kelly, this wasnt even close. Reba is great, but this one is going to kelly. But im going to cut reba some slack. The video & audio quality was terrible. But i still think kelly hands down. Either way neither of them or rossane barr
kelly had more passion and moved a bit more with the song. But she did miss a note or two (this happens it's a tough song to sing). Reba on the other hand did not have any errors but was slightly stiff. More entertaining Kelly, better performance Reba.
agreed. overall I liked kelly's better, but reba looks really young in hers. that must have been one of her older tries. if she tried again, today, she'd woop kelly ;3 (no offense kelly lovers)
Not a Reba fan. I'm sure she has her talent, but she sounds like a sheep singing to me. Too many vowels and broken words. Too country hickish. She was asked once what her favorite food was, and she said Rocky Mountain Oysters (calf balls). Gross!
I agree with you rockinraffi...i wish reba had sang it acapella. I'm not sure though if there are any other taped performances of Reba singing the anthem. My whole point was not really to compare and see who was better anyway, but i guess people will do that naturally.
That is not fair! Reba had a bad band accompanying her. She would have sounded much better a capella, and the quality of the sound in the video did not help her either..
Carrie Underwood did it way better than her or jojo...not to sound mean or anything but carrie did it normal...like it should be...not anything else...we don't need to see how quick they can move their voices!...thats what they make songs for!.. :D
Who is the "her" that you talked about? Kelly or Reba. It doesn't matter who you are talking about, both Kelly and Reba sing the song just as nice as Carrie.
NO....Kelly put Soul and RnB in it, like she alwayz do "the reason she won American Idol i the first Place, doing all Soul Music! Then she flipped the script on soul and did pop! How rude, but she still my girl!
jeez-- i don't know why the race issue even came up. kelly sounded great and the little girls behind her were cute! btw, why compare? it's obvious kelly has her own style and whitney is awesome in her own way.
Kelly is much better sorry Reba xD
TheFear1611 1 year ago
omg! reba looks so young!
katararoxmysox 2 years ago
Reba loves Kelly as a very, very young sister, or a niece, and Kelly respects and adores Reba, so, -----
In fact, both are great and sensational!!
bsdvak 2 years ago 2
Omg, they both are amazing! Reba looks so young!
CatyWasHere13 3 years ago 5
I agree both are so amazing. :) Reba was only 19 at the time she was "discovered" singing the National Anthem in1974. This clip is from that event.
wwrd30 3 years ago 3
wow.
kellyclarksonisgreat 2 years ago
wow she was that young? I didn't know Reba was that young when she sang the national anthem
rebarox85 2 years ago
kelly, this wasnt even close. Reba is great, but this one is going to kelly. But im going to cut reba some slack. The video & audio quality was terrible. But i still think kelly hands down. Either way neither of them or rossane barr
DCProductions77 3 years ago
I think Reba and Kelly did awesome, but if it showed more Reba, we might could judge better. :-)
SeeliAndM 3 years ago
kelly had more passion and moved a bit more with the song. But she did miss a note or two (this happens it's a tough song to sing). Reba on the other hand did not have any errors but was slightly stiff. More entertaining Kelly, better performance Reba.
lookforthelight 3 years ago
agreed. overall I liked kelly's better, but reba looks really young in hers. that must have been one of her older tries. if she tried again, today, she'd woop kelly ;3 (no offense kelly lovers)
mightyling 3 years ago
it sounds like kellys trying to hit a note but she couldnt get there. she tried to sing in C but for some reason she struggled ans stsyed in B
weirdguy75 3 years ago
Gosh Kelly's is awesome - Gave me Goosebumps on my arms !!
itshotandwet 3 years ago 4
kelly bether becausw without back music
kevinkelly51 3 years ago
reba was dfferent
piggyprincess135 3 years ago
Reba got better with age, she's like Fine Wine.
Nikita4ever9000 3 years ago 10
Wow i absolutely loved both, im a bigger kelly fan and i did like kellys more, but dang i LOVED LOVED LOVED rebas.
joepatrick55 3 years ago 2
where they both siging for a nfl game?
timestern 3 years ago 2
amazing i love it great job!
hersheyspresents 3 years ago
bulldog12 (2 months ago ) says Reba was great and Kelly was too !!!!!
chicaxdexchrist 3 years ago
i have to agree kelyl was a little off but mosto f it was good
aliciamariexoxo 3 years ago
Can I find somewhere that Reba's version (whole)? On Youtube?
Shalunamus 4 years ago
GREAT
hitmansmam123 4 years ago
Wow Kelly! You steal my heart again! Look at those big hazel eyes!
iwggwt 4 years ago 5
Kelly sings this song perfectly. The way it should be sung.
ARIELDOG1983 4 years ago 7
they were both really good!!
faithmcentire 4 years ago 9
I think that Reba sing better than Kelly .
musicfan28 4 years ago
Reba said banner funny xD
92927 4 years ago
sorry to say this ,but Faith Hill does better on this song.Reba is also better.kelly is a little off key.I like Kelly but not singing this song.
myrarobinson42 4 years ago
they're both soooo good!!!!!!!!!!!
jaybabiigurl21 4 years ago
Love it,love Reba!
leenm12 4 years ago 3
I Love Kelly and Reba and
I Love Reba's Song Fancy. I also Love her show and I Love most of Kelly's songs!!!!
cbkkmb 4 years ago 3
wow
lovely110023 4 years ago
Reba was on key.
rushmore38 4 years ago
reba had a band with key, kelly was on a different key
genewatsonfan2 4 years ago 5
i think she was 19
supersporty34 4 years ago
Wow, how old was reba here?
bensonlover99 4 years ago
Kelly clarkson ROCKS! n.n I love reba to. But i love kelly more.
Captureitall 4 years ago
I Love Reba And Kelly!
cbkkmb 4 years ago
reba was pretty back then, wasnt she?
bubbleslin 4 years ago
This was not that long ago.
cbkkmb 4 years ago
Not a Reba fan. I'm sure she has her talent, but she sounds like a sheep singing to me. Too many vowels and broken words. Too country hickish. She was asked once what her favorite food was, and she said Rocky Mountain Oysters (calf balls). Gross!
jackson4socks 4 years ago
You must be sick. Reba rocks!!!!
horselovinruthie 4 years ago 2
But I Love Reba!!!
cbkkmb 4 years ago
good
milennio 4 years ago
"Kelly:( Reba :)" ha ha ha
ByillyMcButtButt 4 years ago
Reba's section needs to be louder or lower the volume on Kelly, so they match closer.
sadgreydonkey 4 years ago
kellys version is better, and it's soooooooo cool that she gets to perform with her idol.
Sims2Freak233 4 years ago
I agree with you rockinraffi...i wish reba had sang it acapella. I'm not sure though if there are any other taped performances of Reba singing the anthem. My whole point was not really to compare and see who was better anyway, but i guess people will do that naturally.
supersporty34 4 years ago
Kelly's performance was better, in my opinion
knothead997cdp 4 years ago
That is not fair! Reba had a bad band accompanying her. She would have sounded much better a capella, and the quality of the sound in the video did not help her either..
rockinraffi 4 years ago
i totally agree, but kelly is still awesome and shoulg get her praise...so here it is...u rock kelly! and u rock too Reba
Hotkylerman 4 years ago 3
Kelly:( Reba :)
hedleyxox 4 years ago
if I had to vote between the 2, it'd be a tie, they both did awsome, in their own ways
wheelingdude12 4 years ago
i think everyone did their besttt. :)
sMiLeYlOvEsYoU 4 years ago
Carrie Underwood did it way better than her or jojo...not to sound mean or anything but carrie did it normal...like it should be...not anything else...we don't need to see how quick they can move their voices!...thats what they make songs for!.. :D
shelbytall 4 years ago
I agree with you. She did not have the personality.
ilovesaula07 4 years ago
Kelly :) Reba :(
jjackery6 4 years ago
Who is the "her" that you talked about? Kelly or Reba. It doesn't matter who you are talking about, both Kelly and Reba sing the song just as nice as Carrie.
lovelybabymay 4 years ago
WHY IS SHE DOING ROCK AND POP?! I love her sound but really.....with a voice like that, she needs some soul music out there.
ub3rsc00ber 4 years ago
WOW I GOT GOSSEBUMPS!
snoopy108 4 years ago
I didn't like Kelly's version. Too wavy and inconsistent, if you know what I mean
JoshiesJem 4 years ago
Reba sang the heck out of that song at the rodeo!!
AlwaysRevaAlwaysBud 4 years ago
i like them both but in this kelly outsang reba
Shakira321rules 4 years ago
whats the most awsome to me is that they seem to be about the same age when they sang this
xeniak 4 years ago
I like Kelly Clarkson, but I still like Reba WAY better
Sawyerslove 4 years ago
Big news! It was announced on 04/26/07 that Kelly is going to tour North America in the Summer of 2007!
gymman1031 4 years ago
Were they singing in the at a football game??? If yes, then who was it between???
OklahomaPerson 4 years ago
brilliant very well done and mixed fair play to ya x x x
irises6 4 years ago
kelly put punk into it and reba put country in it
BustaDream 4 years ago
NO....Kelly put Soul and RnB in it, like she alwayz do "the reason she won American Idol i the first Place, doing all Soul Music! Then she flipped the script on soul and did pop! How rude, but she still my girl!
thesinger 4 years ago
thats what i was thinking but i didnt who how to put it in to words haha
Kirstyfaescotland 4 years ago
That video with reba look pretty old. But the video was awesome. :)
uberrios 4 years ago
im pretty sure that the dallas cowboy stadium is in irving, not dallas, they are the dallas cowboys, but the stadium is in irving.
shiningstarz0916 4 years ago
they are so cute, i luv them!
kellyqueenofpop 4 years ago
Reba and Kelly both sang it great!
rebafan18 5 years ago
jeez-- i don't know why the race issue even came up. kelly sounded great and the little girls behind her were cute! btw, why compare? it's obvious kelly has her own style and whitney is awesome in her own way.
terillian 5 years ago
from CMT Giants, which honored Reba.
supersporty34 5 years ago
where did u get the clip of Reba from?
Momoseeko12 5 years ago