Added: 6 months ago
From: tamilcinemareview
Views: 17,840
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (207)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hey I loved your review on Mankatha, Do you have an email address I can contact you at, I have a proposal? Great job and keep it up!!

  • @ashtonsr04 thanks, add me on fb at facebook(dot)com/tamildude , thanks.

  • y do ajith need a formidable villan . he is a big baddie in this movie bro . its highly insensible .and bgm is the soul of this movie . but yo offend it . unfortunately your review for this movie is not so good .

  • mokka film. back ground music is great yuvan is the hero of the film . Yuvan love you .premji comedy inra perula rambam potu irukam da badu.not comfortable for family watching movie.thala padama thani cigrate padama.

  • watched this movie 3 times, awesome movie, ajith as anti hero role rocked and no other superstar actor would dare to do such a role. thumbs up ajith....

  • i happen to see ur 7am arivu and velayudham in facebook and i routed myself here to mankatha i was not happy with ur review u said background music was not good i would say the soul of the movie is its bg and don't use the words mokkai and mankatha is still unstoppable and running so the review u hav made here has let u down (i gave two likes b4) but this one is a dislike

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • hey don't u know he itself a mega villan in tis film y he wants a formidable villan.........don't review any film here after............go ................

  • I think the movie as in storywise would have been better without Ajith because im 100% Venkat Prabhu has changed the script to suit ajith but acting wise ajith was great

  • Nice Review. I am an Ajith fan and I felt the same.Anjali, Bahath were waste. The song between Anjali and vaibhav is boring. But, the SI character was superb choice. "Suppu" (Brother of Arya in Boss) should have been included for more scenes. He does good comedy than Premji ,especially his expressions in the climax was awesome..

    Trisha does not fit the character. Should have tried Asin.

    After all, the movie rocks for all thala fans and AJITH rocks.. spl Thx to venkat prabu..

  • Dai........... Badu yaru da ne Ne thala Movie Pathi Review Pesura, Kal Adi vangi saga pora da

  • apt review. It was just an average movie. I expected much but was disappointed...

  • You simply rock ...no words to express .best review for a movie ...thala pola varuma ...He is a legend..

  • Ajith was playing an anti hero. In a sense you could say Arjun's character is his ememy (i do not want to spoil it but regardless of what happens at the end). I don't think your point about him not having a valid enemy is right.

  • AWSUM REVIEW

  • HI bro, this is a good review of the film. BTW please ask our tamil directors not to copy hollywood, korean, japanese films. and you hesitate to comment on ajith's performance. Just saying " I am a a bad man" wont make a character villan. Yuvan copied 50 cent's song for the theme music of mankatha, take your time and cover all aspects especially directing. anyone can review & comment on any movie, dont care about those brain dead zombies.....keep up the good work...

  • @TheFFighters may i know wat song is that ??the song tat u said yuvan copied from 50cent?...

  • @MrBoi1995 its 50 cents' Ready for war......

  • And another thing, logic nu paakerevenge please padame paakathinge. Superman, Spiderman, yen, nambe Bulletproof Captain paddam kude thaa logic ille, athe vide ithu evvelo theve thaa.. Haha, anyway I agree at that point too, anthe scene innum konjo logic ar panni irukelam.. Actor Arjun kum innum konjo screen space koduthu irukelam.. Other than that I don't find any other minuses in this movie. Regards.

  • Trishya dubbed her own voice for this movie. Wrong information kudukathinge sir. And another thing, review yetho OK. Ana background music avvelo nalla ille nu sonningile, seriously anthe part rombo mokkeiya irunthichi. Maybe you are more into gramathu type of music I guess. Anyway thanks for the review bro.

  • padatha vidu nee peasurathu than bayagara makkaiya iruku. ellarukum weight irukanumna padam oru 10 hours edutha than mudium. onu sollurenu thappa ninaikathiga pure logic irutha athu cinema illa. athu en ungaluku puriya matenguthu?

  • Comment removed

  • you did a good review, oru padam eduka evlo kastamnu ungaluku theriala. padam edutha tha antha kastam therium, so think before speak, dont use mokka. athukanni words. u are always telling the negative point in the movies, try to provide good things.... dont mistake me brother.

  • @59murugan why will i mistake u bro? :) u have every right to comment and speak what u think here :) thanks for the suggestions, i will sure adapt them in my following reviews! :)

  • @59murugan img src="">

  • bro, did trisha dub for herself here?

  • @TheElixir007 nope bro, it is suchithra who did the dubbing

  • @tamilcinemareview oh man... but she did well in manmadhan ambu,... why does she still need a dubbing artiste for????

  • @tamilcinemareview ur wrong trisha dubbed for herself in mankatha

  • @tamilcinemareview : Bro, i think suchitra did it for Lakhsmi rai... Who did it for trisha??? I think its her own voice.. please confirm it :)

  • @tamilcinemareview no... i think suchitra dubbed for lakshmi rai... although she too can speak good tamil

  • @tamilcinemareview i really wud like to appreciate the efforts of urs in reviewing the movie........but do try to get the proper info abt the movie....coz u r givin so much of wrong info' here....eg:- trisha herself has dubbed for her character here and shobi master actually done the choreo for machi open the bottle song......hope u agree with me!!! all the best!!!

  • @rajanddurai totally agree bro, will correct myself for sure!

  • Iam a Hardcore Ajith Fan.This is for all Ajith and Vijay fans who are commenting here. Up to My knowledge Prashanth reviewed perfectly. even for Kaavalan he said both negatives and Positives. He remains neutral. please dont make him feel bad by using unnecessary words.

  • Good review... the drawbacks you mentioned are 100% right and Ajith-Arjun done a grt performance in this movie.... But Yuvan RR is fantastic especially for Ajith's Onscreen presence and Bike stunts....

    -- U R doing A Great Job --

  • cool review na..

  • From my prepective, your review is average, not upto the critics.

    One example of justitying akash aravind character. Thala & Arjun uses akash to get trustworthy into Chettiar network. Thrish ofcourse thala uses to get into chettiar network. He also saves Akash to get more trushtworthy. This is the angle the story is plot. I dont know how u missed this or something else is missing or atleast this is how i am seeing it as. Cheers bro

  • You start grows up!! nanba! good luck lot of comments and views! I knew you for last one year, great development,,,, within 5 days this much viewers! apart from a viewers., AS a friend i congrats you and wish you be reach a great heights! all d very best

  • @vsaauto123  thanks very much nanba, means a lot to me! :)

  • ajith is the only reason to watch this movie even if u are not a fan of him

    movie is Ok, better than ASAL, AGAN

    btw good Genuine review,

  • @sudarsanvr thanks for ur support bro, means a lot to me! :)

  • manaktha movie was rubbish venkat prabhu dont ever ever ever let premji act crap

  • But. Thala has done a very good job in this film...hats off to thala

  • Ya you are right.. still it needs to be improved...

    I have seen that venkat is not serious in this film...

  • hi.. u r doing good job.. i hav been seeing most of ur reviews.. bt sorry to say i surely didnt like this one.. as u say , individuals differ.. we saw it in london n most of them were satisfied wid the movie.. tat itself is a big success for tamil movies.. anyways , keep up the good work n still expecting to see more videos frm u .. thk u..

  • அருமையான விமர்சனம் பிரசாந்த. என் மனதை அப்படியே பிரதிபலித்துள்ளீர்.

  • @snir143 thanks nanbare!

  • hi..you are telling exactly what it is in our mind....good review.....as u said it can be watchable...

  • bro i like all ur reviews...but i feel bad when u let down my thala's movie..come with more positives of his future movies and forget abt the negatives

  • @arsenalspytube sure bro, thanks for being decent and positive! :)

  • correct views......gud sir....

  • nice film....!!!!

    

  • movie is good, cant agree your comments totally.

    Box office collections will say the rest.

    Thala vaazhga.

  • @babus02 bro, who said movie is bad? and mankatha is a super kit, it has already been declared.

  • Really good review man ! Good job go on with it ....

    we definitely want to watch such true review.

  • i am from malaysia..good review bro......we need more movie review....ajith did well in this movie.....thanks bro for your best review

  • @omarfarook6671 thanks very much for the comments bro, it means a lot to me! :0) u make me and im nothing without u people!

  • Nice Review bro! Im a Tamil cinema fan and i like actors who performs well in that movie. Ajith sir has done a comendable job. Dont worry about the abuses, your review was so true!

  • @jesusid87 thanks very much for the encouragement bro, means a lot to me!

  • I am a vijay fan: when compared to sura this is much much much better movie.....I wont say vijay didnt do well in 50th movie....but he didnt give his movie to a correct person.....(first vijay appana kollanum)......by the way: I wont accept your review on this movie......unaku thumbs up kedayadu da....eli marundu venumna tharen........

  • Fucked up movie

  • Comment removed

  • @gouthamjay right thappellam sari thaan, but olunga pesalame? athu kastama?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @gouthamjay dude , just feel free to share anything :) i was much worse than u few years back, so i can completely understand ur head! ;)

  • let the comments flow, positive and negative, i welcome it whole heartedly! thanks for taking time to comment every one! it means a lot to me!

  • Dai mokka tamil nade movie supper nu sollitu irukanga...

    Nee koraiye sollitu irukka nee enna vijay fan ah ??????

    mothalla poi padatha paru( ticket vangi theater la)..

  • Hey...just remove this video you dickhead.......ur face=my ass......u nd ur slang totally sucks....who the hell are you to make a review of my thala's movie?????? STFU and remove this video asshole!!!!!!!!

  • unaku yena madhans therai parvai nadathuratha nenapa......better ask sorry for giving a bad review for mankatha... or else ill mail yur video to ayangaran , venkat prabhu and also to all ajith fan club... then yur link will be bloked ... i hav already done this before for another person..... mind it

  • @arunthemas unnala enna panna mudiyumo atha tharalama pannu, im ready to go court if it is needed. bayamuruthiriya? vera aal paaru , good ajith fans know who im, unakellam bathil solla enaku avasiyam illa.

  • I am hardcore AJITH fan...

    Your review is spot on mate. If v take Ajith out of the movie it is a total crap. Such is his performance. Had VP concentrated more on the script rather than having scenes for premji,arvind and his customary artists it would hav been a roller coaster ride for everyone. Vaibav is exception. He has done good.

    Nevertheless AJITH fans like me can watch it 'n' times just because of thala's performance. Sema mass in movie. Glad that VP has done atleast that in 50th movie.

  • @pravinaspg thanks for ur appreciation bro, means a lot to me!

  • Hi r u in USA. I havt seen this movie I heard some scens ripped from Ocean 11

  • @armaiuran hey bro, am not in the USA, im from india :) 

  • I am a vijay fan.....so i should accept wat u say......but think in a fan point of view not as reviewer.......dey want AJITH as mass in the screen.....dey dont care about editing,side roles,screenplay.....their expectation is over satisfied...i think u will regret ur comments.........

  • @SEKARTHESHAKER if u have watched my review, i would have mentioned that this film is treat for fans! i should make sure that the review is for everybody including fans, so i balance it out bro. i have no regrets wat so ever, u will understand me more when i review more.

  • hmmm great review.....

    wat ever ,i thought after watching the movie...was told by u......

    keep it up.....luking after ur straight forward reviews in near futures!!!

    :-)

  • @aswin90 thanks bro!

  • i am a ajith fan but in some set of scences idont like a othercharecter but as a flim gentral audience not oncemore but thala fans deff more then 2wice we should deffly support our thala bec no other heros dont have dare to do a negative role in a trade mark movie and its deff not a hero falt only the flim maker

  • Bro.. You forgot to mention about Cinematography, Editing and CG... I really loved the way the film is edited.... a different editing.. Praveen's editing is different from Antony and V.T vijayan... THis film's another greatest strength is editing and cinematography.... :)

  • do yu know how yu write review or wat ??????? whn all are sayng mankatha is gr8 and no words ... they even sayng its worth money... but yur saying lik this ..... nvr give review or else we all mark your review as spam ... mind it

  • @arunthemas when will u guys grow?

  • do yu know yu write review or wat ??????? whn all are sayng mankatha is gr8 and nowrds ... they even sayng its worth money... but yur saying lik this ..... nvr give review or else we all mark your review as spam ... mind it

  • half boil mandaya enda ne james cameroon voda asst uh..epadi build up vidra..ethavathu padam direct paniya..bit vu padam eduka kuda laiku illa..

  • @vijay8619 nee enna ithu varaikum panni iruka? ethavathu oru review panni irukiya?

  • enda punda maganae!!! fuck ur cock wt ur teeth if its small means shut ur mouth n sit n yo home watchin porn movie..movie s rocking...

  • i think this s the moct correct review of this movie... lots of lapses n flaws in the movie...if there not had been the last 15 min in the movie the film would have been a definite flop!!!

  • @coolrockstar712267 thanks bro!

  • @tamilcinemareview-If you want a make a good review first learn to balance your personal opinion with the public stuff......and you emphasized more on the con's of the film leaving out many of its pro's.....now tell me is it a review or critisicm.....learn to have a balance between these no matter however the film is..or what so ever....

  • what the hell is this?is this what you call a movie review???omg it says "mangathta movie review" fuck off u bloody....first learn whats meant by a movie review....you talk like as if you are an expert critic....

  • @Dk1100i please teach me how to review movies! im ready to learn from you :0)

  • @Dk1100i im ready to watch your reviews and subscribe to your channel if you start doing reviews, u r clever and know things, so go ahead and do it.

  • @tamilcinemareview Ok Boss If I make reviews I would have got many more subscribers than what u've got.....but I dont have time for all this crap unlike you jobless freak!!!!

  • @Dk1100i :0) im happy to be jobless, seems like u r too greedy and sad with a job , that too in a foreign country! :)

  • Perfect Review :) whatever i observed in this movie have been highlighted over here.. Nice job... keep it up..

  • A very honest review!!! My views coincides with your views!!! Good job!!! Keep up the good work!!!

  • perfect perfect review bro..best review for this movie.ths is exactly wat i felt after watchingthe movie..do not get discouraged by those critising u.. give open critical reviews like these bro

  • Afta watched the movie,this is EXACTLY what i shared to my frends which is not watch the movie yet!!!!Good job by Ajith n Vekat. The mve will b more entertain n fast if they slim down the movie to 2hrs, deleting some scenes afta interval which makes the pace of the movie goin down.Overall watchable mve- From VJ fans.

  • but i saw the film after watching your review.. the logical flaws you mentioned were not that bad..in fact they were unnoticable.. the good part of the review is your comment about premji's role and heroine performances. Of all the reviews you gave i felt this one had a bit of bias in it.. I really want to hear good reviews from you.. so please dont take it personal.. take it as an opinion not even an advice from your distant friend

  • Part of your Review was true but most of them looked like.. you were predetermined to pull the film value down.. you said from the start that its like any other theif police story.. it is not so.. the good point you said about the film were are the minor good points.. you forgot to mention the class of direction and cinematography and storyline.. They were all definitely classy..I felt like its something new to the tamil movie genre.. with an unexpected climax.. I may sound harsh

  • @ramcogniznce oh common bro, u r welcome to be harsh with me :) u r free to express ur views here, it can be anything! :)

  • @tamilcinemareview : thanks for understanding my concern for you.. I am replying you immedately after the movie.. So its like the my direct undiluted feelings on film.. You are a good critic.. some times it may happen that you might felt something bad with the movie.. but i felt as a common tamil audience, Venkat prabhu has tried to feed the higher level classy expectations.. i felt a bit lag only on the 5 mins after interval..

  • thala is a role model to his fans..thats what is missing in mankatha...thala please dont choose these kind of film in the future..

  • 100% CORRECT

    

  • hi, You are abosuletly correct..Only because of Ajith , this movie seemed very different..mataha badi..I didnt like the script at all.The traffic signal hacking also copied from Italian Job movie..

  • Excellent Review! First time to ur channel and u made me to subscribe you!..Keep it up!

  • @sachinbut aah, thanks for the compliment bro, means a lot to me!

  • Otha thalaya pathi ennada therium unakku sootha moodu

  • @vickyasexyboy sari unaku enna theriyum sollu :) naan therinjikanum :)

  • hahahha good review!! ajithum moka avan padamum moka. nalla sonninga boss! sathyama antha stupit padatha nan paka matten

  • film is mokka and worst film

  • hi - good review... would u say that mankatha is up to the level of ko at entertaining? this is because tickets are expensive in foreign countries so ppl may be interested in knowing

  • @Hari2K10 the movie is definitely entertaining bro, good to watch with a gang that to watch alone!

  • Apt review bro. you are doing gr8. oru oru manushanukum oro oru feelings so don't worry about others who criticise you and keep giving reviews.

  • Awesome movie ...... Fair review

  • @atd87atd87 thanks for ur support all the way bro, always owe u!

  • very good review......ajith fans should accept this :-)

  • honest review...these r the things i too felt wen i watch the film... gooooooooooooooooooooooooodddd­d job sir......

  • hey people, thats it, cant comment anylonger as the comments are flowing in, share ur thoughts and enjoy your life!

  • ena la review kodukura film evlo super ah iruku... go n c d film first.. nw 1 ly i'm seeing ur review fr d frst tme.. it s not at all good... hereaftr i wont c ur videos.. u dont know anythng!! vera vela iruntha paarunga thambi

  • One person who I thought should be mentioned is the acting of Vaibhav. Wow..from the roles we have seen him playing...he is a really good actor in my books from this movie. I have never been a diehard Ajith fan, but this movie and him as an actor has really impressed me. In my opinion, only Venkat Prabhu as a director has the talent to make a movie like this, and he should be well appreciated. I seen signs of this in Goa for that last scene on the cruise ship. Keep up the good work!

  • If the gang did not chase Ajith for the money, then there would have been a fault in the script. Who would have chased him..Jayaprakash. You mentioned there is a lot of nonlogic in the script..for ex. the magnet on the truck. Ok..I agree I also saw this in the movie. Aside from this, what else did not make any sense to you, because I could not see any. I thought this new style of film making is really pushing tamil cinema forward.

  • @damastermind789 as i have said, im no one to comment about your views about the movie, u have every right to comment about the movie and have mine too, opinion differ some time. i can point out lots of things in the script etc, but then it will only be a waste of time for both of us. u r more than welcome to share ur views here, which will be endorsed by tamil cinema loving people :) im just one among u remember :)

  • I have been following your reviews for the last year and have watched all of them. I really like most of the reviews that you have posted, but I must say this one I did not like. Many of your criticisms I can definately refute, and there are many aspects of the film that you forgot to mention. You said arvind akash was an unnessary role. He was necessary because he was shown as the head of the Chedi's gang.If he wasn't there, then I would have definately accused Venkat Prabhu.

  • @damastermind789 hey bro, thanks so much for supporting me all this time. im no god to be right about everything bro, ur criticism is always welcome with me! these are my opinion and i may be wrong bro, u never know! :)

  • ANNA...THNKS....VERY HONEST REVIEW......SUPER REVIEW....

  • excellent review

  • @l3ravy thanks bro!

  • 8 mins plus of crap...

    Nee periya parupu ah..??

    If ur sooo f*cking great.. go direct a film b*tch..

    You are Disgrace to intellectual indian.... Just watch the movie and shut up faggot..

  • @gomalah327 dey poda, just dont waste ur time being negative, it is not going to help u in any way.

  • @gomalah327

    you are a pakka local !!! talk dicently !!!

  • unu sola maranthutenga entha mankatha role panrathku kolewodla ajitha thavira vera yarayum thing pani koda mudiyathu all the best nise job

  • SAY WHAT YOU GOT TO SAY BRO DONT BACK DOWN....

  • @atd87atd87 thanks much bro! :)

  • @atd87atd87 thanks for the suport bro!

  • Bad review. You are gonna loose subscribers. Better remove the video. And shut the f**** up. Movie is classy...

  • @dmsundar good people are always with me bro, so no problems :)

  • ur review was really a big comedy.... thanks for entertaining us.... please watch ur video after recording it..... definitely u vl feel it.....  keep rocking many movies yet to come......... walter i want more emosan

  • @carunai im glad u laughed atleast :)

  • ur review was really a big comedy.... thanks for entertaining us.... please watch ur video after recording it..... definitely u vl feel it..... keep rocking many movies yet to come

  • review panna sonna yenna panra?? odidu Film is very racy and classy...

  • @pravinkumar12 enga odurathu sir? odavellam mudiyathu :)

  • you can tell about who you are as we do not know your credibility. Your review is good and you are honest in your comments. But would definitely like to know about you more to believe on your comments

  • @vebalu well, follow me on twitter @itisprashanth , you can know a lot about me! :)

  • Hi bro,bro smal correction..Machi Open The Bottle choreography by Shobi Master not Kalyan Master..nice review keep it up..

  • @seg5505 thanks for the correction bro, dance was fantastic i should say!

  • super comments Friend....

    your comments are true.....

  • @arunkumar9994881459 thanks much for the appreciation bro, it means a lot to me, please subscribe to my channel if you havent! :)

  • You have all rights to express your view, but u dont have any rights to say that peoples can watch it only once, its their wish ....... you have no rights to suggest or interfere in their views.

  • @josunso i have the rights to say anything , it is up to you to make your own decision, u r not a kid to accept my views just like that, no one is!

  • @tamilcinemareview oh... then it is utter waste for all to listen your comments and views....

  • @josunso dont listen then, im okay with that!

  • @tamilcinemareview this is called arrogant, if u say ...... u can say anything, and its our wish to listen it or not, then why and to whom you are giving your views.

  • @josunso people know me, good people i mean. so im not willing to waste my time explaining things to u, better dont watch my reviews if u dont like it, simple as that.

  • Ore oru vendugol ...... KOnjam nalla video camera vaangunga and nalla editing software install panni konjam edit pannunga...... camera munnadi 5 nimisham pesite iruntheengana bore adikkum........ just a suggestion

  • @tvvenkatesh1 nalla camera, software ellame iruku bro :) nethu technical issues, so vera vali illama web camla shoot panninen, watc some of my previous reviews and the quality is much better actually. aana have to improve bro, thanks for ur kind suggestion!

  • How dare u call for Logic in tamil movies.It rarely appears in tamil movies as we have variety of audience who mostly want mere entertainment than substance and depth.As for the movie watch for Ajith else wait for a gud print.

  • anna dey should hv made arjun alone escape and get tat 500c becoz thalaz game was totally over at fire accident but fr a common man lik me noise durin changin is nt known but y he tried so hard to remove screw in tat vechine which is is goin to stand .., great review na all the best to u to go great heightz :)

  • @cbegokulkumar thanks very much for the appreciation bro, it means a lot to me!!