if the rebels = nazis how do you explain the wookies and fish people and assorted minorities that the rebel alliance accepts? but there is only one type of person in the empire. *hint hint*
@HeroOfTheSovietUnion, You are not imagining things. One reference to the similarity of these two scenes can be found on the last page of this article from the New York Times - "Reich Star" By CLIVE JAMES, Published: March 25, 2007. George Lucas was not alone among Hollywood types who admired Leni Riefenstahl.
No idea why some people are debating analogies when Lucas even stated that the Imperial Empire was based on the Nazis, this is Fact not opinion so forget Empire=Romans or Empire=Seperatists.
@magrace1 You are a thingfish with no mind and obviously in bed with the enemy of mankind, but hey, you have every right to walk around thinking yourself smart with your head squarely up your silly ass. ENJOY.
Wow,I was just thinking that could have been the climax of the German victory celebrations had they won.Of course had they won then English girls wouldn't be getting raped by Asians in London,and there wouldn't be any no go zones for white people.WHITE Children would being playing in Adolf Hitler park while their WHITE parents sip lemonade.Had the English soldiers seen the future they'd have defected on mass to the Germans to save their grand-kids from the MultiKult hell that is England today
Btw another nazi parallel is in revenge of the Sith. The plot of Palpatine wanting to go from chancellor to emperor roughly matches that of Hitler who was appointed chancellor and wanted to be dictator.
@ranebow5 Don't forget his using Mace Windu trying to kill him as a reason to declare emergency, take away right and to eliminate his opponents, like Hitler did with the Reichstag fire.
Awesome.....Nazi history equals George Lucas Star Wars story...NO QUESTION ABOUT IT. This is crazy, Hitler invented Star Wars!!!! Storm Troopers, Holding camps from TPM, from Supreme Chancellor to The Emperor,....GENIUS, I'm sure Spielberg through in his 2 cents.
The podrace was Episode I: "The Phantom Menace" from the prequel trilogy. "A New Hope" (Episode IV) was the first ever Star Wars movie. Also, C-3PO was in Episode I, but he just didn't have his golden shell.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The fourth one came out in 1999, and it was the one with the little kid. I know because I remember watching it in the theater, and I watched the other three while I was a young child.
This is not the scene form the Triumph of The Will which is commonly linked with the ending of Star Wars, but it basically draws the same picture. That Lucas used German filing techniques such as the one in that particular scene is undeniable. Who can blame him.?The Germans revolutionize the way things were filmed.
Lucas has long admitted that he stole the final scene from "New Hope" from "Triumph of the Will." I'm glad to finally see someone make the connection more explicit. Hilarious! Thanks.
HA HA HA pissing my self with laughter, Chewy shows up at 0:42!!! Keep up the good work the world needs to lighten up and chill out. Skunk and ecstacy should forced upon all politicians then there would be no wars period. !!!! lol
Execute the dealers, execute the traffickers and execute the manufacturers. Once word gets out that drugs equal DEATH only an idiot would want to deal/traffic or manufacture them, problem would solve itself faster than Nancy Reagan could say "Just say no." Another benefit would be, the darlings who are executed would more than likely recieve darwin awards!
What about Alcohol & tobacco? Between them they have killed more people over the last 200years than ALL WARS COMBINED? and yet they are socially accepted and LEGAL. People in glass houses shouldnt throw stones. If people are foolish enough to risk there lives taking drugs, legalize them tax them and this would reduce crime figures significantly.
PCP aka Angeldust real nice drug to use, causes psychotic behavior in it's user. Real good to have someone on. Ever see them when they decide to get into a fight for no reason? They'll kill 100% of the time. KILL THE DRUG DEALERS! DRUGS ARE DESTROYING THIS NATION, DEATH PENALTY FOR DRUG DEALERS!
When I think about I wondered if the planet Hoth was named after Col.General Herman Hoth whose famous for trying to get the 6th army out of Stalingrad during operation "Winter Storm". Star Wars has alot of nazi references you know.
But if we did care...What about George Lucas's choice to even use the word "stormtrooper", which is taken directly out of the NAZI canon?
You may find many alternative resemblances etc. however George Lucas clearly intended the Glactic Empire to be an allegorical representation of the NAZI administration.
I would say that General Grievous and his Separatists were the analogy of the National Socialists, not the Rebel Alliance. The Rebels were an analogy of NATO.
The Republic was at war with the Separatists i.e. Democratic countries and Communists against the Nazis and Fascists. Why are the Separatists the Fascists and Nazis? Because they were made up of businessmen. Clone Wars= World War II. Empire against Rebel Alliance- Cold War. Empire was the Communist countries because they became very oppressive and the Rebel Alliance were NATO.
Well, the Galactic Empire and Nazi Germany has many things in common that cannot be over looked. For instance both Nazi Germany and the Galactic Empire emerged from a Republic (Weimar Republic=Old Republic), and both Hitler and Palpatine were Chancellors before gaining absolute power. Also they both were granted emergeny power, thus giving them an opportunity to better establish their military regimes. You can also compare Order 66 to The Final Solution, and the Clone Troopers to the Waffen SS.
But you could compare Hitler with Stalin who perverted Socialism and started the Great Purge. Grievous and Dooku were leading the Separatists; Grievous is more ruthless (Hitler) and Dooku is a bit compromising (Mussolini). Dooku gets killed before Grievous just like Mussolini then Hitler.
@chsbcg The Galactic Empire is most closely analogized to the Roman Empire. Episode 3 covers this the best, if you compare it to the rise of the Roman Caesars. The Rebels don't really have an analogy. It's just supposed to make a good story.
This is pretty beautifully cut, Great job!
nate000088 2 days ago
There is a lot to say about them but they at least know how to make an entrance.
J5MARLON 6 days ago
Einstein: Hitler, I am your father!
mindarinas 3 weeks ago
This is how it would have locked like if the Germans won ww2 ;)
SocialistMetalHead 3 weeks ago
god nazis back in the day would shit themselves if they heard this being played behind hitler!
thethethetheluis 1 month ago
I really WANNA favorite this but am slightly afraid to.
englishlouie 1 month ago
So...George Lucas...fan of John Ford, Akira Kurosawa AND Nazi propaganda films. Splendid.
Mikefreed9241 1 month ago
guy @ 1:07
"What the hell is supposed to be going on here?"
KaliQEliYah 2 months ago
LOL
lord1night1wish 2 months ago
My Little Pony ripped star wars off, which ripped Hitler off. This means there is a direct correleation between HItler and My Little Pony.
Moredread25 3 months ago 12
@Moredread25
I came here thinking just the same thing!
xplson 2 months ago
@Moredread25 Fuhrer Celestia is best Fuhrer
EvansRowan123 2 months ago 3
Look at Darth Vader's helmet without the mask. Now, look at a German WWII helmet.
AustinTheGeek777 3 months ago
So Chewbacca got that business about his Aryan certificate straightened out? LOL
eoppen 3 months ago
As a film purist, I must admit that I enjoy seen "A New Hope" in the original black and white...
michstea1 4 months ago
Despite its Naziness, Triumph of the Will was seen as great, in pure filmmaking terms. There's nothing wrong with referencing it.
Christhefireshark 4 months ago
if the rebels = nazis how do you explain the wookies and fish people and assorted minorities that the rebel alliance accepts? but there is only one type of person in the empire. *hint hint*
hokieMV 5 months ago
Imagine how much more morally ambiguous Star Wars would have been if it had been Hitler who'd destroyed the Death Star.
PuissantAlgernon 5 months ago
@HeroOfTheSovietUnion, You are not imagining things. One reference to the similarity of these two scenes can be found on the last page of this article from the New York Times - "Reich Star" By CLIVE JAMES, Published: March 25, 2007. George Lucas was not alone among Hollywood types who admired Leni Riefenstahl.
blicious187 5 months ago
No idea why some people are debating analogies when Lucas even stated that the Imperial Empire was based on the Nazis, this is Fact not opinion so forget Empire=Romans or Empire=Seperatists.
Caribdus 7 months ago
Give me the Imperial Officers of the Galactic Empire or the Field Marshal of the Third Reich anyday!!! These men knew how to rage war!!!
founder222 7 months ago
I heard the scene in Star Wars was actually inspired by Triumph of the Will. I can't find a source, though.
Christhefireshark 8 months ago
Pretty scary that this edit is so fitting. Hitler lived the movie.
jp3sucks 1 year ago
This is funny and yet horrible at the same time
toadsEATbugs 1 year ago
@magrace1 You are a thingfish with no mind and obviously in bed with the enemy of mankind, but hey, you have every right to walk around thinking yourself smart with your head squarely up your silly ass. ENJOY.
videocanone 1 year ago
The Sith are the jewish banksters who corrupt and undermine all true and pure national cultures, working towards their satanic NWO.
videocanone 1 year ago
@videocanone god you are a moron!
magrace1 1 year ago
At the start of the film the Rebel soldiers are wearing what look like DDR army helmets. Rebels = Commie-Nazi Kraut mashup.
dccmpbll 1 year ago
Wow,I was just thinking that could have been the climax of the German victory celebrations had they won.Of course had they won then English girls wouldn't be getting raped by Asians in London,and there wouldn't be any no go zones for white people.WHITE Children would being playing in Adolf Hitler park while their WHITE parents sip lemonade.Had the English soldiers seen the future they'd have defected on mass to the Germans to save their grand-kids from the MultiKult hell that is England today
zombiekiller117 1 year ago
Btw another nazi parallel is in revenge of the Sith. The plot of Palpatine wanting to go from chancellor to emperor roughly matches that of Hitler who was appointed chancellor and wanted to be dictator.
ranebow5 1 year ago
@ranebow5 Don't forget his using Mace Windu trying to kill him as a reason to declare emergency, take away right and to eliminate his opponents, like Hitler did with the Reichstag fire.
dccmpbll 1 year ago
@dccmpbll You can also draw the parallel between Imperial Stormtroopers and Nazi Stormtroopers (Brownshirts)
colonelsanders132 1 year ago
LOL I usually don't like Nazi parodies but this fit pretty good. Thanks.
ranebow5 1 year ago
There's a Dark side of the force in Star Wars
BananoPower2 1 year ago
Comment removed
zombiekiller117 1 year ago
Lucas has never denied how he was influenced by Triumph of the Will.
archer1949 1 year ago
LOL a new hope? what total destruction? !! my guess is this all happened so a million subway sandwich franchizes could be built in germany!
mannequinwizard 1 year ago
So I guess this is how WW 2 would have ended if Hitler had won
GothikOrk 1 year ago
Awesome.....Nazi history equals George Lucas Star Wars story...NO QUESTION ABOUT IT. This is crazy, Hitler invented Star Wars!!!! Storm Troopers, Holding camps from TPM, from Supreme Chancellor to The Emperor,....GENIUS, I'm sure Spielberg through in his 2 cents.
Danny022479 1 year ago
Nice.
It would have been cool if you added Leni Riefenstahl to the credits. XD
deluxe007mx 1 year ago
throne scene was a clever ripoff lol, big nazi banner replaced by vertical blue-glowing thing.
BovrilKetchup 2 years ago 2
The vertical blue-glowing things are windows. :-p
UZDA4RS 1 year ago
Hitler: "Winston, I am you father!"
Churchill: "NOOOOOOOOO!"
Treblaine 2 years ago 37
@Treblaine
LOL
Gooshkinheimer 2 years ago
@Treblaine Churchill was older than him you dumbass.
suicidewafflez 6 months ago
@suicidewafflez
Get a sense of humor, you cuntrag.
crusader149 6 months ago
@crusader149 Where's your fucking balls?
suicidewafflez 6 months ago
I think this video edit was just waiting to happen. Its genius!
Trialbystone17 2 years ago
I lol'd so fucking hard! nice work
Slurm867 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u faggot dont mock star wars
BlairExodus99 2 years ago
It's too perfect.
trav12th 2 years ago
The Sequel Trilogy after GL passes
STAR WARS Episode VII-The Dark Order
STAR WARS Episode VIII-Battle of the Republic
and last but not least
STAR WARS Episode IX-Balance of the Force
KyleKatarn789 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WERE THEY FOLLOWERS OF HITLER??!!! u should be ashamed!!!! oh god .... oh my god..
aaless12 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This doesn't make sense. Star Wars Episode IV didn't have Chewbacca or C3po in it, it was the one with the little kid and the pod race.
spensword 2 years ago
The podrace was Episode I: "The Phantom Menace" from the prequel trilogy. "A New Hope" (Episode IV) was the first ever Star Wars movie. Also, C-3PO was in Episode I, but he just didn't have his golden shell.
guyperson42X 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The fourth one came out in 1999, and it was the one with the little kid. I know because I remember watching it in the theater, and I watched the other three while I was a young child.
spensword 2 years ago
Yes, Episode I was the fourth movie to be released, but it is a prequel. Therefore, it was labeled as Episode I.
Prequel Trilogy (The new movies)
Episode I: The Phantom Menace (1999)
Episode II: Attack of The Clones (2002)
Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005)
Original Trilogy (The old movies)
Episode IV: A New Hope (1977)
Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back (1980)
Episode VI: Return of the Jedi (1983)
I own all of the movies. If you don't believe me go look it up.
guyperson42X 2 years ago
Don't feed the trolls, guise.
RaisonDeCalcul 2 years ago 2
This is not the scene form the Triumph of The Will which is commonly linked with the ending of Star Wars, but it basically draws the same picture. That Lucas used German filing techniques such as the one in that particular scene is undeniable. Who can blame him.?The Germans revolutionize the way things were filmed.
kasttt 2 years ago
funny idea^^
MonsieurClash 2 years ago
plutot, navrant !
jibicoco 2 years ago
Lucas has long admitted that he stole the final scene from "New Hope" from "Triumph of the Will." I'm glad to finally see someone make the connection more explicit. Hilarious! Thanks.
jbmorgan 3 years ago
LOL Chewy =DDDDD
demonichunter47 3 years ago
lol:)
Skipper1177 3 years ago
HA HA HA pissing my self with laughter, Chewy shows up at 0:42!!! Keep up the good work the world needs to lighten up and chill out. Skunk and ecstacy should forced upon all politicians then there would be no wars period. !!!! lol
Dandaniels1978 3 years ago
All people dealing with or manufacturing illegal narcotics should be tried, convicted and sentenced to death by crucifixion.
cafelattefuture 3 years ago
Ok here is the solution then - legalize them. Problem solved, no more crime, period.
Dandaniels1978 3 years ago
Execute the dealers, execute the traffickers and execute the manufacturers. Once word gets out that drugs equal DEATH only an idiot would want to deal/traffic or manufacture them, problem would solve itself faster than Nancy Reagan could say "Just say no." Another benefit would be, the darlings who are executed would more than likely recieve darwin awards!
cafelattefuture 3 years ago
What about Alcohol & tobacco? Between them they have killed more people over the last 200years than ALL WARS COMBINED? and yet they are socially accepted and LEGAL. People in glass houses shouldnt throw stones. If people are foolish enough to risk there lives taking drugs, legalize them tax them and this would reduce crime figures significantly.
Dandaniels1978 3 years ago
PCP aka Angeldust real nice drug to use, causes psychotic behavior in it's user. Real good to have someone on. Ever see them when they decide to get into a fight for no reason? They'll kill 100% of the time. KILL THE DRUG DEALERS! DRUGS ARE DESTROYING THIS NATION, DEATH PENALTY FOR DRUG DEALERS!
cafelattefuture 3 years ago
Limited intellect, i notice you havent answered my question about Alcohol and Tobacco. You must be a politician
Dandaniels1978 3 years ago
lol
racoricor 3 years ago
LOL hahahaha Hitler....Star Wars....OMG this is the most funny video in youtube.
MALAKAS0 3 years ago
When I think about I wondered if the planet Hoth was named after Col.General Herman Hoth whose famous for trying to get the 6th army out of Stalingrad during operation "Winter Storm". Star Wars has alot of nazi references you know.
cripplehawk 3 years ago
Notice how this is exactly how Episode IV ends. Ofcourse its ment to be. Luke Skywalker as Hither etc. Then all the Nazis as the rebels.
0mega7000 3 years ago
Yes, they were evil murdering scumbags bent of world domination, but you have to admit, they had style.
grissom1228 3 years ago 27
@grissom1228 quit bitching shut the fuck up! damn!
btown2011 1 year ago
@grissom1228 and so did the Soviets. It just goes to show catch phrases and awsome flags don't amount to mutch
Vutxzzn2 1 month ago
I saw Chewbacca,C-3PO,and R2-D2!
rjoleary1992 3 years ago
This is disturbing, but in a good way.
princesshannah7 3 years ago
yes they were racist for unhumand beings except if they werent emperors ss
JPR300 3 years ago
But if we did care...What about George Lucas's choice to even use the word "stormtrooper", which is taken directly out of the NAZI canon?
You may find many alternative resemblances etc. however George Lucas clearly intended the Glactic Empire to be an allegorical representation of the NAZI administration.
TechNoir 3 years ago
This is an awesomely funny video.
We dont care about what technicalities he criticizes. chsbcg needs to get laid.
TechNoir 3 years ago
I would say that General Grievous and his Separatists were the analogy of the National Socialists, not the Rebel Alliance. The Rebels were an analogy of NATO.
chsbcg 4 years ago
I would have to say the Galactic Empire is the most like Nazi Germany. The resembalence is uncanny.
HeroOfTheSovietUnion 4 years ago
The Republic was at war with the Separatists i.e. Democratic countries and Communists against the Nazis and Fascists. Why are the Separatists the Fascists and Nazis? Because they were made up of businessmen. Clone Wars= World War II. Empire against Rebel Alliance- Cold War. Empire was the Communist countries because they became very oppressive and the Rebel Alliance were NATO.
chsbcg 4 years ago
Well, the Galactic Empire and Nazi Germany has many things in common that cannot be over looked. For instance both Nazi Germany and the Galactic Empire emerged from a Republic (Weimar Republic=Old Republic), and both Hitler and Palpatine were Chancellors before gaining absolute power. Also they both were granted emergeny power, thus giving them an opportunity to better establish their military regimes. You can also compare Order 66 to The Final Solution, and the Clone Troopers to the Waffen SS.
HeroOfTheSovietUnion 4 years ago 4
But you could compare Hitler with Stalin who perverted Socialism and started the Great Purge. Grievous and Dooku were leading the Separatists; Grievous is more ruthless (Hitler) and Dooku is a bit compromising (Mussolini). Dooku gets killed before Grievous just like Mussolini then Hitler.
chsbcg 4 years ago
the gray uniforms vaders helmit :)
darenun 3 years ago
@chsbcg The Galactic Empire is most closely analogized to the Roman Empire. Episode 3 covers this the best, if you compare it to the rise of the Roman Caesars. The Rebels don't really have an analogy. It's just supposed to make a good story.
stweston 8 months ago
Ilaughed...
swash77 4 years ago
AWESOME, except the nazi germany part...
PoopaPapaPalpatine 4 years ago