Dont you just love how they're advertising a phone, and how good the camera is, and they're recording with an extremly high quality extreme HD camera...
@kgbtechno That is because they are unreal .. LOL !! Believe, if these tricks existed, you would see vids of the greatest players in the world doing them first, not Nokia inventing some new tricks for this commercial first.
Juustement...... There are tricks that are possible, like the helicopter and the super tictac...... But the arial pass from 2 to 5 to the 3 bar is not possible...
fuck you Nokia N8 you fucking unprofessional fucking excuses i was pre order 1st week september I been waiting. now i need to wait end of october fuck you Im saw exited and you fucking delay fuck you NOKIA !!!!!!!!!!!!!support me give him thumbs down
Sorry to go on a rage, but finally, they wouldn't have gone through the trouble of getting people to actually to it (which would subject shooting the advert to probably multiple failures and not the intended effect) when they could easily have the money available to get a near real effect using CGI
@Museman05 Why lie? How did you look them up seeing as none of their names are in the description?
( 0.33 - 0.35 ) And also, he didn't flick it up - It is literally NOT THERE. He brings the feet of the man down, supposedly to where the ball is, but doesn't that mean the ball would be underneath? And also, the character is practically vertical straight before he does the trick, which is implying that he went STRAIGHT THROUGH IT o_O.
@jjblok The ball is on the table, He just flicks it up in the air, The vision of the ball is obscured but look even closer, I can assure you it's real, they all are, I looked it up and half of them are pro foosball players.
real or fake dnt care it looks good and has achieved what it set out to achieve cz were all thinking about the damnned nokia advert!! you see what they do to you! theyre smart ;)
@MrKiR0 I don't know what shocks me more. The fact that Nokia thought they could get away with faking this video, or the fact that they really DID get away with faking this video.
They're all acting. I would go absolutely mental if I scored that goal. They should have shown all the times he got it wrong. Then I'd believe it. Defo..... Here me out..... This is DEFINITELY USING SPECIAL EFFECT!!! It's not real..... so there!
@wodewick72 and theres no way a guy who could pull that off would also be the type to look cool and stylish, youve seen these talented gamers, they dont get out muxch! XD
can i just say... They are using state of the art video equipment and still their slow mo is rubbish lol I did better filming at 120fps on my LG Viewty lolol
for every one who is saying oh look it wasnt filmed using the nokia in the actual add you see the guy filming with the nokia so obviously what you were seeing is gonna have to be another camera
It might have been more convincing if they had remembered to add a sound effect for the ball hitting the player's feet.
I can't believe there is any doubt in anyone's mind - the ball is clearly a CG image stuck on the stop afterwards. It doesn't look like it's really there at all.
@DaveWatts1337 no, weekoolrob was right, that is irony. It's an ad to show how cool the camera is and they're showing us quite clearly in this behind the scenes bit that their camera is not good enough and they had to use these proper cameras.
btw, yes a lot of it's fake but that doesn't mean it's not cool. Does anyone leave the cinema and say "that was a load of crap, I've heard they haven't really got 10-foot tall avatars and they just faked it all!"
@westaad You do know that iPhone 4 owners can use adapter to get 720p (HD Ready) video out of the iPhone 4 and it does not eat batter so badly as the N8?
@iTeenmusic Its some sort of propaganda they are trying to say that a tiny pocket phone can record in perfect quality and slow motion whereas instead they are you video recorders which you will use to shoot a film or sumthing.
Why would you make an advert designed to make it look as if it was filmed on the nokia and then make a complimentary video showing us it wasn't/ It might as well have been a brick.
@huggy3ear what difference does it make? none. adverts are supposed to sell things, this is a cool advert - it must be a cool phone, lets all go buy one. not this adverts cool, but the phone must be shit cos they didnt film the advert with it...
I'm not convinced. Even if the ball did come from the top, all the movements could've easily been manipulated. It's way too over the top for me, sorry.
look at the shadow of the ball @ 0:34 there is no light source from that direction plus the ball at 0:06 does not seen to slow or speed up just up and down as if gravity was turned off
@lvs2spooge1 but the angle of the shadow in relation to the ball shows the light source is coming exactly from where the woman is standing not from the corner of the table where the light is standing
if you watch at 0:35, you'll see a phantom ball appear at the near side of the table and go past the red attacker. that's probably what actually happened to the ball he hit. can't believe the editing is that poor......!
They still got us to watch it, and we've re-watched it so many times trying to tell wether it's real or fake, and to argue about the use of pro-cameras. This is a massive advertising success when you think about it.
@Alchodog success by fakery isnt something to be proud of. lame. nokia is lame. yes at least im mentioning their brand for this advert but only in the name of lameness
@Alchodog Well no because we forget all about the brand identity. The video is supposed to advertise the Nokia's camera quality and at the moment i'd rather figure out whether or it is in fact real or not.
for all those people who say where did the ball come from on 0:32, if you slow the video down to slow motion, it comes from the top, someone dropped the ball, its so simple
to be honest i'd rather it be shot on the better quality camera it means we get better viewing and it's not fake this video is proof, gosh stubborn people annoy me !
"If you look really carefully" it was dropped from the top it didn't magically appear since this is "Behind the scenes" videoing to show u complaining whiners how could it have been edited?
So this ad is supposed to promote the use of film with Nokia phones. Yet I think I can see a top of the end camera shooting every detail, close up. They should really think about releasing behind the scenes footage if it is going to flaw their promotion...
@HelpfulThinking Well, it's quite obvious that the N8 wasn't shooting any of this. I don't think anyone is gullible enough to beleive that the ad was filmed with N8s
@Alchodog Well that's what they are trying to put across in the real ad. Someone is filming with their "uber cool nokia phone". False advertising I say.
Does anyone know what kind of handles they use?
BosDeJosduif 2 months ago
crazy skills ,nice one :)
HouseManqche 4 months ago
oh my god, bonzini tables are so.... heavy and slow to play, and they can do such tricks... insane!
mantazv2 4 months ago
what foosball table is that?
giancomogiorlamo 8 months ago
@giancomogiorlamo Bonzini .. I Think
Kahless59 7 months ago
@giancomogiorlamo yeah it is Bonzini
TrueRockNRolla 7 months ago
Dont you just love how they're advertising a phone, and how good the camera is, and they're recording with an extremly high quality extreme HD camera...
richardmuthwill 8 months ago 3
at college is tournament, I need a PARTNER!!!! xD
dino2509991 9 months ago
wait, so this was not recorded as they were saying with a Nokia cell phone...
luedriver 11 months ago
i wonder what would happen if 1 of us could vs that guy
lildragonZA 1 year ago
ok so that camera did not look like the nokia n8
MrCoolxman1 1 year ago 6
Right, so, not filmed with the phone.
atmhso 1 year ago
So... All these shorts are definitively so not filmed with the Nokia phone.
yanndick 1 year ago
EVERYONE IS SO OBVIOUSLY ACTING
nyrbsamoht 1 year ago
ja ja jaaaa even the behind the scenes are fake...nice detail!!!
catarata1 1 year ago
FORGET THE PHONE! I WANT THE FOOSBALL TABLE!
davidwoo9194 1 year ago
who plays that much fool's ball!!! I would rather spend my time learning to play an instrument or something, good shit though...
1985Trip 1 year ago
i thought there was noo way this was real D:!
devyp2theizo 1 year ago
Now THAT is how you integrate a product
TheConcaveman 1 year ago
Sorry but screw the phone, those Fooseball skills are simply un-real!!
kgbtechno 1 year ago
@kgbtechno That is because they are unreal .. LOL !! Believe, if these tricks existed, you would see vids of the greatest players in the world doing them first, not Nokia inventing some new tricks for this commercial first.
foospuppet 1 year ago
@foospuppet These tricks existed. Just the greatest players don't use them. E.g. some of them are out og the rules.
BUT here is "The Helicopter" from the GREATEST: /watch?v=RqZyu1e4oBg
I think it's better than the Nokia's ;)
nemethricsi 1 year ago
@foospuppet
Juustement...... There are tricks that are possible, like the helicopter and the super tictac...... But the arial pass from 2 to 5 to the 3 bar is not possible...
gEnide7 1 year ago
screw nokia N8 I'm getting a new foosball table!
CrazyDelcyTV 1 year ago
yeah WTF the orignal add was all like "look what your film will look like with our sick phone" BUT IT WASN"T FILMED WITH IT
sddbug 1 year ago
so, this has nothing to do with the N8 ?
mathiaskobel 1 year ago
@mathiaskobel pretty much
thatscrazy360 1 year ago
fake and gay
wilsonmcg 1 year ago
and there was me thinking they would record it on the phone to show off its movie capability
Jamesyg0 1 year ago 2
WTF? i thought they capture it with Nokia's Phone, to show us his quality
pcute1313 1 year ago 2
putz...
wsanchezbr 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
29 seconds ago
fuck you Nokia N8 you fucking unprofessional fucking excuses i was pre order 1st week september I been waiting. now i need to wait end of october fuck you Im saw exited and you fucking delay fuck you NOKIA !!!!!!!!!!!!!support me give him thumbs down
kokeytuyo 1 year ago
i am soooo gettin the new...foosball table!
SlowmoTechno 1 year ago 61
woooooooooooooooooow!!!!
zer0iceph 1 year ago
lol i wanted to see one of the chicks do a trick, oh wait that must be CGI lol
renegade1191 1 year ago
Sorry to go on a rage, but finally, they wouldn't have gone through the trouble of getting people to actually to it (which would subject shooting the advert to probably multiple failures and not the intended effect) when they could easily have the money available to get a near real effect using CGI
SmileyDude909 1 year ago
I don't think that the hype's about it being fake and CGI - It's mainly that they had the NERVE to show more CGI in the behind the scenes video?!
But might I add - 0:38 - This dude is the master of devious >_<
SmileyDude909 1 year ago
@Museman05 Why lie? How did you look them up seeing as none of their names are in the description?
( 0.33 - 0.35 ) And also, he didn't flick it up - It is literally NOT THERE. He brings the feet of the man down, supposedly to where the ball is, but doesn't that mean the ball would be underneath? And also, the character is practically vertical straight before he does the trick, which is implying that he went STRAIGHT THROUGH IT o_O.
SmileyDude909 1 year ago
a teacher at my school used to master some of them in a match against some pupils.
that was f'in awesome back in the days.
kidbull 1 year ago
guys its real they may have some computer work to ENHANCE the view but not much seesh does any think logically?(respect to the people who do respect)
ioukkj 1 year ago
faker
trabiosten 1 year ago
Thumbs up if you know someone who thinks this is real.
SmileyDude909 1 year ago 30
@SmileyDude909 this is real u cunt
ohhhreeceybaybee 1 year ago
this was so rigged
56RENTERIA56 1 year ago
They're all real
mars2803 1 year ago
Okay, so three of them were real.. lol still sick though
mrb543 1 year ago
its real?
iheartnizmojoe 1 year ago
I'm still getting the new Iphone.
wodewick72 1 year ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
wow what a real fake.
amir12444 1 year ago
OMG lok carfully the ball comes out of no where watch 33-35 sec carfully the ball just appears out of no where..fake
jjblok 1 year ago 2
@jjblok someone throws it in
mcjoshio 1 year ago
@jjblok someone throws it in, easy mistake though but you see them throw it on in the main video
Boothg333 1 year ago
@jjblok The ball is on the table, He just flicks it up in the air, The vision of the ball is obscured but look even closer, I can assure you it's real, they all are, I looked it up and half of them are pro foosball players.
Museman05 1 year ago
real or fake dnt care it looks good and has achieved what it set out to achieve cz were all thinking about the damnned nokia advert!! you see what they do to you! theyre smart ;)
noodlesnice 1 year ago
Why still use cgi in a behind the scenes video, fuck you nokia
dmack4142 1 year ago 2
Last time I checked it wasn't 1996 and Nokia are still utterly shit.
MattTheOak 1 year ago 2
i think my penis sexploded
alcoholic54321 1 year ago
HOLLY F@%& THEY ACTUALLY DID THE TRICKS THEMSELVES !!! 0_0
MrKiR0 1 year ago
@MrKiR0 I don't know what shocks me more. The fact that Nokia thought they could get away with faking this video, or the fact that they really DID get away with faking this video.
DarthComrade 1 year ago 2
@MrKiR0 no they didn't this behind the scenes still has computer generated balls, it was just made too trick people like you
dmack4142 1 year ago 3
They're all acting. I would go absolutely mental if I scored that goal. They should have shown all the times he got it wrong. Then I'd believe it. Defo..... Here me out..... This is DEFINITELY USING SPECIAL EFFECT!!! It's not real..... so there!
wodewick72 1 year ago
@wodewick72 and theres no way a guy who could pull that off would also be the type to look cool and stylish, youve seen these talented gamers, they dont get out muxch! XD
Tygenja 1 year ago
@Tygenja SO TRUE "!!!
dobsondale 1 year ago
f people say its fake now i will come round there house and snap there neck
browntrout108 1 year ago
@browntrout108
its real - when you comin round to snap my neck
Kevydee1982 1 year ago
@browntrout108 its fake hahah ill be waiting mate
Everthing4Gamers 1 year ago
@browntrout108 stfu fag
dmack4142 1 year ago
soooooo can these people really do those tricks? or is it just fake? cus i thought " behind the scenes " was how they did it...
Cod123Lord 1 year ago 2
Careless about the phone advert it still looked mint
lucasdaniel91 1 year ago
They aren't using a nokia camera because it's shit for christ's sake.
Anyway, 3410 ftw.
masterbakery 1 year ago
takes two hands to hold this phone
ShopSongs 1 year ago
huahuahuahuaauashdahd!!! Vai ser babaca assim lá... Campanha do caralho!
viniciusmaroch 1 year ago
blah blah
bulzbig 1 year ago
can i just say... They are using state of the art video equipment and still their slow mo is rubbish lol I did better filming at 120fps on my LG Viewty lolol
flaxvert 1 year ago
wow... good looking people really do practice that much foosball... I was such a cynic for thinking it was fake.
rwalker811 1 year ago 3
@rwalker811 not good looking people, just people with lots of makeup
CreativeUpload 1 year ago
All they should of done is say "When you buy this phone you get a free COOKIE!!"
I would totaly buy it.
KRCChannel 1 year ago 3
@KRCChannel well, your a total retard, because you can just go to the asda and get a pack of 5 large baked fresh cookies for like 60p...
CreativeUpload 1 year ago
@CreativeUpload Well.. As you can guess I was kind of joking, So whos the retarded one now? Lmao, your telling me where to go buy cookies? LoL...
KRCChannel 1 year ago
you ppl believe anything your eyes see, soo weak!
gamertolover 1 year ago
how do they do the keppy upies
abs0978aa67 1 year ago
those people are really sad
MikeyandSammy 1 year ago
Comment removed
snownation 1 year ago
for every one who is saying oh look it wasnt filmed using the nokia in the actual add you see the guy filming with the nokia so obviously what you were seeing is gonna have to be another camera
fakeaccount663 1 year ago
it is real
scarlow2 1 year ago
lol so the tricks were real after all.
fakeaccount663 1 year ago
@fakeaccount663 no
dmack4142 1 year ago
well dude u just sold foosball
barrowking1 1 year ago 2
nokia camera rules! ???
StickMarsChannel 1 year ago
now was are they prmoting here foosball or a nokia N8.....
all90killers 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheWarmBrothers 1 year ago
It might have been more convincing if they had remembered to add a sound effect for the ball hitting the player's feet.
I can't believe there is any doubt in anyone's mind - the ball is clearly a CG image stuck on the stop afterwards. It doesn't look like it's really there at all.
matafuko 1 year ago
Plus until the trick starts - there isn't even a ball on the table!
matafuko 1 year ago
@DaveWatts1337 no, weekoolrob was right, that is irony. It's an ad to show how cool the camera is and they're showing us quite clearly in this behind the scenes bit that their camera is not good enough and they had to use these proper cameras.
btw, yes a lot of it's fake but that doesn't mean it's not cool. Does anyone leave the cinema and say "that was a load of crap, I've heard they haven't really got 10-foot tall avatars and they just faked it all!"
morleymonsta 1 year ago
This is not a fake honest santa clause told me it wasn't
TheMcotts 1 year ago 4
Not impossible but I would say fake viral.
Why? Because they don't have the time to wait for the player to perfect that on camera. Don't believe me? Go try it yourself.
If you still believe this is real I have a nice magic carpet you might want to buy.
FuManBoobs 1 year ago
They only showed the real ones. The fakes ones aren't shown. The illuminati is clearly behind this all.
umairrrr 1 year ago 4
It's ironic that they're not using the nokia phone's camara...
weekoolrob 1 year ago 187
@weekoolrob
Why would they... it would look awful when watching the advert then.
Sil4s 1 year ago
@weekoolrob ha ha ha soo true!!
alwayshardcore100 1 year ago
@weekoolrob Because the camera quality is poor. Camera phones are not meant to shoot films or commercials. That is why we have HD camcorders for
sagat4 1 year ago
@weekoolrob Its not about the camera but the connection to the tv out
what will you do with it.
N8 is better than Iphone you know
westaad 1 year ago 2
@westaad You do know that iPhone 4 owners can use adapter to get 720p (HD Ready) video out of the iPhone 4 and it does not eat batter so badly as the N8?
TheFri13 1 year ago
this was nominated for 3 oscars
WOWFPS 1 year ago
They only showed the real ones...
DannyboyRFC06 1 year ago
@DannyboyRFC06 no.... i can do most of these
Lineridarz 1 year ago
why arent they recording using the phone????
iTeenmusic 1 year ago 5
@iTeenmusic lol, nice!
oldhornyman 1 year ago
@iTeenmusic Its some sort of propaganda they are trying to say that a tiny pocket phone can record in perfect quality and slow motion whereas instead they are you video recorders which you will use to shoot a film or sumthing.
TheMadBadMan 1 year ago
It's NOT FAKE!!!! :O
Veejayv 1 year ago 2
pure viral
jayc1981 1 year ago
now thats good
MakiD2010 1 year ago
pure talent
thezacstanley 1 year ago
hmm, im no filming expert, but the ball looks blurry compared to the other objects on the camera - so it looks like its been layered...
bronteamywilson 1 year ago
@bronteamywilson
Good point, might just be the speed it's traveling at though.
PROVISM 1 year ago
it's not fake. watch the Behind the Scenes
mawt 1 year ago
Why would you make an advert designed to make it look as if it was filmed on the nokia and then make a complimentary video showing us it wasn't/ It might as well have been a brick.
huggy3ear 1 year ago 64
@huggy3ear Yeah, Dont understand how nokia could make such a big slip up
xDexBoy 1 year ago
@huggy3ear haha so true
NinjaD444 1 year ago
@huggy3ear what difference does it make? none. adverts are supposed to sell things, this is a cool advert - it must be a cool phone, lets all go buy one. not this adverts cool, but the phone must be shit cos they didnt film the advert with it...
JDShortFilms 1 year ago
@huggy3ear lol i doubt anyone is gonna buy that camera now, welldone nokia :0
MrYodahie 1 year ago 2
@huggy3ear It goes about the connection the nokia gets to the TV outline.
westaad 1 year ago
The ball is added with CGI i think. It isnt real
xdipsterx 1 year ago
@xdipsterx
what CGI
pmcginn497 1 year ago
@pmcginn497 computer generated image
owensyy 1 year ago
THIS MAKES ME WANT TO BUY A NOKIA!!!!!!!!!!!
not..... why would table football or whatever make me do that????
daleiloveqian 1 year ago 3
I love the fact they added a magic trick at 0:33 to make a ball just appear... Legendary
fck3dup4l1fe 1 year ago 3
cant believe u ppl have nothing better to do than try and guess if this is real .... which it horribly isnt.
pasty001 1 year ago
Fake! No doubt!
timshanks80 1 year ago
Oh my... unbelievable!
cmariucci 1 year ago
fuck off not possible if i cor do its not possible ahaa
jk
its awesome!!
pudin463 1 year ago
It's all real baby!!!!!! Loving the foosball REAL tricks.lol. x
69Arris 1 year ago
wow its amazing how big the N8 accualy is , the dude needs two arms to carry it
ShopSongs 1 year ago 3
@ShopSongs lolll
007Nandish 1 year ago
I'm not convinced. Even if the ball did come from the top, all the movements could've easily been manipulated. It's way too over the top for me, sorry.
DarthComrade 1 year ago
look at the shadow of the ball @ 0:34 there is no light source from that direction plus the ball at 0:06 does not seen to slow or speed up just up and down as if gravity was turned off
welshkgk 1 year ago
@welshkgk there is a light, lke all studios there r lights everywhere look at 0:06 where there is a light above
lvs2spooge1 1 year ago
@lvs2spooge1 but the angle of the shadow in relation to the ball shows the light source is coming exactly from where the woman is standing not from the corner of the table where the light is standing
welshkgk 1 year ago
@Glitchinema in England it is and some other EU countries
kkkkkkkkkk704 1 year ago
if you watch at 0:35, you'll see a phantom ball appear at the near side of the table and go past the red attacker. that's probably what actually happened to the ball he hit. can't believe the editing is that poor......!
doymon 1 year ago
im gonna buy a nokia now. itll meake me better at foosball
zzzaaa09900 1 year ago 2
They still got us to watch it, and we've re-watched it so many times trying to tell wether it's real or fake, and to argue about the use of pro-cameras. This is a massive advertising success when you think about it.
Alchodog 1 year ago 4
@Alchodog Absolutely!
metalJBC 1 year ago
@Alchodog success by fakery isnt something to be proud of. lame. nokia is lame. yes at least im mentioning their brand for this advert but only in the name of lameness
zzzzzzd 1 year ago
@Alchodog Well no because we forget all about the brand identity. The video is supposed to advertise the Nokia's camera quality and at the moment i'd rather figure out whether or it is in fact real or not.
TheLyinxx 1 year ago
Its got us all watching - so an adwhores dream
cochranes 1 year ago 2
Staged 'woo' and 'yays' and the clapping did it for me. Fake.
richcolour 1 year ago
nice how
dripzkid27 1 year ago
@frigitar someone drops the ball in dumbass
spideyaidan 1 year ago
for all those people who say where did the ball come from on 0:32, if you slow the video down to slow motion, it comes from the top, someone dropped the ball, its so simple
TheFireflyRob 1 year ago 2
this is shit crazy mad!!! lovin it, i 'm gonna buy a nokia just cause i like this ad so much
sorankurdi 1 year ago
@sorankurdi big corps love people like you XD lol
Whoizcasper 1 year ago
@Whoizcasper
and in all fairness i love them
sorankurdi 1 year ago
to be honest i'd rather it be shot on the better quality camera it means we get better viewing and it's not fake this video is proof, gosh stubborn people annoy me !
BIGBROTHERfan24 1 year ago
I love it how they try and convince us that it is real
MitchKid1991 1 year ago
"If you look really carefully" it was dropped from the top it didn't magically appear since this is "Behind the scenes" videoing to show u complaining whiners how could it have been edited?
aidanlaw95 1 year ago
omg were does the the ball come from at 0:30
coolalex766 1 year ago
@coolalex766 the ball was under the guys feet, then he flicks it up
J4M13F0X 1 year ago
were the f does the ball come from on 0:30 ?
xSnOwxBoixTyLeR 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@xSnOwxBoixTyLeR the ball was under the guys feet, then he flicks it up
J4M13F0X 1 year ago
so wait they did the tricks for real?
it looks a little farfetched
10Dante4 1 year ago
So this ad is supposed to promote the use of film with Nokia phones. Yet I think I can see a top of the end camera shooting every detail, close up. They should really think about releasing behind the scenes footage if it is going to flaw their promotion...
HelpfulThinking 1 year ago
@HelpfulThinking Well, it's quite obvious that the N8 wasn't shooting any of this. I don't think anyone is gullible enough to beleive that the ad was filmed with N8s
Alchodog 1 year ago
@Alchodog Well that's what they are trying to put across in the real ad. Someone is filming with their "uber cool nokia phone". False advertising I say.
HelpfulThinking 1 year ago
fk and der was me thinking dis shit was actually real thanks 4 the heads up Frigtar
urmum212 1 year ago
London has so much talent...
Wow123231 1 year ago
that must of been alot of training
FatalDotP 1 year ago
hax
tomek123kotek 1 year ago
@tomek123kotek Hahahahha!!! Creased
Wolfensteinpwner 1 year ago
@tomek123kotek Hahahahaha!! Creased!
Wolfensteinpwner 1 year ago
maestros!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
59bombin 1 year ago
@takSlasher
i cnt believe u re so stupid...so it mean that u re cheating all the people.
im not talking about N8, im sure is a good phone...im talking about foosball fantasies...
start up ur brain before to answer....
max1511 1 year ago
sorprendido.
cokemon72 1 year ago