@doitanywayz and sometimes hearing his voice before 66 and 67, his voice sounds a lot deeper? is that advances in technoloy, different audio equipment being made or is paul really dead and they used a double?!?!
ahhhh i dont wanna believe it surely it cant be possible but why make a song about paul being dead??!!
Thanks for your reply, Vpmatt. I got that info from a late 1967 article of "Cheatah", a short-lived underground publication. I've a great memory when it comes to music, no matter how far back, but for the life of me, I can't remember what happened this morning!
John insisted that the orchestra wear the party garb. I remember that. It's exactly what Brian Wilson did when he recorded the landmark "fire" music for "Smile"! He had the musicians wear plastic fire hats. You've done a fantastic job with these videos--a lot of insight here I've never seen before. Incidently, does anyone remember what they said on the inner groove? I do.
@tas6010 I love any link between Lennon / The Beatles and Brian Wilson so thanks for your comment. "Smile" is also a work of art and thank God we finally saw it. It was a circle of creative rivalries that produced some of the greatest popular music of all time - Lennon vs McCartney vs Wilson vs The Beatles vs The Beach Boys and back again.
i think you are right, "how i won the war" is the film he is referring to. The line "i just had to look, having read the book" kind of confirms it because the film was based on a novel.
I wrote my Ph.D. dissertation on how U.S. TV News covered JL's death. CBS used this track as an "audio clothesline" on which reporters hung images that worked w/the audio to report, & comment on, int'l reaction to the murder. The study argues that when the receiver is presented with such audio-visual blends, the meanings made can diverge markedly from those that influenced the composer or his "intention." Even so, this vid is a valuable "add" to our culture's lasting interest in this track.
Best Beatles song ever, best song ever, the verses he's dreaming, the bridge he wakes up (at the sound of the alarm clock) then he dreams again... surreal music at it's best
@shatteredlamp12 MOST DEFINATELY!!!!!! i have every album (except yellow submarine, sadly) on my iPod, plus "1" and "Love" (2 "best of" albums)...and i never tire of hearing this song. it's so emotional and amazing...although if any of you have the actual album Sgt Pepper's, listen to the last 30 seconds which i only did once, because it scares me :) (they don't do it on this recording)...and @10shutt, i agree with you too. the beatles are HANDS DOWN the best band to ever have lived....
imagine these musicians had the equipments we have now??!!! artists nowadays are lazy,they do one album and get on t.v and radio and complain that it took a lot out of them to make.
@QuikVidGuy That parts called The Inner Groove a reverse speech song of the beatles saying "we"ll f**k you like we're superman" on the original British vinyls its listed after A Day In The Life, The Beatles were never informed of the addition
Theres a good case to be made IMO that is the first song of our 'modern media era' : all the media preoccupations we are so familiar with today in popular culture are there . Obsessions with fame, reality culture, drugs, death & war, making up a very real part of our day to day routines.. all condensed into a beautifully timed five minute piece, that has become a legend in its own right .
AMAZING info Vpmatt...this my favorite track from them. I'm a 47, black brother who's heavily into Classic Soul/R&B, Funk, Disco, and Classic Hip-hop, and yes, I am a fan of their music. I'm also a mobile DJ, and also have done some radio work, and I love behind-the-scenes stuff like this. Can't wait to check out the others in the series, thanks for posting!
do some people think tara browne was paul mccartney cause people who think paul is dead connect to a 1966 car accident that i guess paul was in?? i dont think paul is dead but it makes sense cause that picture of tara could resemble paul
I am amazed of your info in this beloved song. However, I think you forgot to mention the shhhh sound at the end of the song when accidentaly someone drop a piece of the sound system.... Anyway it seems is not here!
Nice Vid, but you didn't talk about the dog whistle at the end or the restraunt gabber at the fade out. If you record it into sound forge, it says "...never could be any other way". As well as other stuff layered over the top.
@1lundun I'll tell you. Because this recording comes off a CD which for starters is lower fidelity, then compressed into a WMV file which is then further compressed by YouTube when the video is uploaded and processed. Go and buy a vinyl copy of the record, play it on a record player, turn the volume right up and stick your ear next to the speaker.
ok, the part where it reminds me of an insane asylum, seriously scared the shit out of me. Like, i was actually frightened that something was going to attack me. That is a great song...
Both John and Paul were great, and it was the chemistry of their combined abilities that made the Beatles what they were. No point in saying one was better or worse.
Definitely the best Beatles song, and my favorite written by Lennon..all of your videos on the Beatles songs are great so far, please do I Am The Walrus..thats my 3rd fav. song behind this and Strawberry Fields Forever
I hope you eventually do "I Am The Walrus," which you said you might do on one of the 5 that you've already done. That and A Day in the Life are my two favorite Beatles songs. Love all five that you've done btw, as well as the "In My Life" John Lennon Tribute.
Kind of understates McCartney's role. Lennon had a nice tune and vocal but it wasn't going to be much, until McCartney provided overall structure, including not only "his" middle section but the orchestral idea was primarily McCartney's as well.
I think its hilarious how people like the person below feel they have to comment on a band they obviously dont like just to try and get a cheap rise out of people. Its pretty pathetic.
Did you ever come across anything that might corroborate a thing Phil Collins said regarding the drum riffs that alternate with the vocals on the verses?
He had never heard anything like it anywhere. He interpreted it as being a "conversation" between singer and drummer. The riffs, each one distinctly different, giving a sense that the drummer is responding emotionally to each lyric line.
Thanks for taking the time it must have taken to put this together.
Dude please get your facts straight before posting the..especially to this song. This song is well documented....Maybe you should look it up sometime yourself...I realize you are trying but get some more info...
I swear I hear a bit of minimoog in the final chord. I think it was available at that time, at least the Beatles could have gotten one if it was anywhere near completion.
fascinating! i have been a beatles fan since i was 10 (1974) and would listen to my albums constantly and knew every song by heart.i love seeing the back story on these songs
I can't see the word "mistake" there.... a "coincidence" is something different. The clock was put there on purpose. It wasn't a mistake. Noone said it was. McCartney's middle section hadn't been decided on when the clock was recorded. Why would Geoff Emerick make it up? He was there and he recorded the song!
The 24-bar bridge section ended with the sound of an alarm clock triggered by Evans. The original intent was to edit out the ringing alarm clock when the missing section was filled in; however it complemented McCartney's piece well; the first line of McCartney's song began "Woke up, fell out of bed", so the decision was made to keep the sound. Martin later said that editing it out would have been unfeasible in any case.
when did the rumours about paul being dead come along?
this to me is about a car crash and paul dying!!!! why would they have this sing with lyrics about that?
I don't get it, this song is spooky as well...
doitanywayz 1 month ago
@doitanywayz and sometimes hearing his voice before 66 and 67, his voice sounds a lot deeper? is that advances in technoloy, different audio equipment being made or is paul really dead and they used a double?!?!
ahhhh i dont wanna believe it surely it cant be possible but why make a song about paul being dead??!!
doitanywayz 1 month ago
2:52 to 3:22 from Gods lips to your ears. Best #### ever.
cookcookish 2 months ago
Thanks for your reply, Vpmatt. I got that info from a late 1967 article of "Cheatah", a short-lived underground publication. I've a great memory when it comes to music, no matter how far back, but for the life of me, I can't remember what happened this morning!
tas6010 5 months ago
John insisted that the orchestra wear the party garb. I remember that. It's exactly what Brian Wilson did when he recorded the landmark "fire" music for "Smile"! He had the musicians wear plastic fire hats. You've done a fantastic job with these videos--a lot of insight here I've never seen before. Incidently, does anyone remember what they said on the inner groove? I do.
tas6010 5 months ago
@tas6010 I love any link between Lennon / The Beatles and Brian Wilson so thanks for your comment. "Smile" is also a work of art and thank God we finally saw it. It was a circle of creative rivalries that produced some of the greatest popular music of all time - Lennon vs McCartney vs Wilson vs The Beatles vs The Beach Boys and back again.
Vpmatt 5 months ago
And now I finally understood that Yellow Submarine joke...
*in the sea of holes*
John: This reminds me of Blackburn, Lancashire.
Paul: Oh, boy...
MCullenHightopp 6 months ago
@MCullenHightopp LOL
CardingtonLZF 5 months ago
"I'd love to turn you on" got it banned. WOW. music has changed drastically.
robertjf3596 6 months ago
The single page with Lennon's hand-written lyrics for this song recently sold at auction for well over $1 million USD. Go figure.
JeffersonDinedAlone 6 months ago
i think you are right, "how i won the war" is the film he is referring to. The line "i just had to look, having read the book" kind of confirms it because the film was based on a novel.
Nice video, i would have never caught that!
jjws 7 months ago
I wrote my Ph.D. dissertation on how U.S. TV News covered JL's death. CBS used this track as an "audio clothesline" on which reporters hung images that worked w/the audio to report, & comment on, int'l reaction to the murder. The study argues that when the receiver is presented with such audio-visual blends, the meanings made can diverge markedly from those that influenced the composer or his "intention." Even so, this vid is a valuable "add" to our culture's lasting interest in this track.
bkmkerwsa 7 months ago
actually this song was written as part of the great hoax about john lennon's death. as there where also very many clues on the sgt. pepper album
idance4life17 9 months ago
@idance4life17 it wasn't actually, but i think you are referring to the hoax about paul mccartney's death?
AmonCOCO 8 months ago
@AmonCOCO yes that... sorry for the mistake. and i just took a course in british innavasion, it is
idance4life17 8 months ago
The fact that all this was done on a four track tape recorder is mind blowing
TheViralSBK 1 year ago
I dedicate this song to my imaginary MF
mararules 1 year ago
I can't believe that not only do you find all these amazing facts...but also the photos and clips to go with them.
I heard my first Beatles song when I was in class 5 (Across the Universe). I am 38 now....I end every day by listening to them.
redcom111 1 year ago
Best Beatles song ever, best song ever, the verses he's dreaming, the bridge he wakes up (at the sound of the alarm clock) then he dreams again... surreal music at it's best
bpanzullo1 1 year ago
the beatles are the best band of all time
shakejunt654321 1 year ago
@shatteredlamp12 MOST DEFINATELY!!!!!! i have every album (except yellow submarine, sadly) on my iPod, plus "1" and "Love" (2 "best of" albums)...and i never tire of hearing this song. it's so emotional and amazing...although if any of you have the actual album Sgt Pepper's, listen to the last 30 seconds which i only did once, because it scares me :) (they don't do it on this recording)...and @10shutt, i agree with you too. the beatles are HANDS DOWN the best band to ever have lived....
HeartBeatles 1 year ago
imagine these musicians had the equipments we have now??!!! artists nowadays are lazy,they do one album and get on t.v and radio and complain that it took a lot out of them to make.
10shutt 1 year ago
lol on my ipod in the song it says "Oh shit"
CatseaTheCat 1 year ago
Great fun to learn all this.....thanks!
mudhens4ever 1 year ago
@QuikVidGuy That parts called The Inner Groove a reverse speech song of the beatles saying "we"ll f**k you like we're superman" on the original British vinyls its listed after A Day In The Life, The Beatles were never informed of the addition
sUiCiDeSqUrReLz 1 year ago
What about that high-pitched tone, and the repeating "Never to see any other wa-- Never to see any other wa--"?
QuikVidGuy 1 year ago
Theres a good case to be made IMO that is the first song of our 'modern media era' : all the media preoccupations we are so familiar with today in popular culture are there . Obsessions with fame, reality culture, drugs, death & war, making up a very real part of our day to day routines.. all condensed into a beautifully timed five minute piece, that has become a legend in its own right .
dwiseman1 1 year ago
Comment removed
dwiseman1 1 year ago
How about the random noises after the song?
uelssom 1 year ago
never could be any other way
M1t20 1 year ago
hey vpmatt- youre a champ.
TheLindz2798 1 year ago
AMAZING info Vpmatt...this my favorite track from them. I'm a 47, black brother who's heavily into Classic Soul/R&B, Funk, Disco, and Classic Hip-hop, and yes, I am a fan of their music. I'm also a mobile DJ, and also have done some radio work, and I love behind-the-scenes stuff like this. Can't wait to check out the others in the series, thanks for posting!
DJBiggieSpins 1 year ago 3
@DJBiggieSpins Thanks for your comment mate. Enjoy the rest of the series!
Vpmatt 1 year ago
@DJBiggieSpins I agree bro...possibly the Mozart and Beethovens of our time no doubt
Moeman774746 1 year ago
do some people think tara browne was paul mccartney cause people who think paul is dead connect to a 1966 car accident that i guess paul was in?? i dont think paul is dead but it makes sense cause that picture of tara could resemble paul
jias188 1 year ago
I like this song especially that part wear it sounds like a tape being fast-forwarded. Amazing music I must say im only 26..........
Aznac4twentz 1 year ago
The 3 people that disliked this video like red colour. That's the only explanation.
AntiJonasZone 1 year ago
I am amazed of your info in this beloved song. However, I think you forgot to mention the shhhh sound at the end of the song when accidentaly someone drop a piece of the sound system.... Anyway it seems is not here!
Good job!
JoanMenrod 1 year ago
Great job. As a Beatle lover these are priceless!
craigaa52 1 year ago
Nice Vid, but you didn't talk about the dog whistle at the end or the restraunt gabber at the fade out. If you record it into sound forge, it says "...never could be any other way". As well as other stuff layered over the top.
boabyp 1 year ago
can anyone tell why I cant hear the squeaking of rngo`s shoe or the shuffling of the papers?? or the ac??
1lundun 1 year ago
@1lundun I'll tell you. Because this recording comes off a CD which for starters is lower fidelity, then compressed into a WMV file which is then further compressed by YouTube when the video is uploaded and processed. Go and buy a vinyl copy of the record, play it on a record player, turn the volume right up and stick your ear next to the speaker.
Vpmatt 1 year ago 6
@Vpmatt thank for sharing. i learned something today.
1lundun 1 year ago
@Vpmatt lolumad?
IMAGETCHANOMNOMNOM 1 year ago
a 4 track recording , says it all..
bruceleeC64 1 year ago
You should have explained the "Never could be any other way" part of A Day In The Life, a lot of theorists would be pleased :3
TheRealBanjo2 1 year ago
Very informative. Very nice video, thanks!
acac101 1 year ago
no it was based on puals death part of the hoks
theycallmemagic 1 year ago
ok, the part where it reminds me of an insane asylum, seriously scared the shit out of me. Like, i was actually frightened that something was going to attack me. That is a great song...
bunyman4 1 year ago
This is such a great job..
song and video.
J077535 1 year ago
Absolutely brilliant! I was a child when I liked this album ! Now I see the attraction'
wildwahine1 1 year ago
thanks so much for uploading these awessome videos! :)
SecretlyyNerdy 1 year ago
Both John and Paul were great, and it was the chemistry of their combined abilities that made the Beatles what they were. No point in saying one was better or worse.
london2z 1 year ago
please make more videos like these !!!!!
nikitofin 1 year ago
do here comes the sun!
joejr913 1 year ago
Really nice video, just 1 question...why did you not use the Sgt. Pepper version?
ShotGunAnd 1 year ago
I think the Love CD was closer.... and I liked the way you can hear Mal Evans a bit better...
Vpmatt 1 year ago
@Vpmatt lol same here~
Savagekey12 1 year ago
I think that the beatles is the best music I've ever heard in my life
ZomBoiMusic 1 year ago
THE GREATEST SONG IN ALL OF HISTORY.
redbe75 1 year ago
Awesome
liljay121833 1 year ago
Excellent video and lots of cool information.
bamboo4tameshigiri 1 year ago
I hope you will soon do I am the Walrus
ShotGunAnd 2 years ago
Thank You Beatles!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
pallallan 2 years ago
Vpmatt--SPECTACULAR videos!
The Beatles are a part of my DNA, so you must know that what you're doing is important to a lot of people.
I was listening to them last night and already today...Then I ran across your collection.
Amazing info!
Thanks, Vpmatt!
meridethtohayes 2 years ago 5
Wow thanks very much. I appreciate that. There will be more.
Vpmatt 2 years ago
Definitely the best Beatles song, and my favorite written by Lennon..all of your videos on the Beatles songs are great so far, please do I Am The Walrus..thats my 3rd fav. song behind this and Strawberry Fields Forever
kingbreeze2010 2 years ago 3
I hope you eventually do "I Am The Walrus," which you said you might do on one of the 5 that you've already done. That and A Day in the Life are my two favorite Beatles songs. Love all five that you've done btw, as well as the "In My Life" John Lennon Tribute.
ripum853 2 years ago
Which you said you might do on a comment for one of the five that you've already done*
ripum853 2 years ago
Thanks for the feedback. Yep stay tuned for "I am the Walrus".
Vpmatt 2 years ago
Cranberry sauce is a current event ??? I'll remember that next time I'm eating it with my Thanksgiving dinner.
LODGE4444 2 years ago
Guys named Tara, Kim, Courtney? This ole world just gets more mixed up by the decade!
Zickcermacity 2 years ago 2
Absolutely Amazing song. Lennon was on a different level to anyone else. Best composer of all time, impossible to top him.
cockylachy 2 years ago 3
Amaziingg! thank you for this! and i agree; this is THE BEST SONG EVER!
TheLennonDreamer 2 years ago
These "inside" videos are great. Keep them coming if possible. There would've been no end to Lennons creativeness. He was one of a kind>
brad2591 2 years ago 2
bits and pieces of this song is on''revolution no.9''
georgelee43211 2 years ago
this song is not one of the best songs ever............ITS THE BEST SONG EVER
04116404 2 years ago 3
they didnt explained tha very end :/ ... the weird repetitive acid trippy sound xD
rekee3 2 years ago
Kind of understates McCartney's role. Lennon had a nice tune and vocal but it wasn't going to be much, until McCartney provided overall structure, including not only "his" middle section but the orchestral idea was primarily McCartney's as well.
jcarty123 2 years ago 2
I disagree completely. The "nice tune and vocal" is brilliant and is the heart and soul of the song. Not the middle eight or the orchestral climax.
Vpmatt 2 years ago
Very nice primer for those out there who may not know their Beatle history.
Excellent job and kudos.
drencrom68 2 years ago
damn, the alarm clock was accidental? thats an awesome coincidence
MANGO171 2 years ago
make one for penny lane!!!
this was great!!!
greekmavros 2 years ago
Fabulous, just fabulous!
Thank you for all the insight into what took to record this song.
Raulito7 2 years ago
John Lennon was a genius, and Paul McCartney still is.
WiltatKansas 2 years ago 3
this is a great clip about the indisputably greatest rock and roll band EVER
jballard459 2 years ago 5
Best. Band. Ever.
shatteredlamp12 2 years ago 25
I give you an A for content but a an F+ for punctuation
BlackieHugeHands 2 years ago
3:58 I could not stop laughing. This is a fantastic addition to YouTube, thank you so much for posting this gem!
funnybunnyrockstar 2 years ago
this is awesome! Thanks!!!
1971alicat 2 years ago
heart for you love !
drv12021 2 years ago
Wonderful !!!!! Thank you for the info Wonderful !!!!!
RickmalR 2 years ago
the "aaaaahhhhh" part is just perfect.
themusicman1973 2 years ago 2
I think its hilarious how people like the person below feel they have to comment on a band they obviously dont like just to try and get a cheap rise out of people. Its pretty pathetic.
Kriss.
KrissGray 2 years ago
naw naw naw, "the shit" is a good thing, "shit" is bad.
UnfamiliarPlace 2 years ago
The Beatles were the SHIT !
Ephesians1957 2 years ago
they shoudve played what 1:53 if your iterested
davidheromany 2 years ago
Did you ever come across anything that might corroborate a thing Phil Collins said regarding the drum riffs that alternate with the vocals on the verses?
He had never heard anything like it anywhere. He interpreted it as being a "conversation" between singer and drummer. The riffs, each one distinctly different, giving a sense that the drummer is responding emotionally to each lyric line.
Thanks for taking the time it must have taken to put this together.
goldenponderbob 2 years ago
nice video
jammona 2 years ago
yeah agreed great my brain is slowing down its 1:11 am
davidheromany 2 years ago
Dude please get your facts straight before posting the..especially to this song. This song is well documented....Maybe you should look it up sometime yourself...I realize you are trying but get some more info...
wmccoy 2 years ago
You are a wonderful person!
tommynogo 3 years ago
I swear I hear a bit of minimoog in the final chord. I think it was available at that time, at least the Beatles could have gotten one if it was anywhere near completion.
xj14y 3 years ago
brilliant could you do any more 'inside a beatles records' ?? That endless chord = genius
elletingz 3 years ago
Actually, it was the opposite. They couldn't find a ryhm for for "Small" until paul suggested "Albert Hall"
ZeNoodle 3 years ago
one of the best songs ever written in the history of music
marcodicapriotv 3 years ago 35
@marcodicapriotv indeed timeless
bruceleeC64 1 year ago
Is the Love-version playing?
DoctorPencilK 3 years ago
Yes.
Vpmatt 3 years ago
Actually, I'm pretty sure the car accident thing was about Paul... Thus, creating the whole "Paul is Dead" scheme...
alexman331 3 years ago
No, it was about Tara Browne the Guinness heir. He was a friend of the Beatles.
Vpmatt 3 years ago
fascinating! i have been a beatles fan since i was 10 (1974) and would listen to my albums constantly and knew every song by heart.i love seeing the back story on these songs
cwecub 3 years ago
it kinda sounds what i would relate to dying/.. or floatin away as a spirit, or maybe the gates of heaven opening///closing. ne one digg?
pbrox 3 years ago 3
thanks for this- that "endless chord" is intense.
pbrox 3 years ago
Greatest song ever written
rjkahlon 3 years ago 4
The panels go by too fast. I can't read them, so I have to keep pausing the video, which is really annoying.
sirqpidvalentino 3 years ago 3
A great look into an amazing song! Thanks for putting this together.
mofo269 3 years ago 2
SURE!!! The alarm clock at the beginning of the second verse was a mistake...! I call BS.
So much transparent trivia.
squanto2 3 years ago
Who said it was a mistake??
Vpmatt 3 years ago
"Big Mal also let off an alarm clock...which Emerick could also not get rid of..."
"happy coincidence, as it fitted perfectly with the first line..."
B.S. The alarm clock was obviously recorded specifically to be placed where it was in the mix. It's brilliant. Why do people need to make shit up?
squanto2 3 years ago
I can't see the word "mistake" there.... a "coincidence" is something different. The clock was put there on purpose. It wasn't a mistake. Noone said it was. McCartney's middle section hadn't been decided on when the clock was recorded. Why would Geoff Emerick make it up? He was there and he recorded the song!
Vpmatt 3 years ago
The 24-bar bridge section ended with the sound of an alarm clock triggered by Evans. The original intent was to edit out the ringing alarm clock when the missing section was filled in; however it complemented McCartney's piece well; the first line of McCartney's song began "Woke up, fell out of bed", so the decision was made to keep the sound. Martin later said that editing it out would have been unfeasible in any case.
trickbear 3 years ago
More More!!!
SelsdonMowbray 3 years ago
great job, very much enjoying this series
ashtrayheart74 3 years ago
More please!!!
dnsla823 3 years ago
This and the first are absolutely superb. I can't wait for more.
alternativeglasto 3 years ago 2
Thanks! It'll take a little while but stay tuned.
Vpmatt 3 years ago