Nightmare Moon a better villain than Exdeath...how? If I remember correctly, Exdeath managed to be a douche, nearly destroy all of existence, and actually act like a badass. NM doesn't even come close to that, unless you're referring to proportion.
I was playing Team Fortress 2 today, playing on VS Saxton Hale, with the dozens of bosses. So then, I was fighting a pony as a boss... yeah... I can't stand this... Anyways, I just said "I'm sick of these ponies." And then, I was muted... no chat... no voice chat... no way to communicate with my team without the set voice options... I decided to spray over a rule #34 Pinky Pie spray. And the Admin KILLED ME! Those bronies didnt love and tolerate...
i just did some research and found out that tara strong WASN'T Maka from soul eater. In fact she wasn't even in it that was laura bailey, so your comment of twilight being maka is not true. Nevertheless good video though, even if i disagree with alot of you problems. ps, i am a brony
I've never seen the show at all, and this review may or may not count as seeing the first episode. I still don't understand why so many people can enjoy this and I'm afraid that I will never like it.
@TB26 It's not up to me to tell you to like this show. I, for one, was skeptical about checking this show out because, well, how could millions of grown men like My Little Pony? I gave it a shot and I found that I actually like it myself. Now that doesn't happen to everyone, mind you, and I respect that.
This review only contains snippets from the first two episodes. If you want to give this show an earnest shot, go ahead. Just don't expect anything out of it. I didn't.
joshscorcher is the reason im a brony! at first i was happy to see it get critisized as i was a hater then, after a while i got into the artstyle, but not the show. when he released his review of season 2 i got ALOT more interested. Eventually I got so torn on weather or not to watch the show that i made a promise to myself to either watch the show that day or never see it at all. I watched it and i am soooo happy i did! and of course i have josh to thank!
Did you notice how, if Rarity, Applejack, Pinky Pie, Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash are suppoused to be the so-called "Elements of Friendship", that they have a hard time BEING friends?
also those were the first 2 episodes. it gets much better later. i am not hating, i enjoyed this review. a lot, actually. it's a nice unbiased review. but i just belive the show is much better represented in other episodes.
From 3:10 on watching his reaction showed the transformation of the brony process begin it was enjoyable and also cautious so it never happens to me nothing against bronies
Excellent review. I'm not a fan of all of the songs but, their better then other songs on kids shows today. I thought your review was accurate and very fair. (this coming from a brony)
as a fellow brony I respect your opinion.... i respect ur video and your humor against it which btw made me LOL....... i love this videos and all others........ i can haz brohoof? :D
Find it funny how you compare Twilight to Maka when Maka can actually get along with people more quickly than Twilight. I can understand the whole bookworm thing.
My only question is, how is Krillen (spelling) from DBZ a side kick? I'd assume that Gohan would've been more of a side kick due to how much screen time he shows up as much as his Father. =/
I respect your opinion, you tried the show, hell, even reviewed it, and you didn't like it. Being a brony myself, I am used to people who don't like the show calling me gay for liking the show, but how they say it is in one of the most idiotic way possible, example "U LIEK A SHOW ABOUT PONIEZ, UR A GEY FAGGIT" but you on the other hand, constructively reveiwed it and gave it credit where it was needed. Have a good day Mr. Scorcher, and here's a brofist.
lol its funny how you needed to put a disclaimer at the beginning just so no one will hate you. i mean seriously if bronies really "loved and tolerated" then that wouldnt have been needed...
Yes it is a guilty pleasure of mine as well, but I've learn to be a man to accept, love and tolerate. Even when I'm as embarrassed as hell to admit I'm a brony
See, if this didn't have the groan moments, had no musical moments, was in an anime style, had people instead of ponies, and was originally made in Japan nobody would care about it that much.
I just realized something: Nightmare Moon was sealed away for 1000 years. HOW IS CELESTIA STILL ALIVE THEN??? And don't say that it's because ponies live a long time, because Applejack has a grandmother and she does NOT seem like she's 1000 years old!
@kingofmonsters14 Presentation. over and over, presumably to remind himself not to have a HHHNNNNNGGG attack at fluttershy. Or whatever amounts to a HHHNNNGG attack in his case. More like a "that's cute" attack in that case.
Just because it has ponies does not mean it's for girls only. Look at SonictheHedgehog17 for example. He used My Little Pony reference in his a results of top 15 most hated video game characters and it make sense. Hey, joshscorcher, what's your favorite cartoon show and your thoughts of My Little Pony.
I must say, great review. You have some good, understandable points, even though I disagree on most points with you because my personal experience was so different.
I still think my favorite quote is a scene where Fluttershy comments to Pinkie Pie that she's a year older. Why? Same voice actor, I thought it was a funny split-personality moment.
well im halfway through and i now understand you have nothing but nice things to say. i believe if you have feelings for a show (love/hate) it is worth watching. because you get a kick out of it ether way.
Love your review as a Normal typical Brony I love when people just hate on the show especially my dad who won't even look at it I discovered MLPFIM by accident but fell in love with it so much I have Action Figures (or dolls mistermed), wake up specifically on weekends for new episodes, and for Christmas got a T-shirt that says "BRONY" just laughed at your jokes although I don't know what "bro hoof" is thats the 2nd time I've heard that I Love it mostly cause it shows me how to be a friend =' )
I don't agree with everything you hate about the show but for sure this was one excellent review! I mean someone saying bad stuff about the show not because its a girls cartoon or its my little pony but rather watching it and explaining your likes and dislikes about the show made my day! broho-... ill skip that.
To anybody who searches for the Cupcakes after this (at least on Youtube):
For gods sake, at least make it "Cupcakes song", not just "Cupcakes", or else you will find one correct one buried in a fuckload of readings of the creepypasta (yup, it's named Cupcakes), and even animations.
PS: If you like creepypastas, check out creepypasta.wikia.com and type in "Cupcakes". That's the one that animations based on.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I still think the thing sucks. But still, I like the Nostalgia Critic style review of this. Some of your reactions made me laugh. My opinion? The smooth animation and bright colors sucks most people right in when they don't realize how unoriginal it is, I will say it has effort, but still, THIS SHOW IS FOR LITTLE GIRLS. WHY ARE 20 YEAR OLD MEN FALLING IN LOVE WITH THIS SHOW?!?! IT MAKES NO SENSE.
Because people are secure in their masculinity and aren't afraid to watch cartoons? Because maybe they enjoy the underlying themes of friendship and the lessons they can learn? Because they can watch this "little girls show" and not bleed their brains out?
This show is more mature than Spongebob, or anything Nickelodeon or Disney Channel puts out. That's why people enjoy it.
@joshscorcher "There's just this sense to it, this atmosphere, this real likability to this world that they've created. It can be very laid back and very slow paced, but at the same time, these characters are just so interesting and nice that you really enjoy spending time with them. You don't care if not much is going on, you could just have a conversation with anyone of these people and you'd probably be very satisfied." - Doug Walker (Review of Winnie the Pooh from Disneycember)
@joshscorcher Say, thanks Joker, that was a nice gesture for you to defend the Brony position against some troll. I also complement you on your logical and thoughtful response with relevant examples as well.
Thank you, doubtless everypony else in the herd thanks you too.
i agree with u 100% just because it has good visual effects interesting plot and funny moments doesnt defeat the annoying little girl part of it and lol josh i was like that to when i was young and i hate seeing a reflection
When you commented on Nightmare Moon's design, I just realized how much of a bitch it must be to get that helmet on with that frickin' huge horn coming out of her forehead.
in the blue dragon video game made in 2006, Kluke, the female protagonist, is voiced by Tara Strong, the same voice actor as Twilight. i found this out shortly after she screamed in game "If i let go I'm gonna die."
That makes it twice in two rooles that she has had to say roughly the same phrase.
Tell me what you think of this and help contribute to the count.
This has to be the only review that has LOGIC. I like the series but I don't really like the fanbase. (I know R34 exists for a lot of things, but MLP R34? Seriously?) I agree with most of your points, and The show itself isn't a bad show like most of the cartoons aired nowadays. I do admit, i didn't like some of the scenes, sometimes the voice acting is bad, but those are some minor gripes that I have. Overall, Brohoof? -I am a sadomasochist-
i have to say this it is better then most modern american shows like family guy, simpsons, and other things because for 1 thing it isn't constantly trying to be funny all the time which pisses me off if i want to laugh ill go watch a comedian that actually takes time to think of things i guess i like thought put into humor and 2 IT HAS PLOT which most american shows lack these days thats why anime is so popular because it has a balance of humor and plot so that it is telling a story so yea......
You ,my good sir, are definitely respectable. Most people who don't like this show usually give bad reasons. You point out legitimate things, that make sense. Others just kinda say "This show sucks because its gay" Or something like that. While I do enjoy this show, I can respect your opinion. And thank you for actually using logic... Unlike other people on the Internet who act like dumb asses.
@coltsfanca Oh and BTW...I saw the Fluttershy bit and when you facepalmed, I thought: "NO WAY IS HE GOING TO MAKE FUN OF FLUTTERSHY!?! IDK IF I CAN TOLERATE THAT!!" then..."I used to be that!" hahahaha
Nightmare Moon a better villain than Exdeath...how? If I remember correctly, Exdeath managed to be a douche, nearly destroy all of existence, and actually act like a badass. NM doesn't even come close to that, unless you're referring to proportion.
Aadvaki 4 hours ago
YES! THIS. WAS. HILARIOUSLY. AWESOME!
TASTE THE RAINBOW, MOTHER F**KER!
Superellysan 6 hours ago
fuck you with a silver spoon
TheMagnificentPony 22 hours ago
Hey josh! I bet your going to love this story!
I was playing Team Fortress 2 today, playing on VS Saxton Hale, with the dozens of bosses. So then, I was fighting a pony as a boss... yeah... I can't stand this... Anyways, I just said "I'm sick of these ponies." And then, I was muted... no chat... no voice chat... no way to communicate with my team without the set voice options... I decided to spray over a rule #34 Pinky Pie spray. And the Admin KILLED ME! Those bronies didnt love and tolerate...
superblazingnova 1 day ago
i just did some research and found out that tara strong WASN'T Maka from soul eater. In fact she wasn't even in it that was laura bailey, so your comment of twilight being maka is not true. Nevertheless good video though, even if i disagree with alot of you problems. ps, i am a brony
zombieportal1 1 day ago
1:55 The land of LAND of horses
misteridiot 2 days ago
Can't help but LOL at the intro after having seen it pooped so many times.
HylianMadness 2 days ago
I've never seen the show at all, and this review may or may not count as seeing the first episode. I still don't understand why so many people can enjoy this and I'm afraid that I will never like it.
TB26 3 days ago
@TB26 It's not up to me to tell you to like this show. I, for one, was skeptical about checking this show out because, well, how could millions of grown men like My Little Pony? I gave it a shot and I found that I actually like it myself. Now that doesn't happen to everyone, mind you, and I respect that.
This review only contains snippets from the first two episodes. If you want to give this show an earnest shot, go ahead. Just don't expect anything out of it. I didn't.
Take care
Polydunami 2 days ago
Josh has got a feminan sid-
Josh: Ka-BOOOOOOOOOOOM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!LOL
nomoreturtles 3 days ago
10:25 Hooray for improper gramer
nomoreturtles 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
joshscorcher is the reason im a brony! at first i was happy to see it get critisized as i was a hater then, after a while i got into the artstyle, but not the show. when he released his review of season 2 i got ALOT more interested. Eventually I got so torn on weather or not to watch the show that i made a promise to myself to either watch the show that day or never see it at all. I watched it and i am soooo happy i did! and of course i have josh to thank!
fluttershy is best pony in my opinion.
NoMorePopMusic 4 days ago
Comment removed
NoMorePopMusic 4 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did you notice how, if Rarity, Applejack, Pinky Pie, Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash are suppoused to be the so-called "Elements of Friendship", that they have a hard time BEING friends?
LetsPlayGuy12 5 days ago
Comment removed
LetsPlayGuy12 5 days ago
Thank god im not a brony
GGamer745 6 days ago
you had several facepalms. so do most of us.
also those were the first 2 episodes. it gets much better later. i am not hating, i enjoyed this review. a lot, actually. it's a nice unbiased review. but i just belive the show is much better represented in other episodes.
durzafire22 1 week ago
facepalms. we do that a lot. most of us do anyway.
durzafire22 1 week ago
Wait, they changed it?! I never got past the first two seconds before!
fightingleaf 1 week ago
Yay! You reviewed the show! Now I don't have to!
fightingleaf 1 week ago
From 3:10 on watching his reaction showed the transformation of the brony process begin it was enjoyable and also cautious so it never happens to me nothing against bronies
Haloplaya011 1 week ago
he is a brony
xephers3 1 week ago
Excellent review. I'm not a fan of all of the songs but, their better then other songs on kids shows today. I thought your review was accurate and very fair. (this coming from a brony)
BRO-HO....nevermind. x3
kirara2516 1 week ago
alright...I'm gonna cave. LET'S DO THIS!!!
*plays first episode* *cries a little*
AquaSpartan743 1 week ago
I NEED HELP!!! I think I'm becoming a Brony :'(
morrisl123 2 weeks ago
@morrisl123 welcome to the club.
kingofmonsters14 1 week ago
@kingofmonsters14 welcome to the herd actually...
NoMorePopMusic 4 days ago
Bro-hoof, Josh?
Xaniede 2 weeks ago
awwwwwww (SLAP) priceless!!!!
polarity345 2 weeks ago 6
i didnt realise it was maka, till he pointed it out, now all i can imagine is maka sayiong these things that twilight says
duffthebeerslayer 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
awesome review but the mantcore is not Greek its a monster from Persian mythology
seleinathescorpio 2 weeks ago in playlist Favorite videos
Im not a brony. But how the hell did i get here
bluelizard44 3 weeks ago
You know, most bronies will probably agree with every single point you mentioned there :3
asifilich 3 weeks ago
Brohoof /)(\
mrchinchillaman99 3 weeks ago
dude you are awsome and you make an awsome review
007StopMotion 3 weeks ago
as a fellow brony I respect your opinion.... i respect ur video and your humor against it which btw made me LOL....... i love this videos and all others........ i can haz brohoof? :D
amno96 3 weeks ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
it's good to see the fans taking this coll,there should be more people like you bronys in the world.
minsecous 3 weeks ago in playlist Mais vídeos de joshscorcher
I'm not a Broney but this review acualy made me think of the show as good.....still not a brony thoue so fuck that shit.
MrJaydawg1231 3 weeks ago
Don't you know stereotypes make EVERYTHING better?
CarbonCreed1 3 weeks ago
): they made one of the best beasts in Greek mythology look queer
MyBrothers3 3 weeks ago
Bear Grylls: When I was a little filly and the sun was going down...
Ludicrine 4 weeks ago
Find it funny how you compare Twilight to Maka when Maka can actually get along with people more quickly than Twilight. I can understand the whole bookworm thing.
My only question is, how is Krillen (spelling) from DBZ a side kick? I'd assume that Gohan would've been more of a side kick due to how much screen time he shows up as much as his Father. =/
pichugirl6 4 weeks ago
@pichugirl6 Krillin was a sidekick in Dragon Ball.
JadedLightning2387 3 weeks ago
@JadedLightning2387 He doesn't fight a whole lot ever since he fell in love with one of the Andriods. Then he gets a child.
pichugirl6 3 weeks ago
1. im also a brony
2. this revew is awesome
3. pinkie pie is creepy (i stupidly read cupcakes)
4. you can see my wingboner (im a fan of rarity)
5. rainbow dash is overglorifed (i stupidly read rocket to inasnity)
mehmarcus1995 1 month ago
Naruto
p96822 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
Naruto=Sonic What NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
speedster9898 1 month ago
@speedster9898
Believe It=You're Too Slow?
I see it.
laughingfurry 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
Taste the rainbow motha ***** made me LOL
lightningkatana10 1 month ago
As a Brony i have to say this was a very excellent Review.
I mean sure you don't like the Songs but i think its mostly a matter of taste because i for one like these Songs.
And yes i also was never a Fan of Nightmare Moon but its REALLY a close call if she is worse then Exdeath XD.
Besides the Pilot is not my favorite its more an Episode to know all these Characters there far better episodes in Season 1.
again great Review.
P.S Twilight Sparkle is best Pony :)
Sparkledash1 1 month ago 20
@Sparkledash1 No, Pinkie Pie is... But thats your opinion and this is mine and I respect that
dumtrainer 5 days ago
@Sparkledash1
How could anybody not like Exdeath???
Charmolution 5 days ago
You're review just totally summed up why I will NOT watch this show :D
rufusfan 1 month ago
Heh, I don't even need to love and tolerate. This review is really fair, and your reactions made me laugh.
LunarDarkrai 1 month ago
I respect your opinion, you tried the show, hell, even reviewed it, and you didn't like it. Being a brony myself, I am used to people who don't like the show calling me gay for liking the show, but how they say it is in one of the most idiotic way possible, example "U LIEK A SHOW ABOUT PONIEZ, UR A GEY FAGGIT" but you on the other hand, constructively reveiwed it and gave it credit where it was needed. Have a good day Mr. Scorcher, and here's a brofist.
From,
~Some randomguy on the internet
Randomguy2526 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
I can Tell he hated saying "My little Pony Friendship is Magic" at 1:18
SkeletorQ79 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
TASTE THE RAINBOW MOTHERFUCKER
BRONY POWER!
PyroAngel18 1 month ago
lol its funny how you needed to put a disclaimer at the beginning just so no one will hate you. i mean seriously if bronies really "loved and tolerated" then that wouldnt have been needed...
LAD170 1 month ago
wow those are the most epic ponys ever
edac111 1 month ago
I thought Soul Eater was an unknown anime
jackjack565656 1 month ago
Wow, an actual review, checking story, chars and animation without biased opinions from neither side, nice Work there Josh!
Also i loved your face when they showed the manticore... priceless xD
LuigiLonLon 1 month ago
Putting aside everything else, how the hell did a bunch of horses make a hat?
TheMechwar88 1 month ago
Doesn't equestrian technically mean people who ride horses, and the -ia suffix mean nation of? So Equestria means Nation of People who Ride Horses?
GenralMajors 1 month ago
Comparing Old Ponies and Friendship is Magic is like comparing Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog and Sonic SatAM.
ProkoLokor 1 month ago
How about "Do not hurt my friends!" and "You're going to LOVE ME!"
?
ProkoLokor 1 month ago
way to take one for the team josh
xixfas 1 month ago
Is it bad that I almost had the same thoughts as you?
Seriously, it felt like you were reading my mind while you were giving this review.
DragoSonicMile 1 month ago
Oh...and strangely enough, as much as I have seen Nightmare Moon's "NOOOO" coming...
Discord in Season 2 did the SAME thing (You know....yelling "NOO")
But Discord did not shatter, he got epicly stoned
If they ever get to make a Season 3 (?) I am excited what Villain they use here....
LargeFG7777 1 month ago
To me it does not matter if Nightmare Moon is an unoriginal Villain or something, she has cool design.
Seriously how did they animate her Mane and Tail?!
LargeFG7777 1 month ago
Yes it is a guilty pleasure of mine as well, but I've learn to be a man to accept, love and tolerate. Even when I'm as embarrassed as hell to admit I'm a brony
PrinceHeru 1 month ago
Brony pride!!!
zeldafreak247 1 month ago
See, if this didn't have the groan moments, had no musical moments, was in an anime style, had people instead of ponies, and was originally made in Japan nobody would care about it that much.
ShadowJay11 1 month ago
I just realized something: Nightmare Moon was sealed away for 1000 years. HOW IS CELESTIA STILL ALIVE THEN??? And don't say that it's because ponies live a long time, because Applejack has a grandmother and she does NOT seem like she's 1000 years old!
MaverickHunterZero75 1 month ago
@MaverickHunterZero75
MAGIC BITCH!
ironsparten558 1 month ago
@MaverickHunterZero75 She might as well be a god. It just kind of works. Celestia derives from Celestial, which means pertaining to heaven. So yeah.
AlbinoFlareon 1 month ago
what the heck were you repeating after Fluttershy was licked to death by the Manticore?
kingofmonsters14 1 month ago
@kingofmonsters14 Presentation. over and over, presumably to remind himself not to have a HHHNNNNNGGG attack at fluttershy. Or whatever amounts to a HHHNNNGG attack in his case. More like a "that's cute" attack in that case.
Dragodonv2 1 month ago
TASTE THE RAINBOW MUTHERF**KER
pacjac03 1 month ago 33
@pacjac03 that made my day. xD
sedohrable 1 month ago
Who are your favorite ponies, Josh? My favorites would probably be Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie, and Fluttershy
dethbreth8 1 month ago
"and I will hurt you."
*flamethrower* "mrph hrmph hrpm..."
Pindooli 1 month ago
Just because it has ponies does not mean it's for girls only. Look at SonictheHedgehog17 for example. He used My Little Pony reference in his a results of top 15 most hated video game characters and it make sense. Hey, joshscorcher, what's your favorite cartoon show and your thoughts of My Little Pony.
ThundertheHedgehog21 1 month ago
@ThundertheHedgehog21 he meant that was the target audience doesn't mean it's for them. just aimed at them
iateyursandwiches 1 month ago
Whats a Bronie?
SSBBMN64 1 month ago
@SSBBMN64 A Bronie is a teen to adult male fan of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic.
Necronator1 1 month ago
@SSBBMN64 @Necronator1 *brony
DrNazus 1 month ago
BROHOOF!
Specter053 1 month ago
The vocabulary? I dont get it, would it be alright if you explain?
I just dont know what that means, unless your saying the lyrics annoy you. If its not that, then I dont get it.
jm7940 1 month ago
God, I want to watch this show, but if someone found out I would be screwed.
TheSuperEricWarshot 1 month ago
josh: oh no the theme song...
OMG THEY CHANGED IT!
me: But im gonna sing it!
josh: (dramatic 10 second pause) KA-BOOOOOOOOOOOOM!!!
Tobi3440 1 month ago
I must say, great review. You have some good, understandable points, even though I disagree on most points with you because my personal experience was so different.
Stylesdontmatter 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Just as an experiment, let's try the Joker from batman in that checklist (not saying your point is invalid, just for fun)
Boast: check.
Monologue: check.
Laugh: Duh
NOOOOO!: none come to mind, but most likely.
dcfreak222 1 month ago
Comment removed
dcfreak222 1 month ago
death battle rocks
AquaSpartan743 1 month ago
*brohoof* (^.^) /)
glennvanzutphen 1 month ago
12:00 twilight even agrees with you about the song
joe888ism 1 month ago
great review, but i still hate the show so bad
toon10001two 1 month ago
the first part of the song is extremely fucking painful
MrHeadHopper 1 month ago
I still think my favorite quote is a scene where Fluttershy comments to Pinkie Pie that she's a year older. Why? Same voice actor, I thought it was a funny split-personality moment.
CrescentGuard 1 month ago
"this is the Fiery Joker review of My Little Pony: Friendship is....Magic." Wow, I think a part of me just died inside.
Redfeather624 1 month ago
Have you seen the Total Drama series? It is a hilarious show.
pikachu138 1 month ago
oh, just saying you're going to review this had to hurt.
kingofmonsters14 1 month ago
and everytime i hear applejack i think of this little voice.
...........my names ellis............. well aint that a load of shit........
ThePlazmaplayer 1 month ago
im gonna wiki groan and see if its just like i think. yep. it was what i expected. well i groan for these things
girly movies.
sonic franchise.
getting pwnd.
ThePlazmaplayer 1 month ago
wait. but natsu is NOTHING like naruto
declinefan 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
hey, fiery joker.
BROHOOF!
MrCyberSiren 1 month ago
@MrCyberSiren He's gonna hurt you now.
*pulls out video camera*
Necronator1 1 month ago
@Necronator1 YAY!
MrCyberSiren 1 month ago
thumbs up if u celebrated during the title theme like the fiery joker :D
ExplodingTurtle1 1 month ago
I am a Brony, and I thought this was HILARIOUS!
Foehammer18 1 month ago
Brohoof ^^
LordJike 1 month ago
well im halfway through and i now understand you have nothing but nice things to say. i believe if you have feelings for a show (love/hate) it is worth watching. because you get a kick out of it ether way.
ATwiz02 1 month ago
5:07 WT.......F?
Tobi3440 1 month ago
I love your reactions XD
kaampanita1675 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
10:48 Oh god your face cracked me up so badly.
Codyray1992 1 month ago
Oh dear, I can't remember who the red-head is in that category: The Naruto. Anyone fill me in please?
Codyray1992 1 month ago
@Codyray1992 its the main character from fairy tale i dont remember his name though
supermetaknight9000 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
@supermetaknight9000 Oh yeah! Thanks!
Codyray1992 1 month ago
Wait, what is a bro-hoof? Is it like a fist bump?
bluepenguin884 1 month ago
Love your review as a Normal typical Brony I love when people just hate on the show especially my dad who won't even look at it I discovered MLPFIM by accident but fell in love with it so much I have Action Figures (or dolls mistermed), wake up specifically on weekends for new episodes, and for Christmas got a T-shirt that says "BRONY" just laughed at your jokes although I don't know what "bro hoof" is thats the 2nd time I've heard that I Love it mostly cause it shows me how to be a friend =' )
mongo0206 1 month ago
15:22
...Captain Planet.
I almost woke my family up laughing at that.
PylonLulz 1 month ago
I don't agree with everything you hate about the show but for sure this was one excellent review! I mean someone saying bad stuff about the show not because its a girls cartoon or its my little pony but rather watching it and explaining your likes and dislikes about the show made my day! broho-... ill skip that.
FrostedCP 1 month ago
Did you see the one where Pinkie Pye sings a parody of California Gurls?
southplush 1 month ago
To anybody who searches for the Cupcakes after this (at least on Youtube):
For gods sake, at least make it "Cupcakes song", not just "Cupcakes", or else you will find one correct one buried in a fuckload of readings of the creepypasta (yup, it's named Cupcakes), and even animations.
PS: If you like creepypastas, check out creepypasta.wikia.com and type in "Cupcakes". That's the one that animations based on.
kuba65475 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
I like your opinions and great criticism, dude.
HydreigonMaster 1 month ago
I feel like you would like Return of Harmony with Discord much better.
AFlockOfBeagulls 1 month ago
@AFlockOfBeagulls
no...only a little better.
joshscorcher 1 month ago
@joshscorcher -__- i watched the two first episodes... how did my job get this far....
ThePlazmaplayer 1 month ago
I liked all the examples you used for the characters :)
GaiaNex 1 month ago
You better not ask him to bro-hoof. He's in the marine core...he can kill you with a napkin.
c00lstuff1 1 month ago
Honestly, I watch the show because it is shamefully awesome :D And the animation is fantastic.
Cactusman96 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I still think the thing sucks. But still, I like the Nostalgia Critic style review of this. Some of your reactions made me laugh. My opinion? The smooth animation and bright colors sucks most people right in when they don't realize how unoriginal it is, I will say it has effort, but still, THIS SHOW IS FOR LITTLE GIRLS. WHY ARE 20 YEAR OLD MEN FALLING IN LOVE WITH THIS SHOW?!?! IT MAKES NO SENSE.
PaintingKid43219 1 month ago
@PaintingKid43219
Because people are secure in their masculinity and aren't afraid to watch cartoons? Because maybe they enjoy the underlying themes of friendship and the lessons they can learn? Because they can watch this "little girls show" and not bleed their brains out?
This show is more mature than Spongebob, or anything Nickelodeon or Disney Channel puts out. That's why people enjoy it.
joshscorcher 1 month ago 34
@joshscorcher "There's just this sense to it, this atmosphere, this real likability to this world that they've created. It can be very laid back and very slow paced, but at the same time, these characters are just so interesting and nice that you really enjoy spending time with them. You don't care if not much is going on, you could just have a conversation with anyone of these people and you'd probably be very satisfied." - Doug Walker (Review of Winnie the Pooh from Disneycember)
electricmastro 1 month ago
@joshscorcher It's good to see that although you may not like the show, you still can see it's finer points. Great job!
Necronator1 1 month ago
@joshscorcher This show is NOT more mature than Avatar, which was released on Nickelodeon.
TheSuperEricWarshot 1 month ago
@joshscorcher Hey! Kim Possible WAS mature!
Qjackful 1 month ago 3
@joshscorcher Say, thanks Joker, that was a nice gesture for you to defend the Brony position against some troll. I also complement you on your logical and thoughtful response with relevant examples as well.
Thank you, doubtless everypony else in the herd thanks you too.
Dragodonv2 1 month ago
@PaintingKid43219 Next you will say you didn't watch powerpuff girls pffffhffhfhfhfhf....
keggie09 1 month ago in playlist More videos from joshscorcher
@PaintingKid43219 *semi-facepalm*
HerpDerp777 1 month ago
WHO IS MISSING HER SPOTS. (animators, we are dissapionted.
Darklegobrick13 1 month ago
So, Fluttershy reminds you that the show is for Little Girls, and you used to be just like Fluttershy? Uhm.... No Comment.
dontKILLmyCAT 2 months ago
I want to know one thing...how do they hold onto anything without fingers?
noname12327 2 months ago
@noname12327
Suspension of disbelief.
joshscorcher 2 months ago 24
@noname12327
The magic of marshmallow hooves.
Charmolution 1 month ago
YOUR IN THE MARINE CORE MAN!!!
Dean11link 2 months ago
@Dean11link
What does that have to do with anything?
joshscorcher 2 months ago 3
@joshscorcher mmmmmmmm.........nothing.....
Dean11link 2 months ago
i agree with u 100% just because it has good visual effects interesting plot and funny moments doesnt defeat the annoying little girl part of it and lol josh i was like that to when i was young and i hate seeing a reflection
434444334 2 months ago
When you commented on Nightmare Moon's design, I just realized how much of a bitch it must be to get that helmet on with that frickin' huge horn coming out of her forehead.
Charmolution 2 months ago
lol at 15:22
TLtimelord 2 months ago
You did not 'Daww at Fluttershy.
YOU DID NOT 'DAWW AT FLUTTERSHY.
DemonioPenguino 2 months ago
and now for random facts 101.
in the blue dragon video game made in 2006, Kluke, the female protagonist, is voiced by Tara Strong, the same voice actor as Twilight. i found this out shortly after she screamed in game "If i let go I'm gonna die."
That makes it twice in two rooles that she has had to say roughly the same phrase.
Tell me what you think of this and help contribute to the count.
dadsbigman 2 months ago
i feel like all video reviewers are just Nostalgia Critic rip-offs... idk why, lol.
LetsPlayGuy12 2 months ago
This has to be the only review that has LOGIC. I like the series but I don't really like the fanbase. (I know R34 exists for a lot of things, but MLP R34? Seriously?) I agree with most of your points, and The show itself isn't a bad show like most of the cartoons aired nowadays. I do admit, i didn't like some of the scenes, sometimes the voice acting is bad, but those are some minor gripes that I have. Overall, Brohoof? -I am a sadomasochist-
TheKiraDood5 2 months ago
it's funny how Pinky Pie reminds so much of myself
TLtimelord 2 months ago
The first dude I know who watched the show and didn't end up obsessing over it
TLtimelord 2 months ago
brohoof....
spacecardswell 2 months ago
5:40 - 5:43
If you pause at just the right moment, you can get the tiny pony to do an evil face.
TheSuperEricWarshot 2 months ago
i have to say this it is better then most modern american shows like family guy, simpsons, and other things because for 1 thing it isn't constantly trying to be funny all the time which pisses me off if i want to laugh ill go watch a comedian that actually takes time to think of things i guess i like thought put into humor and 2 IT HAS PLOT which most american shows lack these days thats why anime is so popular because it has a balance of humor and plot so that it is telling a story so yea......
eperger 2 months ago 2
@eperger
dat plot
RasecVonWizzlbang 2 months ago
@TheAtticus19
I meant the Generator Rex thing.
triplepogi2009 2 months ago
3:02 - Could be worse, you could be named Doug during a certain time period. *Cough* 1991 - 1992 /1996-1997 *Cough*
5:43 - Focus, Focus, Focus, Focus, Foc... Aw crap!
10:47 - Calm'er down dude.
11:40 - A little too late to say that because....
11:50 - too late.
12:38 - I see no Nostalgia Critic reference there.
13:55 - *Insert price is right loss music here*
17:50 - Get out of my face! or your face, or Whatever.
DarkTwoLion 2 months ago
@joshcorcher Please review TheReturn of Harmony
2010SKG 2 months ago
@TheAtticus19
Hell yeah I agree with this guy.
triplepogi2009 2 months ago
Comment removed
TheAtticus19 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@triplepogi2009 With the review thing or the Generator Rex thing?
TheAtticus19 2 months ago
Sailor Moon rip-off
legefy 2 months ago
Josh, I really enjoyed your review. Keep it up, bro!
ScottPilgrimfan37 2 months ago
You ,my good sir, are definitely respectable. Most people who don't like this show usually give bad reasons. You point out legitimate things, that make sense. Others just kinda say "This show sucks because its gay" Or something like that. While I do enjoy this show, I can respect your opinion. And thank you for actually using logic... Unlike other people on the Internet who act like dumb asses.
Soupr5 2 months ago
I had the same reaction to Rarity...:facepalm:
coltsfanca 2 months ago
@coltsfanca Oh and BTW...I saw the Fluttershy bit and when you facepalmed, I thought: "NO WAY IS HE GOING TO MAKE FUN OF FLUTTERSHY!?! IDK IF I CAN TOLERATE THAT!!" then..."I used to be that!" hahahaha
coltsfanca 2 months ago