@1016Sammy perhaps you should listen to what he is saying, I suspect that you don't really understand therefore, I think it is you who is soooo out of it AND IT SHOWS !
@cjtj8 well you must be really be into conspiracy theory so it explains a lot I wouldn't argue with you on this issue but I don't agree with his views and that does not mean I think he is crazy U have a right to be on his Bus. I have a right to disagree with his views and trust me that is not coming from just this interview. For you not to see that many of his views are misconceived then I will not argue with you. CONGRATULATIONS. I'll rather be realistic and un-bias. he is UNREALISTIC.
@1016Sammy No Sammy, I simply think that Mr Shahak was a wonderful human being. I think perhaps you struggle with him because what he says is quite at odds with your preconceptions on this subject. You have very clearly been brought up to believe that Jews are indeed the 'chosen' ones. So when Mr Shahak explains (with evidence) how the Jews are like lots of other people in that they have done bad things and had bad things done to them, it goes against your 'education' (?) Check out what he says.
Hitler was a fundamentalist Christian, more so than he was an archetypal papist, and as a group fundamentalist Christianity follows a surface-only, hypocritical and stupid non-examination of the Divine. I, myself, have a great love for Christian concepts, but zero for the witch-hunts done by Puritans and papists out of their non-examination. Every fundie is an idolater; he makes an idol out of his Bible, Talmud, Quran, etc—often w/ a murderous contempt for any who resist such idolatry.
@cjtj8 Hey there, codfish brain, do a Google search on "Hitler's Christianity". Then, on the 1st page that appears, go to "The Christianity of Hitler Revealed in his Speeches and Proclamations". It'll be staring you right in the face. I know that might be a task, clicking on something right in front of your face, but give a shot.
@freddietz96 Hey there Dugong brain (that's a sea cow by the way - just staying on the sea creature analogy !) alright, perhaps Hitler wasn't exactly an atheist (though there are schools of thought that suggest he was) but he certainly wasn't a 'christian' in any meaningful sense. He was brought up as a Catholic, but he had long since abandoned any identification with christianity by the time he formed the Nazi Party in the 1920's. Pleased to see you 'took the bait' with your reaction. Hee hee !
*yawn* Why must people call such a man a genious? I might read him, but watch almost an hour? Ugh, I got through ten minutes. And Haaretz is a little bit more of a tabloid than the NYT, although the latter is getting worse and worse...
This man is very well educated. There will be no peace until these Elitists stop treating others as inferior and Sub-Human. Palestine does have just as much right - IF NOT MORE to live in land known for over 2000 years as PALESTINE. Also the UN and IMF bankrupt countries under guise of doing good. The UN is evil!!!
He makes much sense. I knew nothing about him before watching this video. There must be a strong democratic element in Israel since they allow views like this to be expressed. I shall start reading his books.
Mr Channer has many interesting, well-educated guests but he seems to be all at see when interviewing them... Interrupting for no good reason and verbally fumbling about, adding unnecessary interjections and longueurs into an otherwise interesting debate...
One wants to thank him for providing a platform for all of these interesting contributors while at the same time having the desire to slap him every time he breaks the rhythm of discourse - which is every few seconds! frustrating. :(
Btw, the decision of the Gezera of Rabenu Gershom in Ashkenazic Europe about monagamic live style wasn't influenced by the Christians but a private decision NOT an "only by Christian influence". Israel paid for his education?? Making caricatures is science?? Fool.
@ilianyc What has the monagamic "Life style" of Jews decreed by Rabenu Gershon in the 11th century to do with his education? First, he has it wrong to say that this decision was influenced by the Christians in Europe. Besides he has his own tunnel-fission-theory and makes everything fit in this witch is un-academic. He makes caricatures and sell this as scientific facts. I guess this is more close to senility. So I wonder who paid for his education. Were those Israeli or Russian tax-payers?
@ShimonEliezer You mean "monogamous" (monogamic)? By posting these incoherent ramblings, you keep disqualifying yourself from any real discourse, setting yourself up for ridicule. What this man claims are real and true, just because they don't fit your definition of what Judaism is doesn't make them any less valid or factually viable.
@ilianyc As long you don't have to discuss the essence of the matter. He claims 19th/early 20th century bull shit and you buy and sell this too. Nice for you. You and a Shahak don't understand anything about Judaism that's clear. Chatting in the periphery of the main issue and make up your own values suits you both well I see but hasn't to do anything with reality nor with scientific work. Typical only good for a chat-show.
@ilianyc Senile then. You don't even know what Rabenu Gershon decided. Listen to this video again to learn about lifestyle. Pathetic is to fall over a "v" or "f' as long you don't have to discuss the real issue.
I never heard such a foolish professor. He makes so many wrong assumptions and totally ignores orthodox historiography. In his mind he is blocked by his tunnel vision (only political motivation) about the always living Judaism where institutions like the Sanhedrin then and Bate Diniem now live by the day. He himself didn't understood anything about Judaism.
@KosherOrganist You have chosen to vilify one group, only one group - Jews. It is because of ignorant attitudes like yours, and the propensity to vilify one group, that Jews have been slaughtered in the HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS over the course of 3 thousand years. IT IS PEOPLE LIKE YOU who have tried to obliterate us - because of BLIND HATRED! HATRED THAT KILLS! You are part and parcel of the genocide of Jews.
@KosherOrganist answer my comment - you wrote a LIE - as per usual for you. You wrote Ashkenazi Jews never set foot in Israel/Palestine until after 1948! You wrote that Israeli scholars have discussed this. WHAT FUCKING BULLSHIT!!!
You M.O. is to LIE about Jews and Israel, in order to spread hateful propaganda. You HATE for us is DISGUSTING! Have fun uploading your vids elsewhere! you foul foul human excrement.
@ZihavaTigress Do you think with a low level propaganda and filthy talk you can intimidate anyone, thug?
Check out the "The Invention of the Jewish People" by Shlomo Sand. Most the recourses in the book are from the Zionists themselves who knew about the Khazar and the difference between the converted European Jews and the old Hebrews in Palestine, Zionists like Gurion! So keep your legends and religious myths, and don't mix between your racist Zionist mind and Judaism. watch?v=T7JEqYtepbY
There is no doubt, the reason the world is in such a state because of the highly prolific people who call themselves Jews. We have wonderful banks, we have media in all its splendor, we have the penal system, we have the Glorious Church of Rome the very hallmark of what is called Christianity. We owe the Jews so very much. There is no doubt they are a very intelligent and worldly lot. Now, at this time, they hail the reincarnation of Rabbi Sneerson as the King Messiah and all is perfect!
@regardingme1, "we have the Glorious Church of Rome the very hallmark of what is called Christianity"
If you believe that then you really ought to set some time aside to learn the difference between true Christianity (Bible-based Christianity) and Popery (Babylonian Romanism). The Roman Papacy is the Antichrist, having persecuted and killed the Saints of God all through-out history since it was founded by Constantine in the 4th century.
Jews HAVE assimilated more than any other religious group in the history of mankind. You would be wise to embrace a little truth yourself wabbit man, and drop your own baloney. It's starting to rot. You spend your entire life disseminating lies and propaganda about Jews and Israel. Looks like it has come back to bite your fat furry ass.
one think is really interesting to me is that, as the prof said, jews are best in all historical societies due to their supporting roles being as money lenders, financiers alike. e.g on slavery, the white needed slaves and the jews provided them (d middle men), whn d axis & d allies needed war, jews provided money. whn chinese needed secret high tech frm d west, d jews provided it. whn d elites wanted NWO, d jews provided d means via banks..interesting.
This a must see for all who want put in perspective current world geopolitical events and understand the drive behind the phony so called 'war on terror
Excellent to hear some sense instead of the usual baloney..... and, of course, history is littered with failed states which over-extended their capabilities. Israel's leaders would do well to hear this great man's words, pull back to pre '67 borders and get on with it!
Jews were behind the slavery right from the beginning......they were very useful to their masters.......this went onto the African slavery into the USA....
It is telling ... the opinion is the most voted to shut the guest Isreael Shahk...
YHVHatesIsrael 1 week ago
its easy to hate on israel and sometimes rightly so but Mr Israel should face chemistry and leave politics cos he is sooooo out of it and it shows!
1016Sammy 2 months ago
@1016Sammy perhaps you should listen to what he is saying, I suspect that you don't really understand therefore, I think it is you who is soooo out of it AND IT SHOWS !
cjtj8 1 month ago
@cjtj8 well you must be really be into conspiracy theory so it explains a lot I wouldn't argue with you on this issue but I don't agree with his views and that does not mean I think he is crazy U have a right to be on his Bus. I have a right to disagree with his views and trust me that is not coming from just this interview. For you not to see that many of his views are misconceived then I will not argue with you. CONGRATULATIONS. I'll rather be realistic and un-bias. he is UNREALISTIC.
1016Sammy 1 month ago
@1016Sammy No Sammy, I simply think that Mr Shahak was a wonderful human being. I think perhaps you struggle with him because what he says is quite at odds with your preconceptions on this subject. You have very clearly been brought up to believe that Jews are indeed the 'chosen' ones. So when Mr Shahak explains (with evidence) how the Jews are like lots of other people in that they have done bad things and had bad things done to them, it goes against your 'education' (?) Check out what he says.
cjtj8 1 month ago 2
Hitler was a fundamentalist Christian, more so than he was an archetypal papist, and as a group fundamentalist Christianity follows a surface-only, hypocritical and stupid non-examination of the Divine. I, myself, have a great love for Christian concepts, but zero for the witch-hunts done by Puritans and papists out of their non-examination. Every fundie is an idolater; he makes an idol out of his Bible, Talmud, Quran, etc—often w/ a murderous contempt for any who resist such idolatry.
freddietz96 3 months ago
@freddietz96
Dunderhead
Dodikind 3 months ago
@Dodikind I’m just glad my truth stung someone who deserved to be stung. Shows I got my point across.
freddietz96 3 months ago
@freddietz96 What point was that you oaf ?
For your information Hitler was an 'athiest', he wasn't into any religion.
Perhaps you should let some of that helium out of your head, you dig ?
cjtj8 1 month ago
@cjtj8 Hey there, codfish brain, do a Google search on "Hitler's Christianity". Then, on the 1st page that appears, go to "The Christianity of Hitler Revealed in his Speeches and Proclamations". It'll be staring you right in the face. I know that might be a task, clicking on something right in front of your face, but give a shot.
freddietz96 1 month ago
@freddietz96 Hey there Dugong brain (that's a sea cow by the way - just staying on the sea creature analogy !) alright, perhaps Hitler wasn't exactly an atheist (though there are schools of thought that suggest he was) but he certainly wasn't a 'christian' in any meaningful sense. He was brought up as a Catholic, but he had long since abandoned any identification with christianity by the time he formed the Nazi Party in the 1920's. Pleased to see you 'took the bait' with your reaction. Hee hee !
cjtj8 1 month ago
@cjtj8 Whatever.
freddietz96 1 month ago
*yawn* Why must people call such a man a genious? I might read him, but watch almost an hour? Ugh, I got through ten minutes. And Haaretz is a little bit more of a tabloid than the NYT, although the latter is getting worse and worse...
Freefalldreams 7 months ago
I wish this asshole Channer would shut the fuck up and allow Shahak to speak.
AlexDark62 8 months ago 8
God, I wish that interviewer would've just shut his mouth for one minute.
profd65 8 months ago
the interviewer is just such an incompetent hack. can he utter a complete sentence?
MentalCarnival 10 months ago
This man is very well educated. There will be no peace until these Elitists stop treating others as inferior and Sub-Human. Palestine does have just as much right - IF NOT MORE to live in land known for over 2000 years as PALESTINE. Also the UN and IMF bankrupt countries under guise of doing good. The UN is evil!!!
12318dan 1 year ago
@12318dan It makes me laugh that you just stated something that most Israelis agree with you on, and have been saying for decades.
solpapisolmook 10 months ago
He makes much sense. I knew nothing about him before watching this video. There must be a strong democratic element in Israel since they allow views like this to be expressed. I shall start reading his books.
Thanks for uploading.
bambesis 1 year ago
I like and respect Shahak but is he nuts at the end of this video? He actually says
1- it wouldn't be a security risk to Israel to release all Palestinian prisoners and
2- they could easily be rearrested
Both of those statements are utter bullshit. Otherwise, he hits most of the points dead on and correctly
ErikPaulsonFan 1 year ago
Mr Channer has many interesting, well-educated guests but he seems to be all at see when interviewing them... Interrupting for no good reason and verbally fumbling about, adding unnecessary interjections and longueurs into an otherwise interesting debate...
One wants to thank him for providing a platform for all of these interesting contributors while at the same time having the desire to slap him every time he breaks the rhythm of discourse - which is every few seconds! frustrating. :(
umaralansari 1 year ago
@umaralansari
It's as if you stole my thoughts and phrased them better than I would haved.
hemmi79 11 months ago
@hemmi79 :)
umaralansari 11 months ago
Btw, the decision of the Gezera of Rabenu Gershom in Ashkenazic Europe about monagamic live style wasn't influenced by the Christians but a private decision NOT an "only by Christian influence". Israel paid for his education?? Making caricatures is science?? Fool.
ShimonEliezer 1 year ago
@ShimonEliezer "live style"? And you dare criticize his education, calling him a fool? Pathetic.
ilianyc 1 year ago
@ilianyc What has the monagamic "Life style" of Jews decreed by Rabenu Gershon in the 11th century to do with his education? First, he has it wrong to say that this decision was influenced by the Christians in Europe. Besides he has his own tunnel-fission-theory and makes everything fit in this witch is un-academic. He makes caricatures and sell this as scientific facts. I guess this is more close to senility. So I wonder who paid for his education. Were those Israeli or Russian tax-payers?
ShimonEliezer 11 months ago
@ShimonEliezer You mean "monogamous" (monogamic)? By posting these incoherent ramblings, you keep disqualifying yourself from any real discourse, setting yourself up for ridicule. What this man claims are real and true, just because they don't fit your definition of what Judaism is doesn't make them any less valid or factually viable.
ilianyc 11 months ago
@ilianyc As long you don't have to discuss the essence of the matter. He claims 19th/early 20th century bull shit and you buy and sell this too. Nice for you. You and a Shahak don't understand anything about Judaism that's clear. Chatting in the periphery of the main issue and make up your own values suits you both well I see but hasn't to do anything with reality nor with scientific work. Typical only good for a chat-show.
ShimonEliezer 11 months ago
@ilianyc Senile then. You don't even know what Rabenu Gershon decided. Listen to this video again to learn about lifestyle. Pathetic is to fall over a "v" or "f' as long you don't have to discuss the real issue.
ShimonEliezer 11 months ago
I never heard such a foolish professor. He makes so many wrong assumptions and totally ignores orthodox historiography. In his mind he is blocked by his tunnel vision (only political motivation) about the always living Judaism where institutions like the Sanhedrin then and Bate Diniem now live by the day. He himself didn't understood anything about Judaism.
ShimonEliezer 1 year ago
Comment removed
ilianyc 1 year ago
okay, I will join you to see what you're about...thanks!
regardingme1 1 year ago
@KosherOrganist You have chosen to vilify one group, only one group - Jews. It is because of ignorant attitudes like yours, and the propensity to vilify one group, that Jews have been slaughtered in the HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS over the course of 3 thousand years. IT IS PEOPLE LIKE YOU who have tried to obliterate us - because of BLIND HATRED! HATRED THAT KILLS! You are part and parcel of the genocide of Jews.
ZihavaTigress 1 year ago
@KosherOrganist answer my comment - you wrote a LIE - as per usual for you. You wrote Ashkenazi Jews never set foot in Israel/Palestine until after 1948! You wrote that Israeli scholars have discussed this. WHAT FUCKING BULLSHIT!!!
You M.O. is to LIE about Jews and Israel, in order to spread hateful propaganda. You HATE for us is DISGUSTING! Have fun uploading your vids elsewhere! you foul foul human excrement.
ZihavaTigress 1 year ago
@ZihavaTigress Do you think with a low level propaganda and filthy talk you can intimidate anyone, thug?
Check out the "The Invention of the Jewish People" by Shlomo Sand. Most the recourses in the book are from the Zionists themselves who knew about the Khazar and the difference between the converted European Jews and the old Hebrews in Palestine, Zionists like Gurion! So keep your legends and religious myths, and don't mix between your racist Zionist mind and Judaism. watch?v=T7JEqYtepbY
abumiz 1 year ago
@KosherOrganist Spot on!
123decoeli 1 year ago
There is no doubt, the reason the world is in such a state because of the highly prolific people who call themselves Jews. We have wonderful banks, we have media in all its splendor, we have the penal system, we have the Glorious Church of Rome the very hallmark of what is called Christianity. We owe the Jews so very much. There is no doubt they are a very intelligent and worldly lot. Now, at this time, they hail the reincarnation of Rabbi Sneerson as the King Messiah and all is perfect!
regardingme1 1 year ago
@regardingme1, "we have the Glorious Church of Rome the very hallmark of what is called Christianity"
If you believe that then you really ought to set some time aside to learn the difference between true Christianity (Bible-based Christianity) and Popery (Babylonian Romanism). The Roman Papacy is the Antichrist, having persecuted and killed the Saints of God all through-out history since it was founded by Constantine in the 4th century.
Islandretreat 1 year ago
Jews HAVE assimilated more than any other religious group in the history of mankind. You would be wise to embrace a little truth yourself wabbit man, and drop your own baloney. It's starting to rot. You spend your entire life disseminating lies and propaganda about Jews and Israel. Looks like it has come back to bite your fat furry ass.
ZihavaTigress 1 year ago
one think is really interesting to me is that, as the prof said, jews are best in all historical societies due to their supporting roles being as money lenders, financiers alike. e.g on slavery, the white needed slaves and the jews provided them (d middle men), whn d axis & d allies needed war, jews provided money. whn chinese needed secret high tech frm d west, d jews provided it. whn d elites wanted NWO, d jews provided d means via banks..interesting.
javabeserk 1 year ago
This a must see for all who want put in perspective current world geopolitical events and understand the drive behind the phony so called 'war on terror
"We Are All Marching To An Israeli War Drum"
shillbuster 1 year ago
Excellent to hear some sense instead of the usual baloney..... and, of course, history is littered with failed states which over-extended their capabilities. Israel's leaders would do well to hear this great man's words, pull back to pre '67 borders and get on with it!
Philastrophic 1 year ago
Jews were behind the slavery right from the beginning......they were very useful to their masters.......this went onto the African slavery into the USA....
999oneday 1 year ago
Thank you for this interview - it is a subject of massive importance.
123decoeli 1 year ago
lmao, the dumb brainwashed interveiwer is getting fustrated because shahak is speaking with a free mind.
irishgeal1 1 year ago
What's more admirable is how he held back from punching the bold guy in the face!
sbdem1986 1 year ago
There is no question that Israel Shahak was a great and courageous thinker! All that he said in '94 is even more timely today.
nitarenfrew 1 year ago
Where did the Khazarian Jews go then? Did they disappear? People do change religion.
WilhelmDrake 1 year ago
Speak up, Mr Shahak, I can't hear you.
RogerHoare 1 year ago