Peyton hands down. Brady is good but there is no way he is as clutch as manning. and superbowls are a good thing but that doesn't mean anything player-wise. It takes an entire TEAM to make a superbowl, not one quarterback. Manning has more MVP trophies than Brady. plus just look at this season. Colts go without Manning and go 2-14, Pats without Brady go 11-5. Belichick has a better system thats why Brady has so much success. Peyton Manning > Tom Brady
I believe Peyton is the more talented of the two but Brady's more laid back demeanor allows him to come through more in the cluth, which is why he's had more success.
brady is not bad but manning is
NotACreativeName32 2 days ago
Peyton hands down. Brady is good but there is no way he is as clutch as manning. and superbowls are a good thing but that doesn't mean anything player-wise. It takes an entire TEAM to make a superbowl, not one quarterback. Manning has more MVP trophies than Brady. plus just look at this season. Colts go without Manning and go 2-14, Pats without Brady go 11-5. Belichick has a better system thats why Brady has so much success. Peyton Manning > Tom Brady
XxHooyahNAVYxX 2 weeks ago
I believe Peyton is the more talented of the two but Brady's more laid back demeanor allows him to come through more in the cluth, which is why he's had more success.
KnightRider8731 1 month ago
Brady, it's close but Peyton is just about done and Tom has three super bowls and counting.. Go Pats!
mmj7464 1 month ago