Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (57)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow i fell happy!

  • barbra is rally the best there is

  • Barbra is in another level,,,,she sings fantastic,,,it´s not only the voice quality but the emotional feeling

  • you forgot lea salonga

  • @ propugnatorfidei: this is sung by Susan Erens (i don't know if i wrote her name right. she is a great singer and I think she sung this song on a concert of André Rieu in Maastricht. i don't know it really. but i have this concert on tape cause of susa's performance of memories. by the way. all singers are great, but Barbra i think is the best.

  • Andre Rieu is a man... what's the name of the woman at 1:07?

  • IMHO - Barbra Streisand and Elaine Paige are perfectly :)

  • LOL Barbra kicked the others ass big time..

  • Barbra Streisand the best

  • This was great and I don't know how a person could choose one over the other. They all are fantastic. Extremely well done. Thank you.

  • remarquablement!

  • To me, Elaine, Rose and Barbara were the best three in this comparison.

  • Streisand and Buckley are the best of the bunch FOR SURE. Hayley and Sarah B. are the worst!

  • I agree, Streisand all the way

  • Mara Getz is a revelation, check out the full version from "Star Search".

    Not really fair to compare live performances with the studio-professional Streisand version.

  • Barbra, Barbra, Barbra. - mikesterSTLMO is right. And, thank you cutecutecookie for making it easier on those of us looking for does it best. Great video.

  • Memory is such a vocal masterpiece that it's hard to judge, but I would have to go with Barbra; the first to contemporize and popularize the song. Her arrangement and powerful vocals are sublime. I recall a review that said "Listening to Streisand's Memory is perhaps, the reason vinyl was created in the first place". For you children, vinyl is what record albums (black circular disks that play music) were made of.

  • Adoro as vozes de sarah Brigtmann e a da Barbra. Perfeitas!!!

    As outras eu também gosto muito!

  • My favourite is Sarah Brightman, of course.

  • BUCKLEY'S THE BEST!!

  • Great video!  Barbara Streisand is unbeatable.

  • They're all great! Each brings something different to the song putting her own individuality into the interpretation. Sweet, arrogant, despondent, hopeful - what a wide array of emotions are portrayed; it's easy to find something new and different with each watching. These showdowns are fascinating!

  • I'd vote for Hailey Westerner any day of the year....most human, sweetest voice

    rose jang seems somewhat arrogant and the least human of all...

  • Actually, BRAVE! for everyone.

    They are all fantastic.

  • Barbra is always my favorite.

    Rose Jang 의 熱唱 도 BRAVA!

  • Wonderful!!!

  • Rose Jang, Bravo!!!

  • The singing is amazing and perfect !!!!

    I would like to see there is more DIVA SHOWDOWN coming !!!

    Thanks for your sharing !!

    This video is really best

  • Lots of nice singers but I wish you could have showcased Mara Getz more. Her rendition was out of the box. Like liberachi said, she took the song to a different level from all the other singer. In the end, your compilation was nice. Thanks

  • I agree, she's got a great voice; unfortunately Mara's version/ arrangement (also Celine's) is very different which make her surperb performance difficult to blend in with the rest...

  • Desculpe, mas não vejo Susan Boyle como DIVA, as outras citadas são, Susan ainda precisa mostrar mais.

  • すっごい 素晴らしい皆さんの中でスーザンの魅力が増して~

    編集の力がおありで・・・・・・・・ありがとうございました。

    スーザンさんの新しい歌が早く出ないかと 心待ちにしています。

  • thank you for this beautiful mix, I prefer Sarah, Elaine ad Barbra!

  • Great showdown! I love Barbara,Ellen,Betty,Sarah and Celine's soft rendition of this song but Mara Getz for me still stands out because she took the song to another level. All of the singers versions portrayed a sad and soothing tone whereas Mara's version gave a raw and desperation emotion making the lyrics more dramatic.

  • And also, my favourites are by Elaine, Betty, Sarah and Hayley!

  • This was so beautiful, that it actually made me want to cry. Their voices all together was just... amazing. I wish they'd record a actual mix together.

  • Thank you so much for sending me the link to this video. I appreciate that. I love the appearance of Elaine Paige, Barbra Streisand and Hayley Westenra in this video. There are some people I don't know and one I don't like. But, however, this video is very very nice! Thank you again for uploading and sending me the link! Love.

  • Hm...who did you dislike? Personally I didn't like Susan Boyle very much.

  • Yet another really excellent video, one of my all time favourite songs too. Well done, keep up the good work.

  • Oh God This is a great compilation of all the most beautiful voices, but particularly I chose Sarah Brightman's version, for me is the best.

  • 前回にもまして素晴らしい作品ですね。

    ありがとうございました。

  • OH thats a wonderful idea infinitirider

    Donald Braswells Unchained Melody that Simon Cowell asked him to sing... is on his myspace its awesome and its on Youtube...Cookie may have to give up her regular job LOL Cheers Ann

  • cccookie - - how about a showdown with Unchained Melody?? We are keeping you busy, huh??

  • That is in my list as well : )

  • Have you ever listened Maria del Sol version. It's in Spanish, but it's quite good. The name of the song is Recuerdos by Maria del Sol. Look at her she's amazing.

  • また一段とパワーアップしましたね!! 大変素晴らしい物をありがとう \(^_^)/

    It is very wonderful.

  • Thank You Cute Cute Cookie

    Keep at it... its all very exciting

    Thanks for your message

    I've told all my friends

    Ann

  • 途中で書き込まれてしまいましたorz

    すみません。。

    バーバラ・ストライサンドさんはさすがですね。

    LaurieBeechmanさんがいいですねぇ。

    今まで知らなかった、たくさんの素敵な歌姫さんたちを見られて嬉­しいです!!

    スーザン・ボイルさん、あまりに騒がれすぎて固くなってしまって­いるのが残念です。。

    早くCD発売されないかなぁ。楽しみです。

  • 大好きな歌、堪能させていただきました。ありがとうございました­。すばらしい編集です!!

    は

  • This is a fantastic video! Cutecutecookie, your videos are among my favorites. All the divas you show are amazing; it's hard to pick a favorite, but I vote for Barbra Streisand.

    You are so good at putting these together! I also would love to see one for Impossible Dream, and I also think Donald Braswell's version is beyond compare, so go ahead and compare him! Thanks for your wonderful efforts!

  • It seems that Donald Braswell really has quite an inspirational story behind him. Due to popular demand, I will start working on Impossible Dream soon...

  • Wow Thank you Another smash hit.... You do these video so artistically Bravo

    Elaine Paige win my vote.

    Can you try Impossible dream next

    Donald Braswell sings it so well

    Thank you

  • It seems that Donald Braswell really has quite an inspirational story behind him. Due to popular demand, I will start working on Impossible Dream soon...

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more