I would like there to be a CD of all his random songs that are not part of his shows: Donnie Darko, Angry (Feet), and this included. I would certainly buy that!
There is a part of me that rebels against Tim in a beanie. If i can't see his hair i feel like it's an imposter.
Either way, beanie or no beanie he's still a fucking genius and i still dig on him. One of the few musicians around who can make me laugh hysterically and cry too.
@Natalicious132 It's a book by Orwell. It's about a totalitarian dystopia where everything is monitored (among other things but that's pretty much the point here).
Just learned of this guy, seen two or three of the youtube videos of him. How the heck have I not heard of this guy before? He got a laugh outta me, and I'm jaded nowadays.
@pigfarts100 They all got it right. Kinda. One of the teams said Google Maps instead of Street View. The show is somewhere on Youtube and this bit is usually around part 4
I don't think George Orwell would really think he's here in a fiction... he had enough information when he wrote 1984 to know what to expect from the future of this civilisation. We're already more than halfway into 1984...
@Sy3m We've surpassed it, they've just done it slightly more subtley than Orwell predicted and therefore the majority of humanity swallow it all as 'inevitable', 'acceptable' or even 'preferable'!
FYI, the 1984 reference is by the author George Orwell who wrote the book "1984" about the what if's of the spread of communism back before WW2 began. read it, its worth your time.
.... who doesn't know that? it's on like ever high school sylibus ever. I was given the option of reading it for 3 different classes and it was recomended reading for like 2 more. who doesn't know about that novel?
@Tamashi88 This *is* Youtube, and judging by the quality of comments on the site in general, I don't think it's that brash an assumption that someone hasn't heard of Orwell's 1984.
@frilloz4 No. Nineteen Eighty-Four is not about the what-if's of the spread of communism. Did you seriously read the book thinking that the system of government Oceania had in place was communism?
@CullTheLivingFlower i'm not talking about in context to the story of the book, i'm talking in relative to the second world war and then the vietnam and then the korean and then the "war on terror". Look at the big picture not just the story of the book. Orwell was talking about the world around us not oceania itself.
@WillReddish Or when other comments intentionally insult top commets who unintentionally insulted themselves cause of jealousness on earlier top comments in hope to become the new top comment?
You obviously haven't seen his shows or seen him live... the musical side is just like Victoria Wood; its not the funniest part of the act, although it is his strong point as he's so talented, its a part that makes him unique, its impressive and still makes people laugh, his stand-up is freaking hilarious. Oh and by the way, when million of people laugh.... that makes him a comedian, plus its comedian*, not comidian :)
@ButterflyRedrum I don't either actually :/ He's not like, hysterical laugh funny.. He's a good muscisian with smart lyrics if I get a say in this.. I respect him as a sing and song writer, not a comidian.
Ok the youtube argument is getting a bit out of hand maybe you should just stop or take it to your channels please. Tim has just written a funny song no need to be so angry.
@12grubs it's about Google Street View. it's like Google Maps but you can place a man on the map, and you can see the street from any angle with pictures taken on the street by people (and of course, in a picture you might find yourself in one of the circumstances from the song)
I think it's a little overstated. street view is actually useful since I know what a location will look like before I get there.
Also it isn't a live feed and all the people/faces/number plates have been edited out. If you walk around naked in public places you have a good chance of being captured in a shops CCTV feed or something like that. Orwellian? meh...
Google street view is an open public service and it isn't a live feed.
1984 had private CCTV everywhere to spy on people.
@RELIGIONmustDIE I think you've in turn overstated your response. The point Tim is making when comparing 1984 and GSV is that, metaphorically, "Green Apple=Apple=Red Apple". Whilst implemented in a manner more respectful, the idea is dangerous and being able to map out some place before you go there is simply insignificant as a justification compared to the fact that we are being watched. Spying is spying afterall. It is only a matter of time before a live feed is proposed.
@Omnilegence I think you sound paranoid. Google street view is not a live feed and will never be that way.
The London cctv network is more along the lines of what you are talking about. It's a live feed that the government own and run.
It sounds like you don't know the difference between having live streaming footage from a nation-wide camera network and just running through taking one low resolution snapshot with people and cars blurred out.
@RELIGIONmustDIE Come now, let's not resort to precipitous judgements. Firstly I did start my comment by clearly stating that I was arguing Tim's point, not my own. Secondly you need to free your mind of this ridiculous notion that because something is not a live feed doesn't mean it isn't a threat to one's privacy. Personally I care not about privacy, I am not in fact a very ethical being in general, but having satellites staring at you, easily capable of being upgraded to...
@Omnilegence a high resolution live feed is perfectly acceptable as an example of needlessly perverse observation. I don't think simply stating that GSV will never go live stands up as a valid point, why won't it go live? Do you know for certain that CIA or MI5 or some other such organisation have not already used it live? I'm not saying it is already this way, I can't even know for certain if it ever will go that way. You cannot deny it easily could however. I understand what CCTV is.
@Omnilegence The more you write, the more it is clear you have no understanding of technology. Google is a private business entity. They have no interest in developing a live nation-wide camera system. How could they justify the cost? Governments might do it.
Satellites - even the latest military satellites have major issues with atmospheric distortion with the best weather conditions in low earth orbit. Live satellite feeds for the general public? I hope you are joking. You watch too much tv.
@RELIGIONmustDIE I don't even watch TV... This is getting boring. You're clearly more of a troll than you like to think. 1. I didn't mention live feeds for general public. In fact I specifically mentioned the adaptation of this technology for governmental use.
@Omnilegence How will GSV go live? You don't even understand how it works. It's not a live system. It's a car with a gps system that takes a picture every x meters and stores it. Why would Google want it to be a live system? GSV works just fine the way it is right now.
If you are worried about live nation-wide cctv surveillance i'd be looking at government.. Things like the 'patriot act' etc.. That is where I'd focus my attention. Why is it called patriot act when it's about taking away freedom?
@RELIGIONmustDIE Ok, first off i'm tired of playing polite with you. I understand utterly how GSV operates, it's a matter of 9 fucking cameras on a fucking vehicle. It's a set-up of digital technology that YOU clearly fail to comprehend as, being technology of a digital type, it can be overriden with sophisticated software. Easily. All one would need to do is adapt the photographs so that specific hardware would not 'see' blotted out faces...
@RELIGIONmustDIE ...but rather would see crystal clear imagery of peoples faces, the rate at which photographs are taken could be altered, etc etc. Please feel free to stop presuming some sort of expertise in this area, you're clearly a presumptous fellow. Lastly, why do you keep bringing up CCTV? I don't support CCTV, I don't care about freedom and I don't even live in America. The Patriot Act means very little to me.
@Omnilegence Crystal clear images of faces, just like you see when you walk down the street. More pictures, MORE STATIONARY PICTURES. Street View doesn't give a 24/7 view of the world, it's a one-moment take, even if you take more pictures, it'll stil be a one-moment, there aren't cameras at which you can for example see someone walking out of an adult store live. That's all he was saying, get a grip.
@serpenttao Oh my god fuck off you retarded, sub-human, obtuse motherfucker. I am not arguing that GSV is at the present time anything worse than a nonessential utility. I am not even arguing that invasion of privacy is wrong. My point is with the principle of technology that could be developed or used to invade privacy, and being satellite based could be done without our knowing. Notice the 'could's. I do not see why I am being made out to be some paranoid moron, I don't even care about GSV.
@serpenttao I never intended to swamp the whole comments section. My participants insist on misinterpreting my comments. I am simply defending that which I said. Tell me why are YOU making comments? Did you not expect me to respond in the manner which I do?
We can carry on or stop, doesn't bother me in the slightest. Also I would like to point out that what I said was "I don't even care about GSV", not "I don't care about half-wits attempting to get away with throwing bullshit my way".
@Omnilegence You started about it being dangerous and that live feed will be published. I'm just pointing out that's not going to happen. Calling me half-wit or retarded because of that says more about you than it does about me.
2) I google search "Google street view live feed" and get *h*t*t*p*colon*//searchengineland*dot*com/google-testing-youtube-video-stream-in-street-view-39234.
3) You forgot to answer my question!, the one asking why you are commenting at all. Looking at your comments I can't see any useful or even new input to the conversation. You summed it up perfectly yourself you're "I mean i'm just saying", just saying and nothing else.
@Omnilegence You probably have no idea of the kind of infrastructure needed to build a system with that many cameras all networked. I think everyone would know about it if something like that existed. Since you are in the UK you really should know better. You already have an Orwellian system similar to that so close to home and its not called GSV. So you really should understand the difference.
@RELIGIONmustDIE So: Tim Minchin is overstating the threat to privacy of GSV because the convenience of seeing some place at street level in advance to actually going there outweighs the potential for development of this system by any party with sufficient finances to observe any given street at any given time? I believe Tim was overstating the threat to privacy but surely you can see that your argument is weak? You seem to believe that because it would be difficult it won't be done.
Ge is regering to the book "1984" writen by george orwell back in 1949. the book is a peice of fiction based on The Oceanian province of Airstrip One. A world of perpetual war, pervasive government surveillance, and incessant public mind control.
The controversial internet service, was google street view. launched back in 2009, it Allowed any person to surf the net and look at anybody's house, with a full 360 dregree. Since then the street view is not updated often, fixing the problem
I love his jeans,
happynessish 1 week ago
Oh! Oh! I know!
The answer was Google Street View!
MooChooAdoo 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
please click my channel and listen to "the fence" and "i'm in a cage" by tim minchin
2 very good songs
NothinButTheMusic 1 week ago
I didnt watch the program did anybody actually get it XD
darkstarmonkey22 2 weeks ago
No no no buttplugs
GregoMorgan 2 weeks ago
Wossy did not seem impressed ,haha
FutureAbe 2 weeks ago
Maybe if you didn't put the answer to the question in the title then I might have been a bit more intrigued.
dedokta 2 weeks ago
@dedokta What? The song isn't funny or entertaining when you know? Seriously, this is from 2009 and how else would you search for this?
TimLake 2 days ago
1:51 Jonathan Ross = So not falling for that shit again.
pigfarts100 3 weeks ago 3
Listen to it in 1/2 speed. Sounds more like a rap, lol.
BL4D3RUNN3R0M3N 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos 2
Comment removed
BL4D3RUNN3R0M3N 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
I'm in love with Tim Minchin, but I think I'm even more in love with Gangsta Tim
TheLadyGodfrey 1 month ago in playlist More videos from timminchin 19
shane dawson at 0:44
azki94 1 month ago 2
The joke made after this is amazing
JImmy carr:
ross wants your answer to this
Wossy:
It's Qvc for burglars, more commonly know as google maps
jhlvko 1 month ago 3
I see Wossy thinking "s**t, this is going to be about my wife"....
200400986 1 month ago 7
also some germans (ok, it's probably just me, i don't know anyone who doesn't answer who the heck is tim minchin?!) love you and your music :D
rubiksist 1 month ago
I would like there to be a CD of all his random songs that are not part of his shows: Donnie Darko, Angry (Feet), and this included. I would certainly buy that!
SamauraiRippeR 1 month ago 2
@SamauraiRippeR Angry (Feet) is on the So Live DVD. he did use it in a show
Varden99 1 month ago
Funny that Russell Brand is there when he looks so much like Tim Minchin.
BL4D3RUNN3R0M3N 1 month ago
AHHH he has a MAS top xD
I saw this on tv but didnt actually notice :L
kazarific15994 1 month ago
There is a part of me that rebels against Tim in a beanie. If i can't see his hair i feel like it's an imposter.
Either way, beanie or no beanie he's still a fucking genius and i still dig on him. One of the few musicians around who can make me laugh hysterically and cry too.
Sporky86 1 month ago 4
i want zebra print jeans :'(
VICTORIAvampireMETAL 1 month ago
I'd like to know if they got it...
duryduty 2 months ago 2
@duryduty I Know!!!!
TMJBtv 1 month ago in playlist More videos from timminchin
@TMJBtv are you agreeing with me? or do you know if they got it or not?
duryduty 1 month ago
@duryduty lol, ive spoken english all my life yet i still manage to fail at it! Im agreeing with ya, i wish i knew. lol.
TMJBtv 1 month ago
This is probably the best rap song in the world. I guess there wasn't much competition.
unholyjebus 2 months ago 4
Simon Pegg with eye make-up at 00:45
SporeGalaEdit 2 months ago 2
@SporeGalaEdit thats not simon pegg, fucking idiot.
hatakihitaru 2 months ago
@hatakihitaru Or maybe he/she meant that Tim looked like Simon Pegg with eye make-up there... no need to be rude.
Spacemushroomsify 1 month ago 3
@hatakihitaru I like how you call people "fucking idiot" whilst being completely unable to understand what they've written......
DibbzTheLoner 1 month ago 2
@hatakihitaru You're the fucking idiot if you misinterpreted what he wrote.
Gosgosgosu 1 month ago
this year's big fat quiz of the year was worse than the last couple of years, and I think the lack of Tim this year contributed
Yuzling 2 months ago
Comment removed
c0rse 2 months ago
sure.
nicha112 2 months ago
So catchy!
UniQueLyEviL 2 months ago
so what's the answer?
MorrisonEnterprise 2 months ago
@MorrisonEnterprise google earth/street view
greatfelixo 2 months ago
@greatfelixo thank you.. I must have forgotten to read the title of the video before I clicked on it
MorrisonEnterprise 2 months ago
(Extra funny if you're a muse fan and hear matt's voice explain 1984 in the comments "the book you know?")
PiratenPrinsesje 2 months ago
Sorry if this is totally naive but what is Tim referring to that happened in 1984? :/
I <3 Tim ^_^
Natalicious132 2 months ago
@Natalicious132 The book "1984" by George Orwell.
DormantMoon 2 months ago
@Natalicious132 It's a book by Orwell. It's about a totalitarian dystopia where everything is monitored (among other things but that's pretty much the point here).
Wuggynaut 2 months ago 3
@Natalicious132 a book called "1984". its what big brother is based on, with the idea of people being constantly monitored by a higher power
ryanneedhamthe7nth 2 months ago 4
Just learned of this guy, seen two or three of the youtube videos of him. How the heck have I not heard of this guy before? He got a laugh outta me, and I'm jaded nowadays.
WhackjobAPB 2 months ago 6
Sound?
antipusrises 2 months ago
now I'm curious as to who got the question right. :D
pigfarts100 2 months ago 3
@pigfarts100 They all got it right. Kinda. One of the teams said Google Maps instead of Street View. The show is somewhere on Youtube and this bit is usually around part 4
CodeMonkeyGurl 2 months ago
@CodeMonkeyGurl :D thnkz
pigfarts100 2 months ago
Johnathan Ross at 1:49
Still cant forget Tim's song for him on his show.
BunkzT255 3 months ago 5
so he's talking about google maps, right?
uiruu 3 months ago
@uiruu Google Maps: Street View
TechXMarine 3 months ago
I love Tim minchin, ha ha but plugs
nibblesgaming 3 months ago 2
hey! both top comments are equal with 139 likes right now!
CrazyandHyper 3 months ago
oh my god i just noticed the little speed changer!!!
shippodna 3 months ago 7
Ooo a veiw of Tim's bum in tight trousers <3
mangojuise 3 months ago 8
Best goat impression ever. <3 0:49
sarahandthecat 4 months ago 55
I'm gonna listen close and work this out on my bass xD
Cameestewee 4 months ago
Tim as a rapper looks alot like S Dezzy/Shane Dawson
crimsonvipor 4 months ago 8
@crimsonvipor hhaahaha that's what i was thinking :')
LaRstockholmsara 3 months ago
Tim Minchin marry me XD -3
SofJae 4 months ago
@IArtGod hes married with a kid...
ryanneedhamthe7nth 4 months ago
@ryanneedhamthe7nth two kids actually
AliceRoseLambert 2 months ago
fully rotatable 360 degrees...sounds good to me ;)
xlucyhollandx 4 months ago
I find the top comment ironic :/
VideosOfJordan 4 months ago in playlist More videos from timminchin
It's Wossy! He has 4 poofs and 1 piano... Too bad it's not a "Penta-Poofed-Up-Piano-Posse..." :/
ImUnattractive 4 months ago
@ImUnattractive It's 'penta-poofter-piano-posse' :)
KingJoeyJunior 4 months ago
@ImUnattractive But, that doesn't sound as right. xD
ImUnattractive 4 months ago
when he has that hat on he looks like Shane Dawson
1KevinsFamousChili1 4 months ago
I don't think George Orwell would really think he's here in a fiction... he had enough information when he wrote 1984 to know what to expect from the future of this civilisation. We're already more than halfway into 1984...
Sy3m 4 months ago 2
@Sy3m We've surpassed it, they've just done it slightly more subtley than Orwell predicted and therefore the majority of humanity swallow it all as 'inevitable', 'acceptable' or even 'preferable'!
ljmkernow 4 months ago
This is doubleplushilarious!
trollolololololo 4 months ago
Tim's been nominated for the ARIA Award!! Thumbs up for him winning! :)
bekcs 4 months ago 213
Thumbs up for Georgy Orwell :D
ElRihno 4 months ago 11
No.
Yes, buttplugs.
lemoniceluxe 4 months ago
Yeah Yeah Yeah!
gemma5632 4 months ago 2
I have been watching this so many times and laugh every time xD
bekcs 5 months ago 3
i fucking love claudia the jewess
ILoveHenryJames 5 months ago
fuck i wish i had his voice <3
wardzer 5 months ago 2
Baaaah!
anonihamster 5 months ago
so..who answered right?
bored2deathish 5 months ago
Nice makeup job, though.
hawkwynd2000 5 months ago
So fucking funny!
mrkaimarsh 5 months ago
guys a friggin genious
razrX 5 months ago
i think tim would be a brilliant gangster ! *yeah yeah*
Tonythefsih 5 months ago
FYI, the 1984 reference is by the author George Orwell who wrote the book "1984" about the what if's of the spread of communism back before WW2 began. read it, its worth your time.
frilloz4 5 months ago
@frilloz4 don't want to be pedantic but it was written in 1949- four years after the end of WW2
GriddledSardines 5 months ago
@GriddledSardines my apologies, you are correct
frilloz4 5 months ago
@frilloz4
.... who doesn't know that? it's on like ever high school sylibus ever. I was given the option of reading it for 3 different classes and it was recomended reading for like 2 more. who doesn't know about that novel?
Tamashi88 5 months ago
@Tamashi88 This *is* Youtube, and judging by the quality of comments on the site in general, I don't think it's that brash an assumption that someone hasn't heard of Orwell's 1984.
ssrc 5 months ago
@ssrc if they live in a box.... but if they do i doubt they'd be watching Tim Minchin.
Tamashi88 5 months ago
@ssrc Agreed, so far as maybe you are the thought police or judgemental - say, hey whats the diff?
saffonia 5 months ago
@frilloz4 No. Nineteen Eighty-Four is not about the what-if's of the spread of communism. Did you seriously read the book thinking that the system of government Oceania had in place was communism?
CullTheLivingFlower 5 months ago
@CullTheLivingFlower i'm not talking about in context to the story of the book, i'm talking in relative to the second world war and then the vietnam and then the korean and then the "war on terror". Look at the big picture not just the story of the book. Orwell was talking about the world around us not oceania itself.
frilloz4 5 months ago
I actually didn't know what the song was ... even though i clicked "Google Street View by Tim Minchin!"
Killerzac 5 months ago
Love it when one of the top comments is unintentionally insulting himself
WillReddish 5 months ago 9
@WillReddish I had a feeling that'd happen. >.>
SuperMegaAss 5 months ago
@WillReddish Or when other comments intentionally insult top commets who unintentionally insulted themselves cause of jealousness on earlier top comments in hope to become the new top comment?
Warzulg 5 months ago 2
@Warzulg It's a never ending chain, isn't it
WillReddish 4 months ago
i hate when the 2 top comments are the same
Guilfarpt 5 months ago
Music is just fantastic. WOw cant stop listening to it :)
Borwneyes 5 months ago
Real creative top comments, guys.
SuperMegaAss 5 months ago 237
@SuperMegaAss -.-'
SuperMegaAss 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@SuperMegaAss Shutup, faggot.
IArtGod 5 months ago
@IArtGod He's a faggot? Awesome, 3 more and we can have five. I'll bring the pianos
MikeEmery9 5 months ago 500
@MikeEmery9 Just want to say, I bloody love you for that comeback. You are my hero.
RandomObsessiveGirl 3 months ago in playlist More videos from timminchin 9
@MikeEmery9 still got to out Jamie Cullum
MegaScriber 3 months ago 3
@MikeEmery9 then we can have a penta-poofter piano posse
stephenrodgers1000 3 months ago 4
@MikeEmery9 FUCK YES. BEST COMMENT EVER. 1000 internet points to you, sir! (:
MaliceInMyFantasies 2 months ago 5
@MikeEmery9 You win the internet sir
thisismynamehahaha 2 months ago
@MikeEmery9 You absolute legend!! :D
xXMaDEllXx 2 months ago
@IArtGod This is you insulting me over the internet and expecting me to take you seriously.
SuperMegaAss 5 months ago 3
1984well... clever portmanteau Mr Minchin!
I wish I could have seen if they got the answer!
paulec252 6 months ago
@paulec252 they did
PinkDickful 5 months ago
Humor aside, Tim is really talented and his songs are actually very good.
SuperMegaAss 6 months ago 7
@SuperMegaAss Agreed with you
zuhonenn 6 months ago
@SuperMegaAss I've actually never even seen his comedy..find it really bad, but his music..0mg its addictive
TheSevenStrikes 5 months ago
@TheSevenStrikes I love both. His humour is really witty and smart, and I love that.
SuperMegaAss 5 months ago
@EmoAbiTheOnlyOne Why ist that weird? It's a quiz in the beginning of 2010 about various things that happened in the past year ;-)
Snookerfairy 6 months ago
In Fully Searchable Three Hundred And Sixty Degrees!
ConfusedHippos 6 months ago 2
@tobsson
You obviously haven't seen his shows or seen him live... the musical side is just like Victoria Wood; its not the funniest part of the act, although it is his strong point as he's so talented, its a part that makes him unique, its impressive and still makes people laugh, his stand-up is freaking hilarious. Oh and by the way, when million of people laugh.... that makes him a comedian, plus its comedian*, not comidian :)
LittleBennyTyler 6 months ago 2
YOU ARE TRUE GENIOUS TIM!!!
Kimbarockon 6 months ago 2
no butt plugz :>
ridinhood666 6 months ago
I don't think he's that funny.
ButterflyRedrum 6 months ago
@ButterflyRedrum I don't either actually :/ He's not like, hysterical laugh funny.. He's a good muscisian with smart lyrics if I get a say in this.. I respect him as a sing and song writer, not a comidian.
Tobsson 6 months ago
No, No Butt Plug!!
awesomeismeable 6 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
0:18 for repeat if you like this as much as I do.
TheBadAuntie 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Remember when you could watch a video without having to sit through a commercial?
Remember when music videos were uploaded by users and not VEVO
Remember when all the info was to the right of the video?
Remember you could rate a video 1-5 stars?
Remember the famous yellow subscribe button?
Remember when the users controlled the site and now corporations?
WE MISS THE OLD YOUTUBE!
Post this in every video and lets start a youtube revolution!
Thumbs up to keep at the top of the page!
iTomHere 6 months ago
Anybody else get Tim's t-shirt "MAS" reference? ;D
skunkinjunk 6 months ago 4
@skunkinjunk I've been trying to think what it is, but no luck.... Enlighten me.
Pacpiano 6 months ago
@Pacpiano Mildly Amused Smirk - His fan website, which he is pretty involved in tbf, has that instead of "LOL" :)
skunkinjunk 6 months ago
@Pacpiano youtube i recon
djlinehan 6 months ago
@Pacpiano google street view..
djlinehan 6 months ago
Ok the youtube argument is getting a bit out of hand maybe you should just stop or take it to your channels please. Tim has just written a funny song no need to be so angry.
carladraw 6 months ago
I love his jeans, if anyone knows where i can get a pair like them can you pleas respond
MissBlinkette 6 months ago
is this avril lavigne singing?
jjjeykey 6 months ago
if i just understand what he is singing i think than i think its a great song
12grubs 6 months ago
@12grubs it's about Google Street View. it's like Google Maps but you can place a man on the map, and you can see the street from any angle with pictures taken on the street by people (and of course, in a picture you might find yourself in one of the circumstances from the song)
AORNOfficial 6 months ago
I'm going to add my comment in here just to break up the argument.....
eagleeye9011 6 months ago
Such a catchy tune! Hahaha
Kirstin091 7 months ago
I think it's a little overstated. street view is actually useful since I know what a location will look like before I get there.
Also it isn't a live feed and all the people/faces/number plates have been edited out. If you walk around naked in public places you have a good chance of being captured in a shops CCTV feed or something like that. Orwellian? meh...
Google street view is an open public service and it isn't a live feed.
1984 had private CCTV everywhere to spy on people.
Apple=Broccoli?
RELIGIONmustDIE 7 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE I think you've in turn overstated your response. The point Tim is making when comparing 1984 and GSV is that, metaphorically, "Green Apple=Apple=Red Apple". Whilst implemented in a manner more respectful, the idea is dangerous and being able to map out some place before you go there is simply insignificant as a justification compared to the fact that we are being watched. Spying is spying afterall. It is only a matter of time before a live feed is proposed.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence I think you sound paranoid. Google street view is not a live feed and will never be that way.
The London cctv network is more along the lines of what you are talking about. It's a live feed that the government own and run.
It sounds like you don't know the difference between having live streaming footage from a nation-wide camera network and just running through taking one low resolution snapshot with people and cars blurred out.
RELIGIONmustDIE 6 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE Come now, let's not resort to precipitous judgements. Firstly I did start my comment by clearly stating that I was arguing Tim's point, not my own. Secondly you need to free your mind of this ridiculous notion that because something is not a live feed doesn't mean it isn't a threat to one's privacy. Personally I care not about privacy, I am not in fact a very ethical being in general, but having satellites staring at you, easily capable of being upgraded to...
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence a high resolution live feed is perfectly acceptable as an example of needlessly perverse observation. I don't think simply stating that GSV will never go live stands up as a valid point, why won't it go live? Do you know for certain that CIA or MI5 or some other such organisation have not already used it live? I'm not saying it is already this way, I can't even know for certain if it ever will go that way. You cannot deny it easily could however. I understand what CCTV is.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence The more you write, the more it is clear you have no understanding of technology. Google is a private business entity. They have no interest in developing a live nation-wide camera system. How could they justify the cost? Governments might do it.
Satellites - even the latest military satellites have major issues with atmospheric distortion with the best weather conditions in low earth orbit. Live satellite feeds for the general public? I hope you are joking. You watch too much tv.
RELIGIONmustDIE 6 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE I don't even watch TV... This is getting boring. You're clearly more of a troll than you like to think. 1. I didn't mention live feeds for general public. In fact I specifically mentioned the adaptation of this technology for governmental use.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence How will GSV go live? You don't even understand how it works. It's not a live system. It's a car with a gps system that takes a picture every x meters and stores it. Why would Google want it to be a live system? GSV works just fine the way it is right now.
If you are worried about live nation-wide cctv surveillance i'd be looking at government.. Things like the 'patriot act' etc.. That is where I'd focus my attention. Why is it called patriot act when it's about taking away freedom?
RELIGIONmustDIE 6 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE Ok, first off i'm tired of playing polite with you. I understand utterly how GSV operates, it's a matter of 9 fucking cameras on a fucking vehicle. It's a set-up of digital technology that YOU clearly fail to comprehend as, being technology of a digital type, it can be overriden with sophisticated software. Easily. All one would need to do is adapt the photographs so that specific hardware would not 'see' blotted out faces...
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE ...but rather would see crystal clear imagery of peoples faces, the rate at which photographs are taken could be altered, etc etc. Please feel free to stop presuming some sort of expertise in this area, you're clearly a presumptous fellow. Lastly, why do you keep bringing up CCTV? I don't support CCTV, I don't care about freedom and I don't even live in America. The Patriot Act means very little to me.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence Crystal clear images of faces, just like you see when you walk down the street. More pictures, MORE STATIONARY PICTURES. Street View doesn't give a 24/7 view of the world, it's a one-moment take, even if you take more pictures, it'll stil be a one-moment, there aren't cameras at which you can for example see someone walking out of an adult store live. That's all he was saying, get a grip.
serpenttao 6 months ago
@serpenttao Oh my god fuck off you retarded, sub-human, obtuse motherfucker. I am not arguing that GSV is at the present time anything worse than a nonessential utility. I am not even arguing that invasion of privacy is wrong. My point is with the principle of technology that could be developed or used to invade privacy, and being satellite based could be done without our knowing. Notice the 'could's. I do not see why I am being made out to be some paranoid moron, I don't even care about GSV.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence I'm glad you ignored the "Get a grip" part. For someone who doesn't care, you made a shitload of replies. I mean I'm just saying.
serpenttao 6 months ago
@serpenttao I never intended to swamp the whole comments section. My participants insist on misinterpreting my comments. I am simply defending that which I said. Tell me why are YOU making comments? Did you not expect me to respond in the manner which I do?
We can carry on or stop, doesn't bother me in the slightest. Also I would like to point out that what I said was "I don't even care about GSV", not "I don't care about half-wits attempting to get away with throwing bullshit my way".
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence You started about it being dangerous and that live feed will be published. I'm just pointing out that's not going to happen. Calling me half-wit or retarded because of that says more about you than it does about me.
serpenttao 6 months ago
@serpenttao Look:
1) 'Published' is not what I said, 'proposed' is.
2) I google search "Google street view live feed" and get *h*t*t*p*colon*//searchengineland*dot*com/google-testing-youtube-video-stream-in-street-view-39234.
3) You forgot to answer my question!, the one asking why you are commenting at all. Looking at your comments I can't see any useful or even new input to the conversation. You summed it up perfectly yourself you're "I mean i'm just saying", just saying and nothing else.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
@Omnilegence You probably have no idea of the kind of infrastructure needed to build a system with that many cameras all networked. I think everyone would know about it if something like that existed. Since you are in the UK you really should know better. You already have an Orwellian system similar to that so close to home and its not called GSV. So you really should understand the difference.
Just get a clue... ok!
RELIGIONmustDIE 6 months ago
@RELIGIONmustDIE So: Tim Minchin is overstating the threat to privacy of GSV because the convenience of seeing some place at street level in advance to actually going there outweighs the potential for development of this system by any party with sufficient finances to observe any given street at any given time? I believe Tim was overstating the threat to privacy but surely you can see that your argument is weak? You seem to believe that because it would be difficult it won't be done.
Omnilegence 6 months ago
my moment 00:39- 00:43
arround2 7 months ago
Comment removed
arround2 7 months ago
Ge is regering to the book "1984" writen by george orwell back in 1949. the book is a peice of fiction based on The Oceanian province of Airstrip One. A world of perpetual war, pervasive government surveillance, and incessant public mind control.
The controversial internet service, was google street view. launched back in 2009, it Allowed any person to surf the net and look at anybody's house, with a full 360 dregree. Since then the street view is not updated often, fixing the problem
fabool 7 months ago 2
what happened in 1984
xXguitardude9Xx 7 months ago
which was the controversial internet service ?
tafxkz 7 months ago
@tafxkz google streetview
WILDEXPLORERBOYS 7 months ago
@WILDEXPLORERBOYS
yup yup i realized
tafxkz 7 months ago
he looks like lindsey lohan.
NomOnRamen 7 months ago
Tbh tim minchin in a beanie is the best Eminem impression you'll ever see lol.. !!!
DaRkGhOsTGaReTh 7 months ago
I love the look on John Ross's face at the end, it's all like: "That's the guy that wants to do my wife. Grr."
Nextmastermind 7 months ago
great song
Armydude655 7 months ago