I really love this song! Dougie wrote it & does some great versions of it. But, somehow I keep returning to this version, by Amy. It's just so beautifully evocative & lovely.
Amy Macdonald didnae write the song or the lyrics, but this is one of my favourite songs, and now it's been done by one of my favourite people. Brilliant. <3
I'm from South America and respectfully I'd like to say that this original version would've never attracted my attention, I think this is an example of how a great arranger and a great singer as Lisa can make a simple song something thrilling, moving and can cause hard-to-describe emotions. It's a great song!!
read this it really works!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! out your hands on your chest both hands and think of a crush or bf............... tomorrow they will kiss u say they love u or ask u out but here is the catch put this message on five other videos for good luck
Well...I've just been introduced to Amy's music & I think she's simply lovely & I really LOVE this song...sung by her...Thanks my lovely friend, Ron! You're the best! Warmly, Red
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It seems that some of us (like you HHulzebos) are not able to properly listen to a song. If you could, you would not have made so many mistakes by writing the lyrics. Maybe ya should wash your ears more often, or something like that?
OHH my god she is pretty lady, and this song is very nice
wiibermarulanda 2 months ago
As a displaced son of Caledonia, I love this song - cheers Amy for such a beautiful version!
ajandkelly 2 months ago
I really love this song! Dougie wrote it & does some great versions of it. But, somehow I keep returning to this version, by Amy. It's just so beautifully evocative & lovely.
1950BobbyF 3 months ago
Even though I live in Holland I just love this song!
TheHistorytiger 3 months ago
From halfway around the world, The Philippines, lovely song, just like Scotland.
askherbs 3 months ago
one of those songs that are way too short. One hunger for more
ourmoonourstars 3 months ago
Damn, that brung a tear tae ma e'e
acwotam 4 months ago
omg I can't stop listening to this and it makes me proud to be a Scot . what a lovely girl amy is xx
MsLiz50 4 months ago 2
she's just wonderful, and a credit to Scotland, love her x
MsLiz50 4 months ago
love this song :) and love Amy too :)
EweAreCool 6 months ago
amy come back, love from poland <3 we'll sing it with you
MissSaorise 6 months ago
From Holland!
Y love youXXX
bos4701 8 months ago
Scottish Independence here we come! Love this song Amy!
shmolie100 8 months ago 4
stupenda
gbyronbay 9 months ago
buetiful!! xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
marycrotty 10 months ago
Long live Scotlad ! I love this counry. Greetings from Poland for Scots ! :-)
PanKazmisz 11 months ago 6
@PanKazmisz I have many Polish neighbours and they are great and hard workers. They don't mix with us but I am still proud to have them x
MsLiz50 4 months ago
Im looking for somebody who could teach me the Scottisch language? I'm from Belgium. Could you please PM me?
SimonMcBlack 11 months ago
Amy Macdonald didnae write the song or the lyrics, but this is one of my favourite songs, and now it's been done by one of my favourite people. Brilliant. <3
Slvrncld 11 months ago
I first heard this song in Lisa Kelly's version.
I'm from South America and respectfully I'd like to say that this original version would've never attracted my attention, I think this is an example of how a great arranger and a great singer as Lisa can make a simple song something thrilling, moving and can cause hard-to-describe emotions. It's a great song!!
ModularMoog 1 year ago
@ModularMoog Amen! Greetings from India. I heard Lisa Kelly's version first too. I have been listening to it over and over like an addict! :)
penguinskywalker 10 months ago
@penguinskywalker
Definitely, Lisa is very addictive... She makes me cry each and every time I hear her.
:)
ModularMoog 10 months ago
This song demonstrates why scotland is better than england...
chrisbeat1988 1 year ago 3
THATS still real music.. <3 <3
TOP in swizerland :D
colibristuff 1 year ago
Shes got soul. A real one, I meant.
zsuzsa23 1 year ago
I love this song so much <3 I love Scotland also! <3 And Amy's and Paolo Nutini's versions are my fave but... why only 2 minutes? Why Amy? Amazing <3
gula1989 1 year ago
Wow , awesome version
howdofolks 1 year ago
nydelig musikk , minner meg litt om Ida Jenshus :)
bra575 1 year ago
In a kind of way, she remembers me to the young Melanie S., and now I
have the problem to worship two great singers :-)
Amdaro 1 year ago
so so beautiful.
defender5151 1 year ago
Nicely done Amy, as per usual. :)
MrFreddo3 1 year ago
Great version.
ClansmanKerr 1 year ago
Play those bagpipes.
tapp247 1 year ago
brilliant song...love it so much
elianeNR1 1 year ago
this is my favorite song of hers, such talent, also such a good looking girl
MrSoapdodger 2 years ago 3
thank fuck i got amy coz my rangers are shite get a grip the bears
buckboy81 2 years ago
I think the bears got a grip and Amz is a bluenose too ;-)
GMNov 1 year ago
i'm dutch and i loveee the song, <3
essiexD 2 years ago 2
This would be a good song for a Caledonian water ad.
MargeSimpson20 2 years ago
My favorite rendition of Claledonia. short and sweet.
Nhurm 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is not something she should be proud of, sorry.
nooneeither 2 years ago
*__* J'adore !!!!!!!!
Murrey91 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
read this it really works!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! out your hands on your chest both hands and think of a crush or bf............... tomorrow they will kiss u say they love u or ask u out but here is the catch put this message on five other videos for good luck
meandemo 2 years ago
Best Song Ever!!!
MissSunshineGirl15 2 years ago
Well...I've just been introduced to Amy's music & I think she's simply lovely & I really LOVE this song...sung by her...Thanks my lovely friend, Ron! You're the best! Warmly, Red
milliondollarredhead 2 years ago 2
I am a good scotsman the land of William Wallace Amy is all of our love.
ronlbeyer 2 years ago 21
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I love this song and I love Amy but she's made a right hash of this in my opinion.
scuttlebuck 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It seems that some of us (like you HHulzebos) are not able to properly listen to a song. If you could, you would not have made so many mistakes by writing the lyrics. Maybe ya should wash your ears more often, or something like that?
Nerestron 3 years ago
i think it's really nice of him to make such a video but you're right that it would be better if there arent mistakes
Finschi1 2 years ago
so beautiful....
thank you amy macdonald.
greatscot24 3 years ago 32
yeah, faaaaaaaaaar inferior to the original.
Neverhead35811 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she had murdered my song. beast!
audreyhepburn21 3 years ago
how?
jeflossie 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
because she's shite at it. that's how.
what was hard to grasp about it?
audreyhepburn21 3 years ago
Comment removed
BiLoxiGirl008 3 years ago
Today I heard for the first time this singer and i liked her very much(listened to several songs).
ytcont 3 years ago 5
Great *____* x3
FreakyTanosh 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
killed it
awful
georgeisalive 3 years ago