This is wrong. The "explanation" doesn't explain why there is a bulge in the land, not just the ocean, on the side of the earth opposite the moon. The correct explantion is found in George Gamow's book "Gravity," chapter 6. The earth and the moon both orbit a common center of gravity. The earth is rigid; different parts of the earth move at different speeds around this center. The different speeds cause the earth to deform; hence the bulges. Ditto with the oceans.
I have a simple question, it is supposed that moon attracts all water around the earth, so it's clear to me the side of water next to moon goes away from earth to moon but water on the sides and on the opposite side must be attracted too (a bit less due to distance) so, why is there TWO tides (one on the moon side and one on the opposite one)? the fact earth is also attracted by moon does not explain that because earth is attracted lesser than water and so the ide on opposite side must be small
As I noted in a previous Comment, the explanation in this video of the origin of the two tidal "bulges" on opposite sides of the Earth is incorrect. I have therefore posted a link to a website which clarifies the processes causing ocean tides. The explanation on the website uses a series of animated diagrams. This link is available in the Recent Activity section of my YouTube Channel page. This page can be accessed by clicking on my Username below.
This is an imaginative presentation. Unfortunately, the explanation of the origin of the two tidal "bulges" on opposite sides of the Earth is incorrect. They are caused by centrifugal forces due to revolution in the Earth-Moon system, as well as by Lunar gravitation.
I used this for my 6th grade class a couple weeks ago. I followed up with a discussion and whiteboard illustration. I asked several students to share their own experiences with tides. On a test today, one person had no clue how the moon affected the ocean. She remembered the cookie in the video, but not a word that was spoken in the video - or in my talk !! Well, I HAD shown the video just before lunch. Timing is everything.
I agree that the tides has something to do with the gravitational pull or where the sun and the moon is, while the earth rotates around the axis, it also tilts and that's why the sun can be at different places unlike the moon that actually goes around earth
Thank for inviting me. A cubic foot of salt water weight approximaletely 68 pounds. An ocean wave 3 feet high by 6 feet at the base by 100 feet long weight about 61,200 pounds.
Multiply that by all of the waves, thats a tremendous force of lunar pull!
A person weighing 180 pounds disperses 2.65 cubic feet of water. Shouln't we all be floating on air.? Want to know about my theory on gravity and what i have named the X-gravity field factor?
Perfect for me! But could you tell what that thing is called that only occurs once every 18.61 years? It sounds really interesting.
@rezchikov1 I learned at school that the rthe reason it's on the opposite side is because the moon is pulling the earth toward it, and it's pulling the water on that side toward it, and on the other side, it's leaving it behind. Awesome right?
What kind of ending is that? One that makes you want to find out more, I'd say. The moons orbit 'precesses' - it moves position slightly each month, in part because it is at an angle to the earth's orbit. The point where it crosses the line followed by the sun moves slightly, only returning to the same place every 18.6 years. There is an explanation in Wikipedia - look at 'lunar standstill'. The standstill itself is an interesting thing, seen by the ancients who built stone circles to mark it.
Your explanation of the second bulge on the far side of the earth doesn't seem to make sense. Are you not oversimplifying to the point of being incorrect?
erm.. the moon moves the water closest to and the earth? even tho the moon is the smaller of the two and what keeps the far water behind ?? space drag?
Great explanation. I was a bit confused before this video. I have a final in 54 minutes that is going to ask questions about tides. I feel more confident now, after watching this film. Thank you so much for this explanation!
HI, with permission from the video creator, you should download REAL PLAYER, it has a feature you can save YouTube videos to your hard drive - then you can play them back at school!!
thank you , I wish you had gone on a bit more about it , as I am teaching my children about high tides and low tides . bravo , you did a dandy job . I appreciate your video it was a great addition to our homeschool science class.
As long as we're talking about the moon, here's something.
There's a mountain of evidence that the Apollo moon missions were faked. I posted a partial summary of it on a science forum. Google "The Naked Scientists". In the "New Theories" section of the forum there's a thread entitled "Did We Land on the Moon?". The summary is on page 15. It's the 7th post from the top.
People who still think they went to the moon simply haven't seen the hoax evidence yet.
Excellent lucid explanation. Helped me with my science project.
The "let's be quirky and use everyday objects to explain science" approach usually doesn't work for anyone but Bill Nye, but in this video the model was very effective.
nobody posted anything? Well...I now know how tides work, thanks to you meester and your delicious earth cookie I hope you ate:) I couldnt have explained it better myself
very nice xplaination THX
MrZsozsy1977 6 days ago
some sweet info here
alexasmithy 1 week ago
Very enjoyable thank you
ericajjful 2 weeks ago
thus a display of wreckless drunk driving planets on the loose...LOL
clnmyjts 2 weeks ago
Think you can do better then try to explain it yourself means --> Kiss my arse.
0engima0 1 month ago
i get it now
lovetoskifreestyle 1 month ago
now i want that cookie
littleboy707 1 month ago
6 people work for Bill O'rielly.
H3xx99 1 month ago
so nice, very practical illustration. thanks so much and God bless
59ctcod 2 months ago
better than my physics book
UtUbEAdDiCcT13 2 months ago
so wait... the sea is outside of the earth? ;P
PolarGenre 2 months ago
Thanks man! Clarified it!
JohnsLazy 3 months ago
much better to understand using food than those scientific words but what cycle of the sun and moon was he talking about?
irinkalovaxoxo36 3 months ago
makes sense!!
castrolars 3 months ago
someone send this to bill o'reilly
Haradin32 3 months ago
Could someone send this to Bill O'Reilly.
victoriaj272 3 months ago
VERY INFORMATIVE........THNX
AwaisButtSony 3 months ago
How the curvature of space and time is making the tides?
apspacking 3 months ago
why do we have 2 high tides instead of just 1?
jdis101 4 months ago
This is wrong. The "explanation" doesn't explain why there is a bulge in the land, not just the ocean, on the side of the earth opposite the moon. The correct explantion is found in George Gamow's book "Gravity," chapter 6. The earth and the moon both orbit a common center of gravity. The earth is rigid; different parts of the earth move at different speeds around this center. The different speeds cause the earth to deform; hence the bulges. Ditto with the oceans.
jimtrueblue99 4 months ago in playlist Science
SOMEBODY GET ME A GLASS OF MILK FOR MY EARTH!
vaiddoh 4 months ago
Very Good! Thank You!
zman572 4 months ago
nice explanation was that.............
1988Nilesh 4 months ago
I have a simple question, it is supposed that moon attracts all water around the earth, so it's clear to me the side of water next to moon goes away from earth to moon but water on the sides and on the opposite side must be attracted too (a bit less due to distance) so, why is there TWO tides (one on the moon side and one on the opposite one)? the fact earth is also attracted by moon does not explain that because earth is attracted lesser than water and so the ide on opposite side must be small
viditibi 4 months ago
Wow. That was really simple and really helpful.
SchrodingersCake 4 months ago
More people should do these IDIOTIC explanations
They're much better
Crdiggle 4 months ago
steak with pineapple? wtf!?
dfjhgq3pwi45yv30q85 6 months ago
Thank you very much for this lesson; I never understood this until now.
jasoneric 6 months ago
Tide goes in, stain comes out. Can't explain that.
Denshuu 6 months ago
You can't explain the tides you can't explain that
robopirinja 6 months ago
I think you made yourself a breakfast. You even got the sandwich.
iuld 6 months ago
I wish this guy had a tv show again.
leshark 6 months ago
and that's how earthquakes also works.
artemeeb 6 months ago
I got it!
scientifico 6 months ago
Jesus causes the tides!
TheMrgoku1985 6 months ago
Are you infering a gravity shadow protects the water on the oppsite side of the lunar tide?
m230042 6 months ago
Awesome. You're easier than anything I've ever heard. I'm a mariner. From now on, I'm showing my colleagues this vid for training.
morania 7 months ago
Thankyou sir. Well explained.
TheToeProject 7 months ago
As I noted in a previous Comment, the explanation in this video of the origin of the two tidal "bulges" on opposite sides of the Earth is incorrect. I have therefore posted a link to a website which clarifies the processes causing ocean tides. The explanation on the website uses a series of animated diagrams. This link is available in the Recent Activity section of my YouTube Channel page. This page can be accessed by clicking on my Username below.
LunarJim1000 7 months ago
Finally now i got it :) Thx So much :)
pinco112 7 months ago
This is an imaginative presentation. Unfortunately, the explanation of the origin of the two tidal "bulges" on opposite sides of the Earth is incorrect. They are caused by centrifugal forces due to revolution in the Earth-Moon system, as well as by Lunar gravitation.
LunarJim1000 7 months ago
Tide moves in, tide moves out, you can't explain that
SkepticalBastard 7 months ago
It was a little weird at first but then it made so much sense! Thank you! Now I can do my science lab!
omgxd4 7 months ago
thanks smart explatation
93Msprincess 7 months ago
i finally understand thx so much!(:
BFFsbeforeBF 8 months ago
I used this for my 6th grade class a couple weeks ago. I followed up with a discussion and whiteboard illustration. I asked several students to share their own experiences with tides. On a test today, one person had no clue how the moon affected the ocean. She remembered the cookie in the video, but not a word that was spoken in the video - or in my talk !! Well, I HAD shown the video just before lunch. Timing is everything.
LogosTeacher 8 months ago
Comment removed
LogosTeacher 8 months ago
You can't explain that!
superduperjew 9 months ago
STOP PLAYING WITH YOUR FOOD
jackblakeman1234567 9 months ago
I agree that the tides has something to do with the gravitational pull or where the sun and the moon is, while the earth rotates around the axis, it also tilts and that's why the sun can be at different places unlike the moon that actually goes around earth
hamtaruforfashion 10 months ago
Thank you.
LexieANTM 10 months ago
that was weird but, inspirational!!!
mrcharizard51 10 months ago
This is awesome thanks!
luvlove550 10 months ago
Not bad, I think I could use the same explainaion with my ten year old without too much struggling, thanks muchly.
wjcgto65 10 months ago
Great explantion! Can I have the recipe the earth?
pauloscar 11 months ago
thanks...I was having confusion as to how we get two highand two low tides a day nicely explained
styleboy321 11 months ago
Nice explaination! You get the basics. Do you also have a video where you explain a little more? :)
LillyLoLigresse 11 months ago
Thank for inviting me. A cubic foot of salt water weight approximaletely 68 pounds. An ocean wave 3 feet high by 6 feet at the base by 100 feet long weight about 61,200 pounds.
Multiply that by all of the waves, thats a tremendous force of lunar pull!
A person weighing 180 pounds disperses 2.65 cubic feet of water. Shouln't we all be floating on air.? Want to know about my theory on gravity and what i have named the X-gravity field factor?
Email : jqs43@hotmail.com
Serious inquiries only!
jqs1943 11 months ago
gerr i haft to know all that for mon for school good video though
chantale2834 1 year ago
Nice explanation, but I'd like to know more about the cycle mentioned at the end of the video.
neilfein 1 year ago
Bill O'Reilly will say "I click on play button., video plays .. so there is god" !
MrJekyllDrHyde1 1 year ago
Wait, you mean it's not god doing it?!
cockyjeremy 1 year ago
Someone please show this to Bill O'Reilly.
pacific14586 1 year ago 56
Good for me thanks.
fastiva3 1 year ago
Perfect for me! But could you tell what that thing is called that only occurs once every 18.61 years? It sounds really interesting.
@rezchikov1 I learned at school that the rthe reason it's on the opposite side is because the moon is pulling the earth toward it, and it's pulling the water on that side toward it, and on the other side, it's leaving it behind. Awesome right?
keraby13 1 year ago
Perfect for me! But could you tell what that thing is called that only occurs once every 18.61 years? It sounds really interesting.
keraby13 1 year ago
PERFECT explanation
adampilotf22 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
/ watch?v=0vqDQfgOTTk&feature=grec_index
crusty757 1 year ago
/ watch?v=0vqDQfgOTTk&feature=grec_index
crusty757 1 year ago
i need to know What is the cycle of the sun and moon that occurs once every 18.61 years?
crusty757 1 year ago
Does this CORRECTLY explain why there is a bump of water on the other side of the Earth?
rezchikov1 1 year ago
@rezchikov1 sorry it does not
theep16 1 year ago
thank you for explaining it shortly and in a tangible way! :D
twmaniac 1 year ago
not a good ending!
shaurya0833 1 year ago
much better than my professor's two hour explanation. thanks!
Indubitablyme 1 year ago 20
Thanks!!
iceangel18 1 year ago
GREAT video. ANNIOYING ENDING!
Where's the rest of the story?????
bobbymak880 1 year ago
What is the cycle of the sun and moon that occurs once every 18.61 years???
What kind of ending is that? Annoying!
mismos00 1 year ago 22
What kind of ending is that? One that makes you want to find out more, I'd say. The moons orbit 'precesses' - it moves position slightly each month, in part because it is at an angle to the earth's orbit. The point where it crosses the line followed by the sun moves slightly, only returning to the same place every 18.6 years. There is an explanation in Wikipedia - look at 'lunar standstill'. The standstill itself is an interesting thing, seen by the ancients who built stone circles to mark it.
screenhousevids 1 year ago 9
Perfect Sir! Thank you
alisaeeddotcom 1 year ago
Very helpful! Thank you for posting this video.
MsLincolnsghost 1 year ago
great jobb thanks was skeptikal at first seeing a cookie but it df helped explain it better bc i was still cnfused on tids thaks again and well done
lincolncroozer97 1 year ago
Very well done, this is going to be shown/done in my astronomy class tomorrow
spamul27 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your explanation of the second bulge on the far side of the earth doesn't seem to make sense. Are you not oversimplifying to the point of being incorrect?
JSAGruber 1 year ago
Comment removed
JSAGruber 1 year ago
Comment removed
JSAGruber 1 year ago
One of the best explanations on YouTube! Thank You!
zoom598 1 year ago
this was very helpful! i have a final in a few days as well and this helped me learn about the tides a lot better than this damn book. thanks!
rubykins04 1 year ago
Great-simple explanation.
leonardodalongisland 1 year ago
Great job...thanks!
ins7777 1 year ago
erm.. the moon moves the water closest to and the earth? even tho the moon is the smaller of the two and what keeps the far water behind ?? space drag?
piratebandit2 1 year ago
Great explanation. I was a bit confused before this video. I have a final in 54 minutes that is going to ask questions about tides. I feel more confident now, after watching this film. Thank you so much for this explanation!
cbrooke16 1 year ago
He is a good teacher. :)
eatsleepdance18 1 year ago
that was interesting. it helps. also i need some ideas on how to make an experiment on tides. could somebody help me?
Ishah567 1 year ago
helped me alot on my homework!!:D thank u in amillion times!!x)
nanone1994 1 year ago
wow, great! It really help me with my home work, thanks!
mtgluthu 1 year ago
I will totally be using this with my students at school when we get to gravity and tides. Thanks!
ruggerdavey 1 year ago
so the moons gravity can hardly keep an astronaut on its ground yet it can pull the earths water around in strange egg shapes.
no
The shape of the tides is the same as earths magnetic field. The moon always faces earth because it is attached to this field.
cjellwood 1 year ago
Great video. Im going to use this in my classroom. I just cant access youtube at school
shonc1 1 year ago
HI, with permission from the video creator, you should download REAL PLAYER, it has a feature you can save YouTube videos to your hard drive - then you can play them back at school!!
badgerfeatures 1 year ago
Excellent video! Thank you!
daniellenadia 1 year ago
OMG! Thank u soo much! That helped.
LNKDesign 1 year ago
thank you so much this helped m so much in science now can u explain neap tides
LOL6DEE6 2 years ago
This was awesome. It completely makes sense now. Good video!
3020755433 2 years ago
thank you , I wish you had gone on a bit more about it , as I am teaching my children about high tides and low tides . bravo , you did a dandy job . I appreciate your video it was a great addition to our homeschool science class.
healyhouse 2 years ago
Excellent... property law student... thanks very much!!!
ashonie 2 years ago
very good, but what is the event that happens only every 18.6 years?
duron8 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
As long as we're talking about the moon, here's something.
There's a mountain of evidence that the Apollo moon missions were faked. I posted a partial summary of it on a science forum. Google "The Naked Scientists". In the "New Theories" section of the forum there's a thread entitled "Did We Land on the Moon?". The summary is on page 15. It's the 7th post from the top.
People who still think they went to the moon simply haven't seen the hoax evidence yet.
Cosmored 2 years ago
what bout d neap tide ?
gob007me 2 years ago
Excellent lucid explanation. Helped me with my science project.
The "let's be quirky and use everyday objects to explain science" approach usually doesn't work for anyone but Bill Nye, but in this video the model was very effective.
trenteady 2 years ago
The simple matter...
kkkristopher 2 years ago
this one made more sence because you explained it,on the other videos its just an animation whith the moon and earth
thegreenwindninja 2 years ago
great thanks
cro1ne 2 years ago
It was pretty good, but it wasn't alot of information. If the video was twice as long, it would be perfect.
MacHans78 2 years ago
Really good clarification..thanxs!
TerahMoran 2 years ago
nobody posted anything? Well...I now know how tides work, thanks to you meester and your delicious earth cookie I hope you ate:) I couldnt have explained it better myself
KeelyKathleen 2 years ago
Nice explanation!
KEEFCHEEF420 2 years ago
i think this video is ok! it explains stuff about how the moon effects de tides!!! thx 4 helping mwa know about this! i needed it! rotflmao! lol :)
lilmizzsupergirl 2 years ago
pretty good explanation
pvaz 2 years ago
i like how you explain things, you make it real easy for me to learn, make one about how waves work please.
gueranga 2 years ago
Great thanks!
erik9999yahoo 2 years ago
fantastic, thank you. 32 years of not knowing.... 5 stars!
oscargurses 2 years ago
nice one!
hy211 2 years ago
Great i only wish u would tell us how the super high tide works.
KillarBigT 2 years ago
great video, thanks!
the89thkey 2 years ago
the best explanation on youtube! Thank you!
Cordelinyo 2 years ago
Oh wow, helped me with my science homework (Y)
fullbinky 2 years ago
Great explanation!! It makes much more sense to me now! Thanks!
solarpowerproj2008 2 years ago
great i finally understand
ransh 2 years ago
good
lankankd 2 years ago
Great video. Nothing better than cafe explanations!
jakejarmaine 2 years ago
Ah, NOW I get it.
vanillaorchid 3 years ago
awesome
brusieseabass 3 years ago
what an easy way to explain the tides! thanks
useurcamera 3 years ago
Excellent explanation!
elvitron 3 years ago