Mickey Mantle better the Lou Gehrig?? your nuts, Gehrig is second "ONLY" to Ruth, no other Yankee on this list can hold his jockstrap...i disagree with your top 3. 1.Ruth 2.Gehrig 3.Mantle or DiMaggio depending on who you talk to 4.DiMaggio or Mantle 5.Berra 6.Ford 7.Jeter 8.Rivera 9.Dickey 10. Lefty Gomez that's my list(Jackson didn't play long enough as a Yankee to make my list) the top 5 IMO cant be touch.
mariano rivera should be ranked higher than jeter mo is the best closer EVER. in the postseason and the regular season and lou gherig is better than mickey mantle. he delivered every game even with broken fingers and a lot of other injurys and his legacy would be even better if he didnt die from lou gherig disease
All you who say Reggie does not belong WTF did any other Yankee hit 3 HRs in 3 consecutive at bats ??? Mantle ? no Maris ? no Ruth ? no Dimagio ? no Reggie was and still is MR OCTOBER and he didn't get that name playin for Oakland dumbasses
@hellome290 No, but did Reggie out homer entire teams like Ruth did? or Have a 56 game hitting streak like DiMaggio? did he play in 2,130 consecutive games like Gehrig? did he win 7 championships 3 MVP and triple crown like Mantle? or 10 championships and 3 mvp like Berra?? did he hit 3000 like Jeter? there are a lot of Yankees that have done amazing thing, the difference is they played the majority of there career's with the Yankees, i cannot put someone who only played 5 year. over them.
@hellome290 Btw...Lou Gehrig hit 4 home Runs in a single game, as i said...i cannot put a man who only played 5 years ahead of men who played there entire career's(almost for some)and accomplished similar or better feats to Reggie's, and while he was a good player for the Yankees, there are others that belong on the list ahead of him.
Ruth was fast ? NEVER he was not a five tool player to b a five tool player 1 you have to be fast cover alot of ground and steal bases. Ruth was not 2 Great glove gold glove Ruth was not 3 power ruth had it 4 hit for average ruth did 5 arm strength accurate and quick realese he had arm but Not the agility to make plays on the run so Ruth was a 2 and 1 half tool player
wheres Earle Combs he is the best centerfielder the yankees ever had with a carrer batting average of .325 he also was the leadoff hitter before murderers row and twice the player DiMagio ever was
@hellome290 "1 Joe D 2 The Mick 3 Jetes 4 Ruth 5 Reggie 6 Yogi 7 whitey 8 Mo 9 Gehrig 10 Maris"......Your list is retarded...and you know nothing of baseball, if you think that this list is remotely accurate. 1 Ruth, 2 Gehrig, 3 DiMaggio, 4Mantle, 5 Yogi, 6 Whitey, 7 Jeter, 8 Mo, 9 Jackson(dint play long enought to be on this list but what the hell) 10 Maris(same as #9) there i fix it for you, not the true top 10 list...but much better then the crap you had.
Babe Ruth No way #1 where do I start . 1 no speed he couldn't steal a base if the game depended on it 2 no Defense a big liability in the outfield. 3 Played against NO African American players. no Ruth is not the best Yankee Player but the most Popular STILL !!!
@hellome290 in his younger days rith was a five tool player but all that alcohol and cigars got him fat but he is still one of the best players in yankee history
@hellome290 Your a moron...Ruth had good speed, steal base?? when you out homer entire teams...you don't need to steal base. Ruth was a decent defender in the field, and a great pitcher(witch was his true position)how does him not playing with blacks not make him great exactly? last time i check...in baseball its all about the pitcher and hitter, "PITCHING" has been dominated(even after integration) mostly by white player...so Ruth face 90% of the best pitchers of his era retard.
If A-Rod can continue his success, he can go in the top 10 for sure. Some can argue Bernie Williams belongs in the top 10. I don't view him in the same way as the guys in the top 10 now.
Maris nor Reggie belong on the top 10, not even close. Reggie was a Yankee for 5 yrs. Maris for barely longer than that. The Bambino is #1, Gehrig #2, I'd put Dimaggio #3 & Mantle #4. Tough not to put Jeter #5 considering he's not done playing yet and he will have around 3,500 hits and who knows how many more rings. Yogi #6, Whitey #7, Mo Rivera #8 only because he's a closer and its tough to put him over the first 7 despite his total domination for 15 years. Red Ruffing #9 & Mattingly #10
Reggie Jackson might not even be in my 11-20. I can see an argument for Don Mattingly in the Top 10. HERE'S MY TOP 10: 1-Ruth 2-Gehrig 3-DiMaggio 4-Mantle Those players will probably be the Top 4 forever. 5-Rivera 6-Jeter 7-Berra 8-Ford 9-Dickey 10-Ruffing Munson is in my 11-20.
no offense but this list is crap 1. babe ruth 2. lou gehrig 3. mickey mantle 4.roger maris 5.yogi berra 6. reggie jackson 7. derek jeter 8. mariono rivera 9. mike mussina 10.whitey ford
Dickey.....not Reg. Thurman.....not Reg,
huskyjerk 4 months ago
yankees all day
dennyawesome619 4 months ago
I wouldve swapped Reggie and Dimaggio's places, but otherwise a flawless list.
kmccary 5 months ago
jojjimbo 5 months ago
mariano rivera should be ranked higher than jeter mo is the best closer EVER. in the postseason and the regular season and lou gherig is better than mickey mantle. he delivered every game even with broken fingers and a lot of other injurys and his legacy would be even better if he didnt die from lou gherig disease
hswshorts 5 months ago
All you who say Reggie does not belong WTF did any other Yankee hit 3 HRs in 3 consecutive at bats ??? Mantle ? no Maris ? no Ruth ? no Dimagio ? no Reggie was and still is MR OCTOBER and he didn't get that name playin for Oakland dumbasses
hellome290 7 months ago
@hellome290 No, but did Reggie out homer entire teams like Ruth did? or Have a 56 game hitting streak like DiMaggio? did he play in 2,130 consecutive games like Gehrig? did he win 7 championships 3 MVP and triple crown like Mantle? or 10 championships and 3 mvp like Berra?? did he hit 3000 like Jeter? there are a lot of Yankees that have done amazing thing, the difference is they played the majority of there career's with the Yankees, i cannot put someone who only played 5 year. over them.
jojjimbo 5 months ago
@hellome290 Btw...Lou Gehrig hit 4 home Runs in a single game, as i said...i cannot put a man who only played 5 years ahead of men who played there entire career's(almost for some)and accomplished similar or better feats to Reggie's, and while he was a good player for the Yankees, there are others that belong on the list ahead of him.
jojjimbo 5 months ago
Ruth was fast ? NEVER he was not a five tool player to b a five tool player 1 you have to be fast cover alot of ground and steal bases. Ruth was not 2 Great glove gold glove Ruth was not 3 power ruth had it 4 hit for average ruth did 5 arm strength accurate and quick realese he had arm but Not the agility to make plays on the run so Ruth was a 2 and 1 half tool player
hellome290 7 months ago
wheres Earle Combs he is the best centerfielder the yankees ever had with a carrer batting average of .325 he also was the leadoff hitter before murderers row and twice the player DiMagio ever was
LEGEEZY 7 months ago
1 Joe D 2 The Mick 3 Jetes 4 Ruth 5 Reggie 6 Yogi 7 whitey 8 Mo 9 Gehrig 10 Maris
hellome290 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hellome290 "1 Joe D 2 The Mick 3 Jetes 4 Ruth 5 Reggie 6 Yogi 7 whitey 8 Mo 9 Gehrig 10 Maris"......Your list is retarded...and you know nothing of baseball, if you think that this list is remotely accurate. 1 Ruth, 2 Gehrig, 3 DiMaggio, 4Mantle, 5 Yogi, 6 Whitey, 7 Jeter, 8 Mo, 9 Jackson(dint play long enought to be on this list but what the hell) 10 Maris(same as #9) there i fix it for you, not the true top 10 list...but much better then the crap you had.
jojjimbo 5 months ago
Babe Ruth No way #1 where do I start . 1 no speed he couldn't steal a base if the game depended on it 2 no Defense a big liability in the outfield. 3 Played against NO African American players. no Ruth is not the best Yankee Player but the most Popular STILL !!!
hellome290 10 months ago
@hellome290 in his younger days rith was a five tool player but all that alcohol and cigars got him fat but he is still one of the best players in yankee history
LEGEEZY 7 months ago
@hellome290 Your a moron...Ruth had good speed, steal base?? when you out homer entire teams...you don't need to steal base. Ruth was a decent defender in the field, and a great pitcher(witch was his true position)how does him not playing with blacks not make him great exactly? last time i check...in baseball its all about the pitcher and hitter, "PITCHING" has been dominated(even after integration) mostly by white player...so Ruth face 90% of the best pitchers of his era retard.
jojjimbo 5 months ago
Deter Jeter should be top 5
superjack310 1 year ago
If A-Rod can continue his success, he can go in the top 10 for sure. Some can argue Bernie Williams belongs in the top 10. I don't view him in the same way as the guys in the top 10 now.
b04vzxq 1 year ago
Maris nor Reggie belong on the top 10, not even close. Reggie was a Yankee for 5 yrs. Maris for barely longer than that. The Bambino is #1, Gehrig #2, I'd put Dimaggio #3 & Mantle #4. Tough not to put Jeter #5 considering he's not done playing yet and he will have around 3,500 hits and who knows how many more rings. Yogi #6, Whitey #7, Mo Rivera #8 only because he's a closer and its tough to put him over the first 7 despite his total domination for 15 years. Red Ruffing #9 & Mattingly #10
b04vzxq 1 year ago
Why isnt A-Rod on this list somewhere???
xXxTMan1235xXx 1 year ago
wow you didnt even put in roger maris... over Mariano Rivera?
mc2baller 1 year ago
i agree im glad you put mattingly nobody puts him on top 10 yankee players and he belongs there
ZAVEUSZBC 1 year ago
jeter #1 and ruth #2 a rod #3 and lou #4
rayrayrocks1 2 years ago
wenflinger 2 years ago
jacobgundy11 2 years ago
ya i did
gminey33 2 years ago
VERY NICE SELECTION OF PLAYERS did you choose them yourself????
igadillon 2 years ago