Added: 3 years ago
From: belledeball
Views: 81,195
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (220)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • oh man. . .YOU ARE THE BOMBDIGGIDY!!!. . . . .

  • when in love the best that you can close your eyes and hear this. T.T

  • It's very good.. I know many people that learn songs by ear and I really admire them.. I'm 14 and I'm playing the piano 5 years now but I guess I'm not patient enough to learn sth by ear.. Congratulations!:)

  • holy crap this is really good if you did it by ear. im 14 and never had lesoons and i play too. and i think im just gonna have tolearn this lol

  • Ooh...! Really great! <3

    (and u must be kidding that u did't have the notes...=)

  • you play so beautifully! you should make more videos

  • Really good!!!!!!!!!!

    I ♥ it <3333

    ^^

    Please can you make a tutorial? ♥♥♥

  • This is really good for only learning it by ear! That's a talent many musicians wish they could have :)

  • is beautiful ... You are very good

  • The only thing I can say is: Wow, you're amazing.... =)

  • WOW!! You can play this song soo beuatiful on the Piano!!

    I wished I could play the song also so fantastically,

    but I do not know the marks . = (

  • it is a very beautiful song. i think it should have been her lullaby cuz i mean it sounds like something edward wuld write just for some one as unique as her.

  • i love this song secaily on twilight!

  • beautiful =)

  • doing this by ear is quite well put together. I have played classically for almost 15 years. I understand where you are coming from. Congrats on a job well done. and yes, this is a version of what might have been put in Twilight, but wasnt... it was another choice ppl liked, but Carter Burwell had other plans... lol

  • Comment removed

  • @angiegirl2410 maybe your 'fren' should put their version on youtube, then?

  • :) not bellas lullaby. bellas lullaby is by carter burwell and called 'bellas lullaby'.. this is river flows in you by yiruma but this is so beautiful too !

  • @stilettosintheghetto thanks for pointing out the obviouse, cause the title dident say it all...lol

  • THIS IS NOT BELLAS LULLABY

  • @stilettosintheghetto

    Why have everybody downrated this comment?

    This is not Bella's Lullaby, it's Edward's Lullaby.

  • @stilettosintheghetto yes it is, you silly little twat: scribd.com/doc/12873484/Bellas­-LullabyA-River-Flows-In-You#f­ullscreen:on

    No it wasn't used in the movie as Bella's 'actual' lullaby, but the original soundtrack paints a very different picture.

    Get your shit in check before you start running your mouth like you're some sort of authority on the matter.

  • you ommited some notes,, btw nice job, unlike mine,,, you can also look at it, ^^

  • i'm 15 to ;D i played the same song

    but it's not bella's lullaby :) x

  • You're Great! Compliments!

  • okay everyone! this is not bellas lullaby or her old one either. but i like this song though! its great. and your cover is amazing! how long have you been playing?

  • everyone freaking calls river flows bellas lullaby its not. sorry

  • no thats the other version of bella's lullaby. this is a different version so it is called rivers flow in you. the other one is by carter burwell

  • bellas lullaby ist debussy - clair de lune :)

    but great job :D you play very good

  • This is not bellas lullaby sorry chick

  • What piano are that?

  • darm it!!!

  • i can play this, not as good though :)

  • this is AmAzInG

  • you can play it better !! there are some mistakes but nice

  • u didnt learn this by ear. I have the same sheet music u have on your piano. exactly the same note for note.

  • but overall you did a great job :D

  • your piano needs tuning?

  • muito lindo...amo muito piano...sempre toquei....

  • its a beautiful piece thats very well written. i love to sit and listen to the scores and scales of the "lullaby" . i too like to listen to this piece when writing . it is wonderful and i also play piano by ear. nice playing :)

  • if anything u need a better piano

  • Why?? I think it's the camera that doesn't pick up the sound the way it should ..

  • you are incredible!!! That was amaizing!

  • This is very good, but River flows in you isn';t Bella's lullaby!

  • But it is 1000 times better than Carter burdwells lame stupid song.

  • ye, i agree

  • im just mad that people confuse themselfes that such a beautiful song as river flows in you can be something like bella's lullaby o.O

  • ... WOW ...

  • i love your talent... not many people can play by ear! an amazing piece, very very well done!

  • sei davvero bravo!

    complimeni...spero di riuscire anchioa suonare questa magnifica canzone...

  • your really good. im learning this song for my dads funeral its difficult u play it very well

  • where did u get the noteeeeessssssss??

  • i love this song so muchh: i have criedd so many timess

  • Bravo, c'est magnifique !

  • you very talentedd. im learning thiss too.

    but its pretty difficult because i have small hands.

  • Comment removed

  • Beautiful.... very beautiful!!!!!

  • omg... you have an extremely beautiful piano!!!! I'm jealous...

  • its not on twilight retards this is retarded yiruma's river flows through you, iono how people think it is bella lullaby

  • you right aznboi

  • jeez. be so negative.

    it was supposed to be her lullaby. but they changed it to something else.

    your gay!

  • dude its rever flows through me but i twilight they took it and tweaked it but if u listen to both versions there a tad bit different but they both still good

  • omg dat was freakin good cant believe your 15 tho nice work

  • Awesome Job. I luv this song so pretty much anything good but your great.

  • where did you find this music?

  • my friend morgan picked it up by listening to the song also she's 13 you are a very good player. and did an exalent job on the lullaby ♥

  • this is really good....

    you awesome at this....

  • wow! girl

    amazing!!!

    i luv this song♥ and u play awesome!!

    congratulations

    :D

    kepp doing

    GB ♥

    5*****

  • this is really good,

    very close to what it really is.

    missing a little bit of notes, but very good!

  • this is so amazing! you're really good for 15! i know you learned it by ear, but you should make music sheets!

  • great great excellent!!!!

  • great great great... thanx for that good song from twilight....

    good job...

    :-)

  • oh my gosh..when i first heard i couldn't believe that still there is good music.....I want to congratulate you cuz that's great....

  • u mite want to slow it down....but other wise...i wish i could play like u!

  • that's awesome! do you have perfect pitch?

  • I love the Piano, I wish I could play that. You did a very good job. ^_^

  • itz really good for a person who played it by ear! nice 5/5!

  • Wow !

    I love this song <3 you're amazing!!!!

    Great job

  • Impressive!!

  • oh shit shit! BY EAR! WHAT THE FUCK!

    YOU ARE THE AMAZING

    the other day i learn another bella's lullaby created for a fan and i played it for me :)

    but you are like OMG!

    I make the lyrics... could you make it for me? PLEASE!

  • Omg This is AMAZING! Excellent job! :)

  • nice job

  • oh wow how did u do it by ear????? i've played piano for years and i couldn't play that!!! nice job!

  • You're really good!!! I played the piano for about 4 years and I don't think I could play it like you :)

  • WONDERFULLLL. I HOPE, TO LEARN IT

  • I give you 2 thumbs up! You are very good!

  • wow!!! es hermoso!!! :D Felicidades!

  • yOu're reaLLy gOod

  • holy crap, how'd you get it down so well?

    i'm so jealous, you'll have to teach me.

    i LOVE the piano and you really do have a nice one.

  • You my friend have a GORGEOUS piano!

    I'll Kill for on! Good job on the piece!

  • Ótima interpretação!

    Mas pra que a informação de que só tem 15??

    Tem crianças que tocam assim ¬¬'

  • hey...you played it perfectly...i love listening to it again and again..great great job!

  • great job!i would say you got practically the whole song on the dot..keep it up..=)

  • wow!.. its amazing you learned this by ear.

    i use video's, notes, ear.. and friends for help and i still cant do it!

    i am pretty bad though UNLIKE you!

    this song is hard to play because of the timing and i wanna say "you are very good!"

  • What a beautifull melody... The great movie!

  • ur awsome dude ur like omg i dont know what to say when i heard it i jezzed in my pants

  • You're really g8 :)

  • that was really good

    ive been trying to learn it

    ive got bout half so far :P

  • I am so impressed you learnt this by ear. Well done

  • omg you learned this hearing it WOW

    it takes mr=e forever to learn one piece of music with music in front of me

    good on you and your really good

  • Oh yes it is bellas lullaby but it isnt the official. At the Soundtrack theres also this one.

    You did a great job. It's unbeliavdable how you play this.. great...

  • really good I love this !

  • you are really good

  • you did a great job!!

    but this isn't bella's lullaby

  • You are so right! this isnt Bella's lullaby, Its a song out of a chinesse movie called The Secret.

  • this isnt bellas lullyaby its totally diff!

  • This is so beautiful! My 14 year old daughter was listening to this on my computer and I honestly can't stop hitting my refresh button. (lol) Fantastic Job!!

  • geenial!!=D=D

  • omg i wish i could learn to play the piano <3 !

    yurr wonderfull =D !

  • That was Absolutley Amazing. :) Really great

  • wow...ur really good- i love this

  • wooahhhhhh your sooo good! (:

  • ooooh, amazing! you're better than good ;)

  • omg, you are so good:o and that you have learnd it by ear! really good:D

  • pięknie..

  • J'ai envie de savoir le jouer moi aussi!!! :((

  • ouaaaaa trop beau, trop fort j'adore

  • wow this is one of the best ive seen yet of people trying to play it. good job! love the song <3

  • lol thanks! i posted another one as a reply to this which i personaly think isbeter.... but everyone else apparently thinks not :"(

    THank you :)

  • wow. i wish i cud play piano...

    love you edward. come to life and marry me.

  • amazing. great job. sounds beautiful!!

  • you have it backwards. bellas lullaby is by carter burwell and the one you are playing IS esme's favorite by yurima. if you want to hear bellas lullaby go buy the twilight soundtrack, its on there, the correct Bella's lullaby

  • wow.. that's great

    i love this song!!

  • I'm learning to play this song and i cant even play well... all though i can play it

  • i learned this by ear to!

    lol, sounds like yours.

  • this is called esme's favorite not bellas lullaby

  • sorry- thanks :)

  • no, this is Bella's lullaby. Esme's favorite is different.

  • That's really good, learning 'by ear'. Haha.

    As you mean, learning on youtube?? Or watching the people play it?

    It's fairly difficult.

  • no i listened to it over and over again on my ipod

  • this is amazing if you learned this by ear wow!!

    i love this song

    i can pplay it but with the muic :P

    well done!!

  • oh you lucky person having a grand piano in your house :P

  • it was my 16th Birthday present :)

  • W o w.

  • i love the other one as well and i will encourage him surly he can do it or my friends auntie might well keep rockin

    candyflosskitten

    scribble back soon

  • thanks :) its not getting nearly as many views as this one though and i think its better :s

    indeed you keep rockin!

  • Oh My God! I can play the piano but i would never be able to play it that good if i had only learnt it by ear. i want to be able to play it on the piano though.

  • WOW!!!!!!!

  • Holy crap if you learned this just by ear you are freakin amazing!

  • wow you did a fantastic job!

  • OMG U R AWSOME !!!!

    and u learnt that by ear u ar amazing and i love this song so much and u are only15 my dad can play the piano amazingly but he cant play that song so u should keep rockin

    love the song and the way u play

    candyflosskitten

    post back soon

  • Thanks so much for the encouragement! if you look at the video responses i put up a more complex version of it. when i first leart it i put it up straight away and now this other version i personally think is prettier :) keep encouraging your dad! HE CAN DO IT!!

  • you me have to have a sit down and talk............about how amazing you are

    i plaay piano too teach meeeeee!!!!!1

  • if your ever in Bermuda then sure :)

  • Your going to play ay my wedding Right?..Amazing!

  • nice!

    I love this song(L)

  • WOW :| .. Just .. Wow !

  • omg u are really good and yeah i saw some of your comments saying that u are trying to learn bellas lullaby

    yeah isnt that hard?? cause like i can play it NOW finally! lol but ha someparts i mess up on cause i dont have that big of fingers lol

    but go for it!! lol

  • thanks for the encouragement! and kudos to you for learning it!

  • omg, I just love this song :')

  • Isn't bella's lullaby suppose to be the carter burwell one?

    i love this song anyways :D

    by the way,

    your good!

  • carter burwell did a cover of this song and it was rumoured to be the lullaby which i found out AFTER i recorded this.

    the other one is nice as well though :) i am trying to learn it at the moment but it is surprisingly hard...

  • beautiful :)

  • WOW you are really good!!!! I can play a different version of bellas lullaby... xD

  • this was a REALLY good cover of the song, and I hate to burst your bubble, but either you have such perfect ears that you can play this song the EXACT way the sheet music is written, or you just memorized it. Either way, great job!

  • Wow ! You're amazing !

  • wow teach me?

    lovely

  • thisis amazing. by ear!! wow! well done!

  • merveilleux! beautiful!

  • wow....that was beautiful...u U LEARNED THAT BY EAR! wow that was amazing :)

  • wooow :)

  • lovely

  • This is a beautiful interpretations of the song, i cannot believe how well your ear tone is, very impressive, wish i was as good, hehe. I love this. i am now listening to it for the second time.

  • this song gives me butterflies its so beautiful and it really reminds me of bella and edward and their love. it's so sweet and this song probably wouldnt really get to me if i never read the books and saw the movie. if any of you havent read the books, read them. ♥

  • very impresive congrats ;)

  • This is amazing for learning it by ear!

  • absolutely amazing! i got goose bumps listening to it... thats amazing that you learned it by ear!

  • well played im learning this piece along with bellas lullaby by carter burwell.you are really good.

  • I went to see the movie the other night and was so disappointed they didn't use this!

    I'm 15 also, nearly 16 and have learnt to play this all by ear. It's not too hard believe it or not. But I really wished that they used this one, it is perfect/

    Greay playing! + favourites.

  • your very good :D.. great job ,, 5 stars ..

  • you are great. I love it.

  • I want it please ! (the piano partition)

  • this version of the lullaby is pretty beautiful, i won't lie. but i feel that Carter Burwell's version is better, simply due to the fact that it conveys the way that Edward is so deeply in love with Bella. this one, obviously, would have made a better ACTUAL lullaby.

    Carter's idea to have the lullaby in the film express Edward's love was much better. This one just seems to fit into the book better.

  • you are amazing! this is awesome, you did it exactly the same as the original! whenever i hear this song i want to cry, it's so sad!but it is also beautiful and you played it wonderful so dont stop!...and is that your grand piano?!? it's gorgus!(lol)

  • This isnt the official lullaby, but i luv it!! Duz any1 know how 2 play da other one by carter Burwell? ~♥♥♥~

  • I'm learning!!!1 I'm getting good!!