Added: 4 years ago
From: kuyashiinouwww
Views: 791,240
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,361)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Love this movie ♥

  • (33 - ) - neo nazi.

  • obviously, you all know that in the real life, in 'this scene' (I mean W. Szpilman vs Hosenfeld, 1945) he played Chopin nocturne in C sharp minor [just a curio ;) ]. Polański thought it would be more dramatic if he played ballade no 1 in the movie.

  • Chopin!!! Szopen!!! Chopin!!!

  • piękna scena... 

  • Ja cie pierdziu, Chopin  to miał łeb, aż mnie ciary przechodzą

  • 2.40 WHAT A DEEP MELODY

  • I love that scene. One of the best film music scenes ever. In terms of emotional charge and expression resembles a scene from "Philadelphia" when Tom Hanks explains the opera of Maria Callas 'La Mamma Morta'.

    The actor, who plays a Nazi in this scene is perfect. Male and deadly handsome. Shocks how he played the focus, without any words, only with his face, which express thousand of feelings. His calmness, intelligence... This is something amazing, otherworldly!

  • Chopin was prohibited under occupation in Poland. Germans blow up Chopin monument in 1940.

  • Comment removed

  • Polacy zawsze górą :)

  • This is definitely one of the best movies I have ever seen. I think I get emotional at this moment mostly because you know the man wants to throw him to the wolves but when he plays the piano... it's all done. I don't care if Brody was playing or not, I loved the whole film!!!

  • watch "Shoah"

  • you should listen to chopins ballade 1 played by kissin...amazing

  • one-sided zionist propaganda, but a great movie nonetheless.

  • please explain the term ''zionist''

  • @19Gui86 A Zionist is one who believes that the Jewish population should have their own home. David Ben-Gurion was one of the first who after world war II and with the help of Britain and America gained control of Palestine thus creating Israel. Many Modern day conspiracy theorists claim that "Zionists" control the world and are part of some new world order.

  • what does that make you

  • @19Gui86 What do you mean by that?

  • super

  • youtube ce system de capitaliste de merde avec ces putain de blocages

  • just the most beautiful movie scene in history; there is so many interpretations like a moment of heaven and light in a dead place; and the art saved him instead of money.

  • uau, fantasticamente!

  • two things i have to say:i must say that the expression of the german guy is something that can express all our feelings astonished amazed and truly touched by this piece....the second thing:is this actor a pianist too and was he playing those for real?

    ??/

  • nah.. maybe adrien can play piano but this part is tackled by janusz olejniczak

  • the guy's a pianist in real life but he's not really playing in this scene. its sort of like key-synching

  • thx to the inspiriation of this video~

    after half a year of work,

    i finally completed this piece yesterday^^

    now i feel everything is possible!

  • Swietna scena i muzyka . Dzieki Chopin!

  • -Łączymy się z Chopinem.

    -Dziękuję.

  • my favourite tune from Chopin, the genius

  • i cryed..wen i saw this..BEST MOVIE EVER..ily!!!!

  • Although it is filled with propaganda

  • I love this scene so much! It is the epitome, prime example, of music's ability to move and bring out sentiments in people in even the coldest and most inhumane times.

  • It's correct.... just the piano broke the sound... I can say coz I'm learning this one... I'm now on page 2/10... And I promise to practice it everyday... throughout my entire life...

    I'm not a piano major... I just love playing piano...

  • me 2!

    i was inspired by this video to learn this piece 6 months ago.

    a lot had happened during the half year that i spent working on this piece, and when i play it i feel joy, ectascy, sadness altogether.

    i'll post my version as soon as i finished it... hope it'll be within 1 month:)

  • Hey good luck with that, I've also started analyzing it and split the Ballade into 60 parts to make it less daunting so every week I'll go through a bar and hopefully stitch it up at the end probably take me 50 years and by that time I'll have arthritis in my right hand and will only be able to play with the left... anyway good luck

  • entire ballad is cropped...

  • he's an actor first..piano player second

  • my favorite scene!!!

  • This Movie makes me feel bad about beeing german, then I eat my cheezeburger,drink my heiniken, and got some where in my mercedes-bends

  • drinking a dutch beer?

  • Heineken is Related closely to the German culture.

  • Scratch that, I meant St. Pauli Girl.

  • u must be proud being german ... u brought to us great composers

  • heinekin isn't german, nor are cheese burgers.

  • Scratch The Beer and Burger, I meant St. Pauli Girl Beer, and a Hot Dog.

  • awesome scene, the best in a great movie

  • This is my favorite scene in the movie! The whole atmosphere really brought out the emotions in this piece. I was moved to tears. Thanks for sharing the clip

  • who really play this song ??

  • This is simply GENIUS!

  • my faaaaaaavourite part of the whole movie.

    Really brought me to tears,this one.

  • this is the beginning of the chopin's ballade no.1

  • bad grand piano

  • Fantasting music and I think moviemakers chose the best parts of this ballade and made very good montage of it.

  • this isn't the whole piece..what parts did he play??

  • approximately the first 2 pages and the last 2, but the most beautiful part of this work was left out

  • I think the front and back... I know the front and back are there, and it felt like he skipped ahead over something in the middle.

  • juste sublime...

  • @sword1479 me too!!! it says 1,121 on my itunes library ahah

  • I love it.

  • Does anyone know who was playing this piece during the shots of only the hands playing? (when Adrian clearly wasn't playing) I love this interpretation of this song.

  • Yeahp it was Janusz Olejniczak he is the same guy who is featured in the soundtrack of the movie :)

  • Thanks for the reply. I didn't think to check the soundtrack, which is a bit silly of me! :)

  • Comment removed

  • It is indeed Adrian playing, whether you believe it or not.

  • No...

    He played some parts, but if Polanski wanted people to know 100% that he played the parts, he'd be in full body shots, not just hand shots.

  • This is true. Adrian is not a pianist - He learnt the first section of the piece with difficulty, up until the camera cuts to the German officer.

    Wonderful montage of the Ballade, and a brilliant scene in the movie =]

  • No it's not

  • Look it up, he did.

  • The pianist is: Janusz Olejniczak

  • very moving....

  • I preafer hard rocj and metal music but i have to say that it's great !!

  • Just beautiful! My grandfather plays all Chopin, and I can sit for hours listening to him play. Really his life is in an of itself amazing. He just sits at his piano and plays all day long. Hopefully one day my life will play out similarly! The director should have included the entire piece here though! I would have loved to listen more!

  • ur so lucky to have such a great grandfather...

  • You may also enjoy Ingmar Bergman cinema. The focus is a gentle pace, emotion, small moments emphasized. His films impact largely at a primary emotional level and then the deeper philosophical ideas emerge. Very personal journeys.

  • thanks man, ill check em out

  • Chopin was prohibited by Germans under occupation... They destroyed His monument in center of Warsaw on May 31, 1940 and even all copies located in Polish museums.... Head of Chopin monument was found in Wrocław after war...... It was reconstructed in 1958 because nobody could find surviving replicas... So for Poles this scene has more deep....

  • I absolutely hate how it's cut out in the middle, but it was so nice to hear this piece in such a touching movie.

  • so much cruelty yet there is still that sense of hope...... outstanding movie!!!!

  • originally, wladyslaw szpilman played nocturne cis-moll (nocturne 20 in c-minor).

  • Part of the power of this scene is the fact that during WWII, Chopin's music was banned in Warsaw by the Nazis.

  • heh, you can see the breath coming from Adrien Brody's mouth. I don't know about you guys, but if it's that cold, there's no way I'm going to be able to play this Ballade anywhere close to passably.

  • This piece is the most played on my ipod!

  • prob one of the most powerful scenes!

  • I would have to say the most powerful scene in the movie, if not of the last decade. It's a shame that Polanski's "The Ghost" is being delayed.

  • Zimerman plays this i know this.

    it's the the same playing

  • does anybody know who's playing? Is it Zimerman?

  • no it is vladislav spilman. body did learn some notes

  • I guess so too

  • His nose is shining wow :D:D:D

  • i love the coda to this, its the best

  • cuts out half the effing song. awesome.

  • Dude. It's a movie. You think the average American is going to sit there for 9 and a half minutes while they listen to the full piece? I think it was pretty well-edited, even though my favorite part isn't in it.

  • Yes. I think they would. Chances are wonderfully positive that if you're watching a movie called: "The Piano", that you are expecting to hear some music... on the piano... so my response is yes.

  • Well then you're wrong. =P (It's called "The Pianist" btw. Although "The Piano" is also a very good movie.)

    You overestimate the attention span of American audiences my friend.

  • How very careless of me. I still remain steadfast however, seeing as the target audience for this movie was not the "typical American". Consider what is watched by today's typical American's: "Southpark", "Family Guy", and the like. This movie was intended for an audience that could appreciate Romantic music, not be bored by it. You and I are not the only human beings alive that would have liked to have seen the whole performance.

  • 1:00 to 1:40 is the best.

  • THIS IS GREAT!!!!

  • does the actor really know how to play the piano or is he just acting ?

  • From what I understand, Adrien Brody played the obvious parts where you can see him playing, while another person did the clips where you only see the hands.

  • aka the coda... that thing is a beast.

  • The actor does know how to play the song, however all his playing is voiced over with a recording from Janusz Olejniczak playing. He spent months to sync his playing to the recording so it would look realistic

  • i think he knows a little, but the really fast stuff is played by someone else, i saw it in the extras on the DVD.. or somewhere, i forget. but someone else played it for sure

  • GORGEOUSNESS.

  • very compelling, I love Chopin, this Ballade is absolutely wonderful

  • this is what got brody his oscar

  • 1:08 sends chills through my body

  • wow people -_-

    i love this movie, beautiful soundtrack, i could listen to this forever :)

  • Shithead! America is no longer the sole superpower. China owns america now! You can thank you own ignorant self for that

  • We rule China. And what country are you from? Are you guys third world?

  • Nice way of spelling airforce bro.

    please, shut the fuck up and stop trolling.

    Thanks

  • That was a typo. And what the hell is a Troll? I get that from a lot of people!

  • A troll is someone who tries to start idiotic discussions on the internet.

  • Thanks.

  • This is just beautiful.

    Does anyone know where this piece ranks among Chopin's greatest? Is it right up there? I know his Grand Polonaise is pure brilliant too

  • Please!

  • What is this for? What did I say that was wrong

  • I did not say anything. No one has done anything wrong.

  • shasha1873

    Hey dude,

    Take first care about the waste of our planet, with your stupid country, that thinks that the world is all belong to them. The most CO² comes from the USA and you dont give a shit about it.

    Remember, you are a immigrant too, because Amercia is discoverd by Europe.

  • I know about the CO2 problems. We are large and wealthy. We just consume much more than other nations. And yes, America was discovered by Europe. That is why we are white. European Americans are the best. Niggers not so good.

  • When you talk about a 'we' who exactly are you refering to?

    Anyone who is anywhere near being able to direct any kind of nuclear attack doesn't share you pathetic little superiority delusion.

    And no, i'm not from a third world country

  • shasha1873

    stop trolling n being an asshole, you're the kind of person that confirms the sterotype of americans being arrogant pricks.

    i'd like to see you bomb anyone, just because the country you were born in has nuclear weapons available doesn't mean you can boast about being able to bomb anyone.

    Please shut up.

    You are stupid.

  • Have you even seen our aifroce and navy? Do you know what we can do? Japan learned a lesson. Why can't you?

  • Are you proud? Democracy is coming?

    Where did you hear that? CNN, Fox, NBC?

    You are an ignorant that repeat what the tv teach you. WW3? This country can't take pain because it has never been at war with another country in its own soil. you wouldn't survive ww3 proud and ignorant animal.

  • Why are you upset?

  • I am not upset. I'm educating you.

  • We have the best univercities in the US. We are leading the world with everything. That is education.

  • Do you really believe that we are leading the world with everything?

  • What part of US are you from?

  • I'm from NJ

  • Cooll. You are a fellow American. Sorry for making you upset. You are right on the plicies. I do not know what they are thinking.

  • It is ok. I was not upset. What part of US are you from?

  • I am in California. Man, there is about 3,000 miles in between us. LOL

  • I'm sorry for insulting you. I think The US could be the leader of the world as long as it mantains what we stand for. But, so many lobbyst (some foreing) with other interest influence our government a lot. One can not be a real leader unless one can be neutral and objective.

  • No problem. Yes, very true. The entire system needs a change.

  • It's been nice sharing thoughts with you, but I have to go sleep. I have to work at 9am tomorrow. I'l keep in touch.

  • OK. Have a good night.

  • Thank you. You too.

  • If your country does something wrong, it will also be bombed till you are OK. It is very normal.

  • Yes. We bring democracy to countires with bombs. Just look at Japan. After two nuclear bombs, they are now OK.

  • US fixed that mistake by rebuilding and bringing the latest technology to Japan. Now, they are beating us and making better cars, electronics, etc. with the same technology we gave them

  • That is very true.

  • You are right. Some people have taken this country very low. As a matter of fact, it is becoming Mexico.

  • It is not the people. It is never the people. It is some of the policies that our government have adopted.

  • Thats your guys answer to everything WAR WAR WAR!!no hearts!! poeple like you have no souls!!no hearts!!no brains to think about there fellow man!!sure there are people and countrys out there who need a smack but killing millions of people to get the point across is definatly not the way!!America is FAlling!!economically and socially!!I Pray for your Pathetic country!

  • And what country would you be from?

  • New Zealand the real land of the free!!!

  • WOW. Awesome country. You guys have very cute girls there. They are just beautiful.

  • thanks!

  • Your patriotism makes me sick. You're never free until you break free from your delusion.

  • delusion of what you idiot!!im not the delused 1 here!!im not a American ither so im not a patriot!!Im a new zealander!!Which makes me a Warrior!!If we had more New zealanders all over the world it would be a much better place but instead we are stuck with people like you!!

  • Fuck off Maori

  • It does not make you a warrior, it makes you a moron. Just look at what you wrote, "If we had more New zealanders all over the world it would be a much better place". You're too far gone to see that your drowning in your own stupor.

  • How can stupid people rule the world?

  • For what I can see... When you talk about technology you talk about bombs...And I know that people from my country go to yours for a better life....Our president is a stupid asshole... But that doesn´t mean you are our god... I would like to know how many languages you can speak ?? That´s what I mean when I talk about education....We are all equal you dumbass...my country is poor ...your country is rich...that doen´t make you gods asshole.!!! thankyou for your attention...and Ps...Grow up!

  • Well...It looks like we hava a stupid sh*t head in the house... What the fuck are you talking about...let me inform your sorry ass that I´m Venezuela...I can speak spanish, English and Portugues..And I´m studying right Business Administration in Lisbon! WTF is wrong with you...do you think that amounts of payment have to do with where your from ... or is it because of the economic condition of your country?..I´m sorry for you...really...I THINK YOU SHOULD STUDY MORE OF " CULTURE FOR DUMMIES"

  • Do not even listen to what he has to say. He thinks or she thinks, that Latin Americans, do not have culture. What they do not know is that we are able, to speak several languages and they do not care to learn about other countries. Because, they think they are the best, look now? how their economy is falling apart, only for power and oil. Yes, they build atomic bombs to bust their own country. I may say that all americans are not like this shasha1873, I know very well educated americans. Learn!

  • I hope you read some History!! You'll be ashamed of what your country has done to others through history, Latin America being composed of "developing" countries nowadays has a lot to do with Washington's policies. Come on, I don't hate people from U.S and I know most of the U.S population has nothing to do with their country's actions, but people like you certainly suck. PLEASE READ!!

  • We are reading.

  • no more efforts u_u this is a lost cause.

  • You know I am correct. We are first world and you are third. We can bomb you and you can not bomb us.

  • thats all the US is good for bombing people!!MASS murderers! Bombs!War..thats the essence of your pathetic country!

  • Please!

  • We are the only superpower now. So be quiet or bombs will come to your nation in the name of democracy.

  • Man, don't you feel humiliated that a person from the "Third World" is giving you lessons in ethics and history? Bratzini is right when he tells you to grow up. And, for our information, your country is not god...I only see it as a declining former-hegemonic power.

  • What are you talking about?

  • We will soon bomb your country one day. So use caution at all times. Democracy is coming. LOL

  • we are a democratic antion Thankyou!and as for bombs i dont beleive you have the power to bomb us!!thats up to your BLACK president Thank god for him he definatly wont make the mistakes all your previous presidents have made! USA is a place where people beleive they are untouchable!!THINK again!!America can be beautifull!however people like you give it a bad name!!

  • You're a total moron, we're all human beings asshole.

  • Yes, I agree. We are all human beings.