in many manuscripts, show the youtube community why.
airnt 3 years ago
Your attitude seems to suggest that only those who can afford a full harness have any business exploring armored combat techniques. I think the solution these guys have found is 100% better than just studying Harnischfechten from a book... Also, please let me deliver a Mordhau to your expensively helmeted skull and let's see what happens.
Djemps 3 years ago
no it's just nonsensical to spend money on protective gear from football etc. where you could just as well get actual armour for a compareable sum.
armoured like this or something lighter, you are best equipped for half-contact practice of historic fencing (with a federschwert for even more safety).
armoured fencing goes for thrusts to the unarmoured spots and these are deadly today as they have always been. there is no save method of practice here but only coreographed half-contact drills.
BuscoBeast 3 years ago
mordhau, i would damage my expensive helmet and be angry. i don't think it would hurt more than a lance to the face, whilst jousting which I've had numerous times.
all stupid stuff aside...
My first armour was 1345 pounds to buy. It was by no means perfect but gave decent ideas about how it works. The $35000 one i have now is much better, but of course not everyone wants to go that far.
I don't think 1345 quid is much to pay, if one is serious about doing this.
airnt 2 years ago
Honestly, these guys have put together a far more elegant, not to mention cinematically superior work than MOST of what I've seen on YouTube. If they choose to do it in hockey gear, I couldn't care less.
lastnameless 2 years ago 5
awesome
Uthardar 4 years ago
YAWN !!
spenny24950361 4 years ago
Give me a spear!
Catonius 4 years ago
Now that is pretty hardcore...
GnPdemon 4 years ago
Very nice video! I like the effectiveness of your moves and the dramatic duel atmosphere. Quite catching :)
Alux2003 4 years ago
Very impressive. The only thing that I would like to see would be period steel harness used as this will affect and change how you move as opposed to the modern equipment.
RodericValcerre 4 years ago
I like how you guys fought holding both spear and bastard sword. Fighting spear in long range and then sword and finaly dagger in close range. I might use that at some future point in SCA melees.
tsafa1 4 years ago
Another very fun video. I like your solution for fighting in harness without having to spend a fortune on a suit of full plate. This looks just like the armored set from one of Talhoffer's books.
Djemps 4 years ago