超級星光大道 第二季 20080104 偶像合唱抗壓賽 賴銘偉 你是我的眼

[wingchan0311]

我覺得yuming唱得比林宥嘉好聽耶~~

[billyleung1988]

沒真正看不到東西的人，又怎能深刻感受到什麼叫你是我的眼???

還是原唱最有感情

[Zeo2468]

我係認真地唔明點解會話林宥嘉唱得好

完全唔覺得佢理解首歌既feel

聽到好冇癮

[MrIanHsu]

尬的 我聽到蕭煌奇唱 都快哭了

[yolam88]

yoga同佢都唱得唔好,試問世上有誰唱你是我的眼好過蕭煌奇?­

[wingcwyee]

真的令我好感動

[WENDY999able]

yoga sing this song is better

[gogoaxn]

我也是比較喜歡這個版本

除了心目中第一的原唱的版本以外

[hellovics]

音樂自己喜歡就好, 沒必要去說服別人自己喜歡的才是最好的.

音樂也隨心情與經歷變化, 也許過一段時間, 你會喜歡另一個版本, 另一種的演繹.

[porkai]

Yoga not so good,he's too much cheating on this song

[zeegay]

anthony is better than yoga and him lol

[deathcocktai]

yoga is better for me, anthony is better than yuming

[GITA922]

Yuming的是比較跟蕭煌奇的接近

Yoga的是個人風格一點

不過還是Yuming的好聽

[214851279]

个人比较喜欢yoga的版本

[tea550]

唱的比林宥嘉好

[kittencat1983]

@tea550 始終原唱者唱得最好

[yuyumioe]

还是yoga唱得比较好听^@^

[lamhei7]

yoga is better than him

but he is not that bad

[lolboya]

good singing but not touching enough

[pat25wong]

Yuming is musically far more talented than Yoga but emotionally Yoga is better

[soldier492002]

嗓音比較搖滾~"~|||

可能這首歌比較跟他的感覺不符合吧@@"

每個人還是有每個人合適的歌@@"

[BlackRainZero]

sure. i don't expect you to know music when you don't know grammar.

[yjune90]

唱的不錯聽

可是不感動

[animefreak38]

yoga's version is the BEST!

[aznhihboi]

有点像阿信

[jolin802]

萧煌奇 老师，我真的爱你啊。你让我的人生太感动啦。真的好谢谢你！

[apgjnua]

我很喜歡蕭煌奇

[utmostfreedom]

something just lacking from yuming's performance

[BlackRainZero]

the emotion that yoga had.

[luisme719]

his beat was wrong... he could be much better....

i dont get the background music... why is it sooo soft at the beginning....?

[ivan808080]

好像有一点摇滚味道耶。。。@@

[fearofwomen]

amature

[secondkiller92]

i feel yuan chang zhe is better and yoga is also good

[EndLessSinner]

I find yoga singing techs better than him. But he still sing quite ok.

[everybody234]

還是覺得蕭煌奇老師好

[aznsugarp]

well hes professional like really professional but yuming is good too cuz like at least i cant sing like tat

[ispd123]

well professionalism is not the issue here, its how well you express this song. 蕭煌奇 use his life and feelings to sing this, Yuming lack the emotion and 感情

[kaying921]

胡嘉好好多...賴銘偉不可能超越宥嘉.....

[jackyyii]

May I know, how XiaoHuangQi get blind

[pipucanny]

萧煌奇是个曾见过色彩世界的人，所以我相信他的体验过的，普通人­应该难以体会吧。 我很欣赏他。

[poca828]

感情明顯弱很多

[dreamystars2]

i feel so bad about that blind dude....he makes me want to cry out loud ana the tears are dripping out.................

[yen8]

lol give it a break u guys, he is too nerves, not every 1 cant stand still on the stage

[iTaoTao751]

i really like yoga better, i was really moved by yoga, and not by this guy...

[leexiaoxin]

还是比林宥佳和萧煌奇差一点

[freezekingz]

hhmm.. prefers yoga's rendition.. but hes not bd either

[x2005901]

唱的很不錯喔

[hanbao1992]

好像觉得林宥嘉的比较好听耶！！

实话啦。。。

是我个人的立场啦！！

[ss32113]

都很好聽ㄏㄏ

[LEFTEGG2003]

2位風格不同啦~~~~~

[ucfk5m3]

賴銘偉加油..你的音域很寬.歌聲厚度也很棒~~~~~~

星光二班的賴銘偉.黃美珍.梁文音.曾沛慈.林道遠.魏茹昀

這六位歌手~是我們台灣美聲代表

希望你們星光二班六位歌手.能代表台灣.唱給全世界聽

能為我們台灣爭光.加油~~加油~~加油

[cloud1739]

for yuming , my opinion , he is singing tis like a brave blind man but for yoga special voice , he sound more touching then yumin

(no offence to yuming fans sorry)

[nana00sam]

best song...

[pipiwinny]

他不應該唱的那麼快~ 林宥嘉的跟蕭老師好聽!!!!!

[raikage90]

Yoga's version is uber good.. Yuming did well.. but just not as good

[a226344294]

請問一下銘偉是有降key嗎==請大家告訴我

[wenniewennie]

我有被感動到耶!套句倫老師的話"各花入各眼"

說"只是想show"就言重了,看的出他很崇拜蕭煌奇

所以唱蕭老師的歌他才會這麼緊張,我覺得他歌曲詮釋的感情面不是­沒有,而是比較內斂沒那麼外放,用MP3細細品味其實滿動人的,­但就不如外放的詮釋能一下子就吸引大家目光.

[ngycc93]

i so much prefer yoga's version. he does not seem to have his own vocals. yoga treated this song as his song and sung it with his own vocal which was so much nicer. this guy has to improve.

[xiang990]

ya..yoga sung that song with full of feelings

it's like the real feeling is there..

the 25 scores for yoga is for sure!

[staryshine94]

plus i really like yoga's version better. just simply more touching and heart-warming. love him the best!

yogo yogo go go go!

[staryshine94]

i really dont like the starting of this song. its suppose to be a slow, soothing one, but why had it became like this? and i feel that yuming's voice is really too hard and cold, wit no real feelings inside. yes, he does have all those techniques, but how far can techniques bring you too if you have no real feelings in the song at all? forcefully, i can say its nice when i listen for the first time. but a voice with no feelings will nv make me wan to listen it for the sec time.

[teeahber]

铭伟诠释得就象唱歌，就只是唱歌咯。完全没有感情

[him118]

不是有哭腔才叫做唱歌, 每一首歌唱出來也像哭一樣我也不覺得那種叫感情

[sevenandahalfinch]

YUMING SINGING IS TOO FLAT AND CASUAL.

[sevenandahalfinch]

蕭老師和yoga唱的一樣的感動。都令到我流下眼淚。

蕭老師是感人。感召到我的內心感情澎湃。剛強的；

yoga是動人。 輕輕的觸動我的情緒。柔軟的。

聽完yoga，再聽蕭老師，人不垮掉就難，簡直不能自拔。

然後再聽歐陽菲菲的"感恩的心" 去撫摸震動了的心靈。

[145938]

前段真的太快了。。

銘偉怎么能把它变成快版来唱啊？？！！

那怎样能表达这首歌的伤感啊？！

无可否认，銘偉音质很好。。。

不过，很想听蕭敬騰唱这首歌，

相信敬騰的表现会更感人。。。

[TheSecretSanta]

蕭煌奇比皇帝還要尊貴，當真令人好生佩服。

[bibiyew]

remember yoga sang this song during the PK?... Yuming need more tactics & power in singing this song. & he does not deliver enough of his emotions to express this song which i prefer yoga's & the original singer more...

[jazebell]

在听阿嫲的话的时候眼泪差一点就流下来了！

感动啊！真是感动！

[OnmyRedEye]

天啊听到蕭煌奇唱我当下就哭了，太感人了

[zyzyamy]

well...the point of the entire show 超級星光大道 was that singers put on a interpretation of what they think of the original song. SO, it is a fallacy to say yuming is bad singer. you can say...i didn't like his interpretation.

i mean...the point was to hear his interpretation. if you watched the show to see an exact copy of all the feelings and emotion you got from listening to the original one...then you basically wasted your time watching this show. you should just listen to the original song.

[cloud1739]

actually i tink xiao huang qis better (no offence)

[la0yves]

yuming have a relly good voice,he is really good at singing and talented,however his voice is not powerful enough and with full of love to reach my heart and soul

i recommend the original one and yoga's more than yuming's

[frankcoolnhot]

比较喜欢宥嘉的版本，他的声音可以打进人的心。

听铭伟唱我只感受到很厉害的唱功而已。

[ahfu2199]

他們唱出的感覺都不同,賴有夠含蓄

[asd123215]

銘偉唱的比一宥嘉的好多了，雖然宥唱的也很好聽，但銘偉唱得太神­了。

[arsenal46]

怎麼一開始的節奏怪怪的@@

[wenniewennie]

我比較喜歡Yuming的版本,他跟蕭煌奇唱的都比較有力量,

可能因為我本身也比較愛聽有Power的聲音,Yoga的版本就­是另一種味道,比較輕柔,這首歌有力量的詮釋比較對我的胃!

[ergkm87]

i prefer yo ga's version, he really sings into my heart... and yea, his voice is very unique..

[SaminozaL]

感覺賴銘偉的演唱是悲情的，而林宥嘉的演唱是感恩的，感動人的程­度自然不同

[asd123215]

下面有人說：感覺賴銘偉的演唱是悲情的，而林宥嘉的演唱是感恩的­，感動人的程度自然不同。

這話還真噁心，為何賴是悲情、林是感恩，主觀主到自已為是的境界­了。賴的情感很投入啊，為何那就不是感恩的情感，林唱也有情感，­但不能理解那一定是感恩的情感，明明是你因為歌詞的意境自己用那­種情感解釋才是事實吧。

[asd123215]

林宥嘉的演唱是感恩的，是你因為歌詞內容為感恩，所以自己加上的­註釋吧。我怎麼聽到賴唱的才是感恩

[cklleung]

3個版本都有它獨特的味道

各人都有自己的領悟呢

[yonglisen]

sejisoujirou 说的不错。。。我建议大家不妨听听yoga的"你是我的眼" 赖铭伟 的歌声就好像少了些什么

[Kwonzzz]

Yuming is not good. I don't know how he get Champion in season 2, but i definitely think that Wen Yin should be the champ. SHe is much much more better

[sejisoujirou]

我比較喜歡yoga的版本 我特地閉眼聽他們的演唱 yuming給我的感情畫面十分模糊 但yoga的感情畫面就刻畫得十分清楚明確把我帶進那個情景裡面 yuming的聲音其實很不錯但是當閉眼就會感到 他只想盡力的唱對每個字 但在句子的斷句、感情投放等都沒注意 反觀yoga在處理這歌的感情上的做法要成熟很多

音準等方面yuming明顯地有些音有偏差 yoga唱這歌時音是十分準 yuming的聲線是powerful 但沒有打進別人心裡 但yoga的歌聲則打進了別人心裡 相信兩人在這首歌的感情表達上的差距是很多人都得出來 看老師們在yuming唱時都沒有完全投入 但看yoga表演時老師們的表情是截然不同 相當的投入 連蕭煌奇老師也說yuming沒有把感情放在歌裡 反而yoga的你是我的眼則被很多老師評說十分感人，如小胖老師­、小玲老師、張宇老師、roger老師、辛曉琪老師，連黃小琥老­師也對yoga唱的你是我的眼讚譽有嘉 yoga的25分不是開玩笑的 yuming的表演也很棒但感情表達上真的比yoga弱 yoga在處理歌曲上真的十分棒 真是魔術師 可以不同於原唱的風格但也能把歌裡的感情充份表達出來

[sevenandahalfinch]

蕭老師和yoga唱的一樣的感動。都令到我流下眼淚。

蕭老師是感人。感召到我的內心感情澎湃。剛強的；

yoga是動人。 輕輕的觸動我的情緒。柔軟的。

聽完yoga，再聽蕭老師，人不垮掉就難，簡直不能自拔。

然後再聽歐陽菲菲的"感恩的心" 去撫摸震動了的心靈。

[tynnz926]

watch once cry once...

[anyams]

yuming gd..

[anyams]

ya, i prefer yuming style, more touching ...support yuming 4ever!!!!!1  yuming , go go go....

[jwerv]

i think he sings gud . but nt outstanding!

he is juz copying to xiao hwang qi

all the pitch and pronouncation .

other hands , yoga can sing wif his own style , he sang much more different wif the original singer ! yoga sings better than yuming

[hippokathy88]

i completely agree. yumin never sings with any passion... at least it doesnt show in his voice and this song is no exception. his version can never be compared to you jia's. you jia is just too unique. i loved both his live and cd versions.

[hyasuma]

Is not as good as the original. Not as powerful, I dont feel that he was blind, if he is willing to sing this song, he need to show more feeling

[francesyip85]

我覺得宥嘉唱的比較有fu..

賴銘偉好聽歸好聽

可是..

沒感覺= _ =

[weimeica]

正在看重播的超級星光大道，聽見賴銘偉正在唱「你是我的眼」

不自覺的被聲音吸引，不自覺的停下手邊正在敲鍵盤的手

眼睛、耳朵專注的緊緊抓住，然後，眼淚就掉下來了，一種無法解釋­的感動

謝謝Yuming，很棒的幾分鐘

[NK0927]

我比較喜歡Yuming的版本 比較有感情 也很Powerful,看來他真的很崇拜蕭煌奇 而Yoga的版本 軟軟的 鬆鬆的 好像跟歌詞意境連不起來