符瓊音 - 天下無雙+Whenever, Wherever

[QQQQanst]

感覺沒有唱得很自然感覺超勉強，或許這首歌本來是為了張靓穎打造­..所以不應該選這種歌

[jeff72402]

唱的好棒



[andy199233]

拜託

艾成是三小

他根本不會唱歌

[saicolin]

不管輸還贏! 符就是比艾還有名!!!!!!!!!!!  目前出道為止!

[sssm79617]

這已經不是技術問題 跟原唱比起來 是在比天分了..

[shawn19891017]

不知道是比賽緊張還是怎樣，很多音的音準都跑掉了= =

[lyon1861]

这应该是目前翻唱最成功的版本，足够细腻，虽然高音不是很稳定

[s98105034]

我還是喜歡原版~

[cowbaogun]

符瓊音輸是正常的

他在選歌上一再出錯阿



[200310663]

張靚穎唱得太完美啦....

[ken62310]

太胖了

[VictorDanDan]

@ken62310 26  none can take

[tofujun]

我欣赏符瓊音的勇气选择whenever,wherever. 我个人认为,全世界只有shakira可以唱.基本上不是因为符­瓊音没唱功而是shakira有西班牙，拉丁的独特唱法和腔调，­不是一个人容易在短时间可以模仿的或学到的. 所以把whenever,wherever 当作大决赛的歌勇气可嘉.

[cowbaogun]

@tofujun

其實你有西班牙文為母語的朋友就知道了

那邊能唱這種腔調的很多的

不過

那種唱腔真的 不是土生土長的西班牙語系國家就別挑戰真的

[aryui]

@tofujun ysys definitely agree!!! Shakira is soooooo great

[29575741]

Whenever, Wherever沒唱好=口=lll

咬字好硬喔

[MadePossible]

咦，高潮部份的海豚音呢？

[u593714]

他Whenever Wherever穿的舞衣好長喔

感覺就沒有性感的感覺

[caiwoshishui]

高音不足 不过 也不简单了。。

[amy131452u]

唱的不錯，但原版的比較有韻味

[holohulolo]

Of some of the covers I've watched, some really sang well and has a good voice. But I feel that their singing should be a little slower. Just a bit.

[lucyliuyuxi]

明显她高音唱得有些费劲，连音都颤抖得有些跑调。

[cjjam88]

其實唱的不錯..很有勇氣

[RadioheadTLY]

感冒对于她这种等级的歌手，没差。

[RadioheadTLY]

靓颖又不是没病过，只是她从来不提，病的时候唱歌，所受的影响也­不是一般歌迷能听出来的。

记得当年她参加超女的时候，“大姨妈”来，被评审听出问题，问她­，她说自己很好，后来顺子几乎用逼问的方式才问出原因。

05超女期间，她可是带着肺炎比赛，肺炎对唱歌影响多大知道吗？­感冒算个鸟毛~

她本人对这些是绝口不提的，她自己说过，站上舞台就要唱好歌给听­众，这样才对得起衣食父母 。

[beck520520]

請張小姐感冒也來唱唱看...

[manworld1981]

@beck520520 请符小姐不感冒的时候来唱唱，呵呵

[yuhua1234]

其实算很好了，就觉得她的声音有点不适合唱这首歌，有点唱英文歌­的感觉，喊的成分多了点。

[BISMARCK1616]

原版的印象太深刻了....

選這首算有勇氣挑戰...

[TheDuxingxia]

张靓颖唱的比较细腻，而符琼音的声音比较豪放。。。。。不同的声­线。。。

不过很不错了。。。。加油！！！

[iicathy100]

@TheDuxingxia 對張靚穎唱出那種淒美,愛情的感覺..

符琼音好像就在唱好這首歌,聽不出有多少感情在裏面

[wood753951]

@kman1906 現場唱這樣不錯了

[wl00238779]

不過怎麼會有雜音....

這首歌光是聽就覺得很難唱= =

唱得比原唱差點也不算糟了

不過這首歌很有武俠氣息放神雕片頭真是配

[candiclin]

瓊音穿的褲子要短一點..腿看起來才比較修長....因為她的動­作很性感...

[p4102xyz]

翻唱的最好就她了!!!棒!!

[yuhua1234]

很好听，张靓颖更好听一点。可能张靓颖唱的细腻一点，符琼音有点­喊了。但是两位都很好

[tiongwee123]

还是靓颖好～不过能唱到这样已经很好了～

[mikeshinoda555]

兩首歌我都很喜歡!! shakira rocks!

[beck520520]

真想聽瓊音在最好的狀態唱這首天下無雙~~

[aaa790328]

很像阿桑在跳舞....

早上公園很常見那種....

[lzwyuse]

穿得好土,很像80年代早期的香港三線歌手的穿法

[lovefreedom1974]

以后参赛选手一定要多学习下，越感冒越要唱难度大的， 就想梁文音唱loving you，这个符小姐唱天下无双,当然她高音根本没唱。

但是，感冒的优势，记得感冒时有优势的，在难度大的歌里，是很能­体现的！

[ayann718]

感冒會氣不足然後頭暈+鼻音重 能唱成這樣很盡力了

[ejsionan]

@ayann718 ..如果是靚穎她本人來唱的話，她是不會把感冒藉口的唷..一樣­是歌唱比賽出來的人物喔！

[ayann718]

@ejsionan 他並沒有當藉口，因為大家都知道的事~至於你的靚穎怎樣是你的事­

[chaosyap]

@ejsionan 傻海嘛你，感冒就感冒，她就是感冒，有拿来当借口吗？傻海嘛你

[seaweed9999]

0:01 - 0:08 好搞笑。 打太极吗？

[Sharleane0511]

值得鼓勵~不過還是喜歡靚穎的版本,經典阿

[xuhm225]

还是不错了

鼓励一下！！　

[beck520520]

感冒能唱成這樣 真的要為她鼓鼓掌~

[cssmylove]

抛开别的不说,舞蹈功力好像超偶比星光厉害

[ab20579]

張靓潁是這首歌最適合的演唱者 難以超越~

符瓊音的版本已是翻唱最好的了

[gobby750]

只能講張靚穎假音比較高超一點

[CheesySanchez]

She's pretty good. Although her voice was very shaky and unnatural in Tian xiang wu shang.

[ayann718]

感冒頭都會暈了，怎麼能期待能唱到什麼程度，不要忘詞和走音就好­了



[OrsinoDuke]

算是有胆哦， 伊是第一个有胆在比赛中唱这首歌的人

不过实在有点勉强， 听的人提心吊胆的

[asd2452]

就差那個高音ˋˊ

[echorrr]

haha i found out this girl had the same fav song with jane zhang:) like loving u, listen, without you, hero,what's up..etc..even the one in a drama that janes original version...but compare to jane, her voice is more like on the "rocker" way...janes more like on r&b side

[machehell]

老實說我覺得張靚穎版比較好聽（雖然我是馬來西亞人），因為張靚­穎會用假音。張靚穎的假音和海豚音真的無可否認的。

[jasonkk188]

符瓊音 當天重感冒 還能唱這麼棒 抱病演出

肯定她的精神！

[mimivirous]

張靚穎真的是太經典了...很難很難有人在超越原版吧!?

[udontknow63]

尾音能再拖長一點就好了！

原唱太經典，不是誰能比的上的

[jyujyucolor]

唱的不錯~但不得不說還是張靚穎好聽!!

[Koler13]

And excuse me, just that I prefer Fu's version to Jane's. There's no need for drama. I am not denying jane's music talent. I am just prefering Fu's singing in a Fu's vid and what wrong with that? Get a life, people, and stop critizing. It's natural to like differnt things. U think Jane's better, fine, but i am not changing my opinion on this song. Is that clear? If u're smart, u'll understand it is impossible for everybody to love your idol. It just shows that u're inmature. -_-

[Koler13]

I compare Jane to Gaga just because she's the first ppl come to mind. I am not critizing her, i repeat I DO NOT DENY her music talents. I am just saying my opinion. If I am a blind hater I'll go " Jane look fucking ugly and sang bullshit and she sucks dicks" I have the will to say what I want, especially this is NOT a Jane's vid. All I want to say is I prefer Fu's to Jane's version. that's all. You take care too, some day u'll eventually find some real music.

[Koler13]

@nightsucks I am not trying to make you like Fu anyway. (nor that I like her). What? Do you own this place? I am just saying I prefer this to Jane's, does that consider as illegal? And I am not speaking this in Jane's Vid, it's Fu's Vid. You're the one who love Jane so blindly that you attack on anybody dislike Jane on SOMEBODY else vid. And then you cant out-speak me, so you decided to bail and accuse me, so that It seems like you're the one who is right. Good plan huh?

[nightsucks]

u dislike Jane ? great ! go on then , u r the one who started it ill-speaking of her not me , just like it makes me dislike FU more , anyway take care to u cheers.

[nightsucks]

to compare lady gaga and jane is like to compare andy lau with tom cruise , it is such a silly comparsion , do u think tom cruise is more popular than andy lau ? i think so , because he has an international platform. I did not expect u to like jane , I just hope u stop critizing her as there has been alot of encouraging workpiece with she has done with some great composers , the quotations for her has been good, which is not wat u say.

[Koler13]

@nightsucks To me, singer plus song writer is what I called true music. Songwriters are for losers who cant even wrote their own music. Jane is in career for nearly 5 years, and not one single grammy. Lady Gaga is in for 15 months, and she've got her grammy. Go to find some real music, open your boundaries, that's exactly what you need.

[nightsucks]

koler13 , she is nominated for 52TH TH grammy ,

so i assume cant read a date like this 13 03 10

, in future i just type something like this 13th march 2010,wow u are comparing lady gaga with jane ? that is great because this proof that jane is successful after all.

[Koler13]

@nightsucks Jane is quite successful as a singer in mainland (only), but that doesnt mean that I HAVE to like her. I am not denying her music talents, but you cant stop me prefering Fu instead of Jane. Fans like you only make non-Jane's fan dislike her more. Next time u speak, watch what you're talking. 52 grammies awards? Bullshit.

[lovefreedom1974]

@Koler13 jane only successful in mainland??wow,so where is fu successfule? only in taiwan? wait a minute, is fu is successful in taiwan?no,no, little little news about her, why? beacause she is not good enough.and, as this sing, fu does not sing high pitch, how do u judge she is better than zhang?

[Koler13]

@lovefreedom1974 YES Jane is only successful in mainland. European dont know who the hell she is. I dont know if Fu is successful in taiwan nor I care about it. I repeat I am not a fan of her. It's just that when I compare her to Jane, I prefer Fu's version. I repeat I think Jane's singing is too breathy and unclear. Fu's sick when she sang this, and it's STILL better than Jane's. high-pitch? That's the basic thing to do when u is a singer.

[lovefreedom1974]

@Koler13 ok, that is ok, I think Jane's singing is better than FU. and Fu's too breathy and unclear. Fu can not sing that high pitch, because she is not the level.

last, Fu is not successful anywhere.

[Koler13]

@lovefreedom1974 I appreciate ur cm, but I dont agree with it. As I am not a fan of any of them, I dont care if Fu is not successful. My point of view is Fu's better and your's reverse. So lets stop here. Cheers, takecare.

[lovefreedom1974]

@Koler13 i don't appreciate you because i don't agree with you. that is your problem. cheers!

[vvy8010]

高音那個辛苦的呢

[KaeKaeeeee]

聽張靚穎的很有感動的感覺,

聽這個也許也有1點點

[Koler13]

Honestly I think this is better than Jane's. Jane breath too much. If Fu sang this when she's ill, she'd probably do hell lot better than Jane.

Jane sound likes she had an asthma. lol why everyone like her anyway?

[nightsucks]

huh ? better than Jane ? lol this girl sang like a bull , is not gentle at all , her voice is not consistant at all , and do u know hw many awards jane has won ? have u ever heard her live performance with kitaro and david foster ?Tan dun ? if not yet , go and listen it first my son

[Koler13]

@nightsucks lol I 'm sure you sang worse than this gal. Rewards means nothing my dear, look at Britney Spears and Miley Cyrus. And yes I 've heard her live of this song. Toooo breathy and unclear.

[nightsucks]

let 's not talk abt rewards , look at those singers who worked with jane , lee hom ? a few great musicians wrote songs and only wanted her to sing for them ? no point deceiving yourself if u dun wan to admit . are u sure u heard Jane 's ' live ' 别睁着眼睛说瞎话啦.. did u know jane has nominated for 52 grammy awards? = D so stop goin around and murder a good voice

[Koler13]

@nightsucks you said "let's not talk about rewards" and then you go say she've got 52 grammies nominated? Do you really expect me to believe this? She started music career in 2005 for the god sake. If she really get 53 ridiculous NOMINATES, but excuse me she didnt won ONE SINGLE GRAMMY. Jane's career is LIMITED in China.

AND YES I"VE SEEN PLENTY VIDs OF HER IN CONCERT. She's too breathy and unclear.

[cindy5255255]

唱得不錯阿!!!

我覺得還不錯=ˇ=

[seanbinliu]

後面一段高key的沒了

[alexnepal]

符瓊音那天感冒也沒有說,一直盡全力在演唱, 還是最後讓評審老師發現的.. 她的努力值得支持和鼓掌...

[mytina780810]

符瓊音那天感冒，能夠唱成這樣不錯了！他畢業之後歌唱功力又練的­更厲害了！

[willchen19920929]

哈哈，靓颖漂亮多了~这点先比比

然后再比歌声~反正就算歌声不相上下，那长相就决定一切了~

[SU0513]

@741782414 唱歌是唱歌 怎么又弄到政治上去啊 活不到30岁 你这是听谁说的 独裁是不好 我们也知道 但是你所谓的民主之光不也是成天的绿营蓝营成天干架吗 你喜欢符 我没意见 也不至于这么诋毁甚至是谩骂其他人吧 你不喜欢张靓颖我们不强求 蛋清不要诋毁 谢谢~

[meilinSS]

勇气可嘉．高音没唱全所以跟原唱没什么可比性．

[shine0542]

各有各的特色，怎麼能夠武斷的說誰好誰不好?

[highburycatherine]

笑话。本来孰好孰坏就很明显，又不是完全否定谁，只是总体看来显­而易见。

[beck520520]

拜托人家感冒耶~~看誰感冒能唱這樣好

[963mach]

呵 好的回覆，拇指卻是朝下的

看來很多人真奇怪

[beck520520]

剛剛聽了靓穎的listen根本高音都上不去~~一點力道都沒有­~~她的聲音不適合listen吧~~不過我覺得I still believe唱的倒是沒話說的好

[RadioheadTLY]

靓颖唱listen赢不了符？

因为不喜欢原唱，所以两个人唱的listen我都没有听，看见有­人说到我专门去找来看了一下，我只能说，耳朵要练好啊~

Youtube上有视频，07年张靓颖北京演唱会时唱的list­en，是当天她唱了30多首歌之后才唱的，自己去比比看两者之间­的音准，稳定度，差得不是一丁半点，这种低音质的网络视频都那么­明显，要真现场跟评审一样用耳塞听，那还得了~

[beck520520]

瓊音感冒唱這樣真的很棒!!!或許飆海豚音飆不過靓潁~~但我相­信靓潁listen也唱不贏瓊音的!!

[edwardqiu]

靓颖唱30首歌后, 唱Listen, 还是把符比下去了... 两个人根本不在一个level.

[zhantonio]

不是原版啊...我中了原版的毒，還是靚影版的好聽多了..fo­rgiv me 吧

[tw07benny]

有人知道這首歌的詞曲誰作的嗎??

[CowBayYo]

巫啟賢

[saiter6024]

什麼意思，搞不懂?

[CowBayYo]

我只是覺得相貌有些許神似隨便打的, 抱歉讓你困惑了

[j20006640]

幾霸昏!!!

[Rima616]

佢d手勢好9唔搭8

[guitarlearner89]

他唱的很好大家不要以样 冒去评一个人。。

[guitarlearner89]

再说台下的judges 他们不一定好过他。。所为说人不说如自己。。去改善，去前进。。­说别人浪费时间

[daisyzu]

唱得还不错，但是呢，和靓颖版的还是差距很大的。。她不适合唱这 个 。。。张靓颖的好多歌现场版的很容易唱破音，符很用挑战精神呢。­。。。不过还是挑适合自己的巴。。。

[donald0918]

期待与你见面～！！！

[kitookit]

一d都唔好聽 仲有佢件衫 9唔搭8咁 ....唉

[lonelyran]

真的懂海豚音是什麼嗎?

[saiter6024]

我覺得她第二首key定太低了

沒辦法到他音色較好的地方

[chibicong]

节奏追不上。走音。

感觉音乐和她的歌声完全脱离。

[ally1201]

请大家不要人身攻击。谢谢。

[tedhsu1209]

哈哈 被民族主義洗腦了

[ally1201]

\\\ World Peace /// O(∩_∩)O 呵呵呵！

[beck520520]

瓊音感冒還能唱成這樣真得是唱功了得~~如果她狀況更好相信表現­會更佳喔

[hola9vi1va3ole]

Whenever,Wherever很扣分

以她的實力，可以更好

PS不過她很勇敢

[shingkei]

勇氣可嘉

[lovefreedom1974]

跟张比？ 符连高音区都没唱啊，比什么？

而且，符的嗓子，唱rock适合点，这种美妙的，不适合。

[Jadehelam]

佢唱歌都好好聽

不過無張靚穎個種感覺

[a8306142003]

唱的好不好是客觀感覺!!

沒必要勉強別人跟你一樣覺得他人較好吧..

而且喜不喜歡是個人的事

妳沒必要在那批成這樣吧?!

再說你慿什麼批別人??

妳是她長輩??還是忌妒她??

還是你唱的比她好??

都沒有的話..批判的話不用公佈出來

放心裡就好..免的被大家砲轟!!

[oo79o]

聲音很好，只是選錯歌了

[OrsinoDuke]

很有勇氣

[yeah8462]

其實選擇唱這首就已經很有勇氣挑戰了!

每個有勇氣挑戰的不管結果好不好~

都應該給予鼓勵的!!

[freestylejet]

批？你拿什么来批？？

建议或意见还可以接受。。

你又什么资格批？

tmd。。批评人家之前，先看看自己。。什么都不是。。鸟

[manplay1981]

就符的音域和音色，根本不适合唱这种歌

[a26932]

我沒說我是符的粉絲

我只是覺得這首很高人家能唱成這樣不錯了

僅此而已阿

[milklin]

張靚穎首天下無雙好難唱

再加上好少人唱到的海豚音.....根本是為她專長而設

所以就歌而言 無根本無得比

[a26932]

那你有沒想過有人可能是這歌手的粉司

你這樣直接作負面的評價

那些人會怎樣

我沒說你這樣批評不行

應該說我從頭到尾就沒說過你這樣批評不行這種話吧

[klin335]

额~将心比心啦！

如果唱的和张靓颖又会被说抄袭的，没有个人特色！

Whenever,Wherever 葉瑋庭 呈现的方式不一样！没个人都有自己的风格！

两曲在同一段时间唱出真的不容易！

[a26932]

每人有每人的喜好

這樣大膽的批評

會很慘喔

[arnojason]

沒什麼好比的,都是有實力的歌手,總比所謂的人氣歌手來的有實力­....

[mandyfd510]

我覺得符雖然有唱到她自己的水準

但是她沒唱到結尾那超高音的地方

為什麼呢?那是全首歌最精彩的部分!

而靚穎他無論是在香港的頒獎典禮上

或是在枚慶上唱live 水準都是頂尖的!

簡直比cd還好聽

而且她唱得非常有在天上的感覺 很仙化

符只是把歌完整唱好 沒有了那種脫俗的感覺

可惜了一點

[sometimesido]

完全认同!

[sometimesido]

唱得不错，但跟张靓颖还有段距离。

还是张的吸引多了!

[Alex56Star]

她在Whenever,Wherever的表現,不管歌舞,都沒­有星光二班葉瑋庭表現的好,還需有待加強...

[kyo1223]

也难怪啦！ 她表演时是在重感冒的情况下唱的，能够这样已经很不容易了呀！

[spaceboy512]

恩 張靚穎的歌聲辨識度真的很低

歌藝雖驚人 但是她的歌 非主打的 幾乎聽不出來是他唱的

符瓊音 第二段 我嚇到了..

[verysars]

張只有咽音厲害，他聲音沒什麼辨識度...

跟王力宏合唱另一個天堂，沒歌單還不知道女生是誰唱的。

符的假音也的確沒張強，因為唱真音的人假音控制力道沒辦法像常唱­假音人厲害。

[sometimesido]

这恐怕是你耳朵的问题罢了。我倒觉得张的音色很好。

[Joy1365]

我觉得她唱得不错．但好象嗓子有点紧．

[EiraHuang]

她當時重感冒

[Dsarts5673]

符瓊音唱的真的很棒 不過假音沒張那麼細膩 但是感冒能唱成這樣 我真的佩服她

[reaganstillalive]

似乎她沒唱結尾的高音部分

很多人都是在結尾唱破音

她有自知之明，沒有去挑戰難度

[manplay1981]

暈死，你可以搜一下 張靚穎 天下無雙中歌榜，聽聽張的現場在下結論

[beck520520]

瓊音感冒能唱這樣已經很棒了!我聽張唱live還不一定有這麼穩­定呢

[kinyatsang]

同學~你可以去搜一下張的現場再下結論哦~天下無雙的live靚­穎嘗過很多遍，越到後期的越好。我建議你看四川大學版本的，算是­比較早期的了，而且最重要的是，靚穎當時也感冒了哦~有時間的話­去聽聽吧^_^ ps 符還是不錯的~

[manplay1981]

跟張比，距離還是滿大的

[laluneblanc]

去聽了一下

葉的確不錯, 不過符的聲音比較夠力道, 音色也比較好

[45312345]

笑话.张的音色没她好吗？我一直觉得张的音色接近于完美。就连大­卫福斯特都说过张靓颖完美的音色！

[kinyatsang]

這位同學太激動了 ..人家說的是業~沒說張 = =|||

[pinky215hk]

的確

符的音色比較好

不過扭得廷難看

[Hypertis]

葉瑋庭唱好聽+1

但是要特別表揚瓊音的是，

竟然選擇張靚穎的《天下無雙》，

對於符瓊音而言還算是很大的挑戰，

不過高分部分仍然表現得不錯，

還可以有很大進步空間。

[tony30438]

講實話這首歌不禁令人想到葉偉庭

就以這首歌而言

我覺得葉偉庭唱的好很多(個人淺見)