張智霖 - 天梯 (Live 高清HD字幕版本) (原唱: C AllStar)

[akokcZ]

LIVE 唱成咁 仲有得DISLIKE?

不過覺得佢件衫樣衰左少少x_x

[viecasfong01]

！h把聲好迷人

[TCHWAI]

我個人好鐘意chilam 但係我都係覺得原唱好聽D

其實好少歌係翻唱好聽過原唱

但係chilam唱live都可以咁好聽已經很好

[kakaka014]

DISLIKE個20個應該係c fuck star d垃圾死忠

明明好聽n倍都可以話冇原唱咁好聽

一睇就知你地唔識音樂啦！

[crazyshingcrazy]

@kakaka014

人地dislike 關你Q事咩

[ftorres121]

@crazyshingcrazy 人地留comment關你q事咩

[MrNwmoon]

@kakaka014 講野唔好講到咁盡好wo!

我唔係C AllStar fan

亦都無話chilam唱得唔好聽。

但劍峰同佢唱既style都唔同,大家都係唱好歌,點解硬係要踩­到人地好似地底泥先安樂?

[kakaka014]

@MrNwmoon 認真我覺得釘峰唱功真係ok,但係把聲堅係難聽,老牛聲咁,但係­d人仲話佢把聲特別好聽我先好奇

[kakaka014]

@MrNwmoon 係王祖藍果type,有唱功,但係把聲唔好聽+感情流於表面

[kakaka014]

@MrNwmoon 釗鋒把聲同林欣彤其實差唔多,只一過mag鼻音嚴重d,但係唔知­點解咁多人dislike阿mag（我唔係佢fans,只係理性­討論）

[helenhoiling]

我都係鐘意C Allstar's version多啲囉。

[MrKiddolulu]

好細聲

[kh9385]

初哥哥>.<

[hauyuklingkatefb]

好有Danny Chan 既影子...搞咩呀???

[chiueugene]

He did a great job!! Much better than C-Star as he's a much more experienced singer, if he only he had sang the original key, the emotions would be even stronger! I am quite sure it's within his vocal range

[yumoko23]

電死我啦><

[loleev]

看了便想起偶像陳百強,當然他比他堅強和正面

[loleev]

看了便想起偶像彳

[ronaldxdriver]

好正ar!! CHI lam!!!!

[canruth]

@[080:0]

[the03630363]

oh my god, it is a horrible hair cut!

[crazyjcris1]

有無人覺得佢咬字好似有D怪

好似個口拉唔開咁?

係咪打左針sosad

[rexpakyue]

@crazyjcris1

係

Vowel做得唔好



[lock577]

原過隻歌係比佢唱先一定仲勁@@!

[steventube]

咁解嗰首CHOK會得𤟒架？

[candycandywang]

好正lo！



[wonggreg1]

可能c all star太後生唱唔好個feel啫,唔好咁快話人地唱功差好冇?­

[0422kathy]

chilam唱得好聽好多... 有feel好多...

[kotlaer43]

點解佢就係紅唔起...真不該

我心中第一位既chilam...好唔抵

唱歌又有感情

不過佢有時唱live會有d出事(唔係呢首歌,我講有時)

[genegeneize]

他唱的不错，



[Agikmny0821]

天梯原唱是勝在曲跟詞,唱不是太突出,樓下說得對,扯到那麼高音­不代表就會好聽些,都要你控制得到才行。何況還要是LIVE,天­王巨星唱LIVE有時都要降KEY去保證穩定演出啊。

結論:這版本好聽些,勝在懂得如何去演繹

[mingming2005096]

降低左key. 比原唱易唱.

但都十分好聽^^

[Joseph06238]

真的好聽過原唱。

我覺得原唱唔夠氣，假音位過渡得唔smooth，喘氣位好明顯。

初哥哥個version真的避免了那些問題。

[andy1002]

唏噓的低音,更使人沉醉感動=]

[azngalen]

chi lam sounds way better then cstar

[lincolnl16]

其實呢十幾年佢係咪日日用防腐劑沖涼

[MrKaiSenG]

好好聽;gd

[iloveyellowwww]

呢D就係有經歷既歌手同新人冇咩經歷唱出感受感情既唔同了

[117fuckyou]

我覺得CHILAM嘅版本略勝原唱一籌 :)

[mk950210]

chilam降key了？

[BBoxCM]

@mk950210

降左1度^^

[FungYellow]

正!! Chi Lam is so attractive ~

[rebelfiendk]

chilam真係唱得好有首歌入面個種意景~我竟然連續聽左十次­><''

[TheZerocreator]

C- ALLSTAR's ACAPELLA MAKES IT BETTER.. BUT THIS VERSION IS STILL VERY GOOD ^_^

[HIBYEMILK]

正A____A好有FEELLLLLLLLLLLLLLL!!

[iz11223366]

好聽好多

[SunnyCarboy]

wow...好正,真係好正,冇聽過比chilam唱得更加好嘅­版本,比原唱更有味道!!!

[MrKaiSenG]

好正;..呀



[aesopq0311]

隻歌原本是他的

[LOVEPRINCE1225]

屌你,聽歌只係聽key架?佢唱得好聽同有感情咪得囉!高key D就等於好聽D同勁D架啦咩!

[hktony]

吊，首歌原本係佢架

[YOong519]

@hktony 點解話原本係佢既:O??

[rhodrhiyg]

一個show 歌手會盡量用自己最comfortable 嘅方法同key 唱，如果佢就咁歌應該會好好多，因為真音係最激動嘅so 多有d同首歌格格不入

[happyskyscraper]

都幾好聽的。

[rukawashuha]

他在唱一個動人的故事，但是一個和他無關的事。若是他自己的事應­該不只是這個程度的感情表現。剛剛聽過張敬軒的“春秋”過來，這­樣覺得。

[woodytong1994]

有冇知chilam低左幾多個key?

[KIIO1L]

@woodytong1994 應該剛剛好低8度的版本吧

[LEECY112]

@KIIO1L 8度?!

唔好玩啦朋友

[finishwu]

超磁性演繹! 霖爆!

[crazytsui]

佢個頭真係好鬼型



[fungbeartaddy123]

雖然Chilam唱得好聽,但咁溫柔地演繹天梯,我覺得唔係最適­合既~

[HoshiStar32]

唱得好溫柔 :D

different style :)

[Erica19900310]

每一位演繹過這首歌的歌手，

各有自己的獨特風格，唱法和支持者。

誰也没有被比下去。

我個人最愛是釗峰@C AllStar唱的版本~=]

[CHANCHUNKEI]

估唔到...唱得咁好聽....|

+1

[beyond14141]

如首歌本身係張生原唱, 我覺得唔會hit 得起 , 唔係話佢唱得差, 而係唔會有驚喜

[Kelvinc1993]

@beyond14141 lol 咁我又5覺得C AllStar唱會好有驚喜wor~

[mag123007]

這首歌好適合他聲線!

[petercow2000]

如果升番原key唱,加d 假音就好了....而家成首用真音感覺差dd咁

[beytang3]

我個次唱K.聽到佢唱.

真係sorry

好聽過callstar好多.

[ahjess768]

@beytang3 No Way CAllStar's 梁釗峰 sang with so much more emotion!

[eddieqp]

好聽過C AllStar 一百萬倍 ~

[succeenany]

两个版本我都喜欢

[succeenany]

NB



[ranwongzone]

这个版本比原唱版本好听得多了！

[isaactsui]

可惜唱錯少少歌詞....係不用忌諱-,-

[Tearsofutterjoy]

很难相信这是LIVE

Go Chilam! 

[tsewingbe]

why is there dislike!!!???

wrong concept!--

[shanepangkh]

初哥哥~~~~

[angelpuss725]

正!! (Y)

他唱出了另一風味~

他懂這故事因為他也擁有一段幸福的愛情故事!

張生加油呀!!

[alextang1030]

@angelpuss725

我都覺得佢唱得有味道好多~

畢竟對愛情既感受更深~

[KasugaiSeika]

＄１７５

[seriousjan]

好聽 :)

[bettyxslong]

It's too soon~I like this version, though

[fungbeartaddy123]

原來近鏡睇Chilam,睇到佢唱到好感動同好好聽,this live so good~!

[zigen9]

1st!!!! Upload more of this concert!!!!! I LIKE IT!!!!