I think that Jon Snow is Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark's son because Jon Snow is talked about being "born" at The Tower of Joy where Rhaegar and Lyanna fled in love, and Eddard and Howland fought the three Kingsguard and survived and Lyanna's last words to Eddard were "Promis me Ned," probably to raise Jon and not say that he is Rhaegar's son! I can't imagine Eddard Stark ever having an affair, not to mention everyone says that Jon looks like a STark and Arya looks like Lyanna .Theories?
Well technically he was fighting for both. I like to think he was conflicted over whether or not he was doing the right thing. That's just the way I like to read the character.
What you mean is that he didn't WANT to fight for his father. I don't think he did either. But the reality is that he was, whether he liked it or not. That's my point.
i just read game of trhones''in finland it came last october'' cant wait for feast of crows and last page was truly even MORE PEACE of ART than others...dragon eggs hatched and all i was totally speechles for 4 hours !4! HOURS!! best book in my whole life,and that really means something
He kidnapped her. On what little we know of Rhaegar i do not think he raped Lyanna. I think she had a affair with him willingly. She may not of even loved Robert i'm starting to think she was going to marrying him out of duty. I also think that Jon is her and Rhaegars son.
I think she was either kidnapped or she willingly went with Rhaegar without telling anyone. But i'm sure they both had an affair. Especially since she wouldnt want to endanger her child by the world finding out Jon Snow would be a Targaryen. That was Ned's promise.
Also I think Lyanna was reluctant to marry Robert.
@Xantheus07 why this uncertanty...I think is obvious that Rhaegar and Lyanna had an affair...and it was willingly, the marriage with Robert was arranged, she didn't love him...and why what Ned promissed her? To keep to himself that Jon is her and Rhaegar son because she knew that Robert would kill Jon if he find out...That's why Ned was so sad before he died because he didn't explain Jon his true heritage and he was degraded all his life as bastard to keep him safe...
We're probably gonna get a backstory flash back of Rheagar at some point in the later books, probably for the sheer number of fangirl mail he must get demanding it.
To think that one of the reasons the war against the Mad King started was for revenge, that may have been false...dang would have loved to see more of Rhaegar after these pictures, and from what I heard of him.
great... realy great video... rhaegar was one of mine favorite characters in martin's universe... I belive that Rhaegar could win Robert, but... too bad
"Rubies flew like drops of blood from the chest of a dying prince, and he sank to his knees in the water and with his last breath murmured a woman's name..." beautiful CoK p.706
well for one he was born on the same day as the tragedy at summerhall. he also liked to visit there often as it was his birth place.
there are also quotes from the books that say rhaegar's predecessors experimented on making a dragon and one of them even killed himself drinking wilfire.
shame whatever it was that happened killed both dunk and egg.
there seems to be rumours flying around saying rhaegar was the result of a magic experimentation aimed to bring forth dragons once again. which then ended up destroying summerhall. that kinda explains why rhaegar was so somber during his life. whats the opinion?
Have you read the books? Lyanna died from unknown causes at the Tower of Joy. Many assume it was from complications of childbirth. Sansa, Arya, Robb, Bran and Rickon are all 100% Catelyn's children. Many people speculate, however, that she was indeed the mother of Jon Snow, Rhaegar being the father, rather than Eddard being the father.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
No I mean I wished I could read about it but I don't like reading big books like the Harry Potter chapter books. And maybe if someone like the dictators of Lord of the Rings and Chronicles of Narnia create a movie like this so it makes sense and people can talk about it too like forever.
Of all the vids about ASOIAF -and most are great- this is a very special one. I like Nightwish and stuff but I think this music fits extremely well. And those last two pictures, just amazing!
I can almost see a small tear of deep red blood dripping from the blue rose.
i think at 1:37 is probably the best picture of of these hole cards i have never seen these before nor would i buy them but i think that a really good drawing
the artist who make the music is yann tiersen (i ask the same question to taliga72) the pictures is taken from the comics "the edge knights" who talks about dunk and egg.
Mind if I ask what the song was and where the last picture of Robert standing over (Rhaegar) with the view out of the helmet is from? I've looked everywhere for it, but I can't find it anywhere.
Jöhet a kövezés (lásd az egyik Havas Jon kommentet...), de sajna nemtom. Szívesen elküldöm mélben pl ha kell. (Egyébként a 00:43-as az lehet, hogy Naerys és Aegon... :D)
This song fits so well with his character
AdoreYouInAshXI 9 months ago
Rhaegar è bellissimo all'inizio.
Ben fatto lo scontro nel fiume.
Ninive50 9 months ago
incredible to came back after 3 years and fell the same........
the destiny of this great character made this novel so "real"..... there's no happy ending in the seven kingdom!!!
Feorn 9 months ago 2
Also Lyanna died in a bed of blood....Possibly giving birth to Jon....Might be why Kingsguard were guarding the chapel.
Quiksmith98 10 months ago
I think that Jon Snow is Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark's son because Jon Snow is talked about being "born" at The Tower of Joy where Rhaegar and Lyanna fled in love, and Eddard and Howland fought the three Kingsguard and survived and Lyanna's last words to Eddard were "Promis me Ned," probably to raise Jon and not say that he is Rhaegar's son! I can't imagine Eddard Stark ever having an affair, not to mention everyone says that Jon looks like a STark and Arya looks like Lyanna .Theories?
HatedSovietLion 11 months ago
Rhaegar fought honorably,
Rhaegar fought valiantly,
Rhaegar fought nobly,
And Rhaegar died.
HatedSovietLion 11 months ago 2
The last three picures are amazing; nice work!
papger12 1 year ago
Rhaegar and Lynna are John Snows true parents thats my prediction
LetsPlayMineSweeper 1 year ago
beautifull....
SeiryuAmidala 1 year ago
I think Robert won cos he knew he was fighting for good.
Deep down Rheagar knew he was fighting for an insane king.
DrunkenPoetic 1 year ago
@DrunkenPoetic alas, even in a song of ice and fire (or should i say, especially in ASoIaF) things don't work that way
alexcanale98 1 year ago
Dunno. Ice and Fire's pretty realistic and that's the way it goes in real life. Most pissed-off person wins.
DrunkenPoetic 1 year ago
@DrunkenPoetic He fought for beloved girl, not for insane father...
xXArjaXx 1 year ago
@DrunkenPoetic He fought for beloved girl, not for insane father...I mean, Rhaegar fought for her.
xXArjaXx 1 year ago
Well technically he was fighting for both. I like to think he was conflicted over whether or not he was doing the right thing. That's just the way I like to read the character.
DrunkenPoetic 1 year ago
@DrunkenPoetic Well, maybe he fought for girl of other man....but he didn't fought for his father for sure.
xXArjaXx 1 year ago
What you mean is that he didn't WANT to fight for his father. I don't think he did either. But the reality is that he was, whether he liked it or not. That's my point.
DrunkenPoetic 1 year ago
i just read game of trhones''in finland it came last october'' cant wait for feast of crows and last page was truly even MORE PEACE of ART than others...dragon eggs hatched and all i was totally speechles for 4 hours !4! HOURS!! best book in my whole life,and that really means something
Hedu007 1 year ago
love it....song of ice n fore in <3
izumrlimamut 1 year ago
can anyone tell me what's the name of this song? and where is it from....? thanks :)
MrsSpux 1 year ago
@MrsSpux it's in the discription Song: Yann Tiersen - Comptine dun autre ete
XkatarinaXILSB 1 year ago
ooooo. a Stark and a Targaryen in one. Exciting Mix. No wonder Jon is so awseome
waverleykid 1 year ago
"Reghar was injured.. he was sad..." what is a reason of his pain? Mad King or love with Lyanna?
HighlanderNK 1 year ago
Its long time ago since ive red the books and there is one thing dont remember clearly.
Did Rhaegar kidnap Neds sister and rape her?
Or were they in love?
Or was it Rhaegar that kidnapped her at all?
arhvash 1 year ago
He kidnapped her. On what little we know of Rhaegar i do not think he raped Lyanna. I think she had a affair with him willingly. She may not of even loved Robert i'm starting to think she was going to marrying him out of duty. I also think that Jon is her and Rhaegars son.
Xantheus07 1 year ago 2
@Xantheus07 Yes. The ame crazy idea hit
me right after a wrote that comment :)
I remember when I red the description of
Rhaegar. When someone was describing him
to Dany I started do bobd that he would rape
Lyanna. I think that Robert convinced himself that she
loved him and that she had to be saved from Rhaegar.
arhvash 1 year ago
I think she was either kidnapped or she willingly went with Rhaegar without telling anyone. But i'm sure they both had an affair. Especially since she wouldnt want to endanger her child by the world finding out Jon Snow would be a Targaryen. That was Ned's promise.
Also I think Lyanna was reluctant to marry Robert.
Whitewalls19 1 year ago
@Xantheus07 i share your version, in fact i believe in that option
HighlanderNK 1 year ago
@Xantheus07 why this uncertanty...I think is obvious that Rhaegar and Lyanna had an affair...and it was willingly, the marriage with Robert was arranged, she didn't love him...and why what Ned promissed her? To keep to himself that Jon is her and Rhaegar son because she knew that Robert would kill Jon if he find out...That's why Ned was so sad before he died because he didn't explain Jon his true heritage and he was degraded all his life as bastard to keep him safe...
doczg88 1 year ago 4
@doczg88 Jon Snow. The Prince that was promised.
eggmansizzle 1 year ago
i love this...
the song of ice and fire is the best i ever read...
every time i think about it...
its crazy...
i fucking love it.
may the warrior protect george r.r. martin and may the old women guide him in his life!
ljamma1 2 years ago 2
STARK!!!
achaelmer 2 years ago
Rhaegar would have become a fine king if his crazy dad had died sooner. :/
Shadurak 2 years ago 12
"Then he would of been happy."
"Perhaps.... But im not certain it was in Rhaegar to be happy."
"You make him sound so sour," Dany protested.
"Not sour, no, but... there was a melancholy to Prince Rhaegar, a sense...." The old man hesitated again.
"Say it," she urged. "A sense....?"
"..... of doom. He was born in grief, my queen, and that shadow hung over him all his days."
iop333 2 years ago 14
I'm in love with the artwork at 1:37. Can you tell me where you found it?
Elinye 2 years ago
the fact that a character that is -dead- before the books start appeals to so many is such a credit to george RR martins ability
maverickdite 2 years ago 4
Great video and song
iilija64 2 years ago
We're probably gonna get a backstory flash back of Rheagar at some point in the later books, probably for the sheer number of fangirl mail he must get demanding it.
johnnytubeaccount 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
FridaTrollet 2 years ago
0:12 it reminds me to Heath Ledger (RIP)
Nagrandt 2 years ago 3
Agreed! The artist must have used Heath as inspiration.
talgoam 2 years ago
Interestingly enough, it reminds me of Val Kilmer in his debuts in Willow...
RatKrazee 2 years ago
Composer is Yann Tiersen, from Le Fabuleux Destin D'Amelie Poulain (Amelie soundtrack) - song title is Comptine D'Un Autre Ete
mooseclamps 2 years ago
The Film has awesome soundtracks, they blow you away
Nagrandt 2 years ago
Which means: "song from another summer", for the not-so-French viewers... =)
RatKrazee 2 years ago
To think that one of the reasons the war against the Mad King started was for revenge, that may have been false...dang would have loved to see more of Rhaegar after these pictures, and from what I heard of him.
Orkb0yz 2 years ago
great... realy great video... rhaegar was one of mine favorite characters in martin's universe... I belive that Rhaegar could win Robert, but... too bad
PrimarhHorus 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
Palinho61 2 years ago
i feel so bad for robert and rhaegar
they both loved lyana
namekman01 2 years ago
Awesome clip
CortoMaltese86 2 years ago
For those who want to know, the is song is called "Amilie" and the artist is Yann Tiersen^^
Isichan94 2 years ago
Actually it is called "Amelie", the soundtrack of the self titled filmed
Volodioso 2 years ago
Awesome pictures! I love the books^^
AH, I love this song, a friend of mine sent it to me a while ago...
Isichan94 2 years ago
Whats with the picture at 1:55? The artist couldn't tell the difference between an axe and a hammer?
Breaddemon 2 years ago
Who is the artist for this and the Jon Snow piece? I'm referring to the musicians and the name of the songs, both are quite beautiful.
DarkenVise 2 years ago
If I´m not mistaken, the song of this video is from the movie "Le Fabuleux Destin D'Amelie Poulain".
MPoppins007 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"Rubies flew like drops of blood from the chest of a dying prince, and he sank to his knees in the water and with his last breath murmured a woman's name..." beautiful CoK p.706
Braunnylad250 3 years ago
Comment removed
Braunnylad250 3 years ago
Wow, this was awesome. well done
mjsgrass78 3 years ago
well for one he was born on the same day as the tragedy at summerhall. he also liked to visit there often as it was his birth place.
there are also quotes from the books that say rhaegar's predecessors experimented on making a dragon and one of them even killed himself drinking wilfire.
shame whatever it was that happened killed both dunk and egg.
myungish 3 years ago
there seems to be rumours flying around saying rhaegar was the result of a magic experimentation aimed to bring forth dragons once again. which then ended up destroying summerhall. that kinda explains why rhaegar was so somber during his life. whats the opinion?
myungish 3 years ago
Where did you hear that?
I don't think it true.
Rhaegar is just the true dragon blood of high valyria come to live once more.
The good side of the coin.... greatness instead of madness
sjz88 3 years ago
i think it was a theory on 'tower of the hand' website. i did find it abit far reaching but they do have some reasoning behind their thought.
myungish 3 years ago
jon and dani are related.... and since the targaryens practice incest, jon will most likely rule all.
pravin2379 3 years ago
how??? i thought only very very very distantly...
FryingpanThunder 3 years ago
rhaegar looks like heath ledger. nice pictures
siXti66 3 years ago
that's exactly what i thought when i saw the pic
Shenanigans19 3 years ago
Just a guesss, but I think Martin will reveal that Rhaegar died on purpose at the hands of Robert.
bunjumen 3 years ago
It could be, though it would be sort of a let down
maxiart 3 years ago
As do I.
iop333 3 years ago
It was Aerion Brightflame (the one that created all the trouble in the Hedge Knight) that drank the wildfire.
mlburch22 3 years ago
When is the next freaking book coming out!! Argh!
Zabbai 3 years ago 2
I forget, was it Eddard or Brandon with Lyanna when Rhaegar fell for her? I was nearly sure it was Eddard, however I could be wrong.
smitty01209 3 years ago
Eddard and Brandon (and Benjen too) were at Harrenhal with Lyanna.
Taliga72 3 years ago
wait wasnt eddard at the eyrie with robert?
Congohippijippi 3 years ago
@smitty01209
Lyanna was Eddard's sister.
lynxx55 1 year ago
@lynxx55 ...I know that.
smitty01209 1 year ago
Who was that princess on 0:31?
Sarah276602 3 years ago
T'was Lyanna Stark, Eddard's Stark sister.
smitty01209 3 years ago
I heard she died.....but why? Is she Sansa's mother?
Sarah276602 3 years ago
Have you read the books? Lyanna died from unknown causes at the Tower of Joy. Many assume it was from complications of childbirth. Sansa, Arya, Robb, Bran and Rickon are all 100% Catelyn's children. Many people speculate, however, that she was indeed the mother of Jon Snow, Rhaegar being the father, rather than Eddard being the father.
smitty01209 3 years ago
I wished. :(
Sarah276602 3 years ago
Yes, Jon Snow looks absolutely like a Targaryen and NOTHING like Eddard Stark. :rollseyes:
Stalagmite86 3 years ago
Lyanna IS a Stark, Stalagmite. Who's to say that Jon just inherited his mother's ancestral appearance?
smitty01209 3 years ago
yes and he has 'dark' eyes which will probably turn out to be violet
myungish 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No I mean I wished I could read about it but I don't like reading big books like the Harry Potter chapter books. And maybe if someone like the dictators of Lord of the Rings and Chronicles of Narnia create a movie like this so it makes sense and people can talk about it too like forever.
Sarah276602 2 years ago
Of all the vids about ASOIAF -and most are great- this is a very special one. I like Nightwish and stuff but I think this music fits extremely well. And those last two pictures, just amazing!
I can almost see a small tear of deep red blood dripping from the blue rose.
TomOSevens 3 years ago
Thanks a lot!
Taliga72 3 years ago
Like I said sooner, the song:
Yann Tiersen - Comptine d'un Autre Été (Soundtrack of The Fabulous Destiny of Amelie Poulain)
Taliga72 3 years ago
what is a song name
terrykabiezes 3 years ago
Wolf, Dragon, Lion, Crow, Stag, or Kraken?
Long live House Targaryen and House Stark.
happytimedanny1 3 years ago
fantastic
alterminny92 3 years ago
Taliga ! I guess you know who jons parents are ^^ dont ya? I like the blue rose in ya vids ;)
1chD3nkeDuLuegst 3 years ago
Yeah, but that's only 95%... There's no telling.
Taliga72 3 years ago
song name»????plzzz
ltngilberto 3 years ago
i think at 1:37 is probably the best picture of of these hole cards i have never seen these before nor would i buy them but i think that a really good drawing
Wabbit2131 3 years ago
doesnt the pic with the harp resemble heath ledger?
myungish 3 years ago
Val Kilmer+Heath Ledger. :D
Taliga72 3 years ago
omg i just realised who jon snows mum is, its lysa!
11congobongo11 3 years ago
I don't think so...
If you'd like the correct answer, send a message. I don't want to write a really great spoiler here.
Taliga72 3 years ago
No one knows for definate who his Mother is...or his father for that matter. (That statement probably gives away which theory I'm partial to ;)
GRRM refuses to say yay or nay on the subject of Jon's parentage.
Ichcann 3 years ago
jon's mum is not lysa!!!!!
xombified666 3 years ago
i meant lyanna (soz)
11congobongo11 3 years ago
this music is incredible...
11congobongo11 3 years ago
At 00:15 - Rhaegar looks soooooooo sexy!
achitturi 3 years ago
Thanks Everyone!
Music:
Yann Tiersen - Comptine d'un Autre Été (Soundtrack of The Fabulous Destiny of Amelie Poulain)
Taliga72 4 years ago
the artist who make the music is yann tiersen (i ask the same question to taliga72) the pictures is taken from the comics "the edge knights" who talks about dunk and egg.
Long live to GRRM, our great uncle.......
Feorn 4 years ago
what a wonderfully tragic character rhaegar is. nicely done vid by the way.
spectravision 4 years ago
It seems that way, though we don't know much about him. I want a prequal with him POVing. I'd love to see the thought process of Rhaegar
Ichcann 3 years ago
Amazing video, absolutely love it.
Mind if I ask what the song was and where the last picture of Robert standing over (Rhaegar) with the view out of the helmet is from? I've looked everywhere for it, but I can't find it anywhere.
flintgummie 4 years ago 3
It's a bit tricky. :)
Feorn's right, that picture comes from The hedge knight, so You see Lyonel Baratheon (maybe the great-grandfather of Robert) on that.
I found it fit perfectly in this vid, so... pardon! ;)
Taliga72 4 years ago
Rhaegar fought nobly...............
Rhaegar fought valiantly...........
Rhaegar fought Honorably...........
And Rhaegar died...................
Great video, great song, for a great characther of the seven kingdoms!!!
Feorn 4 years ago 19
@Feorn Awesome, way to spoil it for people who haven't read that far into the books..
AdoreYouInAshXI 1 year ago
@AdoreYouInAshXI
spoil?? do you know what are we talking about?
Feorn 1 year ago
A 00:23 nál és a 00:43nál lévő kép honnan van?
Elég régóta gyűjtögetek, de ezek még nincsenek meg.
Annatar01 4 years ago
Jöhet a kövezés (lásd az egyik Havas Jon kommentet...), de sajna nemtom. Szívesen elküldöm mélben pl ha kell. (Egyébként a 00:43-as az lehet, hogy Naerys és Aegon... :D)
Taliga72 4 years ago
Megköszönném.
Annatar01 4 years ago
Beautiful and the music is sad just the way I see the Dragon Prince.
sansa28 4 years ago 2
Kiváló munka, méltó Martin művéhez, egyszerűen gyönyörű!
Csak gratulálni tudok! Várom a folytatást (ha lesz egyáltalán)
benyo72 4 years ago
Köszönöm szépen.
Taliga72 4 years ago