I have been reading all these arguments counter arguments, & can only ask- What on earth is art deco playing?How can Beethoven possibly be played in a art deco way, whatever it is?! It all seems rather pedantic. The only thing that matters is the force & conviction of the playing, & if it convinces that is all that matters. As my old teacher used to say-Play a wrong note, but play it with conviction, and there is somethingto be said for that..
I studied this very hard at college and believe me one can not play around with these early sonatas. By that i mean all you need is the text and a natural understanding of phrasing, one is reminded of Haydn string qtets. having played many many beethoven sonatas this was by far the most difficult. especially the first mvt and the minuet. i guess this envolves not playing in a romantic style. Good day.
Gilels, Op. 7, Sonata in E flat major - recorded one year before his death:
watch?v=kEfGQ1kBM5o
thanks and best wishes.
classicvinylbiz 1 year ago
I have been reading all these arguments counter arguments, & can only ask- What on earth is art deco playing?How can Beethoven possibly be played in a art deco way, whatever it is?! It all seems rather pedantic. The only thing that matters is the force & conviction of the playing, & if it convinces that is all that matters. As my old teacher used to say-Play a wrong note, but play it with conviction, and there is somethingto be said for that..
mehertoorkey 3 years ago
I studied this very hard at college and believe me one can not play around with these early sonatas. By that i mean all you need is the text and a natural understanding of phrasing, one is reminded of Haydn string qtets. having played many many beethoven sonatas this was by far the most difficult. especially the first mvt and the minuet. i guess this envolves not playing in a romantic style. Good day.
chad410 3 years ago