Added: 1 year ago
From: shum65
Views: 77,023
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (161)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • These 2 are as different as de rice an peas

  • @whitebootsify They sure are so different, its great to see how they each

    approach this classic song :))

  • lol shum i hate this mix . Love your vids tho!

  • @MissTeenPregnancy Ha-ha cool my friend, sorry you didn't enjoy

    this mix, but really glad you enjoyed my video, many thanx for that :))

  • the mixing of 3 icons when you take into account Roy Harper's beautiful words & tune

  • miss bush and ms fraser compliment each other like a milk first

    earl grey and a triangular cut cucumber sandwich. frightfully lovely.

  • Oh my God! :-)

  • @lucillaPax69 Hi there, lol :)

  • geniale mengeling van kate + elizabeth_________________Engl­and my lionheart rules

  • @uitjebol Hi there my friend, great to hear from you :)

    I to love "Oh England My Lionheart" Ive done a video for that also :)

  • Shum65 you've outdone yerself. To mix the unmixable Liz with the unmixable Kate (i love them both ever so dearly) to make a truly wonderful mix is outrageous. Congratulations!

  • @SmokeBen586 Hi there my friend,wow Im so pleased you enjoyed this

    mixing of two icons, it was fun attempting this mix and the video also :)

    Many thanks for your kind comments, much appreciated !!!

    Hope your having a great week my friend :-))

  • babushka could better play violin in the background

  • @trevorsss1 Lol love Babushka :))

  • the voices of God just entered my youtube account!!!

  • @autodafeh242 Hi there, glad you enjoyed this mix my friend :)

  • @shum65 Yes thanks i realy did .....never knew Kate Bush was singing this song?!.....But yeah i have to agree...Liz is much more better.....D'ont get me wrong because i own a lot off albums off Kate Bush...But...Liz sounds more.....classic even she is younger than Kate......Loved It and thanks for the upload (always nice when you upload the Cocteau Twins or This Mortal Coil on the channel!!!......My favo of This Mortal Coil is now Tarantula...Love that double 4AD album......

  • @autodafeh242 I love the Liz & This Mortal Coil version to, its so

    classy, I like "Tarantula" also, glad you enjoyed this mix with both

    Liz & Kate, it was just waiting to happen, good to hear from you my friend :)

  • @shum65 Thanks.....keep up the good work!!! 

  • One version is amazing, the other is Kate Bush.

  • @scrunts666 Cheers for your comments my friend, they are two

    very different versions with different production qualities, I love Liz and

    This Mortal Coils Version by far the best. :-))

  • this is great, such a different take on the roy harper original which i urge people to check out.

  • @bradshawvincent Your so right,Roy was an amazing singer-song writer,

    Its always essential to check out the original of any song, my fave has

    got to be Liz Fraser with This Mortal Coil, goosebump delights :)

  • I thought this was a This Mortal Coil track - I remember buying that album when it came out back in the vinyl days and nearly wore out this track and song to the siren - but I had no idea this was a cover too. Think it's time to look at the original. Well done uncovering a Kate Bush version too - It'd be interesting to hear it all the way through even though it can't top Liz...

  • @TheHH1000 Hi there, I too many years ago believed it was a TMC song,

    and had no idea until years later it was the amazing Roy Harper composition,

    loved his and Kate and Peters versions, but like you I love Liz's version :))

  • This is kind of interesting, but Liz Fraser's version is infinitely better, and Kate Bush suffers hugely from the comparison, to the point that I just want to turn this off and listen to just the TMC version.Also, the video imagery is way inappropriate for the song, at least during Kate Bush's portion of it.Nice effort, though.Is Kate Bush covering this, or were both these artists using some other source, like a poem?I don't recall.The original TMC album this came from is still totally classic.

  • @deliusism1  "Another Day" was written by Roy Harper and appeared on his album "Flat, Baroque and Berserk".

  • @deliusism1 i feel that the roy harper version suffers hugely

    in comparison also.

  • In paradise...

    :d*

  • wow..this is amazing dear friend! I honestly haven't heard Kate Bush sing this..or maybe I did but was so young back then?I was so lucky that my 1st gig was Kate Bush's very 1st live concert appearance at Liverpool Empire..think it was 79?I was 12yrs old+KB's only live tour! This is wonderful. 2 of my favourite women..lol.luv Sophie;)

  • @MsMagicalCat Hi there Sophie, wow you saw Kate in concert !!

    Thats something to treasure a life-time :) so glad you enjoyed this

    mixing of the two icons, great to hear from you my friend XxX ;-[))

  • ayzees, add-ons and and-ons

  • @posypity Hi there :)

  • Gargle some more Roy ...

    Make an Old Man Happy

  • @Jimysalad :-)

  • hahahahah

  • TWO GRATE DAMES OF MUSIC !!!

    ALL MY LOVE TO KATE AND ELIZABETH.

  • @3144541 Hi there, well said my friend !!! ;))

  • @3144541 what a love triangle that would be :)

  • :P I have to say, this mash up a little hard around the edges, but a thumbs up for doing it with two of my fav's. I wish Kate had done this song for never for ever it would have fit just right.

  • @vizionthing Hi there its true this is deffo a bit hard around the edges my friend,

    pity I couldnt have blended them better, but thats a good point, this would have

    made a cracking track on her Never Forever album, look out for her new single

    released on the 11th Oct called "Wild Man" taken from her new album..!!! :D

  • @vizionthing SORRY all i can here is Kate singing and garble in between

  • @vizionthing WHAT TOTAL RUBBISH

  • Forget Madonna, forget Lady Gag Gag. THESE are the ladies who should have got ALL the attention.

  • elisabeth better than kate bush

  • @djrubus Hi there, I love both ladies, but I do enjoy Elizabeth's studio

    version the best, Kate's was a live version with Peter Gabriel, so the

    quality of the sound is totally different, great to hear from you my friend :)

  • @shum65 >Hi mate, thanks for your reply. I prefer Liz Frazer cos I adore Cocteau Twins

  • @djrubus Hi there, me too my friend, the Cocteau Twins are Iconic :)

  • Good effort, but neither are a patch on Roy Harper's version

  • @seanus4508 Hi there, guess we all have our personal fave, its certainly Roy's baby,

    My personal fave is Liz Fraser's with This Mortal Coil,included here,good to hear from

    you my friend, :D

  • @seanus4508 Hi there, guess we all have our personal fave, its certainly Roy's baby,

    My personal fave is Liz Fraser's with This Mortal Coil,included here,good to hear from

    you my friend, :D

  • Sorry for my frikking hard words.

    I just want to be honest.

  • @hoeksteen69 No probs my friend, its always good to her everyone's opinions.  :)

  • Comment removed

  • @hoeksteen69 Hi there, sorry you didnt enjoy this mix, thanks for your comments my friend.

  • Well I've never heard of Liz Fraser,but Kate is timeless,love her.

  • @Kattymieoww Hi there, Kate sure is timeless, Liz fronted the Scottish indie band

    called the Cocteau Twins during the 80z/90z, you may know her for This Mortal Coils

    version of "Song To The Siren" good to her from you my friend. :)

  • @shum65 ok , well maybe it´s a bad idea to compair the same song when the Kate Bush one was not recorded on studio, anyway i like a lot KB too (running up that hill for me is extraordinary) no need to be compaired...no hard feelings... :)

  • @ideografica No probs my friend, its really great to hear from ya, I'm a huge admirer to

    of both Kate and Liz, loved "Running Up That Hill" and so many more by her, thanks again

    for your comments, nice to chat with you ideografica :)

  • Sorry Kate this is not the best performance for you...terrible, sounds like a joke singing near the amazing Liz Fraser...Maybe some other songs, but this one...definitively Don´t.

  • @ideografica Hi there, I guess it doesn't help with Kate's version being taken

    from a live Christmas special, whilst Liz's is the studio version, so it did make a big

    difference sound quality-wise when they were merged together,I love Liz's TMC version,

    Kate's was from a duet with Peter Gabriel from a special back in 1979,

    Thanks for your comments my friend. :)

  • Comment removed

  • @omgbetch Hi there, sorry you didnt enjoy this mix my friend, no probs :)

  • Liz Fraser = Cocteau Twins

  • @Octopossible Liz = The Cocteau Twins for sure my friend..!! :D

  • This didn't do it for me. Not as individuals but together - it wasn't aurally complimentary.

    Prob anyone I asked would immediately know who Kate is but few would have a clue who liz Fra-a-a-a-aser is. I could hardly hear Liz's vocals in this mix. I'm quite a fan of singing pure notes in extension rather than pushing them all over the shop - this week anyway (sorry Maria, Whitney and - well almost every1 on X Factor)

    I love Roy's song and it's so hard to beat the performance on Kates TV show

  • @Ayrkashka Ure right my friend, individually both are awesome, but it didnt quite work

    mixing these together, but it was fun trying, and I'm pleased with the video..

  • two great voices

  • @listservice Your so right my friend, such icons...love-em...!!!

  • wow! this is really amazing!

  • @ewmiku1 Hi there ewmiku1, I,m so pleased you enjoyed this mix,

    its great to hear fro you, have a lovely weekend my friend.....!!!!

  • what an amazing song <3 them both Kate and Elizabeth who would of thought?

  • @calvinhigginsjr Hi there, two icons for sure my friend, one classic song.

    Glad you enjoyed it calvinhigginsjr, have a fab weekend... :)

  • I don't know who Liz is, but I love Kate and this wonderful song:) Nice job!

  • @Sharmilka Hi there, glad you enjoyed this moving song, Kate is amazing, Liz was

    the lead singer with the Cocteau Twins, and has sang as guest vocalist on many tracks,

    Check out her version of this song with This Mortal Coil, and "Song To The Siren"

    Good to hear from you my friend.... :))

  • I like Kate and all...but when you put ANYBODY next to Liz, they suddenly pale in comparison.

  • @chrisjackson1 Hi there my friend, its good to hear from you, I think with Kate's

    part being live and Liz's taken from the studio recording, it does make the sound

    quality between the two vocals stand out slightly, but they are such icons...

    Have a fab weekend Chris... :))

  • ahh music to my ears....literally.haha

  • @treasurehiding9 Hi there my friend, I,m so pleased you enjoyed this mix,

    it was real fun bringing two such original artists together......

    Have a great weekend treasurehiding9...!!! :)

  • @PavlovsDog306 Hi There glad you enjoyed this mix my friend, have you listened to the original,

    it was a duet with Kate and Peter Gabriel, back in 1979, check it out..

    Many thanks for you kind comments Pavlovs, have a great weekend...!!!! :)

  • The original was by Roy Harper - off the album Flat Baroque and Berserk [1970] 

  • @Railtonleejohnson Hi There my friend, your totally right of course it was originally

    by Roy Harper many thanks for that, much appreciated, good to hear from you...!! :)

  • I like it.

  • @Cassyan Yippee, many thanks my friend, glad you enjoyed it to,

    it was fun doing this video to two such iconic singers....

  • This is horrible. This is not a juxtaposition, it is a clumsy ear shredding clash of wildly different... everything . If you found it difficult then that should have told you that you were doing something wrong.

  • @Gl0wBuzz3r Hi their my friend, sorry you didnt enjoy my mix of these

    two amazing artist, but many thanks for your comments, its really good

    to hear your thoughts, enjoy the rest of your Sunday G10wBuzz3r.....!!!!

  • @shum65

    I was being too harsh. Keep working on it and I look forward to the next version!

  • @Gl0wBuzz3r Cheers my friend, many thanks for your comments..!!

  • This is horrible. This is not a juxtaposition, it is a clumsy ear shredding clash of wildly different... everything . If you found it difficult then that should have told you that you were doing something wrong.

  • This is horrible. This is not a juxtaposition, it is an ear shredding clash of wildly different vocal delivery. And clumsy too.

  • Kate and Peter Gabriel's duet never came out officially.

  • @MsBkirk Hi their, thats right, its such a pity it was never a single.

    Its an amazing song, good to hear from you MsBkirk.......!!!

  • It's a bit scattered, isn't it?

  • @TroyaE117 Hi Their, it was difficult to put together such different

    sounding versions of the song, especially as Kate already was

    dueting with Peter, and their version was at a slower pace to

    Elizabeths, but hopefully it work pretty well,

    Many thanks for your comments my friend.....

  • Kate or Liz, hmm, difficult to compare the two, so difficult..

  • @INITIALSJE Your so right my friend, 2 icons for sure........!!!

  • @shum65 Back when I was like 17 or 18 yrs old, I heard a song on the radio that had Liz Fraser, Kate Bush & Sinead O' Connor and thought it was about one the coolest collaborations I'd ever heard. I want to say it was called "Peace Together" for some kind of protest for war or something, but my memory is a little fuzzy at this point. I've been looking for that single, but I've never been able to find it anywhere.

  • @INITIALSJE Your right m8, their was an album out of different

    collaborations, I think it was called "Peace Together" featuring

    various artists, I have a video I did with the Cocteaus and Sinead

    called "Be Still" taken from the album, check it out mate....alas Kate

    didnt sing on that one with them though, cheers my friend...!!!

  • @shum65 Hey, thanks. I will check it out. I don't know why I had it stuck in my head that Kate Bush was in that song. I've had thousands of ideas for collaborative albums for years and years. Some of them came to fruition and many more than didn't or never will, sadly. Talk to you later, bra!!

  • @INITIALSJE No problem, hope you enjoy the track.....!!!

    Talk soon mate.....

  • You haven't lost your touch making those vids! YET it does send shivers as Elizabeth Fraser takes over, after all!!!

    PS: It managed and enabled adobe so I can watch the vids at home now.

    Great Post, Shum, (as usual)!

  • You haven't lost your touch making those vids! YET it does send shivers as Elizabeth Fraser takes over, after all!!!

    PS: It managed and enabled adobe so I can watch the vids at home now.

    Great Post, Shum, (as usual)!

  • @salsollo Hi Rich, its so good that you can watch and comment

    on my videos now my friend, your very kind about them all....

    I,m glad you too get those shivers on hearing Lizs voice...

    Its such a moving and touching song, have you seen my other

    video for this song by "This Mortal Coil" hope you like it too..

    Always so good hearing from you Rich, best wishes to you.....!!!!!

  • As much as I love Kate Bush, Liz Fraser's version is better 'cause I've been a long time Cocteau Twins fan since I was 5 and I'm 19 now :)

  • @Mr1991ladarius Hi my friend, My fave version is by Liz also,

    it sends shivers all over, a truly moving and emotional version.

    Not forgetting Kate and Peters amazing live version to....

    Good to hear from you my friend.....

  • DIRE! hahahaha!!! Gold,shum,gold!

  • @seasofabsinthe ha-ha..Cheers my friend...I,m glad you enjoyed it....

    your gold 2..Have a fab weekend ....!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @seasofabsinthe Hi my friend, I,m really glad you enjoyed this mix of two such

    amazing women, I very much appreciate you kind comments about my camera-

    work...it was a real pleasure to do this video my friend....

    I hadnt noticed the picture icon has vanished too, I like seeing those also..

    I dont like the changes myself, I think theyre DIRE....!!

    Great hearing from you mate, have a fab day.....!!!

  • Comment removed

  • Shum65- I am VERY sorry if you think my last comment in any way disrespected your efforts.. I enjoyed it very much, you did a wonderful job! I had thought this was something 'they' released that I didn't know about... It was only afterward that I realized it is something you put together!!!!

  • @FirstLandingOnMedusa Ha-ha, no problem my friend, You were most polite

    I understand what you mean, it would have been heavenly if it had been for real..

    with both the artist actually dueting wow indeed..

    I,m pleased you enjoyed my video also, your very kind, its really good to hear from you my friend.....!!!

  • Kate and Elizabeth.. wow.. how amazing can it get? Would love to hear their voices actually mingled... too late now, i guess.. unless there's a mix-board mage out there who can make it happen... How incredible it would be to see each perform the other's repertoire in her own way... But let's not forget the instrumentalists! =D

  • @FirstLandingOnMedusa Hi their, Thats just what I often wondered, how fab it would

    be hearing these two icons singing together, you never know, theyre both still busy

    recording, Kates in the studio right now working on new material, and Liz is always

    working on projects too...maybe one day my friend..fingers crossed..!!!

  • freaking awesome even though it ends up in different keys and all but you could just treat it as continuous key changes.. awesome idea and great job. I almost feel sorry for those that never got to experiance This Mortal Coil when it came out on their album. Very rare stuff indeed. I feel like I could just die now and everything would be ok. (ha) ~Bluebell

  • Many Thanx my friend, I,m so pleased you

    enjoyed this blending of two icons...

    It was a real buzz doing this mix, I often had thought what would it have been like

    if both Liz and Kate had dueted....

    It was a big risk, but well worth the effort..

    Really great to hear from ya my friend...

    Love your comments....

    Best Wishes to ya jamesgroome...!!!!

  • Great job on the mix Dave,this would have took a fair bit of your time to put together.I appreciate the time and effort by you to create it.

    5 well deserved stars my friend..

  • Hi young John...your very kind mate...

    It took the best part of two days all in all...

    Its nice to be appreciated Mr J.....you too

    take a lot a time and effort with all your top

    video uploads my friend.....!!!!

    Many thanx for your stars.....

    Hope your not having any more troubles

    with those fake warnings...so cruel...

    Good hearing from ya youngster....

    Have a fab Weekend.....!!!

  • Isn't it Liz Fraser... Kate Bush & Peter Gabriel?

  • Hi mate, yeah thats right, I used Liz to sing

    were Peter sang with his duet with Kate

    on this track, in an experiment to put the

    two icons singing together...

    Does that make sense,or have I totally now confused ya..ha-ha...!!!

  • Well since I still realise it is called "editing" I'd say no, you have not confused me at all.

  • Cheers mate, I'm always confused..ha-ha

  • I think there is clearly a very good side to you that you can explore and build on.

    With that in mind... screw confusion. Like anything else, it happens for a reason. No big deal.

  • Cheers my friend....you talk a lot of sense

    Have a fab weekend....!!!

  • You too, dear. In fact had tons of fun in Amsterdam.

  • Sounds cool all that fun in Amsterdam..!!!

  • Every now and again, is not too bad.

  • @LunaSeaSane Hi their...Yeah, its everything in moderation, except chocolate...

    and whisky,and music...I,d better stop their..ha-ha..!!

    Happy weekend my friend....

  • Happy Weekend, Shum.

  • @LunaSeaSane Thanks my friend. Hope your having a great Monday too.....

  • Cheers my friend, your so right, both are

    Magical,and certainly siren-like....and they

    definitely sooth the soul...!!

    Thanx dear Tom, its great hearing from

    ya, I,m really pleased you liked this mix...

    Best wishes to ya..he-he...!!

  • Awe...brilliant comments martinekkes....!!!

    I,m really pleased you enjoyed this mix....

    I wasn't sure if it would work...

    Thanx so much dear friend....!!!

    Hugzzz to ya xxxx

  • Can we buy or download this beautiful version anywhere?

  • Is this available anywhere either to buy or download?

  • Hi my friend, not this mix as I just put this

    version together for my video, but you can

    Download Liz and Kates seperate version

    on beemp3....

    Kate is dueting with Peter Gabriel on her

    original live version....

    I hope thats helpful my friend....!!!

    I,m pleased you enjoyed it....Thanx again..

  • Juat AMAZING~ Thanks Dave! <3 Starr

  • Hi My little Starr....lovely comments indeed

    I,m glad you enjoyed this mix my friend..!!

    Cheers for your kind stars, many thanx...

    Your a starr...he-he....!!

  • The transitions are quite surprising, but i think you managed to keep the overall mood...

    TMC's still my favorite. Eery, otherworldly.

  • Cheers my friend, it was difficult to merge

    to two very different versions together,

    Kate's was a live version,and originally a

    duet with Peter Gabriel, whilst Liz's truly

    heavenly version was with This Mortal Coil

    Liz's version is my fave also....

    Great comments Whalefin1, Thanx....!!!

  • Quelque chose de beau, je n'ai pas de mots pour exprimer son admiration à vous !!!

  • Hi their, its good hearing from you, i hope

    you enjoyed this mix, of 2 truly awesome

    vocalists my friend...

    Many thanks for your comments....!!!!

  • I'm in my sister's house, eating rice in the back garden, and hearing this = Paradise!

    :D

    Thanks a lot, you did it again!!

  • Thanx my friend, I,m so glad your enjoying

    this mix, it was fun to do...

    Hope that rice was good..ha-ha..!!

    Much appreciate your fab comments mate

  • Brilliant work as usual, Shum. I'm going to show off my ignorance here. I didn't know Kate Bush had sung this one, too. This makes me want to know more about the subject matter of the song.

  • Cheers my friend,  Yeah, Kate did this live

    version with peter Gabriel on her Chrimbo

    special back in 1979.the song was written

    by Roy Harper, check it out too....

    thanx for your ace comments my friend.!!

  • You pulled it off, Dave! What a treat to hear both women singing this great song. The images of Kate and Liz are beautiful, too!

  • Hi Dear Bobby..your very kind my friend...

    I always wondered what it would be like,

    hearing these two icons singing together,

    Its the next best thing...

    Cheers buddy...!!!

  • Excellent work!!!!!!

    Two magical women:)))

    5!

  • one word.....AMAZING!!

    U did it again!!

  • Cheers dear friend...your very kind indeed

    I,m so glad you liked this mix,

    Thanx for your lovely comments mate..!!!

    Your Amazing too.....

  • Liz and Kate! WOW!

  • Hi my friend...glad you enjoyed this mixing

    of Liz and Kate, it was great fun to do....

    I agree with you about them both" WOW.!!"

  • five stars for daring.

    five stars for Liz.

    five stars for kate.

    five stars for Shum.

  • Wow my ghostlybuddy...your a STAR 2....!!!

    Many Thanx for all those stars,...I,m really

    pleased you liked this mix of two icons...

    Five stars for ghostsonatasong......!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more