This is a perfect performance... so touching... so pure... nothing else... beautiful lyrics and voice... no more... pathetic Hong Kong music society... no more...
@tessachar It was Faye Wong Scenic Tour 1998/99 -- 7 concerts in China and one in Japan, 17 concerts at Hong Kong Coliseum: 24 Dec 1998 - 9 Jan 99, then 5 more in Singapore, USA & Japan... I attended the one in Hong Kong in Dec 1988. The concert was released on CD and VCD. Great show!
王菲的聲音像個小心翼翼又怕受傷的孩子
聽了只有心疼...
MidoriG05 2 days ago
当时的王菲如此让人怀念。。。
sinsing46 3 weeks ago
这曲还是那英版的要好听,很有女人的沧桑感……
王菲的比较浮。
cactusxj 2 months ago
感觉王菲的版本有低吟的感觉,很随意,却又直达心里,喜欢这个版本~
zhengm2653 2 months ago
每個人的詮釋都不同, 而且各自的版本都很有自己的味道在裹面,
不同人總會偏好某版本, 因為他們被那一個版本的感覺感動了,
我覺得每個版本帶始我的都是感動和驚喜.
mikissue 2 months ago
合音很美
hello2100000 3 months ago
有忘詞!!!
ricky9301 4 months ago
百聽不厭,真的很喜歡這一首歌,王菲唱得很輕鬆自然,有種和世界保持一定距離的冷静與超凡脱俗之感!很棒!
cecilia861224 5 months ago 3
感性的王菲,她的孤芳自賞,永遠給人遙不可及的感覺,只可遠觀而不可褻玩,不食人間煙火。
pamchow 5 months ago
I really like it. Thanks? for uploading.
mac7915 5 months ago
田馥甄
s27945 5 months ago
多么真实
cookingtip 5 months ago
王菲的聲音
好像一個女孩在愛情裡受傷時
還帶著一點愛的夢與愛的糾結
然後由女孩轉變為女人的過程.....
a172387 5 months ago 4
菲,这首歌你让我流泪不止T.T
实在太好听了!
johnson0429 5 months ago
The first time I heard this song, it made me cry. I wish I could find a way to download this song somewhere--it's just too beautiful!
amsiemonster 6 months ago
This is a perfect performance... so touching... so pure... nothing else... beautiful lyrics and voice... no more... pathetic Hong Kong music society... no more...
at9134 7 months ago
王菲婉转空灵的声音诠释的比较好
pyuzhu 8 months ago 2
感覺上王菲現在的聲音比這個演唱會時的弱了,
是因為吸烟的關係嗎?
Kenny2HK 9 months ago
@Kenny2HK
可能是喔 不過後來她戒菸了
gogo20021 3 months ago
唱错了后她自己也笑了。多么真实,多么自然,比那些假唱的做作的女歌手好太多了。这才是天后!
fengtianyuseven 9 months ago
听了王菲的歌总有自己把自己提起来的冲动
beinini 9 months ago
这场演唱会王菲状态很好啊
mrasenca 10 months ago
女神~
thebeanbody 10 months ago
面對王非,我想沒有人有評論的權利!!
sidneycheng67 1 year ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
田馥甄
s27945 1 year ago
王菲這個版本很隨意清新,完了歌聲竟還縈繞在腦海,伴奏的三個結他手演譯得很好。
kennyyg 1 year ago 6
王菲唱得好浪漫~ 喜歡
jiadarxd 1 year ago 5
@jiadarxd I feel the same
craigyuyu 1 year ago
@jiadarxd I feel the same
craigyuyu 1 year ago
声音很好听,可是远没有那英的有感觉。节奏太快,浮和飘的感觉。像极了谈恋爱时的小姑娘 ,没有那英的沧桑和痛醒后的悟。
suiyifeng 1 year ago 5
那英和王菲什麼時候才要同台啊
gordonwu543 1 year ago 7
@gordonwu543 1998 Chinese New Year performance! Great song.
googoochung 1 year ago
当时菲菲还是感冒着的,好心疼
wuqiqi520 1 year ago 2
Faye's version has better background music. sweeter, like a young girl's dream. like it...
ivannmh2000 1 year ago
王菲誯的比較好聽
v123456757 1 year ago
@v123456757 那英的比较有沧桑感,可能没受过伤的人不懂吧。王菲的很甜,但没什么感觉
piaoxue89 1 year ago
@piaoxue89 赞同你的话!那英的比较好听,很容易引起共鸣
fuimeng0919 1 year ago
夢醒了 - 王菲!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
poyinchang 1 year ago
王菲这首歌真的是一气呵成。
miloqing 1 year ago 3
身為一個男人
聽完那英的版本 我會惆悵若有所失
聽完王菲的版本 我會回頭抱住那個女人
qaazzz 1 year ago 33
@qaazzz 你的見解,深入我心...^^
wushumei2075 1 year ago
touching......and i cried
yumikonutfu 2 years ago
「天亮了 我還是不是你的女人」
王菲的歌都是感人的
elaineng03 2 years ago
王菲好靚
bbpigtoy 2 years ago 11
i miss faye
gloryyyyy 2 years ago 7
I was there and enjoyed the concert 110%!
Apt192 2 years ago 4
where was this concert? and when was it?
tessachar 1 year ago
@tessachar It was Faye Wong Scenic Tour 1998/99 -- 7 concerts in China and one in Japan, 17 concerts at Hong Kong Coliseum: 24 Dec 1998 - 9 Jan 99, then 5 more in Singapore, USA & Japan... I attended the one in Hong Kong in Dec 1988. The concert was released on CD and VCD. Great show!
Apt192 1 year ago
@tessachar it was from Faye Wong Scenic Tour 1998/99. this recording in particular was the concert on the new year's eve of 1999 in HK.
youchocolateme 1 year ago
both also good...i like all..
hellokitty2815 2 years ago
「天亮了 我還是不是你的女人」
這句的口氣真要命。
monicalhn 2 years ago 141
大家都有自己喜歡的版本 但 都是最棒!!
tubeisthebestweb 2 years ago 5
听着歌词,想起王菲与窦唯的过去,好像特别有味道.就凭这一点,我觉得王菲的翻唱略胜一筹.
zephyr84 2 years ago 7
王菲的聲音有一種空靈的感覺,像是好久以後的她在述說一份曾經刻苦銘心的感情,我也是比較喜歡她的詮釋
tamaki0114 2 years ago 76
我还是比较喜欢那英的版本.
songokudeen 2 years ago 3
王菲的轉音真是美
549846526598 2 years ago 13
我也觉得这首歌王菲比那英唱得更好﹗
lajabom1 2 years ago 16
屁拉.那英的版本比較好.王菲的聲音乾淨但沒什麼磁性
egg2201 1 year ago
我觉得这首歌王菲比那英唱的要好一点 比较有感觉
bell2566 2 years ago 11
这首歌我还是觉得那英主唱,王菲和音,很好听,因为两种不同声音,有对比的美感。
shanaling 2 years ago 2
我的最愛
kikobuddy 2 years ago
love faye very very much!
she presented the song in a complete different way (from na ying)!! love them both!
lollipop2046 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
好, I like dat!
WrestlingKingTV 2 years ago
0:32忘词了吧
laohu000 3 years ago 7
合音部分真的...很美很美!
hero9992000 3 years ago 4
miss her so much.... i have this orginal vcd before but had given it to my gf. anyone knows where can i buy?
hyl3389 3 years ago
probably u can look around ebay, someone selling at US$29.99, with Item number: 380077733745
jazz2859 3 years ago
hi jazz2859, thank you so much for your recommendation.
hyl3389 3 years ago
The greatest Chinese singer I've ever known.
crazylockwood 3 years ago 8
i've been waiting for this post.
Loves it....
djonutube 3 years ago
beautiful song, faye wong sang it very well
flybaby82 3 years ago 5