SportsGamerShow - Madden NFL 12 vs NFL 2K5

[JasiahPalmer]

Madden Nfl 12 Is More Cool than 2k5 you haters!

[jjla24kobebryant]

dont forgot the first person view



[jjla24kobebryant]

They should bring back the online for nfl 2k5

[12Aldus]

Another great point is that there's no 2k curse now is there Madden?

[MNSNOWBOARDING23]

I think EA and 2k should just swap their exclusive deals for baseball and football. If anyone ever played MVP baseball it was easily the best baseball series out there until 2k bought exclusive Mlb rights. If EA went back to making baseball games and 2k went back to football we would live in a much better world!

[TheTopwaves]

@MNSNOWBOARDING23 100% AGREED.

[TriesPizza]

Madden 12 has so many epic fails in it, it´s ridiculous!

Three gameplay problems which pop to my mind right now...

- stats block the gameplay in the last all important seconds of a game (clock runs and you cannot get your playcall off)

- opposing teams often choose run plays when trailing in the last seconds of a game

- the defense does NOT adjust even if you keep calling the same play

EA developers don´t deserve their pay check.

[nyran125]

2K wins at all sports.. EA sports has always sucked in comparison. in ALL SPORTS.

[jsteedley]

thumbs up if your playing madden 12

[MrNcredbl7]

Madden is trash dookie. Funny how they take 1 thing out or put 1 thing in. Keep the same bullshit animations, gameplay. Have the nerve to call this a sim game and charge 60. EA can eat a dick. At least 2K had some semblance of realism. Smh. And some1 please tell me y the hell u can straffe and position for the ball on defense but cant do that with a WR or RB. Smh

[Turppa21]

Madden needs to make sacks look more realistic, and more wrap up tackles also less stiffness in players

[CRCamp86]

I have a hunch that gamers would be more satisfied with Madden if EA just took the framework of NFL 2k5 and updated the graphics.

[mirrage318]

That is a shame 2k hasn't made an official nfl game for almost 8 years now and madden still can't barely beat it

[SKFD68]

Comparing graphics really isn't fair. Considering the game is 8 years old. It still looks damn god.

[buckdunn21]

2k5....still the king. Man, I miss this game.

[TheBlakeReviews]

FUCK MADDEN! ITS A FAIL! CMON 2K, BUY OUT THE RIGHT TO CREATE AN NFL GAME!!!

[havoc00]

lol @ the madden 12 commentary calling a good game, are you fucking stupid?

[MrMatto91]

I liked 2K5 mainly for the half time and post game shows. I want to see game highlights and stats not just the replays.

[blizzy00]

If i have a PS2, and 2K5, how can i get the latest Rosters on my memory card?. Anyone?

[xHardModex]

@blizzy00 Action replay max EVO, and any usb. amazon(dot)com/gp/product/B001­UIG6M2

I can give you the 2012 files if you need them.

I also heard you can use a ps3 - ps2 convertor, but i'd just use the AR max - since I know it works

[aquateenman3]

man i miss that game, its been a few years since i played any football games so idecided to pick up madden 10 a couple days ago to see if it was any better and just sucks mega balls.

[texmexman1]

6:09 noo really? 

[ATLKIDD05]

ncaa better than both of them

[www366]

I am a huge madden fan, until I played Madden 12. That game fucking sucks. I bought it, traded it back for a 3DS.

[fdsac67]

@www366 3DS are 4 pussys

[samkyupsal]

the fact that nfl 2k5 still challenges madden after 7 years is mind boggling

[TheSokilla]

@samkyupsal Seriously

You can now see why EA bought the NFL rights, shit if a game from 04 can beat a game from this year, you gotta know that EA is just milking the same garbage because they have no competition.

It pisses me off just thinking where the 2k brand would of been with football, if EA didn't fuck it up. They will keep buying the rights because 2k already killed EA's NBA live and they can't afford to lose the cash cow madden, which they would cause they can't compete.

[xIJOS3RAMOSIx]

Thumbs up if you're still playing NFL 2k5 in 2012!

[maplestoryman77]

2k12 isnt as good as madden 12 which is dissapointing

[maplestoryman77]

How was welker on the pats in 2k5 if he joined the pats in 2007?

[str1ver777]

COME BACK NFL 2k!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[dimsuminab0x]

NFL 2k5 had all this in 2004!!! ladies and gents...2004...enough said about Madden and Madden is introducing it now as "new" features. Imagine what the sports simulation would have been like if 2k had the licensing instead of EA.

[TVExotic]

EA Sports and 2k Sports should just take the best features from each game to create a better football game

[IbleedXBOX]

@TVExotic That would be a monopoly if your talking business

[cezz505]

EA should be shame!

[MICHAEL24AZ]

i like how when you get tackled in 2K5 you slide one the grass if madden had that more, like when being tackled in the snow and rain it would be the best, its THE LITTLE things that make me love the football games. there has not been a good madden game sense 09.

[MrSteaglesFan]

if NFL 2K5 had Madden's graphics and player realism it would be the best game in the history of sports games

[MICHAEL24AZ]

@MrSteaglesFan thats what i said

[MrSteaglesFan]

@MICHAEL24AZ LOL

[chriscross987654321]

thats y backbreaker is better

[bts1995]

backbreaker's physics and realism is the shit. if they merged with Madden or 2K, i would shit a brick

[86ETA]

Fuck 2k5 old shit

[55Tonythetigar]

madden 12 is alot more better than NFL 2k5 sure 2k5 is good just not as good as Madden 12!!

[iAmYoungWattz]

I loved the ability to have my own house, first person football, the espn broadcasting kept me entertained, overall the game was just sick. I wish madden had competition with nfl 2k13

[nguyenthanh8]

I fuckn miss 2k5!! Like c'mon ea! Get real! Why have an espn licensed game when you have nothing to do with espn presentation in the game.. With today's hardware and new technology if done right it would look awesome !

[thementalpatient2005]

I wonder if it's legal for xbox live and psn to rerelease NFL2k5 in HD and allow us fans to create the rosters and share them online.

[thatkid780]

madden sucks face it they dont care its money, like cod everyone buys it becuase its madden.

[LoganfarbarTV]

im sorry but i disagree i think madden has ALWAYS been better to me

[tydogg721]

2k5 baby!!!!!!!!!!!!

[281LUCHADOR]

It is sad dat 2k will not be able to do another game for a long time

[Lrvinator]

how are the rosters up to date for 2k5???

[MrJbblood]

Creatin people on madden 12 the people look faker than 2010

[coryisreal]

Madden is garbage. I WANT ESPN NFL 2K13

[MrBFVL]

They should just create NFL 2K13 for next time :D

[sigspits]

madden only has graphics and the ability of online play over 2k5.

[YankeesWin20]

I love both games.... I still play 2k5 and madden... Really it's not a big deal and i dont care what anyone else think it's YOUR opinion so im not going to judge you on it

[gokeith6789]

2k5 sucks

[starwarsROXmy]

@gokeith6789 Really? If it does suck, then why are you watching this video?

[askalucas411]

@gokeith6789 did u seriously just watch the video and say that? or are u just blind and only see eye candy on the madden side

idiot

[Collabsonthego]

tumbs up if your still playing nfl 2k5 in 2011

[Mako4409]

LOL EA knew this well and hence renewed exclusivity. NFL 2k6 woulda been better than madden 12 loool

[TheMrdolphins321]

I really dont understand why u r comparing NFL 2K5 and Madden 12. Madden 12 is a better game with great graphics and gameplay. U need to get over it because EA bought out the rights. If this review made u sad plz visit this website pornhub.com.

[starwarsROXmy]

@TheMrdolphins321 LOL OK KID HAAHAHA YOU MAKE ME LAUGH!

[suny123boy1]

@TheMrdolphins321

Actually the game play is better than madden 12. If you've ever played 2k5 you would agree.

[millionacb]

lol 4:08 thats wat happens when u put a rookie at qb

[HateMeSomeMe]

Honestly I'm sick of playing 2k5.... I need madden's graphics with 2k5's gameplay

[TheSnapPrince]

Amen!! Its funny how EA is still playing catch-up to 2k. 2k kills franchise/dynasty modes. Im still playing College Hoops 2k8 and ESPN Franchise/Dynasty mode. The only thing I play madden for is online. One big difference between the two: Foot-Planting :) Agility actually means something now

[JMarky33]

2k5 is gay.

[Curtis123888]

Its 2011 and I still playing NFL 2K5 on my Xbox 360

[metalrave]

Espn only had to try once to prefect the football game. Madden is still practicing.

[KWelch60]

shut up you fuckers. madden is better. 2K5 was not "mind-blowing" it was a forgetable sports game. madden 12 is acually the best football game ever. go falcons!

[bunghole211]

@KWelch60 something tells me your an EA fanboy 2k5 was way better hands down and still is better

[miamiheatmattwade]

@KWelch60 finally someone with some goddamn sense!!

[TheSteelersguy07]

ya i think madden 12 is really fun but after a while it gets a little boring but i think it is better than 2k5

[55Kamari]

Good Job

[dscribbz]

Pretty sure the Packers beat the Chargers 45-38...

[brycet1991]

its 2011 quit talking about a game that came out in 2004!!!!

[metalrave]

@brycet1991 Its just sad that a game that came out in 2004 still surpasses a franchise that is still practicing to make a good fb game

[TrueSimGamer]

Subbed!!!

[TrueSimGamer]

What's good @SportsGamerShow?! I just updated ESPN NFL 2k5. The NFL 2k12 season is in full effect. Go check it out on my channel. My latest video has the link to download the zip file for the Franchise and rosters.

[SportsGamerShow]

@TrueSimGamer Nice. Went ahead and accepted your video response. Thanks for the link.

[jet4212006]

@SportsGamerShow

how did you update your roster?

[SportsGamerShow]

@jet4212006 nfl2k5rosters-dot-com

[suny123boy1]

@jet4212006

operation sports forums.

[PS3rocks09]

i remember buying 2k5 a few years ago for almost no reason but i loved it. i must admit it is arguably the best football video game out there still today. i always thought 2k sports kinda sucked until i played this game and nba 2k11 and 2k12. 2k sports mlb still needs some work but no matter what im getting the show. nba 2k5 still comepetes with games today. too bad the ps3 slim doesnt play ps2 games cuz i would be playing 2k5 all day

[TheFocusNation]

remember madden moments? yea in madden 09 we had it but in 2k5 we had it to haha

[louiedaboss992]

@TheFocusNation yea rite,dat 25th anerversiery syht.Lol

[MrfryREBORN]

More bias bullshit by nostalgiafags...

[jake92558]

of course 2k5 would win its the best football game of all time madden just came out with the no suction thing while 2k5 had that 7 years ago the presentation blows madden out the water that whole fight for every yard thing that came out last year guess what 2k5 had that already too so from my point of view madden is taking 2k5 stuff and trying to make it better (which it cant of course ) Ea u piss me off so much

[PS3rocks09]

@jake92558 ikr ea's quality of games just keeps going down

[hustledotcom1]

amazing that no matter what your stance, a game from 7 years ago can still compete with a game of today!

[kaliz77]

When does the EA contract expire does anybody know because madden sucks LOL!!!

[NYxxTyler]

@kaliz77 they got a contract extension through 2014 i believe

[TheManiacc45]

Could you imagine if there were a 2k6, 7, 8, 9, ect?!?! Madden would be out of business PERIOD!!!

[natedoog07]

@TheManiacc45 like wat nba 2k11 did to nba live 11 lol....nba live didn't release at all...cause they know they got beat bad!!! lol

[MICHAEL24AZ]

@TheManiacc45 yea but EA is a bunch of pussys and knew that and bought out 2K

[JonnyLeeSwagger]

@TheManiacc45 just like NBA Live lol

[steamboatGriffin]

you have the nfl/espn license and dont use it like 2k5 did! and how is it that ncaa franchise just get madden previous improvement/equipemnt etc and it still plays way better than madden?

[colinpowers7]

How was Matt Ryan in 2K5?

[z4ng3tsu1ch1g0]

@colinpowers7 Updated rosters

[ReedinSD]

@colinpowers7 And Ryan Grant, and I think I saw Aaron Rodgers.

[suny123boy1]

@colinpowers7

roster updates

[ironman36]

the day i buy any Madden game is the day they release a game better than NFL 2k5.

[kobeshow24allday]

snice ea bought the rights for madden for a couple more years, the next 2k game will be espn nfl 2k15 :[

[Mystic2k17]

@kobeshow24allday 2k14 it runs out in january of 2013 so you habe one more year of madden

[awesomenessdude100]

Its amazing that it took Madden till 2011 to create a game that is even close to a game that is in 2004. Thats amazing.

[XxXTacosXxX]

Lol its not 2ks fault..its ea. They have the rights to the nfl so thwy cant make football games

[reliablethreat23]

i can only imagin how awesome a yearly NFL 2k game would be!!!...if they put as much work into its my player mode like nba 2k's, its my player mode would be everything i've ever wanted in a football game!!!...COME ON 2K MAKE A FUCKING NFL FOOTBALL GAME ALREADY!!!!...HOW LONG MUST WE WAIT FOR THIS SHIT???

[xNIKEGOLFx]

This is so sad but sooooo true. ESPN NFL 2k5 > Madden 12

[cocainmonster]

EA is just a bad company, I had to spend a extra 10 dollars each for their "Online Pass" to play online. Such BS

[paranormalactivity91]

Damn, i bought NFL 2k5 for $20. That $20 lasted for the last 6 years. Even though i don't play it anymore i remember updating the roster every year by creating a high profile player i.e. Reggie Bush and i never minded cuz the experience outweighed every Madden game since then (except maybe Madden 06)

[doiknowyousir]

@paranormalactivity91 $20 lasted the past 7 years...the 7 years for madden have been $420 and not worth it. Glad to hold onto to the money and play an enjoyable, realistic, and fun game. :-)

[DJStefixx]

EA is pathetic... NFL2k5 is better then Madden 12.

NBA2k5 is better then NBA Live 10 (they had to quit it was that bad)

and PES 5 is better then FIFA 12.

They should just quit!

[MsFuckduck]

@DJStefixx Hahahahah wtf now you're just being gay with 2K5 being better than Live and PES being better than fifa

[DJStefixx]

@MsFuckduck

You seriously think that Live has shit on 2K? They stopped making Live cause it couldn't compare to 2K. Only a total idiot could respect Live starting in 06. And the gameplay of PES 5 is still to this better then both PES 12 and FIFA 12. That's why theres still hundreds of thousands of people playing PES 5 with current roster updates. The only thing that these new games have are graphics, their gameplay has barely improved!

[MsFuckduck]

@DJStefixx I didn't say the Live franchise has shit on 2k dumbass. I said 2k5 isn't better than Live 10

[GaggleofDoozies]

I can't believe I just watched a vid of Madden 12 compared to a 7 year old game...wow..., that's pretty weird.

[love14601]

wow

[VikeFan284296]

Ummmm.... why wasn't the CRIB mentioned???

[packerfan748]

ok, i bought madden for the first time since 09 because i really loved the demo. THe game speed felt better as well as the throwing and it felt all around better. I was really excited for it. My excitement went down a little when i got the complete game. The fact that madden still does not have timing routes like 2k5 (throwing the ball to a spot before receiver breaks his route) was dissapointing and missing other basic elements. And 2k5 still has that amazing organic feel to the game.

[NSCJ1234]

i want to go out and buy a ps2 just so I can play NFL 2k5!!!!

[ThikPaper]

Commentators in madden 12 are the worrsstttt

[NeasePanters7]

That's not fair to use graphics. If you use the graphics, how about you use a good example? Seriously. How can you compare an xbox/ps2 game to ps3/xbox 360 games? Are you mental? imo, NFL 2k5 looks amazing for a 7 year old game. Can you imagine what NFL 12 would look like with the budget and NFL rights? Madden 12 is the best looking NFL game ever because they owned the rights to the NFL. We don't have ANY other views on how a NFL game should look. Madden 12 looks nice, but gameplay falls short

[ithrowtdz]

that vincent jackson shot fooled me.... It looks like a modern game so I thought it had to be madden

[TyRTi]

Not NFL 12 but what is that other game? Madden 2025?

[TheTechnoloqic]

oh hell yes, 2k5 was the shit.

[THROCKSFULable]

EA needs to come to realization that their developers are dumbasses and aren't as smart as 2k developers

[WeMadCuzTheyBad]

good job EA, after 7 seven years, you got better graphics.

[Jellybeantiger]

LOL @ EA raving about their "new" impact engine in Fifa 12 when NFL 2k5 had this 6 years ago.

[Jellybeantiger]

I'd love to see what 2k sports do to soccer if they had the chance ,even an Aussie Rules game.

20 million Aussie customers here waiting to pay for a great Ausie Rules game.

Massive market untouched.

P.S. I still have my xbox version of NFL 2k5 and love it.

[dagodfatharico]

wow, even on a playstation 2/xbox nfl 2k5 actually gives madden 12 a run when it comes to graphics

[TheLilgalaxy]

i got nfl2k5 when it first came out and juz beat it

[peterchaseify]

2K studios > EA.......the NFL monopoly has to stop and it has to stop soon

[ToddlerEater]

this is just embarrassing for madden. how can a game 7 years older still be so much worse? madden is TERRIBLE. for me, it is literally unplayable its so bad.

[KaRonpage]

I believe NFL 2k5 is still better than Madden 12, I still see time and time again players on defense just randomly falling or stumbling on the floor right in front of the person running with the ball to make it look like he was in the play.......

[funkyflights]

Only thing about NFL 2k5 that was bothersome was the qb sneak... The line-backers and D line didn't react well... BUT I'm not capping on 2k5 because it was still and amazing game overall... Some of the old Madden games were great also .... Madden 2001-2002 I loved... But man I haven't bough a Madden new Gen game since Madden 2006... WHAT garbage!!! This football monopoly crap has to stop.... WE need competition so the products get better....

[Silverandblack95]

gameplay no madden wins but presentation but madden says expect the best commentary in a madden game ever

[P715R]

I'm not a 2k fanboy, I was playing Madden for many years and loved it. Honestly, I hesitated to buy a game that was $20 but i tried it. 2K5 to this day is a game I would play just for the fun of it or for the real feel to it. EA....where's the fun? it's still in 2k5! thanks for the great review/feedback

[MultiMasterflash]

Madden 12 is better overall.

That's not an opinion, it's a fact.

[aharannepacheco]

what about 2k11 that looks bad

[xRedFoo209x]

if they give me madden for free.I'd rather get NFL 2K5 for 10 bucks or less

[THEsquirrel3d]

You know, this is a perfect example of what happens when you have no competition. And yet the sheeple still buy this every year. *shakes head*

[mikemck09]

AMEN!!!!!!!

[nickstencel]

Hate to break it you all, but 2K Football is not coming back anytime soon (SOURCE: 2K Customer Service, Via Email)

[matteoking7]

I would do anything for NFL 2k12

[MrJoseramirez31]

@matteoking7 I HAVENT BOUGHT A FOOTBALL GAME SINCE 2K STOPPED MAKING THEM

[big70nhs]

@matteoking7 you said a mouthful

[KaRonpage]

@matteoking7 Omg me 2

[Hulkamaniac418]

I just don't understand how a football game that is SIX years older than the current Madden has better presentation. It's ridiculous. "Oh, look at our fancy grass." ESPN NFL 2K5 is one of the best sports games I've ever played.

[StonedRambo01]

2K sports animation sends EA back to 10 yard fight !!! You are an absolute IDIOT if you buy EA sports titles every year !!! I could start an EA dick'n the entire industry channel if you want. EA as a company sucks balls !! They try to buy their way to the top instead of working hard and making better games.

[ActionedOut23]

wow nfl 2k5 was just ahead of its time 2k really need to come back & start making football games again they do shit the RIGHT way 

[2011mrkingofkings]

If Madden NFL 2012 doesn't have any playable hall of famers (NFL greats) I'll skip Madden NFL 2012, if it does, I'll give it a chance since I haven't play any new Madden games since Madden NFL 2010.

[xaver351]

madden 12 definetily

[Elvception1979]

You have to admit EA buying the NFL rights and not doing absolutely nothing with it is gotta lame and then they turn around and charge you $60 for it, you gotta be kidding me and all that becuz the other guy was offering a great product for the low price of $20. I'll be really pissed off too heck I was really pissed off but then I realized that things will work themselves out in the end. Heck just knowing the fact that the NFL had talks with 2K Games may be a sign of good things to come.

[THEsquirrel3d]

I wish I could get this NFL2K5 update on my Xbox 360. I don't have the PS2 version (or a PS2 itself).

[H2OMelon93]

Hes not comparing replay values cause its not fair, but comparing graphics is?

[MarzetJunior]

the thing i hate about tackling on madden is that u cant reach out and grab a ballcarrier

u have to have at least half of ur body near him and make a tackle,

in Real Life sometimes snatching the ballcarrier up but failing 2 make the tackle so your teammate can finish him off is all you need to and can do.

[aaljboy]

2k5 is just a classic....The guy said 2k5 is better then madden unbiased opinion .lol...isint that saying something???

[lhemphill3]

WOW a game that came out 8 years ago is better than madden 12. FUCK EA!!!

[earlmccormick88]

I miss NFL 2K5! The best football game ever made. It has been compared to every madden game for the past couple of years, why? Because NFL 2k is the greatest!

[Elvception1979]

I agree but the real reason that NFL 2K5 gets compared to the Madden Franchise is that NFL 2K5 was light years ahead of Madden in nearly everything from Graphics Presentation and Gameplay. Its was a Revolutionary Sports Game while Madden is just another sports game. LOL

[ofpveteran73]

@earlmccormick88 No because they have annoying fan boys.

[Elvception1979]

@ofpveteran73 I can't front I am but I'm also a Hard Core Gaming fan and I call it like I see it.