Added: 2 years ago
From: OnlineKatyPerry
Views: 657,400
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (630)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I didn't know there was an alternate version to the video.

  • boring song

  • I feel this way about my boyfriend. He has changed so much and I miss the person I fell in love with...

  • i feel sorry

  • now, now the lesson's learned

    I touched it, I was burned

    Oh, I think you should know !

    ---

    gusto mong saksakin din kita ?! :">

  • better than the other vid. it tells what exactly on the lyrics

  • That is one messed up video.

  • That was such a sad video I understand this video better than the other one... but still this is so sad and It's scary at the end with the knife and she has blood all over her because i can't see Katy Perry doing anything like that!

  • Is she really smoking? :(

  • @thinkforpink09 Yup she's been trying to quit for years but like everyone says "I've quit a hundred times." so calm your tits she still has an amazing voice.

  • the new music video of thinking of you is much better than this one..

  • i like the newest 2 so much better

  • Gostosa ><

  • i think shboogies is right but the direction of the video doesn't make the concept entirely clear! Also it's a bit violent for general viewing with all the blood? the other video is much better and the concept is clearly defined! plus she is realllly hot in this vid where she's looking a bit plain jane in the video. one of my faves out of this album! :-)

  • wow i really don't get this movie video.... if i see katy, i would ask her:p

  • is my vision getting blurry, or is it the 360p?

    Correct answer: 360p

  • she looks pretty and fresh.. i love the other version of this song.. it is very emotional.. and the guy is really handsome Matt Dallas?

  • ww.youtube.com/watch?v=pKyasYg­2QYg

    Da uma olhada nesse som... bem brisa!!!

    temos que divulgar essa bandaa!! =D

    simples e agradável de ouvir...

  • When she smiled...with bloody hands and pretty eyes I was fucking creeped out. 0.o Love the vid tho !!!

  • i like the other version much better. 

  • well that sucked.

  • @spenserellen yea a little

  • @abby1063 especially in comparison to the ACTUAL video.

  • essa musica e show!!!

  • Anyone ever think that maybe she stabbed the guy in the back because she's crazy, I mean she did just unneccesarily smile while lying a pool of another person's blood? No? okay.

  • Perfeito*=*

  • hi my name is arturo and i was rapped before i died. i used to enjoy pain and now i inflict it upon people. I was tortured and raped until I could no longer breathe. Those meanies now suffer and die, and those who do not repost this to 5 videos will die too. I hate this too but I believe at the strike of 12 am, those who did not repost this will die a horrible death after seeing a bloody face covered with long black hair. Those who repost this will get a kiss from their crush

  • @kairi1yuna This might be more effective if you didn't misspell raped... I highly doubt you spoke in rhymes then died. And you really couldn't have died if your wrote your post.

  • The way I see it, she fell in love with an asshole. Even though she meets the supposed "perfect guy", she cannot stop thinking about the other and stabs him because she didnt feel like she deserved him - a desperate attempt to make him let go of something that cannot move on/ give anymore.

    I should know.

  • katy - i wish i was looking into your eyes:/ your big,beautiful eyes

  • Molto significativo questo video O.o Ci sono rimasta,sinceramente...

    Apparte questo,ma quanti ca**o di video ha fatto su questa musica? xD

  • i didnt understand the blood thing

  • Comment removed

  • What I get from the lyrics is exactly what I see in the video. She was in love with a guy(white room), but it didn't work & she let him go. Come to present time where she's trying to move on with a new guy(black room) but all she feels is an out of body experience, completely lost and unable to stop thinking about the first guy/obsessing over him.(hence why she sees herself asleep next to him in bed, on the complete opposite side). The stabbing was a metaphor that she killed her one true love.

  • @shboogies So now the WHITE room represents the cool guy and the BLACK room represents the not so cool guy? Where's Captain America on times like that?!? WAKE UP YOUR LAWYER

  • @shboogies If you noticed, it shows that he was 'stabbed inthe back' as if she betrayed him.....

  • @shboogies im glad you wrote this comment cus was really confused

  • @shboogies yes thanks for the comment. She can't move on and he said that there was ton 's of fish in the ocean, thanks it all makes sence now. :) It's beautiful, I like this version more than the video I knew .

  • I like this video so much better then the official video. I think this one is more powerful. This one touched me on so many different levels then then the official video.

  • O.o

  • nossa pasmei agora serio nem sabia que esse video existia mais e mais chocante do que o outro mais o outro e mais pro lado mimosinho

  • Comment removed

  • @edwardnewmoon999 I think she's saying she's killing her new relatinoship...because she is still thinking about her old bf, the one who doesn't want to be with her. And she feels "disgusted" with herself because she is intimate with the new guy and leading him on, but she's thinking about the other guy.

  • this song is seriously the description of my life right now ;___;

  • esse nao e o video verdadeiro

  • hahaha pause at 3:26 such an atractive face....thumbs up if you laughed ;)

  • I actually really like this video. And, Katy has the prettiest eyes <3

  • katy PERRY IK WIL KUSSEN HAAR VAN BRUNO VISSER

  • Diiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiva *-*

  • I prefer 1 st version ! ! !

  • hands down one of her best songs....

  • yeaaa i like the other video better....

  • she is so beautiful <3

  • i like the other vid better :/

    its more moving cuz the dude she loved died in war

  • WTH? 

  • why are there 2 videos of this song??

  • I didn't know Katy Perry sang this... oh God she can't sing.

  • That blood looks like BBQ sause.

  • 3:33 creepy smile! :)

  • o_o I dont like it :/

  • why waste time making two vids? no ones hardly even seen this one and ive liked this song a while

  • wait i thought she was going to get married to adam sandler

    ????

  • sou muit fãn dela

  • Caramba eu amor essa music..!

  • you sttabed him .. hooker

  • holy shit, this just rips your heart out!!

  • me declaro fan de esta canción!!

  • This song completely explains my love life right now ;(

  • nice 1

  • I don't think she cheated. Like she feels like she stabbed him in the back by being with someone else, but i think there was a reason she couldn't be with "white room guy" even though he was perfect for her in her eyes, but she had to force herself to move on because she couldn't have him, and she wanted to make him happy by showing him she was strong enough to do what he asked her to do.

  • @applejkx77 I agree because at the beginning she says he told her to move on. He doesn't want to be with her anymore so shes trying to move on but every time shes with the other guy shes thinking of the man she really loves.

  • @applejkx77 its about her boyfriend who was lost in iraq .. </3 . but this song is really touching to anyone of any matter i think .

  • @applejkx77 very good description.

  •  y did she stab the guy that she loved

  • this song never gets old :-)

  • 3:33 u smile

  • her eyes are MAJESTIC AND MAGICAL!

  • I like the other video more than this, but she's gorgeous here

  • te amo katy perry

  • she's too pretty<3

  • this is a shit

  • going thru that right now. <|3

  • she looks sooooooo pretty in the white room i love this song and i think shes the best singer in the world.

  • @edwardcullen4evur thanxs for agreeing with me

  • @misshotyusa23 MMMEEEE TTTTOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I like this video better, It has more pain. She looks more emotional which I think suits the song better. The other video was great, But I think this one's better.

  • Is it bad i just realized after killing the replay button that she didnt stab the black room guy, but the metaphor was she stabbed the guy in the white room's back. You know, "stabbed your back"?

  • The song fits this video better

  • Like this Video apart from the blood bits I was scared when she smiled with blood on her hands at 3:32 Weird with Nife

  • ok the other vid is better

  • I think both videos are good, but I much prefer this one. This one is more artistic and has more depth and symbolism. The other video, while good, seems to me to be just your average music video. I like the official one too, but this one is just more. And I think it suits the song better

  • old katy, please come back.. :(

  • no me gusto el video, porque si se supone que lo amaba porque lo mato?

  • I love this music video and I think she looks beautiful in it, but I still like the other one more. Katy is very talented

  • I like both vids. But the other one is more emotional. it goes better

  • @KateDenaliLuvsU that´s true

  • i think the reason why this wasnt the officail video is because of all the blood at the end though i think this one is amazing

  • esse video e um lixo

  • because this video is different????

  • Comment removed

  • I had been hunting for this video ever since I saw she had made a new video for this song. So glad you have this up.

  • White room is her current relationship and black one is her old one. She loves someone bad for her: the "ripest" apple/ worst temptation. He dumps her cruelly (You said move on, where do I go?) perhaps for the other girl. She tortures herself for letting him go, but still follows his orders to find someone else.The "touched but I was burned" line shows how she has been permanently scarred by their relationship, her obsession leading her to kill whiteroom man, disgusted by being contamined by him

  • I love how she represents the fact that she cheated on him.

    You gotta love that song, I really do. Plus Katy's purrfect. And I find her even sexier when she smokes (only in the clip of course)

    PS : Lol, they made a threesome in the black room.

  • I saw this video a while ago, and then Katy brought out another filmclip. So glad I found this one again! =)

  • o e... there's blood on her.... but beautiful song though :')

  • i love katy perry's eyes! ther beatiful!

  • katie perry smokes??!?!?!?! WAAATTT. lol. thats hot xD

  • Que belleza de video !

  • i think that this video should have been the official one cuz it's more dramatic and artistic

  • @supermereturns

    How is it more dramatic & artistic?

    This has been done SO SO SO many times.. And kind of looks like she made this at home doesn't look professional +Plus it looks staged and over acted.

  • me  encantaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

  • I like this video better than the newest one.

  • Katy Perry is the most beautiful woman on this entire Planet, I hope Russell Brand realizes how awesome she is, as a singer and a beauty! This song is Amazing btw!

  • The other video is more of a 'High Budget' video, but I think this one would be a lot more relatable for most.

  • This song is amazing!

  • good video but it looks like u needed better cameras dont mean 2 affend anyone just saying what i think

  • TOP

    

  • I honestly think Katy Perry is a newer generation Alanis Morrissette, but that's just me!

  • why did she change videos? I like this one better

  • she is gorgeos here in that nightgown with her dark hair that way!

  • @MelanieEvonne 's description probably makes more sense though.

  • I thought that the man in the black room was the past relationship and the man in the white room is her current one. She loved the man in the black room but he replaced her with the other girl and told her to move on. Her new relationship was healthier but all she can think about is how much she loved the man in the black room..she feels like she's betraying the man in the white room and it's killing her. So she has the knife to cut herself.

    That's what I saw, but that happened to me recently..

  • she always has some really hot guys in her songs, on another note, i really like this. been in that before.

  • i like the other music video of thinking of you cause theres a story behind that song...

  • DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTULLY WORKS. YOU WILL BE KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE. TOMARROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN THE NEXT 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READING THIS SO DUNT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY PUT THIS ON AT LEAST 5 VIDEOS IN THE NEXT 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS THIS IS SO SCARY CAUSE IT WORKS

  • Katy is Beautifull!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i like the other video better, this ones ok though.

  • i like the other video more,

    but in this one katy perry looks more hot than the other one ...

    but thats all that matters....soo yeah this one is better

  • amooooooo as musicas da ketty parabens beijos.

  • The black room is her current relationship and the white room was her old one. In the black room she feels dirty because the man wants more. the man in the black room is trying to push something that Katy doesn't want because she still loves the man in the white room but she cheated on him with the man in the black room. that's why there's a knife on the floor and blood on Katy and the man in the white.She stabbed him in the back by cheating but she wants him still.

    Thats what is going on.

  • @MelanieEvonne thnx for explaining. its better then the other one, where this guy said she spilled spagetti on herself and the bed.

  • @maddie32500 its not spagetti its blood she stabed the guy in the back. ps the guy in the white room.

  • @MelanieEvonne if katy is in love with the man in the white room then why did she kill him???????????

  • @TheSuperwildchild1 i think it is a metaphor of her cheating....she stabbed him in the back

  • how did you find out that? google?

  • @obd310 my sister told me once and i just remembered i dont know where she got it from tho

  • @MelanieEvonne damn, thanks for the explanation (:

  • @MelanieEvonne

    thanks soo much that helped A LOT!

  • @MelanieEvonne Don't forget the wine in the white room too! Its a last supper reference from when Judus shared in the meal and wine knowing he was betraying Jesus.

    ...Oh the things being a Literature major do to a person.

  • @MelanieEvonne Wy the other chick

  • @MelanieEvonne I don't really think that's what's going on though.

    I think it's more like he asked her to "move on" and "test the other fish in the water" so the sleazy motel and the clean white room are two 'fishes' she experimented with, but she still can't let go and she feels that they can't compare. I have a few guesses as to why she stabbed him, but I don't think he's the one she's singing about. And there's alcohol all over the bedside table :/

  • @HisHunnyBe ya well i guess none of us really know exept the director but that was just what i think was going on :)

  • The black room is her current relationship and the white room was her old one. In the black room she feels dirty because the man wants more. the man in the black room is trying to push something that Katy doesn't want because she still loves the man in the white room but she cheated on him with the man in the black room. that's why there's a knife on the floor and blood on Katy and the man in the white.She stabbed him in the back by cheating but she wants him still

  • 1:10 her eyes kill me.

  • I love Katy with ALL my heart. She is EVERYTHING to me. But Katy is smoking in this video...and it breaks my heart. I hate when she smokes. :/

  • good song do not like the video

  • ???????????? this is not official i dont get it

  • i LOVE her eyes!

  • i guess she got her period during sex

  • type in "ceej et"by chrisstylez music the kid is killing it!!!!

  • wats on her hands at 2:03??

  • @aoifeawesome Blood

  • @aoifeawesome blood bcuz she stabbed the guy by cheating on him

  • Hi people!

    Listen to my top 20 love songs here on Youtube! Search for "top 20 love songs lucas david" or -> watch?v=FkzDAhQfyEw

    Comment, please! Has one song of Katy Perry! :)

  • Myspace angle @ 2:33

  • she was young when she made this song

  • i just cant get enough of this song!!keeps playing in my head!

  • this is a really pretty song

  • ..Erm if no one said that she did the figureative language I'd be like..why is she smiling while laying down in a pile of blood..

  • @Songs2010Whoot what is she trying to say? with the blood? i didn't get that part.

  • She is using the figureative language stabbing in the back, so she basicaly stabbed him in the back.

  • BIG BIG eyes...

  • wach my vid

  • i like the other version so much better. this one looks cheap and is not convincing

  • katy perry live on my channel! 5 mins!