Breaking benjamin- Greed (live godsmack cover)

[NicolasLP21]

@BreakingBenFanboy Godsmack??? Gay??? JAJAJJAJAJAJAJJAJAJJAJA COOL STORY BRO!!! JAJAJAJAAJA

[KrzysiuPogromca]

omg its orginal nabs

[Pavasarinis]

i actually like it even if vocals suck :>

[86godsmack]

EPIC FAIL!!

[SuperEngage1]

I wanna kill his fucking voice!

[elobiretv]

is it strange that i actually like this?

[TheMurlog12]

i hate it that i must do it but dislike its not one of the good Breaking Benjamin Songs sorry:(

[DJamesP]

Vocals are shit. But, Ben Burley can't sing heavy for shit, either. Love BB, though. But, leave Godsmack to Sully.

[Koberhofer68]

@bonelink90, get the sand out of ur vag and to help help that process I'm prescribing u a medicine called man the fuck up

[bonelink90]

@Koberhofer68 a pussie is still a pussie. You just proved it.

[bonelink90]

BB is for pussies.

[BreakingBenFanboy]

@bonelink90 Godsmack is GAY

[bonelink90]

@BreakingBenFanboy A gay comment coming from a gay person, wow, I never thought I would see that, keep up the good work.

[frankos93]

Yes i like BB but this cover is fucking horrible

[TheMarroquinTwins]

WHAT THE SHIT IT THIS?!?!?! FUCK YOU!!!! _|_ GODSMACK WILL NEVER BE MOCKED!!!!!

[pandabearlover111]

UR SO FUCKING HORRIBLE

[Tyler98015]

Godsmack is my #1 band and has been since I could listen to music. I also like Breaking Benjamin. Bens vocals are just not setup how Sullys are, but this cover is excellent work. Long live Godsmack and Breaking Benjamin. \m/

[XXxReDruMxXX909]

when the song started iwas like wow this may be good, but as soon as the singing started... dissapointment

[SirDoomCookie]

kinda sounds like southpark makin fun of godsmack, don't it?

[edabm75]

@SirDoomCookie - OMG, it totally does, LOL.

[mrWozon87]

their cover sucks at death ;p !

[elobiretv]

As a massive Ben fan, i think this is awesome. Fuck the haters.

[stojk7]

Silly haters, they dont give a fuck about your input..... Rock on ben, damn good job!

[SMFPresident]

what the fuck is the video of? i play greed on my guitar and it is NOTHING like that. also everything is off sync >:( sounds really bad too.

[elobiretv]

@SMFPresident the video is of breaking benjamin "sooner or later"

[1342benecry]

it doesnt even matter..in my opinion..you're not a true Breaking Benjamin fan if you dont like whatever they sing or whatever they feel like singing...i'm not saying it was the best choice for them to do...but come on it's not that bad

[happymonkeyfish]

btw ben i love your music but the echo was a bad choice

[happymonkeyfish]

now we just need love hate sex pain cover by three days grace or bb

[nikmunk12]

some parts its kickass but other parts it sucks

[LSwa284345]

OMG THIS SUCKS~!!! Sorry Ben....<3 you....but your voice SUCKS doing this song~! Especially with the dumb ass echo effect~!

[batman300102]

(hahaha) this is funny but good in a funny way

[shellecat89]

I love Breaking Benjamin, but this sucks so much ass it's not even funny.

[gsdev1]

good cover!



[neil8225]

very very bad~

[JayMess686]

omg....

[MrNico1984]

the singer didn't understood the feeling to singin it

[RocknAndRolln]

Shit

[xzdropdeadxz]

lmao nice voice changer faggot

[fishinandjeepin]

Fuck this shit.

[demonbike666]

WTF!!!

[KingRaaa95]

i love breaking benjamin and godsmack, but let's be honest this is trash. i guess it's okay considering ben was drunk and had a lung problem or something.

[elobiretv]

only idiots think that a cover should be the same as the original....

[Hickory420]

GodSmack plays this in a lower key... this dude needed a capo.... and thus sounds rubbish...

[wrathlasher]

A very good band but they need to stick their own material

[G4M3RFR34KSW3]

lol at the vocal xD

[joondoggy]

As much as I love breaking benjamin and godsmack...this should not have happened. Im sorry

[tigreHHH]

it just doesnt fit them... there is nothing like Godsmack ladies and gentleman

[Drewicfer]

This is a really bad recording of a live track. Godsmack is one of my favorite live bands but after seeing breaking ben 4 times Ben puts on a killer show. Its a blast when they do a cover in their set and get the place going crazy. If your trashing BB save it untill you see a north eastern show then come back and talk trash.

[Chevellefan01]

Everyone needs to shut the fuck up about his voice!! Just because Ben doesn't sound like Sully doesn't mean his singing sucks!! It's called a cover! They did it in tribute to Godsmack because they like them!! This is awesome!!

[travisjoyner37]

this was awful his voice doesnt suit the song and the guitar doesnt even sound remotely close to the original no one can do it like godsmack

[TheMetalko]

WHAT THE FUCKIN' HELL!?! THEY DID WHAT? YOU GOT TO BE KIDDING WITH ME.I CAN SING IT MUCH BETTER! Uploader of that video must delete his profile here!

[KingRaaa95]

vocals suck. ben's a very good singer, but this just isn't his style. the instrumental is good though, but the original is still way better.

[MrTitanman29]

Not enough hair on the balls to pull this off..........no offense.

[ck88gr]

actualy..it sucks

[DarkSlayerRiku]

well , they got the instruments perfect , they sound exactly like godsmack's but the vocals ... I'm sorry but I think they suck >.>

[metallicspades]

@DarkSlayerRiku dont you ever compare shannon larkin to any other drummer!!

[DarkSlayerRiku]

@metallicspades I didn't compare shannon to whatever the hell drummer breaking benjamin has , I just said they got the sound of the guitars and drums right , I didn't say "hey the dude from breaking benjamin does it better then shannon" ( or godsmack in general ) , so yeah shannon rules , in a drum battle he'd rip "anonymous drummer from breaking benjamin's" brains out XD

[metallicspades]

@DarkSlayerRiku hell yeah!

[dragonaxel9]

@DarkSlayerRiku chad szeliga

[dragonaxel9]

and also good luck with that lol chad would put up such a good battle the other guy would just give up

[DarkSlayerRiku]

@dragonaxel9 I'm sorry but there is no way Shannon would ever lose so .. yeah ;D

[dirtyRamrod]

@DarkSlayerRiku its a cover. its not supposed to sound exactly like Godsmack

[LaserTbone]

@DarkSlayerRiku

You are Right :)

It is Actually not a bad band, but their covers suck like hell -.-''

[TheWalkingDeadMan147]

@DarkSlayerRiku You miss the concept of a music cover, bands cover songs in their own style. But hey thats just your own opinion i know.

[dylanjns4]

bad ass cover. if you like this, check out the awake cover.

[Chevellefan01]

@dylanjns4 OMG THANK YOU for know what good music is and understanding what the fuck a cover is!!

[jacekh88]

.......no mann.....no........2x lol

[saxlituup]

he isnt trying to sound like him,they cover this song because they admire Godsmack not to try and be them,they made this in the way THEY wanted to

[xJonnyxBlaz3x]

Its a cover and it is good better than some stupid ass band covering the song. Ben and Sully both have a very unique singing style which makes them both amazing musicians if they want to cover each others shit then let them for their own personal feel that they need to,

[Roundedsnow]

Being a fan of both bands I'll have to give this one to godsmack, though if Ben was drunk doing this performance I'd like to know how their cover sounds sober, because this is quite good.

[HisPresenseWithinME]

horrible God Samck version is wayyyyyyyy better this totally killed it!

[ssjdino]

As a huge godsmack fan.. i can just say.. LOL!

[Tomsterx56]

Fuck all of you homos that clicked the dislike button

[VaultBoy574]

please tell me i am not the only person enjoying this song

[Wolszczak1188]

Is that JOke ???

[Actionmovieman789]

This was great. It was live and better than Godsmack in my opinion. Except the "Sinister notes" Godsmack can have those.

[matthiasprice]

ooooo. FRETBURNOUT knows the drummer. do you just hate the drummer or the entire band

[OneWille]

soud like shit...awfull :/

[fretburner101]

i hate these fags.. i know the drummer hes a fucking douchebag

[SemperFidelis0229]

@fretburner101 they have a different drummer than that bitch jeremy you dumbass

[ZzTheMessenjaHzZ]

Not a bad cover! I love the song :)

[Sk8urDude101]

all i can say is get over it and listen to their newer songs, jeeze, its not their best but its surely not the worst, if you want to hear bad singing listen to black sabbath

[ironsiim]

I admit it's kinda shit... but actually I kinda like it... so no dislike for this... lol

[QuietRaven]

this is horrid fail , the start was amazing untill he sang.

[razorblademask]

Oh you gotta love the douche Godsmack fanatics.

[JJTT1991]

@razorblademask fuck off im a fan of both bands and ya this does soud bad cause ben voice doesnt fit the song and ya people ware probably right he was probably drunk i got nothing agasnt BB Godsmack and BB and my favorite 2 bands but youll never see godsmack covering a BB song if he did i wouldnt rip it apart man

[razorblademask]

@JJTT1991 You act like I don't like Godsmack. I love them, but every band has their horribly annoying fans that won't allow ANYBODY to even touch their music and it gets old.

[hartfarting]

WTF DID U PPL DO TO THE SONG?!?!? fucking christ sully gonna release the fucking demonds on u

[rbergonzi27]

haha i actually like this

[BHVampireLF]

Clowns!!!

[MoonBabyB]

Wet brains of the World....UNITE!!! LMAO!

[FadeToBlack181]

i like now nobody plays in time, that's just classy

[KungFuKid1015]

What he FUCK???????? SOUNDS LIKE SHIT! LOOKS LIKE SHIT>>>>>>>ITS SHITTY AS HELLL......132 people like shitty music......Sully Erna must be puking his guts out. I hope he finds this band and kicks their ass!

[MrTrajik]

@KungFuKid1015

You do grasp the concept that Breaking Benjamin is just as big, if NOT bigger than Godsmack, right? I'm sure Sully wouldn't have ever performed with BB if he really thought they sucked enough to warrant an ass kicking. Learn something bout music before you attempt to critique it mate.

[moltenriches]

The singer sounds constipated :S

[adamsesh33]

lol

[sam18235]

fucking fags!!ur cover sucks big time

[MonsterMetalMusic]

haha love breaking Benjamin but this is kinda horrible

[MrDrGrotesque]

I'm pretty sure even Godsmack is gobsmacked by how god awful this god forsaken cover is.

[songy50]

this is not even breaking benjamin singing bens alot better than this......

[Steventyler96]

how can u take such a perfect song and fuck it all up in 3:17 minutes.... i have no words to explain how much i wanna kill theese guys lol

[Piddleworthable]

@Steventyler96 Shut your small dick. Breaking Benjamin > Godsmack.

[Steventyler96]

@Piddleworthable oh well........Breaking Benjamin kick ass i admit but i don't care what you think, i like Godsmack more..... and for the record ....dick jokes!!! really?!?!?! grow up man ;p

[brawlaventures]

Wow. This is not BB

[OnlyAKnife]

omg, the person cant fucking sing, its not even BB

[juggernautjoff]

FAKE!!!!!! if you believe this is actually BB singing this your STUPID!!

[sweetlynsane1]

@juggernautjoff and if you dont realize that is breaking benjamin playin godsmacks, greed well then you dont know,Ben's voice from Breaking Benjamin i like them but they ruint this song only Sully can sing this and BB shouldnt had even tried

[xXJustFadeAwayXx]

Hahah more dislikes than likes. Usually doesn't happen

[nusucker]

I just puked.

[22j77]

You may think this is a good song if you never heard the original. The original with Sully is just awesome! Can't believe this band thought it would be a good idea to cover Godsmack which is clearly superior.

[SepulturaChris92]

Godsmack is Godsmack and Breaking Benjamin are Breaking Benjamin.Very cool that they did a cover on this song.Sweeet indeed but every band has is own unique sound. Thumbs up if you think like me.

[caddermeran]

SERIOUSLY, is he making fun?

[FuckinMetal3694]

This is so gross ..pathetic

[GemStealth]

@FuckinMetal3694 agree, if anythng i think Ben is dissing Sully lol

[mrdirtbike16]

Soooooooooo not right

[zippera95]

How can you people not get it this is a vocal cover by someone but not BB.The quality of the vocals is like a skype mic...Someone just got the instrumental for Greed and put BB on top for video and did the vocals.Don't get fooled.

[connor2112232]

I flagged this as inappropriate so that this video will get the fuck off the web... O well I've moved from godsmack to soundgarden and now the doors but I think I like the doors the best

[salvajez1]

NO TE SALE!!!!!

TE SALE COMO LA MIERDA, SOLO SULLY LA PUEDE CANTAR

[thornrob]

no one can touch Sully's vocals...

[TheMetalko]

WHAT THE FUCK!!!!! THAT SUX!!!! I am fan of Godsmack but i also like BB but WTF they can't do that sound like Godsmask they are far away from the true...Why They did that?!?! I will vote Down for that SHIT!!!

[zippera95]

@TheMetalko Dude this is some guy who did a vocal cover...If BB were doing this the quality of the sound would be a lot higher.This is done with a skype mic.

[Cyclonus84]

the best part was the beginning. But once he opened his mouth it went down hill. Stick to your own music and don't ruin good songs.

[lockyerm]

I thought this was a joke...very bad joke.

[LegendaryGerous]

lmao there are so many angry people on here, they should just be happy that a band like Breaking Benjamin loves Godsmack. Yeah the vocals aren't nearly as good as Sully, but it's not his type of singing, however in no way can they ruin it, cause they didn't go back and record it for all the new versions of Awake and put this song in it's place lol.

[guitarg3ek]

sullys voice is a great metal voice. this guy has a pussy ass voice. im gonna listen to the real version now so i can man up

[12Godsmack12]

fuck.....holy fuck. i can't get over this. ITS WHAT MAKES ME HATE YOU. you disgraced these songs and whats with the shaky voice? honestly this guy is not good live...not even at "his" own shit. don't try to immitate sully. its fucking impossible. fuck you breaking benjamin...forever.

[DzDeadly1]

@MeetYourMaker69

first off let me say i dont like this band. But if you cover a song by a band its never a disrespect to them, ever. I'd be more than proud to have other bands cover my bands songs, no matter how hard they sucked. the vocals in this are awful he tried to sound like sully but he cant and no1 can to be honest. the solo had no style and wasnt close to matching tony's feel, but they left it in metal and didnt change it to techno so at least give em that hahaa

[Rosstacular]

LMFAO! this has to be a joke!

[beow85]

Ben, forget it! You don't have Sully's voice!

[Dylan99197]

horse shit, BB is no Godsmack

[sofoclebeat]

In all his covers, Ben is trying to sound like someone else. And that is impossible since we all only have one voice. So when you try to sound different you fuck up. Well ... at least he tried and only his voice fails, the melodic line is fine.

[nickz140v1]

Sully Erna has a much more powerful voice.

[digglefritz]

@MrSubzero333 fuck u. it's a cover.

[afik13]

So many godsmack fans here

lol gtfo

i liked it! ^^

[Rosstacular]

@afik13 are u deaf?

[JJTT1991]

Breaking benjamin is good but they cant sing Godsmack songs lol only Godsmack can Sully has such a dam amazing voice

[xerox4211]

So bad.....

[MaryShagrath]

I thought it would be as good as AWAKE is, but I made a mistake..

[MrSubzero333]

These fags stole godsmack's song, someone kill them.

[SeveNzo0rr]

@MrSubzero333 It's a cover you fucktard. Read the fucking title next time. No need to trip over some meaningless shit.

And for the Godsmack fans: considering Ben was fucking drunk during these covers and they were done a long time ago, then why the MOTHERFUCK are you still being oh so brilliant critics ? Fuck off if you don't like it, beligerant clusterfucks.

[MrSubzero333]

@SeveNzo0rr Suck my balls first, then maybe i wont critic the vid :)

[GemStealth]

@SeveNzo0rr didnt dear agony did better than life starts now on sales? they both were realesed the same day..

so i dont hink theyre done but yeah good cover not bad just didnt really had that BB formula

[SeveNzo0rr]

@GemStealth I don't know, my opinion is that both were good albums. Both bands intended on keeping the same sound. Now look at Linkin Park. They've totally drifted away from what they were once. It's all about artistic vision. As you mature, your artistic vision changes and evolves into something else/new. Or it might be about money, but considering what A Thousand Suns presents lyrically, I don't think they care about the money so much anymore.

[invaderslick]

@SeveNzo0rr yeah, i think ur right about the whole LP thing. i think minutes to midnight was more about money/publicity and then A Thousand Suns was a redeemer in their eyes

[Luke16510]

@SeveNzo0rr im not saying your wrong im just wondering how do you know hes drunk(not in a smartass way)

[SeveNzo0rr]

@Luke16510 Well I believe this cover was done way before Phobia for example. And during that period, he himself said he was an alcoholic, so...

The thing is that Ben CAN cover songs like Aenema from Tool, Greed and Awake from Godsmack, Judith from A Perfect Circle or any other song they've covered, but imagine singing while being drunk, can you sing properly ? I know I can't so, if you can, props to you.

[Luke16510]

@SeveNzo0rr

sully used to be fucked all the time in godsmacks old days and he sounded fine

[SeveNzo0rr]

@Luke16510 You know what I tend to think ? That since there is a tone difference (note: not a vocal range difference), it's kinda normal that Ben's voice sounds a little bit awkward trying to cover a song that wasn't specifically written to be sung in a voice like his.

The closest to Ben and Sully's voices I could find a resemblance into would be Maynard Keenan's voice, since he's got both the gritty and the clean voice into one lol.

[MrGodsmack30]

@SeveNzo0rr i like breaking benjamin the only problem i see with this is they both (Ben and Sully) have uniqe voices and ben tries to change his and makes the sound sound worse and i dont thin sully could cover a breakking benjamin song because thier voices are both to differnt

[SeveNzo0rr]

@MrGodsmack30 I think it's got to do with the way the songs are made ... and that's why it might feel like one artist sounds awkward trying to cover the song of another artist. Of course Ben is not going to sound the same as Sully. And it's not that Sully has a powerful voice, because both Ben and Sully's voices are great in their own way, but when you make a song, I think it has something to do with how you hit those notes and how you accentuate the way you sing everything. Just my opinion.

[MrGodsmack30]

@SeveNzo0rr you know what i think your absolutly right

[omarninja]

@SeveNzo0rr Your awesomeness knows no bound! Represent the BB brotherhood (H)

[SeveNzo0rr]

@omarninja Lol.

[DodgeViperACRX]

omg ruined it!!! >:( haha stick to ur own stuff BB

[xmetl]

this cover is so friggen terrible its almost seems like a joke

[CHIMERA259]

omg noooooooo stop

[sulkierknight]

i thought it would be good... i was mistaken...

[jugalokid69]

this could've been worse, like flyleaf covering smells like teen spirit. all in all it wasnt too bad

[XxDomiiixX]

rape my ears

sry, they might have good songs but thats absolutly shit >.<

[rigga40]

Just cause you can play the song doesnt always mean you should....

[wowhobbscrazy]

sully would say that benjamin is crying like a b!tch LOL sounds horrible

[TheCyprusX]

@wowhobbscrazy

He would probably say " Good day to die , don't you think Ben? "

[xmetl]

i cant believe how bad this cover is..........

[elderon01]

i like breaking benajmin but they arent really anywhere close to godsmack and idint know that his name was benjamin

[NTJR1]

I think Ben is Trying to sound like Sully too much so he didn't do.. his um best? aha

he should just stick to doing other covers, leave Godsmack alone :p, and before people get in my face I know this was before Breaking Benjamin made Saturate :/

[EvilHippy38]

If Ben didn't try to sound like Sully, it would be great.

[KaNe1493]

it may not be the best cover... but i still like it =]

[Nossi83]

what a bad cover of a really good song...Breaking Benjamin Sucks

[ddrumdude]

@Nossi83 wow you say they suck just because of a cover you didnt like. How narrow minded can you get?

[54chaos45]

i like breaking benjamin but i am sorry this sucks leave this to godsmack

[JohnnyRayLetsPlay]

Well, I love Breaking Benjamin and I really like this cover.

[Erebus3113]

Benjamin is a good singer but he cant sing the kind of music Godsmack plays at all lol. I love Breaking Benjamin to death but this is kinda shitty =/

[cheynecastillo]

haha the vocals seems like a joke..amost like a drunken hill billy sung it

[Crispy27]

@cheynecastillo So you're saying it's a faithful cover.

[GemStealth]

@cheynecastillo sully should still be flatterd

[anthonyjv602]

lol not cool

[Dillson01]

0:21.... way to ruin a great song with shitty vocals