@RigamonteDiego I meant that Anette sounds better in new songs because we used to hear them with her voice.Old songs are better in Tarja's version cause we used to hear her voice in old songs.
@Haistapaska01 Yeah!:D I love this song is amazing,magic and always make my day better!Tarja sang it better than Anette but Anette is the best in new songs.
I think all this fights between fans are childish and silly.
q hermosa es tarja,ella no deveria estar en esta tierra,ella es del cielo al lado de dios,su voz te estremece te lleva al cielo y te hace regresar.cantale a dios mi niña a el le gustara tu eres unica.........TARJA TURUNEN la mas bella voz en la tierra.
seit sie weg ist, höre ich keine nightwish musik mehr! Nur die alten songs! anette's stimme ist so ne allerweltsstimme, die jede zweite hat! das hier war was außergewöhnliches!
VERY sad to say, but NW just is not the same anymore w/o Tarja! No offense, Anette, you do have a great voice - but now Nightwish is "just another great Metalband with a good female voice". It is not the same anymore...
To me, there is comparison between the new and the old NW...For example, I first hear "Amaranth" and "Bye bye beautiful" with Annete and then I put this clip with Tarja,which is so touching and relaxing...And then I realise that TARJA IS JUST WONDERFUL and it's a pitty she left the band...I don't like the new NW because they lost their initial style...That's my opinion...
I have to admit, Tarja's voice is phenomenal even if she was a bitch. Although Toumas' voice is just as amazing. Don't really see why they got Annette...
Umbra your an ass...what the hell did you want them to do. Because Tarja left they can never play anything that she sang ever again...well then using your logic, Metallica can't play anything before St. Anger came out cause they got rid of Jason. Tarja is a great singer, but you said it your self, Nightwish KICKED TARJA OUT,it happens, and if you read the letter on there website they sent her, I side with Nightwish and Tuomas.
wow that would stink too the new metallica is crap by comparision i dont like anything modern of theirs at all. they have the right to sing them so whether it is tacky or not who cares. stop all the arguing nightwish is still around in a sense and she is solo using her pipes enjoy both and stop worrying no one on the outside has all the fact so i wont judge them or her.
Did any of you know that Nightwish is performing the songs that Tarja wrote when she was in the band, and they're having a Annette sing them. How fucking pathetic is that? I hate Nightwish ever since they kicked Tarja out. Love you Tarja!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Tarja wrote all the Nightwish songs before she was kicked out. Nightwish still performs still performs Sleeping Sun, and other Nightwish favorites, but Annette (the new singer) sings them. I thought was like a stab in the back for Tarja.
You wrong, Tuomas wrote all the songs before their album ONCE, when he co-wrote with Emppu, Tarja NEVER wrote any of the lyrics, she just sang for nightwish, so dont come saying that Tarja did wrote the lyrics for the songs cause she didnt...
You know what? I feel like an idiot. I went to grab a Nightwish booklet to look at the credits to prove you all wrong. I guess I really did overlook the thing about tuomas. Lame. Well, I guess you can bag on me for that then.
What do you think of Annette singing the old Nightwish songs? Even though Tarja didn't write any of the songs nor does she have any ownership towards them, it's kinda like a slap in the face to have Annette sing those.
no umbra16! tuomas said a lot of lies during the time, but he DID wrote the songs: lyrics and music! the wrights of an author is something hard to hide, so i don't think you are wright!
Hey! Four comments up. You see that? I already know that Tuomas wrote all the songs. Maybe you should try getting all the facts before jumping into a conversation.
I still say it's fine, because like I said before, does Metallica stop playing songs cause they had Cliff or Jason on bass when they were written. Alot of Bands when they change singers keep there older songs cause it is what they are known for. If they didn't there concerts would be less than 90 minutes and only the DPP album.
He didn't write all of them. He wrote most of them but not all.
And I completely agree, it's not just that she's singing them it seems like they're forcing her voice on the fans a bit, why can't they focus on getting her accepted as herself before they give opportunities for fans to compare, at their gigs they do like 3 from the new album max, it's rediculous.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Just sack the giant turd in a miniskirt they have now. Would be nice for Tarja to come back but even a dying dog or a robot would sound better than their new singer.
OMG she is soooooo talented, really can't believe this is live!! Listen to the Annette's performance of Sleeping sun and think a little of what is going on, really!
If your job is bugging you then you now have a great opportunity to make some fast cash at Fulltiltpoker com. All you have to do is register for free with the Referral Code JUSTMORE and you receive a $600 gift to poker with. Remember though, that with those $600 you are getting, you can still do so much more! All Americans are very welcome there!!
Tarja have a classical voice, but i never heard something close to her voice... its so unique... it's a little bit dark and heavy but at the same time its softly
I love the fact that Tarja uses opera for a metal band, it makes them so unique. Her voice suits the songs, I think that Anette is also really good, both their voices are beautiful and they both are gorgeous.
Yeah, that's really great. I'm a lead singer of a band, too. We make symphonic and power Metal with a little bit romance. I do the same. Opera for metal. I'll be never as good as Tarja is but I think it doesn't matter. She is just... there is no singer like her and there will never be another. She is just Tarja :)
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Tarja has a beatifull voice but she makes the songs sound like opera.i think that doesnt suit to a Metal band like nightwish.Annete is very good for this position and her voice is great and i like nightwish with annete
someone can hear the poppy voice of anette because is a comercial vocie as the britney, but it doesn´t have nothing special like tarja. and the people who says that anette is better than tarja is because they don´t know nothing about music, and this doesn´t meaning that anette sings bad, she sins good but not int his genre.
fuck Anette that ugly bitch suks at singing from so many singers they found this bitchy doll that screams and dances like a pussycat doll be real how can people even compare this 2 singers when anette wasn`t knows they all kissed taja in the ass now anette is here and you forgot who tarja was and still is?? what kind of fans are you? i wasn`t a huge fan Nightwish but i always listen to theyrs songs with joy and i know how to apreciate a great singer not a slut on stage like ANETTE!!
apparently you don't. if you would know how to appreciate a great singer you wouldnt need to call anette a slut. you could simply accept that there is a difference in taste between people. i personally like both tarja and anette but i guess someone as narrowminded as you would not understand that.
seh was not in the Band because seh wanted success why they kikked their out she studdied Music and she loveed it you can feel it now Nightwish sucks.
You are so right... Anette only SCREAMS, what she does cannnot be called singing... Not to talk about the way she moves on the scene. She is really hilLarious...
i'm wondering if those people, who are commenting videos about anette's version of this song, ever saw Tarja perform it!
"wow anette did such a great job on this one","anette does it way better than tarja","anette got such a beautiful voice", blabla.. i can't here it anymore!
WTF people, are you deaf?
ANETTE SUCKS AT THE OLD SONGS! THERE ARE WORLDS IN BETWEEN TARJA AND ANETTE!
This concert was one of their greatest live acts i think, i wish i could have been there...
ok everyone needs to just stop saying what they THINK happened because none of us were actually there to witness the events...soooo just accept the fact and move on!
Thank you Tig2007ger! Finally someone who doesn't say "she was fired because she was a bitch!". Relationships are a bit more complicated than that. Maybe she did say that she didn't need the band anymore, but it was in the middle of an argument, and we don't know what Tuomas had told her to make her say that (of course, THIS is not the kind of things he would put in an open letter).
Tarja was fired from the band around October/November 2005 and I guess they brought Anette in a few months later. Tarja had problems with the band and management not being professional enough with booking, promotion, etc. and providing the things she needed, like rest, water, a place to change, etc. to sound and look her best on stage. The band interpreted this as her being a "diva" and being "corrupted by money."
Tarja tried to resolve her problems with the band but finally decided they weren't going to ever be fixed so she told the band she planned to leave in 2007 to concentrate on solo career after recording the next album and touring for it. However the band waited until the end of the 2005 tour and then fired her. Nightwish's Wikipedia entry is a good source of info on all of this.
Oh, no. Maybe you are thinking of Tuomas Holopainen? Her last name is Turunen, and that's not her married name. She doesn't share a last name with anyone in the band.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Tarja got fired (kicked out of the band) reason why ? Because she thout that she rules everything in the band and it will be No nightwish without her ..but it is now you liked or not ..they found a loung lady from Sweden different sound and vocal not really opera sineg but her she is ...
What bull. All she asked for was some professionalism from the band and management. When she didn't get it after NINE YEARS, she told the band she planned to leave to pursue a solo career, but would stay on to record one more album and tour for it. She never claimed the band couldn't survive without her.
LOL 2:37 thats me singing like an idiot and the girl going im dumping him asap lol!
yugster78 1 month ago
Anette hace lo que puede la pobre pero es como tratar que un fiat 600 compita con un Ferrari gto
moblle21 3 months ago
Finnish singer ♥ ~♫ Tarja [ Like ] - Anette [ Dislike ]
WolfVince 8 months ago 5
@RigamonteDiego I meant that Anette sounds better in new songs because we used to hear them with her voice.Old songs are better in Tarja's version cause we used to hear her voice in old songs.
meela1000 9 months ago
Great, great song but this is the naff arrangement.
jezkn 1 year ago
tarja is a perfect singer thumps up if u agree ?? :)
MegaNami123 1 year ago 2
OMG...
Tarja is the best
:)
scoorpio931031 1 year ago 2
The most beautiful song for me <3
AddaHietala 1 year ago 8
This woman IS nightwish
MrsLesleyOlivia 1 year ago 8
Agree.
scoorpio931031 1 year ago
@MrsLesleyOlivia Tuomas IS Nightwish
Haistapaska01 1 year ago
@Haistapaska01 Yeah!:D I love this song is amazing,magic and always make my day better!Tarja sang it better than Anette but Anette is the best in new songs.
I think all this fights between fans are childish and silly.
meela1000 1 year ago 2
Tarja musi wrocić do nightwisha !!
ma piękny głos !!
(;
pieknie to zaśpiewała
PaulaaAve 1 year ago
@PaulaaAve dokładnie chciałem napisać to co ty. Niezastąpiony...
betonowy18 1 year ago
Tarja forever in my heart :(
MajinLao 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tarja is Nightwish, fuck! i want her back.
Enanurri 1 year ago
Tarja is Nightwish, fuck! i want her back.
Enanurri 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tarja is Nightwish, fuck! i want her back.
Enanurri 1 year ago
Tarja is Nightwish, fuck! i want her back.
Enanurri 1 year ago
flawless
zombies8u 1 year ago
Ihana <3
so perfect *.*
TarjaSenpai 2 years ago 2
if there was any way how to see them together again... just once and performing just this song... I´d give my all :(
GothicDaniela 2 years ago 11
@GothicDaniela
+1
I would die to see them performing sleeping sun together again!
TarjaSenpai 2 years ago 8
@TarjaSenpai oh...believe me....me too..
diana17rock 2 years ago
q hermosa es tarja,ella no deveria estar en esta tierra,ella es del cielo al lado de dios,su voz te estremece te lleva al cielo y te hace regresar.cantale a dios mi niña a el le gustara tu eres unica.........TARJA TURUNEN la mas bella voz en la tierra.
paato70 2 years ago
Tarja je t'aime ::)
maxouel53 2 years ago 2
1:45 she forgot the words a min b4 the show started and had to write them down on her hand. HA i kill me!
Great show!
OllieRockin 2 years ago
haha looks like it
schip9893 2 years ago
hahaha xD.....
Stephen3Asp 2 years ago
Tarja ich Liebe dich soooo sehr!! Meine Traumfrau!!!!!
NatiTarja 2 years ago 4
Ja sie ist einfach toll. Schade das es die nicht mehr zusammen gibt. Nightwish ist einfach nicht mehr wie früher.
Fantasyfightgirl 2 years ago 3
seit sie weg ist, höre ich keine nightwish musik mehr! Nur die alten songs! anette's stimme ist so ne allerweltsstimme, die jede zweite hat! das hier war was außergewöhnliches!
taiga284 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
cool! cool! cool! cool! cool! cool!
KaWayNayA 2 years ago
Tarja we miss you sooo much. NW is not the same without you
HighSumonerYuna 2 years ago 62
this is what i call GREAT & PERFECT SINGER
EvanescentWhisper 2 years ago 42
This has been flagged as spam show
do u think she is a " GREAT & PERFECT BLOWJOBER" too??? LOOOL
marcomerdissima 2 years ago
You'll never know....
MegaLangosta 2 years ago
Comment removed
Montenegro990 2 years ago
VERY sad to say, but NW just is not the same anymore w/o Tarja! No offense, Anette, you do have a great voice - but now Nightwish is "just another great Metalband with a good female voice". It is not the same anymore...
paux1974 2 years ago 16
You are completly right
parlapoco 2 years ago
To me, there is comparison between the new and the old NW...For example, I first hear "Amaranth" and "Bye bye beautiful" with Annete and then I put this clip with Tarja,which is so touching and relaxing...And then I realise that TARJA IS JUST WONDERFUL and it's a pitty she left the band...I don't like the new NW because they lost their initial style...That's my opinion...
marilena6 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
es una exelente cancion y marica e ignorante el que opine lo contrario...!
jorgeahervo1 2 years ago
A great song performed by a great singer!! We love you Tarja....
Maggoulini00 2 years ago 24
Невероянтый голос
Irka5556220 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
TARJA , KISS MY ESS
jorgeahervo1 2 years ago
Comment removed
Maggoulini00 2 years ago
so mesmerizing...
tyegreen93 2 years ago 6
she's amazing
hilflosmara 2 years ago 11
It is with this video I've known about Nightwish, three years ago: the most amazing thing that had ever happened to me yet.
sirenia4 2 years ago 11
q buena esta tarja
rapcoremanx 3 years ago 4
beaureful song!!
MishkinAndrei 3 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
2:45 wash your hair
wolffe93 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fuck you enya nightwish had to sing for the lord of the rings movies :D
vitakinesis 3 years ago
...loosing faith makes the crime.....
undertaker343 3 years ago 4
tarja is still the best. anette is good but tarja is better.
mistressofdolls 3 years ago 18
One of the best performances of the song! I Wish the best to both Nightwish and Tarja (even if they were better together)
I posted on youtube some great performances of this song.
soundslikeblue 3 years ago 6
Gotta Love this song :D
TattooParis 3 years ago 8
i love Tarja!
gedde570 3 years ago 12
tarja is the best!
giorgi248 3 years ago 16
omg so amazing!!! nightwish 4ever :)
RenegadeOO 3 years ago 11
You HAVE to love this
Capsici 3 years ago 11
love nightwis anette is a good and tarja
Cuizard 3 years ago
I have to admit, Tarja's voice is phenomenal even if she was a bitch. Although Toumas' voice is just as amazing. Don't really see why they got Annette...
unholyiguana 3 years ago
Tarja is the best!
drummeraca 3 years ago 7
where this live?
yoon0479 3 years ago
I miss Tarja. Can't help it :(
Dryadanna 3 years ago 6
Anyway, I like Tarja's voice better~
ShirlleyG22 3 years ago 5
This is one of the only songs that bring tears to my eyes... It's so beautiful!
Staria6x111 3 years ago 3
Umbra your an ass...what the hell did you want them to do. Because Tarja left they can never play anything that she sang ever again...well then using your logic, Metallica can't play anything before St. Anger came out cause they got rid of Jason. Tarja is a great singer, but you said it your self, Nightwish KICKED TARJA OUT,it happens, and if you read the letter on there website they sent her, I side with Nightwish and Tuomas.
CodA2501 3 years ago
bad for you, tuomas lies so much in that letter!
anaarkadievna 3 years ago
wow that would stink too the new metallica is crap by comparision i dont like anything modern of theirs at all. they have the right to sing them so whether it is tacky or not who cares. stop all the arguing nightwish is still around in a sense and she is solo using her pipes enjoy both and stop worrying no one on the outside has all the fact so i wont judge them or her.
GREAT SONG
TearisShatteredMoon 3 years ago 4
tarja has the best voice ever ! only her voice fits to the music nightwish is playing !
terapus 3 years ago 8
Did any of you know that Nightwish is performing the songs that Tarja wrote when she was in the band, and they're having a Annette sing them. How fucking pathetic is that? I hate Nightwish ever since they kicked Tarja out. Love you Tarja!
Umbra16 3 years ago 5
What songs Tarja wrote???
(Sorry on my english)
sleepwalker1992 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tarja wrote all the Nightwish songs before she was kicked out. Nightwish still performs still performs Sleeping Sun, and other Nightwish favorites, but Annette (the new singer) sings them. I thought was like a stab in the back for Tarja.
Umbra16 3 years ago
You wrong, Tuomas wrote all the songs before their album ONCE, when he co-wrote with Emppu, Tarja NEVER wrote any of the lyrics, she just sang for nightwish, so dont come saying that Tarja did wrote the lyrics for the songs cause she didnt...
Nemesis18x 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, I'm not gonna argue with you. I have a life outside of youtube instead of having to argue with someone I don't even know.
Umbra16 3 years ago
Tarja worte Nightwish songs? Please, don't make me laugh.... xD bullshit
Anes1991 3 years ago 5
lol Tarja didn't write any songs, any fan of Nightwish would know that.
Roisia 3 years ago
Haha too funny xD xD xD And his answer is genious... ^^
xXxSwissMasterxXx 3 years ago
You know what? I feel like an idiot. I went to grab a Nightwish booklet to look at the credits to prove you all wrong. I guess I really did overlook the thing about tuomas. Lame. Well, I guess you can bag on me for that then.
Umbra16 3 years ago
I'm not going to bag you on that, it's quite alright. I think everyone on the internet has had that type of moment :)
Roisia 3 years ago
What do you think of Annette singing the old Nightwish songs? Even though Tarja didn't write any of the songs nor does she have any ownership towards them, it's kinda like a slap in the face to have Annette sing those.
Umbra16 3 years ago
no umbra16! tuomas said a lot of lies during the time, but he DID wrote the songs: lyrics and music! the wrights of an author is something hard to hide, so i don't think you are wright!
anaarkadievna 3 years ago
Hey! Four comments up. You see that? I already know that Tuomas wrote all the songs. Maybe you should try getting all the facts before jumping into a conversation.
Umbra16 3 years ago
I still say it's fine, because like I said before, does Metallica stop playing songs cause they had Cliff or Jason on bass when they were written. Alot of Bands when they change singers keep there older songs cause it is what they are known for. If they didn't there concerts would be less than 90 minutes and only the DPP album.
CodA2501 3 years ago
He didn't write all of them. He wrote most of them but not all.
And I completely agree, it's not just that she's singing them it seems like they're forcing her voice on the fans a bit, why can't they focus on getting her accepted as herself before they give opportunities for fans to compare, at their gigs they do like 3 from the new album max, it's rediculous.
LindziBrap 3 years ago
Wow...these comments are so old. And did you just call me Max?
Umbra16 3 years ago
rofl no. i meant maximum.
LindziBrap 3 years ago
Oh, haha. I feel retarded. Haha
Umbra16 3 years ago
actually tuomas wrote them.
pake321 3 years ago 2
TUOMAS WROTE all the songs!
plutoniangirl 3 years ago 5
yeah, he's a great musician
wolffe93 3 years ago
tarja plz come back
ufc95 3 years ago
we miss you tarja, nightwish is just not the same without you.. Anette is okey, but tarjas voice makes me cry. We really miss you tarja.
xSwedishGirl 3 years ago 4
hayyy hermosa
thexdarkxdoll 3 years ago
goosebumps*
mantispriest 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
her pronounciation sucks ass
ajkorras 3 years ago
So does your spelling.
OgTheClever1992 3 years ago
it was close enough imo ;D
ajkorras 3 years ago
her pronunciation is also close.
DeeceGuy 3 years ago
linda musik carajuuuuuuuuuuu
beeslayne19 3 years ago
You will always be in our hearts Tarja !! We miss you ( we = the true NightWish Fans ... )
blcknight16 3 years ago 9
So beautiful .. I love this song !
SauronnBR 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No thank you ! Albano's version is much better !
Scocondrilla 3 years ago
Wonderful
Alexandrine92 3 years ago 10
its one of those songs that makes me hold my breath and listen to it;
like looking at the sinkin' Sun in the evening!
cillverbullet 3 years ago 7
the best song ever
ifranquito 3 years ago 3
Tarja is definitly the best singer in the world.
Dat34my 3 years ago 21
lovely dis song relax me :3
lauzhis 3 years ago 2
oh how i wish that tarja come back to nightwish!!!
amy26250305 3 years ago 8
that would be great :) but.... :|
silkroad37 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just sack the giant turd in a miniskirt they have now. Would be nice for Tarja to come back but even a dying dog or a robot would sound better than their new singer.
DirEnGay 3 years ago
tarja...great memories...
BritneySpearsRox 3 years ago 10
Tarja's voice is wonderful
p8little 3 years ago 25
yeah!! is so so great!!
:)
kremastanera 3 years ago 9
simply GREAT!!!
maolino73 3 years ago 10
We love you Tarja!!<3<3<3<!3
mummy923 3 years ago 15
Good thing we have videos like these to remember the days Tarja sang with Nightwish.
Thankyou -sinerjay- for posting this particular video. <3
Melodia75 3 years ago 9
You're perfectly right!
mummy923 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
mummy? eeh..?
heylalla2 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
?????????????
sadestre 3 years ago
same here
oc3anborn 3 years ago
Tarja, Love youre voice,
whish you were back,
miss you.
ladyoftheancient 3 years ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
There are 20 angels in this world
10 are sleeping
9 are playing
1 is reading this
put this on 4 video comments within 15 mins,if u do, sum one u love will surprise u sum how!! If u don't , u will lose ur love.!!
YESIMETALERA 3 years ago
why do people say that Nightwish is pop rock?
This is a masterpiece!!! THIS is music!
LuthienMel 3 years ago 9
because none of them ever heard of Symphonic Metal.
ComaLies225 3 years ago 8
OMG she is soooooo talented, really can't believe this is live!! Listen to the Annette's performance of Sleeping sun and think a little of what is going on, really!
sara092 3 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
If your job is bugging you then you now have a great opportunity to make some fast cash at Fulltiltpoker com. All you have to do is register for free with the Referral Code JUSTMORE and you receive a $600 gift to poker with. Remember though, that with those $600 you are getting, you can still do so much more! All Americans are very welcome there!!
Spurweite9 3 years ago
That was amazing! She sings so beautiful.. Can't believe this is live!
I love Tarja with or without Nightwish!
IngeMP92 3 years ago 17
Tarja have a classical voice, but i never heard something close to her voice... its so unique... it's a little bit dark and heavy but at the same time its softly
starbreez3 3 years ago 9
she's got an amazing voice, good looking and live she's great!
IWantMyInnocenceBack 3 years ago 6
Tarja.. she's so unique. One of the best female voices. Compared to those mainstream shit, they're just crap. I love Nightwish!!
ulimali 3 years ago 8
magia
katee1990 3 years ago 2
she is a classicaly singer but not opera..
sadestre 3 years ago
:´( this song makes me cry... so beautiful!!!!
bolzprinzessinxxx 3 years ago 6
muy buena la cancion!!!!
jesu556 3 years ago 3
I love the fact that Tarja uses opera for a metal band, it makes them so unique. Her voice suits the songs, I think that Anette is also really good, both their voices are beautiful and they both are gorgeous.
19raeofhope19 3 years ago 6
Yeah, that's really great. I'm a lead singer of a band, too. We make symphonic and power Metal with a little bit romance. I do the same. Opera for metal. I'll be never as good as Tarja is but I think it doesn't matter. She is just... there is no singer like her and there will never be another. She is just Tarja :)
EuropeenGodess 3 years ago
its not opera, its operatic or classical singing style.
Betrion 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tarja has a beatifull voice but she makes the songs sound like opera.i think that doesnt suit to a Metal band like nightwish.Annete is very good for this position and her voice is great and i like nightwish with annete
JimDimTheGreat 3 years ago
since anette its just another commerce band.
robinwiese 3 years ago 7
Robin, you hit the nail on the head there. That "opera" DimJim, is what makes nightwish so special.
Madman141 3 years ago 3
Wow this song, even in live concert, sounds soo peaceful.
CresentLuna 3 years ago 2
That's is so fucking great!
Nightwish rocks and Tarja is definitly the best singer!
Dat34my 3 years ago 3
Amazing live koncert.. Love this song<3
sleepinginthenight 3 years ago
On behalf of Blind Faith, we salute you tarja, and hope this comment somehow finds you.
shafs33 3 years ago
Damn I miss tarja :(
annaoo 3 years ago 12
someone can hear the poppy voice of anette because is a comercial vocie as the britney, but it doesn´t have nothing special like tarja. and the people who says that anette is better than tarja is because they don´t know nothing about music, and this doesn´t meaning that anette sings bad, she sins good but not int his genre.
sorry for my english
r0sa06 3 years ago 5
fuck Anette that ugly bitch suks at singing from so many singers they found this bitchy doll that screams and dances like a pussycat doll be real how can people even compare this 2 singers when anette wasn`t knows they all kissed taja in the ass now anette is here and you forgot who tarja was and still is?? what kind of fans are you? i wasn`t a huge fan Nightwish but i always listen to theyrs songs with joy and i know how to apreciate a great singer not a slut on stage like ANETTE!!
busylovingyou2 3 years ago 4
apparently you don't. if you would know how to appreciate a great singer you wouldnt need to call anette a slut. you could simply accept that there is a difference in taste between people. i personally like both tarja and anette but i guess someone as narrowminded as you would not understand that.
N3f4r1u5 3 years ago
This Song For You Jansue :D
DorukanRasim 3 years ago
best nightwish song
HaKoMaNs 4 years ago 5
Which song so beautiful ...
marisolmanson 4 years ago
TARJA FOREVER!! < 3
mickina1 4 years ago 2
seh was not in the Band because seh wanted success why they kikked their out she studdied Music and she loveed it you can feel it now Nightwish sucks.
Tarja 4ever.
Bartsam 4 years ago
You are so right... Anette only SCREAMS, what she does cannnot be called singing... Not to talk about the way she moves on the scene. She is really hilLarious...
Swanheart1982 4 years ago 3
i'm wondering if those people, who are commenting videos about anette's version of this song, ever saw Tarja perform it!
"wow anette did such a great job on this one","anette does it way better than tarja","anette got such a beautiful voice", blabla.. i can't here it anymore!
WTF people, are you deaf?
ANETTE SUCKS AT THE OLD SONGS! THERE ARE WORLDS IN BETWEEN TARJA AND ANETTE!
This concert was one of their greatest live acts i think, i wish i could have been there...
TheB1gEd 4 years ago 7
This is from the "Raumanmeri 2003" (a finnish midsummer festival) if i remember correctly..absolutely great piece of music!!!
Jokeripoks81 4 years ago
At 3:34 - there is a moment where you know she loves the song and she loves performing with the band.
panthro555 4 years ago 8
You noticed that too huh? lol
tig2007ger 4 years ago
All Tuomas said was bullshit, she loved the band, she didn't want to leave. Fuck the new Nightwish.
Fribbe 4 years ago 6
ok everyone needs to just stop saying what they THINK happened because none of us were actually there to witness the events...soooo just accept the fact and move on!
Lileroo 4 years ago 3
so the first clever person - nobody know thats happened really between them
Terpsihora1986 4 years ago
thank you
Lileroo 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she is amazing :D
valentinacuello 4 years ago 2
I love Tarja!!! I miss her so much, her voice is so...so... perfect for Tuomas'songs... A inimitable duet! I miss my real nightwish!
SleepingWinter 4 years ago 11
Tarja' voice is so amazing!! So pure and angelic!! I love this song soooo much!!
lebanesa13 4 years ago 5
Thank you Tig2007ger! Finally someone who doesn't say "she was fired because she was a bitch!". Relationships are a bit more complicated than that. Maybe she did say that she didn't need the band anymore, but it was in the middle of an argument, and we don't know what Tuomas had told her to make her say that (of course, THIS is not the kind of things he would put in an open letter).
Elanore7 4 years ago
hey i just started listening to nightwish and can someone tell me when did jarja leave and when did annette come and why did tarja leave?
can someone plz tell me
violentbeauty1012 4 years ago
Tarja was fired from the band around October/November 2005 and I guess they brought Anette in a few months later. Tarja had problems with the band and management not being professional enough with booking, promotion, etc. and providing the things she needed, like rest, water, a place to change, etc. to sound and look her best on stage. The band interpreted this as her being a "diva" and being "corrupted by money."
tig2007ger 4 years ago
Tarja tried to resolve her problems with the band but finally decided they weren't going to ever be fixed so she told the band she planned to leave in 2007 to concentrate on solo career after recording the next album and touring for it. However the band waited until the end of the 2005 tour and then fired her. Nightwish's Wikipedia entry is a good source of info on all of this.
tig2007ger 4 years ago
oh... thanks! but also isnt her brother in the band too?
violentbeauty1012 4 years ago
Oh, no. Maybe you are thinking of Tuomas Holopainen? Her last name is Turunen, and that's not her married name. She doesn't share a last name with anyone in the band.
tig2007ger 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tarja got fired (kicked out of the band) reason why ? Because she thout that she rules everything in the band and it will be No nightwish without her ..but it is now you liked or not ..they found a loung lady from Sweden different sound and vocal not really opera sineg but her she is ...
deadxjoker 4 years ago
What bull. All she asked for was some professionalism from the band and management. When she didn't get it after NINE YEARS, she told the band she planned to leave to pursue a solo career, but would stay on to record one more album and tour for it. She never claimed the band couldn't survive without her.
tig2007ger 4 years ago 3