Popular Drugstore mascaras: Hits and Misses (review)

[microgabrielle]

which mascara r u wearing in the video?

[33foxhound]

can u PLEASE do another mascara review in just waterproof????

[eefjewentelteefje198]

I want my food to be crispy and crunchy, not my lashes!!!



[ccape8]

AGREED on all your recommendations and avoids!

[bubblegumify13]

I love how you do your makeup <3

[IrishRandomGirl]

you've Drew Barrymore's mouth! :P lol

[macarari]

for me, the Colossal is the best!!! I love waterproof mascaras

[S3ries0fTub3z]

the beauty tubes waterproof mascara formula is very different from the original

basically if you're gonna use the beuty tubes go for the original

it does come off in tubes with warm water (so fun) and when your eyes get runny it doesn't budge UNLESS you rub your eyes

it's a great mascara so try the original formula !

[sweety11480]

The colossal is the best! :)

[sarahffmcity]

I Hated!! The essence dior Show copy ugggh and the smell was disgusting!

[strawberypinklove]

L'Oreal telescopic carbon black mascara is also really good! x x

[lilnavynurse84]

I also love L'Oreal Voluminous mascara!

[iloveyou546546]

you remind me of Adele <3

but awesome video! :)

[nicenurse77]

Very helpful. You just saved me a tonne of money in mascara fails. Thank you:)

[carebear1335]

im a freak for pointing this else, but PLEASE CUT YOUR NAILS THEY ARE CURLING INTO YOUR FINGER ITS NASTY (NOT THAT BAD BUT PLEASE, CUT THAT SHIT)

[FaithFading]

I love the Define a Lash....

[LovlyLadybug1]

the first one : why dont you do your normal mascarra on top and the one with the ball on the bottom lashes... :/

[Tesorazorz]

I recently tried the Maybelline The Colossal Volum' Express. It's the first mascara I really like because, like you say, it actually keeps the lashes separate so you don't get that horrible spider-leg lashes look. The only downside is that once the fluid in the tube starts to dry out even a little bit, it gets thick and sticky and does give you the spider look. You've got to replace it pretty often, like once a month.

[sybercat1]

Thank you so much now I don't have to spend money that I don't have finding a mascara that I like. I will take your advise!! Love your makeup by the way!!!

[MsLola107]

and i was just about to buy the Maybelline Define a Lash...

[ecjane13]

i agree with the colossal mascara i have it and it works really well as a matter of fact im wearing it right now

[candylandfan101]

I dont like covergirl products. Wouldn't reccomend them.

[ArtsyAmbriehl]

I use colossal, and I love it! It can get clumpy, but I"m very careful with my mascara, so.. yeah. aha. I'm looking for a VERY black mascara, and I heard that there was a very black one by MAC, but I don't know MAC very well.... anyone have any ideas? Thanks! :)

[MissEverythingPretty]

L'OREAL DOUBLE EXTEND MASCARA IS THE BEST MASCARA EVER! I THINK UR CRAZY NOT TO LIKE IT! no offence lol

[MissEverythingPretty]

@MissEverythingPretty AND IT SO COMES OUT IN TUBES! EXCEPT THWATERPROOF ONE SUCKS BUT THE RED ORIGINAL IS GOOD BUT OMG THE COLOSAL MASCARA IS HORRIBLE! ITS SO CLUMPY AND IT WAS A HUGE BRUSH

[xMoonLiteRose]

@MissEverythingPretty everyone has different types of eyelashes, ex: thin lashes vs thick lashes, so its just her opinion on how she liked it, plus this video was made in 2009..sometimes formulas change :-/

[MissEverythingPretty]

@xMoonLiteRose ok i wasnt being rude-i dont need someone to tell meabout lashs. I have super thin my younger sister looks like shes always wearing fake ones.

[xMoonLiteRose]

@MissEverythingPretty ok, good for you then. because everyones perception is different, so using caps like that made me percieved it differently than how you meant to say it but i never said you were rude.

[MissEverythingPretty]

@xMoonLiteRose well it soundeed pretty rudeto me :/

[xMoonLiteRose]

@MissEverythingPretty *shrugs* oh well i guess.

[MissEverythingPretty]

@xMoonLiteRose Ha ww, low

[smiffer1995]

plz do a make up tutorial plz mention me

[ChristinaMagma]

I loved the video. But why complain about how hard it is to get waterproof mascara off? I mean that's the whole point? Don't like it don't use it. 

[Nadia2015]

in a nut shell which one is your favorite?

[mzlatinnnagurl]

the colossal scent irritated my eyes if i wore it several hours :/

[Makeupgirl2001]

I love beauty tubes

[kelley174]

Thanks :)

[purbledream999]

ur make up is v nice and ur skin look great

[LilyXxxTruesdale]

Can you do a video like this for more recent mascara releases? :)

[emma8547]

Thank god you said the maybeline define-a-lash was so bad. I tried it recently and it looked so bad I thought I must have done something wrong. I threw it out and went back to my old revlon mascara.

[robinandbf3]

deutsch ;) ?

[lizii24]

Thank U! very helpful ^^

[leah1597]

haha she says mascara funny, I like it! She says mascera. XD

[missyanimal]

you are so pretty!!!

[Thisgirgirluvspurses]

Love your videos! Please do a makeup tutorial on this look! Your so gorgeous. :)

[LashControl]

Great review, really helpful!

[TheScript55]

i love the collasol mascura :D

[matheya]

"Maybelline" is the best mascara ! :) Never failes!

Has anyone tried CATRICE products ? I believe it's a german new brand ?

[chechumoli]

ME GUSTAN MUCHO TUS VIDEOS!!!SON DE UNA GRAN AYUDA!!! GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR TUS SABERES

[jnjndiamond]

L'oreal Double extension not the waterproof one is amazing! non-waterproof mascaras are usually better

[makeuplova2534]

i recommend making a video about all of the makeup you need.

[LOVELYNSREEN]

uhh i spend most of my time watching your mouth checking if that was a tongue ring lol

loved ur review

[arsj1996]

Wow, you are beautiful :)

[123plutt456]

Do more mascara review please!!

[aksoccer1000]

@123plutt456 ummmmm isnt this what it is? a mascara review?

[makeupjunkiexo1]

@aksoccer1000

there are more drugstore mascaras out there.

[JaymeLucas]

Do they have online drugstores? I have been hearing about makeup cheap at drugstores but i have never heard of a local drug store... so if you have an online site to a cheap drug store please let me know

[LancomeReviews]

Whatever you do, DONT buy covergirl mascaras, they're the worst! I highly recommend Lancome Hypnose Drama, check out my review (if you want) ;)

[KnG1Dakota]

i actually hated the colossal and loved the last blast but like they say to each to their own

[mickayllacaroline]

I want a makeup tutorial on your eyes! They are so pretty!

[WEAREANIMALS]

the wiggle brush was so weird! I like maybelline mascara. especially the falsies mascara, it really lengthens your lashes!!

[MelisaSmileyFace]

I love ur makeup!

[MartheyMakeup]

My first mascara was Maybeline Define A Lash, i diden't have any problems with it. And i have tried the Telescopic, i diden't like it at all. But now I am using L'Oreal Voluminous Carbon Black, and i love it ♥

[Lesley1000]

@MartheyMakeup i keep going back to voluminous. mine doesnt smudge as she says though. i hope they dont discontinue this cos i really like it

[winter177]

i love the colossal lash mascara too!!

[JNSBT96]

Are you Swiss? wenn ja, vo wo genau?

[MrLorangutan]

@JNSBT96 Schweizer deutsch nervt!! :D na ja :)

[MrsTameraRoberts]

I like Maybelline Colossal lashes, it's a really good mascara.... but it smells really bad, like a really strong perfume (and yes it smells like that when its new)

[Stasalj]

I do not understand on whom Loreal must be testing their product?Or they must be testing on people?It is a normal procedure.

[KTclarkemullen]

the loreal telescopic gets better as is dries out :)

[NorwegianMuslimGirl]

@heidibonon

I didn't know :o) i had 2 of them, and threw them.. thanks! =D

[MzSanchez15]

I have been using define a lash waterproof for quite a while now and I personally love it, makes my eyelashes look super long and great. It's just a matter of getting used to and knowing how to handle the wiggly-ness

[CyndiGarguilo]

I use the Loreal Double Extend in the regular non water proof version and I love it! It comes off like magic! Definitely comes off it tubes with just warm water, doesnt smudge. I like it :)

[darlingmoon]

I haven't seen Max Factor at my drugstore anymore..wonder what has happened to this line of cosmetics?

[MsYesenia94]

you remind me of chloe kardashian(: in a good way!

[jaysway808]

i love using the mascara i got from this website...a m w a y . c o m / ajr21 check out the virtual makeup... n the light up lip gloss with an attached mirror...

[DiiDee66]

OMG! I use the Maybelline Colossal AND the L'Oreal Voluminous aswell!! BOTH are my top picks. What a coincidence! I am now sure of my choices since you think the same too. Thank you for the review. Very helpful.

[horselovergirl98]

thanks for the awesome tutorial ^^

[xobekahgirl]

i agree, Colossal is so underrated but i love it! i've repurchased a few times which i hardly ever do with mascara. & i also agree w/ the Lash Blast.. way overrated. i didn't like it at all!

[themaddi2013]

IM LOVIN THIS EYE LOOK :)

[MakeUpMadeEasy]

hi julia i am in the market for a new mascara but find lots of them burn the eyes out of me even the high end ones. is there a drugstore one that u might know of that doesnt cause itching or burning in your experience thanks

[mattcossel29]

lol at being on my guys account. do you have tutorial for the eye makeup you're wearing in this video, i'm in love with it!

[LeneAndEmi]

yeah but on the maybelline define a lash, its supposed to be flexi. says on the packaging.

[Ayami861]

After seeing what you said about Maybelline Define-a-Lash, I went to check mine out. I have the none waterproof one (pink) and mine easily slides back in and the brush doesn't bend like yours did. Maybe its the packaging. Now, I'm glad I didn't pick up Essence mascaras, I'll just stick to their gel liners and nail polish.

[Aldoggaaa]

voldemort fingernails. hahah

[TheBeautyGeek1]

wtf is with the L'Oreal Telescopic Explosions' brush!?

[sassiecassie89]

@TheBeautyGeek1 THank you! I would never even try that weird looking mascara.

[jj102797]

i love the colossal 1 i have it now but the only thing i dont like is if it gets 2 hot i guess it kinda sorta melts and u have to shake it upand push it back in a few times to fix it other then that i love it

[LovelyLady1431]

She is very expert .I like all Loreal products.

[melisopa1]

Maybelline The Colossal is waterproof?

[doringeniko]

@melisopa1 it has a waterproof version, I've been using it for more than a very, it's very good.

[MrMaximillion1]

I love your nails! what do you do to them??

[dmt543nerd]

totes agree on the mascara's! subscribing. :)

[killuanette07]

What do you think of the Ony By one Volum express by maybelline ?

[crazylittlpenguin]

Your skin looks amazing!

[ilovevarsityfanclubb]

love the colossal

[Beauty4Aspies]

U know, one day, maybe the laws regarding that stuff will change.

[LoveIsMakeup1]

The best mascara ever to use on your upper lashes is the falsies by maybelline! Check my channel to see! It's amazing! THE BEST TO USE ON LOWER TO LENGTHEN AND THICKEN IS THE MINERAL INFUSED MASCARA BY ELF!!! IT'S AMaZING! serisouly try them out! The elf one is only 1 or 3 dollars and the falsies is only 6 or something!

[jbieberfan9806]

I have the maybelline colossal and I personally luv it

[wickedqueenamanda]

Do you remember what kind of mascara you were wearing in this video? It looks awesome. Thanks for uploading this. I'm always trying to find a good inexpensive mascara - right now I'm using Loreal Telescopic Carbon Black & I love it, but I always like to have a "backup" mascara just in case.

[xNicolex10]

Ive tried the non-waterproof version of the L'Oreal Double Extension and its really really good :)

[thecoolsis07]

Hiiii I love your lip color! What lipstick did you use on it? thanks. Looks great. :D

[Traci483]

what are u wearing on your lips? they're gorgeous!!1

[ellykatze]

mach bitte bitte mehr deutsche videos :D

[MsBeautyRush04]

Mascara is probably a personal thing because everyone's lashes are different!

[lapedrazza]

and what about their resistance to water-tears....I mean...if I have a sensitive bride as a client which would you suggest?

[LivandNat13]

@lapedrazza i would suggest maybelline full n soft mascara, i lvoe it. if im swimming it never ever comes off and it just completely stays!! i would highly recommend that!!

[nernio]

I've tried the maybelline colossal mascara and i hated it ! I almost always curl my lashes and this mascara does not hold curl at all ! i fould it made them straighter than they were before! also it is a mess to use since the wand is so big! gets everywhere

[fabgirl489]

Can u do another mascara review for the newer mascaras...PLZ?

[summertime361]

love your eye make up

[areliwashere]

This is extremely helpful. Thanks for posting(:

[jackieeluciaa]

very helpful thanks !(:

[linkinparkcb1]

ok

[kellyvogely]

love her eyeshadow <3

[Glamstarxo]

Omg ur so pretty! You have nice makeup on

[heidibonbon]

Its too bad Loreal does animal testing. I will NEVER buy their crap ever again. I advise everyone to not support this awful company.

[emilylane22296]

@heidibonbon

Almost all drug store products do animal testings :/

[heidibonbon]

@emilylane22296 Hard Candy doesn't. And It's sad that alot of them do. Which is why I only buy things from Sephora & ULTA now.

[emilylane22296]

@heidibonbon

Yeah, Hard Candy is all i use lol. 

[SecretsToBeauty1]

@heidibonbon i agree that testing animals is wrong but if they don't test on animals the test on people I'de rather animals then people. You probably thinking 'oh its killing them' it's better animals then people and when you eat meat your killing animals tooo

[heidibonbon]

@SecretsToBeauty1 I agree obviously that people are more important than animals but again.. if the chemicals they are using even need to be tested in the first place its probably not a good thing.

[Beauty4Aspies]

@heidibonbon Hey, L'oreal has actually stopped testing on animals! I'm not kidding. check xxmakeupiscoolxx's video entitled "ANIMAL TESTING" she has the proof right there.

[heidibonbon]

@Beauty4Aspies hey actually they haven't completely stopped yet. I went to their website last month and in the fine print it says for some things they still do testing. Most of it has stopped but honestly if they are using things in their makeup that they need to test... its probably bad anyways and I still want no part of that. Hard Candy and other companies don't test so I feel that they don't need to at all.

[Beauty4Aspies]

@heidibonbon That's because they don't unless required to do so by law, and they aren't required by law all the time. Only if there had been problems with an ingredient, or if there's a new ingredient, then they have to test it on EVERYTHING by law.

[heidibonbon]

@Beauty4Aspies still... I don't agree with it period. They shouldn't have to suffer for us being vain. I would understand if it was for a drug to help people like for medical reasons but for makeup? Kindof stupid.

[LilyLaikesCats]

@heidibonbon

I LOVE YOU. I do the same :3

[heidibonbon]

@LilyLaikesCats Thank you!! haha :)

[iSing00Icing]

@heidibonbon I thought I was the only one I cared. :o <3 You rock for hating on L'Oréal!

[heidibonbon]

@iSing00Icing Thank you!!! :)

[LadEMakeup]

@heidibonbon :0 really

[thegirlnexxtdoor1]

@heidibonbon

If you are looking for a REALLY good shampoo/conditioner combo that doesnt test on animals, take a look at the brand called Nexus, its a great brand and they dont test on animals :)

[1129buttons]

Respond to this video... Cover Girl and Garnier products also test on animals. I only know because I emailed them and they proudly said yes. Sad

[heidibonbon]

@1129buttons THAT'S AWFUL!!! Thank God for Sephora!!!!!! No more drugstore crap for me!

[kndllramos]

@heidibonbon really?

[heidibonbon]

@kndllramos yes really, I'm a cosmetologist so I get good discounts on matrix , biolage etc. So im done using hair products & makeup that tests on animals PERIOD. Even if I have to spend more money.

[iamthefirstbeans]

@heidibonbon why? they are not awful, most of their products are very good, and it wont kill the animals, its mascara!

[heidibonbon]

@iamthefirstbeans yes they are awful for still doing that crap.... when tons of other companies stopped.. or never have... its my personal choice to NOT support companies that in this day and age decide to test on animals whether its rats or mice or monkeys. They are ALL still animals that can feel pain and have no control over what humans do to them therefore I see it as CRUELTY. I'M DONE explaining myself about this.

[iamthefirstbeans]

@heidibonbon Yes, but does mascara cause pain? No. If the companies test drugs, or medicines on animals, then I will not support them.

[heidibonbon]

@iamthefirstbeans how do you know that the chemicals in mascara didnt cause animals pain? Obviously there are some things like that in their mascaras and other products. So in actually they are in fact WORSE for testing animals for VANITY for human beings to look good, than the drug companies who test animals TO FIND A CURE FOR CANCER. I fully support medical research to find drugs to save lives. NOT for stupid ass makeup. THE END.

[iamthefirstbeans]

@heidibonbon OK. So you acctually, think oh its drugs, the animal will be fine. Not oh it's mascara, it is safe for near eyes. So it is obviously sage. So yeah, a drug doesn't work kills an animal. Mascara doesn't work, no effects.

[melbelx13]

i have the mabaline one that you said is the worst but i like it becuase it makes them long and it hold curls becuase it isnt watery but yeah the wiggily part is only bad when putting it back into the bottom but i dont find it wiggle around on my lashes at all but i put it on with a light hand

[pulchi01]

your nails are very pretty! 

[TREYOLDHIPPIE]

ihave Maybelline from when there was no plastic, no jars. its bakelite, with a dry brush and dry mascara in a pan.. and yeah, I have like Maybelline for decades.. even tho I do drift and try most all others. Chanel had a good 'fine lash' style, it was off the market soon as I got it.. baloney.

[SuperStewTV]

I don't really like the Colossal all that much, but that's just my lash type.

[MaddieGracep]

define a lash is amazzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzing

[marbledog07]

i got the colossal and it was pretty good but then after a couple days it got all gloppy and melted

[Tiffyluvscash]

I love colossal

[omgELIZABETHHH]

LOreal's voluminous ALWAYS smudges on me! I've seen so many videos saying how great it is, but I'm disappointed because it smudges like crazy and runs in water, even though its waterproof. Does anyone else have this problem..?

[lifeisforlivingsodo]

i use lash exact paired up with colossal because the yellow one (colossal) makes them volumize while the purple one (lash exact by cover girl) seperates and get each and everyone of my lashes to a extent and they are long and comes off very easy

[MsNaziam]

I am using the colossal mascara an di love it! it really gives u volume n lenght..it doesnt flake or anything. my fav!

[erinokaz]

I'm just looking for a new mascara :) All my old ones are out of date now and everytime I buy one I get one I haven't had before but I'm influenced by packaging far too much sometimes xD

[1013veggie]

@erinokaz Oh my Gosh! I am looking for new mascara too ! (:

[Sandfirestar]

I have the Maybelline Colossal mascara too. It really does define my lashes and I really really like it(: The only thing is the smell, that's a little weird, but it fades away after a while, so it's not that big a deal.

[HelloListenGoodbye]

u remind me of Adele idk why [: its a complement <3

[Rokrpixie09]

I have the colossal mascara too hahah I tot I was da only one who tot da smell was kinda strong lol

[kees1357]

Those eyes. Just.. Mesmerizing.. Theres just so much going on.. In those eyes..

Woa, been trying to describe your eyes since the start of the vid and its already at 6:23 O_o

Yeah.. Mesmerizing eyes.. And then the vid is already over D:

[Iamhappy149]

thank you very much!

[Jessi3Nightmar3]

Can you do a review on eyeliners? I have a really hard time with finding good eyeliners. >_>

[HelloListenGoodbye]

Am i the only one that notices she has her tongue pierced

[AshleeElena]

My favorite drugstore mascara at the moment is the Loreal telescopic mascara :) oh! And the one bye one mascara by maybeline

[BasicBeauty01]

what lipstick was you wearing? its gawjuz x

[sammieegirll11]

i've been using the covergirl lashblast mascaras. except they have different colors/wands for different needs. i bought the purple one first and the yellow one second. the yellow one worked well, but it dried out too fast. so i just bought the colossal one and it's too wet and clumpy-ish for me. but i've only used it a couple times. i'll just have to get used to it i guess. :/

[michaelaballerina]

Haha I always thought the colossal mascara smelled like flowers, too:)

[melonshots]

your makeup looks great in this video! thanks for the info!

[barfpuke18]

The Collosal was too wet of a formula for me.. I'm kinda waiting for it to dry out a bit lol.

[XxBieberLover42499xX]

dude! covergirl lash blast is like the best! i love it(:

[lifelovingurl]

what lipstick are you wearing? Thanks =)

[TheChicClique]

i dont know why but waterproof mascara always seems to suck compared to the original kinds

[somethingsweett]

I love love love love define a lash, it's my favorite!! Haha and I've tried every one of those except the 2000 calorie kind and the very last 2 you reviewed. :P

[1heartclaire]

i really love the maybelline define a lash mascara but not in waterproof.

[JoyceThe]

i luv ur vids!!! they never get me bored!

[StalulaXsta]

Love the reviews! Even though my question has nothing to do with the mascaras, I was wondering what lipgloss are you wearing? It appears very pink and its lovely :)

[Cwarnic93]

The beauty tubes (in regular not waterproof) is amazing. It makes the lashes a lot longer and DOES come off in tubes -- which I find more convenient. It doesn't smear either.

[JustABitFabulous]

i love the loreal voluminous mascara! Its EXTREMELY lengthening! I just did a review of my mascara collection (it includes loreal voluminous!) so if you want to check that out then just pop over to my page! I hope this helps everyone, xoxo, Hayley :)

[lulallybayb]

i love the define a lash.. its my favorite lol

[diamond0993]

@lulallybayb me too lol, i haven't tried this but i love the volumising pink one :D :)

[gynkaithleen]

Should I get colassal /lash blast / falsie?? I going get a new mascara soon and I really can't decide... Any suggestion for "fan like" lash???

[SpyderT22]

@gynkaithleen i suggest the falsies, but not the black drama one! just get the original one with the teal and pink packaging