Classic Game Room - AMY review

[GamerDan001]

PAT....I like it.

[chilliningamestop]

this game is a shit version res evil or silent hill

[Gamerguy4721]

Do not buy Amy. Do not play Amy. Do not look at Amy. Do not think about Amy. If your sister is named Amy, move to another country, and tell people your entire family was eaten by racist wolverines.

[michiyoyoshiku]

This game gets Autism all wrong....ALL WRONG.

[DeadlyMountainPro]

Is this for pc ?

[PSspecialist]

@DeadlyMountainPro why do you care? it sucks balls! it had a nice concept i'll give it that but the execution was pathetic.

[Kevb0ardGames]

expect RE5? well i would never even try a game if i knew it was like RE5...

RE5 killed off everything iconic of its series and for me it was the most disappointing game of this generation...

i played the demo of Amy and it wasnt that bad but i would never buy it :|

[PS3GAMER291]

I think they should discuss more. Less of the Q&A style it seems to be going for. Still awesome, though.

[purrex]

go solo plz.

[DamianWayne777]

I'm sorry, but I just cannot stand CGRUndertow and as such cannot bring myself to finish this video. I know the game sucks anyway but I have always enjoyed CGR reviews as he spends a decent amount of time on even the worst of games (I'm looking at you Mindjack) and usually persuades my opinion in getting them if only for the experience and achievement points. CGRUndertow however....your voice is annoying and your reviews are meh. Stay out of the normal Classic Game Room.

[RicardoB92]

are you guys doing a review on The simpsons arcade that's coming out for the ps3?

[AwlrightProductions]

Thumbs up of you thought the title was "ANY Review" and were confused for a sec

[nollie127]

@AwlrightProductions sorry im not dislexic

[miltbottleboy]

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. I see you face.

[misereiko666]

@GamerNinjaX 1st of all,you don't tell me what to do/say,you didn't understood my comment(i never skyrim was a fps & i didn't said that fps was the only genre today,learn to read completely & comprehend it,genius)you stop being judgemental & i say whatever i want(my 1st comment wasn't directed at anyone,the trolls are the ones that want to"down"my comment,but obviously they can't & never will)if you don't agree with a comment,don't reply & move on.

[VietnamTom1955]

dude with long hair sounds like scott pilgrim

[redsoxfan1984]

Get your undertow out of my OGCGR

[misereiko666]

@WirelessxD i don't care if you're a"skyrim hater",i bet you're one of those that hates all fps & new games(even the good ones)just because that was misfits do these days,how original(by the way,i have been a gamer since the atari days & i appreciate new games & have lots of them as my favorites & best of all time,same thing with some old ones.)

[GamerNinjaX]

@misereiko666 no offense but stop being so judgemental #1 and #2 skyrim is not even a first person shooter. I generally dont like shooters these days, (not that they are the only games out there these days) they are just so mindless and boring. but thats MY opinion, you dont have to put someone down for there opinions (unless he put you down first).

[misereiko666]

@fudgehog68 obviously no.

[aaronscrazieroo]

I don't approve of "Derek"........this is all.

[misereiko666]

so he reviews the worst game of this year so far but not the best game of last year. *sigh*-_-

[WirelessxD]

@misereiko666 And with this you mean skyrim? ._.

[fudgehog68]

@misereiko666 umm he reviewed MW3

[GamerNinjaX]

this game got pretty high scores (at least for this game) on the psn

[Haruchan2010]

@GamerNinjaX : lol what? Metacritic says differently.

And if by PSN you mean user ratings, I wouldn't take those seriously if I were you. Practically everything on PSN (and XBL even) is around the 4/5 star rating.

[MrRatedRRedneck]

@Haruchan2010 Yeah, playing Amy is like trying to play Vampire Rain, while being drunk, while spinning around in a chair.......that's how much I hate Amy, maybe went alittle over board with that analogie.

[Haruchan2010]

@MrRatedRRedneck : Naw I'd say it's accurate.

[spspear81]

worse than vampire rain?

[MacDonagh]

I went out and bought this straight when it came out. It is absolutely saddening because there were some great ideas that were poorly executed.

[djscottbrady]

derek? die. ginger. fucking. loser.

[IanCooked]

how does that sound like fear

[Sonic2332]

I still don't quite understand why people hate Amy so much. This guy doesn't seem to hate it, but his reasons for the game being a bad are rather vague in the video.

[EkajTheSwordsman]

@Sonic2332 Read Eurogamer's review.

[smackknot]

@Sonic2332 Try playing it yourself (as in the whole game) that's really the only way you'd be able to understand the hate for it.

[micol19]

pat

[Corad4]

''The game is called Amy, but that's why it should be called Pat!''

Oh no! I've had my fair share of zombies lately, I don't want to slaughter some more of those!

Good review, I will admit that the game does look interesting though.

[DoxiMoxi]

I want retro reviews......

[radioclash84]

go solo Mark

[guitarman2134568]

@radioclash84 Thats not very cool to say...bet you made the co-host feel good.

[LiamNeesonsDick]

Mark is hilarious, Derek is well-spoken in his similes and descriptiveness.

It's a good balance.

Anyone who says otherwise can go fuck themselves.

[Laternater]

Derek looks like he has Michael Cera's face mixed with the Geico Cavemen hairstyle. Ew :p

[Blazter55]

Seems like pretty much a really long escort-mission. Dreadful.

[crackedheretic]

I'll mash the buttons on my keyboard if you beat him with your lynx

[RnVjayB5b3UgTXVzbGlt]

im liking these reviews i dont understand some of you having a problem with this he still does solo reviews watch those ones only if you dont like it

[sprdvx]

Why do people have to hate on the gingers?

[mOike83]

@sprdvx because they have souls apparently

[ChimairaGod]

Postman Pat The Video Game????? If you don't know what im talking about just search Postman Pat.

[TheGravitationist]

I really don't get intense hatred for Derek some seem to have...

[mrnicktoyou]

They both have such beautiful hair. Lol, no homo.

[spinamajig]

I have to say, I really like these duo reviews! If people would just stop complaining...

[ItThunderbolt]

One thing about the game...it does not, I repet! DOES NOT! hold your hand, AT ALL!

[AFDex16]

@ItThunderbolt which is ironic, considering that you have to hold Amy's hand for alot of it, haha

[viet411]

Honestly Mark.... as much as I love your reviews, I really do. But this style of reviewing, don't know. I prefer you reviewing games on your own, it's more fun to watch and laugh at your silly puns and comedic humor on the games. This is good too, don't get me wrong, but it would be nice if you'd go back to the normal CGR Mark game reviews.

[PhillyBlunt6988]

@viet411 He has still been doing his normal reviews, this just seems to be an extra project he's trying out...I agree with you though his solo reviews are much better.

[ricky56]

i like derek WAY more then that other guy who played FF7 in a whole setting. i dunno his name but he is just not the comedic type

[JanettySupportTour]

Derrick looks like an ugly middle school girl

[PhillyBlunt6988]

@JanettySupportTour lol

[goldensolder44]

I thought Amy was about a radioactive monkey

[TheCageMage]

Ew. Co- op review. YUCK. Why? WHY?

[TheGravitationist]

@TheCageMage

What's so gross about it?

[colliric]

@svicciarelli

This is how they used to review games when they first started in 1999/2000.... so it's not new... it's old school "Game Room" style from before they were "Classic"!!!

Yes they've returned to it because fans like myself continually requested it.

[foxmakeba]

@colliric But with the OTHER ORIGINAL GUY!! NOT THIS DOUCHEBAG!!

[Goremaster]

Amy looks like it tried to be Ico...but instead of getting a stunned ghostly chick you get an autistic little girl...

[Guernicaman]

I only played the demo, so keep that in mind, and while there was A LOT wrong with Amy, esp. on the technical side, the game is nowhere near as bad as people are making it out to be. You get used to the combat rather quickly and there is a certain charm to the awfullness of the game.

[CAPCOM784]

i enjoyed the video and a 2nd opinion from someone else :))

[svicciarelli]

game review, I mean.

[svicciarelli]

is this the new format for every game?

[Boomhauer393]

Somebody send him an Atari Jaguar ffs.

[indydriver80]

Nice haircut Mark, looking spiffy!

[munk109]

Wow the Classic game room guy looks like an Imp

[piplupZero]

You really need to stop name dropping old console in every review.....

[RadiumZ1]

Mark...your face always looks like your going to crack up. You such a F#%KING joker man, I love it. I live for your videos.

[Weirdreviewsnerd]

I like Amy! Pat on the back please.

[Starwars4J]

My main problem with these new co-hosted reviews (and yes I'm aware of CGR history) is that Mark has been reduced to someone who interviews other people about the games rather than showing his own knowledge and giving his own interesting takes on gameplay and mechanics. He's pretty much just around to supply the charisma the other hosts sorely lack, and that's a shame. Most of us watch this channel for Mark's take, not...this :/

[Croxyndul]

I like these reviews when he's with another person.

[Weirdreviewsnerd]

@Booine7272 Not sure how hes a hipster...

[Arquenemeh]

@Booine7272 There's that word again. I don't think it means what you think it means.

[dotsydude]

@Booine7272 thats no hipster!!! thats derrick!!!!!

[RJTamm93]

@Booine7272 Hipster? The classic CGR was like this. :|

[Booine7272]

@RJTamm93 i used to love the older cgr episodes with guest reviewers. i just never really liked Derek

[skatepunk217]

@Booine7272 Hey you....lose the false sense of authority and go back to being a noob.

[ansharzero]

@Booine7272 Yeah, this sounds kind of cruel, but I almost instantly stop watching lately just because I see that guy there. Yikes.

[waterbuffalo901]

@Booine7272 lmao, when did nerds become hipsters

[helmybuhary]

Hahahah! "Button mash n swing an atari links on you later" mark ur hilarious!

[yokoshima1000]

It was fine to me.I think some people are just way to picky now days.No wonder people wonder why kids are to spoiled now days,just saying.Dont mean to offend anyone here.

[digioverlord]

@yokoshima1000 pffft if aything these kids missed out and WE were the spoiled ones :P

[yokoshima1000]

@digioverlord lol yeah they did miss out on the super nintendo oh how i wish i had one still XD

[TheFreakRocker]

mark can you go back to reviewing games instead of showing off your retro consoles and using them in every joke. dont get me wrong, love every single one of your reviews, but this style of reviewing is gettin offtrack...

[xXE4GLEyEXx]

i w8 for Last Of Us :D

[LupusRexRgis]

Derek's review on CGR Undertow was better.

[91238673]

When this video first started I thought some chick named Amy was sitting next to Mark.

[djscottbrady]

@91238673 i wish derek would die

[Haruchan2010]

I thought it was terrible. I had to push myself to even bother once the first zombie died so easily after ONE HIT of a weapon.

[Haruchan2010]

@Haruchan2010 : ALso it's not just "some" bad reviews...it's overwhelmingly negative by both users AND critics.

[CyberLance26]

I just beat Amy and i actually really liked it.

Its far from a masterpiece but it was a very fun game and got pretty scary sometimes.

It sure does not deserve the bad reputation it got.

[jerzy862]

I never thought Derek would look like this. I imagined a polished guy in a button down shirt or something haha.

[Bloodthr0e]

@jerzy862 I used to imagine a 12 year old who carried around a thesaurus everywhere.

[daivenluo]

can't justify a bad game with low price. I rather pay full 60 bucks for a good game than get a free game that's bad.

[Uuzuki]

Mark, play Deadly Premonition!

[althoir88]

Derek's the best co-reviewer you got man!

[FuckDragonQuest]

mark/jen reviews next?

[chocholatefrenchpudd]

no hud like dead space?

[jcmbica]

derek is a retard. i like sega.. @youjoshing

[fsmetal]

MORE MARK/DEREK REVIEWS!

[HawkBasham]

I wanna smoke Derek up. I mean; look at that hair. He's a pothead.

[YouJoshing]

Dereks cool he likes Nintendo, Mark likes Sega, they complete each other. I happen to like Sega.

[Yoshigotraped]

Review Soul Calibur V!

[KrownClown]

this game blows so bad.

[cgamyes]

amy (the little girl) look scary

[Sakotius]

@cgamyes

So it's not a AAA title. maybe their are better titles, but what does that have to do with it. Point is, it's never going to be as polished as i retail release

[Sakotius]

It's a frigging arcade game. Give it some leeway :L

[KrownClown]

@Sakotius so? there is wayyyyyyyy better games than this on the arcade

[joselito2379]

ITS CALLED AMY! what would you expect!

[ShyBoy6D9]

Haha. I like Derek. Not a big fan of TJ, though. Seems like he tries too hard to be funny.

Co-host criticism aside, I gotta say THANK YOU for not totally bashing a game for not being the greatest game around. Of course that's only to be expected from a CGR video, but people these days obviously haven't played truly bad games, at least in a long time.

[Picogeta]

I quite enjoyed the game. It's not a masterpiece, but it's by no means worthy of the bashing it's been subjected to.

[gamegloss]

@Picogeta I wouldn't quite say that. It's probably one of the worst games to come out in a very long time, or at least one of the worst that I've played in a least the past 5 years or so. Though I haven't really played that many bad games this decade. I suppose your impression of the game is more relative than mine. What's your point of reference? (what worse games have you played?)

[Picogeta]

@gamegloss Well, considering it's a 10 Euro game and I mostly play the big releases, it's hard to put them on the same level, but I will say that I enjoyed "Amy" better than "Resident Evil 5", or the lastest "Silent Hill" incarnations. Even in other genres, I liked it better than other big names I bought on release, like "Brink". I know those are hardly stellar games by themselves, but see, at least with "Amy" I had the feeling that I was playing a game that was trying to do things differently.

[ch0k0latemuffin]

picked up resident evil 4 HD a week ago

RE 4 = 20 $

AMY = 10$

RE 4 = still an amazing game - took me 15 hours to complete

AMY = no idea, I'm fine with resident evil

[cooleo1c]

Get a hair cut

[Jackc8201]

Love survival horror, but I think I'll be taking a pass. Too bad it's not a regular retail game, I might pick it up when it got down to $5. Like in a couple of weeks.

[Caluma122]

There should't be a next one!

[TheWaRGFX]

Makes brink look like gold..

[krunchyfrog]

Danny Bona-douchebag.

[ssiigguurrddhhuu]

did mark get a new haircut?

[nemocat117]

I have autism and I cannot make zombies lol

[necrogenesis1981]

I don't know about anyone else, but I'd like to see Clock Tower come back, the concept of this game sort of reminds me of that, with a little bit of Ico thrown in as well. Poor execution in terms of controls but good concept overall.

[g1Chase357]

@necrogenesis1981 Hell yeah! Clock Tower was awesome. The real ones. Not 3. Or 2: The Struggle Within (AKA Ghost Head in Japan). Just Clock Tower and Clock Tower (The American release) AKA Clock Tower 2 in Japan.

[1shoryuken]

@necrogenesis1981 absolutely, Clock Tower was freaking terrifying. You had no idea when Scissorman would show up and the layout for the house changed in every playthrough. Brilliant game.

[necrogenesis1981]

@1shoryuken Exactly! I think Clock Tower scared me even more than Resident Evil did in some ways, of course for entirely different reasons though.

[1shoryuken]

@necrogenesis1981 well yeah, because in Clock Tower, you are in most cases defenseless.

[MrPlaystation3freak]

@necrogenesis1981 What console was clock tower for?

[necrogenesis1981]

@MrPlaystation3freak PS1, there were also sequels, one of them (Clock Tower 3) being on PS2 but the 1st Clock Tower was the best.

[necrogenesis1981]

@MrPlaystation3freak I believe it was on SNES as well but I had the PS1 version.

[Puppified30]

@necrogenesis1981 Scissorman!

[erictheded]

Waitaminit... this is a RERUN!



[fuzzmanx]

Horror films and games ALWAYS suck at the beginning of the year. Just look at Devil Inside. A terrible film.

[Doom2Guy]

There was hype for this game? I hadn't even heard about it until it was released

[d21lewis]

I like what I played so far. Not a waste of $10, for me.

[SonicMaverick3000]

And Mark, why are you asking about how a game's gotten bad reviews? This isn't like you, you usually review a game without acknowledging those things, and why do you need Derek to help you review when he already did it on his channel? I haven't watched CGR in a while, and everything's changed...

[SonicMaverick3000]

Mark can you go back to reviewing games by yourself?

[mymovienerd]

We need to give the game developers credit who are at least trying to make something other than just another multi-player shooter.

[LaughingUltros]

@mymovienerd

No we don't.

[mymovienerd]

@LaughingUltros I said credit, not money.

[afterlifeproducer]

@mymovienerd no we dont...and there are plenty of games out there that are not multi player shooters,,''if the game is shit, it doesnt deserve anything,

[mymovienerd]

@afterlifeproducer  I haven't played the game so i don't know how bad it is.

[MrPrototypz]

@mymovienerd What a major revelation we already knew.

[mymovienerd]

@MrPrototypz  I've played games that i liked that other have called shit, though, so that doesn't discredit what I said about original games. do you realize that 90 % of the games being made are basically the same shit repackaged over and over again?

[MrPrototypz]

@mymovienerd "do you realize that 90 % of the games being made are basically the same shit repackaged over and over again?"

:O!!!!!

REALLY!? OMG!

I've never looked at it that way before. But.... WAIT.. does that mean.. is Modern Warfare 3 possibly be your "biggest example"..?

[mymovienerd]

@MrPrototypz Only one example. I didn't bother listing all examples because, frankly, there isn't enough room.

[MrPrototypz]

@mymovienerd Thanks for acknowledging my point. You go on and enjoy your 0% credit now and act like you're a expert critic or some delusive redundant bullshit. I'll be laughing when you make videos where you try to "Review" a bunch of things.

[mymovienerd]

@MrPrototypz Having an interest in something makes us all critics and fans at the same time. You can go and have that stick pulled out of your ass, while you're at it.

[Lupucillo]

A survival horror game with...surprise surprise...Zombies!!! Wow, that's unheard of.

[NotHomelessAnymore]

Is all that screen tear actually in-game or is my laptop just playing up?

[IHeart16Bit]

.... well I liked it.

[dingy06]

i lolled as soon as Samson opened his mouth. Clearly duped by his lion-esque exterior.

[SnipesWithWolvesV2]

Derek is my favorite on Undertow. He has character in my eyes

[wanyal]

I wanted to see Mark's review, Derek's review is already on Undertow...

[misterdon666]

@wanyal I'd imagine that Mark doesn't want to suffer, so he had derek do it. That's what I would do...shit game.

[TheMGSBigFan]

DA FUCK!? Stay over at undertow Derreck... >:(

[reesercliff]

is mark doing videos with undertow to help him with viewers. get a haircut you damn hippie

[DrZoutan]

finally i can see the guy's face :D

[bazfanv2]

Amy is better than Resident Evil 4 and 5. It will also be better than 6. Mark my words.

[jma10241]

@bazfanv2 lol better then RE4 and 5 are you serious if you think that good for you but no way is it better

[MrPrototypz]

@bazfanv2 *Facefuckingpalm*

[bazfanv2]

@MrPrototypz *Facefuckingpalm* whats that?. Are you respecting me?. Theres no need. I dont need your approval. Thankyou.

[MrPrototypz]

@bazfanv2 You're really deluded, aren't you, little kiddie?

[bazfanv2]

@bazfanv2 your still here?

[bazfanv2]

Does Mark have to have his wife with him?. Go solo Mark or your gonna lose viewers. I always said Undetow will be the demise of Mark. The Prophecy unfolds.

[RetroAdvanced]

@bazfanv2 I actually like Derek too, I don't see a problem