Fiona's intro is fresh and relevant yet so insync with the rest of the song. She sings it in G instead of F. Instead of singing 50 notes on everyother syllable, like so many do on star search, she keeps it real, but bending the key notes just enough to give the song even more feeling. (see Julia Nunes:"I wasn't Worried" or "I'll be back", c 4 ur selves how bending a single note with emotion, makes allthe difference in the world" So, this Cover is the best of all, for now, Jan. 1st, 2012.
love fiona!!! this is a far cry from the video" criminal" in 1998,,,, whether it is the softer side of her or the 90's version... she will always be my favorite SPOOKY GIRL !!!!!!!
She is so beautiful in every way. Her incredible & unique voice, her humble personality, her exquisite beauty, the depth of her spirit that shows through her words...Fiona leaves me speechless I just love her. What a sweet, talented, & humble woman;)
Sorry but it ain't the singer as much as the song.She even sounds flat on the low notes. Just sayin - give me Sophie tucker on this. I see ya'll pretty much think she's the nuts so don't hate me listen again..
@medmond6 I don't hate you. I followed your advice. I listened again. You're wrong.
It's the singer at least as much as it is the song.
It's because if you have a good singer and a good song, they collide. And they make me forget which of the two to appreciate. I like the whole lot. A lot.
@medmond6 It is the singer. You even note a singer in your comparison. If it wasn't the singer, YouTube would be fille with instrumentals. If you've heard a better versio of this song, it's because of the singer.
@medmond6 Yes but we haven't had Sophie around for quite a while...and yes there was and is no one like the Red Hot Momma but its admirable that a young woman is chosing to sing this and other songs from that period...and she aint bad.... so what if she went flat on the low notes.
Does she have a hired song writer or does she write her own songs? In today's music anyone can make a few a bucks in music most of it sucks ass. As for fiona she is here to stay as long as she wants her voice and style of singing can make a bad song worth listening to
@ghostifyable She writes her own music, aside from her numerous covers. Check out iTunes Originals – Fiona Apple (available you know where) for an interview with Fiona Apple where she discusses her motivation behind the lyrics and talks about a lot of her work.
She mentions once that writing music is an exhaustive process for her, and not something she always enjoys doing. I've always thought, if she should ever stop making albums, she'd make a tremendous jazz singer. I never get tired of her.
I never normally say songs are 'better' than the original, but her voice is really spectacular on this clip and she lives the nuances of the melody so perfectly, my favourite version of a jazz classic 90 years after the original :)
wow time flies! she was hot back in the 90's in terms of her popularity. then, didn't know where she went after that. sucks REAL singers aren't as popular today...a few but not people like Fiona.
Fiona, u r the greatest of all the women artits, every judgeable person knows...hope u r well and produce as wonderfull albums as u do...luv u... dont make fun of it i really do......since 1996 cos u got me straight in my heart...fingers crossed keep well, and i really luv ya, i know everyone says so but ireally do so... :) i am gonna be a dentist so if u got problem.let me know..fan discount.:) not that u need some...just want to see u ;) keep on, fiona..ňu r the one of the men that r :-*ň
I had never heard of Mrs. Fiona Apple until four minutes ago. Is it possible to fall in love in just four minutes? What a voice, what a performance, what a mesmerizing natural beauty! My wife, whom I do love forever and a day, is blessed that Fiona & I live worlds apart :-)
Yes, this is an INCREDIBLE performance. If you are new to her please go get her last two albums Extraordinary Machine and When the Pawn.... Her debut Tidal also has some AMAZING songs on it (listen to "Never is a Promise" - NOW, especially if you like THIS performance) but in my opinion, nothing touches the two albums I mentioned which are so, so good. Not a single bad track on either of them. Amazing, amazing stuff.
@daj721 Those eyes kill me . . . I dated a girl who had the same eyes . and those lips .. First time I really paid much attention to Fiona it was spooky how similar the two were . . .
She's so unpretentious...her contemporaries can't come close to her. She has a heart, and because of that, it's probably been stomped on alot..bless her, may she prevail and come out stronger because of it.
@axelrodxx It's like a creek, or groan, or they have too much styling. That jazzy vocal style is NICE but it's over used sometimes. Also there's this fad where women sort of sound mumbly. Yarg.
What's the setting, just out of curiosity, and when was this? A bit of context would be nice; what a professional presentation in such a very different venue.
@dellaroux I believe this is at a music store doing a promotion for her CD. Probably Extraordinary Machine. Wouldn't that be something to see her this close and personal?
hey guys ... it would be much appreciated if anyone could check out a vid of a song i posted possibly gimmie some feedback and let me know if i should post more.. much love, - a starving artist.
I love how at the end it sounds like she's gonna say "I love you, too." But she stops at "you." One of the best things about Fiona is that she wears her vulnerabilities and insecurities on her sleeve. When someone allows themselves to be vulnerable in front of me, it's a display of affection, trust, and love. The feeling is mutual, Fiona. To my last dying breath.
this is first time listening to her,she is genius!!!!! what a beautiful lady and amazing voice. She modernized SophieTucker's version with freshness and new feeling. I'm amazed
Live she's even better than digital.
127eadgbe 1 day ago
I am in love.
WendyLaurenE 4 days ago
Um...the number of notes you sing to a syllable is sort of a non-issue, you know? It's how you sing them....
dellaroux 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Help get Fiona's 4th album out! Sign the petition so SONY will release the music that Fiona has already recorded!
Google- "Fiona Apple Change.org" and sign the petition!
MrLlieno 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Help get Fiona's 4th album out! Its Free Fiona 2.0! Sign the petition so SONY will release the music that Fiona has already recorded!
Google- "Fiona Apple Change.org" and sign the petition!
MrLlieno 2 weeks ago
Her songs see so hones it's a nice change from the usual stuff I listen to
mrstevost 3 weeks ago
wow...
phyphorous 3 weeks ago
Fiona's intro is fresh and relevant yet so insync with the rest of the song. She sings it in G instead of F. Instead of singing 50 notes on everyother syllable, like so many do on star search, she keeps it real, but bending the key notes just enough to give the song even more feeling. (see Julia Nunes:"I wasn't Worried" or "I'll be back", c 4 ur selves how bending a single note with emotion, makes allthe difference in the world" So, this Cover is the best of all, for now, Jan. 1st, 2012.
MrPanetela 3 weeks ago in playlist after you've gone
@MrPanetela
I totally agree that it's a relief that she doesn't sing 50 notes on every other syllable, like many jazz singers do.
But I disagree that she sings in the key of G. This is definately in the key of C.
All the best :-)
aortsx 2 weeks ago
@aortsx Key of C confirmed.
magic4matt 2 weeks ago
i met her last night backstage at Largo..... AAMMMAAAZZIINNGGG
videofunfuntime 3 weeks ago
this girl is just awesome, there isnt a soul who doesnt relate to her music!
halenny 1 month ago
Great singer, the most expressive eyes ever seen real soul mirrors
minnowpd 1 month ago
so good ! i love her <3
sanzbonella 2 months ago
Bessy Smith- the true originator of this song
DJNation 2 months ago
@DJNation Well technically Marion Harris, but neither of them wrote it anyway.
CoolerKing37 1 month ago
love fiona!!! this is a far cry from the video" criminal" in 1998,,,, whether it is the softer side of her or the 90's version... she will always be my favorite SPOOKY GIRL !!!!!!!
courtcol 2 months ago
She is so beautiful in every way. Her incredible & unique voice, her humble personality, her exquisite beauty, the depth of her spirit that shows through her words...Fiona leaves me speechless I just love her. What a sweet, talented, & humble woman;)
Bless her.
angeleyes86ebby 2 months ago 6
I have been in love with this woman for nearly a decade.
zarasynn 2 months ago 4
I really love the voice, she has style, but it's not the original, that's what I look for.
stuman62 3 months ago
Great but check out Dr Johns singing on Hugh Laurie's CD and see what that does to you!
egokingkeys 3 months ago
chills ..
GetLoko29 3 months ago
terrible ...the song is 100 times better than her ..not even close to touching it
budmusic 4 months ago
wow I love her voice
imhappywithmyself 4 months ago
That's a really cool video.
Rosalee9703 4 months ago
Sorry but it ain't the singer as much as the song.She even sounds flat on the low notes. Just sayin - give me Sophie tucker on this. I see ya'll pretty much think she's the nuts so don't hate me listen again..
medmond6 4 months ago
@medmond6 I don't hate you. I followed your advice. I listened again. You're wrong.
It's the singer at least as much as it is the song.
It's because if you have a good singer and a good song, they collide. And they make me forget which of the two to appreciate. I like the whole lot. A lot.
hminkema 4 months ago
@hminkema Normally i would agree with you - It just doesn't work for me in this instance but go ahead and enjoy. I do dig the piano though.
medmond6 4 months ago
@medmond6 You are obviously in denial :-) Could happen to the best of us.
hminkema 3 months ago
@medmond6 It is the singer. You even note a singer in your comparison. If it wasn't the singer, YouTube would be fille with instrumentals. If you've heard a better versio of this song, it's because of the singer.
BLACKWINGEDBEING 3 months ago
@medmond6 Yes but we haven't had Sophie around for quite a while...and yes there was and is no one like the Red Hot Momma but its admirable that a young woman is chosing to sing this and other songs from that period...and she aint bad.... so what if she went flat on the low notes.
miltsar 2 months ago
@miltsar OK
medmond6 2 months ago
Damn bitch where you at! Nearing on 7 years...
beatrixkiddo10439 4 months ago
@beatrixkiddo10439 LOL harsh but true i need more Fiona .. it's about time!
Malkmus99 4 months ago
A VERY Valiant attempt, but this song really needs a gruff voice like Bessie's.
Yoseman1 4 months ago
Does she have a hired song writer or does she write her own songs? In today's music anyone can make a few a bucks in music most of it sucks ass. As for fiona she is here to stay as long as she wants her voice and style of singing can make a bad song worth listening to
ghostifyable 4 months ago
@ghostifyable She writes her own music, aside from her numerous covers. Check out iTunes Originals – Fiona Apple (available you know where) for an interview with Fiona Apple where she discusses her motivation behind the lyrics and talks about a lot of her work.
She mentions once that writing music is an exhaustive process for her, and not something she always enjoys doing. I've always thought, if she should ever stop making albums, she'd make a tremendous jazz singer. I never get tired of her.
kruks 4 months ago
In this present day, this comes close to a Bessie Smith vintage session. I am very impressed.
taildragger53 4 months ago
She had so many off the album songs!! Wish there was someplace i could download them and have it on my itunes. Gah. Love her.
LoveSpiritLife 4 months ago
yes it's possible
whostolesnoodle 4 months ago
I love this woman, what a great performance!
MrCurtishay 4 months ago
I never normally say songs are 'better' than the original, but her voice is really spectacular on this clip and she lives the nuances of the melody so perfectly, my favourite version of a jazz classic 90 years after the original :)
Butterfliesandzebras 4 months ago 3
Why should someone who is blessed with good looks also be blessed with a singing voice.
Surely it should be shared out a bit better?
andreaneilcmc 5 months ago
There isn't any red haha
GraceWasntHere 5 months ago
Hope your wife feels that way about someone, you jackass
SmashBox73 5 months ago 2
@SmashBox73 Don't get carried away, sonny. That 'someone' won't be you. My wife has a sense of humor.
hminkema 4 months ago
Comment removed
rbf0621 5 months ago
Comment removed
rbf0621 5 months ago
Canta como una cabra
luisitosax 5 months ago
@luisitosax que emvidiosa eres y que idiota ; pide perdon a Dios . Solo el podra .
oirdiv 5 months ago
Comment removed
luisitosax 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@oirdiv Ok, lo hare, pero...canta como una cabra
luisitosax 5 months ago
@luisitosax Troll
llickthestars 5 months ago
@llickthestars a tus ordenes jefe..jejeje
luisitosax 5 months ago
@luisitosax Jefa en todo caso.
llickthestars 5 months ago
@llickthestars jefa
luisitosax 5 months ago
She is really beautiful and an amazing artist....simply great!
ChrisDstrict 5 months ago
I love this song!
fivepercentjuice 5 months ago
I think I'm in love...
Pannemat 5 months ago
jeepers creepers aint that gal got beautiful peepers lol!!
49mrjd 6 months ago
I thought this was great. Except for all the heads. Better for listening. I'm sure Amy Winehouse heard this.
dasbigboy 6 months ago
so this is where selena gomez and ashley tisdale got the idea it's ok to butcher songs!!! foreshame fiona.....
doobeedoo58 6 months ago
wow time flies! she was hot back in the 90's in terms of her popularity. then, didn't know where she went after that. sucks REAL singers aren't as popular today...a few but not people like Fiona.
rbmt3rd2007 6 months ago
All I have to say is thank goodness that guy had a flat-top.
MadeOopsi 6 months ago 32
@MadeOopsi hahahahahah true!!!
tahoebound98 2 months ago
Fiona, would you be my son's new mommy?
renomotlex 6 months ago 2
STUNNING performance! Raw talent straight up. She IS an extraordinary machine!
kristy2769 6 months ago
her eyes are stunning.
streetfootballer100 6 months ago 2
Fiona, u r the greatest of all the women artits, every judgeable person knows...hope u r well and produce as wonderfull albums as u do...luv u... dont make fun of it i really do......since 1996 cos u got me straight in my heart...fingers crossed keep well, and i really luv ya, i know everyone says so but ireally do so... :) i am gonna be a dentist so if u got problem.let me know..fan discount.:) not that u need some...just want to see u ;) keep on, fiona..ňu r the one of the men that r :-*ň
iggycfc 6 months ago
I had never heard of Mrs. Fiona Apple until four minutes ago. Is it possible to fall in love in just four minutes? What a voice, what a performance, what a mesmerizing natural beauty! My wife, whom I do love forever and a day, is blessed that Fiona & I live worlds apart :-)
hminkema 6 months ago 60
@hminkema Then you'd better hope she doesn't read your ' in love' stuff' mate LOL.
loai050 4 months ago
@hminkema YOU MEAN 3 MONTHS AGO? JK
dbarroga 3 months ago
@hminkema:
Yes, this is an INCREDIBLE performance. If you are new to her please go get her last two albums Extraordinary Machine and When the Pawn.... Her debut Tidal also has some AMAZING songs on it (listen to "Never is a Promise" - NOW, especially if you like THIS performance) but in my opinion, nothing touches the two albums I mentioned which are so, so good. Not a single bad track on either of them. Amazing, amazing stuff.
LanIost 3 weeks ago
very moving writing veggie..
razso007 6 months ago
She has the most amazing eyes i've ever seen
daj721 6 months ago
@daj721 Those eyes kill me . . . I dated a girl who had the same eyes . and those lips .. First time I really paid much attention to Fiona it was spooky how similar the two were . . .
crazycrow76 6 months ago
paquita barrio's daughter!!!
salbanebala 7 months ago
She's so unpretentious...her contemporaries can't come close to her. She has a heart, and because of that, it's probably been stomped on alot..bless her, may she prevail and come out stronger because of it.
grannynara 7 months ago
Do you see how much passion and anger she put into this sweet song? You can see her pain in her eyes.
xoxolizzygirlxoxo 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you is completely beautiful
49mrjd 7 months ago
I am a customer of Brighthouse networks so I can't actually see this video--won't play for my current subscription rate!
fungibleone 7 months ago
dapppaura!
GianMarcoTavazzani 7 months ago
Pretty good camera work given the circumstances. Also: great performance.
pgk2006 8 months ago
I wanna be her bassist/boyfriend.
bassistdc 8 months ago 3
wow !!!!
49mrjd 8 months ago
What a voice...
jbikemoore 8 months ago
She's beautiful and so talented! I LOVE YOU, FIONA!
cleanpalette 8 months ago 3
I wish she was around influencing female vocalists who do that stupid thing with their voice, you know the thing. CLEAR VOCALS PLEASE!
faithm 8 months ago
@faithm What thing?
axelrodxx 8 months ago
@axelrodxx It's like a creek, or groan, or they have too much styling. That jazzy vocal style is NICE but it's over used sometimes. Also there's this fad where women sort of sound mumbly. Yarg.
faithm 8 months ago
@faithm If anything, it's Fiona doing a jazzy thing with her voice - the way she phrases, the excellent sense of rhythm. You probably mean RnB thing.
Aenokhe 8 months ago 2
@Aenokhe yeah maybe, :)
faithm 8 months ago
I miss Fiona Apple.
ardentluma 8 months ago
Actually, Bessie Smith - Fiona Apple, for this song. Imo. Better voice and I feel more emotion.
salvmon1 8 months ago 2
Fiona's good. But Bessie did it better.
DutchKalhoun 9 months ago
Great.
Featureman 9 months ago
She is very true with her feelings. Yeah!!! girl.
Lynmitramalapitan 9 months ago
She truely is beautiful.
paleblack1989 9 months ago 3
she has something special
dolchi21 9 months ago 51
This has been flagged as spam show
@dolchi21 sure she does:)
cityoficecream 9 months ago
Awesome cover! Thanks for posting this!
lidia4u 9 months ago
I love her. I sure hope she comes out with some new music soon. Its been a long while now.
lewis3265 9 months ago
God, she is so incredibly beautiful. What a voice, what talent. I am so grateful for her and her music.
Joyandblissniss 9 months ago 2
@Joyandblissniss I've heard rumor of a new album soon. ;o Let's hope so.
paleblack1989 9 months ago
Comment removed
handoveryourcookies 10 months ago
Wow, phenomenal cover! Her voice is so compelling here (always), and her face, so captivating.
handoveryourcookies 10 months ago 2
What's the setting, just out of curiosity, and when was this? A bit of context would be nice; what a professional presentation in such a very different venue.
dellaroux 10 months ago
@dellaroux I believe this is at a music store doing a promotion for her CD. Probably Extraordinary Machine. Wouldn't that be something to see her this close and personal?
MegaWhiner 9 months ago
Coon sanders sings this song! :)
Titanic19127 10 months ago
her eyes....
alko053 10 months ago
אין יותר יפה מהשיר הזה
anatrotem 10 months ago
אין יותר יפה מהשיר הזה
anatrotem 10 months ago
what a voice f*** all these pop star studio voices :)
treelove35 10 months ago 2
what a voice f all these pop star studio voices :)
treelove35 10 months ago
wow what a wonderful voice !
mishallka1 10 months ago
she a bit wierd, but amazing at the same time. very retro
loopylottieloo96 10 months ago
Beautiful!!!
gregonline6506 10 months ago
Fiona h monadikh moy agaph
petrospetridis2 10 months ago
She looks a bit like the Olsen twins.
megustaverlas 10 months ago 3
Thank you i love you more. cya later ;)
megadethzo6 10 months ago
hers is the best version! love this one the most! really really touching...
xingchunmeng 10 months ago
francisca valenzuela
pompint 10 months ago
FRANCISCA VALENZUELA not Fiona Apple
pompint 10 months ago
@pompint no, that is fiona apple.
bradandrews007 10 months ago
this is it, one of the best voices around!!!
jerebenok81 10 months ago
Her voice just kills me.
velconstantcraving 10 months ago 2
WOW.....just WOW!
ncc1968 10 months ago
I'm speechless...
wideeyewonder 11 months ago
I'm not gonna lie, I have a complete girl crush on Fiona.
TheMelamia 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
guu16 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey guys ... it would be much appreciated if anyone could check out a vid of a song i posted possibly gimmie some feedback and let me know if i should post more.. much love, - a starving artist.
SethFailsafe420 11 months ago
I´m in love with this girl
jornybear 11 months ago
@jornybear get in line behind me
whathoney73 11 months ago
Absolutely great performance!!! She is really something!!! Great video!!!
marinilce 11 months ago
When she sings "you'll miss the bestest pal you've ever had," all these people "whoo!" as if she had sung "the bestest sex you've ever had."
peterquint 11 months ago
Great job with the video, very cute!
lionsrose 11 months ago
love fiona.
jillyc06 11 months ago
nice voice
Timpeira1986 11 months ago
I love her, but not sure she loves me 2 :)
salihhajlakovic 11 months ago
Great to hear the contemporary singers cover the classics and actually do them justice.
susandiane311 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello I am a half American/half Danish singer songwriter living in Copenhagen Denmark inspired by PJ Harvey.
Check out my music if you like PJ HARVEY!
missscarlettemusic 11 months ago
1:46
I love when she sings like this. so powerful
Ficklesnoot 11 months ago
@Ficklesnoot I love that part too. Gives me chills every time.
kra112233 5 months ago
23 people had gone forever
fuku7 11 months ago
LOVE!!!!
MegaLuckyginger 11 months ago
She has such an adult and mature voice for such a young woman. Amazing and beautiful and so much soul.
baklnesbitt 11 months ago
Beautiful!!!!!!!! I love fiona!
ExesAndOwes 1 year ago
She looks particularly sexy in this video.
helicrashpro 1 year ago
I love how at the end it sounds like she's gonna say "I love you, too." But she stops at "you." One of the best things about Fiona is that she wears her vulnerabilities and insecurities on her sleeve. When someone allows themselves to be vulnerable in front of me, it's a display of affection, trust, and love. The feeling is mutual, Fiona. To my last dying breath.
veggievampire 1 year ago 61
Real star I discovered tonight.
Phenomenon.
Thank you, up-loader.
starywron 1 year ago
Wow. I love this girl.
chenarch 1 year ago
Yeah , by far the bbbbbbest
elduroduroduro 1 year ago
wow.
blueyandstormy 1 year ago
This version of "After You've Gone" ranks up there with Bessie Smith's - and that's saying a lot from me!
MissGoldenDreams13 1 year ago
watch her cover of Costello's song "I want you" it's amazing!!! better than original!
titti1506 1 year ago
what a fatalistic bitch :D
KingMinosxxvi 1 year ago
This is phenomenal. Love it :)
darklabrynthlily 1 year ago
cant stop playing this song...
anatrotem 1 year ago 5
She has so much charisma... An amazing cover and live here
macmule 1 year ago
I....I....I think... I'm in love.
KrummyBear 1 year ago
this woman is amazing indeed
munchrow 1 year ago
aww... shes a virgo... we're not compatible (as friends i mean)... but i really like her from her videos..hehe.
beautifulRHdrinker 1 year ago
Jon Brion.
cacashojas 1 year ago
great voice! FIONA APPLE
1234lillie 1 year ago
Shirley Manson, Sheryl Crow, Gwen Stefani, Sarah McGlaughlin, Liz Phair, Tori Amos, Jewel, Alanis. The Lillith Faire. It was great era.
naughtmoses 1 year ago 3
@naughtmoses ..now we are graced with cyrus ;perry;taylor cant sing a lick swift and tone deaf rihanna,alas the music has died
walterbrob 11 months ago
@walterbrob Looks to me like popular music reflects the attitudes of society at the time.
naughtmoses 11 months ago
I'm in love.
marakabi 1 year ago
this is first time listening to her,she is genius!!!!! what a beautiful lady and amazing voice. She modernized SophieTucker's version with freshness and new feeling. I'm amazed
spabrat 1 year ago 5
Marry Me
Rici011 1 year ago
what country is she , canada? beaultiful voice
hill10x 1 year ago
@hill10x she is from the united states-- born in manhatten, new york !!!!!
courtcol 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow i'm totally gay for her....love you fiona
pumpkinofevil 1 year ago
wow i¡m totally gay for her ...love you fiona
pumpkinofevil 1 year ago 4
Eu casava com essa mulher, e se ela me traísse eu tinha orgulho de ser corno!!
xD
danadrignoli 1 year ago 2
I have to find myself a woman like Fiona!
babblerabla 1 year ago 2
@babblerabla good luck
RangRing68 1 year ago
she is so beautiful and talented!
I can't wait to see her live again!
CKconcerts 1 year ago
she makes me fall in love!!! I won't ever leave you fiona!!! <3
luisfranchu 1 year ago
damn she has a deep voice..... like i think she would have a great voice for a broadway show..... then again thats just my opinion
tylerhaunted 1 year ago
I love her eyes
arianeh2 1 year ago