I must say that I'm not overtly impressed. I simply find that the song and the video were not a proper fit. The clips just don't seem to have the right flow with the music, nor do they seem to really match the lyrics. Perhaps even to the point of disorganization. Nevertheless, there are signs of effort.
TBH the point of an amv is to act like a music video, a music video should make sense without the need to watch something first, thus if you can not relate the music and the anime together without watching the show, then it does need some improvements.
yea but if u dont know what the anime is about you shouldnt be makin opinions about it. only if u know the anime can u say that its crappy and needs work.
an amv isn't supposed to be about the show, they are supposed to try to match the music studio's standards, it's an extremely difficult thing to do, and even though i am not as good as a music studio yet, i agree that until you produce that quality, and even when you do, you deserve criticism, otherwise, how would we know what the public wants, or what we need to improve. bad yet constructive criticism is way more helpful than good as we can build on it.
firstly dumbass, i was stating that he says there is no resemblance between whats going on in the vid and the lyrics to the song. if he had seen the show then he would have known what was going on and thus informing him on the comparison. get your facts straight before you go ranting.
This video is really good quality and the song is awsome,but the clips didn't have anything to do with the song.Also,if you pick just one or two topics(as in a character or a pairing),it will be easier to figure out what to do and the video will make more sense and have an actual meaning to it.
Hey, i was the gal who like made this video, and well, yeah i get where ya coming from, i made this quite a while ago though and i didn't really care about what the music was about. :P
this song dosen't really go with fullmetal, sorry
78lecamino 10 months ago
this song makes no sense with no clips at all
fjsonic 11 months ago
I'm just watching a bunch of FMA amvs and feeling nostalgic...
DoodleJumpAddict 11 months ago
The song does not seem to be synced with the clips at all....
StarlightKonata 11 months ago 4
Need to connect the scenes with the music.
TheSaintArbiter 1 year ago
i love this song
TheStarfishMonkey 1 year ago
what episodes is it from 1:28 to 3:30 ???
i like it hehe
sweettobigirl 1 year ago
@sweettobigirl episodes 4 and 5. The one with the blue rose is 4. and the one with ed ontop of the train is 5.
Suigin118 8 months ago
XD Ed pwned the guy with a knee in the face! lol^^
BadEevee 2 years ago
I like how at 3:12 they say "You!" And the subtitle on the video said "You...!" XD
But yeah, very nice video~! :DD
KumoriKururugi 2 years ago
@KumoriKururugi 3:10 my bad
KumoriKururugi 2 years ago
3 days grace kinda scares me... but i lov the band. is that odd?
ArtIsABang432 2 years ago
@ArtIsABang432 no not really some younger kids like this music but get creeped out by the band's make-up or clothes
legoindyproductions 1 year ago
great band: Three Days Grace
great anime: Full Metal Alchemist.
love it 5/5
anyonecrazy56 2 years ago
Love the song & Really miss the anime... Only thing that could make this better is having scenes from more than the first 5 episodes or so.
Zodiac0racle 2 years ago
maaaan. i miss that anime.
electricrad 2 years ago 2
cool
sasukeslove19 2 years ago
massachutess
KIOSHI100 2 years ago
Ed+ME= is true love (H) haha
Ichiigo15 3 years ago
I love that song TRHEE DAYS GRACE ROCKS
^.^ Adam Gontier he so cool!!
Phantogirl 3 years ago
hey who wrote that song??
amaliadominga 3 years ago 2
Three Days Grace
Kodyjr4 3 years ago 4
♫ - ♫
saya4haji 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Ed+Rose=LOVE 4 EVER!!!! =]
Toshy990 3 years ago
Ed+ Me= Love :P
ILuvUchihaItachi 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ed+ME= Undying Love (Hahaha)
StephMcKay3 3 years ago
Ed + WINRY = Love 4 ever
Rose fails
heh heh
Ermi5432 3 years ago 2
hey guys can u remind me what eppisode it is when ed is in the desert place i cant remember -.-'' so uhh can some1 tell me XD excelent amv btw
chris31795 3 years ago
1 o.o
animemistress669 2 years ago
That song is soo cool poor Ed and Al
SasorisHelper 3 years ago 2
I must say that I'm not overtly impressed. I simply find that the song and the video were not a proper fit. The clips just don't seem to have the right flow with the music, nor do they seem to really match the lyrics. Perhaps even to the point of disorganization. Nevertheless, there are signs of effort.
TheFerretofDoom 3 years ago 4
this song rules
EDGEoFiCE 3 years ago
this vid makes no sense with the clips and song
anonfalcon 3 years ago 26
@anonfalcon I'll have to agree the vid is great the song is great but together it's just a weird combination
Twiggymaster666 1 year ago
i LOVE it
sagitterius2728 3 years ago
i like dis song
...yes
misterman0007 3 years ago 4
???
W3BKINZ4LIVE 3 years ago
cooles amv.
JackDragon02 3 years ago
Stop complaining about the damn video and be happy that your hearing the amazing song!
prestonkillz 3 years ago 2
Little variety, and seemed more like a video slideshow than a AMV.
Orochimustang 3 years ago
ha ed fell down
karmaluvr 3 years ago
Extrem i love it
makosharkman 3 years ago
This simply doesn't work.. How does the song link with anyone on the video? Needs much improvement in my opinion..
Haphazy 4 years ago
well then get a better opinioon and watch the show
promaniac120 3 years ago
TBH the point of an amv is to act like a music video, a music video should make sense without the need to watch something first, thus if you can not relate the music and the anime together without watching the show, then it does need some improvements.
zorbon 3 years ago 4
yea but if u dont know what the anime is about you shouldnt be makin opinions about it. only if u know the anime can u say that its crappy and needs work.
cadoo13 3 years ago
an amv isn't supposed to be about the show, they are supposed to try to match the music studio's standards, it's an extremely difficult thing to do, and even though i am not as good as a music studio yet, i agree that until you produce that quality, and even when you do, you deserve criticism, otherwise, how would we know what the public wants, or what we need to improve. bad yet constructive criticism is way more helpful than good as we can build on it.
zorbon 3 years ago 4
its not made to relate to everyone in the world therefore it doesnt need improvements maybe this was made only to relate to people who like the show?
havok4 3 years ago
firstly dumbass, i was stating that he says there is no resemblance between whats going on in the vid and the lyrics to the song. if he had seen the show then he would have known what was going on and thus informing him on the comparison. get your facts straight before you go ranting.
promaniac120 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
promaniac: I've watched the show three times over, so I think I have an idea what's going on with it.
Haphazy 3 years ago
dude you right, this douche dunno no, but im not one to talk, i haven't seen the show often
EDGEoFiCE 3 years ago
What ep is 2:16?
x0dragonfly0x 4 years ago
episode 4
AyaxEd9 3 years ago
i love this song =/
DarkJennylynn 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
you have o improve your cut, its yust too longgggggggggggg, and try a movie frame... the subs are anoying
all in all its ok
adsklgqhgiae 4 years ago
omg i luv this song so much. I like the video too.
fluffysama91 4 years ago 3
Awsomeness XD
AresGrim 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
what up bitches and hoes!!!
uvtx 4 years ago
<< i agree with kaori be better if the song had a clip that linked to it x .x then it'd be awesome
Daemon102 5 years ago
dude i love this song 2...
Kagoma5656 5 years ago 3
dude i luv this song soo much...
animekid414 5 years ago 3
This video is really good quality and the song is awsome,but the clips didn't have anything to do with the song.Also,if you pick just one or two topics(as in a character or a pairing),it will be easier to figure out what to do and the video will make more sense and have an actual meaning to it.
Kaorichan92 5 years ago 2
Hey, i was the gal who like made this video, and well, yeah i get where ya coming from, i made this quite a while ago though and i didn't really care about what the music was about. :P
ViolenceSmidge 4 years ago 2