I prefer Simon Vance's reading. He has so many different voices at his command, it's almost like listening to a narration with a full cast. I've listened to Patrick Tull's as well, and he's my second favorite reader of O'Brian's works.
I started Reading the books ón my own, but being Danish i had a hard time understanding All the suddleties in the tekst so i wass delighted to discover his recordings, simpley perfect (please excuse my spelling)...
WOW- by coincidence, this is one of the most recent books I listened to - Having sailed the seven seas with Jack and Steven, at the end of this scene - I wept.
Heart-wrenching, especially to a fan of the series and audiobooks. Tull certainly got muscular tone of the prose right. I wish I had read these books a little earlier, so that I could have written letters of admiration to these two artists.
I've heard that O'Brian didn't quite approve of Tull's narration, as he is said to have wanted the understated to remain that way. But for fans of the canon, there is nothing better.
Even though I have read them, Maturin, Aubrey, Killick and the rest will always sound like Tull's personation, in my head.
In Tull's death, we have to honour him: his rich voice was earned the hard way.
Thanks for the thoughtful comment, Morecake2. Tull was indeed the aural embodiment of the Canon for so many of us. But I had heard the opposite - that Tull was O'Brian's favorite narrator. Be that as it may, we all miss both of the Patricks.
I got the audio book for Reverse of the Medal but didn't look at the narrator. When it wasn't Patrick Tull i had to stop the recording. I cannot listen if anyone but Tull. He is the greatest.
@jrmurph It's exactly the same for me. I checked out the series from my library, adored Mr. Tull's narrations, and was disappointed and upset when several of their audio volumes were by another narrator. (One, with a pinched, nasal voice, was particularly disagreeable.)
It seems to me that a love of the works in Mr. Tull's voice shines through as he reads. He gives life to the prose and characters to such an extent that I don't wish to even give other narrators a chance.
Mr Tull's readings aren't available here in Australia, and while I really enjoy the readers I have heard, after seeing this video I realise I have missed a real treat. What a marevelous, passionate reading!
I hope one day I will have access to his readings of my favourite series ever.
Patrick O'Brian and Patrick Tull were true treasures of the literary world, now lost to us. Seeing Tull perform here is a great treat. What I wouldn't give to have video performances of all of these books done by him. Every book he has recorded has been spot on. When Tull's voice ends in mid sentence in "21," tears run down my face. Like Aubrey and Maturin, these two were made for each other.
My initial exposure to Aubrey/Maturin was Mr. Tull's rendering. I have since read them all 10 times or more. They are my greatest reading joy. Tull reading O'brian is as good as anything Michael Jordon did on the basketball court or Elvis or the Beatles recorded. It is amoung the best things I have seen human beings do. I am sad to hear he is dead as I did not know it til I read it here.
I have thus far read the Aubrey/Maturin series five times and am never tired of it. Before today I had never heard of Mr. Tull, but I have to say that was a masterfull reading of one of the most moving passages O'Brian or anyone else has ever written. It is hard to stay dry eyed when "the cheering began". Thank you sir and well done!
The great narrator of the world! What a joy it was, recently, to find I can rediscover the O'Brian novels anew--having read them all several times--thanks to the pitch perfect renderings of Mr Tull. So sad he's no longer with us. Thanks for posting this!
What an absolute joy to see the man whose readings of Patrick O'Brian's great novels has brought me so much happiness. Much gratitude to you for posting this gem :)
Very moving...Tull was one of..if not the greatest narrator of prose, a one man theater company...I have all his audio books and this is the first time Ive had the honour to see him at work...thanks so much
I would read the whole series again(which I am,and will again)to lead up to this passage and the one at the end of "Blue at the Mizzen". Never before have I sobbed audibly.
Thank you so much for making this available. I have the complete set of CDs and am listening to them for the second time (I do a lot of driving!). Its' wonderful to see his gestures and facial expressions as well as hearing his amazing range of voices.
I second what Gilly said. This is one of the most memorable fragments of O'Brian's A/M series. I've been trying to hold my tears all through the video, specially after reading in your comment that Patrick Tull left us not a day ago. Thank you very dearly for this video.
Thank you so very much for putting this up. It's the one scene in the entire series that I don't think I shall ever forget. I teared up hearing it again now.
I prefer Simon Vance's reading. He has so many different voices at his command, it's almost like listening to a narration with a full cast. I've listened to Patrick Tull's as well, and he's my second favorite reader of O'Brian's works.
Renaiya 4 months ago
How did he die?
cnlaw 4 months ago
A magnificent interpreter of the works of Patrick O'Brian, he brought these wonderful stories to life for me.
Aubrey/Maturin will always belong to Patrick Tull, thank you. RIP
greenslime27 7 months ago
Killick!, Killick there!
mozartfx1 1 year ago
Patrick and Patrick. An incredible, rare, wonderful, surpassing, absolutely fantastic combination.
95ersUniverse 1 year ago
what a fellow he was! what a loss to the world. i've watched this a dozen times and it still makes me tear up. rest in peace patrick a-cushla
paulyearwig 1 year ago
God set a flower on your head Sir !
(btw, the face never does match the mental image you get from just the voice!)
fortyfivesemi 1 year ago
I started Reading the books ón my own, but being Danish i had a hard time understanding All the suddleties in the tekst so i wass delighted to discover his recordings, simpley perfect (please excuse my spelling)...
heino090285 1 year ago
WOW- by coincidence, this is one of the most recent books I listened to - Having sailed the seven seas with Jack and Steven, at the end of this scene - I wept.
funpete 2 years ago 3
Thanks, funpete - Patrick excelled as an actor, and a reader.
ponto 2 years ago
Awesome narration the second best i've ever heard. what an orator.
DevilinDeep 2 years ago
Oh, Mr Tull, I wish I'd known you. Your voice, reading Mr O'Brian, has gotten me through the hardest times I've ever faced.
NewHomemaker 2 years ago 3
Heart-wrenching, especially to a fan of the series and audiobooks. Tull certainly got muscular tone of the prose right. I wish I had read these books a little earlier, so that I could have written letters of admiration to these two artists.
aristotleschild 2 years ago 3
I just finished listening to the recorded audio of George Orwell's "Down and Out in Paris and London" read by Patrick Tull. Fantastic!
thebestofmosdef 2 years ago 2
I've heard that O'Brian didn't quite approve of Tull's narration, as he is said to have wanted the understated to remain that way. But for fans of the canon, there is nothing better.
Even though I have read them, Maturin, Aubrey, Killick and the rest will always sound like Tull's personation, in my head.
In Tull's death, we have to honour him: his rich voice was earned the hard way.
He too gave his life to his art.
Morecake2 2 years ago 2
Thanks for the thoughtful comment, Morecake2. Tull was indeed the aural embodiment of the Canon for so many of us. But I had heard the opposite - that Tull was O'Brian's favorite narrator. Be that as it may, we all miss both of the Patricks.
ponto 2 years ago
Absolutely.
The most amusing thing is that most people have no idea how addictive the whole world of Aubrey & Maturin is.
Postcaptain69 says he's read them 10 times and this is not unusual.
Morecake2 2 years ago
Ponto, you're correct. Mr. Tull was the only narrator he approved of, and they were, in fact, quite fond of one another.
antheia77 2 years ago 2
I got the audio book for Reverse of the Medal but didn't look at the narrator. When it wasn't Patrick Tull i had to stop the recording. I cannot listen if anyone but Tull. He is the greatest.
jrmurph 2 years ago 2
@jrmurph It's exactly the same for me. I checked out the series from my library, adored Mr. Tull's narrations, and was disappointed and upset when several of their audio volumes were by another narrator. (One, with a pinched, nasal voice, was particularly disagreeable.)
It seems to me that a love of the works in Mr. Tull's voice shines through as he reads. He gives life to the prose and characters to such an extent that I don't wish to even give other narrators a chance.
RIP, and thank you.
NotPotable 1 year ago
Mr Tull's readings aren't available here in Australia, and while I really enjoy the readers I have heard, after seeing this video I realise I have missed a real treat. What a marevelous, passionate reading!
I hope one day I will have access to his readings of my favourite series ever.
Thanks for sharing!
gillianinoz 3 years ago 3
Thanks, gillianinoz.
ponto 3 years ago
Patrick O'Brian and Patrick Tull were true treasures of the literary world, now lost to us. Seeing Tull perform here is a great treat. What I wouldn't give to have video performances of all of these books done by him. Every book he has recorded has been spot on. When Tull's voice ends in mid sentence in "21," tears run down my face. Like Aubrey and Maturin, these two were made for each other.
blueyesdetector 3 years ago
Bravo Tull! Also, as to your ending admonition, I believe those were the
words of Jimmy Buffet : )
mwp62 3 years ago
My initial exposure to Aubrey/Maturin was Mr. Tull's rendering. I have since read them all 10 times or more. They are my greatest reading joy. Tull reading O'brian is as good as anything Michael Jordon did on the basketball court or Elvis or the Beatles recorded. It is amoung the best things I have seen human beings do. I am sad to hear he is dead as I did not know it til I read it here.
postcaptain69 3 years ago
I had read all the novels and when I discovered Patrick tulls
readings I was initially dubious then overjoyed.
It was like discovering these great novels all over again
and his readng helped me appreciate them even more and catch
some of the wit and nuances I had been too dull to 'smoke' the first time.
Thank you Patric
reggiecx 3 years ago
I have thus far read the Aubrey/Maturin series five times and am never tired of it. Before today I had never heard of Mr. Tull, but I have to say that was a masterfull reading of one of the most moving passages O'Brian or anyone else has ever written. It is hard to stay dry eyed when "the cheering began". Thank you sir and well done!
raceygofast 3 years ago
The great narrator of the world! What a joy it was, recently, to find I can rediscover the O'Brian novels anew--having read them all several times--thanks to the pitch perfect renderings of Mr Tull. So sad he's no longer with us. Thanks for posting this!
stickpictures 3 years ago
Outstanding.
Thanks for taking the time to post this gem.
I hadn't had the pleasure of hearing Mr. Tull before this, and I'm happy to note this as the beginning of a long acquaintance with his works.
cornlungs 3 years ago
Which I'm listening to them again, ain't I?
94z07 3 years ago 14
@94z07 brilliant absolutely brilliant
charliesacoolkid 2 months ago
If you haven't heard Patrick Tull's Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, I highly suggest you look into it. I can't praise it enough.
Caligulita 3 years ago
I have listened to the series at least three times. There is something magical about Tull + O'Brian. I cannot stop listening. Thanks for the upload!
God bless them both.
utubenamex 4 years ago
A great reader interpreting a great author -- many thanks for posting!
bayardcoll 4 years ago
What an absolute joy to see the man whose readings of Patrick O'Brian's great novels has brought me so much happiness. Much gratitude to you for posting this gem :)
housepiglet 4 years ago 2
Just as Patrick O'Brian has ruined me for lesser authors, Patrick Tull has ruined me for lesser narrators, their souls to the devil.
SteveRT2006 4 years ago
In the words of Stephen Maturin him self
"Jesus, Mary and Joseph! that was splendid, truly splendid"
thanks for the vid. its a real treasure
Bondzy1220 4 years ago
Very moving...Tull was one of..if not the greatest narrator of prose, a one man theater company...I have all his audio books and this is the first time Ive had the honour to see him at work...thanks so much
MongosGoat 4 years ago
I listened him doing Pickwick Papers and I say he is one of the joyful narrators of audiobook history. Can't believe he died!
drcoxcentral 4 years ago
Capital :)
GregSamsa 5 years ago
Amazing bringing to life of a very moving passage. Thank you so much for posting.
nervouspete 5 years ago
I would read the whole series again(which I am,and will again)to lead up to this passage and the one at the end of "Blue at the Mizzen". Never before have I sobbed audibly.
gti2165 5 years ago
Thank you so much for making this available. I have the complete set of CDs and am listening to them for the second time (I do a lot of driving!). Its' wonderful to see his gestures and facial expressions as well as hearing his amazing range of voices.
jankapoor 5 years ago
I second what Gilly said. This is one of the most memorable fragments of O'Brian's A/M series. I've been trying to hold my tears all through the video, specially after reading in your comment that Patrick Tull left us not a day ago. Thank you very dearly for this video.
Steampunkgirl 5 years ago
Thanks, Steampunkgirl, and everyone else, too. I'm happy to to be able to share Patrick's memorable reading.
ponto 5 years ago
Thnaks for putting that up. It brings back good memories.
I'm the man in the striped T shirt at 6:08.
n6tqs 5 years ago
Thank you for sharing - *S*. I second what Gilly said above.
prairie11 5 years ago
Patrick Tull is the reader of the world. And that excerpt never ceases to make me sniffle. Thanks for putting it up
esteven69 5 years ago
Thank you, Gillywraith - glad you liked it.
ponto 5 years ago
Thank you so very much for putting this up. It's the one scene in the entire series that I don't think I shall ever forget. I teared up hearing it again now.
Thank you.
Gillywraith 5 years ago