Not bad, but Cantonese is actually more demanding on the voice quality. He can no longer use those R&B style variations to cover some of his weaknesses.
@januarymenno yea that he released on an album. shame really... he said in an interview he finds it extremely difficult to express his true emotions when singing in cantonese.. so tahts why he sticks with writing mando songs.. too bad, im from hk, and would love to hear more canto songs from him even tho im fluent in mandarin and english ^^
i think in this whole CD it was all different versions of other peoples songs. he has other CD of the ones he composed himself. its just this CD is different
Would like to see how Khalil would sing his RnB/Soul songs in Cantonese in the future. But it's a good start with this cover song! New arrangement is much better!
大同唱得好得意hehe
佢已經講左自己講廣東話係最差
但想試下唱廣東話歌
我覺得好特別好得意hehe
kwannyava 5 months ago
始終都係菊姐既原唱好,更能表達套戲既感情和Messages。
不過方大同也不差,都算唱得投入用感情。
raymondkkng 1 year ago
願意面對自己的弱點的人才是強人。
逃避是沒有用的。
qt247ha 1 year ago 7
港澳人淨係識無限倍放大別人ge缺點,佢地係唔識欣賞人地ge優點架~~
Stephen01620 1 year ago 4
@Stephen01620 講得好!有時我喺論壇見到一D人自我感覺良好咁去踩人哋小小嘅缺點,真係戥哩D人悲哀,心空狹窄到死。我覺得香港樂壇提不起競其中一個原因係D人猛咁喺到批評,係又批評,唔係又批評。其他地方嘅嘢就咩都話好,就算做得差都選擇性當睇唔到,反而香港就小小做得唔好就記實,好嗰D就選擇性當睇唔到。
historyrockz 1 year ago
Not bad, but Cantonese is actually more demanding on the voice quality. He can no longer use those R&B style variations to cover some of his weaknesses.
myhairlosing 2 years ago
hes so good at singin cantonese, marderin & english
so pro!! tht wt a real singer is! not look thos garbage singer who cant even sing the right key!!
POONyukfai 2 years ago 2
question.
is this the first cantonese song of his?
januarymenno 2 years ago
@januarymenno yea that he released on an album. shame really... he said in an interview he finds it extremely difficult to express his true emotions when singing in cantonese.. so tahts why he sticks with writing mando songs.. too bad, im from hk, and would love to hear more canto songs from him even tho im fluent in mandarin and english ^^
zapma 1 year ago
方大同呢張碟真係絕對冇對唔住原唱
din3786 2 years ago 15
he sound good but i like 關菊英 better
tvbcskwan 2 years ago 5
hey....
he sings cantonese
not bad...
<3 his sound
daniellol999 2 years ago
nice! like it very much!
snsk83 2 years ago 4
關菊英 , 1976年
kfcsir 2 years ago 5
whos the real singer of this song
liangzhai00 2 years ago
omg love <3
h0neybearrr 2 years ago
well he has to try something differentD=
XxXmalaybabeXxX 2 years ago 3
He should find some song of his own..if follow song oni many people had become singer.
kenatu 2 years ago
i think in this whole CD it was all different versions of other peoples songs. he has other CD of the ones he composed himself. its just this CD is different
XxXmalaybabeXxX 2 years ago
^__^ 唔知點解每次聽到佢既聲音就覺得好似好辛褔咁... 錯. 係辛褔.
sexcjesstar 2 years ago 3
請大家給予支持而不是無理的批評
MHY0202 2 years ago 2
i kinda think he should just sing in mandarin...his cantonese voice isn't that appealing..but not bad
jyw003 2 years ago
我都覺得佢唱得幾好!加油!
tommylam05251 2 years ago 4
我覺得唔錯,幾好聽,將首舊歌付予新既靈魂!!THE FEEL IS SO GOOD!! Bravo!!
coolkoo123 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
乜 幾許歡and笑 個個狂潮卷起 人生的是x找 你我心中 幾許 多少假and真 個個狂潮舞
lauwai14 2 years ago
點解好似第一句唱到似"是叉也是梨和鵝"
yvonne88123 2 years ago 16
Comment removed
tam1234hk 2 years ago
叉鵝??
tungchiwahwah 2 years ago
你聽錯拉.如果真系唱成甘既話.
就1早比人寫拉-33-*
聽多幾次.聽真d.就吾會出現.
p.s. 不喜請無視.
yikkitracy 2 years ago
walkmanzone[dot]info to download this album
musicshaun 2 years ago
好聽, 請大同繼續唱多d廣東歌給我們聽~ 順便教教敬騰講廣東話喔~
siuchu610 2 years ago 16
This has been flagged as spam show
菊姐唱得好聽過佢
sososocy 2 years ago
人地係唱歌唔係唱字
你係要研究佢咬字就無謂聽歌
mafatasi5afalean 2 years ago
唱歌都要咬字正, 讀音準.
英文歌普通話都係一樣.
唔聽字既倒不如聽midi?!
我覺得大同唱得唔錯.
都算準, 比起平時講野準好多.
katzbabe 2 years ago 16
是叉也是梨和鵝
yvonne88123 2 years ago 6
開餐lu~ 有生果XD
lonelywolfSD 2 years ago
xDDD
longshanlung 2 years ago
好正....... khalil應該唱多d廣東歌!!
doraemon2151 2 years ago 11
普通話比較易唱
廣東話d音好難發揮到佢把聲
SupreMetttt 2 years ago 15
好似俾人感覺佢好努力咁講廣東話咁=.=
plkgary999 2 years ago 10
方大同真係好慘
之前就唱普通話
d人就話佢淨係唱國語,唔唱廣東歌
佢一早表明左自己廣東話唔正
依家唱廣東,又話人地廣東唔正
19938155 2 years ago 74
同意,
左右做人難啊!
pakeyboy 2 years ago 2
remind me some old things with a guy, who cannot speak cantoness good too.
RoxannaK 2 years ago 2
點解好似第一句唱到似"是叉也是梨和鵝"咁-_-
mandyiong1018 2 years ago 4
XD, 超搞笑
winnieyipyip 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
大好きです@@
KulaiEHaraikotsu 2 years ago
香港人打咩日文- -
識日文唔洗哂舨出黎 =.=
鍾意就打"鍾意" =.=
pakeyboy 2 years ago 2
大同啲廣東話唔差嫁,話哂都係香港住左好多年....
kennethFOB 2 years ago
其實真係唔錯架
係有小小唔正
唱多幾次咩都得架啦
AitSweet 2 years ago 3
希望大同能唱多点广东歌。
chineseswordsman 2 years ago 3
改得有點差...都係原本個版本好聽
方大同都係唱番自style d唱好d..
TommyYamap 2 years ago 2
呵呵~ 第一次聽大同唱廣東歌~ 好聽 ~
siuchu610 2 years ago 2
笑人唔正=.=
人地笑返你英文同普通話唔正咋~
mikeshinoda555 2 years ago 30
我鍾意佢前幾隻碟多D~
d歌好聽d~而家就.....有少少定型....
不過問我佢唱廣東話~我又覺得佢可以wo~
skinbanana 2 years ago
好好聽牙!!希望大同會出更多廣東歌^^
SsamuelxX 2 years ago 7
awesome!!!Khalil~!!!!
watch4nothing 2 years ago 5
比d機會人啦 ,
佢唱普通話個陣你地係咪一樣咁憎佢 ?
ChanFiona1228 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
唔好唱廣東話啦
cammycammy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你我各留痕
cammycammy 2 years ago
唱錯有咩問題
人地最佳男歌手
你地得唔得先
kokto1989 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
ruins the song.
whateveryouyouyou 2 years ago
未聽過佢唱中文-v-
不過真係唱得好好聽.
mariii0316 2 years ago 6
普通話唔係中文?
dyth 2 years ago 3
廣東話又唔係佢第1語言,唔準有幾奇?
人地咪又笑返你普通話唔準
mandyball1 2 years ago 13
非常讚同!!! =]
9090ka 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
on99~ 留痕
cammycammy 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
佢d咬字好差
tk25 2 years ago
難得聽佢唱廣東話,大同把聲真係好好聽..
gilbycgilby 2 years ago 7
的確咬唔清.
但如果你覺得方大同既音樂好垃圾.
唔該認真你對比下佢既編曲同其他所謂既canton-pop既編曲對比下.
pc20021050 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
"你"應該係"nei"音, 方生唱錯晒喎
bmw1121kin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
字典機發音?
Terencehkhk 2 years ago
maybe u should check ur ear, i didn't hear any wrong word.
kenleung88 2 years ago 5
nice try~:D
michellelyc1 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
um, 有點奇怪, 咬字麻麻咁.. 原版好聽d
下面個d 話覺得ok既, 叫人唔好踩人既,唔鍾意人地意見可以唔出聲, 但係都唔應該係去鬧返人呀?
cbabb2009 2 years ago
omg! khalil finally sang a cantonese song! :) he sounds great.
IoIIip0p 2 years ago 6
omg! His voice is amazing. LOOOVE this song to start with. He got a good taste & try to re-invent this song. Super!
ameh108 2 years ago 2
我覺得好正....
好特別....
kingbeck7 2 years ago 3
我覺得好好聽,有震動到我
henry2890 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
who is he????? is he or she?
wt is he/she singing ?
i hv many ?s in my mind..
mswtfwtfwtf 2 years ago
Comment removed
mswtfwtfwtf 2 years ago
ok丫!加油
fokhoyi0716 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
方大同正垃圾
hkfchow 2 years ago
您有病架?咁踩人都有o既!?
r112rr112r 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
是叉也是你和我 wtf ???
咬字都未清 on99
emmanuel912chan 2 years ago
你唔喜歡可以作善意的評批
但唔該收返你句「on99」
你媽媽無教你點尊重人的嗎?
freegohome 2 years ago 6
not bad ... he can sing cantoness as good as mandarin
livia208s 2 years ago 3
比較習慣他唱國語喇~怪怪地
不過很好聽喇~
yin00show 2 years ago 4
好怪
我聽唔慣xDD
didididi11 2 years ago
大同 廣東話 終於 畫上等號 !
=v=
babekurav3v 2 years ago 9
嘩嘩嘩廣東話!!!
maylovemoney1 2 years ago 2
It is so freaky, he sing this song, one of my favorite songs back to 1970's......good! Look forward to his album, when to release?
EKYFUNG 2 years ago
14/08/2009
tatyee 2 years ago
they actually changed it to 11/08/2009
misschinesepride 2 years ago
WOW I am totally looking forward to his newest album timeless!!! should have a lot of goodies!!!
sandalls 2 years ago 5
有股溫柔FU....
petsong 2 years ago 3
wow finally canto song!!!! Khalil the best!
chungblam 2 years ago 5
It's a elegant version of the song, good job on remixing the song.
Unfortunately Khalil lost his unique soul soul singing style when it comes to Cantonese songs. Nevertheless it's still a good song.
milala6891 2 years ago 10
好正 我愛大同啊
iloveukatherine 2 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
nice try but...
mirandayuen 2 years ago
shocked....
charlottecheng 2 years ago 5
i like orginal more...but nice they remember this song & sing again....
jollychippy 2 years ago
終於等到佢唱廣東歌
cookie8888hk 2 years ago 6
好正丫..大同
唱得好好
beanpin199 2 years ago 3
Wow~很怀旧、很有格调的感觉~!我喜欢~!^.^
CatLimDX 2 years ago 4
乜咁經典.
holandsms 2 years ago
wow!!!!its so surprising!!!!!!!i am quite touched by the song!!
evaaaaan1001 2 years ago 2
extremely shocked
stellaaanwy 2 years ago 4
amazing
liwalung 2 years ago
Would like to see how Khalil would sing his RnB/Soul songs in Cantonese in the future. But it's a good start with this cover song! New arrangement is much better!
sport3888 2 years ago
wow...this is nice.....and it's cantonese song too :D
py2001 2 years ago 2
好感動
MereKiraa 2 years ago 5
曲編的很細緻啊....
仔細聼真的很感動
misschinesepride 2 years ago 6
佢編曲一向好細膩
好耐聽
6ling0 2 years ago 6
大同終於開金口唱廣東歌
travissbicklee 2 years ago 4
終於有廣東歌!!
arielcheung 2 years ago 2
終於唱廣東歌
但係....一點都唔soul~
-0-
jasonshum 2 years ago 3
請問狂潮點soul?@@
karrrjones 2 years ago 6
而且廣東話好難soul啊
misschinesepride 2 years ago 8
佢做音樂又係全為soul
如果淨係要聽soul 唯有聽佢舊作吧啦
6ling0 2 years ago 4
廣東歌唱其他曲風係好難發揮出黎..
mrlsing 2 years ago 9
he FINALLY sings a cantonese song.
10centwings 2 years ago 9
unbelievable
kl928 2 years ago 6