I love you and respect your thoughts Narenjan kumar....dont listen to such stupids...listen to me and such pure Pakistanis..we love Pakistan and will love Pakistan always chahie kuch bhe hoo jaey...Jeevey Pakistan
@sonaaro really sad sir i am also considered minority in Pakistan.Just pray for our country.I can feel your difficulties that I have the same situation.
@sonaaro yaar aisay logon ki baat chordo yeah wohi log hain jo is mulk ko torna chahtay hain
Be it SINDHI, PUNJABI BALUCHI, PATHAN or URDU SPEAKER or koi bhi ethnicity ka ho ya kisi bhi religious fraternity se tall'luq ho Hindu, Christian, ya SIKH we all are PAKISTANIs and we shoud be proud of it :)
@sonaaro Kis nay kaha aap Patriotic Pakistani nahi? jo log eisa kahtay hein wo Pakistan kay dost nahi dushman hain. Pakistan ka her citizen chahay wo hindu ho christian ho ya koe or utna he Pakistani hai jitna aik Muslim Pakistani hai. hamay itihaad ke bat karna chaeye jo her dor me zarori hei na kay tornay ke... mai ik Muslim Pakistani hon or Pakistan ke her Citizen chahay wo kisi mazhab se ho aik suchay Pakistani ke hesiyat se dekhta hon. Allah Pakistan ko salamat rakhay ameen!
you shouldn't mind those people you are Pakistani and that is what important if someone call you traitor because of your religious believes then trust me those are real traitors!!!
i would love to see one day a Hindu, Sikh or christian at least president of Pakistan because this is their mother land as much as others
any country who cherish its minority's is a just society else they are doomed!!!
@Asif410 i agree .. But to The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 A non Muslim can not be the president of Islamic Republic of Pakistan .. and Yeah it is the Mother Land of Hindu Christan sikh and all otherz ...
@12345bloch ap jesen p fakhr he hm unite rhen ge to dushman ke aankhn nochne k slahiyat rkhn ge god bles u baloch bhai jhan ap ka pasina vhan mera blood pakistan zindabad india israel america murda bad
Pakistan from its creation is under threat for traitors inside and external threats...We should unite again and lift the nation..get rid of all Mir Jaffers from Pakistan.
Pakistan from its creation is under threat for traitors inside and external threats...We should unite again and lift the nation..get rid of all Mir Jaffers from Pakistan.
We Pakistanis never forget our palestinian,bosnian and chechan brothers and
sisters and how can we do this to our beloved and sweet brothers and sisters of east pakistan.Names can b different but relation belongs to Islam......
May UUUUU(East Pakistanis) live in peace ever........
For someone who has lived through the wars of 1965 and 1971, this song invokes some very painful memories and we (Pakistan) paid a price for our high-handedness. The critical question is whether we have learned anything. Unfortunately, now Baluchistan seems to be going through similar issues as we saw earlier in 1971. True justice and democracy are critical going forward. She was a very gifted voice.
@sandyrow100 i thought it was pakistanis who needed swimming costumes nowadays?! no??? oh i forgot, u guys need Israel aka USA to donate you the swimming costumes. u already had spent the money ur saudi dady gave you on buying F16s. My bad.
You are such an ignorant that I feel sorry. Are all pakis like you?! that would be disaster. BENGALIS WANTED TO MAKE THEIR LANGUAGE OFFICIAL BECAUSE THEY WERE PART OF PAKISTAN AND HENCE THEIR LANGUAGE WAS PART OF PAKISTAN, you moron.
@randominitializer you guys are all the same when you cant win an argument you resort to abuse.BENGALI GOT OFFICIAL STATIUS IN 1956 (check old passports if you dont believe) so I think you must be the moron. India had a similar problem when they tried to impose Hindi as the official language but they did not recognise other language as official until the 1960s (incidentally including Bengali) |t least Pakistan does not have to borrow Indial helicoptors and pilots if there is a problem
@randominitializer Ok, u Idiot U Indians say that India is gonna become Super Power in 10 to 15 years i think u r ignorant fools or u dont have brains. Large population of Dehli and Calcutta still sleeps on streets they cant buy food even if it is cheapest in the world. U Indians r really stupids. U cant compare India With Pakistan. In our country we live like Kings. Our people doesnt sleep on streets. We eat as we like and as we want. Have plenty of Wealth. U Indians r masters of Propaganda.
(source: UN Human Development Report 2010) Indians are better off than Pakistanis. Period.
I'm not saying that India doesn't have its problems, but you should at least look such things up and pore over the actual figures before writing such ignorant comments as 'all Pakistanis live like kings, India is much more poor.. blah blah blah.' It reflects poorly on yourself.
@randominitializer Tell me one more think if U Indians have such a bold Armed Forces than why cant they crush Pakistan. Thats becoz u Fucking Indians know that We Pakistanis will blow your asses really hard. Fuck u and your AIDS India. Gay Hind
@sandyrow100 you are being immature. I have Bihari friends in Bangladesh and they enjoy the highest economic and cultural freedom in Bangladesh, unlike stranded Bengalis in Pakistan. Biharis have voted Awami League in the last election. Go to Corbis, there are photo proofs by western journalists. Bengalis never had any issue with English being official language. They had issue with Urdu being official language while Bengali being ignnored. Bengalis only speak Bengali, not urdu, unlike punjabis.
@randominitializer Keep pumping out the inane propaganda.There are also photos of murdered and tortured Biharis. There are no stranded Bengalis in Pakistan in fact 2,000,000 moved to Karachi alone. See my other note about BENGALI being an OFFICIAL LANGUAGE SINCE 1956
@randominitializer Punjabis speak good Urdu and Sindhis and Balochis too, Its only Pathans which cant speak urdu correctly as accent. Although they can speak Urdu too at an acceptable level.
Accha??? so you want seriously "bengal back" - what does it actually mean? Do you mean liasion with Pakistan again or Liasion with West Bengal again? Going back with W. Bengal again is not possible. Bangladesh is indirectly ruled by India, and India will never do this 'act'. First, if they let w.bengal unity with east bengal they will rebel against India itself along with Asam. To rebel & fight against India clever & coward W.Bengalis again use naive people of East Bengal.
Secondly, it is not good for the ppl of Bangladesh. They have seen how the minority Hindus left them poor , destitute without education, business and money in past (before 1947) when hindus developed by being "have" with the British. This was one of the reasons ppl of BD joined wth pk in 1947. But pak people also did not make good example of co-existing.
If you are talking of joining with Pak - it is not possible. Time has passed, leaders of both wings have missed opportunity
@MistressOfWood The case for South Indians and Bengalis in Bangladesh is completely different. Bengalis in West Bengal can speak English better than Bangladeshis, when we consider the general population. That is because of the dire need of the West Bengalis to communicate with the people outside their province in the huge India. In Bangladesh a person can speak only Bengali and spend his whole life without worrying to learn another language. It's the social cultural situation that demands this.
@jaygdidhdbgsg As I said , pak missed opportunity to have its base in the middle of India. Was there any way to overpower the united pak for India? NO! Leaders of Pak should have used ideas instead of force how to keep unite and develop. How foolish then leaders were to miss the opportunity to have bipolar-hegemony in the subcontinent? India claims that it is developing - it is doing so by terrorising and taking money from its neighbours.
I wish our stupid politicians were mature back then, but unfortunately, they still are as dumb as ever. Bangladesh was our Equal half in every regard. I'm a Pakistani American & have met many people from Bangladesh & find them most genuine & very well natured people.
@Mistressofwood, you are very right in what you've said. Its individual actions that should matter more than nationalism, etc. Bangladesh is still our best brother nation, atleast many Pakistani common people still believe
It reminds of my childhood when I was a student of class (vii) and this song was famous throughout Pakistan. East Pakistan had ceased to exist and a new country Bangladesh was formed. Pakistan was broken and wounded but great patriotic songs like this injected new soul into nation and soon Pakistan stood on its feet but then a hypocrite ruler ziaul haque came who destroyed the very fabric of the country.
stop spreading the missinformation nothing is wrong with caption of this song it is 100% correct dont stick ur noise into stuff that u are not sure of it!!
Hum abhi tak Eik Qaum na ban sake bus Eik Hajoom hain .Soona jab zaron ki swrat main rait main lila hota he to pawn tale masla jata he lykin jab yahee zare mil kar dali ban jate hain to badshahon ke taj ki zeenat banta he.
Probably her prettiest video clip. She is the best and one of a kind. For god sake don't bring politics into music . I am a Bangladeshi and I love my country. But shahnaz's beautifull singing of the National anthem ,shows her beautiful voice quality and nothing else.
@shibapi I myself am a Bangladeshi and I don't see her as a traitor. She sung this when Bangladesh was a part of Pakistan. Also, remember that it was Bengalis who first gave birth to the idea of a separate homeland for Muslims of the sub-continent (e.g., Pakistan). The Muslim League was established in Dhaka. Are you going to say that we all are traitors to our country? That would be riddiculous.
@DesiRockMetal :i am from pakistan and i know we together struggle for a separate homeland..Pakistan....i knw becz of politicians and military dictatorships we had develop some misunderstandings bt now i believe let bury the hatchet and try to make our countries strong.....strong Pakistan and strong Bangladesh mean a strong muslim influence on south asian region
@fahadwifi I agree... I would like to see a strong Bangladesh and a strong Pakistan. I hate people who were responsible for the 1971 genecide. I wish more Pakistanis acknowledge what Pakistan did to East Pakistan was wrong and bring those who were responsible to justice. However, I see Pakistanis in general as my Muslim brothers/ sisters.
@DesiRockMetal :we are a one nation...maulana bhashani was a very strong advocate of pakistan....pakistan resolution was passed in lahore by a bengali,we had icons like khawaja nazim ud deen and seharwardi from east pakistan..
@DesiRockMetal .brother i hate those who were responsible for 71 atrocities bt they were from both sides,,,,i knw pakistan army had done a lot of cruel on bengalies bt pakistani nation is nt responsible for it..u knw there was a military dictatorship at tht time...u knw a large number of urdu speaking biharies,punjabi and pushtoons were also killed by mukti bahini
@fahadwifi I know brother... that's why I don't hold any grudge against Pakistanis in general, only those who were responsible for the attrocities. I love Pakistanis as I love Bangladeshis.
Yes, they have a reason to think like that , when Mujib came he started to sing the songs of 'ethnicity' and 'bangla gelo', where as, the nation was built on the basis of "two nation theory". Mujib was pridominantly nurtured, created supported by India. It was not possible to trust Mijub by the former Pak leaders.
It is very simple that the Indians will always want to break the Pak, because, they were afraid of unity. They instigated bangaldeshis. Bangladeshis love their culture, and they used it (where as, west bengale people didn't say a single word against India or hindi) we were 'fooled' and instigated. Our cultural class did the main job by inspiring people with literature, poems etc... and West Pak leaders failed make them trusted by Bengalis. So the both sides had mistakes.
See here is the problem. You have taken the independence of bangladesh and Pakistan's then Govt Yahia Khan's action in personal level. Neither you were the leader , nor I was. Using intelligence is important.
@MistressOfWood Bangladesh (or East Begal when British) is 20% Hindu so India had a fifth column and also an interest. I do not excuse Yahya Khan or other military leaders for there cruelty and mistakes. One thing I find interesting Bengladeshis are overwhelmingly Muslim, when Muslims fight their cry is "Allaha Akhbar" In Bengladesh they cried "Jai Bangla" the flag has no Islamic symbol and even Soviet Muslim states had the crescent. This all points towards the fact thhey were Indian Stooges
what you are not understanding is that a country should not be based on any religious identity. When Pakistan was formed, it also should have been secular though it was formed on the basis of of giving the people a seperate state who are muslims. The main problem of forming religious country is that it forces its people to follow religion, when you force , love for religion goes away, people start to force each other in the name of Allah. this results instability.
@MistressOfWood the instability comes from corrupted politicians and people who don't follow Islam properly. No Pakistani leader properly followed Islam. So there is no question of forcing religion or making people feel disgust about religion. Even when Bangladeshis fought against Pakistanis, it was not against Islam, but was against the political, economical and racism aspects.
I think, idea of having islamic government system should be avoided, because, people will call each other not following the islamic rules properly, due to diff interpretation, this will crease confusion, chaos - as belief is sensitive, people can do anything in the name of Allah/God.
Bangladesh actually did not fight against Pakistanis, they fought against then rulers. But, any action may have multiple beneficiaries, main beneficiaries are those who wanted to weaken the power of those who were rulling class in this subcontinent and wanted to disparse by any means, so that they can gain ultimate power.
Its not about religion, its about the group of people who believe in certain faith. In past those people rejected sanatan and accepted a new religion coming from a foreign land. How can their clan people forget this rejection? They have not accepted it well, and they never will.
@MistressOfWood In Islam it says there is "NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION" you can try to tell people you think they are going astray but it is not permissable to force someone to follow a particular sect
another thing you have to remember tha bangladeshis are respectful of their culture and language, for instance, a punjabi is proud of his culture and language. So are bengalis. Adding crescent in your flag is not what you should do for your religion, rather 'amal' or work accordign to religious belief. what language one speaks, what symbol one carries are are much smaller than what is a person's philosophy. :) anyway Bye
@sandyrow100 Are you insane? Bangladesh has 10% hindu population, not 20%. So what? did you know Muhammad peace be upon him said "Beware! Whoever is cruel and hard on a non-Muslim minority, or curtails their rights, or burdens them with more than they can bear, or takes anything from them against their free will; I (Prophet Muhammad) will complain against that person on the Day of Judgment.". So having a very small minority of hindu population does not change the Islamic nature of Bangladeshis.
@randominitializer you obviously consider it ok to be cruel to the MUSLIM BIHARIS, most of whom are deprived of citizenship, live in concentration camps suffered discrimination and violence including murder.Stop kidding yourselves that you are near anything that could be called Muslim, saying prayer 5 times a day does not automatically make you a muslim when you have a twisted and cruel insincere heart.Obviously the Hindu % has declined over the years,BTW is urdu an official language?
As a Bangladeshi, in my growing up process I never heard that Biharis are living in such a terrible condition inside BD. How can I? there is no book that writes abt them, there is no media that covers their problem, nothing! All we heard is 'silly' prejudiced 'reason' for their destitute condition is their support for Pak. But, think for a moment , they were like this even before 71. Why was that? This is very sad.
@sandyrow100 Who is cruel to Muslim bihari?! Muslim biharis in Bangladesh are excelling through enjoying equal opportunities everywhere! I had numerous bihari friends and they participated in every occasion with me in Bangladesh! The richest kid in my friend circle was a bihari kid, so stop spreading lies abt concentration camp.Only people who denounced their Bangladeshi citizenship are in UN camp. More than 99% of the population speak Bengali,why would Urdu be a national language in Bangladesh?
I am bangladeshi. Those who are excelling through "enjoying equal opportunities " who are they? can they be distinguished as Beharis? why is that? why don't hear them urdu speakers in bd, no TV program? Actually there is no place in bd for anyone one else who do not call themselves bengali. Why is that? Are we also trying to make them Bengali. Flooding the whole nation in the wave of 'Bengali' , making ppl non-bengalis bengali is INSANE!!
During 1947, 99% population did not speak only Bengali. Note, my father knows better english than my brothers.
In W Bengal 99% people speak bengali - yet why Hindi is made India's national language. 100% south indians did not know Hindi- yet they accepted hindi as national language. Gujratis and Punjabis have very strong culture , yet why they did not fight for language?
@MistressOfWood During 1947, more than 99% population in East Bengal spoke Bengali. The reason why ur father speak better English than ur brother is perhaps he was educated before 47 where the British enforced us to learn English and being British India it was quite normal for us to learn the language. In India, there is no national language. Hindi is not a national language in India, it's just an official language along with English. It is perfectly acceptable to learn English and not Hindi.
4. U answered, Yes My dad was educated during british era. Brit enforced eng for 200 yrs. After taking this for 200 yrs, while the whole world is flooded with eng already, is there any reason 2 drive it away? Wht kind of foolishness is it 2 increasing awareness of mother tongue 2 lose d grasp of d most spoken languages of the world. & making ppl monolingual?
@MistressOfWood yes, moving English away from Bangladeshi education system was foolishness. but do u know who did it? The Pakistan Military Academy educated dictator General Ershad ordered removal of official status of English from Bangladesh. English along with Bengali should have remained as one of the two official languages in Bangladesh.
aha!! error error ... long b4 Ershad the death of english started, it started with 'language movement' The emotion was created around mother tongue - which politicians are still using.
Hello, why you blaming Pak training of Ershad ? loll, Ershad himself knows better english then others who are trained in bangladesh :) you are kidding .. aren't you?
After making four borno , rest were called 'untoucheables' . even anyone came from other countries became no-caste people. while muslims came huge amounts of tortured buddists and those who are not given any group took Islam. For long time they did not get anything - they were already weak. In bengal even during the muslim rulers the land lords, professionals, trade people all were hindus. Muslims remained in dark. they were deprived of all thedevelopents.
It is enough to raise some useless identities in a nation to break its backbone. I heard that the Britishers made people of Hong Kong addicted to produce and sell drugs. The idea of bangla is bengali is more vicious than that - it is so skillfull that people are not able to see that they really were intoxicated. shame our leaders.
@MistressOfWood you have no idea on the status of language in Indian constitution. Please do some research and then talk about them. It becomes irritating arguing with someone who has no bloody idea of the subject.
There are 21 recognized scheduled languages in Indian constitution including Bengali. South Indians do not use Hindi as their official language as each state in India uses its own regional language as official language of correspondence. For Union, it's English and Hindi.
Before 1947 , majority of east bengal muslims were peasants and working class. Now tell me who made them bengali and lover of bengali language? Does making national language mean taking away your mother tongue? Did south indians stop speaking their language? Instead, they became multilingual and excelled in every way.
Who gave the idea that laguage is medium of culture? how? Is it because some people made us bengali by intoxicating us with the beauty of Bangla literature?
@MistressOfWood you don't make sense in any way. before 47, people spoke Bengali in Bengal.A human being becomes a lover of his first language since he starts to hear the sounds from his mother at infant age.national language means the language of the nation. I have known many South Indians and I have yet to encounter a single of them who can speak hindi efficiently. They speak Telugu, Tamil or whatever their language is and use English as they must, to communicate with non-South Indians.
I guess you are nor clear yet . 1. you have already answered my point. South Indians did not lose their mother tongue though Hindi was made national language. Got it? 2. b4 1947 there were many urdu speaking families too, where r those ppl now? There R various tribal languages in bd too. 3. The truth of emotional tie with mother tongue was successfully used for political purpose , isn't ??- by making propaganda "Ora amar mayer bhasha kaira nite chay".
@MistressOfWood 1. Hindi is not a national language in India.
2. South Indians speak and officially correspond in their own language in their own city and state and use English to correspond to Union or other states.
3. 1947-1971 issue was different as Bengali was not recognized as an official language of correspondence in East Pakistan and Urdu, a complete alien language to Bengalis was forced upon Bengalis as official language. That was not the case for Bengalis in India. clear on that?
Other hint I was giving, U already hv mentioned in ur scrap. Plz tell me how come a Bihari of 35 yrs old know English as if it is his mother tongue, & a 23 yrs old Banglore girl is better at English than her mother tongue 'mangalore' language?
Who is developing? bangladeshis? or Indians?
Our Bangaliness only helped the west bengal music industry and the works fr hindu group (the 'have' during brit era) who were able to produce tons of works by buttering brits.
alien language? plz go and see how many bangladeshis are fluently speaking hindi now - hindi and urdu is almost same , to revive hindi , urdu was sabotaged in the Indian subcontinent. They used us to sabotage it too. Urdu language carried many stories of muslim rulers 400-600 yrs. eng books & other books produced buring brit to target defame muslim rulers as they needed it to establish their rule.
bangla carried hindu version of story - we carried away by this. Yet we speak in their tone. they made us believ that we are 'bengali' race, which we are not, we are mixed. They have taken over our head/brain . this is true the language. Thats why and how they know the danger of intriduction of urdu in this place. If the naive people of this country start to read both english and urdu - they will surpass them (the cowards of upper caste west bengali hindus)
The coward Sen kings revived Hindusim , and forcefully converted all buddists into hindus. He also introduced borno system. Indian history made story of 'Aryans' which they never have prove. This total fraud!They called group of light skinned people aryan to rule black skinned ppl of this region. (During that time I guess they didn't have idea wht is blond). Sens revived Hindusim. made barno for the admin purpose. and ppl took it so seriously yet they can't come out.
During British era most loved people for the British were the hindus. Pls look at the history - al most all of the people who were proponants of so called Bangla Renaissance studied in English medium at school. even after 1947, none of them stopped studying in english.
Didn't they have love for their mother language?? I want to ask now - WHY they instigated and play our naive people in the name of language ? Is it to sell their products of Bangla?
before 71 Pakistan was united nation, right? Geographically Bangladesh is very important for both india and Pakistan. Specially for United Pakistan. Because , think about it another wing of Pakistan was bangladesh and India didn't have any other choice but be afraid of the combined power from both side. Neither India wanted the newly formed state to grow. So they needed to break it down.
@MistressOfWood The Indians learnt well from the British, the policy of divide & rule works just as well today and the Bengalis fell for it, effectively they are ruled by India just as Pakistan would be if they didnt have nuclear weapons
I agree with you - bangladeshis fell for it, only because our so called intellectuals are 'fool' , our past leader 'Mujibor' is a Hugely incopetent idiot - who was made by India, and majority people didn't have any clue whats going on - they are very naive.
Why should I stop telling the truth? truth is truth - it may hurt.... yet it is the truth. A person who cannot see future should not go for leading a nation.
I may be an idiot too - but I didn't go for leading and misguiding a nation. Doesn't demonstrate that at least I am not in the category to be called an 'idiot' :) as I know my limitations. Knowing limitations is a sign of intelligence. Isn't?
India had enormous interest in instigating cultural identity within the people in Bangladesh. Bangladesh and bangla language has very rich cultural heritage in this subcontinent. As normally our muslims(I guess ppl in your country too) are not very smart, they are easy to manipulate & convince. the people who are culturally elite were mainly hindus from west bengal, and they have given their best effort to make it happen.
India was standing there to support Bangalis, because it needed to break the bond. But those who were leaders in Pak didn't realise that what will be the best way to handle this people too. Leaders from that part (west pak) thought force is the best way. (which the leaders in pak are still using). But managing thru by force and threat doesn't work very well. As you can see India used power of persuation.
Pakistan then leaders were not very wise to handle things and didn't forsee the situation, they didn't realise that gaining mutual trust and bring stability is moore important for better future. rather thought about their own interest. Pakistan leaders didn't realise that these people joined with them, so needed to be treat nice and make them able to handle future country.
On the other hand some bd leaders were strongly supported with the help of India (who wants the division to weaken Pak). Those leaders apparently only saw the how they had been ill treated - made all the small issues bigger, could not wait and see how things can be improved rather started dream to come in power.
However, while you said "east bengle could never have seperated", you actually didn't understand that Bengal is also a part of Pakistan, so it is not nice to suddenly start massive killing in Bangladesh, many of whom are general people. This kind of decision can only come from a military brain. Arms cannot win mind.
@MistressOfWood I do not excuse the successive and repressive military governments Pakistan had,Ireland screwed up cos they concentrated on the racial (anti english) movement and did not try to establish a genuine democratic and free society. In the end the tyranny continued under the catholic church who gave a free hand to, their pedophile priests and callous nuns of the Magdaline Laundries who are still escaping justice today
Nobody likes military rule. BD now cannot try for democracy because , with the influence of India its democracy is not possible. Indian's present policy is to change the mentality of Bangladeshis, by making them feel proud of being 'bengali', proud of 'bangla', and free entry of 'Hindi' language and culture thru media. & of course keeping anti-pak attitude.
Btw, Indians also united themselves by 'anti-pak' , but they are clever/shrewed. they r doing other things too.
you know what the leaders from your side did ? Each time since 1950 they tried to solve anything with force - instead of verbal persuation. Force doesn't work. So, within 23 years of together, people from pakisn side did foolish acts and also the people from this side. No country had peace. In the middle India started their development. When military brain Yahia thought he can just shut the bengalis mouth up by force.
@MistressOfWood The main problem was the ambition of Bernazir Bhutto's father, he could not be Prime minister of a United Pakistan because the Bengali awami League outnumbered his party. His solution, get rid of East Pakistan although he let the Indians do the dirty work as it was to their advantage also (divide & rule) they Invadedand defeated the Pkistan army, the Bengaldeshis did not win their own "independence"
When military brain Yahia thought he can just shut the bengalis mouth up by force. he had no idea what kind of future he has leading all of us into. General Bangladeshis actually were very happy when they were united with pakistan. Bengalis are intelligent Pakistan could be benefited. On the other hand Pakistan had muscle power , bengalis could be benefited.
However, when you said we are doomed to suffer. you are not understanding that how much your country is also suffering. See, this is where intelligence comes for. The mistakes the leaders done there are still there. You guys are still thinking that applying force is the best way, and this is exactly the problem area. Your leaders made you believe that. To be honest, pakistan had a lot of potentials only is you can bring stability inside the country.
"siding with idolaters" is very racist comment. No need to answer that from my part. All human beings are equal. No one is less no one is more. When you can change this view that day you'll gain peace.
I think the executioners should not do the killing at all. Because, the popularity of Mujib was reducing very quickly, he would have been knocked out of the position anyway.
My first year in high school and Shanaz begum was an ideal singer with so much beauty and equally great voice. The music of sohail rana has made this patriotic song an immortal thing. Thak you very much for posting buddy. Thanks to "uhotatokyahota" this is a fact that people of Indo pakistan wants to live in peace and they have no grudges for each others but its a divide and rule game by America bahadur.
i m indian but as a indian i always want india and pakistan as friend helping each other then only the world can take example from us. jai india and jai pkistan.............
Jeevay Pakistan!
hassaanzia110 3 months ago
Bangladeshi Shahnaz Rahmatullah sang this song becz she do not know bangladesh will be born.then her other song Joy bangla banglar joy hobe hobe
2lovecute 4 months ago
@2lovecute The song was sung in 1972, and Bangladesh was already there then.
hassaanzia110 3 months ago
I love you and respect your thoughts Narenjan kumar....dont listen to such stupids...listen to me and such pure Pakistanis..we love Pakistan and will love Pakistan always chahie kuch bhe hoo jaey...Jeevey Pakistan
sam1123khan 4 months ago
love the song, how old is this
gtvapsamtik 5 months ago
@sonaaro
Love you Narenjan. You are only true Pakistani. Our identity is not Hindu , not Muslim , not Christian etc..
We are one Pakistan! and you are Patriotic Pakistani.
daeerefasd 5 months ago 4
iss geet ko sun kar bachpan mein school k din yaad aagaye! Jab 14 aug aur 23 mar ko gaya kartay thay. kya din thay woh dosto!
I really miss those days!
Love u Pakistan, love you my childhood , love those beautiful days!
daeerefasd 5 months ago
Yaaro aaj kya ho gaya hamaray Pakistan ko? Kitna khoobsurat tha hamara Pakistan!
aaj bohat arsay baad iss geet ko sun kar aankhon mein aansoo bhar aaye!
I really wanna cry!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
daeerefasd 5 months ago
This song really touches deep in my heart!
Love you my dear Pakistan!
daeerefasd 5 months ago
JEEVAY JEEVAY PAKISTAN
daeerefasd 5 months ago
LOVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVE THIS SONG!
daeerefasd 5 months ago
lovely song..
Indian
kumbhu1 6 months ago
Shenaz Begum~! What a stunning beauty~!
deadpinkowl 6 months ago
@sonaaro really sad sir i am also considered minority in Pakistan.Just pray for our country.I can feel your difficulties that I have the same situation.
labeeb10000 6 months ago
One day the modern superpowers will be teared apart and Pakistan will take their place, mashallah.
Alhazem1 6 months ago
Today I miss my great pakistan in germany.allah tahla pakistan ko mulvio say pakistan
1974luqman 6 months ago
I love too much with my pakistan
1974luqman 6 months ago
we are all Pakistani
dilawarlatif 6 months ago
@sonaaro
dont be flustered by these maulvis and radicals man... a Pakistani is a Pakistani whether he is muslim or hindu or christian
blobloblaw12 6 months ago 3
@sonaaro yaar aisay logon ki baat chordo yeah wohi log hain jo is mulk ko torna chahtay hain
Be it SINDHI, PUNJABI BALUCHI, PATHAN or URDU SPEAKER or koi bhi ethnicity ka ho ya kisi bhi religious fraternity se tall'luq ho Hindu, Christian, ya SIKH we all are PAKISTANIs and we shoud be proud of it :)
And should work for its betterment
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD
rollno19 6 months ago 6
@sonaaro Kis nay kaha aap Patriotic Pakistani nahi? jo log eisa kahtay hein wo Pakistan kay dost nahi dushman hain. Pakistan ka her citizen chahay wo hindu ho christian ho ya koe or utna he Pakistani hai jitna aik Muslim Pakistani hai. hamay itihaad ke bat karna chaeye jo her dor me zarori hei na kay tornay ke... mai ik Muslim Pakistani hon or Pakistan ke her Citizen chahay wo kisi mazhab se ho aik suchay Pakistani ke hesiyat se dekhta hon. Allah Pakistan ko salamat rakhay ameen!
venus983able 6 months ago 5
Jeeve jeeve Pakistan.........Proud to b a Pakistani........
Ranasadia 6 months ago
BEAUTIFUL SONG. THANKS FOR UPLOADING THIS TREASURE.
tradecycles 6 months ago
JIYO MERE DOSTO...LOVELY SONG
MrZhengqiuliang 6 months ago
@sonaaro I salute you Mr. Narenjan Jee!
We love our Hindu brothers and sisters as much we love any Muslim Pakistani!
hotsparkles 7 months ago 52
@sonaaro
you shouldn't mind those people you are Pakistani and that is what important if someone call you traitor because of your religious believes then trust me those are real traitors!!!
i would love to see one day a Hindu, Sikh or christian at least president of Pakistan because this is their mother land as much as others
any country who cherish its minority's is a just society else they are doomed!!!
Asif410 7 months ago 56
@Asif410 i agree .. But to The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 A non Muslim can not be the president of Islamic Republic of Pakistan .. and Yeah it is the Mother Land of Hindu Christan sikh and all otherz ...
mahsanseo 6 months ago
@12345bloch ap jesen p fakhr he hm unite rhen ge to dushman ke aankhn nochne k slahiyat rkhn ge god bles u baloch bhai jhan ap ka pasina vhan mera blood pakistan zindabad india israel america murda bad
bravo6910 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Pakistan from its creation is under threat for traitors inside and external threats...We should unite again and lift the nation..get rid of all Mir Jaffers from Pakistan.
chilliyou 9 months ago
Pakistan from its creation is under threat for traitors inside and external threats...We should unite again and lift the nation..get rid of all Mir Jaffers from Pakistan.
chilliyou 9 months ago
We Pakistanis never forget our palestinian,bosnian and chechan brothers and
sisters and how can we do this to our beloved and sweet brothers and sisters of east pakistan.Names can b different but relation belongs to Islam......
May UUUUU(East Pakistanis) live in peace ever........
inqalabi041190 9 months ago
For someone who has lived through the wars of 1965 and 1971, this song invokes some very painful memories and we (Pakistan) paid a price for our high-handedness. The critical question is whether we have learned anything. Unfortunately, now Baluchistan seems to be going through similar issues as we saw earlier in 1971. True justice and democracy are critical going forward. She was a very gifted voice.
jogijogi99 10 months ago
shahnaz begum is a bengali frm east pakistan (now known as bangladesh) and wot a beautiful song she sang for pakistan
reunite 1 day inshallah
zainkiani1 11 months ago
Bengala Deshi are our brother. Best Wishes for them.
MrShafqatraza 8 months ago
shahnaz begum is a bengali frm east pakistan (now known as bangladesh) and wot a beautiful song she sang
reunite inshallah 1 day
zainkiani1 11 months ago
shahnaz begum is a bengali frm east pakistan (now known as bangladesh) and wot a beautiful song she sang!
reunite inshallah 1 day
zainkiani1 11 months ago
beautiful voice
puranijeans2002 11 months ago
Best Wishes to the Islamic Republic of Pakistan on the occasion of its 71st National Day!
2005xynul 11 months ago
Drowned in a Tsunami of Emotions - -11-3-2011/Zain Abidin from Mauritius!
2005xynul 11 months ago
good voice quality...nice
ravindragandhile 11 months ago
Me too coz of Jemima Khan
njawad12 1 year ago
I'm here because of Jamima Khan
uzicool 1 year ago 2
@uzicool
me too ;)
TheAlibaabaa 1 year ago
@uzicool so do I.............
haseebfazi1 1 year ago
@sandyrow100 i thought it was pakistanis who needed swimming costumes nowadays?! no??? oh i forgot, u guys need Israel aka USA to donate you the swimming costumes. u already had spent the money ur saudi dady gave you on buying F16s. My bad.
You are such an ignorant that I feel sorry. Are all pakis like you?! that would be disaster. BENGALIS WANTED TO MAKE THEIR LANGUAGE OFFICIAL BECAUSE THEY WERE PART OF PAKISTAN AND HENCE THEIR LANGUAGE WAS PART OF PAKISTAN, you moron.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer you guys are all the same when you cant win an argument you resort to abuse.BENGALI GOT OFFICIAL STATIUS IN 1956 (check old passports if you dont believe) so I think you must be the moron. India had a similar problem when they tried to impose Hindi as the official language but they did not recognise other language as official until the 1960s (incidentally including Bengali) |t least Pakistan does not have to borrow Indial helicoptors and pilots if there is a problem
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@randominitializer Ok, u Idiot U Indians say that India is gonna become Super Power in 10 to 15 years i think u r ignorant fools or u dont have brains. Large population of Dehli and Calcutta still sleeps on streets they cant buy food even if it is cheapest in the world. U Indians r really stupids. U cant compare India With Pakistan. In our country we live like Kings. Our people doesnt sleep on streets. We eat as we like and as we want. Have plenty of Wealth. U Indians r masters of Propaganda.
1985MUHAMMADBILAL 1 year ago
@1985MUHAMMADBILAL Pakistan's HDI- 0.490 Per-capita GDP (PPP)- $2,700
India's HDI- 0.520 Per-capita GDP (PPP)- $3,300
(source: UN Human Development Report 2010) Indians are better off than Pakistanis. Period.
I'm not saying that India doesn't have its problems, but you should at least look such things up and pore over the actual figures before writing such ignorant comments as 'all Pakistanis live like kings, India is much more poor.. blah blah blah.' It reflects poorly on yourself.
thephilosopherkartik 1 year ago
@thephilosopherkartik u should consider listening to Palagummi Sainath, if u are intrested in talking abt HDI and Per capita income stuff
zainussami 1 year ago
@1985MUHAMMADBILAL That is true...:(
ravindragandhile 11 months ago
@randominitializer Tell me one more think if U Indians have such a bold Armed Forces than why cant they crush Pakistan. Thats becoz u Fucking Indians know that We Pakistanis will blow your asses really hard. Fuck u and your AIDS India. Gay Hind
1985MUHAMMADBILAL 1 year ago
@sandyrow100 you are being immature. I have Bihari friends in Bangladesh and they enjoy the highest economic and cultural freedom in Bangladesh, unlike stranded Bengalis in Pakistan. Biharis have voted Awami League in the last election. Go to Corbis, there are photo proofs by western journalists. Bengalis never had any issue with English being official language. They had issue with Urdu being official language while Bengali being ignnored. Bengalis only speak Bengali, not urdu, unlike punjabis.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer Keep pumping out the inane propaganda.There are also photos of murdered and tortured Biharis. There are no stranded Bengalis in Pakistan in fact 2,000,000 moved to Karachi alone. See my other note about BENGALI being an OFFICIAL LANGUAGE SINCE 1956
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@randominitializer Punjabis speak good Urdu and Sindhis and Balochis too, Its only Pathans which cant speak urdu correctly as accent. Although they can speak Urdu too at an acceptable level.
1985MUHAMMADBILAL 1 year ago
sweet song:)
Pirzadagm 1 year ago
we seriously want bengal back...inshALLAH we'l get one day
jaygdidhdbgsg 1 year ago
@jaygdidhdbgsg
Accha??? so you want seriously "bengal back" - what does it actually mean? Do you mean liasion with Pakistan again or Liasion with West Bengal again? Going back with W. Bengal again is not possible. Bangladesh is indirectly ruled by India, and India will never do this 'act'. First, if they let w.bengal unity with east bengal they will rebel against India itself along with Asam. To rebel & fight against India clever & coward W.Bengalis again use naive people of East Bengal.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@jaygdidhdbgsg
Secondly, it is not good for the ppl of Bangladesh. They have seen how the minority Hindus left them poor , destitute without education, business and money in past (before 1947) when hindus developed by being "have" with the British. This was one of the reasons ppl of BD joined wth pk in 1947. But pak people also did not make good example of co-existing.
If you are talking of joining with Pak - it is not possible. Time has passed, leaders of both wings have missed opportunity
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood The case for South Indians and Bengalis in Bangladesh is completely different. Bengalis in West Bengal can speak English better than Bangladeshis, when we consider the general population. That is because of the dire need of the West Bengalis to communicate with the people outside their province in the huge India. In Bangladesh a person can speak only Bengali and spend his whole life without worrying to learn another language. It's the social cultural situation that demands this.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@jaygdidhdbgsg As I said , pak missed opportunity to have its base in the middle of India. Was there any way to overpower the united pak for India? NO! Leaders of Pak should have used ideas instead of force how to keep unite and develop. How foolish then leaders were to miss the opportunity to have bipolar-hegemony in the subcontinent? India claims that it is developing - it is doing so by terrorising and taking money from its neighbours.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
I wish our stupid politicians were mature back then, but unfortunately, they still are as dumb as ever. Bangladesh was our Equal half in every regard. I'm a Pakistani American & have met many people from Bangladesh & find them most genuine & very well natured people.
@Mistressofwood, you are very right in what you've said. Its individual actions that should matter more than nationalism, etc. Bangladesh is still our best brother nation, atleast many Pakistani common people still believe
datzburier 1 year ago
It reminds of my childhood when I was a student of class (vii) and this song was famous throughout Pakistan. East Pakistan had ceased to exist and a new country Bangladesh was formed. Pakistan was broken and wounded but great patriotic songs like this injected new soul into nation and soon Pakistan stood on its feet but then a hypocrite ruler ziaul haque came who destroyed the very fabric of the country.
MuhammadAhmad1 1 year ago
God bless Shahnaz Begum. God bless Pakistan. Jeeway Pakistan, indeed. God bless Shahnaz Begum's Bangladesh.
clifton7777 1 year ago
nothing wrong
pisrr 1 year ago
pakistan zindabad.................
MyPak1947 1 year ago
Sung in 1972 and still soul warming.
saeedm1939 1 year ago
@saeedm1939 It was sung before 1971. This song was dated most likely around 1968/69 or even before but not after.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
stop spreading the missinformation nothing is wrong with caption of this song it is 100% correct dont stick ur noise into stuff that u are not sure of it!!
Asif410 1 year ago
@saeedm1939 the captions in the clip itself was added later and it bears wrong information.
randominitializer 1 year ago
Salaam Pakistan :)
lostsoul324 1 year ago
Hum abhi tak Eik Qaum na ban sake bus Eik Hajoom hain .Soona jab zaron ki swrat main rait main lila hota he to pawn tale masla jata he lykin jab yahee zare mil kar dali ban jate hain to badshahon ke taj ki zeenat banta he.
with regards
shakeel hussain
shakeelsunny02 1 year ago
awesome thank you so much
asherswing 1 year ago
She was a Pakistani, not Bangladeshi singer when this song was sung..
aquamajor1 1 year ago
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
eleonormurtuza 1 year ago
Probably her prettiest video clip. She is the best and one of a kind. For god sake don't bring politics into music . I am a Bangladeshi and I love my country. But shahnaz's beautifull singing of the National anthem ,shows her beautiful voice quality and nothing else.
topazscorpiio 1 year ago
@topazscorpiio Agreed. We also love Bangladesh. She was Pakistani when the song was sung and nothing else.
Pallangi 1 year ago
amazing song????????
mughal83kh 1 year ago
She is a great "Razakar". She should move way from Bangladesh.
Azad from Finland.
shibapi 1 year ago
@shibapi I myself am a Bangladeshi and I don't see her as a traitor. She sung this when Bangladesh was a part of Pakistan. Also, remember that it was Bengalis who first gave birth to the idea of a separate homeland for Muslims of the sub-continent (e.g., Pakistan). The Muslim League was established in Dhaka. Are you going to say that we all are traitors to our country? That would be riddiculous.
DesiRockMetal 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal :i am from pakistan and i know we together struggle for a separate homeland..Pakistan....i knw becz of politicians and military dictatorships we had develop some misunderstandings bt now i believe let bury the hatchet and try to make our countries strong.....strong Pakistan and strong Bangladesh mean a strong muslim influence on south asian region
fahadwifi 1 year ago
@fahadwifi I agree... I would like to see a strong Bangladesh and a strong Pakistan. I hate people who were responsible for the 1971 genecide. I wish more Pakistanis acknowledge what Pakistan did to East Pakistan was wrong and bring those who were responsible to justice. However, I see Pakistanis in general as my Muslim brothers/ sisters.
DesiRockMetal 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal :we are a one nation...maulana bhashani was a very strong advocate of pakistan....pakistan resolution was passed in lahore by a bengali,we had icons like khawaja nazim ud deen and seharwardi from east pakistan..
fahadwifi 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal .brother i hate those who were responsible for 71 atrocities bt they were from both sides,,,,i knw pakistan army had done a lot of cruel on bengalies bt pakistani nation is nt responsible for it..u knw there was a military dictatorship at tht time...u knw a large number of urdu speaking biharies,punjabi and pushtoons were also killed by mukti bahini
fahadwifi 1 year ago
@fahadwifi I know brother... that's why I don't hold any grudge against Pakistanis in general, only those who were responsible for the attrocities. I love Pakistanis as I love Bangladeshis.
DesiRockMetal 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal
Yes, they have a reason to think like that , when Mujib came he started to sing the songs of 'ethnicity' and 'bangla gelo', where as, the nation was built on the basis of "two nation theory". Mujib was pridominantly nurtured, created supported by India. It was not possible to trust Mijub by the former Pak leaders.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal
It is very simple that the Indians will always want to break the Pak, because, they were afraid of unity. They instigated bangaldeshis. Bangladeshis love their culture, and they used it (where as, west bengale people didn't say a single word against India or hindi) we were 'fooled' and instigated. Our cultural class did the main job by inspiring people with literature, poems etc... and West Pak leaders failed make them trusted by Bengalis. So the both sides had mistakes.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood East Bengal could never have separated from Pakistan without Indian troops and will be doomed to suffer for siding with idolaters
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
See here is the problem. You have taken the independence of bangladesh and Pakistan's then Govt Yahia Khan's action in personal level. Neither you were the leader , nor I was. Using intelligence is important.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood Bangladesh (or East Begal when British) is 20% Hindu so India had a fifth column and also an interest. I do not excuse Yahya Khan or other military leaders for there cruelty and mistakes. One thing I find interesting Bengladeshis are overwhelmingly Muslim, when Muslims fight their cry is "Allaha Akhbar" In Bengladesh they cried "Jai Bangla" the flag has no Islamic symbol and even Soviet Muslim states had the crescent. This all points towards the fact thhey were Indian Stooges
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
what you are not understanding is that a country should not be based on any religious identity. When Pakistan was formed, it also should have been secular though it was formed on the basis of of giving the people a seperate state who are muslims. The main problem of forming religious country is that it forces its people to follow religion, when you force , love for religion goes away, people start to force each other in the name of Allah. this results instability.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood the instability comes from corrupted politicians and people who don't follow Islam properly. No Pakistani leader properly followed Islam. So there is no question of forcing religion or making people feel disgust about religion. Even when Bangladeshis fought against Pakistanis, it was not against Islam, but was against the political, economical and racism aspects.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
I think, idea of having islamic government system should be avoided, because, people will call each other not following the islamic rules properly, due to diff interpretation, this will crease confusion, chaos - as belief is sensitive, people can do anything in the name of Allah/God.
So, a state should be secular.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
Comment removed
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer ,
Bangladesh actually did not fight against Pakistanis, they fought against then rulers. But, any action may have multiple beneficiaries, main beneficiaries are those who wanted to weaken the power of those who were rulling class in this subcontinent and wanted to disparse by any means, so that they can gain ultimate power.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
Its not about religion, its about the group of people who believe in certain faith. In past those people rejected sanatan and accepted a new religion coming from a foreign land. How can their clan people forget this rejection? They have not accepted it well, and they never will.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood In Islam it says there is "NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION" you can try to tell people you think they are going astray but it is not permissable to force someone to follow a particular sect
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
another thing you have to remember tha bangladeshis are respectful of their culture and language, for instance, a punjabi is proud of his culture and language. So are bengalis. Adding crescent in your flag is not what you should do for your religion, rather 'amal' or work accordign to religious belief. what language one speaks, what symbol one carries are are much smaller than what is a person's philosophy. :) anyway Bye
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100 Are you insane? Bangladesh has 10% hindu population, not 20%. So what? did you know Muhammad peace be upon him said "Beware! Whoever is cruel and hard on a non-Muslim minority, or curtails their rights, or burdens them with more than they can bear, or takes anything from them against their free will; I (Prophet Muhammad) will complain against that person on the Day of Judgment.". So having a very small minority of hindu population does not change the Islamic nature of Bangladeshis.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer you obviously consider it ok to be cruel to the MUSLIM BIHARIS, most of whom are deprived of citizenship, live in concentration camps suffered discrimination and violence including murder.Stop kidding yourselves that you are near anything that could be called Muslim, saying prayer 5 times a day does not automatically make you a muslim when you have a twisted and cruel insincere heart.Obviously the Hindu % has declined over the years,BTW is urdu an official language?
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
As a Bangladeshi, in my growing up process I never heard that Biharis are living in such a terrible condition inside BD. How can I? there is no book that writes abt them, there is no media that covers their problem, nothing! All we heard is 'silly' prejudiced 'reason' for their destitute condition is their support for Pak. But, think for a moment , they were like this even before 71. Why was that? This is very sad.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100 Who is cruel to Muslim bihari?! Muslim biharis in Bangladesh are excelling through enjoying equal opportunities everywhere! I had numerous bihari friends and they participated in every occasion with me in Bangladesh! The richest kid in my friend circle was a bihari kid, so stop spreading lies abt concentration camp.Only people who denounced their Bangladeshi citizenship are in UN camp. More than 99% of the population speak Bengali,why would Urdu be a national language in Bangladesh?
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
I am bangladeshi. Those who are excelling through "enjoying equal opportunities " who are they? can they be distinguished as Beharis? why is that? why don't hear them urdu speakers in bd, no TV program? Actually there is no place in bd for anyone one else who do not call themselves bengali. Why is that? Are we also trying to make them Bengali. Flooding the whole nation in the wave of 'Bengali' , making ppl non-bengalis bengali is INSANE!!
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
During 1947, 99% population did not speak only Bengali. Note, my father knows better english than my brothers.
In W Bengal 99% people speak bengali - yet why Hindi is made India's national language. 100% south indians did not know Hindi- yet they accepted hindi as national language. Gujratis and Punjabis have very strong culture , yet why they did not fight for language?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood During 1947, more than 99% population in East Bengal spoke Bengali. The reason why ur father speak better English than ur brother is perhaps he was educated before 47 where the British enforced us to learn English and being British India it was quite normal for us to learn the language. In India, there is no national language. Hindi is not a national language in India, it's just an official language along with English. It is perfectly acceptable to learn English and not Hindi.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
4. U answered, Yes My dad was educated during british era. Brit enforced eng for 200 yrs. After taking this for 200 yrs, while the whole world is flooded with eng already, is there any reason 2 drive it away? Wht kind of foolishness is it 2 increasing awareness of mother tongue 2 lose d grasp of d most spoken languages of the world. & making ppl monolingual?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood yes, moving English away from Bangladeshi education system was foolishness. but do u know who did it? The Pakistan Military Academy educated dictator General Ershad ordered removal of official status of English from Bangladesh. English along with Bengali should have remained as one of the two official languages in Bangladesh.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
aha!! error error ... long b4 Ershad the death of english started, it started with 'language movement' The emotion was created around mother tongue - which politicians are still using.
Hello, why you blaming Pak training of Ershad ? loll, Ershad himself knows better english then others who are trained in bangladesh :) you are kidding .. aren't you?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
After making four borno , rest were called 'untoucheables' . even anyone came from other countries became no-caste people. while muslims came huge amounts of tortured buddists and those who are not given any group took Islam. For long time they did not get anything - they were already weak. In bengal even during the muslim rulers the land lords, professionals, trade people all were hindus. Muslims remained in dark. they were deprived of all thedevelopents.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
It is enough to raise some useless identities in a nation to break its backbone. I heard that the Britishers made people of Hong Kong addicted to produce and sell drugs. The idea of bangla is bengali is more vicious than that - it is so skillfull that people are not able to see that they really were intoxicated. shame our leaders.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood you have no idea on the status of language in Indian constitution. Please do some research and then talk about them. It becomes irritating arguing with someone who has no bloody idea of the subject.
There are 21 recognized scheduled languages in Indian constitution including Bengali. South Indians do not use Hindi as their official language as each state in India uses its own regional language as official language of correspondence. For Union, it's English and Hindi.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
Before 1947 , majority of east bengal muslims were peasants and working class. Now tell me who made them bengali and lover of bengali language? Does making national language mean taking away your mother tongue? Did south indians stop speaking their language? Instead, they became multilingual and excelled in every way.
Who gave the idea that laguage is medium of culture? how? Is it because some people made us bengali by intoxicating us with the beauty of Bangla literature?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood you don't make sense in any way. before 47, people spoke Bengali in Bengal.A human being becomes a lover of his first language since he starts to hear the sounds from his mother at infant age.national language means the language of the nation. I have known many South Indians and I have yet to encounter a single of them who can speak hindi efficiently. They speak Telugu, Tamil or whatever their language is and use English as they must, to communicate with non-South Indians.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
I guess you are nor clear yet . 1. you have already answered my point. South Indians did not lose their mother tongue though Hindi was made national language. Got it? 2. b4 1947 there were many urdu speaking families too, where r those ppl now? There R various tribal languages in bd too. 3. The truth of emotional tie with mother tongue was successfully used for political purpose , isn't ??- by making propaganda "Ora amar mayer bhasha kaira nite chay".
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood 1. Hindi is not a national language in India.
2. South Indians speak and officially correspond in their own language in their own city and state and use English to correspond to Union or other states.
3. 1947-1971 issue was different as Bengali was not recognized as an official language of correspondence in East Pakistan and Urdu, a complete alien language to Bengalis was forced upon Bengalis as official language. That was not the case for Bengalis in India. clear on that?
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
Other hint I was giving, U already hv mentioned in ur scrap. Plz tell me how come a Bihari of 35 yrs old know English as if it is his mother tongue, & a 23 yrs old Banglore girl is better at English than her mother tongue 'mangalore' language?
Who is developing? bangladeshis? or Indians?
Our Bangaliness only helped the west bengal music industry and the works fr hindu group (the 'have' during brit era) who were able to produce tons of works by buttering brits.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
alien language? plz go and see how many bangladeshis are fluently speaking hindi now - hindi and urdu is almost same , to revive hindi , urdu was sabotaged in the Indian subcontinent. They used us to sabotage it too. Urdu language carried many stories of muslim rulers 400-600 yrs. eng books & other books produced buring brit to target defame muslim rulers as they needed it to establish their rule.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood Thats true my dear. But not complete true.
1985MUHAMMADBILAL 1 year ago
@randominitializer
bangla carried hindu version of story - we carried away by this. Yet we speak in their tone. they made us believ that we are 'bengali' race, which we are not, we are mixed. They have taken over our head/brain . this is true the language. Thats why and how they know the danger of intriduction of urdu in this place. If the naive people of this country start to read both english and urdu - they will surpass them (the cowards of upper caste west bengali hindus)
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
The coward Sen kings revived Hindusim , and forcefully converted all buddists into hindus. He also introduced borno system. Indian history made story of 'Aryans' which they never have prove. This total fraud!They called group of light skinned people aryan to rule black skinned ppl of this region. (During that time I guess they didn't have idea wht is blond). Sens revived Hindusim. made barno for the admin purpose. and ppl took it so seriously yet they can't come out.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@randominitializer
During British era most loved people for the British were the hindus. Pls look at the history - al most all of the people who were proponants of so called Bangla Renaissance studied in English medium at school. even after 1947, none of them stopped studying in english.
Didn't they have love for their mother language?? I want to ask now - WHY they instigated and play our naive people in the name of language ? Is it to sell their products of Bangla?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
before 71 Pakistan was united nation, right? Geographically Bangladesh is very important for both india and Pakistan. Specially for United Pakistan. Because , think about it another wing of Pakistan was bangladesh and India didn't have any other choice but be afraid of the combined power from both side. Neither India wanted the newly formed state to grow. So they needed to break it down.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood The Indians learnt well from the British, the policy of divide & rule works just as well today and the Bengalis fell for it, effectively they are ruled by India just as Pakistan would be if they didnt have nuclear weapons
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
I agree with you - bangladeshis fell for it, only because our so called intellectuals are 'fool' , our past leader 'Mujibor' is a Hugely incopetent idiot - who was made by India, and majority people didn't have any clue whats going on - they are very naive.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood before calling Mujib an idiot, you should look at yourself.
randominitializer 1 year ago
@randominitializer
Why should I stop telling the truth? truth is truth - it may hurt.... yet it is the truth. A person who cannot see future should not go for leading a nation.
I may be an idiot too - but I didn't go for leading and misguiding a nation. Doesn't demonstrate that at least I am not in the category to be called an 'idiot' :) as I know my limitations. Knowing limitations is a sign of intelligence. Isn't?
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
India had enormous interest in instigating cultural identity within the people in Bangladesh. Bangladesh and bangla language has very rich cultural heritage in this subcontinent. As normally our muslims(I guess ppl in your country too) are not very smart, they are easy to manipulate & convince. the people who are culturally elite were mainly hindus from west bengal, and they have given their best effort to make it happen.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
India was standing there to support Bangalis, because it needed to break the bond. But those who were leaders in Pak didn't realise that what will be the best way to handle this people too. Leaders from that part (west pak) thought force is the best way. (which the leaders in pak are still using). But managing thru by force and threat doesn't work very well. As you can see India used power of persuation.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
Pakistan then leaders were not very wise to handle things and didn't forsee the situation, they didn't realise that gaining mutual trust and bring stability is moore important for better future. rather thought about their own interest. Pakistan leaders didn't realise that these people joined with them, so needed to be treat nice and make them able to handle future country.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
On the other hand some bd leaders were strongly supported with the help of India (who wants the division to weaken Pak). Those leaders apparently only saw the how they had been ill treated - made all the small issues bigger, could not wait and see how things can be improved rather started dream to come in power.
So there was failure from both side.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
However, while you said "east bengle could never have seperated", you actually didn't understand that Bengal is also a part of Pakistan, so it is not nice to suddenly start massive killing in Bangladesh, many of whom are general people. This kind of decision can only come from a military brain. Arms cannot win mind.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood I do not excuse the successive and repressive military governments Pakistan had,Ireland screwed up cos they concentrated on the racial (anti english) movement and did not try to establish a genuine democratic and free society. In the end the tyranny continued under the catholic church who gave a free hand to, their pedophile priests and callous nuns of the Magdaline Laundries who are still escaping justice today
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
Nobody likes military rule. BD now cannot try for democracy because , with the influence of India its democracy is not possible. Indian's present policy is to change the mentality of Bangladeshis, by making them feel proud of being 'bengali', proud of 'bangla', and free entry of 'Hindi' language and culture thru media. & of course keeping anti-pak attitude.
Btw, Indians also united themselves by 'anti-pak' , but they are clever/shrewed. they r doing other things too.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
India's new technique is cultural invasion.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
you know what the leaders from your side did ? Each time since 1950 they tried to solve anything with force - instead of verbal persuation. Force doesn't work. So, within 23 years of together, people from pakisn side did foolish acts and also the people from this side. No country had peace. In the middle India started their development. When military brain Yahia thought he can just shut the bengalis mouth up by force.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood The main problem was the ambition of Bernazir Bhutto's father, he could not be Prime minister of a United Pakistan because the Bengali awami League outnumbered his party. His solution, get rid of East Pakistan although he let the Indians do the dirty work as it was to their advantage also (divide & rule) they Invadedand defeated the Pkistan army, the Bengaldeshis did not win their own "independence"
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
When military brain Yahia thought he can just shut the bengalis mouth up by force. he had no idea what kind of future he has leading all of us into. General Bangladeshis actually were very happy when they were united with pakistan. Bengalis are intelligent Pakistan could be benefited. On the other hand Pakistan had muscle power , bengalis could be benefited.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
However, when you said we are doomed to suffer. you are not understanding that how much your country is also suffering. See, this is where intelligence comes for. The mistakes the leaders done there are still there. You guys are still thinking that applying force is the best way, and this is exactly the problem area. Your leaders made you believe that. To be honest, pakistan had a lot of potentials only is you can bring stability inside the country.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
"siding with idolaters" is very racist comment. No need to answer that from my part. All human beings are equal. No one is less no one is more. When you can change this view that day you'll gain peace.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal
End result is break of Pak. major gain is for India. Mujib was a damn 'fool'. He was fooled.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@MistressOfWood his executioners were bigger fools, they left his daughter alive and now you can see what happened
sandyrow100 1 year ago
@sandyrow100
I think the executioners should not do the killing at all. Because, the popularity of Mujib was reducing very quickly, he would have been knocked out of the position anyway.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
@DesiRockMetal
Btw, I am a bangladeshi too:)
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
Amazing!
msauofa 2 years ago
Thank you!
Gorgeous Shahnaz Begum and her beautiful voice... long live Shahnaz!.
I love all her songs.
Please let me know If anyone have her full CD or DVD..
Thank you
coolwtr033 2 years ago 3
@coolwtr033 shenaz begum aap jhan bhee rhian allh aap khush rakhay ameeen iftikhar ahmed germany
tanziel 1 year ago
My first year in high school and Shanaz begum was an ideal singer with so much beauty and equally great voice. The music of sohail rana has made this patriotic song an immortal thing. Thak you very much for posting buddy. Thanks to "uhotatokyahota" this is a fact that people of Indo pakistan wants to live in peace and they have no grudges for each others but its a divide and rule game by America bahadur.
The291962 2 years ago 2
A beautiful Composition and Brilliant Singing.
Thanks a lot for Posting this Song Made for Pakistan Sung By a Bangladeshi Singer and admired by an Indian(that's Me)
uhotatokyahota 2 years ago 4
PAKISTAN ZINDABAD
ASLAMBAHI 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
uhotatokyahota 2 years ago
brilliant
Pakistan Zindabad
haider5555 2 years ago 3
best pakistani patriotic song sung by a bangladesh singer
pisrr 2 years ago 11
@pisrr
So what ? if she was bangladeshi. Bangladesh was part of undivided Pakistan before 1971. Nothing wrong in that.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
I lov this song
chikoolover82 2 years ago 3
She looks like Sophia Loren!
myusernameisusername 2 years ago 4
Lovely song. Jeeway Paistan. Long live Pakistan. What shall I say, but 'Ameen"
PS: An Indian here. Yaar, lets's not fight and use foul words. Let's live like brothers. Let's overcome hate with love.
(One more word and I will sound like a politician :)
supersirsridhar 2 years ago 6
hahhahahahhhahahhhahahh
agree wd u, bro.
mohabat70 2 years ago 2
Yes brother. But unfortunately we are in trouble under power of international plitics :(
muss76 2 years ago 2
@supersirsridhar
loll, brother ...indeed you sounded like a politician. But great job of praising a Pakistani patriotic song sang by a Bangladeshi Singer .....
Yes , only love can overcome conflict and we can co-exist with difference.
MistressOfWood 1 year ago
jeewy jewy Pakistaaaaaan.
this song was once sung before bhutto and he danced on the stage, can any bodu post that clip pleasssssssssssssssssssss.
mohabat70 2 years ago 4
old is gold
88a 2 years ago 4
PAKISTAN Zinda baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad
shynotee1 2 years ago 6
best patiot song any had ever sung any wd ever sing
6581omer 2 years ago 2
i m indian but as a indian i always want india and pakistan as friend helping each other then only the world can take example from us. jai india and jai pkistan.............
MegaUjjal 2 years ago 4
i like it , pakistan zindabaad
india zindabad
mohabat70 2 years ago