I'm not a hater but I don't know, I just feel like there's no sharpness, no exciteness, no flow. Unlike other productions I've seen. Rent: Live on Broadway was one of them. This scene, especially, they're flirting in the first place. Where's the spark in lighting that candle?
and as much as i hate to say anything bad about aaron tveit (literally, my stomach starts churning) he was a little too angry and needed to be a bit more conflicted, he can feel himself starting the like mimi and he's obviously attracted to her but he's also depressed and scared and he wants to protect himself from the danger he sees in her (how shes flirty and uses) just like april used to
Gosh Vanessa just ruins this so much for me! I think Aaron does a great job with Roger, but it's like Vanessa doesn't really get Mimi. She plays Mimi like a high school mean girl (like the Lindsay Lohan movie). Mimi's supposed to be sassy, but sort of naive. Plus, Vanessa's voice is much too nasally, I prefer more rasp.
Sure she was trying hard you can tell, but in the end she was miscast. Not her fault, but doesn't make her any less awkward to watch.
Well she made Mimi seem like a slut, but shes not! I mean yeah shes a stripper but the character Mimi is so much more than that. I honestly don't think she understood the role entirely. She might of actually been good if she figured out what Mimi's all about, and maybe if she had more vocal coaching for this role that might've got the bad singing out of the way. Although some songs she does sound alright.
I don't understand why is everyone complaining about Vanessas singing, to me it doesn't sound bad at all, besides she's got way more emotion in it than the movie-version-Mimi. Okay she does sound pretty bad in 'Out tonight', so the dancing and singing together don't bring up her best sides but anyway..
Is Vanessa the best Mimi out there? No. Was it weird to hear her say that she dropped her stash and has the best ass below 14th street? Hell yes. But you can tell she put everything she had into the performance. She may not be the best Mimi out there, but she was the best Mimi she could be. Plus, you have to admit, she did the best with the "No, with my father." line. When I watched the movie version I thought she was serious.
She does resembles mimi! but I don't know about the way of singing... and behaving... About that Roger... mmm... his voice is not what I'm used to listen... But I think Vanessa can play Mimi very good!
It wasn't bad. Though, the one thing bothering me is that, from what I remember and took our of the original, was that this song was supposed to be kind of sweet... not... well, kinda skanky-ish. I liked it though, I think the cast did fantastic.
the delivery of all these songs was set for the hollywood bowl and not the smaller broadway stage. The true intimate nature of show had to be modified and I think in this perspective - it was terrific. This cast did a great job.
I didn't sense much between the two of them, personally. Oh well. And Vanessa's grab for the stash at the end felt awkward to me. :S At least she didn't forget to steal it this time. :)
OMGosh!! Thank you, thank you so much! You rock!!!! I really appreciate this!! I am forever grateful!! You should compile all your videos and sell it. I'll be the first one to buy it!! He he you made my day!!! :)
This was better than the opening night performance, but holy timing. Pick a tempo and stick with it, preferably the original tempo. And Vanessa remembered to grab her stash this time, even if it was the least stealthy awkward grab instead of a smooth dance move.
Thanks for all the videos! Would love to see One Song Glory, if it wouldn't be too much trouble to request that as the next song.
In my opinion, Vanessa Hudgens just isn't Mimi.
However, this definitely sounded better than when she sang "Out Tonight"...
nisashafield 2 weeks ago 4
i Love Nessa ♥ She is the best!
billie123babyv 2 weeks ago
I actually think Roger (Tveit) is blah. Hudgens did her own thing with Mimi. I like it.
lornarocker 1 month ago
i feel like she's trying too hard to be sexy...
moonlightshadow1122 1 month ago
@moonlightshadow1122 That is the point of this song.....
CoronaBeachBum 1 month ago
I'm not a hater but I don't know, I just feel like there's no sharpness, no exciteness, no flow. Unlike other productions I've seen. Rent: Live on Broadway was one of them. This scene, especially, they're flirting in the first place. Where's the spark in lighting that candle?
kaye192 2 months ago
she did AMAZING
HorsesandTennisGirl 2 months ago
her timing seems kind of off at some parts and they don't have much chemistry....but its a decent performance, definitely not the best
MusicAb 3 months ago in playlist More videos from SkylarAstinFan
aw i kind of love this though
oliviadesalvo 3 months ago
she wasn't so bad
gemmabear 3 months ago
Clumping around in those stupid boots. Where's the class? Mimi had class!
thorwithoutthehammer 3 months ago
This isn't very good acting. The singing is decent at best.
KHTimeProtecter 4 months ago
1:28 Aaron is all like "BITCH GET OUT OF MY HOUSE!"
TheRamenLovinGamer 4 months ago
I loved her on HSM, but she's not the best live performer...very pretty girl though.
Aaron Tveit was fantastic, not a surprise. He can sing and act.
selemawit14 4 months ago
she sounds a little juvenile at some parts
and as much as i hate to say anything bad about aaron tveit (literally, my stomach starts churning) he was a little too angry and needed to be a bit more conflicted, he can feel himself starting the like mimi and he's obviously attracted to her but he's also depressed and scared and he wants to protect himself from the danger he sees in her (how shes flirty and uses) just like april used to
heathi51 4 months ago
i can't decide if i like vanessa as mimi...like, there are some songs where i really really do, and then some where's i'm like "eh..." :P
LennonRevolution9 4 months ago in playlist More videos from SkylarAstinFan
Don't like Vanessa for Mimi... she isn't *there* the the character or her choices. She's definitely a movie actress and not a stage actress.
KodiHful 4 months ago
The song is kinda low?
Vanessa is not a good Mimi...
FERNANDOPATTDOSSANTO 4 months ago
what is the name of this guy
tomris4 4 months ago
@tomris4 Aaron Tveit
OMFGthatsweird 4 months ago
It's funny when he kicks her out and rolls his eyes. XD But it's just not like Roger.
lily8394 4 months ago
Awesome video :)
SuperMrshoe 5 months ago in playlist SuperMrshoe's Favourited Videos
i love the zoned out face aaron has when he stares at vanessas ass!
erin154booya 5 months ago
Voice is okay, she just can't act in a mature role.
unsmurfettable 5 months ago 4
i'm sorry but i'm not a vanessa fan
SingingFool123 6 months ago
Gosh Vanessa just ruins this so much for me! I think Aaron does a great job with Roger, but it's like Vanessa doesn't really get Mimi. She plays Mimi like a high school mean girl (like the Lindsay Lohan movie). Mimi's supposed to be sassy, but sort of naive. Plus, Vanessa's voice is much too nasally, I prefer more rasp.
Sure she was trying hard you can tell, but in the end she was miscast. Not her fault, but doesn't make her any less awkward to watch.
alicia535 6 months ago 6
Vanessa did Mimi so wrong, she made her seem slutty and annoyed. The complete opposite of what Mimi is.
GabbyCapasso 6 months ago
Well she made Mimi seem like a slut, but shes not! I mean yeah shes a stripper but the character Mimi is so much more than that. I honestly don't think she understood the role entirely. She might of actually been good if she figured out what Mimi's all about, and maybe if she had more vocal coaching for this role that might've got the bad singing out of the way. Although some songs she does sound alright.
Wickedloverrent 6 months ago
I dont think she is that bad. she is decient not the best but ok. And her singing is actually pretty good too
77anthonyh 7 months ago
I don't understand why is everyone complaining about Vanessas singing, to me it doesn't sound bad at all, besides she's got way more emotion in it than the movie-version-Mimi. Okay she does sound pretty bad in 'Out tonight', so the dancing and singing together don't bring up her best sides but anyway..
calima1310 7 months ago
I don't like that most of girls play Mimi kind of slutty on that scene, it should be sweet.
Rohpink 9 months ago
@Rohpink But Mimi is a slut, it's true to character.
beckyboston 8 months ago
Is Vanessa the best Mimi out there? No. Was it weird to hear her say that she dropped her stash and has the best ass below 14th street? Hell yes. But you can tell she put everything she had into the performance. She may not be the best Mimi out there, but she was the best Mimi she could be. Plus, you have to admit, she did the best with the "No, with my father." line. When I watched the movie version I thought she was serious.
ElleBelle171 9 months ago 4
@ElleBelle171 If "the best she could do" was singing several of the notes on the wrong pitch, then she shouldn't be singing live theater.
beckyboston 8 months ago
why does Aaron look angry all the time?
Snackaholic 10 months ago
AARON TVEIT!!!! <3
DivahMusicGal 10 months ago
i finally found out what my problem was with the hollywood bowl. a couple of things:
1. vanessa played mimi with NO levels. you know what im saying? mimi is a really complex character... and I get NONE of that with vanessa.
2. damn... aaron is hot. we can all agree on that! but his voice isnt rock enough for rodger
bananasmakeup 11 months ago 4
Honestly, this is my favorite RENT song...I'm a bit disappointed...
kandicemariejenkins 11 months ago
she does much better in balled type songs I don't think she did very well on out tonight at all tto forced.
20091211 1 year ago 3
she sounds far to childish..
BabyJPoC 1 year ago 3
she sounds a lottttttttt better here!
is august 7 day 3?
haleyshivs3 1 year ago 2
I have nothing against Vanessa and I think she is adorable...but this is really terrible.
Jenna10227 1 year ago 4
She does resembles mimi! but I don't know about the way of singing... and behaving... About that Roger... mmm... his voice is not what I'm used to listen... But I think Vanessa can play Mimi very good!
Disape324 1 year ago 8
It wasn't bad. Though, the one thing bothering me is that, from what I remember and took our of the original, was that this song was supposed to be kind of sweet... not... well, kinda skanky-ish. I liked it though, I think the cast did fantastic.
Aaron Tveit, though... =)
TheNamesNicole1012 1 year ago 4
the delivery of all these songs was set for the hollywood bowl and not the smaller broadway stage. The true intimate nature of show had to be modified and I think in this perspective - it was terrific. This cast did a great job.
skb1355264 1 year ago 5
If only she was singing on-key...
kesierafy 1 year ago 9
That was the most fake stumble I have ever seen. And I wish that was the only wrong thing. He didn't do bad, though.
Avarhilien 1 year ago 2
Vanessa is sooo fucking gooooood!!! my role model <3333
XxlaladyxX 1 year ago
After another look she over sings thats where it goes wrong for her.
Bomama84 1 year ago
Thank you for uploading! :)
jetiem 1 year ago
Thanks for uploading! :)
I didn't sense much between the two of them, personally. Oh well. And Vanessa's grab for the stash at the end felt awkward to me. :S At least she didn't forget to steal it this time. :)
IDieWithoutU 1 year ago 3
awkward staging...
tellmewhatsahappenin 1 year ago
Love this performance, Aaron and vanessa are great, love Aaron voice and V did amazing!!! I love their chemistry!!!!!
BabyV151 1 year ago 3
thank you for uploading this vanessa did great!!!!
BabyV151 1 year ago 29
You're like my hero for uploading these!!! THANK YOU!!
WinnyFoster 1 year ago
Thank you for uploading!! Love them!
Could you maybe upload Another Day next? Preferably from the 3rd night.
vanessahloverr 1 year ago
@vanessahloverr I do not have Another Day from the 3rd night. I was caught video taping by an usher and didn't get that one. I only have it on audio.
SkylarAstinFan 1 year ago
Wonderful!! Thank you for uploading the videos of Vanessa Hudgens
nameslynn 1 year ago
have i told you i love you ^___^, thank you for uploading, this number so cute and funny
sa8mster 1 year ago
thanks for uploading :))
vanessaannebest 1 year ago
aaaa, have i told you i love you, thank you, you are the best, this number is funny and cute ^___^
sa8mster 1 year ago 2
Vanessa is SO hott!
princessvanessahsm 1 year ago 34
v is fabulous
tammy1995able 1 year ago 3
LOVE IT!!! <3
thank you so much for posting! your videos are the best quality!
The only ones where I can really see Vanessa's facial expressions, beautiful :)
Anneris 1 year ago 2
this is her best one out of the 3 nights.
gezbez 1 year ago
OMGosh!! Thank you, thank you so much! You rock!!!! I really appreciate this!! I am forever grateful!! You should compile all your videos and sell it. I'll be the first one to buy it!! He he you made my day!!! :)
narniapc2 1 year ago
This was better than the opening night performance, but holy timing. Pick a tempo and stick with it, preferably the original tempo. And Vanessa remembered to grab her stash this time, even if it was the least stealthy awkward grab instead of a smooth dance move.
Thanks for all the videos! Would love to see One Song Glory, if it wouldn't be too much trouble to request that as the next song.
dancethrulife1 1 year ago
Thank you for posting! :)
RippledStarr 1 year ago